Added: 2 years ago
From: TheMurtaghFan
Views: 57,335
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the guys who made the movie earagon need to read the book

  • i read all the books and loved them and i loved this movie.. but what i don't understand is why they cut sooo much out of it, they have deleted scenes of Katrina and the twins... they are important to the movie, if they hadn't cut them out they could make the second third and forth movie, i'm pretty disappointed that they can't now cause this is my favorite series.

  • the twins were very important

  • @hiloboy06 as they gave murtagh to gallbatorix.... an they wear eyeliner

  • what the hell! this movie would have at least have been a bit better if they included this scene

  • The twins are not even twins. It's one man and they copied him. They should have kept this scene, or better use twop actors instead of one. This could have been such a great series of movies, it could have stood together with Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings. It's a shame they can't even make a second part, because KAtrina never showed in the first one and because Razacs were killed by Brom. I wish the director had read the book properly before turning a great story into a shitty one. :(

  • Garrett Hedlund (Murtagh) was the only reason i saw this movie it was a disappointment hardly like the book. But atleast i saw Garrett he is my all time favorite actor hahaha

  • the whole movie sucked christopher should re make his movie with a better director im 100 percent sure that if he had a better director and better actors and actresses that looked like the characters in the book AND got the story line 100 percent right this series would be even more popular then harry potter

  • this is so gay! it is not how it happened and there is such bad acting and the dwarfs are regular human height! soooooo GAY!!!!!!

  • the sword seemed to big for him to carry i always imagined the sword a little bit smaller

  • that was the wimpiest roar i ever heard.

  • How do u get the deleted scenes?

  • Speelers wasn't a terrible Eragon neither were the actors of Brom, Garrow, Murtagh, Ajihad or Durza. Everyone else sucked and the entire feel of the movie betrayed the heart of the novel. its a cheap, forgettable, one-time only cinematic experience. But there's hope! Just think about Ralph Bakshi's Lord of the Rings from the 70s. ever heard of it? if not, good! that will be this film in a few decades. Hopefully some Peter Jackson type of director will reboot it to give it the quality it deserves

  • @thuperthamy101 yeah!

  • @thuperthamy101 and why does druza turn ugly whn he gets shot? that freaks me out ~.~

  • This movie was such a huge dissapointment for me. I love the books about Eragon, and this movie could have been so epic, but they ruined the entire story.

  • How does throwing a sword at somone cause that kind of scar!?!?!?! O.o

  • @TheGuardianssorrow It was Zar'roc.

  • Eragon is HOOOOTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • The ONLY thing this movie did was give you an idea of what a smaller Saphira may have looked like. Aside from that, it was terrible. The characters didn't fit CP's books in the least, and the plot was very upside-down.

  • this is so painful to watch....

  • @DarkDNAngel13 Well, the last time I saw it was in 2010 and by then, as we all know, the first three books were already released, and I had already read the Eragon book, so I still like the movie no matter what, and not one person in this world can tell me anything otherwise.

  • @valrico63 your a blind fool to like the movie. even when you've read the book. fox fucked this movie up and any chance of another studio rebooting it....good job fox you cheap ass bastards.

  • The movie was awesome! So were all the books! Shut the heck up all those who don't like it! You've already wasted all your lives by not liking this move! Darn you all who don't like the Eragon movie!

  • @valrico63 i agree that the movie is good, but after you read the books (of if you read them before you watched the movie) the movie is kinda of a disappointment. I know movies can't incorporate everything from the book but this movie strays from the book and leaves out key details that were necessary for the movie... sorry about the long rant and it's just my opinion because I loved the movie when it first came out since i was younger but now that i read the books, i was just disappointed.

  • @DarkDNAngel13 sorry... necessary for the plot (not the movie)

  • now that all the books are released, I wish they could just redo it, with better actors and better director. It could be a wonderful movie series.

  • @BURNoutxx it's not entirly the director's fault fox is the one who screwed it up. they don't care about the source material, and they only gave them like 1 million dollars which in hollywood is like $1-10.

  • hated this movie. terrible acting, and the story wasn't even correct. loved the book however

  • Who talked Djimon Hounsou into this one?

  • this could have been a wonderful movie series as was the book series BUT THE DIRECTOR TOTALY FUCKED IT UP!

  • Did anyone notice they used the exact same footage for both of saphira's roars? they just mirrored it!

  • He has passed the TEST

    We proTEST

    He will REST

    lol

  • so wait the scenes with the twins who are major villains int he next book got deleted

    The scene with katrina who is roran's love interest and driving force for the rest of the novles got deleted

    The scene that set up elva one of the main fucking plot points throughout the novels got deleted

    but we get to see galbatorix whose appearance was supposed to remain a mystery until the end of the series....

  • Okay, the twins are kinda creepy (I'm glad they die in Eldest), Ajihad is NOT a very good actor and Saphira's roar sounded like she was passing gas.....

  • AHAHAHAHAH Eragon's face at\ 0:55 had me rolling on the floor

  • ive seen the movie and read the book.in the movie,where r the dwarves and y isnt eragon going with arya to du weldenvarden?in the book,it didnt metion that brom looked like an elf.in the movie,brom doesnt look like an elf with the clearly visible ears which arya doesnt have. riders would look like elves if they arent one yet.galbatorix and brom r human dragon riders.brom didnt have the face of an elf and we dont know about galbatorix.

  • @funin2beds Human riders dont look like elves. Thats specific to Eragon because of the Agaeti Blodhren in the second book where he becomes half elf.

  • @IMTHATGUY3927 well i remeber in the book that brom said that human riders will slowly get elf ears and the abilities of an elf

  • @funin2beds exactly,they slowly get the ears and abilities.in time, human riders start to look like elves

  • lol i love how when they see Murtagh they're all like "GTFO" (well not really in the book,.... in book Murtagh said that is he started living with they Varden he would end up a "Fat scholar" but.... they didnt really get alot of things right in the movie sooo.......)

  • this might actual be the best part of the movie, the end credits make a very close second

  • I don't like it that muck 'cause Saphira roars twice and it's preatty much the same.... TWINS ARE CREEPY

  • @saphara00900 I am a twin!

  • "The rider has passed his test" "We strongly protest" HAHAHA, rhyme xD

  • Why didn't they put this in the movie?

  • The twins are creepier than I expected

  • @SimmerSab

    OMG, u are so right....

  • Murtagh is hot tho :I

    They could have made the movie... so... much... better. BUT THEY DID NOT. >:

  • I just watched this for the first time it was horrible the book was so much better I wish they would remake it with spielberg as director

  • Yeah right... Since when are dwarves as tall as humans? Eragon is so fucking ugly...

  • PROBLEMS....ajihad doesn't come in at the beginning, its just the dwarves, eragon and murtaugh. Murtaugh's scar was acrosss is back, from shoulder to hip... not his side. THE TWINS WERE DWARVESSSS!!!! grrrrr why does hollywood mess up books so badly!?

  • @jessifoley You need to read the book again. The twins were men. It says multiple times, "The bald man". It also says, "He was taller than most of the men..."

  • @jessifoley Exactly.. but one thing I must correct. The twins were not dwarves, they were regular human.

  • @jessifoley The twins were not dwarves you neanderthal...

  • Murtagh has really nice teeth O.o

  • is that black guy Ajihad?

  • @hellveteran45 yeah

  • WHY IS THE SWORD FREAKIN BLUE???!!!

  • Why did they take this out. They could have edited it, and made it better, but it is one of the most important part of the book.

  • its a bad film......

  • this should have been in the movie!

  • Now I'm super annoyed this wasn't in the movie.... Its kinda a major element...

  • @MichMashxx They left a lot of major elements out of the movie. That is, if you're comparing it to the book. In my opinion, they made a mess of the movie.

  • Comment removed

  • Twins are bald and freaky, PERFECT!

    Take a look at eragon's eyes at 0:53 LOL!

  • well for a start in the book it said the twins didnt show there faces so wierd???

  • I love this movie. Murtagh's my favorite. And this is pretty important. Oh well.

  • Why didn't they keep this? It's kind of important, actually.

  • it looks like a scene from a 1980's movie...not great acting..great actors just not there best performance..

  • that sucked. Eragon went from detached, to discomfort when the Twins tested him, and then back to detached seconds later after Saphira did that stupid cat growl. He didn't even look perturbed by the fact that the Twins attacked his mind and in the book, if he called out to Saphira like that, she wouldn't have just cat growled, she would have pounced on them.

  • In the book Murtagh told Eragon he was Morzan's son before hey even gotto the Varden.

  • I think all the actors did a great job, I think they just made to many mistakes in the movies's script

  • Biggest problem with this film? All the actors are too young, and look it.

  • yeah i'm pretty sure the twins were dwarves and slightly less creepy..

  • @downbythebrooke actually I'm pretty sure they were human, and very creepy, and supposed to be hate able characters.in the book i mean.

  • @archmage5245 i guess they were humans hmm i haven't read the books in a while

  • Are those supposed to be dwarves?

  • I swear that when saphira roared again it was the same scene flipped. The only good bit in this movie is murtagh he looks like he actually fits the character ok but occasionally needs to improve his acting

  • @loonygoldfish Thats because that saphira scene IS flipped.

  • I bet he twins were payed one MEEELLIIIONNNN DOLLLARRSSS. (austin powers)

  • such shitty acting, omfggggg! they were just shoving murtagh along, not even holding him and you can see he could have just shrugged them off. this is terrible.

  • know why this movie is CHEAP? 0:43 is the exact same sequence as 2:37. You can see the green screening pretty clear in the host where the two twins stand behind Eragon...hollywood B film at its best...and that is by no means a compliment. Some actors were good, music was good, saphira was nicely done and thats about it. Varden look like a bunch of persian nomads, I imagined them far more disciplined...

  • @Fangornmmc your right its the same scene but its flipped.

  • Im starting to think the director of this mocie anf M Night Shamalamadingdong have some sort of pact to ruin all books to movies. Gosh i hope The Hunger Games turns out okay.

  • @MsBookworm15 All I can say to that is, lol. And I agree with you

  • My god this acting is awful. What the hell was the director thinking? It looks like a bunch of high schoolers on a theatre stage playing their rolls. >_> And the Eragon in this movie doesn't even fit the description in the book. Jeez... Saphira was the best actor of the movie, and she wasn't even real, just animated. Lol.

  • @Lindseydive haha so true

  • @Lindseydive The voice of Saphira was actually done by an Oscar winning actress, lol

  • @Lindseydive I still think Jeremy Irons (Brom) was the best actor in this movie. He's a bit younger than in the book but he really understands Brom's character and plays him like he should.

  • @kristofize Strongly agreed.

  • @Lindseydive Brom was pretty good in my opinion. 

  • @Lindseydive What's the desciption in the book? I don't remember

  • hmmm, i always pictured the twins from yugioh for these guys for some reason :P

  • 2:40, rhyming game! "the rider has past his test" "we strongly protest" "he will rest"

  • While I agree the movie absolutely butchered the book, I have to admit the acting really isn't that bad at all. This movie had so much potential..

  • @thatfatcat734 had is right....terrible acting, shitty

  • God Damn, the faggot who plays Eragon is so ridiculously lame I want to shoot him in the face every time he says a word. :/ fuck...

  • dr. evil x two

  • why are the dwarfs taller than the humans! they are dwarfs! they are supposed to be small, tiny, waist high. don't any of these terms register in your tiny brains ohh ye of little knowledge movie makers. they are called dwarfs for a reason. THEY ARE DWARFED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! so.......... now that i'm finished with my rant how are you?

  • who plays those asses that are the Twins? They're doing a good job...

  • Ah! Murtagh!!!!!! Luv him

  • 0:16 Murtagh looks so shmexy

  • i cant believe this was a deleted scene considering it was ACCUALLY IN THE MOVIE!!!!! everything else pretty much was not... they really should remake it!

  • I thought the twins were migets. epicly migdets

  • Listen: I watched the movie before reading the book, and I thought the movie was extremely good. If it was named anything else and NOT based on the book (which is infinitely better), this would be a great movie!

  • @Technoguy3 the movie is crap

  • does anyone know if there is going to be Eldest movie, or Brisingr or Inheritance?

  • so now they're going to have trouble creating tronjheem [i forget how to spell it to be honest..]and du weldenvarden all in one movie, arya wasnt nearly as impressive as she was in the book, she looks too human to be an elf, again the lack of dwarves, and the time period in which this all took place. around 3-4 days tops in movie i believe? took almost a full year to go from carvahall -> varden in book. traveling and training...they completely skipped yazuak didnt they? yeah they did..

  • the ONLY thing i was pleased with the movie, was brom. he actually seemed to feel right maybe not the gay ass clothes they put him in, but definitly the way he acted, it felt right. eragon arya [lack of any dwarves] and the final battle with durza. what the FUCK were they thinking, oh lets just have him summon a dragon-monster thing out of SMOKE. that would be so cool! no. they failed. no scar on eragons back, they didnt show the politic side of nthe varden

  • @ProTunafish I concur, I just finished the first book, and I watched the movie before that, I didnt even need to read the book to know that they got nearly everthing wrong, Except Brom, If it werent for Jeremy Irons I wouldnt even bothered watching this movie, and if I hadnt watched the movie I probably wouldnt have read the book so thanks to Jeremy Irons

  • did anyone else notice that the safira roaring scean at 0:43 is the same as the roar at 2:37 ????

    and i think the two reasons they deleted the scence was 1; in eragon's memories they show katrina, which was only in a deleted scene and 2; the twins were heavily makeuped and ugly.... lolz

  • @h2o274 Yup, although the image is flipped. How fucking lazy of them.

  • Years ago, I saw a clip where Eragon and Arya actually kissed at the end(obviously they deleted that scene) but I can't find it anywhere.

  • if they wouldve added all these deleted scenes to the movie, it woulve be a bit better. like now its 50% in goodness. (or worse) but adding these scenes it wouldve been 60%

    because they missed arya, katrina, the twins, HOW THE CHARACTERS LOOKED LIKE (like saphira's wings, broms beard, ARYA, ERAGON....) and soooo much more.

    they inflicted pain on poor inocent fans

    THUMBS UP IF THEY NEED A REMAKE, WE DONT CARE IF ITS LONG, AS LONG AS ITS AS GOOD AS THEY BOOK WAS

  • it was bad, lets just leave it at that and enjoy the books, though the only actor in the film that i felt was any good was the guy who played murtagh :L

  • THis is just painful.

  • this is the biggest let down for the movies ever they didn't even follow the plot of the books. first off brom didn't die from the shade. he died from the ra zac. second in the book he goes to the forture tell at least third times in this movie he only want to her once. third they never showed the part where brom brought, eragon to the house to heal. i agree that they should re make the movies. now they have the twins in the deleted scenes we didn't seen them untill the second one.

  • thats parts allmost like the book allllllllllmost :/

  • Is it just me or is all Saphira does in this movie roaring at people? She's supposed to be smarter than all of them :/

  • Is it just me or is all Saphira does in this movie roaring at people? She's supposed to be smarter than all of them :/

  • This movie completly ruined the book, Paolini should write a new script that dosent leave out the best parts of the book and completly remake the movie, especially Saphira she should look so much better in the movie they did a terrible job.

  • So they cast the twins made this scene but cut it out and didn't even have the twins around as backround people? gahhhhh

  • This movie has Z FILM written all over it. Seriously the FOOTAGE at 0:43 IS THE SAME as 2:29 only mirrored. THAT IS CHEEEEEEEEEEEEAP as fuck.

  • they should have made a part 1 and 2 so they could at least add in teirm

  • Budget = Osamas spoils after 9/11

  • the should've deleted the whole movie lol

  • god I hate this movie they ruined the book

  • uuuuuh that was bad acting xD

  • i always wondered what the twins would look like i never could really picture them in my mind

  • press 8 " IMA FIRIN MAH LAZAR"

  • If only they included all the deleted scenes in the movie, the second movie would already be out and they will be making the third movie soon...

  • since when does having an Irish accent make you a dwarf? :/

  • @GabbyGraffiti they're usually scottish :p anyway Hrothgar is WAY too tall in the movie. Worst movie adaption ever!

  • Why the hell did they cut out so many important scenes? If the they hadn't cut them all out, they could have made a quite good movie after all...although...what with all the flaws in character and presentation...no...it would have been bad nevertheless...

  • press 2 he looks at murtophs dick

  • press 3 or 0:51 lol that face ^.^

  • WHY DID THEY DELETE SO MANY SCENES?!?!?!?

  • WHAY DID THEY DELETE SO MANY SCENES?!?!?!?

  • Why do urgals have no horns in this movie

  • This was in the movie except when that bald guy appeared.

  • I downloaded the movie so I got to watch part of what was shown. I didn't see the part when the twins viewed his memories.

  • this series coulda been such a good few movies..but some amatuer director had to wreck it.

  • who directed this movie

  • OMG, WHERE ARE THE DWARVES!!!

  • this ajihad makes me laugh.

  • @eggroll62 okay, thank you

  • okay uhm I have read Eragon and Eldest, and I've seen the movie but isn't Murtagh's scar suposed to be on his back? -confused- ...or maybe that was Eragon's scar? anybody want to give me correct information? ^-^

  • @gothickid6 Both Murtagh and Eragons' scars are supposed to be on their back. Murtagh from Left to Right, Eragons' from Right to Left. The movie did not give Eragon a scar so that is why you are probably utterly confused.

  • Ok, let me get this straight. They deleted scenes of The Twins, Katrina and Elva's blessing. The three clips which made the film remotely like the book!? Idiots :/

  • they aren't making anymore movies, you guys know that right?

  • they reused the shot where Saphira roared. they just mirrored it - the sound is the same

  • I loled when Roran killed those bastards in Eldest

  • oh god it sucks so bad ican't stop laughing!! :))))

  • i agree with almost every disparaging comment about this movie, such as one about those aren't dwarves, and another about cutting scenes about characters who have a major part further along in the series.

    Vote Up if you agree?

  • @paolinifan you know what sucks, i cant thumbs ur comment up a billion times....

  • it's been so darn long since i saw this scene...

  • they did a good job on the twins. i hate them lol

  • i like how the lord of the rinds movie was older than this and got the dwarfs and their height correct

  • Movie was horrible beyond words.

  • wtf they cut so much scenes. can`t belive it !

  • No damn it! dwarves are not meant to be taller than the average human being D:

  • they even got the deleated scenes wrong. eragons let the twins examin his mind. if hed wanted too him and saphira could have easily overwhelmed the tins. how can they have gotten everything wrong? thank god they at least got brom, durza, saphira and murtagh right.

  • murtagh is soooooo sexy we he is dripping wet!! :)

  • Ajihad is Roca in Never Back Down XD.........and why did they delete all the crucial scenes and put in unnecessary ones?

  • yeah but lets all agree that the first movie must be remaked before atempting to make the other 2 movies ok