Added: 5 years ago
From: oysteryogurt
Views: 846,748
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (834)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @jackcafc I just went and listened to clocks. No, no it doesn't. This song is incredibly original as is clocks.

  • Beautiful. I did fall in love and drove to Chicago.  And I made a lot of mistakes. But driving to Chicago was not one of them!

  • sounds like coldplay-clocks.

  • Brilliant

  • this is what maintstreamer girls should listen to, instead of idk what they do that they think is "deep"

  • @qounqer fuck you, pal. girls can listen to whatever the hell they want.

  • @greenkoolayd okay.........

  • @qounqer amen

  • Just listen to the song! :)

  • I'm going to buy a trumpet

  • lady gaga is a better musicHAHAHA cant even say it without laughing

  • i love him. that's real music. Better than this Lady Gaga shit.

    

  • He sounds so flawless live

  • And I think this song is terrific.

  • @Khalilullah I never said anything derogatory about Christianity or religion or whatever. I just came here to listen to the song and I read your comment about how the problem with atheists is their "strong fundamentalism." Which is ridiculous, because you described EXACTLY how most fundamental Christians behave. I don't "insult and bash" any type of religion. I'm just pointing out that your classification of "the real weakness of Atheism" is hogwash and completely judgmental.

  • FUCK RELIGION AND LISTEN!!!!

  • i first knew of sufjan stevens thanks to the OC. been a fan of him since then. flawless artist with flawless songs.

  • It's a very sad day when someone singing a song about his beliefs outrages people. The real weakness of Atheism is the strong fundamentalism that atheists display. *YOU* are wrong, *I* and right, any time that *YOU* say what I don't believe in, I will insult and bash you. How is that better?

  • @Khalilullah How is that any different from how many Christians act?

  • @hpfan9 How-is-it-better? If they are bad, how are you better? If you are the same, then you are just as bad...be the change you want to see.

  • Drove to chicago all things go

  • I'm pretty sure that if I saw him live I would cry from the pure beauty of this song and any other for that matter...

  • Sufjan Stevens IS an angel!

  • he did the acoustic version live...what a fantastic man.

    would love to see the adult contemporary version live on day

    can't wait to see him live...

  • You can do whatever you want with your own music, but Jesus, if I had written a masterpiece like this. I would make this a concert experience so euphoric as to ruin concerts for the rest of my audience's life. And it would be easy to do, just full instrumentation and ENERGY. Not this bullshit.

  • @babbleon12 haha, so fucking true, do you see the dinky little freaking instruments in the background. he could easily take the world by storm with this kind of song. he just needs to blast the audience with instrumentation, and it would be sooo easy!

  • do you think that's an SM-58 he's using?

  • Its not a religion its a relationship with the big man upstairs

  • I like that he has a (foldable) stand...nice to switch it up and makes it feel more intimate. love this guy.

  • These comments on the song? Didn't think so. Go fight somewhere else guys

  • His voice sounds great no matter what. Beautiful performance. One of the most stunning musicians.

  • Okay, as an atheist I'm ashamed of my fellow non-believers on this forum.

    Really, It is pitiful that we have more knowledge about Biblical Passages and Religion then actual Religious people!

  • @Froggenell

    It's a pity that it looks like a middle school kid typed your comment.

    Atheists....always thinking that they have more knowledge than everyone else...that's a pity in itself. It's your pride that leads your faith.

  • @thousandumbrellas

    Don't base your opinions about atheists on the stereotype as to which we have developed.

    We base our beliefs on knowledge, what we know, and what Science has proven to us, instead of what a couple of pastors and a book told you.

    But, I digress, this song is awesome.

  • Comment removed

  • @Froggenell

    And referring to the comment, "we base our beliefs on knowledge." Have you ever studied Creation vs Evolution (unbiased) or seen the documentary "Expelled?" There are many Christian scientists out there, but they don't receive funding due to the fact that, assuming He exists, God is supernatural.

    We know He can't be proven or disproven. That's a fact for both sides. Incidentally, we would still like to provide evidence, but it rarely gets out due to the "supernatural" fact.

  • @thousandumbrellas No, I haven't studied Creation vs. Evolution, and no, I have, nor will i ever, not watched Expelled. For it's completely Glenn Beck-esque material and I am not for that minority. I agree, Christians (Catholics in general) get a hard time, but down (Australia) I see us Atheists are the minority, Scientists? I dunno.

    I refuse to research these things based on me purely not giving a shit, I'm sorry to say, not my form of expertise. Simply, I don't believe in a God. Final.

  • @Froggenell

    Odd, considering you apparently base your opinion off of science and knowledge. Creation vs. Evolution is the core of all scientific argument for or against a God. If you only study one side, then you have no possible way of knowing truth or fact for certain. You are only accepting ignorance. Which is cool, I guess, if you believe the whole "ignorance is bliss" rant.

    This is going nowhere, though. Thanks for the discussion.

  • @thousandumbrellas I simply don't have time to worry about something as trivial as religion, not trying to be offensive, but I find the whole religious debate extremely naive compared to something more important, like.. The BP Oil Spill, Third World countries and such.

    I rather not bide my time with such trivial things, there are people out there that would though, so try and argue with them, sadly they have nothing better to do.

    Also, dude. Expelled is one of the worst movies I've seen.

  • @Froggenell

    Haha, are you serious? The oil spill and third world countries? You are aware that none of those things matter, right? They are all temporary. We all die. That's a fact. The only thing that "really" matters is the truth about life itself. If you get that wrong, then you could be setting yourself up for much worse than some pollution or a few more lives lost.

    And "dude," Expelled is a documentary. It's not for entertainment. It's for knowledge.

  • @Froggenell

    Also, I feel somewhat bad for crowding this video. If you would like to continue, please don't leave another comment. Send a message to my inbox. Incidentally, I'd prefer you just stop. It seems as if you are some kid, most likely late high school or early college, that just wants to argue to "seem" intelligent by semantics. Unfortunately, semantics mean nothing to me when your underlying points aren't fully thought through and you have no real knowledge that is of importance.

  • @thousandumbrellas So you are picking on my intelligence and yet avoid all of the topics which I have put forward to you, simply stating that they "do not matter" and that 'we all die".

    There isn't really any truth to life itself, and if you are looking for any truth as to why lives matter then you are going down a long and narrow path to nowhere.

    Also: On Expelled, it had too many narrow-minded arguments for me to really get anything out of it, it was all opinion, not fact.

  • @Froggenell

    You're an idiot. Sorry, but ignorance annoys me more than anything. People like you are worse than trolls. You have yet to "put forth" anything but a ton of ranting on how you don't care. If anything, you've ignored most of what I said by giving replies that don't address an argument. Maybe you should read over the conversation again.

    Also, did you even watch the documentary or are you reading crap reviews online? The documentary is a compilation of facts, not opinion.

  • @Froggenell

    As for my statement prior; Anything you learn about in this life does NOT matter when death comes. Oil spills...don't matter.....Poverty....does not matter. Knowing whether or not there is an eternal life to work for afterwards....DOES matter....Because IF there is a heaven and hell and you're too damn cool to work for it, then that's eternity of misery you couldn't imagine. IF not, then the only thing you lose is a few decades of a life that won't matter when it's over.

  • @thousandumbrellas So your argument is to believe in case there is a heaven?? Not very logical or confident. Like defending religion and faith using quotes from the Bible. "It is so because God said it is so"  Grow up.

  • @USEY0URBRAIN

    Where did I use quotes from the bible to defend my faith? Atheists use "reasoning" that most believe came about by "randomness"....that's so much more logical, isn't it?

    The logic, in saying "in case there is a heaven," comes from seeing and understanding all viewpoints as a possibility...not just your own. It's something that most idiots tend to forget when producing an argument. There's no lack of confidence here.

  • @USEY0URBRAIN

    And for the record, truth is greater than confidence. If the idea is more logical and holds fact, then confidence in the idea itself need not matter. The only confidence needed is knowing that the fact is indeed fact.

    Maybe you should "grow up" and not attack any person who you disagree with out of ignorance. You're a common troll that give Atheists a bad name. I've talked to so many like you online that void ultimate points just to get their shot at attacking the faithful.

  • @Froggenell

    If that last statement wasn't clear enough for you (it seems as if most things aren't clear enough for you), then here is a quote from a decent philosopher:

    Camus said, "I would rather live my life as if there is a God and die to find out there isn't, than live my life as if there isn't and die to find out there is."

    I won't take as much time to explain everything else as I did for that last thing, so there ya go. If you're just going to tell me you don't care, then give it up.

  • Comment removed

  • Sufjan Stevens doesn't sing about god he sings about himself.... which happens to be God!

  • Online Asian women  busizz4me.info

  • im not religious but i don't hate sufjan stevens or his lyrics. he's not trying to push christianity on people he's just singing music

  • when you say something negative about a religion and how it is so bad, no one cares....okay we want to hear the song....but one more thing, just because someone is of a certain religion or not of a certain religion doesnt mean that they are better or worse than you. Like someone else said...religion isnt a person it cant hate, sometimes PEOPLE use it to hate others.

  • @jgus2415 sufjan is a lot older than justin bieber and he's been making songs a lot longer than him... sufjan is extremely talented and has a non-gay beautiful voice... i really don't understand your statement at all.

  • @jgus2415 wow u hav no taste in music ur the gay faggot

  • @yasemonkey I meant "gay" as in happy. that is what it used to mean, but it does sound to me like you are the homosexual not me. thanks for your time bud

  • @jgus2415 it's just you. really.

  • @jgus2415 you need to shut the hell up

  • @jgus2415 fuck no. shut your whore mouth

  • @jgus2415 *cough* Troll *cough*

  • this is really really awesome, the intro is better than the over produced version on Illiinoise

  • Sufjan's in Minneapolis tonight...checking out how he sounds live. I'm excited !!

  • lol he messed up the lyrics to the first part of the song

    eee i love him so much this song is so amazing

  • He's so perfect. I think I'm in love.

  • @kitkatsig11 im 100% straight and im in love

  • gorgeous

  • A very Talented Man! I just heard the studio version of Chicago by chance on a bike ride this AM.. a Campus Radio Station. MSU... WKAR.. I bought this song on iTunes.. I think we've all made a lot of mistakes in our lives!

  • Little treasures like this song make a smile last for days

  • He's perfect. 

  • WOW! i like the live version much better then the studio version.

  • Sufjan's storytelling in his lyrics are great, his songs are incredibly inspiring

  • How could you possibly DISLIKE this???????

  • I hate when people comment on the 'dislikes' to a video, but seriously... How could ANYONE dislike this video. It's so soothing, and... PERFECT!

    Gah, Soofyan, get in my pants.

  • Comment removed

  • Sufjan Stevens - Brilliant

  • thanks to Lee Dewyze I have discovered this band... to cool

  • It's always gonna be this. And the mainstream, record label conglomerate-backed "music" wins. St. Vincent, or (ugh) Ke$ha? Sufjan Stevens, or Mika? Even worse, The Postal Service, or Owl City?

    Btw, I appreciated American Idol for featuring this. The real winner is Sufjan... watch that iTunes chart placement coming up soon!

  • @PenaltyKillah what? besides the last one, i don't get any of those comparisons.

  • incredible musician :-| see, i wouldnt mind christians if they were all like sufjan :/

  • It's a little offensive that you generalize Christians for being a certain way, it's like people generalizing atheists and saying they're bad people which isn't true at all.

    All of the Christians I know are nice and don't push religion on anyone...

  • I love this sooong soooo muuucchhhh. Its one of my favorites. I actually tried to make my own cover of it, and just put it on my site....

    I don't even know if I want to keep it up though, It doesn't do Sufjan's beautiful music justice.

    I think I've dreamt of Sufjan in at least half of my dreams in the past year.

  • This is America we love!!

  • he's so amazing, words can't describe.

  • He's so... amazing, astonishing, astounding! ... beautiful <3

  • Honestly, they did it. EVERYTHING WE WANTED TO DO, ONLY BETTER!!!!

    LOVE-ANG

  • Come on , kids stop fighting listen to this piece of good music

  • Probably at the univ of illinois website...

  • where can i find that shirt hes wearing idont even know what to look up on ebay !

  • you talk EXACTLY like a teen good job

  • why thank you. :] you talk exactly like mxd9(?)

  • Nice!

  • Come to Spokane! I will be up front!

  • Sufjan.. Take Europe!!

  • If only they would play this song to the Olympic committee.

  • I cannot listen to this song without crying , truly amazing song

  • Thank goodness I saw, "Little Miss Sunshine," or I may never have heard of Sufjan. I have adopted this beautiful song as my hometown anthem.

  • just beautiful

  • if i ebver saw sufjan stevens live, i would cry. just seeing this bit here is making my eyes sting

    what a beautiful, beautiful man

  • Notice you never see comments like "oh woot this guy is an atheist!", yet for some reason people also feel the need to bring up if someone is a "christian", let the song mean what it does to you, and enjoy this marvelous musician.

  • What a beautiful song for a Chicago boy.

  • I've made a lot of mistakes....so truthful, love this song...touches my heart and soul.

  • this song its so beautiful it hurts

  • i never ever thought of this song as anything religiously related ever.

  • I luv living in Chicago <3

  • Who cares if Sufjan is a Christian or if his songs relate to God or not, he's still amazing. Quit your bitching about religion and enjoy the song.

  • haha everyone get owned

  • @WordsInMotion amen to that!

  • sufjan stevens

  • A perfect Sufjan Stevens day...

  • he's just so beautiful

  • His voice... he is beautiful. I would love to meet him

  • Fuck genius

  • who says god is a he.who says theres a god.if there was a god im sure it wouldnt have a gender.God is more of an idea, an entity that lives withing an individual.

    i hope sufjan isnt a christian.i dont care his beliefs but not christianity. Religion has caused more wars, casualties, and can even turn family members against eachother. and christianity is themost perverted one.i like to think sufjans music transcends religious borders and is just beautiful music.

  • Then you will be dissapointed in Sufjan. Besides, why should Christianity be the most perverted of all? What of Islam and others? That is simply biasim to say Christianity is the worst of them all.

  • first off does the crusades ring a bell.what about politicians using christianity to justify curruption.how many times have u heard of a mother drownding her children cuz god told her to.Christianity pushes their agenda on people more than any other religion. Statistics show that countries that have a high number of atheism are more productive, healthier economies, happier people. all religion is bad because it hold back humanity and retards our society from logic,evidence,and critical thinking

  • where are these 'statistics' you speak of? the only thing retarded that i can see is your spelling and grammar. i'm not a christian myself, but respect those who are and recognize that while the media likes to focus a lot of attention on the bad stuff stemming from religion, a lot of churches/religions promote charities, help the homeless and disenfranchised, and generally treat others in a respectful manner (ie. most will not foist their beliefs upon you even though you're an atheist).

  • Adrian White's "world map of happiness" and Phil Zuckerman's "Atheis:contemorary rates and patterns"

    why do we need to bring religion into charities.why cant we just help out fellow human beings because its the right thing to do.i use to have tolerance against religion but its gotten out of hand. religion is becomming the death of humanity sending us down the same primitive path we came from long ago. &dont complain about spelling over the internet.u will never win. get real.

  • Religion gives faith to the hopeless and it's a source of innner strenght. However, some abuse religion because their mindset became perverted or selfish. I believe that nothing could be really pure, like wise to christians, there are bad ones and good ones. Atheist too have bad people and good people.A world full of unbelievers won't make the world a better place. We're all different because of our views. Freedom and diversity makes the world fascinating. U don't want everybody to be the same?

  • religion is the fascism of the spirit and soul

  • Look up "fascism" in the encyclopedia, and maybe, just maybe you'll take that back, my youtube friend.

  • religion is the awakening of the spirit and soul for some people. don't talk badly about religion, it can seriously offend a lot of people, and more than just youtube offend.

  • well, religion offends me a lot cos it steals manhood freedom in most of religion types, and it offends me more when i think the people that was murdered in the name of God; so lets clean that religions name and after that, tell me to dont claim for my rights.

  • i don't really know what you just said, but with all the blood that has been spilled over religion? that's just folk taking it a little too far. i am not a religious person, infact i am atheist, but i don't hate religion. i'm not telling you to revoke your comment, i'm just saying that what you are sayin can really offend people that are religious.

  • and i'm telling you that religion offended me so much time before i made that comment; i have the right to hate what hurted me, and it hadn't the right to hurt and lie me, nor the right to kill anybody but they did. need a draw too?

  • religion isn't a person. it doesnt offend, hurt, lie, or kill... youre dumb

  • @sirbick you're the fool if you cant see how the word religion is used as an instrument of domination, to murder, steal and discriminate...so it can be all i said even the guilty is always a person.

  • nice grammar, it really supports your flimsy arguments

  • Oh Mr. Yhelotharqtpi, i'm really sorry for my mistakes, it's my third idiom but i promess i'll improve my grammar level; how many do you speak or write?

    Me apuesto los riñones de la zorra gorda y desdentada de tu madre a que ni si quiera hablas bien tu jodido idioma, pedazo de retrasado pedante hijo de puta.

    Votre education egalement dit beaucoup en faveur de tes arguments et vous avez déjà démontré que la vôtre, si elles existent, ne sont pas très bonnes.

  • hahah good comeback... yo puedo entender tu espanol

  • jajajajajaja buena ronda de insultos! haha

  • talking about religion can offend plenty of non-believers too..It works both ways...everyone should keep their beliefs to themselves

  • many thanks, it looks like if nobody could understand that religion has been an instrument for a few men to dominate the others and it has made worst things than better ones...hey mate, but you dont have the most important letter in your keyboard...the famous ÑÑÑÑÑ hahaha un saludo!

  • Good call, let's not share our personal opinions because someone might be OFFENDED! OMG! NOT THAT! ANYTHING BUT THAT!!!!

  • @forgottenknights amen to THAT.!

  • @bignectar82 right on man

  • @bignectar82 how would the world be like if that happened?

  • @bignectar82

    yeah religion and republicans are the two most offensive things in the world.

  • @bignectar82 or... everyone could stop seeing expression of beliefs as a personal assault and learn that it's not about them... :\ Maybe, just maybe, speaking what you believe should be celebrated. Even if I don't agree, at least I know you feel.

  • @bignectar82 why should people keep their beliefs to themselves just because of what other people will think? you're encouraging people to keep their mouths shut, because other people might have a problem with what they say, but that's what free speech is about. The Westboro Baptist Church says some pretty crazy things, but as long as we're educated, those ideas will be kept on the fringes. If Sufjan wants to sing about his religion, then I as an atheist, can make the judgement whether to listen

  • I think your view is correct. If you look at any cross section of society whether it be religous or secular your going to find asshole and good people.

  • wow he is so freakin good im going to learn this right away

  • I love that his songs are so easy to play, but they still sound so fucking amazing :) Stevens rocks simplicity hardcore.

  • beautiful voice.

    beautiful song.

    :)

  • I'm in love <3

  • Beautiful song. This is the most recognized song, but the others are all good too!

  • Great acoustic number!

  • One of my favourite bands!

    Big respect from Gothenburg, Sweden!

  • He's got a great voice, a great style, and I just really love this kind of music. I became a fan the very first time I heard this song on the DVD -I mean I had to have this soundtrack. I ewnjoyed the movie, too, btw. This live version is even more sincere than the CD track. Love it.

  • I wish he was 1) gay, and 2) my soulmate.

  • dont be a hater

  • why is that so bad? seven thumbs down? Your all pissbuckets. I love Sufjan stevens i aint no hater.

  • i think based on his lyrics that he is gay.

    and he is my soulmate regardless.

  • Sufjan refers the God as "he" sometimes and having a connection with God.

    Maybe thats why =)

  • This is breathtaking, I haven't other words for it! Sufjan, please come to Belgium, I can't wait any longer!

  • I agree , we're ready for Sufjan in our little f*cked up country :)

  • Comment removed