Added: 3 years ago
From: themarinersrevenge
Views: 625,777
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (295)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • bon iver > ed sheeran > birdy.

  • I wish I could play guitar

  • Ich: Mama, ich muss los.

    Mama: Wohin denn?

    Ich: Nur schnell 25 Leute umbringen

    Mama: Ich komme mit.

    :DD

  • Incredible song! Please check out my homage cover to it!

  • bon iver > birdy > ed sheeran

  • @Lukey21094 Bon Iver > Ed Sheeran > Birdy

  • waaayy better than birdy's cover, even though i am a big fan

  • I like Birdy's cover, I like Bon Iver's original. I like them both and I wish people would stop hating on Birdy, she has an amazing voice for her age. Why can't people appreciate that?

  • i broke up... said the wrong thing and she took it out of context... i cant believe it's over and cant believe that i'm crying at a laptop screen.

    thank you Bon Liver

  • Birdy's song version is bettter. my opinion

  • @meggandruby regardless of whether or not that is true (in my opinion, it is) be prepared for a lot of hate :p

  • love this guy

  • this song melts me.:)

  • dont know how people can say this is better than birdy?

  • love this song so much :)

  • PERFECT COVER!!! /watch?v=qwSq615yqCo&feature=g­-u-u&context=G29a90faFUAAAAAAA­AAA

  • this must be the first time i put a reaction on youtube,

    just cause the music combined with this video must be the best thing I've seen and heard for about 5 years. Thank you

  • cool voice

  • **To everyone arguing over whether Birdy or Bon Iver sing this better Listen Up! **

    First of all, this song is originally by Bon Iver, so you can't really compare the original singer with a cover, she wasn't trying to outdo the song, she just liked it and made her own version. Secondly, people stop saying that Birdy is talentless and stuff like that. Again, SHE IS NOT TRYING TO OUTDO THE REAL ARTIST!! If you don't like her version don't listen to it, I personally prefer it but it's my opinion...

  • @KarenHalberthal i compleatly agree

  • This is the first time I've ever heard the original.. I don't think I'll ever listen to the covers again.. This is beautiful!

  • @UndeadTilTheDayWeDie me too. :) it sounds so cool and modern, ever more modern than Birdy'S song

  • I did a cover of this song, check it out! :D <3

  • It's rare that I like both the original and cover versions of a song. Both seem to convey different sentiments and affect me differently. I like them equally, and Bon Iver truly deserves the Grammy

  • wow, first time i've heard bon iver. he deserves that grammy!

  • Who's 'Birdy'? I thought you guys were talking about actual birds and I doubt they can sing it better than Bon Iver. I came because I love Bon Iver, not birds. :P

  • its annoyed me that the past few days everyone has been posting these lyrics, then i found out its because the cover by "Birdy" is in the charts, and 90% of them probably haven't even heard the original. pisses my life off.

  • like this only coz u wanted 2 hear the original version of this song coz u've just heard birdy's version and hers is way betta

  • @milchsauger Then you do not deserve to have ears. My Dad lost 50% of his hearing and he is a classical clarinettist and jazz saxophonist. He likes decent music even if he can't hear it.

  • i think it's sad that Birdy's version has 15million more views and this is the original...

  • @misssophieeex yep !! but in You Tube land the mainstream always seem to "win" ..this is a great song:)

  • Chuck :)

  • It annoys me when people say this song is originally by Birdy....

  • amazing song, makes everything seem worth while and beautiful xx

  • I love this version it is so up tempo.

  • birdy's version sounds more like an original, has more emotion

  • Nice, but prefer Birdy's version soz:'(

  • Althought the song is amazing, I must say that the complet film from the footage shown is a great movie by a great artist as well: Murnau.

  • I heart this song and video.....sigh

  • is this the official music video?

  • Better Than the Birdy version xDD

  • @AliceInWonderland458 well, it is the original....

  • @AliceInWonderland458 well duh

  • I think that this version is much better :)

  • Birdy's version feels better, because it is close to my heart. But this one is really good too. c:

  • TE DEDICO ESTA CANCION SKINNY LOVE ATI NIÑO AMOR MI OLIVIER Y A TI QUETZALLI MANON MIS BENDICIONES Y ESCUCHENLA MIS NIÑOS.

  • MAGNIFICO

    LETRA INSPIRADORA A REFLEXIONAR

  • I think the difference is context. The original writer of the song only knows it's true meaning and can convey what he or she intended. When someone covers the song, they play the notes, sing the lyrics, maybe even have their own emotion to the song, but it's not the same, nor can it ever be. This is the difference between Bon Iver's original and Birdy's cover.

  • @cjthom2 Birdy's cover sucks. She probably thought "skinny love" meant "you don't really love me" so she began whining like every single girl.

  • why does it say the artist is the toxic avenger?

  • @misslindsayframe I actually really like Birdy's version because of its soulful quality, though I also really appreciate this version, which has what her version lacks. I think that they're both merit worthy but not in the same ways.

  • perfect song to reflect

  • why do u guys rip on a girl of 15 years old. sad guys u are

  • @BronzeGamer i totally agree! It's not like she's Rebecca Black or anythng, She's in a WHOLE OTHER LEAGUE to her; she has much more talent, and a much nicer voice too.

  • OMG, this is so much better than birdy's version

  • Ed sheerans version is better then birdy's one

  • And who the hell was I???

    I love this Song!

  • Birdy sung a song, Bon Iver told a story :)

  • what which version do u prefer

  • Birdy's cover of this song is so beautiful <3 :D :D

  • Birdy did a great cover of this.

  • I'm in love.

  • Jessica Simpson likes

  • Wow.

  • btw I'm going to see Bon Iver tonight in Berlin.

  • 2 weeks ago I went to a Feist concert in Berlin, Germany and there was a big screen in a background and the whole time this film was playing. some guys made a synthe-filmscore as an opening act.

  • I love Sunrise! <3

  • I love this song, and this is a nice video in the background aswell :)

  • both are cool - actually like this better than birdy. what is this movie?

  • @Steiger1 Aurora, by Murnau.

  • both are cool - actually like this better than birdy. what is this movie?

  • Noh. I still hink Birdy´s version is better.... But thats just my opinion C;

  • @xXUngeXx

    yeah but you got to give credit to bon iver for creating this song

    birdy just covered it

    my opinion is that bon iver's version is better :)

  • This is a lovely song

  • Awesome

  • This song is so appropriate for me right now. A friend of mine just left the rehab I am at today, overdosed on heroin, and is dead.

  • @jjjankman I don't know whether to vote up because I sympathize or vote down because that's an awful thing to go through. :/

  • makes me feel sad, but i love this song.

  • i really love this but birdy did also an amazing job by covering this song! she is young and talented.

  • @BonIverSUCKS ok, so first of all this isn't considered a depressed song, unless your depressed, then a lot of songs are, this type of music is expendable, it attaches to any emotion you have and makes you happy. but you know, everyone has their opinions, for you, strong ones, what music *do* you like?

  • one m0:00re time!

  • @BonIverSUCKS Did you make ten profiles just to dislike this song?

  • @10037047 no, 11, he just made another lol

  • @TechnoTranceGeek you are a fail

  • Comment removed

  • @ca666rlos actually I do; one that you're not a part of so GTFO.

  • @10037047 he made 2 more

  • @10037047 No he just meant to press like but mistakenly press dislike.. what can you say we all slip up sometimes.

  • @BonIverSUCKS Believe it or not people tend to use music as a way to cope with their problems (as if you have never done that) for you to try and insult people with your CH name as well as your comment is just down right wrong. Grow up i am not saying that you shouldn't speak your mind but somethings are just best left unsaid especially when it comes to a "depressed junkie"

  • Comment removed

  • loved the video :)

  • Seen this film with live backgrounds sounds made by the last Movie Organ in continental Europe. Amazing.

    And the song... Damn ! Bon Iver's just a God.

  • just so amazing...this song does make you think a lot

  • @pinhead739 have you heard his voice, or are you a little screwed up in the head? You realize this is his real voice, he didn't use any machines to make it better, unlike the shot you probably listen to, so autotuned it's more like a robot than a human -__-

  • Pinhead is a pinhead. Go listed to Lady Gaga

  • @pinhead739 Shut your mouth son! His voice is beautiful! It really suits this style of music!

  • @pinhead739 You, my friend, need a hearing check-up.

  • This is a beautiful sounding song, but the "skinny love" part of it is kind of annoying. What does he mean by "skinny love"? It just sounds like one of those quirky/cutesy terms make up to sound cool in the song, rather than something really soulful. Someone please explain so i can really love this song!

  • @sovrov Skinny love means their love has grown weak, Justin Vernon is a poet and would never write without meaning

  • @MegamaRay Guess you haven't read some of his interviews then ... he writes some of his lyrics by singing sounds that fit the feel of the vocal melody and finds words after that resemble the sounds

  • @ashdelete I think this might be more towards his Bon Iver album, where there are literally sounds instead of words in his songs

  • @MegamaRay It was this album he was talking about

  • @MegamaRay i think skinny love, by definition, is when two people love each other, and even though its is obvious, they are too scared to show it. anyway, i agree; he is a poet, and what a great one!

  • @FizzNews You are so damn right. 

  • @sovrov Skinny Love refers to the fact their love is wasting away- shrinking to skinny. so sad

  • @sovrov have you ever loved somebody, but after a while you realize it is not enough to keep on being together? Like on the one hand you love and feel a lot but you see that the other person doesnt need your feeling any more. It is skinny love for me :S

  • I absolutely love bon iver, justin's voice is just amazing, but as hard as i try to listen to more of his other stuff, i always get drawn back to this song. Dunno what it is about it it's just stunning... just have to sit back and appreciate...

  • I just cannot get enough of this song at the moment. It's wonderful.

  • Look up his live version on later with jools holland. You really feel the emotion!

  • I really wish Justin didn't allow some girl to cover his song with absolutely no feeling or attachment to it whatsoever.

  • I love this song, but I prefer the way Birdy sang it more because her voice is almost haunting yet angelic so it changes the song, but I love Bon Iver's version . ♥

  • @iheartemoboys41 her version is boring and weak. this is not.

  • does the guy in the video remind anyone else of Alex O'Loughlin?

  • Comment removed

  • hey i just started listening to Bon Iver, anyone have any recommendations?? :) Thanks

  • @xkidd092

    Hey, you should listen to Mick Flannery, his song Goodbye is a peach; hope you enjoy :)

  • great song, funny video !!! :D

  • i feel like people have to prefer one or the other...

    i love both version's of this song

  • Yeah as much as ppl say the original is good. Birdy beats the living shot out of this guy with her voice. She is without question a better singer

  • @flame0731 yeah her voice is great and i love her version but compared with the original it is exchangeable...nothing special....bon ivers version is hauntingly perfect <3

  • @Snoeterfatt lol like I said. I think her version is a vast improvement on his. I think her's is perfect his is maybe a 5 on a scale of 1-10 10 being the best. Just my opinion.

  • As much as I love the Birdy cover NOTHING beats the original <3

  • @Ro3ieful why, i don't get the video xx

  • all i did while watching was cry,

  • In the style of the late Ronnie Laine's The Debris. It's in hear live at the BBC if you want to hear something that supersedes this.

  • having listend to both versions, I have to say I prefer this one

  • does he sing all of birdy songs

  • @martin11161 the real question is: why does SHE sing all their songs? ^^

  • Birdy's version is also good, but this is the best. :)

  • i saw this on vampire diaries!

  • love it !!!

  • birdy's version has like 540,000 more views than this, the vampire diaries really boosted her version

  • this is the song in vampire diaries season 2 episode 21, searched for it and loooove it!! <3

  • @Ckdizon look up "skinny love by birdy" thats the girl singing itt & the actual one that played on last nights episode

  • @Ckdizon The one at the end of The Vampire Diaries was a cover of this song by Birdy.

  • vampire diaries<3

  • Brilliant. ♥

  • maybe i am ignorant or i am just to tired, but I don´t get the acquisition from the video and song.

    I often have the feeling that something is called perfect just because it is old and vintage-chic.

    But the song is epic :)

  • Perfect , just perfect

  • i cried.

  • thank you for this i loved it.i got lost in it.

  • I don't like his voice. It's too fake sounding for me.

  • LUV LUV LUV LUV LUV. I could listen to this track all day long and never tire of his voice...

  • This is wrongly titled. It should be 'PERFECTION'.

  • X-cellent video: Thank U. Love Bon Iver and this song. I know all too well about "skinny love."

  • how is the miserable murdered cover of this song in the charts and this one hasnt had anything! xx

  • The song with this footage was a great choice. I can't get the song out of my head and when I hear it I can visualize this video...thanks to whoever put these two together. Renting the movie from Netflix just because :)

  • @MatthewBrainsMoore *Birdy is a 14 yearold girl who made a cover of this song, which is in the UK charts right now. She won some UK talent show, not sure! But her real name is Jasmine, it's just her stage name which is Birdy.

  • Now I have to watch this movie because im either not smart enough to fully understand this film and song together or dont have the time at the moment to watch it a bunch of times. I can see it is beautiful though

  • beautiful video goes really well with the song! good job :)

  • there might not be a better video to fit this song.. epic!!

  • I held my breath the entire music video, felt like I was about to cry. This was absolutely amazing.

  • This video is adorable and perfect. Seeing the 6 dislikes makes me wonder if there are idiots out there who think it's funny to just go around giving a thumbs down to any video they come across...

    Seriously, GREAT job! :)

    p.s.: I LOVE the Decemberists song I'm assuming your screenname is from haha

  • Shit