ok, I have to admit, I flinched when Emmy Rossum started singing. She's not horrible, it's just really shrill especially after Patrick's smooth voice.
@lissygirl532 do you study music or something? i agree i do't have her voice, but she has sung better this song :) she's amazing...but here i don't like her
i feel like this went too fast. the piano was not the music that is what is known to be the original....makes me sad...because its a masterpiece. the whole opera.
@wernera1 Ya I noticed its a bit different, but thats Andrew lloyd Weber on the keys back there so im sure he had his reasons for changing it. so its not like it is some hack of a pianist
I think the reason she lowered the key was that it was just the piano. I mean, those high notes wouldn't sound very good with the piano live. Idk. I've only seen the movie with her in it, and of course she's not going to sound like she was on the track. I still think it's good though.
@sarahxboxbeara Sorry. I just disagreed with your thought that it was transposed down due to the accompaniment. Sorry again. I must say I admire your eclectic musical tastes.
@zt689 this isn't an opera, it's a musical. the music for it has a bit more of a romantic and operatic style, but it's still musical theatre. the most operatic piece in the show is "think of me", particularly at the end, but this song is just between two romantically involved characters hiding in the opera house.
@lineskogans25 You are right it isn't technically an opera, though it does use many operatic devices of the Romantic tradition. Particularly for the managers.
Now this is singing talent from them both. Absolutely amazing voices and wonderful chemistry. Too many artists these days can't sing live like this, or well, at all.
I appreciate Emmy for getting me into Phantom -- she was soft enough to help me fall in love with the musical initially. And she's a beautiful young actress -- good for the movie.
When you listen to just the voice, she is good. But if we are talking quality, she is really breathy. She couldn't hold it long enough to sing each line. She also is not fully relaxed through it all. So she sings some parts too soft, and looses the sound alot. Compared to Britney spears, she is great, not comparing to anyone she is good, but compared to Sarah Brightman(whom this was all made for back in the day), well she would just not do well. What ever happened to total quality?
Here's my opinion: I don't think either one of them "suck" and that's just rude to say. I think Emmy has a more "urban" sound - aka untrained, very light, kind of airy and subtle which movie goers who haven't seen Phantom would find more appealing to the ear. Sarah and others who play it on Broadway have classic, legit and thoroughly trained voices. They both have different, lovely vocal qualities, personally, I prefer the 'legit' sounding Christines but I guess it comes down to what you like!
Emmy is an amazing singer, i love and envy her voice!!!! in my opinion, she fit the roll perfectly and it wuz az if she wuz born to be Christine!!!! and if yhu dont think so, watch the movie!!! :D
So stupid that they lowered the key. They should have never had Emmy in this role. She's a good actress but she's not ready to sing this. If she had more time and training she probably would be a lot better. Her vibrato is sooo fake and the tone of her voice is sooooo dark (soft pallet is like overly raised)! Patrick is amazing though.
@Rachster86 She would be better if she could hold notes, work on not dying (not hearing the person suckin air like they are dying), and not needing to use so much vibrado. Sarah Brightman lives on through her sound from the late 80's , 90's. She has aged gracefully, but her voice is not the same. So compared to her voice now...Emmy wins sadly, but only because Sarah lost her range.
It was so sweet when she seemed nervous at 1:30 and had to start really fast and he took her hand. Maybe that's just the choreography but I thought it looked sweet like he was trying to help her.
She sounds (and looks) like freshman students in my voice program - lots of unnecessary movement and vocal instability. There are also some very strange vowel sounds happening here, some overmodification.. hmm.
Also, just a note: "Phantom of the Opera" is not opera. It is musical theater.
@elizabu I agree, but it's also I guess a way to mirror opera in a way. It's supposed to have elements of, but not really be, an opera. And you're right. She really does sound unstable. Renata Fusco...the Italian dub singer, now that is secure without giving up an innocent, young sound (which is apparently what they're going for).
Yeah, put that Andrew Lloyd Webber character to work. OMG, Christine is hot, beautiful, sexy and has a magnificent voice. Wait, is this the same Emmy as in the movie? If it is, she's much better than in the movie. I hate the movie. Just terrible. The Phantom doesn't even look scary. All he looks like is that he needed so Proactiv and that's it. Stupid rendition of the broadway. My opinion. Chill you psycho fantoms. haha : )
I thought Emmy was perfect. She kinda did mediocre in this performance. She tried too hard to make every note strong, which sucks cuz the thing I like about her voice the most is how subtle it is. Though I have to say that Andrew rushed on the piano too much. I don't know if they were trying to meet a quota but the accompaniment was way too fast. As for Sarah: like Emmy better. I don't think we can really figure out the best "Christine" because it's really all about preference.
its been 3 years sence the movie came out and im sure emmys voice is still maturing which is y she sounds so different... emmy and gerard r the best cast!!!!
I know it's almost impossible not to compare sarah brightman & emmy rossum but really it's kind of unfair to do so..
emmy was 18 when she sang this! For someone who is so young with clearly less operatic experience as sarah, she was pretty amazing.
Another thing-they were able to re-do the tracks as much as they wanted for the movie. Singing live is a whole other story for someone whose trade is not opera singer. While I think some parts could have been improved, she was pretty amazing overall
@SamSkii14 She may not be a soprano now. Her voice has developed into a lower range. But when she did the film & this, she was able to sing the required score. I also have to diasgree. (In respectful way) I think Emmy had near perfect characterization for Christine. I think she really brought the emotional essence into the story. What didn't you like about her portrayal?
I think Emmy and Patrick did a wonderful job with this iconic song! Their voices blended together so beautifully. Their portrayals of Christine & Raoul is one of my favorites!
love patrick so much!!!!!! patrick's voice is so charming, even his looks, and moves!!! waaa!! he's like a prince charming!!!!! emmy is so beautiful and talented.. so young but so excellent!!!
Sarah beats Emmy... But although Sarah possesses the most beautiful voice, there is no version as sweet and mesmerizing as Barbra's... Anyway, the three of them are definitely marvelous singers...
Emmy is good! She sings well. But Sarah Brightman is a million times better...Sarah's voice is perfect!!! There's no way to compare cuz Sarah is the best ever!!
i think what amazes me is that emmy was fairly young when she was first in Phantom. I love her though, Sarah Brightman was good, but Emmy just sounds more genuine, like she's not trying hard at all. And Patrick is amazing as always!
That's true. Emmy's better. Sarah's so operatic! Yes this is suppose to be opera but it's just difficult too appreciate her. They're both good in their own rights, I guess.
@mjgirl3 While I don't think Emmy is bad at all which is what some people claim. In fact I think she has a beautiful voice. It is untrue that Emmy has the best voice for this role. You are more then welcome to call her your favorite as that is your opinion. But it's a fact there are much more talented sopranos with trained technique that blow her away. She's actually a mezzo who had trouble sustaining many of the higher notes. Her E flat in the title song was digitally enhanced.
In the professional singing world, that mans she has a well-trained voice and that her vocal chords are relaxed enough for her to move naturally. It's a good thing.
thank you sooooo much for finally saying soemthing to those kind of judgemental ppl who say Emmy can't sing and yet i bet they can't even carry a tune
Maybe she was nervous, but I definitely don't like her performance
dayfirefly 1 week ago
OMG... he sings gracefully.....
MoreMizz 2 months ago 4
ok, I have to admit, I flinched when Emmy Rossum started singing. She's not horrible, it's just really shrill especially after Patrick's smooth voice.
pippacrawford 2 months ago 2
SO beautiful! I would give my left arm to be able to sing like her. Patrick isn't too bad either haha ;). Just lovely voices
redejb87 2 months ago
Patrick Wilson. Unf.
rebekahm07 3 months ago
he was in the movie The Alomo he played as Travis
Ghostchick100032 3 months ago
What's so wrong with her ?? I thought she was did a good job as Patrik.
Tangmo7446 3 months ago 5
@Tangmo7446 Same... :S
ToastyTheToastMan 3 days ago
patrik wilson can sing reelly good
PeaceLovePink223 4 months ago
You guys say Patrick sang better, but good lord I could never do what Emmy did right there. I think she has a stunning voice <3 beautiful!
lissygirl532 4 months ago
@lissygirl532 do you study music or something? i agree i do't have her voice, but she has sung better this song :) she's amazing...but here i don't like her
Milylily4Ever 4 months ago 2
Loved it. Patrick is such a handsome man. Love his voice. Emmy's dress is lovely.
ZaneAmadeoBloo 4 months ago 3
I thought Andrew Lloyd Weber on the piano was the best performer :D and yeah Emmy Rossum didn't sound as great as she does in the movie.
christinamoniz 4 months ago
It's incredible that Emmy Rossum can sing like that. Opera is such a hard style to sing and she nails it.
tobyluvr17 5 months ago
Patrick Wilson...you are yummy :)
hbclark63 5 months ago 7
I love Patrick Wilson! I wish he'd hold my hand!
PJWFTW 6 months ago 2
Emmy sounds like she is really pushing the words out. Patrick is smooth as can be.
shinobusora 6 months ago
are they in Japan?????!!!!
JonasLover183 6 months ago 2
i feel like this went too fast. the piano was not the music that is what is known to be the original....makes me sad...because its a masterpiece. the whole opera.
wernera1 6 months ago
@wernera1 Ya I noticed its a bit different, but thats Andrew lloyd Weber on the keys back there so im sure he had his reasons for changing it. so its not like it is some hack of a pianist
alamoaustin12 6 months ago 3
Did Patrick wear a wig for the movie or did he get his hair cut after the movie?
RacbecSkywalker 7 months ago
@RacbecSkywalker I think it was cut.
srabel11 7 months ago
@RacbecSkywalker I'm pretty sure he wore a wig. In the special features you can see a blonde Raoul wig in the background.
mymostpreciouslife 6 months ago
is she also an actress? lovely voice!!
SweetieWee 7 months ago
@SweetieWee yes thats emmy, she played cristene in the movie phantom of the opera
DarkSkysify 6 months ago
I just love it ... very well done both of you ;-)
jeabybkk2008 7 months ago
@iheartlove7 .. I know...just to remember the fans... That man is "the man"...alw :)
rickballista 7 months ago
Look ate the pianist...
rickballista 7 months ago
@rickballista thats andrew lloyd weber, he made the music for phantom of the opera
iheartlove7 7 months ago
wow patrick is amazing!
piperandleoxx4 7 months ago
Not that it really matters, but any reason why they lowered this song to C Major?
music88loverable 7 months ago 3
Pay no attention to the man playing the piano.
broadwaymusic4life 7 months ago 3
@broadwaymusic4life THE MAN???? oh no don't mind him ... only THE MAN that composed the bloody thing!!!!!! my god!
blahdiblah2010 7 months ago 2
i got the ringtone of this and it was like turn my head with talk of summertime and not raouls part i was soo mad lol i love this song go team raoul
Glitterbear5151 7 months ago
emmy is so. ridiculously. pretty.
Shmoofles 8 months ago
I think the reason she lowered the key was that it was just the piano. I mean, those high notes wouldn't sound very good with the piano live. Idk. I've only seen the movie with her in it, and of course she's not going to sound like she was on the track. I still think it's good though.
sarahxboxbeara 8 months ago
Comment removed
1AdrianR 8 months ago
@1AdrianR This isn't an english test, no one asked you for T or F.
sarahxboxbeara 8 months ago
@sarahxboxbeara Sorry. I just disagreed with your thought that it was transposed down due to the accompaniment. Sorry again. I must say I admire your eclectic musical tastes.
1AdrianR 8 months ago
@1AdrianR whatever
sarahxboxbeara 8 months ago
She was so shy, she was singing so fast. :p
AliceIsAMonster 9 months ago
dude, this is an Opera. and you are takling about a pop version is better!
zt689 9 months ago in playlist 001c - All I Ask of You
@zt689 this isn't an opera, it's a musical. the music for it has a bit more of a romantic and operatic style, but it's still musical theatre. the most operatic piece in the show is "think of me", particularly at the end, but this song is just between two romantically involved characters hiding in the opera house.
lineskogans25 9 months ago in playlist 001c - All I Ask of You 4
@lineskogans25 You are right it isn't technically an opera, though it does use many operatic devices of the Romantic tradition. Particularly for the managers.
1AdrianR 8 months ago
Comment removed
lineskogans25 9 months ago in playlist 001c - All I Ask of You
Now this is singing talent from them both. Absolutely amazing voices and wonderful chemistry. Too many artists these days can't sing live like this, or well, at all.
AllStrike90 9 months ago 2
Aww she's nervouss
erickakershner123 10 months ago 2
AMAZING!!!! HAHAHA Emmy is so tiny and dainty I'm so scared she's going to break :P
anieitaly 10 months ago
They were great although better in other versions. And I believe Emmy Rossum has been sininging opera since childhood
imrubeth 10 months ago
I appreciate Emmy for getting me into Phantom -- she was soft enough to help me fall in love with the musical initially. And she's a beautiful young actress -- good for the movie.
But Sarah Brightman is the best. It's her role.
angedemusique5 10 months ago 3
emmy is ok she did good but nowhere near to sarah shes wonderful
lovegc55 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is nervous..... but good
awwyeahme2 11 months ago
When you listen to just the voice, she is good. But if we are talking quality, she is really breathy. She couldn't hold it long enough to sing each line. She also is not fully relaxed through it all. So she sings some parts too soft, and looses the sound alot. Compared to Britney spears, she is great, not comparing to anyone she is good, but compared to Sarah Brightman(whom this was all made for back in the day), well she would just not do well. What ever happened to total quality?
eyeneed6969 11 months ago 2
emmy's the best christine in my opinion....
genliyin 11 months ago
Here's my opinion: I don't think either one of them "suck" and that's just rude to say. I think Emmy has a more "urban" sound - aka untrained, very light, kind of airy and subtle which movie goers who haven't seen Phantom would find more appealing to the ear. Sarah and others who play it on Broadway have classic, legit and thoroughly trained voices. They both have different, lovely vocal qualities, personally, I prefer the 'legit' sounding Christines but I guess it comes down to what you like!
JWeb4U 11 months ago
Emmy is an amazing singer, i love and envy her voice!!!! in my opinion, she fit the roll perfectly and it wuz az if she wuz born to be Christine!!!! and if yhu dont think so, watch the movie!!! :D
GothicAngel13100 11 months ago 2
So stupid that they lowered the key. They should have never had Emmy in this role. She's a good actress but she's not ready to sing this. If she had more time and training she probably would be a lot better. Her vibrato is sooo fake and the tone of her voice is sooooo dark (soft pallet is like overly raised)! Patrick is amazing though.
Rachster86 11 months ago
@Rachster86 She would be better if she could hold notes, work on not dying (not hearing the person suckin air like they are dying), and not needing to use so much vibrado. Sarah Brightman lives on through her sound from the late 80's , 90's. She has aged gracefully, but her voice is not the same. So compared to her voice now...Emmy wins sadly, but only because Sarah lost her range.
Sarah Brightman Forever
eyeneed6969 11 months ago
How Patrik hits that big note at the end is beyond me!
Alexh0508 1 year ago
Emmy is CLEARLY not professionaly trained, her breath support sucks.
Tabby4684 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
ADGuvetis 1 year ago
Nothing is more beautiful than Andrew himself playing this on the piano...gorgeous.
musicalchix 1 year ago
They look like they make a cute couple. :)
CDF90622 1 year ago
patrick wilson blows me away.
kitkatrinaa 1 year ago 3
Didn't know Patrick Wilson could sing? He sings beautifully!
la214la 1 year ago
Emmy sang badly but patrick really did a good job.
cwang22 1 year ago 23
@cwang22 sarah brightman fan. :P
jazzrockzz 6 months ago 2
@cwang22 In all honesty,i probably wouldn't sing that well with a fox like Patrick singng to me all romantically *sigh* <3
RoniePryor 4 months ago 2
omg its andrew lloyd webber himself playin piano
hansoff 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
hansoff 1 year ago
@heavymetalangelx: Me too :)
PixieChic447 1 year ago
i LOVE patrick wilson
heavymetalangelx 1 year ago
Argh Emmy getson my nerves, she's terrible.
PhanPhanPhanPhanPhan 1 year ago
Emmy is gorgeous and talented, but I think her voice needed time to mature a bit more first. SHes only gonna get better with age.
shazzqsong 1 year ago
It was so sweet when she seemed nervous at 1:30 and had to start really fast and he took her hand. Maybe that's just the choreography but I thought it looked sweet like he was trying to help her.
gotGodandHislove 1 year ago
emmy is really good but sarah brightmans the best =]
Cutiekat82 1 year ago
super loooooooooove it...<3 ^_^ <3
iszybella 1 year ago
Emmy is amazing. I think she's better than Sarah. And Patrick is much better than I expected him to be, I will admit. (:
tobyluvr17 1 year ago 2
whoa he's even better lookin with his haircut :p haha
moviegurl16 1 year ago
HOTTTTT!!!! hahahahahaha....yeah!!!!!
Islandgurl2015 1 year ago
I love this version.
sajapornt 1 year ago
Patrick Wilson and Michael Ball are the best in this role!
BroadwayGirl24 1 year ago
Emmy is awesome. Patrick sounds sooo much better here than he did in the movie...and he was great in the movie.
hiflip57 1 year ago
She's not very good live, is she? Pretty voice, but not very good.
RaWrZzZz 1 year ago 2
i love her dress
TheOrchaDork 1 year ago
emmy rossum is the best christine by far, sorry thats the truth, period.
balogh12 1 year ago
good god patrick wilson is georgeous
devlynoc 1 year ago 2
I love it
Andrea810929 1 year ago
anne hathaway was originally going to play the part of christine in the movie...i wonder how it would have sounded with her? still like emmy though!
LovingOrli 1 year ago
He is SO MUCH BETTER than she is.
She sounds (and looks) like freshman students in my voice program - lots of unnecessary movement and vocal instability. There are also some very strange vowel sounds happening here, some overmodification.. hmm.
Also, just a note: "Phantom of the Opera" is not opera. It is musical theater.
elizabu 1 year ago 4
@elizabu I agree, but it's also I guess a way to mirror opera in a way. It's supposed to have elements of, but not really be, an opera. And you're right. She really does sound unstable. Renata Fusco...the Italian dub singer, now that is secure without giving up an innocent, young sound (which is apparently what they're going for).
SMSProductions1 1 year ago
@SMSProductions1 She's probably nervous.
JolSummerville 1 year ago
@elizabu I love listening to her, and isnt that the point?
SugarBunny119 1 year ago
I love this! but anyone else notice the odd thing emmy always does with her lips?
kourtneyandhearts 1 year ago
OMG she would not stop moving her head!!! lol
BroadwayBoundable 1 year ago
I like Emma , But I prefer Sarah , her voice is more beautiful than Emma !!!!!
Lualulu19 1 year ago 4
yay i love them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Misspoipoi 1 year ago
It sounds a little bit strange to me...with the piano
ChoosingShadows 1 year ago
Yeah, put that Andrew Lloyd Webber character to work. OMG, Christine is hot, beautiful, sexy and has a magnificent voice. Wait, is this the same Emmy as in the movie? If it is, she's much better than in the movie. I hate the movie. Just terrible. The Phantom doesn't even look scary. All he looks like is that he needed so Proactiv and that's it. Stupid rendition of the broadway. My opinion. Chill you psycho fantoms. haha : )
musicalphantom2010 1 year ago
I thought Emmy was perfect. She kinda did mediocre in this performance. She tried too hard to make every note strong, which sucks cuz the thing I like about her voice the most is how subtle it is. Though I have to say that Andrew rushed on the piano too much. I don't know if they were trying to meet a quota but the accompaniment was way too fast. As for Sarah: like Emmy better. I don't think we can really figure out the best "Christine" because it's really all about preference.
lakacro 1 year ago 2
@lakacro
its been 3 years sence the movie came out and im sure emmys voice is still maturing which is y she sounds so different... emmy and gerard r the best cast!!!!
eriksangelofmusic98 1 year ago
Patrick Wilson has one remarkable voice
v49624430 1 year ago 36
I know it's almost impossible not to compare sarah brightman & emmy rossum but really it's kind of unfair to do so..
emmy was 18 when she sang this! For someone who is so young with clearly less operatic experience as sarah, she was pretty amazing.
Another thing-they were able to re-do the tracks as much as they wanted for the movie. Singing live is a whole other story for someone whose trade is not opera singer. While I think some parts could have been improved, she was pretty amazing overall
thanksxforxthexvenom 1 year ago
prooven ....
Emmy is NOT a soprano,
and NOT Christine!
SamSkii14 1 year ago
@SamSkii14 She may not be a soprano now. Her voice has developed into a lower range. But when she did the film & this, she was able to sing the required score. I also have to diasgree. (In respectful way) I think Emmy had near perfect characterization for Christine. I think she really brought the emotional essence into the story. What didn't you like about her portrayal?
Silver54ful 1 year ago
I think Emmy and Patrick did a wonderful job with this iconic song! Their voices blended together so beautifully. Their portrayals of Christine & Raoul is one of my favorites!
Silver54ful 1 year ago 2
AMAZING
oinegueotama 1 year ago
she's not so good when her voice isn't being altered
Yellie876 1 year ago
@Yellie876 i totally agree, it doesnt sound as pure or smooth, as it does when its altered.
Zanadu95 1 year ago
love patrick so much!!!!!! patrick's voice is so charming, even his looks, and moves!!! waaa!! he's like a prince charming!!!!! emmy is so beautiful and talented.. so young but so excellent!!!
genliyin 1 year ago
Lloyd Webber = GENIOUS!
catarininhah 1 year ago 2
Emmy does have a nice voice but it's to modern.... -.- Sarah has such an amazing voice!
Kazunomiya32 1 year ago
@Kazunomiya32
Sarah has had lots of training too, Emmy has not had as much training, but for what she has is doing very well.
FaerieMom1 1 year ago
Sarah beats Emmy... But although Sarah possesses the most beautiful voice, there is no version as sweet and mesmerizing as Barbra's... Anyway, the three of them are definitely marvelous singers...
dracodormiensnunq 2 years ago
This love song is perfect for any love couple out there in the real world. LOVE IS FOREVER!
Concertchoir75 2 years ago
nice ^.^
martyneczka1995 2 years ago
Patrick Wilson was the best singer of the three leads in Phantom! He has a musical theatre background. Plus, he's very charming as Raoul.
JeddtheJedi 2 years ago
i love this song...very much
pochiekohh 2 years ago 4
Emmy is good! She sings well. But Sarah Brightman is a million times better...Sarah's voice is perfect!!! There's no way to compare cuz Sarah is the best ever!!
leandrooliveiramg 2 years ago
too much operatic is so ANNOYING! ..... EMMY'S version is the BEST!
culture92 2 years ago 6
Patrick is so mesmerizing!
Ser3n 2 years ago 3
i think what amazes me is that emmy was fairly young when she was first in Phantom. I love her though, Sarah Brightman was good, but Emmy just sounds more genuine, like she's not trying hard at all. And Patrick is amazing as always!
narniaprincess05 2 years ago 45
Woooow Patrick is amazing!
NinnyV 2 years ago 4
She is no Sarah Brightman!
res57 2 years ago
That's true. Emmy's better. Sarah's so operatic! Yes this is suppose to be opera but it's just difficult too appreciate her. They're both good in their own rights, I guess.
czamonix 2 years ago 57
@czamonix i think emmy is the best at singing this, i dont like claire moore or sarah singing it!
mjgirl3 1 year ago
@mjgirl3 While I don't think Emmy is bad at all which is what some people claim. In fact I think she has a beautiful voice. It is untrue that Emmy has the best voice for this role. You are more then welcome to call her your favorite as that is your opinion. But it's a fact there are much more talented sopranos with trained technique that blow her away. She's actually a mezzo who had trouble sustaining many of the higher notes. Her E flat in the title song was digitally enhanced.
Silver54ful 1 year ago 2
@czamonix LOL! I've never read anything so ridiculous before.
haroof 1 year ago
emmy is soooo lucky!!! patrick is amazing, handsome and talented
aznized 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I bet she's a screamer when she's having sex. what do you reckon?
londonplayer 2 years ago
so gifted both of them!!!!
s1NgLErlkmf 2 years ago 5
he has a more natural talented voice. not to mention her odd head bobbing thing.
BlissfllEy3 2 years ago 4
Nice!!!
:)
marroli 2 years ago 3
Flipping hell, Emmy's head was like one of them bobbing head things.
NiGHTSFangirl 2 years ago 3
In the professional singing world, that mans she has a well-trained voice and that her vocal chords are relaxed enough for her to move naturally. It's a good thing.
Elemiriel 2 years ago 5
Whoa! I didn't know Night Owl can sing!
littlefoo20 2 years ago 2
She is gorgeous
trendyxxfish 2 years ago 3
r they goen out it looks like they like each other or r they ackting
hlchiboroski 2 years ago
they're acting. they played opposite each other in Phantom of the Opera, Patrick played Raoul and Emmy played Christine
Elemiriel 2 years ago 3
She struggles alot as you can hear it in the cracking of the voice.
at1212b 2 years ago
Oh, plz... can u do better?
lilanoangel 2 years ago
thank you sooooo much for finally saying soemthing to those kind of judgemental ppl who say Emmy can't sing and yet i bet they can't even carry a tune
stardusth2o 2 years ago 8
Emmy´s voice is amazing as well as Patrick´s! Both are awesome and two of my favorite singers.
happysweetamy 2 years ago 4
lovely....just lovley....
webbersarahlover 2 years ago 4
still love :D
SassySM 2 years ago 3
I wonder if Patrick knew he would have to do "promotion" like this lol.
haroof 2 years ago 2
raoul is AMAZING!!!!he needs to be on broadway or west end!!!!! em's an ok singer, but if mr. webber liked her than that's enough for me.
MTwannaB4jesus 2 years ago 3
He's a long way ahead of her lol, his singing is just brilliant. Couldn't have picked a better Raoul.
Powerofthecowboy 2 years ago 4
i like emmy. she sings really well in my opinion. patriks voice is like velvet
smellydee 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
She was awful in the movie, she's awful here. Can't hold a note for longer than a second and she apparently thinks diction is for bitches.
He, on the other hand, is lovely. Here and in the movie.
lolwuttles 2 years ago
@lolwuttles thank you!!!!!!
jtg10795 1 year ago
it sounds lower than in the movie, not a huge fan of her as a singer, but a good actress....
09Elegance 2 years ago
Wow they truly are great singers they were good in the movie but i thought it was because they touch it up and stuff
kiki09ist 2 years ago
OH!! It took me like, 20 seconds to figure out that it's Patrick Wilson!!! I didn't recognize him with out the hair from the movie. . . Wow.
LittleMeg1992 2 years ago
of course the voices are different. in the movie their voices were digitally enhanced and altered
bluelionpilot 2 years ago
I love their live voices much better than the recorded version in the movie. Both voices are more strong, and better developed.
Kelin236 2 years ago 2
COMPLETELY agree!!!
they souns do much better live!
oh, i love Patrik (L)
SamSkii14 2 years ago 2
Completely agree.
cscentrlTV 2 years ago 2
amazing.. simply amazing
pavelgazzo 2 years ago
her voice has changed
Katluver56 2 years ago 5
Nice fog, haha.
Patrik Wilson's voice makes my heart melt. <3
aw, that kiss at the end was cute.
underthebloodredsky 2 years ago 6
~*Emmy And Patrick Sing Beautifully, One of the Best movies Ever! *~ -D
jackskellington13000 2 years ago 4
Emmy sings so beautifully!
and is it just me or does she wear white a lot? in interviews and stuff :P
I love her!!
momoiscrazii 2 years ago 3
She's alright but I love Sarah Brightman she is a beautiful singer!!
mhmjhm1130 2 years ago
Emmy Rossum is a classically trained singer.
mayuuuu 2 years ago 2
WOAH, Andrew Lloyd Webber!!
davidovich00 2 years ago 3
Not bad. Really, not bad. Thanks for posting!
Innuband 2 years ago
WOW he shits all over her LIVE!!! hes fantastic here.
katesinger 2 years ago
He's good, isn't he :)
deChagnysAsian 2 years ago 2
Nihon?
douxelle 2 years ago
Emmy has a pretty good voice for an actress. There are some parts where she's good and some parts are just eh...
but Patrick! O