Added: 4 years ago
From: hifkfani93
Views: 778,973
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (701)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Angels take us where we think we are going, and water is the river to take us there.

  • People really need something else to talk about. Rather than the old debate Tarja -vs- Annette, I wonder why nighwish seems so obsessed with water and angels? (By the way, I love NIGHTWISH, no old, no new, they're all great!)

  • Comment removed

  • One of the most beautiful song

  • you need to be finnish and leave in finland to know where and how tuomas gets all these feelings and ambiances this awesome music ... people always say that finnish people are so depressive and angry etc. but even though finnish people are so harsh and inwards they can make very beautifull and sensitive music ... i am so proud that i am finnish :) !

  • spongebob brought me here :)

  • It's not just about whether Tarja can sing better than Anette. Anyone who has seen Tarja on stage can see that she is a PERFORMER, not just a singer. Her wonderful clothes, her expressive body language and interpretation of the songs. Her emotion is apparent in every song. She not only sings them, she acts them out. Comparing them is chalk and cheese.

    T Holopainen is the difference between N/w and a lot of bands in the genre. His song construction makes for many memorable songs on each album.

  • someone please tell me WHY people are STILL going on about Tarja and Anette?

  • @peoplesuck1995 that's easy the new people or fans that heard first annete like her more and people that heard tarja first like her more as i do so is a non ending fight it also depends on your preferences of the music u like

  • @peoplesuck1995 because they are haters...

  • @peoplesuck1995 good queston, it may be because some people still havent get over that they did kick Tarja out of the band..

  • @Wittuilija it's more like they're in denial XD

  • ich brauch ein Autogramm!!

  • Tarja was perfect but she's gone. Nothing will change it and I think she couldn't chose better- now she's solo but even more fantastic than while she was with NW. And now Anette is "the first voice" and I'm really happy about that. Imaginaerum is incredible good, DPP was okay so I hope every next album will be better and better than previous :)

  • Thumbs up if your name is "Angel's Whispering" too!!!

  • tarja is better for nightwish and general the best singer for symphonic <333

  • Everyone says Annette is mediocore, i dont think so she sings better than medoicore, but yes i'll admit she's no match for Tarja, so everyone just shut the fuck up get over it cuz it's been nearly 5 years grow up, at LEAST Nightwish didn't break up completly

  • Just listen to this epic song and forget all this sh1ts abouts annette and tarja .

  • @Feanor2345

    Good riddance, then. If you think Tarja was all of the talent, then you're an idiot. Pop? PLEASE. It's the same style as before with slight melody changes. IF anything, it's gotten harder at points than in the past.

  • @fullmetalgod

    Anette = popish singer, who even can't sing old songs.

    New songs = more on more popish and commercial and boring.

    Btw. Nightwish songs was newer modifield to Tarja . Tuomas only wrote them and then Tarja try to sing them.

    Tarja is a classically trained singer and Tuomas do not know anything about classical singing.

  • @Feanor2345 Oh my God you are stupid!

  • @TajemnaTemnota

    O-o prove that I'm wrong instead that you are talking like idiot.

  • Best Nightwish song ever !!! Thumbs up if you agree :)

  • @Feanor2345 i totally agree with you, i only losten songs where the amazing Tarja sings, i really hate anette...she even dindnt TRYd to help Tarja

  • Annette sings better than I ever could.

    Tarja sings better than Annette or anyone else ever could.

    Simple as that. Her songs define music; Annette's singing defines empty lyrics of a band that lost something amazing.

    Songs like Ocean Soul and Ever Dream will never die.

  • @shrekfan92

    They have different approaches to singing, so it's just stupid to compare them. Want to compare R Kelly to Micheal Bolton next to see who's the better singer?

    Annette is great at the songs she's sang and I think the band has worked around her voice...so the same song sung byTarja wouldn't sound as great due to that. Same if Annette sang many of the old Nightwish songs that haven't been modified to fit her.

  • @fullmetalgod Who are R Kelly and Micheal Bolton?

    Yes, I've heard Annette sing Tarja's songs. It's...kinda sad. And I haven't seen one REAL video of Tarja singing any of Annette's songs; so I think the restyled Nightwish band is just trying to say, 'We're going to let Annette sing your songs because, well, we know she sucks.' And okay, I like some of Annette's songs; but she's just no match for Tarja.

  • 666 comments!!!

  • So I decide to listen to Nightwish. All I read is comments debating about a former vocalist. It really feels like walking into a new pub for the first time in middle of a brawl.

    Good music though.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • those who want tarja back I just have one thing to say: read once upon a nightwish, the official biography! thats all

  • I like them both but Anette seems hotter and more relaxed

  • Comment removed

  • Why the hell isn't this album on itunes?!

  • Why do i see the name of Miley Cyrus in a Nightwish song ??? Has the world gone mad ??

  • i love the the lyrics this song had to be one of her best

  • Tarja>Anette

  • *-* I like

  • WE WANT TARJA BACK!

  • annoying when the most thumbed up comment has 'justin bieber' standing somewhere in it.. you people realize your just making him more famous and more money :) quit crying

  • This song is a very sad one, it reminds me of many sad memories ,it's true that TUOMAS HOLOPAINEN's lyrics describe my life + the voice of Tarja makes it even more perfect, it's beyond the words ...what can I say; I LOVE THE OLD NIGHTWISH!! <3

  • Comment removed

  • Did they ever play this live? I can't find a video of it >.>

  • @teharbiterpwns No they didn't. In one of the live dvds, Tuomas stated he wouldn't.

  • DON'T READ THIS. You will get kissed by Spaghetti-O's and the people will try to recreate communist chickens. I eat people for dessert and your love of potato chips will make the world defecate on planet Sparta. Pringles are funny and you can leave my store if you so desire. Now you have the right to remain silent. Any thing you say can and will be used against you in my pencil-covered sandwich.

    Copy and paste this to 10 other videos and everyone will think you're a fucking idiot.

  • And this is called music!!! My child.

  • the beast song in the history

    

  • I just love this song.

  • Guys can you just stop with the 'x people disliked this song because...' seriously? Its REALLY old. Don't even mentioned the dreaded JB.

  • annete songs beautifull too, tarja songs awesome also, i love both of them

  • to je delova skladba.super.super.vravim ze NIGHTWISH bez TARJI neni NAGHTWISH.a to ma nikto nepresvedci.

  • @pizzaworkout .......Okay, what? <.<

  • Miley Cyrus - Party in the USA

    WTF? Why is this crap on related videos? OMG!

    Justin Bieber made 27 fake profiles to dislike this song! ^^

  • Omfg people, stop feeding the trolls.

  • Bye lol.. Your Bat shit. dam stillflallowingme on youtube. toobad my cd's got broke.

  • hi

  • Who cares that she was fired?? Does that effect her voice? Hey! I like Miley Cyrus voice, but I don't like HER and I still listen to the music sometimes! Yes, Anette is not as good, (Though her songs is very good) and Targa is better (Her voice fits the style of Nightwish better)

    We all miss her. Yes, and people's is going to hate/dislike Anette as people hate/dislike Targa.

  • @Writerofthegods *Tarja.

  • @jutubjusa srry

  • @Writerofthegods yeah...her name isn't "targa"...ana some people just can't listen to annete's voice.

  • @LucianaPuma true and srry I messed up her name.

  • @Writerofthegods ...

    you listen to miley cyrus?

  • @videomaster098 Very few times, there is only so much of her I can stand. Her early songs before she changed, the really deep songs, I like.

  • Comment removed

  • @videomaster098 why he should not listen to miley cyrus and nightwish?

  • @dereptor XD

  • @Writerofthegods Yes. Hmm I dont like Miley voice xD.

  • @Writerofthegods To be correct, her name is Tarja :P

  • @Writerofthegods OMG Miley Cyrus.. WTF?!?

  • @Writerofthegods TARJA!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Writerofthegods It is Tarja not "Targa" if you are going to say her name at least say it right.

  • @Writerofthegods You are right about that.It was tarja's fault that she was fired.I heared that she had stolen money from the band...too bad:(.And yes, her voice is perfect for nightwish, better than anette's voice.Anette can not reach so high notes, that tarja could reach very easy....We all are going to miss Tarja.

  • @boboletzu BS.

    She never stole money from the band. The band just saw her as a diva. She never did anything criminal or morally wrong. They just clashed with her style because she liked flying with her boyfriend on a different plane and not with the band and spent more time with him than practicing. And the band eventually had problems with her attitude when she said she did not need the band and could leave at any time.

    Not criminal, just from the bands point of view a complete bitch.

  • @boboletzu No its just cause she was being a HUUUUGE Diva, and the band decided that her "divaness" would slow them down.

  • @Writerofthegods OK, no offense here - seriously - but your name is Writerofthegods and you've misspelled or mispronounced so many things.

    But your name does sound good. :)

  • @Writerofthegods I doubt anyone here dislikes Targa . Mostly because Nightwish never had a mamber named targa : D

  • @Writerofthegods Tarja wanted leave Nightwish... is not Anette fault.

    .... but I don't like the way that Nightwish take :/ Without Tarja, is not the same.

  • This is the only song Tuomas refused to do live, He said it was a very personal song to him and he just couldn't.......

  • This music is the best of it all, rock, sorta opera, a soaring and beautiful voice... not sure what anyone is complaining about.... but I sure like it....... Its strangely beautiful, almost a dreamlike rock-n-roll.. They lyrics are pure poetry.  Nightwish... more like a lovely Nightdream.... to everyone their own.

  • what the hell is everyone not agree with Anette?? It's a great singer and the song is beautiful! It is true that we all miss Tarja, but for God's sake ... and Anette is very good! NIGHTWISH good job for everything you have done, and true fans will always love you whatever happens! (sorry for my english, im romanian)

  • tarja is awesome a goddess blessed her angelic vox i love her and miss her

    we all do!

  • Losing emotion,

    Finding devotion

    Should I dress in white and search the see

    As I always wish to be

    One with the waves

    Ocean soul

  • Big like!!

  • beautiful!

  • Precious song ^^

  • 26 people ARE SICK AND DEAF!!!

  • as i have born near the see and i have see so many times the see, this song makes me melancholic

  • whenever starting a Nighwish video, you know it's "EARGASM ahead"...

  • @Dragonclaw422 the catfish. My peter still works. Its longer, now. ^_^

  • theres no lonely souls .....axel rose told the truth....everybody needs sometime on your own....jajajaja

    i knew a girl che used to say that was a lonely soul....then she became a bitch....now you open your stupid eyes. its a song.....ni sikiera un ninja puede vivir solo toda su vida.

  • aawh , How many times will I have to say... youtube , U gotta fix that "dislike" button

  • I love their music. what confuses me though is I don't quite understand what exactly an ocean soul is. anyone care to elaborate?

  • @alyssajonesforever Ocean soul is what sailors used to say about people who died at sea, its a scandinavian thing though and doent translate exactly into english x

  • @gorgreal12345 thanks. I don't like to be ignorant about things. especially my music

  • 26 people have lonely souls.

  • This song reminds me of the time I went skinny dipping and my peter got bit by a catfish. I hung it on my wall as a trophy.

  • @puregenius7112 You hung your peter on the wall as a trophy or the catfish?? Lol

  • @wsp999 no. they just don't like it.

    we kinda still live in a free world that everybody can like what they want, like or dislike what they want and they have a right to press thumbs down to a stupid comment as yours.

    not everybody likes gaga, neither nightwish. no need to be offensive about that. maybe they thinks same about you. for them, you are the stupid mothafucka :)

    stop writing stupid comments.. or now u gonna tell me "we live in a free world" where anyone can do shit like they want to?

  • @thunderxy Stop ruining our fun! We know this already!

  • @tvpnbb who are you people?

    what kind of fun is this?

  • @thunderxy It is our fun.

  • @tvpnbb yes. yours :| :))

    whatever

  • I don't like this song.

    I love it!

  • I only wished to become something beautiful...........

  • @SuperPenetration hahahah...

    Stop the pathetic and lame jokes about Justin Bieber... Their annoying and nobody wanna read about Justin Bieber in a video not related to him in any fucking way! But hey... Since guys like you keep talking about him I guess you're just some kind of trolls or justin bieber fanboys going to random videos spamming with shitty comments about him..Just doing some loud thinking... ;)

  • @Acryingtear il be honest. i posted that comment becouse i saw those types get most thumbs up, so i wanted to test it out myself ;)

  • @Acryingtear btw, u mad? :)

  • @SuperPenetration Not really... Just pretty annoying kids have to spam decent music videos with Justin Bieber comments... or comments about other ridiculous crap...

    It ruins the Youtube community when kids can't respect other peoples opinions..

  • @Acryingtear Tulip, you love Justin Bieber, just admit it!

  • @Acryingtear You win at life. Isn't the song strong enough to not have to participate in a cock contest with whichever teen idol happens to be popular at the time?

  • what a great voice and song!!!!!!

  • @wsp999

    People who don't like metal.....Don't be a ignorant douchebag

    Nightwish \m/

  • Should I dress in white and search the sea...

  • @mimmo619 yep

  • @wsp999 25

  • Nightwish is one of the best bands ever. if not the best at all...

  • ;) perfect song..nightwish 4EVEEEEEER

  • Nightwish still awesome,You guys need to grow up,If you still comparing Tarja and Anette...Nightwish is Tuomas lyrics...Sheesh...

  • @FaithfulSam If I want good lyrics, I can read a poetry book ¬¬. I want good MUSIC, I don't want a woman than sing like me.

  • @AnitaMCV you are just retarded, if a song has good lyrics and voices and the instrumental part is good too, the song is good twice.

  • @FaithfulSam Its not the lyrics people cry about, its the vocals.. Tarja's voice is amazing, and gives that opera-like feeling to it.. Anette will never become as good as Tarja..

    I'm not hating on Anette, she's a great vocalist and a great addition to Nightwish, its just my opinion that Tarja sounds better..

    Still, old Nightwish or new Nightwish... I love them both!

  • @cuber1 Well then obviously people have different views of what they find most pleasing in music. Sure I like a good voice as much as the next person. I think both Tarja and Anette have beautiful voices, but what really drives me back to Nightwish has ALWAYS been the lyrics. Nothing made me fall more in love with Nightwish than listening to Tuomas spill his soul into his music with his poetic lyrics. Both new and old, he's always carried what I found to be the true soul in Nightwish.

    my opinion

  • @FaithfulSam i agree, but when i hear nightwish now, i have to think they are another band, cuz i will think tarja and not anette

  • back when nightwish was still awesome

  • Oh my fucking god, how the fuck can you people still compare singers like Tarja to Lady Gaga or whoever! They have both have a different singing style and make different music. Get over it. To each it's own.

  • This is probably one of nightwish's best songs imo. it's underrated

  • Even though Tarja had a cold, she still sounds absolutely amazing on Century Child

  • Tarja at her best!!!

  • @wsp999 let them believe what they want....only a few people know what real music is!!:)

  • Ppl who clicked on the dislike butten trought it mean >> Dis i like

  • justin bieber sucks!!!!!

  • omg awesome song :P

    crownless is still the best song

  • 1301 ocean souls.

  • Tarja had a terrible cold recording this. You can hear it in the beginning. Actually, she was ill during the whole recording on Century child.

    Imagine, it sounds like this, and she was ill. O.o

  • Comment removed

  • @Nightwishoneandonly I've always wondered why she sounds so stuffy in the beginning. Now I know. Thanks!

  • Beautiful song by an awesome band. Keep it coming Nightwish. Even though Tarja is not with them, Nightwish still rocks.

  • Ich liebe nightwish....und liebe nightwishs fans... ^^

  • This is like the OLD Nightwish, when they were not mainstream, and filled more gigs.

  • @wsp999 Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Aesthetics is all a matter of perspective.

  • Now even 24 people are pedo-bievers, amazing! ...

  • This song is just too much, you can almost feel the sentiment of pain, guilt or whatever the song is trying to explain. And Tarja's voice oh! It tears me apart.

  • A wonderful song. pity they make no more beauties as that ...

  • Somehow so beautiful song.....

  • the beginning makes me think of lord of the rings :D

  • nightwish's videos don't deserve "dislike" button

  • @Ikrizelle1 like rap doesnt deserve the like button

  • @Ikrizelle1 THIS

  • Something so beautiful it hurts....

  • @wsp999 I can!

  • @strgaltdelete Then why even come to the song?

  • I just wonder why are people so obsessed about all those pop singers on every (EVERY!) video of some metal band?

    Is it so hard to just ignore them instead of bashing them on every comment page?

    It just shows how pathetic you are trying to get thumbs up for comments like "Bieber sucks" and "23 people like Justin Bieber".

    Two currently highest rated comments prove my point.

  • amo esta cancion

  • Let's enjoy the music!

    :)

  • You're right!!!

    I really love this song

  • omg tARJAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA...­.. come back :( , we love you....

  • fuck justin bieber!

    fuck jhonas brothers!

    fuck hanna montana and fuck all disney´s shitti bands!

  • @federom18 please my good friend, do not ruin our songs with detestable memories of bad singers please. just relax and enjoy the music, let the music wash over you and be calm..

  • @SilverSteam1 ok.

  • @SilverSteam1 Amen, brother!!!

  • thank you Tuomas for this wonderful music... <3

  • @wsp999 stfu about justin bieber we get the picture enjoy the fucking song and stop talking abot him

    im sick of seeing his name on ever music vid

    its getting boring

  • @wsp999 I m Nightwish fan , I loveeeeee this song so so much ..... but i think everyone sholdn't say like this about Justin . he is just a normal singer

  • Want real music? Tired of that thing that is called music nowadays? Look no further, here's Nightwish! The band that makes up for all the musical mishaps of today!

  • Voted down both most rated comments.

    Comment the damn music and don't compare it with shit. Period.

  • This song is soooo beautiful...sooo beautiful...I even cant believe that in this world we still have this wonderful music....Thank you Tuomas(and the rest of Nightwish )

  • I love this one! Nightwish with Tarja Rules!

  • Nightwish is the best:):):)