Check out the band 5MTB here! Best Songs: Walter, Walter (Prelude) if you like this music, subscribe! we're working on an album right now (12-14 songs) and we'll let you know when we're done!
@TheMartin108 joanna and rebecca are completly different and sound nothing alike, joanna has talent and is an angel, i have no grudge against rebecca but she has no talent in singing anyways.
This is weird...When my friend had me listen to Joanna on her iPod, the first thing I thought of was Mists of Avalon, and now when I watch this video she seems exactly like one of the crazy priestess chicks in that book, just sitting in a classroom instead of a castle.
I really don't know weather I like her voice, one minute, I think my cat can do better, another I love it and it makes me feel really good, but I love her harp playing and as I already play the harp It really gives me something to aim for!!
Did anyone else listen to this, knowing nothing about Joanna Newsom, and think that she's a child prodigy or something? I did... I thought she was 13-ish when I watched this video the first few times. And then I looked her up on wikipedia and... whoops. xDDD
Further proof that the lovely miss Newsom is secretly an immortal elf or... something. x3
joanna newsome is an aquired taste, but i definitely have it. i wish i heard more stuff like this on the radio and not just top 40 synthesized, auto tuned, talent-void crap
An amazing song but I have to say that I prefer the version of this song by Sholi. There aren't many covers that I prefer to the original, but the Sholi version seems to have more passion in it. There's no good video of Sholi's version on youtube, but it's on Spotify, and you guys should check it out ;-)
I love the meandering, dreamy quality of this...a friend sent this to me saying this reminded her of me. I can definitely see is in the knick knacks, the dreaming, the randomness, and lying below that tree just lazing...=D I love her outfits! especially the blue one at 3:37. I wonder where I could get that?
I like her- never heard oh her till today, just happened to see a girl with a harp in the sidebar when I was listening to Carri Coltrane. Can't tell if she's a kid or young woman who looks kind of like a kid! Cute, talented, unique- I'll have to check out some more songs.
Maybe they meant "self-indulgent" as if she just wrote it so she could take pleasure in creating such beautiful music. After all, I'd totally write and play songs like this is I was incredibly musically talented. I agree, that is a strange description. >:][
How can anyone like her singing? Because its subjective: like people who listen to thrash or punk, or speed metal, or opera or medieval motets. It's alternative and you don't have to like it. But many of us do. It reminds me of Appalachian folk music. The lyrics are beautiful. And the music is sweet.
@PNSVIDS you know how, as you grow older, your food preferences change? well, over time mainstream music is no longer satisfying. Not everyone get's so into music, and there is nothing wrong with that. But those who do are continuously searching for something they haven't heard yet, to be satisfied all over again.
@ngholden I've been looking for more and more music for half my life, hah. Joanna is something special though.. so pure, unconventional, all that jazz.
Her music is so easy to feel. It's full bodied and sensual, like a religion that takes hold of you and makes you believe everything that it wants you to believe. She's really wonderful.
@LittleSelfia You know what's funny? People who quote movies all the time. It's so funny when people keep repeating the same phrases over and over again. You have a good one.
@peaky999 are you effing deaf???? Honey this is music its pure clean and beautiful...i shudder to think of the garbage you listen to..what kind of moron are you? Why come here and trash her just because you dont care for her music?? Your an asshole please do us all a favor and take your idiotic comment elsewhere She has more talent in one finger then you could ever hope to have in your sad close minxded life..open your ears and hear the beauty ..untouched pure from the soul..god given talent
@dallasdebbie If you're calling that singing, then my cat can sing when its fighting another cat!! Fair enough she is amazing at playing the harp but she HAS to stop singing!
@peaky999 Her voice is much more refined on her new album. I'd check it out, if you like the music itself. I'm being kind because I was on the same boat as you a few years ago. It took me a while to "get" her voice.
@peaky999 are you effing deaf???? Honey this is music its pure clean and beautiful...i shudder to think of the garbage you listen to..what kind of moron are you? Why come here and trash her just because you dont care for her music?? Your an asshole please do us all a favor and take your idiotic comment elsewhere She has more talent in one finger then you could ever hope to have in your sad close minded life..open your ears and hear the beauty ..untouched pure from the soul..god given talent
I'll never forget the day I played this while my 4 nieces and nephews were playing in my computer room....when they heard her sing, they stopped what they were doing and came over to see....the two older girls together broke into an interpretive dance and the two younger boys were transfixed by the sound....
Not a haiku, but written with that spare, evocative form in mind. It's about a park in Japan, beautifully designed 30 years or so ago, now mostly ignored while the suburbs around it fill with huge houses filled with electronics and people who are neither social nor familial--everything serving acquisition and a dreamlike march toward a shallow promise of a life of protection, comfort. Outside is threatening, neighbours are unknown... it's a bleak view, but not the only one, happily!
she has the hands of an angel,her harp skills are magnificant.
shapesandcoleurs10 8 months ago
andy sanberg is tappin that.... just sayin.
happychair69 8 months ago
LOL there's didgeridoos in the background.
walke0113 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@walke0113 can i ask why you are laughing out loud at instruments?
brookynMike 8 months ago
it's so strange pairing her face with her voice. i trips me out every time
MemphsTgr 9 months ago
@CaliKushh yes
sebasboner 9 months ago
They say only angels know how to play the harp. Never the less, a great song.
LastCaress7 9 months ago
Check out the band 5MTB here! Best Songs: Walter, Walter (Prelude) if you like this music, subscribe! we're working on an album right now (12-14 songs) and we'll let you know when we're done!
Official5MTB 9 months ago
I love her voice... i love this video... it's wonderfull...
saralunarossa 9 months ago
i know right dustin :) hes my brother
ilovesophiealot 9 months ago
This song i find creepy. So creppy. Video creeper. when your watching strangers, creepist. so scary.
Dustin7110 9 months ago 2
scaary noooooo
ilovesophiealot 9 months ago
scaary
ilovesophiealot 9 months ago
wonderful.. *tears*
MayadIdub 9 months ago
@CaliKushh yeah.
Hashirama101098 10 months ago
the part "should we go outside" scares the shit outta me! Especially at night!
14ILOVECHRISTIAN 10 months ago
after watching the strangers, this song now freaks the shit out of me.
emilyitsme43 10 months ago
@emilyitsme43 SAME SAME =D so CREEPY.
Dustin7110 9 months ago
this song is so scary after the movie the strangers
chfootball84 10 months ago 2
beautiful
marianasj93 10 months ago
So Lisa Simpson channels her inner Bjork and Harpo Marx.
I guess I don't get it.
But she is clever. I have no doubt she'll confirm it if you ask her.
toolkien 10 months ago
très belle musique assortie d'une voix douce et originale
winston2818 10 months ago
@totoroiscutie umm it was an expression thing i didnt mean it she sounds like it but its a good song
CarissaLupi 10 months ago
i think of this song when i am studying for my midterms/finals....should i go outside? ....nope. hahaha
vishos12 10 months ago
sounds a bit like Rustinman + Beth Gibbons (or vice versa I dont; know which)
cool
stashcode 10 months ago
just support your artists people and the haters wont be heard
Weedandbones12 10 months ago
um is she 5?
CarissaLupi 10 months ago
@CarissaLupi just saying, look at the copyright date. no, she is not five. :|
totoroiscutie 10 months ago
dont like this woman, shes clueless and refuses to accept anything thats different to her
yttihp11 10 months ago
who ever talks about friday any further should be shunned by this magical video!
ingridishkewlio 10 months ago
??? What's up w/ her voice? ?Not to be rude!
AliClovis 10 months ago
This songs even creeper when your watching the strangers!~
Dustinxxx123 11 months ago 2
@Dustinxxx123 same here!
CarissaLupi 10 months ago
her voice sounds like Rebecca Black in "Friday"
TheMartin108 11 months ago
@TheMartin108 joanna and rebecca are completly different and sound nothing alike, joanna has talent and is an angel, i have no grudge against rebecca but she has no talent in singing anyways.
Hashirama101098 11 months ago
@TheMartin108 stop... just please stop. don't embarrass yourself any further.
rrlj456 11 months ago
@TheMartin108 Woah weird how friday got to this video ahaha
Dustinxxx123 11 months ago
@TheMartin108 Hahahahaha
i kind of hear it yeah
pinkfuzzie123 11 months ago
it doesn't hurt that she's beautiful
oatsy64 11 months ago
her voice is amazing! :) I love her music! It's my most played on my ipod! :)
loveiswhoIam97 11 months ago
this song is incredible god it's good, it has that special something that makes you feel what can only be termed as... Bliss
thefezmancan 11 months ago
At least Iris Dement could stay in key
BobbyJohnson11 11 months ago
so much anger. wow, i thought i loved this chick before. but when she creates this kind of controversy, well,thats a whole new level of love
bobolandlover123 11 months ago
Her voice is unique, if anything.
At least its not auto-tuned generic garbage everyone is so keen on nowadays.
donnk 11 months ago 2
This is weird...When my friend had me listen to Joanna on her iPod, the first thing I thought of was Mists of Avalon, and now when I watch this video she seems exactly like one of the crazy priestess chicks in that book, just sitting in a classroom instead of a castle.
1066anglophile 1 year ago
I really don't know weather I like her voice, one minute, I think my cat can do better, another I love it and it makes me feel really good, but I love her harp playing and as I already play the harp It really gives me something to aim for!!
EllaMargolin 1 year ago 2
*SPROUT AND THE BEAN
MyKeturah 1 year ago
Did anyone else listen to this, knowing nothing about Joanna Newsom, and think that she's a child prodigy or something? I did... I thought she was 13-ish when I watched this video the first few times. And then I looked her up on wikipedia and... whoops. xDDD
Further proof that the lovely miss Newsom is secretly an immortal elf or... something. x3
ClichedNameFTW 1 year ago 2
Sounds like Lisa Simpson!
pandaeyes42 1 year ago
I love how The Strangers used this song. <3 That made me love the movie so much.
KeelysNotAmused 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes trying to sound like bjork
shizeninho 1 year ago
What a Song, this is what the music industry don't want you to hear lol
ALCHEEZE92 1 year ago 18
@ALCHEEZE92 then why does it have a musical video..
asdasdasdasdasdas497 9 months ago
@asdasdasdasdasdas497 She only got money cuz her parents broke bread
ALCHEEZE92 8 months ago
Yes, that's her
generichrist 1 year ago
joanna newsome is an aquired taste, but i definitely have it. i wish i heard more stuff like this on the radio and not just top 40 synthesized, auto tuned, talent-void crap
pootinhammer 1 year ago 3
Really wonderful.
icntube 1 year ago
@icntube
Utter Shite!
pandaeyes42 1 year ago
CaliKushh said "yep" three days ago. I agree.
enderjsvl 1 year ago
@CaliKushh Yep.
UnholyWarcry 1 year ago
An amazing song but I have to say that I prefer the version of this song by Sholi. There aren't many covers that I prefer to the original, but the Sholi version seems to have more passion in it. There's no good video of Sholi's version on youtube, but it's on Spotify, and you guys should check it out ;-)
holland2312 1 year ago
she should do more videos
Madzho89 1 year ago
she's amazing!
srgpeppers1 1 year ago
Sooooomeones a /b/fag!
Coyseph 1 year ago
If you don't like her voice, don't listen to her. Personally, I think her voice has that originality I was looking for in the music I listen to.
LaurenIFWoolley 1 year ago
LOL, her voice is so annoying that I love it
SuperRockyRacoon 1 year ago
She went to my high school a couple years before me. And I met her and Andy Samberg in my hometown.
Zapbrannigan23 1 year ago
elf
TheCommentBandit 1 year ago
oooooooooooooommmmmmmmmmmmmmmgggggggggggg i cannot get over how awesome Joanna is, she has such an original sound!!! <3
alyssapwelling 1 year ago
i really don't get the meaning of this song. my theory would be "miscariage". but it's so mysterious =)
MaryJoMcCormic 1 year ago
This is sooo goodi listen to this song and video alot
christineaminn 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really love this song and video
christineaminn 1 year ago
I really love this song and video
christineaminn 1 year ago
The voice sounds A LOT like Julia Stone...
BBQPeanut 1 year ago
@BBQPeanut I think it's all the way around, buddy.
misterj0nes 1 year ago
I love the meandering, dreamy quality of this...a friend sent this to me saying this reminded her of me. I can definitely see is in the knick knacks, the dreaming, the randomness, and lying below that tree just lazing...=D I love her outfits! especially the blue one at 3:37. I wonder where I could get that?
theultimateotaku 1 year ago
@theultimateotaku alessi is that you!? >D
jaggysnake57 9 months ago
@jaggysnake57 haha, no, sorry!
theultimateotaku 8 months ago
I like her- never heard oh her till today, just happened to see a girl with a harp in the sidebar when I was listening to Carri Coltrane. Can't tell if she's a kid or young woman who looks kind of like a kid! Cute, talented, unique- I'll have to check out some more songs.
JoeSzilagy 1 year ago
@enderjsvl
Maybe they meant "self-indulgent" as if she just wrote it so she could take pleasure in creating such beautiful music. After all, I'd totally write and play songs like this is I was incredibly musically talented. I agree, that is a strange description. >:][
mychemicalwhatever 1 year ago
How does this video not have more views? I don't get it.
enderjsvl 1 year ago
she sounds like Lisa Simpson.
i love this song btw
hankerforahunka 1 year ago 2
come cantante un vero strazio...
5valle 1 year ago
I think she's cute.
from93till 1 year ago
Her latest, Have One On Me, is very Kate Bush... but that's no bad thing... I love both these women! =O)
nickthelick 1 year ago
incredibly self indulgent
OhSheeshYallTAD 1 year ago
@OhSheeshYallTAD How is this self-indulgent? Like, she wrote it just so she could listen to it herself? Such a strange description to use for a song.
enderjsvl 1 year ago
She sounds a lot like Regina Spektor in this song.
nexttothemoon1 1 year ago
beautiful
papadosio 1 year ago
Her music is so weird. I love it.
aGuyCalledQUEST11 1 year ago
Bob Dylan much?
dilcofilms 1 year ago
@dilcofilms
no. not much.
polishpunk911 1 year ago
How can anyone like her singing? Because its subjective: like people who listen to thrash or punk, or speed metal, or opera or medieval motets. It's alternative and you don't have to like it. But many of us do. It reminds me of Appalachian folk music. The lyrics are beautiful. And the music is sweet.
zimbeline 1 year ago
this is really beautiful
mramerecka 1 year ago
how do you people seriously like this music? her singing is so terrible! im sorry, i like the harp but the singing is just down right awful!
PNSVIDS 1 year ago
@PNSVIDS you know how, as you grow older, your food preferences change? well, over time mainstream music is no longer satisfying. Not everyone get's so into music, and there is nothing wrong with that. But those who do are continuously searching for something they haven't heard yet, to be satisfied all over again.
ngholden 1 year ago 99
@ngholden What a great comment! Totally agree :)
CreatePerform 1 year ago
@ngholden you´re right :)
ElizabethxPete 1 year ago
@ngholden I've been looking for more and more music for half my life, hah. Joanna is something special though.. so pure, unconventional, all that jazz.
MikePostDrums 1 year ago
@ngholden
This is so true!!!
Pyamamoidl 1 year ago
@ngholden
This is si true!!!!
Pyamamoidl 1 year ago
@ngholden i think you just defined my "taste" in music better than i could :)
zminemx 1 year ago
@ngholden i agree with your comment, im just now hearing this and i like it
kevindagame 11 months ago
Her music is so easy to feel. It's full bodied and sensual, like a religion that takes hold of you and makes you believe everything that it wants you to believe. She's really wonderful.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago 42
@LittleSelfia that is such a good way to imagine her words!
confuzzled785 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LittleSelfia that is such a good way to imagine her words!
confuzzled785 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia are you serious?
I just get the feeling you're going a little over the top about the whole "up your own ass" thing. "Full bodied and sensual?"
Come on, dude. Really.
Don't do shit shit to me.
DesMoinesT 1 year ago
@DesMoinesT Cool story, bro.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia You know what's funny? People who quote movies all the time. It's so funny when people keep repeating the same phrases over and over again. You have a good one.
DesMoinesT 1 year ago
Comment removed
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@DesMoinesT Cool story, bro. I still don't care.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia Cool double post.
U MAD? U JELLY? U MIRIN?
DesMoinesT 1 year ago
@DesMoinesT Cool story, bro.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia Holy shit, you're so indifferent you keep replying out of sheer ambivalence. You've got me, there.
DesMoinesT 1 year ago
@DesMoinesT Cool story, bro. Glad you could tell me about it.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia Yeah, I like that story. It's so full bodied and sensual.
DesMoinesT 1 year ago
@DesMoinesT Cool story, bro.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@LittleSelfia Are you retarded? I've better noise out of my ass!
peaky999 1 year ago
@peaky999 Yeah, I'm glad you told me that.
LittleSelfia 1 year ago
@peaky999 are you effing deaf???? Honey this is music its pure clean and beautiful...i shudder to think of the garbage you listen to..what kind of moron are you? Why come here and trash her just because you dont care for her music?? Your an asshole please do us all a favor and take your idiotic comment elsewhere She has more talent in one finger then you could ever hope to have in your sad close minxded life..open your ears and hear the beauty ..untouched pure from the soul..god given talent
dallasdebbie 1 year ago
@dallasdebbie If you're calling that singing, then my cat can sing when its fighting another cat!! Fair enough she is amazing at playing the harp but she HAS to stop singing!
peaky999 1 year ago
@peaky999 Actually her singing is much better live I reckon. I saw her at WOMADelaide just last night and it was amazing.
Tripsey128 1 year ago
@peaky999
To put it charitably, you're an imbecile. Hush up, now.
FungusMossGnosis 11 months ago
@peaky999 Her voice is much more refined on her new album. I'd check it out, if you like the music itself. I'm being kind because I was on the same boat as you a few years ago. It took me a while to "get" her voice.
Jonmad17 11 months ago
@peaky999 are you effing deaf???? Honey this is music its pure clean and beautiful...i shudder to think of the garbage you listen to..what kind of moron are you? Why come here and trash her just because you dont care for her music?? Your an asshole please do us all a favor and take your idiotic comment elsewhere She has more talent in one finger then you could ever hope to have in your sad close minded life..open your ears and hear the beauty ..untouched pure from the soul..god given talent
dallasdebbie 1 year ago
@LittleSelfia
Well Said...
Oracle428 11 months ago
que bonita cancion!!!!
syztem95 1 year ago
She sounds a lot like Catatonia's song Road Rage. And a bit like Bjerk, and yes, like Kate Bush.
qwerky1309 1 year ago
is it me or does anyone feel she sounds kinda like kate bush?
pureecstasy 1 year ago
I'll never forget the day I played this while my 4 nieces and nephews were playing in my computer room....when they heard her sing, they stopped what they were doing and came over to see....the two older girls together broke into an interpretive dance and the two younger boys were transfixed by the sound....
....pure magic.
scherado01 1 year ago 2
soooo beatiful
onestep1984 1 year ago
are there ghost parks in your town?
where is the social world?
we should go outside
mccullochker 2 years ago
@mccullochker
I am very poor at recognizing such things, but is this a haiku?
Th3Hegemon 1 year ago
@Th3Hegemon
Not a haiku, but written with that spare, evocative form in mind. It's about a park in Japan, beautifully designed 30 years or so ago, now mostly ignored while the suburbs around it fill with huge houses filled with electronics and people who are neither social nor familial--everything serving acquisition and a dreamlike march toward a shallow promise of a life of protection, comfort. Outside is threatening, neighbours are unknown... it's a bleak view, but not the only one, happily!
mccullochker 1 year ago