despite technique here christina had the better performance because it was a tribute and there was more on the line for her to prove to measure up to james brown and the audience like hers better as you can see but if we go by technicality, beyonce wins by a mile
Singers can understand that christina is not screaming "it's all head voice babies" instead it's her own way. she's been lined up to whitney and mariah for a REASON. not you hater can bring her down "screw your mama, and stare away" lols.....i love you christina but my heart also for beyonce.. both of you are winners for me :)
people say christina is screaming and not singing but shes feeling the soul of the music. they both are good but most of the people saying christina was bad cant even sing lol
beyonce has better control of her voice and she's not just screaming on the top of her lungs. Don't get me wrong I do like Chrisitna but Beyonce wins.
I dont like either. Beyonce was not her usual self, she's just ok here. as for christina, i just dont get this performance, i mean she is screaming and growling throughout and to top it all off, that horrific scream in the middle. she has butchered the song into pieces. its just an overrated performance overall, i mean the other performances of that night were pretty bad, so i guess all the screaming she did had to stand out in comparison. James Brown was too good with the song.
@Alvinamigo1 funny because james brown always did that scream when he sang it..if it was so horrible then xtina wouldnt have a gotten a standing ovation that night #justsaying
Guys come on! why is this even a question? of course Christina is better. waaaayyyyy better! i'll tell you why. you see, beyonce is a black woman and we know that black people have better voices than the white, christina is white and it is unbelievable that she can be compared with such a good artist (beyonce) and that she wins! Xtina!!! <3 <3 <3
@ablackguy123456789 yes they can if she really was sick that day she could have just said she's sick & can't sing but I don't think that was the case here I just think that Christina tribute performance was so great that when it was her turn on stage she was not great as she usually is . That night I remember it as if it was yesterday Christina Aguilera got a standing ovation & everyone one including the press could not stop talking about how great Christina was .
Beyonce would always be my favorite. She is non stop when it comes to music. She's just not a one hit wonder then try to come back up. Christina is my gurl she got soul thats what i love about her.
Christina killed it. This was not the best performance of Beyoncé... And also she is not that good at changing the way her songs normally go, Christina does that way more naturally...
Kinda unfair. Considering Christinas is a cover, and Beyonce is just her own song. But Christina kills it. Her voice is more soulful and powerful. Thats why shes the voice of our generation :)
Beyonce!!!! Not only can she sing but if u listen to her throught out the years her voice seens to continue to grow. Her album 4 she be killing it!!! So Beyonce is abovisly the best. She a LEGEND in the making still! She could sing and dance circles around Christina!
Christina's voice is AMAZING but she always gets too messy and she screams waaaay too much.. Beyonce gives such a clean performance that you'd be able to feel what she feels while she's singing.... Christina can hit those notes but its not always about that
If this were a singing competition, no doubt, it's Christina! Beyonce's number was good but Christina's was awesome! What's amazing about her is she's not afraid to let it all out and she killed the high notes!
Love christina but she is just so over the top literally all the time. Too many runs for me so it jus sounds so messy... An that scream was too much. Beyonce has a sweeter voice and sounded great the whole time. She's so elegant and her voice just gave me chills. She took that one for sure. If it was a contest on who could sing and scream the loudest Christina would have won in a heartbeat.
I Just have to say, watchin xtina, it was nice, but Beyonce gave me chills, she's more sure of the notes she's hiting, and her voice is truly more beautiful tham xtina's,
The biggest most overrated female artist in history. She takes home the title of the copyright infringement queen without a doubt or competition when it comes to stealing other people's work the fraud is on a league of her own.She has done everything from stealing songs/image/ideas from other artist, to buying grammys, to faking a pregnancy or bribing billboard's millenium award. She leaves no questions to ask about why she's the fraud of this generation.
Am not a hater , I know what Beyonce can do & that night she was not on her game & sorry to say it but if you pin Christina doing & tribute to the godfather of soul against Beyonce am sorry but Christina always brings the house down . Her Stan's can cry all they want , who she was sick . Honey if you really was that sick she would be home resting not singing
@man4man7110 she was sick dumbass as she said on the eleen show next day and ellen said i was helping u out she was singing in the audience and that CHOKING STRAIN mess *YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAHRGHHHHHHH* "ITS A STRAINS WORLD"
Singing is not just shouting and shouting and shouting..im a voice teacher thats why i knew it...BEYONCE is better than Christina...
Then lets talk about their dance performances..Beyonce can sing and dance upto the fullest...while christina can just sway her booties like a GRO's in a Bar..
@cyberlooks Try to shout and and tell me if sounds the same as Christina. You're an ignorant cause what you call "shout" I call "vocal range", learn of music!
Christina seems to have a cat stuck in the throat. Beyonce hits the same notes with the greatest simplicity, while Christina does an absurd effort. And people confuse this with vocal power. This for me is called SHOUT. Beyonce was really sick, but did it better. Now I want to see you compare to the performance of "Listen" on Oprah.
Beyonce has a beautiful voice...but Christina is plain perfect in this performance...she manged to do the song her own but still with clear signs to the man she was paying homage to...her voice is incredible.
Both are great but I prefer Christina. Thats in my opinion the best performance of her. Sooo much raw soul and stage presence. James Brown would be proud.
Christina is really hit and miss. Beyonce is more constant in her performances. But when Christina is a hit....fuck she is incredible. Her rendition of James Brown was absolutely phenomenal. She definitely won this.
CHRISTINA has so much more soul in her voice, seriously. Beyonce and Christina, both are good vocalist but when you listen to Christina, she sings with such soul and emotion.
Xtina has a wonderfull voice nd a gr8 vocalist no doubt BUT she dosnt have a wide vocal range nd dosnt have control at tyms, she has a very powerfull voice nd dats wat helps her a lot. I've watchd a lot of xtina nd I'm a fan nd I notice dat she sounds thesame nd gives desame dramatic loud screamin performances ova nd ova nd over dos it som tyms.. Btw beyonce was ill when she sang this incase u have forgtn
Christina beats beyonce every night beyonces performance was boring , her stans say that it was because she was sick . Bullshit she just was not as good as Christina plain &b simple .
christina is great and her vocal range stretches way high. but i feel sometimes she screams abit to much. beyonce has a soothing undertone. i guess it depends on what song they are singing to see who sings better
Christina aguilera by far!!!! beyonce is a gret singer, but christina she is Phenomenal, Godness, TALENT, ARTIST, WOW, AMAZING, Legend, The best Singer of all the time!!!
Christina was amazing...always.... I love beyonce just as much but I wish beyonce would have made this a more hardcore vocal than a softer version of this song. She looks beautiful though no question. As far as comparing, you shouldn't compare these two divas. THEY ARE SIMPLY AMAZING and A SYMBOL OF OUR TIMES. I love them both and cherish them with all my heart...keep it up girls
Christina was amazing...always.... I love beyonce just as much but I wish beyonce would have made this a more hardcore vocal than a softer version of this song. She looks beautiful though no question. As far as comparing, you shouldn't compare these two divas. THEY ARE SIMPLY AMAZING and A SYMBOL OF OUR TIMES. I love them both and cherish them with all my heart...keep it up girls
@zanoases Strained or not, she still considered by most people to be a better vocalist than Beyonce. & her anthem flub only made her even more famous. Any press is good press!
@zanoases beyonce cannot even write her own songs ,she is such a lier , how many times have people being sueding her ass for stealing , she just had another album just the other day and she has being called out about 4 times already for stealing and xtina write her own songs, along with Linda Perry ,Christina making a mistake and forgetting the words like you are so perfect to never forget the words to a song especially when you are overcome with emotion and you 'r caught up in the moment
@zanoases shut up you don't know anything Christina singing a man world when on to be the 3 rd most Grammy moment ever , Christina is always making history , that was a E6 , people like you are always talking about her screaming who that fuck can sing like her the VOICE OF THE GENERATION , there is no one like her and it called a range when people scream it's a off pitch that is not a scream ... beyonce cannot sing like christina, she is only a performer not an artist .
2:18-2:41 was bloody awful. Christina was a mess all over the place, shouting things with so much tension & strain I started to get a headache. Just plain bad ugh -,-
Beyonce was simple & effortless. Both have 4 albums yet Beyonce has 12 solo grammys and Christina 4..LOL ok that explains it.
@tinaford101x Any one can sell albums and get grammes even producers it's all bout being cunning and know the right people Grammy doesn't make a artist even the great Michael Jackson who has 20 Grammy said so , so i don't see you point , Christina is one of the best vocalist in the world put among the best her performance that night made history and was talked about even on to this very day , beyonce is just a performer not an artist, she lacks soul and is all bout making money.
@MsTreysongz1 LOL girl plz# Beyonce sold 75 million records solo & was given the Artist of the Millenium Award, Female Artist of the decade. The point is this whole video was about the Grammys and Beyonce owns the show. But if you want to talk about something else, go ahead Beyonce will beat Xtina to it. When was Xtina's last #1? 10 years ago? #1 album and a grammy was 5 years ago. She has been forgotten so how could she be the voice of the generation if no one pays attention to her?
@MsTreysongz1 Thats with sales and popularity which means Beyonce is a more known name worldwide and people must like her music better, if more people went to go buy it (:
In terms of voice:
/watch?v=4JfkxKR_mKw Explain this video. If you give me a rubbish response dismissing Christina losing her voice, you are one of those in denial that she is just plain bad. Again no one calls her the voice of the generation except her tone deaf fans who have decreased in number since her last album..
Ok you all need to realize that the one note Christina did was not a screetch!! She was paying Homage to James Brown because he always shouted and did stuff like this in his performances. Her performance is praised to be one of the best performance ever at the grammys, and there is a reason why it is. Artists undertand the meaning of what she did, including her amazing vocals and emotional performance. Christina is the voice of out generation, and there is a reason why she is!!! HER VOICE!!
beyonce was ill and she sounded way better than christina's tiring performance... for u ppl who agree with her not perfecting her vocals, its hard to watch her struggle like that....
Christina Aguilera "screams" but her performance was amazing to me. Why does everyone have to sing perfectly and go by what a vocal coach says? She's managed and has been praised for her voice because it stands out IN A GOOD WAY despite what people say is vocally "incorrect". I thought there was more to singing and music than that. She obviously is still a solid vocalist, unless you think you can do any better lol doubt it though. Not many artists can, let alone you.
Christina Aguilera "screams" but her performance was amazing to me. Why does everyone have to sing perfectly and go by what a vocal coach says? She's managed and has been praised for her voice because it stands out IN A GOOD WAY despite what people say is vocally "incorrect". I thought there was more to singing and music than that. She obviously is still a solid vocalist, unless you think you can do any better lol doubt it though. Not many artists can, let alone you.
b-sing very well but is most known for her performance
XTINA IS KNOWN FOR HER VOICE
XTINA AND B, i love how ppl who dont study notes and range are the ones who say B is better STUDY NOTES SO THEN YOU HAVE A CORRECT OPINION AND NOT AN IGNORANT One
xtina has a bigger range, which means xtina can not only sing the notes that b can but can sing higher notes, xtina can hit the notes alot stronger 2
so many pll have voices like beyonce, their just not famous like her
Beyoncé! Xtina is bored, and Beyoncé was sick in this performance! And Beyoncé wons at Grammy in one night what Xtina wons in all her life with one grammys more!
xtina rules, who is that bitchonce?
daniolitheone 1 week ago
and beyonce wasnt even at her best here she was sick and still sounded amazing and sung better than christina
wozniacki15 1 week ago
despite technique here christina had the better performance because it was a tribute and there was more on the line for her to prove to measure up to james brown and the audience like hers better as you can see but if we go by technicality, beyonce wins by a mile
wozniacki15 1 week ago
Let the audience decide on this. They simply gave the legendary Christina an STANDING OVATION. What more proofs do u want?
edwarddorozan 2 weeks ago
Singers can understand that christina is not screaming "it's all head voice babies" instead it's her own way. she's been lined up to whitney and mariah for a REASON. not you hater can bring her down "screw your mama, and stare away" lols.....i love you christina but my heart also for beyonce.. both of you are winners for me :)
edwarddorozan 2 weeks ago
you guys are idiots .... these songs are completly diffrent
carloscnz06 2 weeks ago
-pulls out a chair for christina-
Dancing406 2 weeks ago
2:00 Christina Screamed for me Beyonce wins
16CelineDion 2 weeks ago
@16CelineDion QUE ES ESO DE CELINE DION, QUE TE PASA¡¡¡ HA VOLVIENDO AL TEMA CHRISTINA NO SOLO PARA MI ES LA MEJOR, SORRY DARLING
joce1596 2 weeks ago
sorry but its really hard to tell whether christina is singing or screaming sometimes
2:00 the fuck was that?
beyonce wins
dizzyb230 2 weeks ago
@dizzyb230 Christina manda¡¡¡
joce1596 2 weeks ago
The two best singers in the world being compared? bullshit
MrBabygirl08x 2 weeks ago
Who could I spend my money on to see live? Obviously beyonce
effahthebest 3 weeks ago
Beyonce:) but i also love Christina<33 They're are both amazing
cfkfhbldkfjh98 3 weeks ago
Etta James: "At Last" & " Tell Momma" put Beyonce & Aguilera to shame.
byzinski 3 weeks ago
people say christina is screaming and not singing but shes feeling the soul of the music. they both are good but most of the people saying christina was bad cant even sing lol
kingnickle002 3 weeks ago
Tumbs up if you think that the 2 are both PERFECT
ILoveMusic7710 3 weeks ago
CHRISTINA! 4sure!
101rafia 3 weeks ago
CHRISTINA IS AMAAAAAAAAAAAAAZING!!
IngridCalvo 3 weeks ago
CHRISTINA!!!!
azul1116 3 weeks ago
Beyonce is perfection oppose to Xtina's screaming grunting and unidentified notes
10hooper 3 weeks ago
beyonce hit that high note i cannot hit it at all even when i try lol
lissanbrown 3 weeks ago
Christina Bravo Bravo
NICAT646 3 weeks ago
Beyonce, love Christina but sometimes you want singing and not screaming
tjackwc 4 weeks ago
Beyonce SEMPRE!!!
elen1507 4 weeks ago
beyonce has better control of her voice and she's not just screaming on the top of her lungs. Don't get me wrong I do like Chrisitna but Beyonce wins.
JKiNG945 4 weeks ago
christina is 10x sexier than b-shit!
gawdesanket 4 weeks ago
Beyonce !!! La canción de Christina fue como muchos gritoss no me gusto para nada!!
Deby1232 1 month ago
CHRISTINA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ahtivah 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I dont like either. Beyonce was not her usual self, she's just ok here. as for christina, i just dont get this performance, i mean she is screaming and growling throughout and to top it all off, that horrific scream in the middle. she has butchered the song into pieces. its just an overrated performance overall, i mean the other performances of that night were pretty bad, so i guess all the screaming she did had to stand out in comparison. James Brown was too good with the song.
sandyzmz 1 month ago
Comment removed
sandyzmz 1 month ago
2:00 its like any girl screaming... BEYONCE is LEGEND!
Alvinamigo1 1 month ago
@Alvinamigo1 funny because james brown always did that scream when he sang it..if it was so horrible then xtina wouldnt have a gotten a standing ovation that night #justsaying
gangstaladie 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
Alvinamigo1 1 month ago
It's all Christina!! Always will be!
TheAditiSA 1 month ago
Guys come on! why is this even a question? of course Christina is better. waaaayyyyy better! i'll tell you why. you see, beyonce is a black woman and we know that black people have better voices than the white, christina is white and it is unbelievable that she can be compared with such a good artist (beyonce) and that she wins! Xtina!!! <3 <3 <3
emmawatson1997fan 1 month ago
@emmawatson1997fan racist.
hoyauhung 1 month ago
@hoyauhung i'm not a racist so shut up! i'm christina's fan:))
emmawatson1997fan 1 week ago
@emmawatson1997fan stupid
swacman04 1 month ago
btw, christina got this! <3
CooolioBaby 1 month ago
Why is this even a question? Both women are amazing in their own way, but Christina takes this battle.
AdrenalineHeat 1 month ago 6
@ablackguy123456789 yes they can if she really was sick that day she could have just said she's sick & can't sing but I don't think that was the case here I just think that Christina tribute performance was so great that when it was her turn on stage she was not great as she usually is . That night I remember it as if it was yesterday Christina Aguilera got a standing ovation & everyone one including the press could not stop talking about how great Christina was .
man4man7110 1 month ago
@MsRaven61 Mariah, Whitney, Kelly, Beyonce, Barbra, Aretha, Lara, Mary, Jennifer, Amber, Taeyeon, And many more
SuperPianogirl123 1 month ago
Beyonce would always be my favorite. She is non stop when it comes to music. She's just not a one hit wonder then try to come back up. Christina is my gurl she got soul thats what i love about her.
puffin105 1 month ago
For me Christina has the best voice. but The only Queen of R&B Beyoncé is wonderful.
MisterGaGa1685 1 month ago
Christina killed it. This was not the best performance of Beyoncé... And also she is not that good at changing the way her songs normally go, Christina does that way more naturally...
almuublanco 2 months ago
christina aguilera!!!! =)
francocou87 2 months ago
BOTH .) but CHRISTINA IS QWEEN !!..)))
ladislavpompa 2 months ago
Also Beyonce has echo on lmfao.
21JaBbAwOcKeEz21 2 months ago
Kinda unfair. Considering Christinas is a cover, and Beyonce is just her own song. But Christina kills it. Her voice is more soulful and powerful. Thats why shes the voice of our generation :)
21JaBbAwOcKeEz21 2 months ago 4
Beyonce!!!! Not only can she sing but if u listen to her throught out the years her voice seens to continue to grow. Her album 4 she be killing it!!! So Beyonce is abovisly the best. She a LEGEND in the making still! She could sing and dance circles around Christina!
juvus1000 2 months ago
Comment removed
wax291 2 months ago
Comment removed
wax291 2 months ago
b looked so stupid here.. aguilera wins!
wax291 2 months ago 2
I THOUGHT XTINA IS GIVING BIRTH ON STAGE WHEN SHE SCREAM THAT SCREACHY NOTE
pieceofbritnald 2 months ago 2
Beyonce!
EdwinElChulo 2 months ago
CHRISTINA AGUILERA #THEBEST
NickOfficialMusic 2 months ago 2
Christina es la MEJOR del MUNDO en VOZ!!!!
TheRoberteacher 2 months ago
QUEEN XTINA!!
charmd1818 2 months ago
Christina's voice is AMAZING but she always gets too messy and she screams waaaay too much.. Beyonce gives such a clean performance that you'd be able to feel what she feels while she's singing.... Christina can hit those notes but its not always about that
toyosioduko2 2 months ago
Excuse me....Queen bee wins!!
Roleenepierre890 2 months ago
Sorry Christina i can' say nothing u have a really goood voice ,,, but only this ...
BEYONCE is everything .... she's a LEGEND !!
Monster94100 2 months ago 4
Christina is fantastic, but in the big picture, Beyoncés the best, and will always be... B the Queen.
TheNikolajnn 2 months ago 19
@TheNikolajnn when it comes the biggest slut picture. one and only b-shit reminds me. lol!
gawdesanket 4 weeks ago
I love them both, they are the 2 pop stars that can actually sing but Christina's performance was better.
arianneoneill 2 months ago
BEYONCE! BEYONCE! BEYONCE!!!!
courtdnz 2 months ago
in terms of voice they are both good!!! but who is the reaLLy great?????
jayJB102095 2 months ago
If this were a singing competition, no doubt, it's Christina! Beyonce's number was good but Christina's was awesome! What's amazing about her is she's not afraid to let it all out and she killed the high notes!
mikajolie 2 months ago 2
BEYONCé is realy realy good singer HOWEVER AGUILERA HAS SOMETHING SPECIAL IN HER VOICE MAKES HER unique !!!! just sayin'
SuperSuperalgerien 2 months ago
Love christina but she is just so over the top literally all the time. Too many runs for me so it jus sounds so messy... An that scream was too much. Beyonce has a sweeter voice and sounded great the whole time. She's so elegant and her voice just gave me chills. She took that one for sure. If it was a contest on who could sing and scream the loudest Christina would have won in a heartbeat.
Smiles23341 3 months ago
The Christina's voice is incredible....I like beyonce but nobody as Chrix
rosalinda1428 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I Just have to say, watchin xtina, it was nice, but Beyonce gave me chills, she's more sure of the notes she's hiting, and her voice is truly more beautiful tham xtina's,
KingBBaly 3 months ago
Comment removed
KingBBaly 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The biggest most overrated female artist in history. She takes home the title of the copyright infringement queen without a doubt or competition when it comes to stealing other people's work the fraud is on a league of her own.She has done everything from stealing songs/image/ideas from other artist, to buying grammys, to faking a pregnancy or bribing billboard's millenium award. She leaves no questions to ask about why she's the fraud of this generation.
lc0309 3 months ago
Obviously Christina had more soul than beyonce. But as we know queen b has the goods when entertaining a crowd with a dance routine
Rollinginthevoice 3 months ago 3
Christina gives me chills Beyoncé not. Both are my favorite singers but Christina's voice Awesome!!!
jldalex 3 months ago
Christina <3
iloveXtina94 3 months ago
XTINA WAAAAAAAAAAY BETTER
leandrooalmeida11 3 months ago
BEYONCEEE :)
captainpineappleMaVi 3 months ago
christinaaaaa
chyna9th 3 months ago
christina is a better singer than beyonce! her voice is just phenomenal but i love beyonce too
tarmoul1 3 months ago
Christina)
StasiaDenisova 3 months ago
Scream some more christina...maybe it will actually sound good some day.
slayer3to10 3 months ago
Christina Aguilera HANDS DOWN!!!
jdizzo21 3 months ago
Am not a hater , I know what Beyonce can do & that night she was not on her game & sorry to say it but if you pin Christina doing & tribute to the godfather of soul against Beyonce am sorry but Christina always brings the house down . Her Stan's can cry all they want , who she was sick . Honey if you really was that sick she would be home resting not singing
man4man7110 3 months ago
@man4man7110
Go see her other performances of Listen.
WhitneyElizabethH 3 months ago 5
@man4man7110 a singer can't just cancel a gig or a performance at the last minute. it's not that simple
ablackguy123456789 1 month ago
@man4man7110 she was sick dumbass as she said on the eleen show next day and ellen said i was helping u out she was singing in the audience and that CHOKING STRAIN mess *YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAHRGHHHHHHH* "ITS A STRAINS WORLD"
beyonceboy100 1 month ago
James Brown is right! It IS a man's world! No matter how many fucking females try to do a cover for this or just sing it Boys will Always rule!
Females know that boys rule and that's why they keep singing this song!
MrDjoyahs 3 months ago
Beyonce's is good for all genres and is soothing and Christina might as well be black
rocket123j 3 months ago
Christina Aguilera tem uma voz incrivel, mais compara-lá com Beyonce é um pecado ¬¬, Beyonce é um artista completa !
E a questão das notas, Beyonce alcança sem esforço já Cristina Aguilera faz muito esforço para alcançar a nota !
Igorbianchi1 4 months ago
Crisrtina is better, does waay more with her voice
pascalleye 4 months ago
BEYONCÉ IS SOOO MUCH BETTER THAN CHRISTINA AGUILERA !
sarah77743 4 months ago
@sarah77743 NOOOOOO SHE IS DEFINITLY NOOOOOOOOOOOOOT!! SHE IS BOOORING AND WITHOUT HEEEER GREEEAAAT TECHNICE SHEE WOULD BEE TALENTLEEEEESSS!
CooolioBaby 1 month ago
Christina should be compared to Gaga .. Gaga is such a copier ..
brownchix18 4 months ago
@brownchix18 wouldn't that just be disrespectful to Christina?
MrDjoyahs 3 months ago
of course QUEENTINA <3
xtinasfighter 4 months ago 2
I love Beyoncé and Listen but Christina wins without no doubt, she has more vocal range sooo far!
EverbodyLovesMegamix 4 months ago
Beyonce outshines everyone else on the planet concerning vocals and over all talent, maybe not on this occasion, but everyone has their off days...
paulstuartgreenough 4 months ago
Singing is not just shouting and shouting and shouting..im a voice teacher thats why i knew it...BEYONCE is better than Christina...
Then lets talk about their dance performances..Beyonce can sing and dance upto the fullest...while christina can just sway her booties like a GRO's in a Bar..
cyberlooks 4 months ago
@cyberlooks sorry, but you're an idiot.
djtr1ck 4 months ago
@djtr1ck Totally agree!
EverbodyLovesMegamix 4 months ago
Comment removed
EverbodyLovesMegamix 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cyberlooks Try to shout and and tell me if sounds the same as Christina. You're an ignorant cause what you call "shout" I call "vocal range", learn of music!
EverbodyLovesMegamix 4 months ago
beyonce is good but christina aguilera is PHENOMENAL
tarmoul1 4 months ago 35
i love beyonce, but Christina is Perfection in this Grammy performence, so raw and powerful!
SAIDON92 4 months ago 4
What was that shit at 1:57? Shameful attempt to whistle.
rafael0s3 4 months ago
Christina seems to have a cat stuck in the throat. Beyonce hits the same notes with the greatest simplicity, while Christina does an absurd effort. And people confuse this with vocal power. This for me is called SHOUT. Beyonce was really sick, but did it better. Now I want to see you compare to the performance of "Listen" on Oprah.
rafael0s3 4 months ago 2
@rafael0s3 i doubt if Beyonce can shout like that. It takes vocal skills to shout like Christina. bet my ass Rihanna can't do that.
SAIDON92 4 months ago
@SAIDON92 As I said, Beyonce can do it better, because she hits the same notes with no effort.
rafael0s3 4 months ago 2
Beyoncé was sick on this performance,
makes no sense to compare ....
But Christina don't sing, she screams ...
Beyoncé is better EVER!
rafael0s3 4 months ago 2
i love them both... probably beyonce the most, but nobody can top christina's 'man's world' no one!
NadiaLFCullen 4 months ago
Beyonce has a beautiful voice...but Christina is plain perfect in this performance...she manged to do the song her own but still with clear signs to the man she was paying homage to...her voice is incredible.
rosemaju 4 months ago 2
christina
ana34972 4 months ago 2
GEEEEZ ALL THE SCREAMING POWER OMG!! I DONT CALL THAT MUSIC, THAT IS NOISE!!! YEAH CHRISTINA SURE GOT THE SCREAMING POWER LOL!
eigger57 4 months ago
Both are great but I prefer Christina. Thats in my opinion the best performance of her. Sooo much raw soul and stage presence. James Brown would be proud.
ArchiducDeBelgrade 4 months ago 2
BEOYNCE WAS ILL AT THIS PERFORMACNE!!!
itsMUSICY 4 months ago
Christina is really hit and miss. Beyonce is more constant in her performances. But when Christina is a hit....fuck she is incredible. Her rendition of James Brown was absolutely phenomenal. She definitely won this.
kolossal17 4 months ago
christina
MsTreysongz1 4 months ago
i pick christina but they're both awesome. best singers of my generation
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
CHRISTINA has so much more soul in her voice, seriously. Beyonce and Christina, both are good vocalist but when you listen to Christina, she sings with such soul and emotion.
watchmakeuptips 4 months ago
Comment removed
watchmakeuptips 4 months ago
Xtina has a wonderfull voice nd a gr8 vocalist no doubt BUT she dosnt have a wide vocal range nd dosnt have control at tyms, she has a very powerfull voice nd dats wat helps her a lot. I've watchd a lot of xtina nd I'm a fan nd I notice dat she sounds thesame nd gives desame dramatic loud screamin performances ova nd ova nd over dos it som tyms.. Btw beyonce was ill when she sang this incase u have forgtn
missArsenal18x 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I dont think so
Sexyduff 4 months ago
Beyonce has NOTHING on Christina Aguilera, her voice is just LEGENDARY.
MilesDemetriaSelx 4 months ago
Christina beats beyonce every night beyonces performance was boring , her stans say that it was because she was sick . Bullshit she just was not as good as Christina plain &b simple .
man4man7110 4 months ago
@man4man7110
Well Her 'Listen' Performances are usuallty bettter then this So i think it's a Good enough excuse
WhitneyElizabethH 4 months ago 7
@man4man7110 bullshit!!! we all know that Beyonce slaughtered christina that night!!!
Beyoncefan1000 4 months ago
@man4man7110 i sense hate... hmm.
Jisjimmy07 3 months ago
@man4man7110 What to expect Beyonce should dance to the tune of listen? BULLSHIT 2x
neshutch 3 months ago
christina is great and her vocal range stretches way high. but i feel sometimes she screams abit to much. beyonce has a soothing undertone. i guess it depends on what song they are singing to see who sings better
atwodollarnote 4 months ago
Christina Aguilera obvious! she got more power in her voice
Sexyduff 4 months ago
@Sexyduff Beyonce is better!!!
Beyoncefan1000 4 months ago
Christina aguilera by far!!!! beyonce is a gret singer, but christina she is Phenomenal, Godness, TALENT, ARTIST, WOW, AMAZING, Legend, The best Singer of all the time!!!
tarmoul1 4 months ago
Christina wiped the floor with Beyonce . No one remembers her boring performance after X-Tina took the stage
man4man7110 4 months ago
i love how everyone forgets that beyonce was sick during her listen performance.
MeowTKD316 5 months ago
CHRISTINA AGUILERA IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE THE VOICE.....wow her voice is so powerfull.... Love her.
I love Beyonce too.! but she's better dancing!
MrRafaTony 5 months ago
Christina was amazing...always.... I love beyonce just as much but I wish beyonce would have made this a more hardcore vocal than a softer version of this song. She looks beautiful though no question. As far as comparing, you shouldn't compare these two divas. THEY ARE SIMPLY AMAZING and A SYMBOL OF OUR TIMES. I love them both and cherish them with all my heart...keep it up girls
LilMissBlueEyes247 5 months ago
Christina was amazing...always.... I love beyonce just as much but I wish beyonce would have made this a more hardcore vocal than a softer version of this song. She looks beautiful though no question. As far as comparing, you shouldn't compare these two divas. THEY ARE SIMPLY AMAZING and A SYMBOL OF OUR TIMES. I love them both and cherish them with all my heart...keep it up girls
LilMissBlueEyes247 5 months ago
Christina's Grammy performance of "A Man's World" completely shits all over every thing Beyonce has done. Sorry.
WeaponsOfSeduction 5 months ago 2
asshole...and you're wrong
LilMissBlueEyes247 5 months ago
WeaponsOfSeduction sorry, Christina Screamlera cant sing, forced vocals 2:00 thats not singing!
christina vocals are always strained, not controlled, hahahaha she is the biggest anthem fail ever
zanoases 5 months ago
@zanoases Strained or not, she still considered by most people to be a better vocalist than Beyonce. & her anthem flub only made her even more famous. Any press is good press!
WeaponsOfSeduction 5 months ago 3
Comment removed
zanoases 5 months ago
@zanoases beyonce cannot even write her own songs ,she is such a lier , how many times have people being sueding her ass for stealing , she just had another album just the other day and she has being called out about 4 times already for stealing and xtina write her own songs, along with Linda Perry ,Christina making a mistake and forgetting the words like you are so perfect to never forget the words to a song especially when you are overcome with emotion and you 'r caught up in the moment
MsTreysongz1 4 months ago
@zanoases shut up you don't know anything Christina singing a man world when on to be the 3 rd most Grammy moment ever , Christina is always making history , that was a E6 , people like you are always talking about her screaming who that fuck can sing like her the VOICE OF THE GENERATION , there is no one like her and it called a range when people scream it's a off pitch that is not a scream ... beyonce cannot sing like christina, she is only a performer not an artist .
MsTreysongz1 4 months ago
XTINA XTINA XTINA XTINA
finallyrealasyhari 5 months ago 2
2:18-2:41 was bloody awful. Christina was a mess all over the place, shouting things with so much tension & strain I started to get a headache. Just plain bad ugh -,-
Beyonce was simple & effortless. Both have 4 albums yet Beyonce has 12 solo grammys and Christina 4..LOL ok that explains it.
tinaford101x 5 months ago
@tinaford101x Any one can sell albums and get grammes even producers it's all bout being cunning and know the right people Grammy doesn't make a artist even the great Michael Jackson who has 20 Grammy said so , so i don't see you point , Christina is one of the best vocalist in the world put among the best her performance that night made history and was talked about even on to this very day , beyonce is just a performer not an artist, she lacks soul and is all bout making money.
MsTreysongz1 4 months ago
@MsTreysongz1 LOL girl plz# Beyonce sold 75 million records solo & was given the Artist of the Millenium Award, Female Artist of the decade. The point is this whole video was about the Grammys and Beyonce owns the show. But if you want to talk about something else, go ahead Beyonce will beat Xtina to it. When was Xtina's last #1? 10 years ago? #1 album and a grammy was 5 years ago. She has been forgotten so how could she be the voice of the generation if no one pays attention to her?
tinaford101x 4 months ago
@MsTreysongz1 Thats with sales and popularity which means Beyonce is a more known name worldwide and people must like her music better, if more people went to go buy it (:
In terms of voice:
/watch?v=4JfkxKR_mKw Explain this video. If you give me a rubbish response dismissing Christina losing her voice, you are one of those in denial that she is just plain bad. Again no one calls her the voice of the generation except her tone deaf fans who have decreased in number since her last album..
tinaford101x 4 months ago
this made me a Christina Fan. Her best live vocal performance. Maybe one of the best in Grammy History.
westboem 5 months ago
i'll never understand why that out of tune, flat strained fest performance of christina is rendered as something phenomenal to her fans. :(
kelvinpyaeko 5 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko
well aren't you a joyful thing.
MrsMeowMeowWoof 5 months ago
@MrsMeowMeowWoof and your point?
kelvinpyaeko 5 months ago
Ok you all need to realize that the one note Christina did was not a screetch!! She was paying Homage to James Brown because he always shouted and did stuff like this in his performances. Her performance is praised to be one of the best performance ever at the grammys, and there is a reason why it is. Artists undertand the meaning of what she did, including her amazing vocals and emotional performance. Christina is the voice of out generation, and there is a reason why she is!!! HER VOICE!!
jakes48162 5 months ago 2
Christina is always the best! Beyonce saks ;)
krechetana 5 months ago 4
CHRISTINA KILLED IT. AINT NO OTHER MAN MTV MOVIE AWARDS 2006. AND LADY MARMALADE GRAMMYS WITH PATTIE LABELLE. TAKE THAT JACKASS
DESHAWNKASUMI21 5 months ago 9
CHRISTINA AGUILERA IS A DAM SINGER who give **** about her tchnique BEYONC2 IS REALY GOOD BUT XTINA IS SO DIFFRENT §§
poperline 5 months ago
beyonce was ill and she sounded way better than christina's tiring performance... for u ppl who agree with her not perfecting her vocals, its hard to watch her struggle like that....
Vediboi888 5 months ago
Christina Aguilera "screams" but her performance was amazing to me. Why does everyone have to sing perfectly and go by what a vocal coach says? She's managed and has been praised for her voice because it stands out IN A GOOD WAY despite what people say is vocally "incorrect". I thought there was more to singing and music than that. She obviously is still a solid vocalist, unless you think you can do any better lol doubt it though. Not many artists can, let alone you.
tito121090 5 months ago
Christina Aguilera "screams" but her performance was amazing to me. Why does everyone have to sing perfectly and go by what a vocal coach says? She's managed and has been praised for her voice because it stands out IN A GOOD WAY despite what people say is vocally "incorrect". I thought there was more to singing and music than that. She obviously is still a solid vocalist, unless you think you can do any better lol doubt it though. Not many artists can, let alone you.
tito121090 5 months ago
christina christina!! beyonce beyonce!!
TheAicha1996 5 months ago 3
beyonce best
georgialovesqueenB 5 months ago 3
I'm sorry but no one beats Christina Aguilera she's got a hell of a range.
MsRaven61 6 months ago 52
xtina-VOICE OF OUR GENERATION
b-sing very well but is most known for her performance
XTINA IS KNOWN FOR HER VOICE
XTINA AND B, i love how ppl who dont study notes and range are the ones who say B is better STUDY NOTES SO THEN YOU HAVE A CORRECT OPINION AND NOT AN IGNORANT One
xtina has a bigger range, which means xtina can not only sing the notes that b can but can sing higher notes, xtina can hit the notes alot stronger 2
so many pll have voices like beyonce, their just not famous like her
cuptink1331 6 months ago 2
xtina beautiful! beyonce screems horrible!
mrkfitz 6 months ago
Beyoncé! Xtina is bored, and Beyoncé was sick in this performance! And Beyoncé wons at Grammy in one night what Xtina wons in all her life with one grammys more!
IwannaBeUrGod 6 months ago
who got the standing ovation though?
Mcvideos92 6 months ago
@Mcvideos92 lol right!
bklynchicka994 6 months ago
THE END NOTE OF FLOPTINA POOR STRAIN OMG
beyonceboy100 6 months ago