I did not pull for Alexandréa Lushington, but I believe that she should have made the top 12 replacing Kristy Lee Cook. She is at least top 6 material. I think she should have been in the finale with David Archuleta.
I loved her so much! I was so sad that she went home so quickly. I think she said stupid things when they talked to her, but she really turned it on when she performed. I hope she will come out with an album, but it's been over a year already, so maybe not :-(
How does the best singer in the competition not make the top 12? If they had the save last season she would of been saved. Because they saw the face of the generation talent in her, she will be the Billie Holiday of this generation.
I love Alex. I've always loved her. She's amazing voice-wise and personality-wise. I'm glad I met her when I lived in Douglasville and went to Douglas County High.
I agree Syesha was probably a stronger vocalist but we never saw all the Alexandra was capable of either. She had quite an instrument. ALex was definitely top 6 material.
@StewNWT I've sung with her, and now that I've gone back to watch the Idol videos, i can assure you Idol never saw her best. That said, this is pretty amazing.
It's the home viewers that are "brushing aside" this "talent" so what's your complaint? It's not the judges or producers getting rid of her. Stop complaining.
jcstefan, you must be completely ignorant about how the voting system works. It's a minority that's deciding who gets through. The voting system needs to be better regulated to prevent abuse, which is why great singers are being screwed over in favor of slightly more pretty people with far less vocal ability.
actually, shes really good i agree with that. but her vocals are everywhere and she doesnt know how to control very well it seems to me. brooke was a fantastic singer and she was constistent, ur right though kristy didnt deserve to be there.
@nightshade0306 i agree with half of what you say..kristy sucked!!! brooke was strong until her departure....i do disagree with brooke's consistenticy
i've never forgotten this performance. definitely one of my favorites that season.
ameliasamson 11 months ago
I think we would have seen plenty of Alex but her 2nd song choice was pretty terrible
StewNWT 1 year ago
I did not pull for Alexandréa Lushington, but I believe that she should have made the top 12 replacing Kristy Lee Cook. She is at least top 6 material. I think she should have been in the finale with David Archuleta.
TediusZanarukando 1 year ago
This amazing singer, is my friend's cousin :)
BieberLoveDust 1 year ago
I KNOW HER! Ha ha, i saw her a few days ago. She graduated from my high school. She is friends with alot of people i know.
Alteredinside 2 years ago
god bless u and your fam
singerinlead 2 years ago
her top 20 performance wasnt good, but she completely deserved top 12 for this performance (yes, it was that good)
SuperPanetone 2 years ago 2
Now that I'm thinking about Ameican Idol again, I was thinking about one of my FAVORITE PERFORMANCES that I've seen on the show. STILL GREAT
Wierdon 2 years ago
i want her to come back!!!!!!
kateliz1223 2 years ago
She was one of my favorites!
yuuichinatsukage 2 years ago
myne too!
djdean75 2 years ago
Ahahaha Paula at 4.12 "of course not" makes me soooo laugh xD
Anyway I loved Alex, sad to know she's been eliminated!
Lawrence2525 2 years ago
I loved her so much! I was so sad that she went home so quickly. I think she said stupid things when they talked to her, but she really turned it on when she performed. I hope she will come out with an album, but it's been over a year already, so maybe not :-(
moonbeamdaydream 2 years ago
How does the best singer in the competition not make the top 12? If they had the save last season she would of been saved. Because they saw the face of the generation talent in her, she will be the Billie Holiday of this generation.
ij3nnif3r13 3 years ago
I love Alex. I've always loved her. She's amazing voice-wise and personality-wise. I'm glad I met her when I lived in Douglasville and went to Douglas County High.
gaaralover01 2 years ago 2
Hahaha Ryan..."that's because I'm ridiculous"
lccarlton 3 years ago
Comment removed
curlingiron7658 3 years ago
What?!? It was!!!
curlingiron7658 3 years ago
so. underrated.
fish0matic 3 years ago 10
I like 2:36
Ihatedumbpeople88 3 years ago
The band nailed this... the drummer was sick!!
thickpoloatl 3 years ago 3
I agree Syesha was probably a stronger vocalist but we never saw all the Alexandra was capable of either. She had quite an instrument. ALex was definitely top 6 material.
StewNWT 3 years ago 7
@StewNWT omg toni braxton prodigy i agree this was one of the best that week... fluck k. lee cook
GRomance0804 2 years ago
@StewNWT I've sung with her, and now that I've gone back to watch the Idol videos, i can assure you Idol never saw her best. That said, this is pretty amazing.
DeapPolitical 1 year ago
i don't think simon gave this performance enough credit! it was AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
rjs5146 3 years ago 4
@rjs5146 omg yeah this is perfection and so r&b relevance in 2010 and this is a 60s song!!
GRomance0804 2 years ago
She was amazing. Her vocal technique is incredible. One of the top performances of the entire season, imo
mommm1 3 years ago 3
Aw this is one of my favorite female performances on that season. She can sing and dance well :o)
Svhsgirl 3 years ago 4
True talent like this gets brushed aside... brooke and kristy-lee make it to the top 10. Yeah, I really wonder why A.I. ratings are down..
Hiltongroupie 3 years ago 3
It's the home viewers that are "brushing aside" this "talent" so what's your complaint? It's not the judges or producers getting rid of her. Stop complaining.
jcstefan4698 3 years ago 2
jcstefan, you must be completely ignorant about how the voting system works. It's a minority that's deciding who gets through. The voting system needs to be better regulated to prevent abuse, which is why great singers are being screwed over in favor of slightly more pretty people with far less vocal ability.
Hiltongroupie 3 years ago
actually, shes really good i agree with that. but her vocals are everywhere and she doesnt know how to control very well it seems to me. brooke was a fantastic singer and she was constistent, ur right though kristy didnt deserve to be there.
nightshade0306 3 years ago
wow...im sorry, but as an sls student i dont think brooke could sing very well
cookiedoughlover36 3 years ago 2
@nightshade0306 i agree with half of what you say..kristy sucked!!! brooke was strong until her departure....i do disagree with brooke's consistenticy
GRomance0804 2 years ago
@Hiltongroupie kristy was the nikki Mickibben, Carmen Rasmusen, haley scarnato/......brooke was better than them
GRomance0804 2 years ago
I like her, she is very unique...I liked her better than Kristy Lee... very SADE like
GRomance0804 3 years ago 4
she was one of my fav females, i can't believe syesha did better. hate her.
RayatoTV 3 years ago
syesha sings circles around this girl. nothing against alexandrea but syesha could def sing and deserved to be in the top 3, if not in the finale.
crzyluis11 3 years ago
ummmm wat r u saying syesha did make it to the top 3?
ClUbPenGuIn0wNz 3 years ago
Yes, Syesha was 3rd.
kricert 3 years ago
maybe because they're both great singers, but syesha's better...
qg6ff 3 years ago
i liked how she sang starting on 2:03 and how she moved there it was cool
rynapostol09 3 years ago
she knows how to move on stage.
icezorg 3 years ago 3
different voice, personality, and look.She's pretty good.
Bluejayberry 3 years ago
Loved her!!!
mommm1 3 years ago