Added: 3 years ago
From: jennofnovella
Views: 31,884
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (50)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Quoting Corgan when he first heard Teen Spirit in Butch Vig's home: "This is going to change music forever". Actually man, I really don't care. I said that just to tease. The thing is, I prefer Nirvana. When I listen to them I never get bored. The same doesn't happen when I ear SP, and they are very good. But, you know, that's just a matter of personal taste.

  • both amazing, shut the FUCK up bye

  • nirvana were a great band but SP are on a much different level

  • @troglodyto True. Nirvana is up there and SP is in the middle section.

  • @primaryspiral i don't feel the same way. nirvana get a lot of hype just because of their attitude and some "movement" they were supposedly part of, and kurt cobain's suicide. but musically, SP was a lot better.

  • they were both great but pumpkins were alot more diverse wish the 90s would come back and save us from the crap we got now

  • He stillllll dresses like a goth??? dude, please grow some hair and act like a fuckin baddass now.

  • pumpkins are a sick band but nirvana are on much different level

  • Billy Corgan is Megamind!!! Love his music!

  • @7kole4 i aprreciate your opinion but i have to disagree i think kurt was alot better than he let on, it was cool to play badly at the time. but to say he was better than corgan is a bit silly. i love guitarists that are different and odd but cobain isnt one of them. check out pixies and sonic youth if you wanna hear where kurt stole riffs from. kurt even admitted that most of his songs were ripped off from those bands.

  • @kilja11 Agreed. Kurt was a lot better than thought to be or that he let people see up front. Then again, there were a lot of mysterious things about Kurt weren't there? As for Billy, he's my hero who's also my ex-hero of the gen X revolution/repulsion. I feel sad when I see him now, kind of like the kid who got beat up all the time in the school yard and then you see them when they're 30 and they're no better off than they were then....

  • @kilja11 Those bits of "admittance" were of low self-esteem, sort of a defensive move so that no one could really accuse him of stealing riffs. That said, Bleach and "Radio Friendly Unit Shifter" off of In Utero proved to me that Cobain had a knack for playing guitar, only problem is that his addiction was seriously hindering his ability. Playing guitar on any type of substance, really downers, is a fucking struggle and he managed to fair pretty well, considering his "scratch and mute" style.

  • @Nintendorks12345 "low self esteem" what were you Kurt's psychiatrist or something? well jimmy chamberlin was on a lot of heroine and he played pretty fucking well. and no i haven't only heard the single i used to be a massive nirvana fan as a kid i learn't to play almost all their songs on guitar as well as the pumpkins. i think pumpkins guitar was a lot more interesting!

  • @kilja11 Good music isn't measured on guitars. I could easily judge the pumpkins based on their extensive production and the fact that they practically built their career on the same Hendrix chord, but I don't because I like their music. As for the "low self-esteem", that might not be the proper term, but yes. You don't have to be a certified genius to figure out what he was doing by admitting his "steals". He only pointed them out before anyone else could. It was pretty defensive.

  • @Nintendorks12345 no offense but i dont really care what you think, you're entitled to your opinion and i to mine. i just think nirvana are totally overrated and its sad to see people worship someone who pretty much did nothing in the grand scheme of things.

  • @kilja11 Worship? I'm being objective. People hang on to every word spoken by Billy Corgan or Eddie Vedder the same way people hung on and continue to hang on to every word Cobain said (and didn't say). It's sad to think that the idea of who is worshiped is exclusive to the "overrated band". But hey, it's all opinion, so fuck it.

  • yea courtney actually broke up with billy for kurt. so im guessing there was some mutual animosity between then

  • im pretty sure billy and kurt hated each other! probably cos kurt got so much respect even though he was a shit guitarist/songwriter compared to corgan! bring on the 14year olds onslaught.

  • @kilja11 They were actually great friends. There's a video out there somewhere of them playing twister together.

  • @kilja11 well, they had something in common. They each wrote a 'hole' album.

  • @kilja11 Kurt was a better musician that Billy, Billy is a typical good musician. Kurt was different, odd and not your typical great guitarist and musician. If you base your opinion on NIRVANA just by the "nevermind" album you must be stupid because even the members of NIRVANA didnt like that album much.

  • Comment removed

  • Yeah, Billy definitley respects Kurt. In fact the song Here is No Why is about Kurt.

  • @iamaladycanyousaveme I like Incesticide the best myself. I remember when I got it in 1992 I use to listen to it way more then Nevermind. But, I always liked Gish better than either one. Then when Siamese Dream came out I was blown away an thought it was the best. It was the first CD I ever got because I always got cassettes before that. I have just always liked The Pumpkins better than Nirvana. The only album by Nirvana I don't get sick of is Unplugged. Too bad they didn't do more of that.

  • @iamaladycanyousaveme I don't agree with that at all. I actually think that Billy was a better songwriter. Kurt's stuff was simple and I only really think Nevermind is their great album. Everything else has hits and misses. Kurt was a good singer, no doubt, but I don't like some of the ways he sang live. Just like Billy. The both sounded really good on record, but way different live. I think they were about equal in terms of singing and songwriting. But, this is a matter of opinion I guess.

  • theres a video of kurt and billy playing a game of twister with eachother,

  • @fernandothamessanlee

    I saw that! James Iha looked really uncomfortable and Krist Novoselic was half naked for some reason.

  • hahaha!!!

  • I would assume it's like this rule where you can't say anything bad about another rocker's work out loud but inside you can say how shitty it is .

  • LOL....fans are like.....HUH?....WAIT!!....WHA­T?..classic Billy. He did this with different popular songs in the 90's. Saw them 12 times for their first three albums.

  • If Billy played it as a lefty, then I could believe it.

    On the whole, both bands were great. I'm sure Billy respects Kurt's work.

  • Billy is left handed actually, just plays guitar right. Still would be awesome though.

  • @themooddisorders The funny thing about Billy is that he is left handed. I know because he signed my copy of MCIS that I have on vinyl and writes with his left hand. Even though I love Nirvana, Billy is 10 times the guitarist Kurt ever was.

  • It was all in fun!... I'm just happy to be on the radio in Indonesia right now.

  • Try being in Canada and trying to compete with fucking Nickelback.... Canadian Content Laws SUCK ASS! Look it up! Then listen to some of my stuff.....I can't advertise here apparently.....but watch a video of mine and follow the website on the screen.

  • and her ironically quit playing his fender mustang to differentiate himself from cobain....

  • Awesome

  • billy hated kurt cause they were fucking the same broad...billy has nothing but respect for cobain these days

  • no, you dipshit. billy started dating courtney love long after kurt cobains death you idiot! they didn't hate eachother, theres a video of them playing a game of twister with eachother, in fact, lol

  • @mattatat819 wrong again...billy dated courtney first

  • yes but it was not at the same time cobain was. and then, after cobains suicide they got back together for a while

  • Andrewface is right. Billy dated Courtney first

  • @andrewface HIGH FIVE!!

  • He didn't even play the whole cover... he was just messing around because he was high on cold meds lol

  • @jennofnovella I think you're right about the cold meds part. I saw them in Vegas around that time and he had a cold. It fact, he gave a tissue to a fan that wanted it and said to sell it on eBay. Funny shit. They were still great and nice to see live, even without James and D'arcy. I don't know how it's going to be without Jimmy, though, but I still love Billy.

  • Sweet thanks for uploading, not a bad cover but not the whole thing either

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more