L'amour est un oiseau rebelle Elina Garanca MET 2009

[crinoix]

She is not a soprano...who said that...doesn't know anything.There are several types of mezzosoprano voices.Garanza is probably a lyric mezzo-soprano.Anyway,she has a mezzo-soprano timbre.Who say she isn't,i think that person doesn't like Garanca from another point of view..

[Woelfin001]

@crinoix She is definitely a mezzo - the dark metallic timbre is a dead give-away :-) Bty lyric? Never! Definitely a dramatic mezzo, or 'll eat my hat!

[bodiloto]

SOPRANO.

[Woelfin001]

@bodiloto Pure ignorance!

[Woelfin001]

@bodiloto I have had to use a translator to understand your comment. :-) I am happy to have given you a good laugh, as you say, it is good for the health. But I too have ears: such strength in her lower registers and the 'darkness' that she takes up into the higher ones... this cannot be a soprano. What makes you think it is? Not that it is important - she is wonderful, at least we agrree on that :-) Have a nice day, Bodolito!

[itsmrturdwrestler2u]

Indeed what man wouldn't drop everything to run off with her, I'm afraid I woud.

[yaakovha]

strange , unique and wonderful!

FORZA ELINA!

[nekonorma]

Elina !! She was born to sing Carmen. I have never seen such a sexy and wonderful Carmen. Thank you!!

[norwichterrierfan1]

Thank you for the music AND pictures - both lovely.

[danibal54]

¡¡¡Es Maravillosa!!!, y si se puede decir,

¡¡¡Esta Definitivamente Entre Mis Favori-

tas!!!. Lo confirme, hoy sabado 15/2010,

cuando la vi desde el Met. Realmente es

¡¡¡Gloriosa!!

[tychaton08]

Merci!

[luvxl]

ça y'est on y est presque! et dire que je n'y croyais qu'à moitié... Rhaaaa je déteste un peu la merveilleuse Elina de ne point chanter sa Carmen à Paris!

I gotta say I hate her a little bit for not bringing her Carmen to Paris...