Very very good, not my favorite, but very very good. For all of you with nasty comments about this performance, please give us the link to YOUR YouTube recording of this so we can see how it should be done. thank you :-)
I think Edita is IDEAL for Mozart. For me , she is the best of the best.
I like a lot Lucia Popp in Mozart , too. I really like Lucia, but....Edita is so great, so perfect, her voice is sooooo beautiful. that is the number one for me.
Beautiful! Pristine! Thank God for Sutherland and herself! Who wants to listen to Alleluia sang as if coming from a machine gun like Bartoli! Ill never understand her popularity!
Coloratura is when you can regulate your air flow to sing numerous amounts of notes in one measure. Such as this one, starting at 0:43, each one of those notes she's singing is separated, but you can't really tell because she's been trained as a coloratura. And soprano is..Just high pitched voice. In fact, any voice range can be a coloratura, but not every voice can be a soprano. Does that make sense? XC
I love her voice. I Notice the comparisons to Diana Damrau, and while Damrau gives a wonderful and most joyous performance, I like Edita Gruberova's voice more.
Great coloratura singing should always sound breathless and light and easy. Edita manages to do all in this arduous music. SHe is truly a great artist!
Edita is a dramatic coloratura, but she's still a coloratura - a lighter voice type. She would never be able to sing over Wagnerian singers for example, but for this piece her voice is more than suitable. Who really wants to hear Brunnhilde sing this anyway... ;)
ttutiusati, I think this version is more natural and soft, Cecilia Bartoli´s (who is a wonderfull singer and I like so much ) version is realy a litlle harder.., Cecilia doen´t work with Mozart....
This version I think is wonderful, so natural, so soft, and with a lovely musically ,fines lines and clean coloratura.., it is absolutely perfct..
I prefer Cecilia, because she is more into the music.. Gruberova's Alleluja is wonderful, natural, soft: perfect, but too perfect, too cold... I love the enthusiasm in the voice of Cecilia, although she is less perfect than Gruberova...
@saxamaphoneguy1 But still Gruberova's coloratura is flowing, completely natural that is you don't hear separation between the notes, whereas with Damrau you hear it there is all the difference.A wonderful energy is emanating from her though.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don`t like her voice.. or I don't understand her voice.. that is very strange for me.. really. She is a very good singer but in can undertand her voice..
wonderful technic. she's a little sad on the halleluja. i mean it's a halleluja!!! its full of happyness and emotion. look at bartoli's exibition. cecilia is maybe too exalted, but i think it's more that way!!!
????? i cannot believe ur comment. you cannot hear the clean coloratura runs and wonderful legato? all you see is bad things when it comes to gruberova, this is sad.
Opinion on voices and singers is always varied and subjective.
I don't think it's a "sad" situation when someone is not of the same opinion as me - it would suggest that I believed that person to be somehow deficient or lacking in good judgement.
it's not about different opinions, it's about criticising. we were not talking about gruberova's voice, but about the fact you mentioned only the scoop which is not even there! this is what I call a "sad situation";) but nevermind, let's stop arguing about this topic, it's pointless.
How beautiful is this!!! What a magnificant voice... coloratura is impeccable. Her support is second-to-none. Pitch is wonderful also. Makes me wish I was a soprano and not a baritone, hahaha!!! Nice voice, excellent performance!
Its one of the best one but lacking JOY Mozart is praising all creation and the creator it should be filled with exuberance and abandonment
lloydsk 1 month ago
Very very good, not my favorite, but very very good. For all of you with nasty comments about this performance, please give us the link to YOUR YouTube recording of this so we can see how it should be done. thank you :-)
davinapons 3 months ago
I think Edita is IDEAL for Mozart. For me , she is the best of the best.
I like a lot Lucia Popp in Mozart , too. I really like Lucia, but....Edita is so great, so perfect, her voice is sooooo beautiful. that is the number one for me.
Swan607 4 months ago
Comment removed
nestorfabianpz 6 months ago
Perfectly acceptable. But light-years below Dame Kiri.
cantorga 8 months ago
only one world:
"alleluia"
Exultate Jubilate
graciaz!!!
20roberto10 11 months ago
i must confess this is the best coloratura i've ever heard.
zralokvemigraci 1 year ago 4
I love simfonic music.
brisco2k 1 year ago
Perfection. I love her.
homerbunny 1 year ago
She is never into the music and real interpretation. A jukebox machine....
filippo441 1 year ago
Beautiful! Pristine! Thank God for Sutherland and herself! Who wants to listen to Alleluia sang as if coming from a machine gun like Bartoli! Ill never understand her popularity!
kamikazekate 1 year ago 2
Man, what tits !
MucusFelidae 1 year ago
she is the best!
ButterflyRockyGirl 1 year ago 3
Je t'adore ....
Rainarr 1 year ago
BRAVA Gruberova!
SopranoLeggero 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ordinary, listen to Lucia Popp
vivegedda 1 year ago
Beautiful interpretation and voice...unique and original.Thanks for sharing it.
GeneKLM747 1 year ago
Supper!
goharners 1 year ago
This is the most effortless clean and exhillerating performance of this I have ever seen. It gives me goosebumps.
cynobitya 1 year ago
Melopedia: a pesar de nó escucharse con claridad este video, Edita Gruberova está portentosa como siempre.-
melopedia 1 year ago
This is the best legato singing of Alleluja, grandioseness interpretation !!!
ocakavanie 1 year ago 3
yo go Edita!! your my favourite Gilda!
Maggielicious21 1 year ago
Bravissima, diva!
elisadiva 1 year ago 3
This is soo good. I have to play this for solo and ensemble on my clarinet, I'm nervous (:
ilypaulmccartney 1 year ago
@ilypaulmccartney: Just take a deep breath! and you'll be great.
bonnies1234567 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I hear that Mozart wrote very difficult work for singers... with G3... could you tell me how it is called?
Divina126 2 years ago
Comment removed
Divina126 2 years ago
Can anyone tell me? What is the difference between coloratura and sorpano?
saxonfield 2 years ago
Coloratura is when you can regulate your air flow to sing numerous amounts of notes in one measure. Such as this one, starting at 0:43, each one of those notes she's singing is separated, but you can't really tell because she's been trained as a coloratura. And soprano is..Just high pitched voice. In fact, any voice range can be a coloratura, but not every voice can be a soprano. Does that make sense? XC
kit11104 2 years ago
Bueno si amas a la Bartoli, escribe en el otro correo sobre la Cecilia, y no aqui no te parece?
acitipo 2 years ago
wow..her coloraturas are wonderful!I wish I can do it so easy as her
amillia007 2 years ago 3
wow! that coloratura!!!
sweetsoprano1211 2 years ago 5
BEAUTIFUL
leoperarm 2 years ago 5
Haha... 'Nuff said :D
broadwaystar2011 2 years ago
I love her voice. I Notice the comparisons to Diana Damrau, and while Damrau gives a wonderful and most joyous performance, I like Edita Gruberova's voice more.
MandyJMaddison 2 years ago 4
Exactly I find Damrau is always faking it
passerabianca 2 years ago
Outstanding!
MisterSoprano 2 years ago 3
ohhhh.......such flawless coloratura......
tiernan87 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's pretty decent, but far from flawless -- especially considering the period style.
CountertenorJ 2 years ago
Celebrando la EXCELENCIA...
mozart230647 2 years ago 4
Great coloratura singing should always sound breathless and light and easy. Edita manages to do all in this arduous music. SHe is truly a great artist!
operaoaf 2 years ago 5
Isn't this piece meant for a more lighter, lyric soprano rather than a dramatic one?
hotqueekboi 2 years ago 2
Edita is a dramatic coloratura, but she's still a coloratura - a lighter voice type. She would never be able to sing over Wagnerian singers for example, but for this piece her voice is more than suitable. Who really wants to hear Brunnhilde sing this anyway... ;)
musicyh 2 years ago 2
Listen to Cecilia Bartoli's version, which is more natural...
tuttiusati 2 years ago
Not vocally. She may be more into the music, but Edita's untouchable musically here. Cecilia's technique is inappropriate for Mozart.
Iareto 2 years ago 26
@Iareto Could you give some historical evidence to support that claim, please?
CountertenorJ 1 year ago
@CountertenorJ jkajka yeah =) Her attack to high notes (gruberova's) is the most appropriate for anything in opera.
RoOodOoOloOmeg 1 year ago
@Iareto exactly.
2010wieliczka 6 months ago
I love Bartoli, but don't like her choppy version of this. I prefer this interpretation. Yes, it's an Alleluia, but still Mozart.
yourbliss888 2 years ago 10
ttutiusati, I think this version is more natural and soft, Cecilia Bartoli´s (who is a wonderfull singer and I like so much ) version is realy a litlle harder.., Cecilia doen´t work with Mozart....
This version I think is wonderful, so natural, so soft, and with a lovely musically ,fines lines and clean coloratura.., it is absolutely perfct..
Brunildilla 2 years ago 14
I prefer Cecilia, because she is more into the music.. Gruberova's Alleluja is wonderful, natural, soft: perfect, but too perfect, too cold... I love the enthusiasm in the voice of Cecilia, although she is less perfect than Gruberova...
tuttiusati 2 years ago 4
Of course I understand you, Cecilia is a great artist , I think she is terrific and wonderful in
Barroco repertorie.
Brunildilla 2 years ago 4
You try Diana Damrau! She has the same voice type and talent as Gruberova, but the enthusiasm of Bartoli. it's wonderful.
saxamaphoneguy1 2 years ago
AMEN! All hail Diana!
tiernan87 2 years ago
You sound like one of those who don't feel difference between Horowitz and Lang Lang
passerabianca 2 years ago
@saxamaphoneguy1 But still Gruberova's coloratura is flowing, completely natural that is you don't hear separation between the notes, whereas with Damrau you hear it there is all the difference.A wonderful energy is emanating from her though.
diradour 1 year ago
@tuttiusati Sorry, but Cecilia singing Alleluja in my opinion is like athlete forced to run 800m in championschip.
2010wieliczka 2 months ago
@Brunildilla It is not possible to sing it perfect but Edita was very, very close...
2010wieliczka 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don`t like her voice.. or I don't understand her voice.. that is very strange for me.. really. She is a very good singer but in can undertand her voice..
anasconuto 2 years ago
I think I've found my standard version of this piece!
She is really great and she sings effortlessly.
Love it!
vettae 3 years ago 9
I am not a big fan of Edita... in fact i don't like her very much, but she was great here. Thanks for posting it.
ejrouge 3 years ago
I love her!!
ksmcaron 3 years ago 2
wonderful technic. she's a little sad on the halleluja. i mean it's a halleluja!!! its full of happyness and emotion. look at bartoli's exibition. cecilia is maybe too exalted, but i think it's more that way!!!
newhotmailit 3 years ago
Fantastic. Never heard such clean coloratura runs - and at this speed! Wow!
Glenmed 3 years ago 10
wow que escoteeeeee, jajaja... Aparte de eso, canta lindo.
Janibeva 3 years ago
She's indeed the queen of coloratura.
gemininer 3 years ago 8
BRAVO Edita.
You are the Best of.
Robertirobbie 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This work Mozart composed for a castrato and not for a woman....:)
wskfan 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bit of a squawk to reach the top note, and she slides up to it.
Knappa22 3 years ago
????? i cannot believe ur comment. you cannot hear the clean coloratura runs and wonderful legato? all you see is bad things when it comes to gruberova, this is sad.
operaeater 3 years ago 6
No. There are several good points to the performance.
There is no need to call someone is "sad" just because they don't share your opinions.
Knappa22 3 years ago
i didn't call u sad, I thought the situation was sad.
operaeater 3 years ago 2
Opinion on voices and singers is always varied and subjective.
I don't think it's a "sad" situation when someone is not of the same opinion as me - it would suggest that I believed that person to be somehow deficient or lacking in good judgement.
Knappa22 3 years ago
it's not about different opinions, it's about criticising. we were not talking about gruberova's voice, but about the fact you mentioned only the scoop which is not even there! this is what I call a "sad situation";) but nevermind, let's stop arguing about this topic, it's pointless.
operaeater 3 years ago 4
I believe there was a scoop - quite a pronounced one too.
And nowhere have I suggested that the performance is altogether bad. There are, as you pointed out, several good points to it.
Knappa22 3 years ago
I Louise Fribo the best for this song. Clean, effortless and warm.
raymondkkng 3 years ago
Diana Damrau ROCKS!!!!
exodus9000 3 years ago
The Queen of Coloratura!
podimusicus 3 years ago 6
usually i don't like vibrato that much but she actually uses it the proper way and can stay on pitch
Bassetenator 3 years ago 3
This is real class. She makes it seem so effortless. What a great voice.
swanningaround 3 years ago 29
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She es good but whitout soul
19911991ja 3 years ago
Oh yes! But it would be kind of nice to know where this took place and what orchestra it is.
radostsguy 3 years ago 2
thats generally missing with classical pieces on youtube, dont know why.
kralle7611 3 years ago
If you don't want these videos to be removed and accounts closed, then leaving that information out is a good thing :(
coloraturafan 3 years ago 2
BEAUTIFUL SHE'S ANGEL
debourget 4 years ago 6
How beautiful is this!!! What a magnificant voice... coloratura is impeccable. Her support is second-to-none. Pitch is wonderful also. Makes me wish I was a soprano and not a baritone, hahaha!!! Nice voice, excellent performance!
novascotiawill 4 years ago 12
LOVEZ IT! Haha
33blueberries 4 years ago
Incredible singing! The coloratura is so smooth, and yet it is accented. This is probably the best rendition I've heard of this piece!
operamagnus 4 years ago 12
My favorite performance of this aria as well -- how exciting!!! This woman can sing anything. A goddess!
jboygb 4 years ago 11
Easily my favorite performance of this aria!
Hal5423 4 years ago 5
Wow! Thank you for posting this.
It's beautiful!
freespiritQC 4 years ago 5