U2 - Window in the skies (Artist Subtitles)

[terzapersonasingolar]

grandissimo

[magolandia1]

Where is Eric Clapton????????

[Perfughesina77]

semplicemente il più bello!!

[minouche411]

@ 1:30 Ike Turner?

[Sun295]

il video è fantastico e lo guardo molto spesso,tuttavia io avrei dedicato qualche fotogramma in più ai queen piuttosto che cantanti come beyoncè o mary j. blige

[nabucodonosan]

Entrambe rappresentano l'anima della musica popolare afroamericana (r'nB)

[AdiMercury]

3:03: it's "Queen" not "The Queen"!!!

[nabucodonosan]

yeah, true!!!! ... fixed it

[AdiMercury]

Thanks! ;-)

[RoxRancid]

at 0.58 Ramones : D The besttttttttttttt!

[imajeepster]

amazing how many of these people are gone now...

[marfranco69]

Esse video simplesmente e maravilhoso, e a historia da musica mundial com todos esses artistas que aparecem nele, sou fã do Duran Duran, mas esse do u2 ficou 10. valeu.

[oOMorrisonHotelOo]

This is a great video; led zeppelin, Nirvana, Jimmy Hendrix, Janis Joplin.

But they should've included The Doors

[Sun295]

esattamente dov'è janis????

[markmustb1]

dont need you to point out the best

Morrissey !!

[Matteic]

Hey, there's update since the last time I came ! Thank you everyone !

[tigerchief]

i'm thinking 1:31 is one of the neville brothers, but i'm not sure, could someone find out who that is? DEFINITELY NOT al green! i'd bet my life on it.

[bobby6649]

its keith

[Solaski]

Keith Richards? No way, thats George Harrison!

And I also doubt if it's Robert Plant or Rory Gallagher after Elvis.

[Total1993]

it´s keith...definitely!

[luckystrike76]

no its george harrison!

[undersolo]

That's not Sly and the Family Stone. That's Parliament-Funkadelic.

[nabucodonosan]

Do you know the name of the video (or concert) where i can verify with my informations?

[cannellino92]

there isn't robbie williams, it's crazy

[TickiTackiToe]

Amazing song and an amazing video!

[soeperik]

Ok, if u say so :) Reaally don't know about the guitars, but the guy looks to me more like GH than KR.

Maybe you're right.

[koompasia]

That's Keith Richards allright. He does resemble George Harrison but as nabucodonosan pointed out the guitar was a dead giveaway.

[soeperik]

on 2.11 that's definitely not Keith Richards but George Harrisson. Shame on you MTV!

[nabucodonosan]

For me is Keith Richards without any doubt. Until 1969 the Gibson SG guitar was used by Harrison. The Guitar in the clip is an Gibson Les Paul Custom, the classic guitar of Keith Richards of that period.

[BOSTACHE]

oh...btw at 0:44 is a scene from Led Zeppelin Live At Royal Albert Hall 1970...i'm verry sure i've seen the conceert few times and i checked at it is u can check to :)

[nabucodonosan]

Yes! Fixed. Also to 2:27 is John Bonham from the same concert

[BOSTACHE]

great video...the best video ever made...and the song is good to but the video....btw gj with the subtitles

[angelitaanderson]

the most beautiful misic in the world

[shavierrr]

its not the wu tang klan but three 6 mafia

[nabucodonosan]

Do you know the name of this title of the Three 6 Mafia where i can verify?

[shavierrr]

no, i just know that for the faces of the rappers, look for a picture with google and you'll see.

[evandrigor]

2 28 Sam Cooke. Peace.

[nabucodonosan]

Ok, i've fixed but i'm dubious

[evandrigor]

killergirl10 is a fuckin' muppet. Twat. Peace.

[killergirl10]

grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr u2 is so gay!!!!!!!!!!

[tommywm24]

Where the Beatles in there? Plus what about INXS...Bono was great friends with Michael Hutchence and sings their songs frequently!

[evandrigor]

The first clip of kids running is from "When We Were Kings". Peace.

[nabucodonosan]

Thanks, i've fixed. Peace to you

[soulfix89]

that's definitely not keith richards, he is george harrison from the beatles, and it's definetely temptations

[franknirvana]

krist is wearing a shirt while kurt is wearing a grey/green sweather. Kurt rarely wore t shirt while playing a gig.

[franknirvana]

2:04 is krist novoselic. Kurt played guitar in front of the mic.

[nabucodonosan]

Yes, at 1:04 is Krist Novoselic

[franknirvana]

its krist. Not cobain. Just look at the "lithium" video. Its from the same show in seattle. Btw, they doesnt look alike.

[Fishmusician]

Noel Redding isn't black....

[nabucodonosan]

At 2:03 i've write "Charles Mingus or Noel Redding", this is Charles Mingus.

Question also fixed in the thread: the doubt with Noel Redding (guitar bass of jimi) was elsewhere.

[battyboyzzz]

the first time you show nirvana it's Krist Novoselic first, not kurt cobain, and that's definitely thom yorke not paul maccartney and thte guy playing the red guitar is jon frusciante and at the end its most definitely pj harvey

[nabucodonosan]

Ok! Fixed, at 1:04 is Krist Novoselic

[julmastersolrac]

I love the song!!! but if that wasn´t george harrison I will be mad!! and hate the video because is not posible make a video with that kind of images and dont put Beatles in there!!!!

[valibal]

3:27 - NOT Bob Seger, that's Jesse Galagher of little known but absolutely ROCKING band Apollo Sunshine.

[Ra5mu550n]

i love this song

[elreenlynch]

3:25 she looked like CHARLENE SPITERI of TEXAS

[dollam]

Bob Dylan plays the guitar with right hand. So maybe it can be him?

[nabucodonosan]

Yes, but i have't certainty. Thanks for your opinion!

[barycoise]

the fingers playing the guitar (at 3:39) are that of Frank Zappa live in New York from the Dvd Does Humor Belong in Music?

[ajhleix]

I am pretty sure at the 10 second mark, its PJ Harvey and not Bjork

[nabucodonosan]

She's Bjork at Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival (27-April-2002)

[Garompo]

that's not kaith rochards, that george harrison O_O

[nabucodonosan]

At 2:11 is Keith Richards. Sure 100%

[diegoescolochog]

No!!!. Its Richards. Pause the video and look his face, Harrison face was more "skelettic"

[johnnydinkis2]

That's not Bob Dylan. I think it's Jimi Hendrix again.

[nabucodonosan]

Jimi Hendrix plays the guitar with the left hand (for Jimi you can see at 2:13) while the subject in the clip(at 2:15) plays the guitar with the right hand. But no sure if he's Bob Dylan(!)

[nabucodonosan]

Oh, thanks for your opinion! It's many gratifying

[celinablack]

are the artist names completely accurate?

[nabucodonosan]

Oh yes! But remark:

30": About certainly is Noel Redding

46"-47": Errata "Topper Headon (The Clash)" -> Corrige "Keith Moon (The Who)"

47"-48": Errata "Keith Moon (The Who)" -> Corrige "The Rolling Stones"

1'22":About certainly is Tom Yorke

1'43":Errata "Back"-> Corrige "Beck"

2'03":I've write "Charles Mingus or Noel Redding". Evidently the doubt with Noel Redding(bass guitar of di Jimi Hendrix) was elsewhere

3'46": Children who run on the sand -> from the movie "The Constant Gardner"

[seremariposa]

mi sono accorta adesso che la mia indicazione era già stata scritta ... beh complimenti lo stesso! gh ..

[nabucodonosan]

Già! Manco a farlo appòsta, ricordo che il pomeriggio postai il video e in serata vidi il film!

Purtroppo se sistemo il video (ci sarebbero da sistemare 4-5 cose), poi mi cambia il link di youtube...bye

[seremariposa]

Posso dirti da che film è preso il frammento a 3.47 con i bambini africani ... Dovrebbe essere da "The constant gardener".

Non serve a molto e magari è pure sbagliato, ma volevo dare il mio contributo!

Bel lavoro davvero. Complimenti!

[vivathe90s]

who's the guy at 1:02?

[Laura924]

Hendrix or Cobane!

[nabucodonosan]

Topless cymbal player is John Bonham (Led Zeppelin)

[Z10]

I'm almost sure that the guy playing bass guitar at 3:41 is john entwistle from the who

[nabucodonosan]

Do you know the name of the video (or concert) where i can verify?

[Z10]

look for "my generation live from monterey pop festival", i'm not sure but you can check

[nabucodonosan]

Ok! I've fixed

[Matteic]

You're a King.

[librax24]

veramente bellissimo...senza parole.

[ank2rik3]

Ciao a tutti!

Qualcuno mi sa dire qualcosa in più del Iggy Pop in qst video?

Tipo il periodo, il concerto da cui sono prese le immagini e cose così...?

Lo so...non è una risposta semplice...

Grazie!!

[nabucodonosan]

Aggiornamento:

30": quasi sicuramente è Noel Redding

46"-47": Errata "Topper Headon (The Clash)" -> Corrige "Keith Moon (The Who)"

47"-48": Errata "Keith Moon (The Who)" -> Corrige "The Rolling Stones"

1'22":quasi sicuramente è Tom Yorke

1'43":Errata "Back"-> Corrige "Beck"

2'03":Ho scritto"Charles Mingus or Noel Redding". Ovviamente il dubbio con Noel Redding(bassista di Jimi Hendrix)era altrove

3'46":banbini di colore che corrono -> dal film "The Constant Gardner"

[nabucodonosan]

Fra le cose "al limite" che mi sono giunte (ma complimenti se dovessero essere vere) :

20": Willie Dixon al contrabbasso

2'19": Bacio di Adam Clayton e successivo bacio di Edge (quello con la testa pelata)

2'46": i piedi:alcuni vanno su James Brown e altri su Mick Jagger

Domanda: qualcuno sa se è possibile aggiornare in Youtube il solo video in oggetto lasciando inalterato il link originale?

[Peep1ngTom]

OTTIMO! Bravissimo!

se permetti, due cosette:

a 01:43 è Beck (piccolo errore di battitura)

a 2:46 i piedi in bianco e nero sono di James Brown.

Cioè non avremo mai la certezza ma il passettino è il suo...

aggiungerei che i piedi nudi subito dopo, per me, sono di Novoselic dei Nirvana ma lì siamo già sulla pura teoria.

Grazie per questa cosa che hai voluto condividere.

[mangaterusso]

bravo...è un lavoro davvero difficile

[sandifra]

Bello Massi!

Davvero bravo!

[Bloom83]

Bellissimo! Ben Fatto!