This song never fail to make me cry... Ka Kui, there were still so much more you could share with us, why are you so cruel? Why you left us so soon? You can never be replaced... The most talented and passionate rock and roll artist of all time! I love you!
@howintang 要樂壇要起,係需要正視咩係音樂 要做真正令心思索既歌,唔係只係靠所謂既[功力] 論唱,GEM真係唱得,但佢都仍然只係唱pop love song 當一批可以唱pop love song以外,都可以引起迴響,引起共嗚 樂壇先叫得上[有救] 始終,香港既樂壇未受過教育,只係以錢行先 只係制造一班人俾人去喜愛,從而搵錢 我夠膽講句,問而窕所謂既歌星,咩係音樂教育 十個未必有三個答得出真正既答案 音樂唔只係娛樂咁簡單的
So many people have sung this song, even top singers like Jacky Cheung but not one person sings it as good as Ka Kui. NO ONE sings this song as good as Ka Kui does. He sings this song like an angel.
i have been trying to mimic this line, for 10+ years. i just cannot achieve, even once. as far as i know, no one ever can approach the technique and uniqueness.
To me, his technique is even better than jacky cheung in singing. of course, jacky is in the top level doubtlessly.
Beyond is the best band in Hong Kong, even in the world. No one can replace them in my heart! No one can replace them in Hong Kong! What they contribute to Hong Kong can't use the words to describe! How I miss them also can't use the words to describe!
it's a good time listening to kakui's 情人 on Valentines day... i always listened to this song alone when it's Valentines day... just feels that kakui is by our side...
its just stupid to compare s.h.e. to beyond. both entirely different genres.. beyond is about music. s.h.e... wait, my little teeny bopper cousin listens to them!
u see? apparently u r not very welcome here as a die hard s.h.e fan. but if u really want to express yourself, -
you can scroll your mouse up, find the search box, type your sweet heart's name, click search, go to those vds, and STICK WITH IT. Im sure u will feel better there, when there r people like u all around.
Of course, thats only if u dont like to make fool of yourself
to me,s.h.e is nothing n still a long way compare to beyond...they depend on image look not like ka kui...he sing with his emotion n let everybody noe wat is call music....like music not because of beautiful image or handsome...like music because u understand the meaning of the music they sang...
i remember i saw this vid when i was a kid n my memory of the vid is blurry... therefore i'v always been wanting to watch it again... n now i have a chance... i appreciate that... love this vid as it's kind of a mini documentary of ka kui...
legend singer
roackmai 2 days ago
This song never fail to make me cry... Ka Kui, there were still so much more you could share with us, why are you so cruel? Why you left us so soon? You can never be replaced... The most talented and passionate rock and roll artist of all time! I love you!
Chotto1977 1 week ago
想你~家駒~
gogogogog85 1 month ago
家駒 我地好懷念你 我在97年之後先出生 仲未聽你唱歌架 點解你要離開我地?
abc50451 1 month ago 6
冇得彈!
2121kit 1 month ago
根據非正式統計27萬人中仲會有5個標奇立異的人~
888stephenchu 1 month ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
one of the great regret in my life is i got no chance to listen this song with live version.. .
wINgLuVnEvErDiE 4 months ago
Comment removed
wINgLuVnEvErDiE 4 months ago
RIP 家駒;-*
520Mello 4 months ago
best song ever to bad his dead
huyyeuco3 4 months ago
Absolutely a legend. People who have this kind of passion come through in their music come once a century, if that.
We miss you dearly, Ka Kui.
KeleiSpeaks 4 months ago 3
best oldschool canto song ever
huyyeuco3 5 months ago in playlist Beyond
神曲為什麼有人不喜歡呢
Nickbabyify 5 months ago
多謝您家駒! 你是香港人的光榮! 溫柔,善良, 有內涵, 清新, 充滿愛的種子!
永遠記念你!
wanny611 6 months ago
雖然佢離開後幾個月至出世,但睇到佢D經典片段,真係好鍾意佢呀
alexyk923 6 months ago
Comment removed
seahouse520 7 months ago
實在是不想相信 你真的離開了
就算再經過N年 你還是在我們心中...
arica916 8 months ago
如果家駒還在,不知有多好,你真是個好人!真的深深被你的才華吸引!你去世時我才11歲!我現在已快30了!現在才懂得欣賞你的才華,如果有下輩子,希望我能早點認識你~唉
y92315101 9 months ago
@y92315101
其實PAUL已經說過
當時家駒已經想退出樂壇的了
如果家駒當年沒有[走]
讓他看到現今樂壇
不是更可悲嗎?
當作讓家駒走時心中還有一點的美好回憶吧
gemi0606 3 months ago 3
@gemi0606 i think GEM will bring 樂壇 back to live.
howintang 1 month ago
Comment removed
dooolu 1 month ago
gemi0606 1 month ago 2
我即使離開 你的天空裡
anyeram 9 months ago
你可知,誰甘心歸去...
Alan123103 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Happy Valentines Day....
stephanielenalee 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Happy Valentines Day.....
stephanielenalee 11 months ago
Comment removed
stephanielenalee 11 months ago
我朋友的妹妹從小就很聰明而且獨立但身體總是很墟弱,不到廿歲就因病逝世。在她的回魂夜我朋友和他的雙親看見她身穿白袍坐在客廳裡全身散發箸異彩;對他們說道〝我本來是天上的使者因為進行歷練投身為你們的家人而已,請不要為我難過,請把我忘了,要好好的生活〞她說完了就消失了。
koreanetbuy 11 months ago
華人的音樂精神繫於家駒
nickchu316 1 year ago
@nickchu316
抱歉按錯了不喜歡,希望你別介意...
sitchunman 2 months ago
very sad
184352 1 year ago
Comment removed
5230ken 1 year ago
順道一提~小弟是個樂團愛好者,看過那麼多台上台下的歌手,真的沒一個人唱的比家駒好聽,他的聲線太獨特了
1234567890aska 1 year ago 5
@1234567890aska
0704Nightmare 1 year ago
我認為~
老天爺常提早帶走一些不一樣的人,因為這些人把未來的東西提前帶來這個世界,,
就像這首歌~以現有的新歌詞曲都不一定比這首來的有情感,像李小龍,約翰藍儂,貓王,都是給世界帶來了一定的影響和改變,但都提早讓上帝帶回去身邊,真的很神奇
1234567890aska 1 year ago 8
堪称经典中之经典,谁与争锋,家驹,永远致敬。
winnietennis 1 year ago
多谢家驹哥哥不死的精神,痛爱他的曲与词。激历人心。。非常怀念家驹哥哥的声音!祝福你
Avelynncwy 1 year ago
憂鬱滄桑的歌聲
聽了我流淚~
biobi520 1 year ago
love n peace, that's what u taught me when i was young. stil reminds in my heart, love you always
elasticandygal 1 year ago
太屌了~
biobi520 1 year ago
百聽不厭!
loveleslie100 1 year ago 2
想不到,多年後我聽的,還是家駒的歌!
markpukete 1 year ago
有Beyond,有音樂!!!
friensddogdog 1 year ago
subscribe me whoever u are if u like my videos
larrainewong 1 year ago
百聲不厭不足以形容這首歌,這輩最愛的歌
mamalikb 1 year ago
懷念家駒!!
namida401 1 year ago
You're the best and no one can sing your songs better than you. I absolutely love you.
smilesmile247 1 year ago
懷念家駒
mamiying 1 year ago
首首歌都咁好聼. 現在的歌星真的要學習下咯?
willy1b1b 1 year ago
我第–次看家駒的videos,很特別,於是我花時間看差不多全部在youtube的影片,他是有理想有忍耐的人,聲音特別很吸引,對音樂的熱情比任何歌手熱情,有愛心很努苦,他同陳百強一橡都是天才但風格不同,2人付出很多,回報很少,可能真正樂者諒是這樣吧!真的不想他們死,很痛心!謝謝!
faifaigirl 1 year ago 6
盼望家駒在天的另一方能開心快樂,我永遠祝福你
gao1580 1 year ago 2
怀念家驹
guangsu1118 1 year ago 2
我是听BEYOND歌长大的!!!! 家駒!!!!
ijikoya 1 year ago 5
Love you forever 家驹!my heart, my <3, my inspiration. ^v^
georgiatbk 1 year ago
果段獻給詞本來係beyond送比歌迷,
而家就彷彿家駒生前送比歌迷既遺言....唉.....
lowping54 1 year ago 2
人不在,歌還在,他的歌他的人會遠留在我們心中
evo19841203 1 year ago 4
看到你天真的笑容...認真的模樣...真是讓人無法想像你就這樣走了...老天爺..為什麼?
beyond630610 1 year ago 6
真的好想你....家駒!你是大家永遠的~情人~!
beyond630610 1 year ago 6
Best Love song EVER in history
acaftermath 2 years ago 4
百聽不厭...
kuen1688 2 years ago 17
家駒是永恆的,,beyond的歌都是~~
love ka kui forever!!
bestsmalltwin 2 years ago 5
It's ashame that we can't hear him singing live.
PsalterCrystal 2 years ago 3
So many people have sung this song, even top singers like Jacky Cheung but not one person sings it as good as Ka Kui. NO ONE sings this song as good as Ka Kui does. He sings this song like an angel.
ewan4ever 2 years ago 29
家駒係冇人可以代替既
Ventolinloveu 2 years ago 3
BEYOND FOREVER!
mryoji 2 years ago 6
希望你快樂...
只是,我總是無法停止想你念你,帶著這首歌,有天我們會再見.
vicky52019840 2 years ago 6
家駒我好想你喔!
你給我們的一切聲音
真是太美好了
希望你永遠快樂
peteroo147852 2 years ago 6
我不知道这种感觉可不可以形容成怀念一个旧情人。
虽然很多回忆模糊了,但那份感觉还很强。就听听这首歌。。。
你也许可以明白 Beyond 给过我的那份回忆。
kevlee127 2 years ago 7
好歌!
endeavor6636 2 years ago 4
每每听这首歌都很伤感。。。想念你,家驹。
cissim86 2 years ago 3
Singapore fans will remember u forever 家駒....
JediCris 2 years ago 4
懷念家驅不巧的音樂精神~(beyond的永遠樂迷)
gtat123 2 years ago 9
好掛住家駒呀,,,,
MrHanghang 2 years ago 7
Can anyone have an attempt to translate this in english. I am chinese but my cantonese is crap.
laisunliu 2 years ago
Comment removed
laisunliu 2 years ago
i love you Ka Kui
no one can sing this song better than you
absolutely no one !
hei398 2 years ago 5
足以流傳後世的經典之作
zitane0815 2 years ago 4
永垂不朽的金曲
dominiclok 2 years ago 8
我呢十幾年聽呢隻歌已經有千次、萬次,但我始終於呢隻歌美極既旋律、美極既歌詞及美極既意境。《情人》呢隻歌就好似我既夢中情人,佢代表著我最美既幻想,令我無時無刻都迷戀著。
goodmanttw 2 years ago 16
懷念與想念永遠的家駒~
army1729 2 years ago 3
this is the best song I 've ever heard of beyon .....I Love them so much.....!
stevo890 2 years ago 4
情人這首歌雖然是10幾年的歌了,到現在聽起來一點也不老,真是百聽不厭,家駒作曲的功力真是一個字"強"
ayu661205 2 years ago 113
也聽過幾個翻唱的.但聽起來就是沒有家駒唱的有感覺有感情 (家駒的歌聲太有磁性)
ayu661205 2 years ago 11
他能帶出那份空虛和無奈,別的是無法比擬的。
dominiclok 2 years ago 7
@ayu661205
真正的音乐很经得起时间的考验,相信我。再过10年你也喜欢这首歌。
alexanderliustar 6 months ago 4
@ayu661205 对,现在很少有个乐队能像他们,真的好怀念
klein8699 4 months ago
我愛你家駒 係你d歌同家駒精神令我起番身
96512396 2 years ago 4
不死傳奇:黃家駒
tanwengseng 2 years ago 4
Miss You .家駒
雖然你離開左咁多年,但我還喜歡聽你的歌!
每次聽到家駒歌 我就覺得佢重來都無離開過我地!
hide940115 2 years ago 5
miss 家駒
HSCool 2 years ago 6
副歌的地方好像一首詩
simontse1992 2 years ago 8
太可惜/情人/地知道嗎/
snooker927 2 years ago 3
一生不枉過,但卻短暫.
ricardotik817 2 years ago 6
一生虽短暂,但是不枉过
teapotfish 2 years ago 7
如今~你远走比岸,
告诉我那边天色好吗???
我望着你走远,
我并没有心酸,
唯望天边一方它朝可重逢,
永远怀念你。。。家駒!!!
methkidd85 2 years ago 4
this is my favourite.
chkaus1 2 years ago 4
this song makes me miss you so much, jia ju.
cissim86 2 years ago
想一想,
如果你還在世
便有更多你的歌存在
可是,
事與願遺
你能在天堂生活得好嗎?
liplip414 3 years ago 9
我相信祝福能能幫助他在「異國」生活得更好(我更相信他在別的空間生活中)
雖然我也不想這麼有才華的歌手, 就這樣灰心似的離世 .... 但令我更學懂 , 老套但真理的一句話....
☆「珍惜身邊的人」☆
讓我們一起祝福他 , 但更珍惜身邊人
spinel20 2 years ago 4
Miss u, Ka Kui.
elvisbin 3 years ago
Always so deep in meaning, even in love songs, without a hint of sweet-talk at all. One hell of a musical artist indeed.
josemour100 3 years ago 2
我諗當時劉卓輝既意思係:
是緣是情是童真 還是意外
是人是牆是寒冬 藏在眼內
這是家駒,beyond對fans既心聲
有淚有罪有付出 還有忍耐
有日有夜有幻想 無法等待
這是fans既心聲
有人有另一些睇法嗎?
abcabccoco20081212 3 years ago 4
我都有一個想法,
我想是beyond向夢想出發
叫親人,情人,朋友給beyond支持同鼓勵
lp130irene 3 years ago
給beyond 的支持之外 , 我覺得更重要是給身邊的人支持 , 請更珍惜身邊的人
spinel20 2 years ago 5
rezpect this legend!
theshadowboy607 3 years ago 4
好難再人有家駒的創作精神
lungkings 3 years ago 17
很可惜他從沒有唱過這首歌(live)給我們看,現在看這個MV,真的很懷念他喔!家駒,希望你在那邊過得開心,我們很希望有一天能跟你重聚...
cantonpop 3 years ago 53
雖然我不太認識他..
但每一次聽他的歌也能打動自己的心靈..~
19920516 3 years ago 14
yes!! i agree
minisshin 3 years ago 6
家駒多謝你。。。。
tomohannw 3 years ago 6
家駒,你的歌打動了我,我永遠都掛念你~
cherrycherles 3 years ago 9
怀念
liaohaiy23 3 years ago 6
too bad he passed away, feeling like missing Kah Kui so much when I hear this song.
fwukaiquahundo 3 years ago 5
It's cool~~~
kelchong102 3 years ago
想不到他生前的作曲現在能安撫還在思念他的人. 希望家駒能安息進入樂土
abcdeabcde2 3 years ago 18
十五年或以後~家駒還是依舊~我愛你~forever~
jc9319xxxx 3 years ago 9
十五年了..
kano11392 3 years ago 5
想不到一首給情人的歌是最好是表達我們對家驅你的思念...
十五年了,悲傷依然未能放下... 尤其是你的旋律響起,眼只能淚流不止...
yyyui0 3 years ago 15
This has been flagged as spam show
以前曾聽說,一個人不幸離世了,若在世的人多祝福他,他會更放心地前去樂土世界,若你想去他時,仍悲慘流淚,我相信他也不開心的
閣下的心情我能了解,我也有這感覺...
但讓我們一起笑著懷念和祝福他,好嗎?
spinel20 3 years ago 48
@spinel20 笑...我真的笑不出來.每聽一次哭一次.好想念你.
egg2201 1 year ago
@egg2201
想哭時 , 請看 1:15左右
會不會對一個笑得這麼開心的人哭呢 ? ^^
spinel20 1 year ago 2
有日有夜有幻想。。。
i have been trying to mimic this line, for 10+ years. i just cannot achieve, even once. as far as i know, no one ever can approach the technique and uniqueness.
To me, his technique is even better than jacky cheung in singing. of course, jacky is in the top level doubtlessly.
wongjonny123456 3 years ago 4
he'll never die!
theshadowboy607 3 years ago 8
He is the best
jc601 3 years ago
word
theshadowboy607 3 years ago
beautiful song!
mujinhuaxi 3 years ago
Favourite song of my life.
chinghoong 3 years ago
ka kui, misss you!
Happy Birthday, ka kui
bestsmalltwin 3 years ago 3
我愛家駒
iversonlow 3 years ago 10
Beyond is the best band in Hong Kong, even in the world. No one can replace them in my heart! No one can replace them in Hong Kong! What they contribute to Hong Kong can't use the words to describe! How I miss them also can't use the words to describe!
bestsmalltwin 3 years ago 5
我愛家駒!
bestsmalltwin 3 years ago
one of my favs. of all time... Thanks.
Steppen03 3 years ago 2
a nice hk singer i ever respect. "lover" is a good song. does it have a version in english.
reevesup 3 years ago 3
no english version. It is composed by Ka Kui
bestsmalltwin 3 years ago
我愛家駒!
komabb 3 years ago 3
wow great song =]
etz182 3 years ago 3
his voice is unique and so emotional..so far no-one can sing this song better than him
indigo9931 3 years ago 10
1000% agree with you!
bestsmalltwin 3 years ago
越聴越好聽,very like is song
sugyoung 3 years ago 6
his voice is extremely sublime n surreal, which makes me like the original a whole lot better
cbnm3 3 years ago 6
One of beyonds best song.. so good
beatlesalbum 3 years ago 3
請尊重家駒和其他歌手...
家駒的歌很多也主張和平和尊重他人...
請各位不要在這麼好的歌前互相指罵了...
謝謝
spinel20 3 years ago 21
love you Ka Kui!
penguinfromthenorth 3 years ago
it's a good time listening to kakui's 情人 on Valentines day... i always listened to this song alone when it's Valentines day... just feels that kakui is by our side...
jan6 4 years ago
I agree with you!
1960Roma 3 years ago
thanks for agreeing
jan6 3 years ago
its just stupid to compare s.h.e. to beyond. both entirely different genres.. beyond is about music. s.h.e... wait, my little teeny bopper cousin listens to them!
cc620 4 years ago 5
This is my love song forever ~
suede2727 4 years ago 3
s.h.e go die la just a shit,they dun know music at all,shut the fuck up
gootom 4 years ago 6
Comment removed
ellabaobei 4 years ago
Nothing is better than original singer
oliveolay 4 years ago 3
If you really like S.H.E, then please respect them, not posting this kind of comments in other artists' videos! Stupid!
duddenhill 4 years ago 3
Comment removed
grocknam 2 years ago
u see? apparently u r not very welcome here as a die hard s.h.e fan. but if u really want to express yourself, -
you can scroll your mouse up, find the search box, type your sweet heart's name, click search, go to those vds, and STICK WITH IT. Im sure u will feel better there, when there r people like u all around.
Of course, thats only if u dont like to make fool of yourself
grocknam 2 years ago 5
好好聽
cherrycherles 4 years ago 3
好掛念黃家駒先生
cherrycherles 4 years ago 4
BEYOND的灵魂人物!!!
bruceran 4 years ago 3
to me,s.h.e is nothing n still a long way compare to beyond...they depend on image look not like ka kui...he sing with his emotion n let everybody noe wat is call music....like music not because of beautiful image or handsome...like music because u understand the meaning of the music they sang...
cheekham 4 years ago 3
yea, and he wrote his own songs that i love hearing till now, a true artist, not merely a performer.
zara271175 4 years ago 4
this is definitely one of the greatest song in the history of Hong Kong's Music.
hksimpsons 4 years ago 4
情人 ? !
是緣還是意外 ?
有淚還有忍耐 !
風雨崎嶇不變 ?
唏噓常在人海 !
yipmeg 4 years ago
beyond e best keep support..2 all fans & siubakkoi..brocksynam
clevantteng 4 years ago
if 家駒 still here , i wonder what will happen to BEYOND now ...
KennRicky 4 years ago
I guess Beyond would be so famous as well as Muse
SimonIsSkinnyCat 4 years ago
ka kui is the best
LEONG20044 4 years ago
that is my favorite song
HSCool 4 years ago
i remember s.h.e fans say they sing better than beyond..FUCK..who know their fans pls tell them 2 see this mv n open their ears listen.......
clevantteng 4 years ago 11
oh really.shame on them..But we never care what s.h.e fans say, right? they can never reach to chat with beyond's fans....dreaming
brocksynam 4 years ago
no 1 can reach them & oso chat wif beyond die heart fans..
clevantteng 4 years ago
totally agree with you~Kai Ku has a quique talent for music,no-one can replace him~
indigo9931 4 years ago 3
I wonder if their fans would remember them in couple years when their tits are hanging down.
siubakkoi 4 years ago
the best love song ever
suckerlastforever 4 years ago 2
His sweat soul lights up my life.
dorislee9999 4 years ago 5
remind me of my "middle school" life in China too
tw1222 4 years ago
i love this song
DEADLY360 4 years ago
i remember i saw this vid when i was a kid n my memory of the vid is blurry... therefore i'v always been wanting to watch it again... n now i have a chance... i appreciate that... love this vid as it's kind of a mini documentary of ka kui...
sexysteve 4 years ago