Lilly Scott - I Fall To Pieces

[Doobie1975]

While I didn't think her Top 16 performance was as good as her previous performances I still thought Lilly should have gone further, I was predicting she'd be in the Top 5

[Doobie1975]

I was so mad that Lilly didn't make it to the Top 12 yet Paige and Lacey (who I never cared for) did.

[MRCrashFusion]

She has mad talent. All of her performances were solid. How is she not on top of the billboards by now?

[CeridwenLynne]

I wish she had made it to the top 10. I thought she was great.

[rhyno951]

both her and crystal were robbed

[TotalDramaCountry]

I love her voise, but i think she looks like a blonde Darlene from Roseanne :O

[XxEquestrianGalxX]

I love her music. She is like a mix between Regina Spektor and Ingrid Michaelson!!! So Indie!!! LOVE this!!

[jeenluck]

Lilly hope you read these comments - I love you spin on this classic please record it

[musicman0260]

Lilly came to nebraska for a wedding with her cool boyfriend. She sang 3 songs on my dj system. She is still awesome and should record a cd.

[vilmad007]

Lilly Scott, if you ever read this - you were the reason I was watching American Idol. When you went off the show, I lost interest. I know someday you will be in the headlines and I will buy your music along with thousands of your fans.

[CoolTDIguy815]

@vilmad007

*Replies so this persons comment can be at the top*

[xsintric23]

I think Patsy Cline would have loved Lilly's version on the song. I thought she did a brilliant cover, it sounded current. Patsy Cline is one of my all time favorite female singers. Someone needs to sign this girl and give her a shot, she was my second favorite after Crystal.

[Danklin24]

Actually it was Lacey that robbed Lilly. Lacey had no business being on the show, especially the top 12 or 10.

[Kanoclaw]

even now,the night of the finale I think .. Man lilly scott should be there xD love her voice!

[silvanski]

Lily realy deserved to go further on Idol, but I'm afraid it's the song which caused her to be voted off. She should have picked a contemporary songs.

[xnavytutu]

beautiful@!

[cocoamoo331]

it was kind of the judges fault she got voted off.

they praised everyone else's performances, but when it was lilly's turn to be judged, they were just like, "yeah it was good"

really it's what the judges say that matters, because that's what the voters listen, too unfortunately.

[finix65]

Well personally I think her voice is kind of too annoying for her to have gotten through to the top 12

[kitkatkaraoke]

Unique voice however Patsy is turning over in her grave listening to this rendition. Wrong song for Lilly

[sharong1209]

Wow, so good, it gave me goose bumps. If PatsyCline heard this, I think she would have been really impressed, Lilly, you did good!

[smoothmoves97]

Her earrings look like discolored lumps of broccoli or misplaced hunks of yarn.

[theaterstar89]

damn that was great. people who voted her off-STUPID!

[RaichuSparks]

the first time i heard you sing i said thats the next american idol but they had to do this to you i wish you luck on your siging journey

[dannessicity]

So beautiful, I don't understand....... :(

[iRocker85]

She got kicked off for this performence???

Ummmm was anyone listening to that no talent Lacey Brown or did someone confuse the numbers?

[jli1112]

dude i got soooo mad when lilly got voted off.. and alex lambert. :p

[vrwltn0809]

what fool thinks this is better than patsy cline version? Take the wax out...It does sound better the more I play it. Also it is a different era. What the heck they are both awesome..

I learned a new artist today.Look forward to seeing what she does (music).

[idioticscheme666]

Me too! I was so PISSED OFF!! Lilly didn't even make the top 12!!! America was totally wrong!

[CoolTDIguy815]

America was so wrong on this decision... I am so pissed....

[liveforevermaybe]

@CoolTDIguy815 only in american do they not know talent when it pisses them in there face.

[CoolTDIguy815]

@liveforevermaybe

True, that....

[kathrynIS]

@liveforevermaybe I liked her musically but I thought her delivery of I fall to pieces was not very good

[micap20078]

i just thought of something. its a good thing lily was voted off now she has the fame to do whatever she wants and be her own artist american idol would have just restricted her and turned her into a cheesy type of singer. to hell with american idol!!

[FallOffAClift]

Lilly was the best, but please refer to other contestants by their respective names.

[DanSnot69]

Lilly was the only reason I watched this stupid show the black chick sucked and should have been voted off Lilly will be successful somewhere else

[7WebbieKinz]

Yeah I feel the Same Exact Way!

[MRCrashFusion]

Do you people know why Alex Lambert and Lilly Scott (Some of the most interesting contestants of the season) were voted off? Because you people didn't vote for them! Everyone on that Alex Lambert petition didn't vote for him! They should have stayed. Tim should have gone instead of Alex and Paige should have gone instead of Lilly.

[jaylynnyellowcloud]

Americas soo stupid. Lilly is really gooood. D:

[kriskemkem]

guy's did u dont know that supposed to be there are 8 girls and only 4 boys now in the contest ? it is i read it on the newspapaer , and katelyn and Lilly should own thoose two spots . so sad , rules of AI is so disgusting ... from philippines

[chanshikun666]

i seriously thnk Katie took away Lilly's spot..Damn it!!I still wanna hear Lilly's vocals..she really has a unique voice..Hope that there will be a wild card round but i highly doubt so=(

[lifeismusic01]

katie is not even good! i also agree with you! lilly was amazing!

[ja1207]

@chanshikun666

no, not katie, but lacey...that damn lacey brown...she just wasted 1 spot in the top12 just to be eliminated first...

[iRocker85]

@chanshikun666

Katie???

At least she was somewhat likable compared to that talentless ferret looking Lacey.

I just wish she got the votes she deserved

[CoolTDIguy815]

Lilly if you ever read this by chance (hey, Mishavonna Henson watched my video of her performance!!!) I am so terribly sorry that America did this. You DID NOT deserve to go home. You are a very talented and unique singer and i wish you the best of luck in the future.

Sincerely, CoolTDIguy815.

[quat56]

Fuck Lilly has been eliminated damn u AMERICAN IDOL SHITTY BONE-HEADED VOTERS SHE SHOULD HAVE DEFINITELY SELECTED OVER THAT HORRIBLE KATIE IN THE TOP 12 THIS YEAR!!

[LJMmack]

How dare Lilly be voted off! She was the best singer American Idol had this year.

I may never watch American Idol again.

[Shinin111]

I gagged on this horrible rendition of Patsy's classic. Its Willie Nelson in drag.

[Shinin111]

I almost heaved on this horrible out of pitch rendition of a great Cline classic

[EmilyBehm99]

She Shouldnt Have been voted off!!!

Crap! LOL xD

[miku282]

OMG she's so good. T__T WHAT THE HECK AMERICA??!? Katie Stevens' conscience will haunt her and tell her she stayed while Lilly who she knew was better than her (which is why she was crying) had to frikkin leave.

[TheThinkingBiatch]

who said no one can sing a Patsy Cline??

I even started to listen to that song(i fall to pieces)

since Lilly sang it on AI. Honestly, Lilly's style made the song more "listenable" than the original. Cuz' just admit it, Patsy Cline's just to old for todays music listeners.

[hizBBYBOO]

AO should put Lilly back where she belongs... the top three! WILDCARD ROUND ! Gosh, America is stupid...

[pisoisa789]

one of the best contestant . very unique and a very good singer . how can you save someone like PAIGE MILES and KATIE STEVENS who never entertained the judges . LILLY SCOTT is one of the best contestant in the show ever . as in since season 1 . i was almost on tears when i learned that she is eliminated . her talent must be recognized through out the world . she is exceptionally talent among the contestant . she herself is shocked when katie is called to the top twelve .

[BandxOfxBrothers]

No offense to all Americans, but to those who watch this show, you're all IDIOTS! (with the exception of the ones who voted for Lilly). Honestly, how stupid do you have to be. You must not know real music. She is one of the top 4 for all the contestants (1st in my mind). I probably wont watch the rest of this season, or even the show again because it is frustrating seeing such talent going to waste all because of a bunch of Idiot Americans who don't know music (Not All Americans)

[pisoisa789]

america should vote wisely . i am here at the philippines so i am not able to vote for lilly . i hope that america chooses the right talent and singer to win in this competition . don't put lilly scott's talent to waste . she is very deserving of the title . oh my god , i almost cried . KATIE STEVENS AND PAIGE MILES SUCKS ! i am the other side of the world enjoying lilly's voice and now she out of the show . super unfair . i never thought it would end up this way .

[Orangeman334]

The good news is she can keep her Indie status going and she can control whatever she produces. She won't be told what to write or how to dress or who she can play with. Maybe this will work out better

[lifeismusic01]

i agree! she was like one of my top! and then she didn't get in top 12 are you serious? like wtf ? no america sucks!

[TotalDramaCountry]

the only ONLY way someone as amazing as her got voted off was bc ppl thought she was safe, only way someone this good could lose! >:O

[The01time]

what a joke. three of four should of stayed. lilly should have been a top three at the end. and she sang that song well. changed it up a bit but not to the point to disrespect the song. patsy cline would be proud. and anyone that thinks she didn't deserve to stay. go and listen to your commercial music over produced and overmastered. hopefully a major will pick up lilly and make her big bucks. just ashame that its kids voting . should be done by the panel until the last part of the season

[Valdoman7]

she was my favorite i think shes AMAZING :-)

[kolinkllo]

she is amazing and should have stayed love her!

[AnniethePainter13]

shes so amasing

[superguru09]

Make a record hun' and I'll go buy it.

[micap20078]

this really isnt that bad she deserved a place i the top 12 americans are just too cheesy to understand uniqueness. they would rather listen shaky wanabees like paige and boredom like katie

[nbenjers]

She deserved to be in the final 12. I love her voice. I will buy her cds anytime. Sorry honey that America does NOT recognize your talent

[RavensFan2812]

@nbenjers She's a natural. They canned her and kept Paige? Bullcrap. Period. Lilly's got it going on.

[sportsgal1211]

Shes amazing!!! SCREW YOU IF YOU VOTED 4 ANYONE ELSE!!!

[SquidwarDude12]

I was devastated when she got kicked off. She was my second favorite to siobhan. she has such a great voice and I really hope that she gets an album out. I loved when she said that a lot of good talent left that night and that she doesnt know what america wants to hear. I completely agree. There were a few people that made it that know that they do not deserve to be there. I could see it on their faces. Good luck Lilly!!

[rickyesparza]

She was one of my favorites. 3 of the four that got voted off we thought would be in the top 12. People must have thought she was safe. Too bad she will not be able to release a original song in over one year so it will be very hard to get a contract. They should have a new TV show with the 12 contestants who got voted off.

[rockanrollgal39]

screw the americans tht did not vote 4 her, i am soooooo pissed of bout her leaving. katie sounded like bull compared 2 lilly, katie should have ben out voted, i HATE u ppl tht either 1) did not vote 4 lilly 2) tht voted 4 katie

[potaterr]

You cannot deny that she has a pretty voice.

[Luigi32826]

How the hell did she get voted off???

she is so unique and amazing

[tuhrisha]

Ok, who wants to help me out and build a channel for youtube of all Lilly Scott fans? I'll make the first video, but than you guys can email me videos and stuff'? I want it to go really far, and I want lilly to realize that she does have tons of fans. Please, who's with me!

[starpopz1]

SHE CANT BE GONE I VOTED FOR HER WAY TOO MANY TIMES FOR HER NOT TO BE IN THE TOP 12

lilly scott > america

[indierules17]

how could she be kicked she was amazing america screw you, she had the most potential out of all the female contestants, her voice is also unique

[Dwhee18216]

God Pasty Cline must be rolling in her grave at this horrible singer's rendition of her hit song. This is why I quit watching AI due to weak voices like this. For the record the comment I followed needs to know that great is nor spelled grat, believe is not spelled beleave, release is not spelled release, and album is not spelled albume.

[zuss10]

man thats very disturbing

i can't beleave she's out

grat lost to th show

i hooooooooooooooooooooope

she releas an albume cause she a grate arist that's for sure

[zuss10]

i think that who ever didn't vote to lilly must take thows phones and stick them in thier asses

i am so very pistt off man!!!

[HighBoos55]

I don't know if they're going to have a wild card show this season, but I hope they do.

[livluvlaff50]

My mouth dropped open when Lilly was dropped!! Kept thinking poor Katie has to wait all that time to hear that she's going home and POW!! I thought it was a mistake!! And indeed I believe it is!! Lilly is a distinctive artist who has her own special style and voice that should have had her in the top 3!! Another blemish on the voters for American Idol. Can't vote 'cause I'm Canadian.

[mandieellis]

Lilly Scott TOTALLY messed up that song!!!Im not at all surprised she got voted off. It has nothing to do with the type of singer she is....she messed with a classic and you just dont do that...espeically when its country.The last girl that messed with a classic was Mandisa I dont remember the season but she sang Any Man of Mine by Shania Twain and the next night she got voted off too. She sucked on that song and it showed.

[navarrosgirl]

She has to be one PIST OFF CHICK THIS MORNING !! AI always good for shockin people when u least expect it ...lol...thats how they get their ratings...can anyone say ...Chris Daughtry !!

[navarrosgirl]

Lilly Scott ...Are you serious ??? There is no way n hell that Lilly Scott should have been sent home instead of Katie. Lilly was so much better than most of the girls on the show and def most of the guys !! What a Huge mistake that was sending her home. I really do believe Lilly is way to good for American Idol anyway. Hey Lilly, I have an Idea....Try Contacting Dave Navarro's radio station...His always looking for new bands ... :-)

[shamusroc]

is there some serious political crap going on at idol or what?! seriously? lily scott is one of the best. she should of at least made it the final four. whatever! i didn't know much when i was a teenybopper either.

[potaterr]

Oh my goodness. They kicked all my favourites.

[ja1207]

I wish I can vote...so that somehow, I may have a chance to save her...now, I've lost one of my top3, along with crystal and siobhan....

i know you'll do good in the indie music scene...

screw you katie stevens...you're the one who's supposed to be eliminated...you'll never win this thing...NEVER....

the ones who should go early are andrew, katie, lacey and tim....bllltttt....

[starpopz1]

@ja1207 i know i started to cry because lilly definitely belongs in the top 12. ): im such a loser.

[tuhrisha]

I cried to... I mean i was so sad

[BladeJones]

Lilly enunciates, has a great tone high or low. I love her voice. The problem with this show is that it's 14 year old girls who watch the show and vote 200 times an hour for bubble gum pop tarts -- not "indie" singers with substance. You mean to tell me that the chick who baby sits her grandma is a better singer than Lilly?

[anibislockward]

i dont get why america still wants the same lame artists, instead of giving new opportunitties to really different talented people, hope this crap wont happen again with crystal

[kriskemkem]

i Hate it . Lilly is very deserving to make it to th 12 , even top 2 !! is there any chances that Lilly will be back in AI ? I hope there is a wildcard contest ..

[mrc926]

No one should sing a Patsy Cline song-no one will be satisfied with anyone but Patsy when it comes to a song Patsy sang. Lilly would still be there if she sang a different song. too bad.

[Asterid88]

Lilly and Alex gone? Wtf happened? If there is any justice in this world, there will be some sort of wild card system. (though, sadly, I highly doubt that...)

[atnbrittazniak]

WORST elimination before the top 24 EVER. And not only was hers the worst elimination, it was the worst elimination night EVER. Honestly, Lilly, Katelyn, AND Alex??? This is gonna be a shitty, SHITTY top 12.

[PKAtheist1092]

OMG! I know!!! I mean it was bad enough when Chris Golightly couldn't be in the top 24 and they put that piece of shit Urban in there instead. But really?!?!?! Who the hell voted those other idiots in?!?!

[dud3man6969]

@atnbrittazniak yep, they got rid of 3/5 of the top 5 in one hour.

[Fartchi]

I'm pissed they kicked her of and the guy who sang sombody to love!!!!!!!!!

[pinkpartycat]

HOW THE EFF DID SHE GET KICKED?!?! Im so angry errr

):<

[txmssippi]

oh, so charming. unique, evocative, intimate interpretation of this Patsy Cline classic.

[ShannonJane]

never watching this show ever again. She should have decked that high school cunt in the face.

[coffeebean906]

@ShannonJane THAT IS 100% RIGHT

[prajna8]

@ShannonJane : Yes she should have also done the same to that pompous imbecile called Simon Cowell as well. Voting is all a gimmick. It is that jackass Simon who decides who gets booted out and not the voters.

[bishal509]

American Idol is such a crap.........Nobody should watch it........I'm not gonna watch it from now.........how could possibly how could they do that.............

All I can say is

This public voting might not work if you are looking for talent because the person who perform well, people might think other will vote and they don't vote......

[prajna8]

Voting is an eye wash. Simon Cowell has the final vote.

[lllsandylll]

I can't believe she was booted off. She has such a fresh, unique voice. If she cuts an album, I'll buy it.

[l3montwista]

I am so mad that she lost. She was the best one there.

[LittleMissBurrrman]

Shes gonna win

[pferd18]

She should have won

[RayPaganJr]

I love this girl, but I believe this was not a shining moment for her. God why did she pick this song?

[deathsythe89]

love her voice