Hi lads very interesting project. You say the magnet is north from the front and the north end facing the rail now put me right on this if I am wrong,but if you take the large sides being north and south each end and sides would be split north and south am I right in saying this.Is there any particular way these magnets a magnetized.
The two wooden rails are about an inch high and 3/8 wide.
The two wooden rods are .25" square. I believe the total gap is slightly more than that. The channel is 5/8 and I think each rail is 3/8 wide. I can let you know for sure this weekend.
@ChilesGreen Sorry Chiles, but no catapults.....no reason to trick anyone, this is just a school science project. If you look at the other video, the wooden pieces are taken out - it is just simple wood.
Thanks so much for the additional info. Do you recall where you purchased the ceramic magnets? Any idea what the 'strength' of the neodymiums were (N32/N40/etc)? No problems if you don't know or lost the info. I'd like to try to build one of these as well, it's a great project, and as I'm sure you know, has the peculiar property of not trapping the 'projectile' at the end of the run.
@antostoof1 Here's an idea...build another one..face them towards each other (opposite in direction)..then see if you can tune it to oscillate back and forth. If you incorporated a wound copper coil in between them, then you would have a free electricity generator!
It would be very nice to see you shoot that with the board on an angle, such as accelerating upwards. It would also be nice to know how much force you are pushing the bar magnet. Lastly, what is the purpose of the graphite and why do you use it? Oh, and your telling us you have no input electricity or pre-charged bars in the system?
@beapilot11 No electricity or any batteries or anything. The graphite is just to reduce friction on the wood. We never tried shooting it up. We'll try that!
@antostoof1 Please send me a video of the results. Did you try considering building multiple replicas of the board, so where the magnet shoots out, it enters the next board of magnets and continues on its straight path? Would you build another replica so it is in front of the end of the first one so the magnet bar can shoot into the entrance of the first replica? I look forward to this other video.
If you guys raise the end of "gun" and shoot in an angle, you can stop the bullet in a simple sand bed and measure the distance. Together with the weight (sorry, mass) of the bullet=train=cubes this gives a real reading of the enegry of the shot. Maybe topic for another physics project? Your teacher could help you with the formular to calculate the energy from this parameters.
Hi again! Txs for explaining the "neutral spot". The key question right now for the engineering mind seems to be:
a) Is the force required to plase the "train" (4 cubes) into starting position like pressing a spring and strong enough to produce same "shot" from release of such equivalent spring?
I hope this is not a hoax. There better not be any type of electrical input in the two rods. If so, then it is a typical railgun, in which nothing new happened. You might be introducing some scientists who will be interested in this.
@ncrozier132 I think a rectangle would work. We are going to try a ball but since you need to keep the poles facing each other, it probably won't work.
There are details of this little trick they're not showing you. No static arrangement of magnets will create energy gain. There's no such thing as perpetual motion. If they pulled a rabbit out of their hat is it magic?
I see through this, It's a trick. If you were to arrange these magnetic projectiles on an armature you'd have a perpetual motion machine. It's impossible for a static arrangement of magnets to create energy out of nothing.
@antostoof1 Hey will just a single cube magnet launch, or does it only work if all four are connected together? Also did you buy the magnets online? If so, what site?
@KingJoeKong A single or double magnet flies up and won't break out of the "launch field" Three magnets stay trapped in the field. It seems to need 4 magnets to have the speed/mass to launch out of the field.
Hi Oneness - initially a small amount of resistance and then it tries to pull it in. You can find a spot where it is in equilibrium and it just sits there. If you notice at the beginning of this video, that is how the magnets are sitting - kind of in "neutral"
So then force is being applied when you load the gun right? Nice!
TheSeg1 11 hours ago
Hi lads very interesting project. You say the magnet is north from the front and the north end facing the rail now put me right on this if I am wrong,but if you take the large sides being north and south each end and sides would be split north and south am I right in saying this.Is there any particular way these magnets a magnetized.
dennissayer 4 days ago
This does work the question is can it be scaled up in size speed etc.
MrAmazing340 5 days ago
Now build the same way rail but in circle, so the "bullet" will back to its start position and keep going around infinite times :)
kafel 1 week ago
Hi guys! Would you mind telling me what are the 4 cubes made of? Thank you very much! :D
FreakyScaryM 1 week ago
@FreakyScaryM They are neodymium
antostoof1 1 week ago
how both sides be north ? did u join two magnets ?
user66699 1 week ago
@user66699 If we said that, we made a mistake.
antostoof1 1 week ago
The pole that faces the rail us north and the front of the projectile is north.
antostoof1 2 weeks ago
whats the pole that faces the rail and what are the projectile magnetic poles
user66699 2 weeks ago
@user66699 the pole that faces the rail is north and the projectile is north on the front.
antostoof1 2 weeks ago
Its pronounced NEE-o-DIM-ee-um
PHDnFUN 3 weeks ago
If this think would realy work , you would get the nobel price. ;)
tomtoonotavaiable 3 weeks ago
where did you get the ceramic magnets?
johnshepherd2011 1 month ago
Andreas got about 4 years older in a day...
JCloth431 1 month ago
The two wooden rails are about an inch high and 3/8 wide.
The two wooden rods are .25" square. I believe the total gap is slightly more than that. The channel is 5/8 and I think each rail is 3/8 wide. I can let you know for sure this weekend.
antostoof1 2 months ago
Congratulations on the good work guys! This is one of my favourite videos on YT.
You are showing great dignity in ignoring the trolls; well done.
There is a delivery of these ceramics arriving here tomorrow and I will try to replicate this.
If it goes well I will add a couple of mods and see what happens.
Am I right thinking that the two wooden rails abutting the Ceramics are .25" square, giving a total gap of 1 & 1\8th inch?
(The two wooden rods are also .25" square too, right?)
Cheers!
JohnnyRing0 2 months ago
@JohnnyRing0 Let me know if antostoof1 holds true and post some videos.
beapilot11 2 months ago
@JohnnyRing0 Oh - and thanks for the nice things you said. We hope to have one or two more up this weekend.
antostoof1 2 months ago
Love the fake Russian Accent,
ChilesGreen 3 months ago
Notice the slit in the guide rod between the magnets? A hidden catapult launches the magnets through the magic hat.
ChilesGreen 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
@ChilesGreen Sorry Chiles, but no catapults.....no reason to trick anyone, this is just a school science project. If you look at the other video, the wooden pieces are taken out - it is just simple wood.
antostoof1 2 months ago
@antostoof1
Not a catapult per se.
ChilesGreen 2 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
Oh, and btw, you guys look like you've aged 3 years. :)
jcims 3 months ago
@jcims Only about a year and a half and still can't drive!
antostoof1 3 months ago
Hey Guys,
Thanks so much for the additional info. Do you recall where you purchased the ceramic magnets? Any idea what the 'strength' of the neodymiums were (N32/N40/etc)? No problems if you don't know or lost the info. I'd like to try to build one of these as well, it's a great project, and as I'm sure you know, has the peculiar property of not trapping the 'projectile' at the end of the run.
jcims 3 months ago
@jcims Not sure but we bought them on the internet. Good luck building it!
antostoof1 3 months ago
@antostoof1 Is all the ceramic magnets pointing to the inside north, on both sides?
OnenessApostolicMan 2 months ago
@OnenessApostolicMan All the magnets are north facing in
antostoof1 2 months ago
@antostoof1 Thanks!
OnenessApostolicMan 2 months ago
would this work in a circular pattern? keep the cubes in continual motion or something? just an idea that popped into my head. :3
SealyProductions 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
@SealyProductions We'd like to try.....we'll see....
antostoof1 3 months ago
@antostoof1 Here's an idea...build another one..face them towards each other (opposite in direction)..then see if you can tune it to oscillate back and forth. If you incorporated a wound copper coil in between them, then you would have a free electricity generator!
jfilmmusic 3 months ago
@jfilmmusic I think it would die out after a few bounces.
antostoof1 3 months ago
It would be very nice to see you shoot that with the board on an angle, such as accelerating upwards. It would also be nice to know how much force you are pushing the bar magnet. Lastly, what is the purpose of the graphite and why do you use it? Oh, and your telling us you have no input electricity or pre-charged bars in the system?
beapilot11 3 months ago
@beapilot11 No electricity or any batteries or anything. The graphite is just to reduce friction on the wood. We never tried shooting it up. We'll try that!
antostoof1 3 months ago
@antostoof1 Please send me a video of the results. Did you try considering building multiple replicas of the board, so where the magnet shoots out, it enters the next board of magnets and continues on its straight path? Would you build another replica so it is in front of the end of the first one so the magnet bar can shoot into the entrance of the first replica? I look forward to this other video.
beapilot11 2 months ago
have you thought to have some wheels underneath the magnet?
ilikeamanda 3 months ago
@ilikeamanda all the time......
antostoof1 3 months ago
Another idea...
If you guys raise the end of "gun" and shoot in an angle, you can stop the bullet in a simple sand bed and measure the distance. Together with the weight (sorry, mass) of the bullet=train=cubes this gives a real reading of the enegry of the shot. Maybe topic for another physics project? Your teacher could help you with the formular to calculate the energy from this parameters.
Just saying...
108sharif 3 months ago
SORRY, typo! Should have been: "required to place the train"
108sharif 3 months ago
Hi again! Txs for explaining the "neutral spot". The key question right now for the engineering mind seems to be:
a) Is the force required to plase the "train" (4 cubes) into starting position like pressing a spring and strong enough to produce same "shot" from release of such equivalent spring?
b) What happens with 5 and 6 cubes as the train?
Txs for second video!
108sharif 3 months ago
I hope this is not a hoax. There better not be any type of electrical input in the two rods. If so, then it is a typical railgun, in which nothing new happened. You might be introducing some scientists who will be interested in this.
beapilot11 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
Does the projectile magnet need to be square?
ncrozier132 3 months ago
@ncrozier132 I think a rectangle would work. We are going to try a ball but since you need to keep the poles facing each other, it probably won't work.
antostoof1 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
@ncrozier132 No, we think a rectangle will work. We'll let you know.
antostoof1 3 months ago
Thanks! do you have any ideas for us?
antostoof1 3 months ago
@antostoof1 this Idea is revolutionary regards to both I will try to make my own, lot of thanks.
tamagakun 3 months ago
@tamagakun
There are details of this little trick they're not showing you. No static arrangement of magnets will create energy gain. There's no such thing as perpetual motion. If they pulled a rabbit out of their hat is it magic?
ChilesGreen 3 months ago
@ChilesGreen well I think that we should try to do the same experiment before give a critical opinion.
tamagakun 3 months ago
Comment removed
ChilesGreen 3 months ago
@tamagakun
Let me know how your perpetual motion machine works out;-)
ChilesGreen 3 months ago
@ChilesGreen anyway I will try to duplicate and get out the doubts
tamagakun 2 months ago
@tamagakun Good luck and I'm sure you will have a great result. It isn't that hard to make.
antostoof1 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tamagakun
I see through this, It's a trick. If you were to arrange these magnetic projectiles on an armature you'd have a perpetual motion machine. It's impossible for a static arrangement of magnets to create energy out of nothing.
ChilesGreen 3 months ago
@antostoof1 Hey will just a single cube magnet launch, or does it only work if all four are connected together? Also did you buy the magnets online? If so, what site?
KingJoeKong 3 months ago
@KingJoeKong A single or double magnet flies up and won't break out of the "launch field" Three magnets stay trapped in the field. It seems to need 4 magnets to have the speed/mass to launch out of the field.
antostoof1 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
@antostoof1 Thankyou, also, did this device only work when you had 18 magnets on each side, or would a smaller number, like 12, work on each side.
KingJoeKong 3 months ago
Brilliant and simple. I love it! I don't think however you've fully considered the applied potential of this. What if ...
MrDiggerodelll 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1
The polarity of the magnets I mean the position N and S, how are oriented?
tamagakun 3 months ago
@tamagakun Hi Tamagakun - the ceramics are north facing in and the neos' north side faces the north of the ceramics
antostoof1 3 months ago
Hi Oneness - initially a small amount of resistance and then it tries to pull it in. You can find a spot where it is in equilibrium and it just sits there. If you notice at the beginning of this video, that is how the magnets are sitting - kind of in "neutral"
antostoof1 3 months ago
@antostoof1 Ok, Thanks. :)
OnenessApostolicMan 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
When you first place the magnet in the front. Is it trying to pull it thru or is there resistance?
OnenessApostolicMan 3 months ago in playlist More videos from antostoof1