Война и мир (сериал 2007) - Первый бал Наташи Ростовой

[tokala44]

Wow, how beautiful, how romantic...

[vardapet100]

wals in Aram Xachaturyan, armenian copazitor,

[OdinistSonata]

Anyone know how is called the music that starts around 1:48?

[MarialeSiso26]

@OdinistSonata That's the arrange from the main music of the series. It's composed by Jan A.P. Kaczmarek

[Arminiushoff]

ohhhh, this is very elegant, thank you uploader.

[Alina280195]

как я могу скачать этот ролик на свой компьютер??подскажите

[Alina280195]

что бы тут не говорили,для меня этот эпизод и фильм снят просто замечательно)))

[ruhochka1990]

Такое ощущение, что никто из комментирующих данное видео не читал "Войну и Мир". На мой взгляд, фильм снят потрясающе. Наташа словно из книжки, подходит по всем описаниям Толстого: "Черноглазая, с большим ртом, некрасивая, но живая девочка, с своими детскими открытыми плечиками, которые, сжимаясь, двигались в своем корсаже от быстрого бега, с своими сбившимися назад черными кудрями, тоненькими оголенными руками и маленькими ножками в кружевных панталончиках и открытых башмачках"

[Rudsina]

. Причем тут Толстой и " Война и мир"? Стыдоба какая,,, И вальс Хачатуряна :( Все в кучу намешать...Взяли бы свою какую классику попортили...

[lamarchesado]

At the college I studied Russian language and literature and had the pleasure of reading the novel War and Peace : did I commit a crime, did I offend Russians for reading one of their books and trying to learn their history , poets and literature ? Frankly the comments I read here are quite ridiculous, one may enjoy or dislike a movie, but claiming that no one has a right to shoot a movie because of a different nationality is an offence to human intelligence.

[AigerimKopeyeva]

@lamarchesado Yeah, you r right. This work, however, is an act of respect to the memory of a great writer of all times. But i also cn understand people who dislike it - it's.... inaccurate, really. and this music.... and it's...such an american movie))) no offence intended, but Russians can be played by Russians only, at least, for now.... and what u can't take away from them, russians can play Anybody... this is their passion...))) However, this one is a good film))

[lamarchesado]

@AigerimKopeyeva oh, as for that I dislike inaccuracy too and I am not particularly fond of modern Hollywood movies also. But I think we must give a chance to everybody. It's not long since Russia is an open country, we need time to understand and know better this nation... but Tolstoy is world heritage and ...we must give a chance ! :-)

[auroradawn23]

@AigerimKopeyeva Most Hollywood productions from the last 20 years are rubbish, but there are excellent independent American films. Besides, this isn't an American film. As for your claim that "only Russians" should portray Russian characters, while there are many talented Russian actors, it's absurdly narrow-minded to insist that foreign actors shouldn't portray Russian characters. The British, for instance, have produced excellent adaptations of Tolstoy & Dostoevsky's novels.

[AigerimKopeyeva]

@auroradawn23 if you read accurately, you would notice that i didn't "insist that foreign actors shouldn't portray russian characters". I meant, that nobody can do it better than Russians themselves. that spirit is very hard to play onscreen, if it's not youre inborn,

p.s. "narrow-minded"? no, it's only that i'm sure in what i'm saying. in prev comment if u notuced, i did support the idea of "giving a chance" to everybody. ...ok, doesn't matter...

[ElviraRussian]

Боже!!!нет!это жалкая пародия на Наташу((((((

[79lunaverde]

Everything is terrible. This Natasha is not a countess, but a poor girl from a province, "llimita", looking for the glamour. No manners, no character, no personality.Еще одна кухарка в "Едим дома".

[TheOelun]

Natasha Rostova is so terrible

[Ianey11]

This is absurd. Aram Khatchaturian's Masquerade Suite wasn't even written yet in 19th century Russia, Khatchaturian wasn't even born yet, and he was Armenian, talk about historically inaccurate.

[Yelishenda]

Фу, и Наташа - не Наташа, и Андрей - не Андрей, и вообще всё не так!!! :(

[AnnaBekk]

ohhhhhhh!!!its terrible...its for laughing

[LuckyTartTea]

А как вальс Хачатуряна, написанный для "Маскарада", оказался в "Войне и мире"? оО

[purplelunacy]

I'm half Russian, half French, but both halves are appalled by this version of Vojna i Mir... But I guess, when you've seen Bondarchuk's movie, you can't really appreciate any other version. Still I think that Non-Russians shouldn't be allowed to shoot adaptations of Russian books, nor to play one of their characters (unless of the characters himself isn't Russian).

Clémence Poésy here is just NOT credible as Natasha !

[auroradawn23]

@purplelun - By that token no one but the Brits should be allowed to make film adaptations of British novels. And what about the French? Are only French actors, directors, etc., allowed to make adaptations of French novels? What rubbish.

[Coginy]

it is absolutely and utterly horrific!

[timursh]

Пустышка какая то. А где та буря чувств в голове юной Наташи? Что за школьная дискотека?

[fars190768]

нет, это не Наташа Ростова! ужасно неестественно! Наташа совсем другая!

[MsHappiness123456789]

Это просто ужас! Насколько наигранна да и просто откровенно некрасива Наташа Ростова в исполнении Клеменс Поэзи. Разве можно сравнить ее с нашей Наташей Ростовой. Кто выбирал эту актрису, где его глаза были? Ей же только в фильмах про гоблинов играть!!!! Ну или на худой конец в Гарри Потере)))

[Valde11994]

@MsHappiness123456789 no pomoemu oskorbit to ne nado bilo .ona otli4no ispolnyayet svoy rol-ved ona nastoyasyaya russkaya devuwka)

[anisindr]

М-да... и эта ... Наташа Ростова ?!