you do realize you can opt out of capitalism right? You can just quit your job, buy land and collective it, if a mass of people do that capitalism collapses.
@XBloodyRevolutionX not necessarily. true communism is a type of anarchy but anarchy is not a type of communism. the only prerequisite for an anarchist society is an abolition of authority. it can be as individualist or collectivist as the people want it to be.
I'm an spanish anarchoindividualist and the spanish civil war was probably the most horrible event in our entire history, where fascists, communists, anarchosyndicalists, republicans and lots of other political groups destroyed the country. The spanish civil war was no fight for ideologies but a fight that probed the extent of human savagery. The fascist killed a lot of people, but the exact same was done by the communists and the anarchists. En vez de decir NO PASARÁN, decid NO VOLVERÁ A PASAR.
@vudu8ball You really don't have an idea of what the Spanish Civil was. The war was not a fight for ideas, but I fight that portrayed the decadence of humanity. Stay with your socialistic ideals but trust me when I say that there weren't many differences between the fascists and the socialists in the war. It is nonsense and even offensive to say that this war was a high point in human history.
mmm now every time a I talk to a young right wing Neo Con American who says he is an Anarchist or a Libertarian I will direct him to this video. Great video Guys
Hacabo de terminar el libro the Orwell Homenaje a Catalonia ... Que hijos de putas son los Bolshevik Y las demas democracias de el mundo que se quedaron con el dedo en el culo .
Good for you, skinhead. By the way, using caps isn't going to help you prove your "point". Anyway, Anarchy doesn't promote nor does it associate itself Destruction and Violence. You need to get an education.
Are you capable of independent thought? Or even capable of forming a complete sentence? Your grammar skills are atrocious. Honestly, you sound like a doll with a pull-string. You only say about 5 phrases of bullshit.
Is that all you can come up with? Go Die? Could sink any lower? Or get any more immature? You're pretty small-minded, even for a skinhead. Wow, you really do need to learn how to think independently.
That's because you're under-educated, small-minded and, in short, an imbecile. You fail as a troll and a human being. You might want to start making efforts in improving your life and stop being so narcissistic.
@MovieMagicMaster Oh, you're probably right, unfortunately - I think I just sorta have to assume many people are trolls rather than idiots in order to continue to hold faith in our species....
@7Averroes7 I don't know why you say that it wouldn't work, Barcelona was managed by a anarchist comitee between 1936-1939 and it even increased our productivity and improved the life of the workers of course the government and all the newspaper or magazines managed by rich people wouldn't say the same.
By the way, there are some Durruti images on the video, if we had anyone like him that could reorganize the fight may be we could have a chance...
@Davidfaca94 your facts are absolutely right! Anarchism in Spain was a great success until the loss of Durruti (RIP) and the combined threat from francos fascist beasts and Stalins lackeys e.g.Orlov
"The State is a condition, a certain relationship between human beings, a mode of behaviour; we destroy it by contracting other relationships, by behaving differently toward one another… We are the State and we shall continue to be the State until we have created the institutions that form a real community."
What the people organized in Spain in 1936 was truly amazing. It is the clearest example of the effectiveness of an anarchist system, though it was a sadly short lived experience. I can only imagine the terror that swept over Spain with their defeat. I feel for the 716 of my own Canadian brothers and sisters who died fighting for this cause.
@TheSage555 Yes, it was great, even money was abolished in Cataluña and Aragón. The anarchosyndicalist system was so good that if anyone was caught using money, they would be shot in the head. Wow, now it doesn't sound that anarchist LOL.
great! absolutely overwhelming! :-D thanks to comrades franco and salazar the perverted ideology of communism (communism!!! ha ha ha ....) could be succesfully kept out of the peninsula. all decent people and true spanish patriots will be indebted forever.
Belíssimo! 1936 renasce em todo o mundo, desde a Grécia até Tailândia, e logo em toda parte! E que tenha um final diferente do que ocorreu na Espanha! Comunismo libertário! Revolução social!
Interested in the Lincoln Brigade? Consider attending the 74th Volunteers for Liberty Reunion in NY May 2 and meet Matti Mattson and Amy Goodman of Democracy Now! Bruce Barthol performs songs of the Spanish Civil War. Google Abraham Lincoln Brigade Archive for more info
@WVliberty....the state is not necessary as workers can organize horizontally as opposed to hierarchically. A state is not an abstract entity it is the oppression of the minority (ruling elite) over the majority (workers). Those rulers whether political party or (more often in USA) corporations will never allow the freedom of the proletariat in place of the importance of capital (profiteering). But you and I are still on the same side!!
the rich no matter if there conservative or liberal are always screwing the working man, my people had the largest labour uprising in US history, The Battle of Blair Mountain, I'd hope one day we'll do it again, The rich ruling class must be crushed!
@ryamnesty You know, I'm not as idealist as to imagine Anarchy could work but I completely agree about us being like little ants in the hands of a few thieves who handle political and economic power. Their point is just proffit and power. They achieve this almost always at the expense of humans', citizens' and nature's health, rights and well being or even lifes. You can call them watever names or political parties, they are a bunch of Vampires who like any kind of present or future blood.
@ryamnesty Why don't we start by having some control over what is going on, having all decisions from government, parliaments, city halls, public institutions, etc. placed for free access on the internet. As well as all the expenses related with those decisions, and the taxes declarations of all rulers.
@ryamnesty Magnificent & speaks truth with its ideals in tow
Absolutely, the Anarcho-Syndicalist/Lib-Com & C. can/does work; I'd say the point no one dares understand is that "the State" is reborn as the ppls cooperative, which is the closest to pure liberty ever conceived for a society, which is why it was&IS the biggest threat to All three "others," like the lie of my USA - Fascist/Corporatist reality disguised in symbols that mean so much to ppl keep the spirit the System forever subverts
@ryamnesty oh I did want to add: "the proletariat" doesn't really exist as it was originally defined as the Iron Fist & the Masses under its yoke have both evolved and adapted to a world more stratified than "the proletariat" as a mass industrial working class, esp in Post-industrial States. The "State" we agree is still the Anti-Liberty machine with a new hat; the S-Q model (esp my US) is the "we all pretend that we are 'free'" while the "free market" is 2days face on the same 'ole enslavement
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song as well as the propaganda quality of the "republican" side, explains why Franco won the war. You are really not serious people politicaly speaking.
Yes, the people who stood up to superior military forces on several different fronts, for three years, were not at all "serious" with their intentions. The Soviet Union undermining the revolution certainly didn't have anything to do with their defeat. Neither did the fact that Franco had support from Nazi Germany, as well as from Italy.
You can criticize when you have an idea what you're talking about, but until then, I'd suggest you go read a fucking book.
For anyone interested in the role of anarchists and communists in Spain during the revolution,
I had a discussion with touaregk in the comments section about 2 months ago if anyone wishes to see them. I referenced various historians such as Bolloten, Thomas and Fraiser. Some of my posts may look out of order because I mostly replied to my posts.
For more information about Libertarianism (ie. anarchism) in general please see: anarchistFAQ[dot]org
I'm not sure what you mean. What is your definition of government? The libertarian definition of government is power over a given area controlled by a minority in a top down manner.
As Kropotkin states:
The state is: "...the instrument for establishing monopolies in favour of the ruling minorities..."
libertarians are more or less the rediscovery of everything the american founding fathers talked about and where they derived it from. they are not anarchists... they beleive in government, but that gov is evil and should be minimalized as much as possible... they do not beleive in the destrustion of the state
Ok. I think I know what you are talking about. Are you talking about the Capitalist minimal statists who started through unintentional co-incidence in the '1970's' to call themselves 'Libertarians'?
Here's a bit of history of where I am using Libertarian from. Libertarian was first used in the anarchist journal La Libertaire, Journal du Mouvement Social. It was published in New York between 1858 and 1861 by French Anarchist Joseph Dejacque.
Joseph Dejacque used the term Libertarian as he preferred it over the term Anarchy I believe. The CNT started using the term in the 1930's. The market socialist Tucker used in it in America in 1897 in his journal Liberty, no. 350 pp 5. Ofcourse they also use the term Libertarian Communist in the song above. So the original meaning of the term has been used since the 1850's to mean a free society with equality of opportunity. In other words another term for the same theory (Anarchism)
the CNT can say whatever the hell it wants. Libertarians are NOT anarchists... Libertarians are capitalists... 'Libertarian socialism', which is an oxymoron, is closer, but its still an oxymoron
"the CNT can say whatever the hell it wants. Libertarians are NOT anarchists... Libertarians are capitalists..."
Have it your way. However, the term Libertarian has been used around 130 years before the Capitalists incorrectly tried to use it. Someone would have to willfully or unintentionally ignore history in order to continue to use 'Libertarian' to mean minimal state Capitalism.
Are you saying all those people in the CNT using it are wrong and your right despite all?
Its either the 1971 'Libertarian' Party, or the many people in Europe and America and elsewhere who called themselves Libertarians since the 1850's. Which came first?
I think it would have been good if Nolan and other founders of the so-called 'Libertarian' Party had known about history and the history of the term they choose to describe their party. It would have avoided this confusion.
That said, I do respect Nolan and his associates for their pro- freedom of speech ect.
Actually the term Libertarian that I am using and has been used in America and Europe ect. since 1850's refers to a free society that is only economically socialist (whether free market socialist, regulated market socialist, collectivist or gift economy)
The anarchistFAQ(dot)org goes into more detail about how it would work free from the state.
But I could also tell you here if your interested.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ya'll are pretty stubborn... i already said the libertarians are deifned as beleivers in liberty... you find liberty in marxism, i find it in capitalism... fundamentally we are both libertarians
don't bother with YouTube. Go look up the term "libertarian" in a political context. Only in America does it mean Ron Paul/lower taxes/etc etc. In the rest of the world (including Spain) if you say you're "libertarian" they will assume you are an anarchist. And I'm speaking from personal experience as well as from bothering to look it up.
you do realize you can opt out of capitalism right? You can just quit your job, buy land and collective it, if a mass of people do that capitalism collapses.
death9719 1 week ago
the name of this band is SIN DIOS. A spanish band the title is 1936
Viva la CNT
Viva el comunismo libertario.
Viva la revolución social.
Today more than ever alive anarchy
unesclavomas1 2 months ago
does anyone know the name of this band?
khoroshoorange 2 months ago
What band is this?
EmilioCasavegas 2 months ago
@EmilioCasavegas It is "Sin dios"
AnarchoPunkish 3 weeks ago
@AnarchoPunkish Very cool, I've only heard "Alerta Anifacista" by them. This song was better than that whole album.
EmilioCasavegas 3 weeks ago
Autonomy, Equality Solidarity!
Love the song can you please tell me the band and the song name please?
BloodRaven360 2 months ago
anarhisti - drugovi u ratu za komunizam u Španjolskoj - slava im i hvala
ogrix1 2 months ago
CNT-FAI....
7antifahooligan 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ⓐ☭ ★
666PYRIFLEYETHON666 3 months ago
Sin_Dios
Are the band!
GX
georgexander 4 months ago
this anarchist/communist conflict is pretty old and pretty useless. enough with that. greetings from turkey...
aporia82 4 months ago
Nosotros somos el Pueblo!
carlos86902 4 months ago
ANTIFA!!!!!!!!!!!! A.C.A.B for greek
ALEXPZ12 5 months ago
viva espana.. viva nuestros ermanos y ermanas. viva.. la anarquia
MrBleedingass 5 months ago
GREETINGS FROM GREECE.
FREEDOM TO THEOFILOS MAUROPOYLOS
JuggledaJungle 5 months ago
@JuggledaJungle LEFTERIA STOUS SYNTROFOUS STA KELIA -A-
SmokerVeNoM21 5 months ago
FUCK THE NAZI BASTARDS THE FILTHY COMMUNISTS THE WEALTHY CAPITALISTS .... THE SOLUTION IS REVOLUTION....Greetings From The Burning Greece -A-
SmokerVeNoM21 5 months ago 23
@SmokerVeNoM21 anarchy is basically a type of communism in case you didn't know, just thought i should let you know.
XBloodyRevolutionX 2 months ago
@XBloodyRevolutionX not necessarily. true communism is a type of anarchy but anarchy is not a type of communism. the only prerequisite for an anarchist society is an abolition of authority. it can be as individualist or collectivist as the people want it to be.
allwittynamestaken 1 month ago
Comment removed
XBloodyRevolutionX 2 months ago
@SmokerVeNoM21 Yeah, how is that workin' out for you?
Halo4Lyf 3 weeks ago
who is this playing?
Dukepapi 6 months ago
@Dukepapi
Sin Dios
Scatmanfi 6 months ago
our next battle ground is the Middle East the anarchists must fight there now
death9719 6 months ago
anarchism is the last pure product from the early enlightenment, uncompromising in its promise to freedom
Marenqo 7 months ago
I'm an spanish anarchoindividualist and the spanish civil war was probably the most horrible event in our entire history, where fascists, communists, anarchosyndicalists, republicans and lots of other political groups destroyed the country. The spanish civil war was no fight for ideologies but a fight that probed the extent of human savagery. The fascist killed a lot of people, but the exact same was done by the communists and the anarchists. En vez de decir NO PASARÁN, decid NO VOLVERÁ A PASAR.
alejandro163 7 months ago
la lucha contra el fascismo es la lucha por la libertad...contra el racismo, el sexismo, el capital e toda autoridad...ALERTA...ALERTA ANTIFASCISTA!
the fight against fascism is the fight for freedom...agains racism, sexism, the capital and all authority....ALERTA...ALERTA ANTIFASCISTA!
ozarmetallica 7 months ago
The Spanish Civil War and the Paris commune are the high points of human history so far!
vudu8ball 7 months ago 2
@vudu8ball You really don't have an idea of what the Spanish Civil was. The war was not a fight for ideas, but I fight that portrayed the decadence of humanity. Stay with your socialistic ideals but trust me when I say that there weren't many differences between the fascists and the socialists in the war. It is nonsense and even offensive to say that this war was a high point in human history.
alejandro163 7 months ago
@alejandro163 the communists who did the killing were the Stalinists not the anarchists they didn't start the fighting they just defended themselves
death9719 6 months ago
@alejandro163 you're an idiot.
jameslofton 2 months ago
@vudu8ball yes the were
death9719 6 months ago
lets hope anarchism comes of age again before we kill ourselves with capitalism
ulogisk 7 months ago
Good song too bad i don't speak Spanish but thanks for the subtitles. Bakunin would be proud.
bluevalium10 7 months ago
What's the name of this band? I dig it. I'm surprised you didn't even put it here hahaha
kwaal 9 months ago
Viva Durruti! victory to the people! Death to fascism!
swfcocs1 9 months ago
Stalin is the only one who supports the Spanish republic against Franko !
proletarcccp 9 months ago
il faut etre demeuré pour rien comprendre à ce point non ? Ce groupe ferait presque penser que c'est pas plus mal que les fachos ai gagné !
acxhetez vous des livres les anars et faite pas chier avec votre idéalisme, laissez les grands faire la révolution c'est pas pour vous !
harmandification 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR STARTED BY JEWS FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF SPANISH PEOPLE. THE jew WINS. ALL SPAIN TODAY ARE AUTONOMOUS TERRITORIES
unfukkkmee 10 months ago
date un occhiata a questo spaces: su google TANA ROSSA
kamapao 11 months ago
Solidarity!
LibPornQuig 11 months ago
Palestine? No thanks.
tazpi 11 months ago
Thanks for translation, great lyric! The People will be free One Day!
SmashThaNaziscum 11 months ago
Socialism will be victorious eventually.Don`t have any doubts
andjelko2ooo 11 months ago 10
@andjelko2ooo
doubts can sharpen your mind but they can also destroy and haunt you.
i just hope that the people will wake up before its too late.
Libertad Comrades!
khoroshoorange 2 months ago
@andjelko2ooo I'll burn the world to a cinder before I let you assholes run things.
Halo4Lyf 3 weeks ago
@Halo4Lyf You have already burned the world with your capitalist rule, but don't worry, enjoy in what ever time you have left
andjelko2ooo 3 weeks ago
I love this song!
CNT! FAI!
DirEnGrey363 1 year ago 2
mmm now every time a I talk to a young right wing Neo Con American who says he is an Anarchist or a Libertarian I will direct him to this video. Great video Guys
franks2732 1 year ago
Hacabo de terminar el libro the Orwell Homenaje a Catalonia ... Que hijos de putas son los Bolshevik Y las demas democracias de el mundo que se quedaron con el dedo en el culo .
N0g0dzN0masterz 1 year ago
It'd be awesome if someone could find guitar tabs for this, I love the guitar in this song and need to learn it, even if it's a Spanish song.
Mabuza14 1 year ago 3
long live the FAI and the CNT ! Anarchy!
ravenargentina 1 year ago 3
SPAIN ARE FULL WITH ANARCHO-FASCISTS
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Actually, Fascism is the opposite of Anarchism. You might want to try using words you actually understand next time.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster LEARN WHAT MEANS THE WORD FASCISM
THE ANARCHY IS PURE FASCISM
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Wrong again troll.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Aren't you the uneducated chimp. Fascism is a form Totalitarianism. In other words, the exact opposite of Anarchy.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster THE DESTRUCTION IS FASCISM THE VIOLENCE FOR ONE IDEOLOGY IS FASCISM
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Good for you, skinhead. By the way, using caps isn't going to help you prove your "point". Anyway, Anarchy doesn't promote nor does it associate itself Destruction and Violence. You need to get an education.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster THE ANARCHY IS DESTRUCTION AND VIOLENCE
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Wrong again zealot. (you probably don't even know what zealot is, do you?) Why don't you educate yourself and look up what Anarchy really is.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster UR TRUTH PAINER
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Are you capable of independent thought? Or even capable of forming a complete sentence? Your grammar skills are atrocious. Honestly, you sound like a doll with a pull-string. You only say about 5 phrases of bullshit.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster GO DIE
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Is that all you can come up with? Go Die? Could sink any lower? Or get any more immature? You're pretty small-minded, even for a skinhead. Wow, you really do need to learn how to think independently.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster I DONT UNDERSTAND WHAT U SAY
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
That's because you're under-educated, small-minded and, in short, an imbecile. You fail as a troll and a human being. You might want to start making efforts in improving your life and stop being so narcissistic.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster SHOW ME ONE REASON WHY I MUST KNOW ENGLISH?
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Your comments written in English dip-shit.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster I DONT KNOW GOOD ENGLISH
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
That's obvious. You should make an effort to make yourself smarter.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster UR FILM IS INSERT
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Your grammar is terrible
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster GIVE ME GRAMMAR
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
You cannot just be simply given grammar. You must learn it for yourself.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster DONT WORRY
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Then get started.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster BACK OFF
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@unfukkkmee
Now you're trying to act tougher than you really are over the internet? Pathetic.
MovieMagicMaster 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster .I.
unfukkkmee 1 year ago
@MovieMagicMaster I'm pretty sure this dude's just trolling, I mean look at what he's writing hahaha
Few are truly that stupid.
kwaal 9 months ago
@kwaal
I think it may be more than a few...XD
MovieMagicMaster 9 months ago
@MovieMagicMaster Oh, you're probably right, unfortunately - I think I just sorta have to assume many people are trolls rather than idiots in order to continue to hold faith in our species....
kwaal 9 months ago
@kwaal
*nods* I agree.
MovieMagicMaster 9 months ago
tremenda la cansion!
N0g0dzN0masterz 1 year ago
@7Averroes7 I don't know why you say that it wouldn't work, Barcelona was managed by a anarchist comitee between 1936-1939 and it even increased our productivity and improved the life of the workers of course the government and all the newspaper or magazines managed by rich people wouldn't say the same.
By the way, there are some Durruti images on the video, if we had anyone like him that could reorganize the fight may be we could have a chance...
¡Viva la revolucion libertaria camaradas!
Davidfaca94 1 year ago 2
@Davidfaca94 your facts are absolutely right! Anarchism in Spain was a great success until the loss of Durruti (RIP) and the combined threat from francos fascist beasts and Stalins lackeys e.g.Orlov
viva Durruti !
viva CNT/FAI !
"we carry a new world, here in our hearts"
viva comrade! greetings from England!!
swfcocs1 1 year ago 2
thanks 4 the translation Viva la Revolucion!
mgs1234567890 1 year ago
"The State is a condition, a certain relationship between human beings, a mode of behaviour; we destroy it by contracting other relationships, by behaving differently toward one another… We are the State and we shall continue to be the State until we have created the institutions that form a real community."
— Gustav Landauer
JapeUK 1 year ago
That form of government has been tried a lot. Fails every time. Sorry mate.
butch356 1 year ago
No passaran, hermanos!
pugovichnick 1 year ago
what about Trotskyist Revisionism ?
workergirls 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
These people are MASSIVE supporters of the State. They are Socialists!
Everything should be Voluntary, the EXACT opposite of Communism/Fascism.
qwertypoiu4321 1 year ago
Do you know the name of this song and where could I get it's lyrics in spanish?
Slipknotter8 1 year ago
@Slipknotter8
sind dios - 1936
for lyrics use google
greetz
53N53L355 1 year ago
@53N53L355 Thank you so much. Cheers.
Slipknotter8 1 year ago
Comment removed
Slipknotter8 1 year ago
LONG LIVE THE PEOPLE'S REVOLUTION!!
1Mafioso4 1 year ago
What the people organized in Spain in 1936 was truly amazing. It is the clearest example of the effectiveness of an anarchist system, though it was a sadly short lived experience. I can only imagine the terror that swept over Spain with their defeat. I feel for the 716 of my own Canadian brothers and sisters who died fighting for this cause.
TheSage555 1 year ago 43
@TheSage555 Yes, it was great, even money was abolished in Cataluña and Aragón. The anarchosyndicalist system was so good that if anyone was caught using money, they would be shot in the head. Wow, now it doesn't sound that anarchist LOL.
alejandro163 7 months ago
@alejandro163 no you just couldn't use money it didn't work like if i tried to buy comics with leaves
death9719 6 months ago
Awesome:-)
(A)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
fuck ya!!!!
Lowerclassboards 1 year ago
fuck ya.
Lowerclassboards 1 year ago
great! absolutely overwhelming! :-D thanks to comrades franco and salazar the perverted ideology of communism (communism!!! ha ha ha ....) could be succesfully kept out of the peninsula. all decent people and true spanish patriots will be indebted forever.
SmokingKoala 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Viva la revolucion!
alwayssmilinggirl 1 year ago
We want Durruti and Ascaso back , we want the CNT of 1936 back... viva la revolution! viva la FAI
Antreaccc 1 year ago
Belíssimo! 1936 renasce em todo o mundo, desde a Grécia até Tailândia, e logo em toda parte! E que tenha um final diferente do que ocorreu na Espanha! Comunismo libertário! Revolução social!
piolhento 1 year ago
greetings from greece anarchy or death!!!!!!
EFKILIO 1 year ago
ANTIFA!
spike6819 1 year ago 22
anarchists don't play LES PAULS...they play Telecasters or bashed-up Burns or even cheap 1969 Japanese exports.
PoireauMan68 1 year ago
@PoireauMan68 They play what they can get their hands on!
CinnAlla 1 year ago
Gracias, compa?ero, por traducir esto, hasta la vicoria!
carzymike 1 year ago
Interested in the Lincoln Brigade? Consider attending the 74th Volunteers for Liberty Reunion in NY May 2 and meet Matti Mattson and Amy Goodman of Democracy Now! Bruce Barthol performs songs of the Spanish Civil War. Google Abraham Lincoln Brigade Archive for more info
Glamourbrain 1 year ago
Hmm...and look what your chum Stalin and his mates did to you lot.You never learn,do you?
jasincl 1 year ago
la anarquia es inviable, majos
aracy54 1 year ago
@aracy54 sin embargo financiar a los bancos cuando estos se hunden, para mantener el bluque de privilegiados si lo es.
KikinBcN 1 year ago
...!
dussokagi368 1 year ago
what's the name of the song?
tsaras4ever 1 year ago
@tsaras4ever it's by a band from spain calleds sin dios; and it's called "1936."
Mennismervice 1 year ago
@Mennismervice thnx
tsaras4ever 1 year ago
hola.
What is the name of the performing band in this vide please?
thanks.
stralsundpatriot 1 year ago
At first, say to you that is a great job to translate this, cause I am spanish and it's difficult even to me to understand some parts.
One question, what's the name of the group?
jabostayla92 1 year ago 12
@jabostayla92
Sin Dios
mr1001nights 1 year ago 3
@mr1001nights Thanks a lot!
jabostayla92 1 year ago
@mr1001nights
and teh name of te song is..?
squattersounds 11 months ago
WORK UNION, LIVE BETTER!!!
MPArmstrong84 1 year ago 4
Fucking nice video mate! Viva la CNT/FAI! No Pasaran!
Scatmanfi 1 year ago 50
@Scatmanfi Pasaron
kehizman 1 year ago
@kehizman jajajaajajaj
elmaximoexponenteeee 1 year ago
Bad ass vid
sysoflambofgod 1 year ago
THis is a great song.
@WVliberty....the state is not necessary as workers can organize horizontally as opposed to hierarchically. A state is not an abstract entity it is the oppression of the minority (ruling elite) over the majority (workers). Those rulers whether political party or (more often in USA) corporations will never allow the freedom of the proletariat in place of the importance of capital (profiteering). But you and I are still on the same side!!
Viva l'Anarquia siempre
ryamnesty 1 year ago 39
the rich no matter if there conservative or liberal are always screwing the working man, my people had the largest labour uprising in US history, The Battle of Blair Mountain, I'd hope one day we'll do it again, The rich ruling class must be crushed!
WVliberty 1 year ago 4
@ryamnesty You know, I'm not as idealist as to imagine Anarchy could work but I completely agree about us being like little ants in the hands of a few thieves who handle political and economic power. Their point is just proffit and power. They achieve this almost always at the expense of humans', citizens' and nature's health, rights and well being or even lifes. You can call them watever names or political parties, they are a bunch of Vampires who like any kind of present or future blood.
7Averroes7 1 year ago
@ryamnesty Why don't we start by having some control over what is going on, having all decisions from government, parliaments, city halls, public institutions, etc. placed for free access on the internet. As well as all the expenses related with those decisions, and the taxes declarations of all rulers.
7Averroes7 1 year ago
@ryamnesty Magnificent & speaks truth with its ideals in tow
Absolutely, the Anarcho-Syndicalist/Lib-Com & C. can/does work; I'd say the point no one dares understand is that "the State" is reborn as the ppls cooperative, which is the closest to pure liberty ever conceived for a society, which is why it was&IS the biggest threat to All three "others," like the lie of my USA - Fascist/Corporatist reality disguised in symbols that mean so much to ppl keep the spirit the System forever subverts
AnomicDeadDisciple 11 months ago
@ryamnesty oh I did want to add: "the proletariat" doesn't really exist as it was originally defined as the Iron Fist & the Masses under its yoke have both evolved and adapted to a world more stratified than "the proletariat" as a mass industrial working class, esp in Post-industrial States. The "State" we agree is still the Anti-Liberty machine with a new hat; the S-Q model (esp my US) is the "we all pretend that we are 'free'" while the "free market" is 2days face on the same 'ole enslavement
AnomicDeadDisciple 11 months ago
You can discuss the many-we must look and listen!
oregontaxdebtrelief 1 year ago
Progressive really means Communist just ask Sen Bernie Sanders from Vermont AKA the former Socialist Mayor of Burlington Vt.
dwodno 2 years ago
Nazis & Stalinists feared the revolution because it could give the people everything they longed for....
AntifaKelly 2 years ago 3
(A) viva anarcismo! (///)
Skinhead77Oi69 2 years ago 5
who play this song??? in pm plz
MrJenich 2 years ago
@MrJenich
Sin Dios. It's called "1936".
SLCThunk 2 years ago
What's the name of the band?
norgel77 2 years ago
Sin Dios.
PunkSkaOi 2 years ago
@PunkSkaOi : thanks, they are great!
norgel77 2 years ago
Awesomesauce.
Cutlesnap 2 years ago
DESDE CAMPANA ARGENTINA .SALUD
makisarg 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song as well as the propaganda quality of the "republican" side, explains why Franco won the war. You are really not serious people politicaly speaking.
barkohba 2 years ago
@barkohba the liberty of poverty
Evthedrunk 2 years ago
Yes, the people who stood up to superior military forces on several different fronts, for three years, were not at all "serious" with their intentions. The Soviet Union undermining the revolution certainly didn't have anything to do with their defeat. Neither did the fact that Franco had support from Nazi Germany, as well as from Italy.
You can criticize when you have an idea what you're talking about, but until then, I'd suggest you go read a fucking book.
PunkSkaOi 2 years ago
GOOD PIC THINKS DUDE
leo994life 2 years ago
just come across this glad to know its not just me and a few mates who think like this we will win cus we must win
Evthedrunk 2 years ago 2
GRAN TEMA
PAGENSIO 2 years ago
nice job, thanx
no gods, no masters
kebetanus 2 years ago 4
I still search the name of the group and also of the song... can anybody help me?
RoteZecke 2 years ago
group: sin dios
song: 1936
bakunin888 2 years ago 2
thanks a lot :-)
RoteZecke 2 years ago
Hello,
For anyone interested in the role of anarchists and communists in Spain during the revolution,
I had a discussion with touaregk in the comments section about 2 months ago if anyone wishes to see them. I referenced various historians such as Bolloten, Thomas and Fraiser. Some of my posts may look out of order because I mostly replied to my posts.
For more information about Libertarianism (ie. anarchism) in general please see: anarchistFAQ[dot]org
Thank you for your time,
Nick
Libertad450 2 years ago
libertarians beleive in government... just a gov beaten and tied up in the basement.
msiterE 2 years ago
Hello,
I'm not sure what you mean. What is your definition of government? The libertarian definition of government is power over a given area controlled by a minority in a top down manner.
As Kropotkin states:
The state is: "...the instrument for establishing monopolies in favour of the ruling minorities..."
Kropotkin, Peter. Anarchism. Encyclopedia Britannica. 1910
Best to you,
Libertad450
Libertad450 2 years ago
libertarians are more or less the rediscovery of everything the american founding fathers talked about and where they derived it from. they are not anarchists... they beleive in government, but that gov is evil and should be minimalized as much as possible... they do not beleive in the destrustion of the state
msiterE 2 years ago
Hello,
Ok. I think I know what you are talking about. Are you talking about the Capitalist minimal statists who started through unintentional co-incidence in the '1970's' to call themselves 'Libertarians'?
Here's a bit of history of where I am using Libertarian from. Libertarian was first used in the anarchist journal La Libertaire, Journal du Mouvement Social. It was published in New York between 1858 and 1861 by French Anarchist Joseph Dejacque.
Libertad450 2 years ago
Joseph Dejacque used the term Libertarian as he preferred it over the term Anarchy I believe. The CNT started using the term in the 1930's. The market socialist Tucker used in it in America in 1897 in his journal Liberty, no. 350 pp 5. Ofcourse they also use the term Libertarian Communist in the song above. So the original meaning of the term has been used since the 1850's to mean a free society with equality of opportunity. In other words another term for the same theory (Anarchism)
Best,
L
Libertad450 2 years ago
Hello,
"The CNT started using the term in the 1930's"
My mistake, the CNT used the term Libertarian before the 1930's as well ofcourse.
Best to you,
Libertad450
Libertad450 2 years ago
BTW, here is the source where I got my information from about the history of the term Libertarian if anyone is interested:
AFAQ Blog. 150 Years of Libertarian. Anarchist Writers: AFAQs Blog (12/11/2008)
Thank you for your time,
Libertad450
Libertad450 2 years ago
the CNT can say whatever the hell it wants. Libertarians are NOT anarchists... Libertarians are capitalists... 'Libertarian socialism', which is an oxymoron, is closer, but its still an oxymoron
msiterE 2 years ago
"the CNT can say whatever the hell it wants. Libertarians are NOT anarchists... Libertarians are capitalists..."
Have it your way. However, the term Libertarian has been used around 130 years before the Capitalists incorrectly tried to use it. Someone would have to willfully or unintentionally ignore history in order to continue to use 'Libertarian' to mean minimal state Capitalism.
Are you saying all those people in the CNT using it are wrong and your right despite all?
Best to you,
L
Libertad450 2 years ago 3
unless the Libertarian party has no idea what its own name means
msiterE 2 years ago
Well,
Its either the 1971 'Libertarian' Party, or the many people in Europe and America and elsewhere who called themselves Libertarians since the 1850's. Which came first?
I think it would have been good if Nolan and other founders of the so-called 'Libertarian' Party had known about history and the history of the term they choose to describe their party. It would have avoided this confusion.
That said, I do respect Nolan and his associates for their pro- freedom of speech ect.
Best,
L
Libertad450 2 years ago
Libertarians beleive in liberty... capitalism and socialism are more secondary issues... but still never met a socialist one before
msiterE 2 years ago
Hi,
Actually the term Libertarian that I am using and has been used in America and Europe ect. since 1850's refers to a free society that is only economically socialist (whether free market socialist, regulated market socialist, collectivist or gift economy)
The anarchistFAQ(dot)org goes into more detail about how it would work free from the state.
But I could also tell you here if your interested.
I hope you are well.
Best wishes,
Libertad450
Libertad450 2 years ago
@msiterE correct- they haven't a clue what they're talking about, with regard to this and much else
Tharg1UK 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ya'll are pretty stubborn... i already said the libertarians are deifned as beleivers in liberty... you find liberty in marxism, i find it in capitalism... fundamentally we are both libertarians
msiterE 2 years ago
maybe you mean "libertarianism". The libertarianism is capitalist. The libertarian is socialist / anarchist.
Reyludd 2 years ago
a libertarian is a beleiver in libertarianism.... much like a facsist beleives in facsism... thats an asinine statement
msiterE 2 years ago
@msiterE
don't bother with YouTube. Go look up the term "libertarian" in a political context. Only in America does it mean Ron Paul/lower taxes/etc etc. In the rest of the world (including Spain) if you say you're "libertarian" they will assume you are an anarchist. And I'm speaking from personal experience as well as from bothering to look it up.
SLCThunk 2 years ago 5