Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (110)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i sign language my name boo yah it was like 7 yrs ago so now im 16 now but almost 17

  • This video help :) I'm trying to learn it cuz I have friends that r deaf and we r using too much paper ha :) thanks

  • Your a really bad teacher im 11 and i can sigh better than you

    im not even deaf............i learn off my deaf friend (:

  • @abby692216 Huh, funny, my grandmother was deaf and I have signed my entire life, I even took a class in college. I think she does a great job. Perhaps, you should go back to trolling the Justin Bieber fan sites.

  • @sambomuaythaijack I'm Not Trying To Troll? Some Comments Are Even Ruder Than Mine, I Do Apologize For Saying She's A Bad Teacher. But Honestly She's Not Very Good. She Should Learn More Before She Posts A Video That So Many People Will See. If Someone Tries To Do This In Public They Would Be Laughed At. Look At Other Comments They Agree. At Least The Lady Tried.(: Once Again I Don't Troll.

  • if i was really deaf i wouldnt watch this because she doesnt even do the letters one by one its very difficult and doesnt make it easy to learn the alphabets -____-

  • @primaj100 if you where deaf you wouldnt be learning sign language on youtube.

  • totaly rong!!!!!!!!!!

  • TOO FAST!! SO HARD!!

  • Better to learn ASL the wrong way than to not learn it at all. Think of all the hearing people who use grammar wrong and speak incorrectly yet they are somewhat understandable, but yeah this lady isn't very good.

  • OMG! Awful! TAKE ASL class FIRST then teach.

  • Now Every Time I Do K , I Start Out As P Then I Do K :(

  • The first Alphabet 'A' is wrong.......lady, learn first then teach.....

  • aboot? Is she canadian?! maybe its like canadian sign language?

  • she almost made me do k wrong.

  • i thought this was a lesson for beginners

  • what's up with all these useless negative comments. If you think she's wrong, say exactly *what* she's doing wrong. I honestly don't see much difference between her and what I see illustrated in sign language books. Negative comments are welcome, but be specific.

  • the letter z kills the whole thing XD

  • She's teaching wrong! These are NOT the write signs!

  • aboot :|

  • Kool

  • It's not shocking to find out she's a "weather specialist" and not an actual SL educator. She should stick with making "How To Sign Up For Facebook" videos.

  • We own a restaurant and we have Deaf Customers, And I would like to impress them with sign. :) Thank you for the video

  • I am deaf and I cannot understand a word she is saying, but I know exactly that she is doing, everything almost perfect and dont be mean about the letter A. Thats how I learned it.

  • Thnx this is very helpful im trying to learn sign language cuz there r so many deaf ppl I noe that I wuld lyk tah b able tah communicate wit thnx(:

  • when did they change the letter A ?

  • worst alphabet video ever.

  • she is doing to fast!!!!!!!1

  • You are doing the ABC wrong.

    A, G, H, X is completely wrong...

  • she used the H sign for U...xD

  • a is wrong so is h and k so is p and q. it so funny watching her mess up like that and she doesn't even notice

  • Your doing the alphabet wrong. A, H, X, and G is wrong. You need to be more firmer with the signs. It can't be sloppy

  • this is way wrong. her hands shouldnt be flopping all over the place

  • @RaptorLuv, Sign IS NOT universal. There is BSL(British Sign Language) ISL(Irish Sign Language) FSL(French Sign Language) ASL (American Sign Language) and ALL are different. Sign Language is like any other language in that it varies by country. She sounds Canadian and may be signing the Canadian version of Sign.

  • So if this is not the correct alphabet in ASL then where might one find the right one? I'm taking a class in college in this is what we have learned and every where I've looked online has the same thing.

  • @Tamsin2010 Well it might be because she's doing it to be sure the handshape is understood, but generally you wouldn't spell things that far out from your body and that high up. Also, her A, G, and H are the only letters I find awkward, but this could be due to the region she's from. Maybe they sign it differently which is always a possibility. Different regions have different signs whether completely or partially.

  • No. She's doing it this way because she doesn't know any better. She's is NOT a fluent signer. She's simply looking this stuff up in a book and putting together lessons to make money off it. (ExpertVillage pays her to do this).

  • Want to learn the correct handshapes as well as correct arm positioning and spelling techniques? Check out my channel.

  • This isn't the alphabet I learned O_o

  • even though sign language is universal some of the expressions are different and some alphabet letters are different also. like in europe some letters are diff and in asia too

  • ....why is this alphabet different from the one that I know? ...and my friend knows...and different from every deaf person I've met....? I know that some people do the letters a little different like people pronounce words different in certain areas....that's it right?

  • No, KoriKitti! You are correct! This lady is teaching the ASL alphabets all wrong! I am taking a ASL class at my college and believe me, she is erroring quite a bit. You are correct in your assumption!

  • Thanks for the confirmation. ^^ I hate getting my languages mixed up. In Spanish some people pronounce double l's as "y" and some pronounce is as "j". I personally pronounce it with a y, but there are so many exceptions to linguistic rules!

  • I agree with budbud. This lady does NOT know ASL. She learned these signs from a book (and is showing them incorrectly in these videos).

  • Lady, what ARE you teaching..? A number of the alphabets you're teaching are WRONG, including the very first alphabet itself. --' Please refrain from teaching others the wrong thing. You're gonna make the people who learn from you a laughing stock.

  • Too late. She's already a laughingstock. But she also makes certified teachers like myself very disappointed because she's taking advantage of my language to make money.

  • @BYUFanatic And then I go to your website where it says I have to pay to learn it. Lame.

  • @xktgx33 Excuse me, but you do not pay to learn the alphabet from me. I give that knowledge away freely to everyone. What I DO offer though, is in-depth, low-cost lessons on how to accurately and correctly learn ASL from someone who has spent years studying how to teach and is a certified ASL teacher. But, if you'd rather learn from this woman who is incorrectly "teaching" signs that she self-taught herself from a book, then THAT is lame.

  • @BYUFanatic Excuse me, but I never said I did. And you're still taking advantage of knowing your language to get money out of it. Not saying it's wrong, but if you're going to talk down to others for doing the same, it seems...inappropriate. You are a teacher, and you do deserve to get money for your services to others, but I believe you're showing yourself in a rather unprofessional manner.

  • @xktgx33 Actually, yes you DID say that. In fact, you used the word "lame" in sharing your opinion of it. Interesting that you would say I am "taking advantage" of my knowledge of ASL. If I was offering Spanish lessons or French lessons, people like you wouldn't be so rude. But, because people like you view ASL as only a sort of "quasi-language" you feel that it should be offered for free because it's "not really a language." [continued...]

  • [continued...] In fact, if you want to talk about "taking advantage" then you should be aware that this woman who made this videos knows absolutely NOTHING about ASL. She couldn't carry on a conversation with a Deaf person to save her life. And yet, she is getting PAID by "expertvillage" for these lessons. I bet you didn't know that did you? Now THAT is taking advantage of ME, MY CULTURE, and MY LANGUAGE. That is what I would consider to be "unprofessional" and "lame." (To use your words.)

  • @BYUFanatic Final comments on this... I am VERY professional in my teaching style and in how I defend my language and culture. I've put together a top quality website that teaches my language in an organized and in-depth manner (rather than random videos). I have such a passion for sharing my language that I offer my lessons for dirt-cheap while others charge as much as $30 or more for one lesson module. I also have over two dozen FREE videos on my YouTube channel. Yep, lame indeed.

  • @BYUFanatic Yes, I did know that she gets paid for these videos. She doesn't deserve it, I might add, but that doesn't change anything. If there's a demand for something and people can use that knowledge or make it look plausible, then they're going to do what they can to make that knowledge worthwhile. Still, you're taking advantage of your knowledge about the subject, whether you like to admit it or not. By getting paid for knowing something others don't, you take advantage of it.

  • @xktgx33, that's the most bizarre statement. "By getting paid for knowing something other's don't, you take advantage of it." No, actually, he's getting paid to TEACH something other's don't know, and they (the paying customers) are getting something of value in exchange. In your mind, teachers don't deserve payment. Why, exactly? And why does this woman, who is NOT a teacher, deserve to get paid? The information she is sharing is false. She is tricking people into thinking she is a teacher.

  • @Banerika Why are you following this? Especially when I clearly told him "You are a teacher, and you do deserve to get money for your services to others". That's a quote from a previous comment of mine. Go argue elsewhere.

  • @xktgx33, I'm following this because I've made it my mission to make others aware that this woman is banking on other people's ignorance. I'd like people to know that this is not ASL, and that she is not an expert. She is spreading misconceptions about the language with each and every view she receives.

  • @xktgx33 You apparently have a problem with accurately expressing yourself. "Taking advantage of" something is generally considered a negative term. So is the word "lame" (you called me this earlier). Do I "admit" that I am creating a quality product that people happily purchase because they know they're getting their money's worth? Yes. Am I tricking people by pretending to be something I'm not? No. I'm still scratching my head to try and figure out what point you're trying to make.

  • @BYUFanatic Taking advantage of your knowledge and taking advantage of other people are two different things. In this case, it would be taking advantage of the lack of prior knowledge that other people have (for this women). Taking advantage of the innocence that others have would probably be a better wording for it. Taking advantage of does have negative connotations but I do believe it means to use something for your own gain. Correct? I do want to state again that in my eyes you do (cont.)

  • @BYUFanatic Deserve what you get, and probably more than you do charge, but you're still talking down to this person. You're not just making others aware; you're making them aware in an obnoxious way. Commenting once on each video would have been okay, but commenting multiple times on each video while insulting her is not, even if she does deserve it. Being able to hold your composure in a situation like this is what I consider professional, and not being able to do so projects the opposite.

  • @xktgx33 "Talking down" to a person who is the equivalent of a "carpetbagger"? Again, interesting choice of words. What you call "obnoxious," others do not. I get many comments from others who are grateful that I have cautioned them about learning from people like this woman. My comments are factual and to the point. If you consider that unprofessional then that's your problem, not mine. As for why I comment more than once - it's because most people only read the first page or two of comments.

  • @BYUFanatic Repeating something numerous times with a rude tone isn't obnoxious? Since you can't be loud through text, you seem to make up for it with the number of comments you leave. There's a line between letting people know what's going on with this woman and letting your anger show.

  • @xktgx33 Ah, but it's ok for you to be rude by calling me "lame?" Isn't that kinda like the kettle calling the pot black? What you consider obnoxious, I consider righteous indignation. After all, it's MY language and MY culture that this woman is exploiting for personal profit while blatantly spreading false information and misperceptions. How silly of me to express my displeasure for her actions.

  • @xktgx33, why is it that people are not allowed show they're angry when they are seriously offended?

  • @xktgx33. I don't think you see the point. The reason BYUFanatic and many others make multiple comments is because this is the only way to impact the perception that people have that she is some kind of expert, which is ludicrous. Is it obnoxious to inform others that she is not an expert, and not teaching ASL? I don't think so. I think she's the obnoxious one here. The rest of of us are trying to inform people so they are not tricked or fooled, nor embarrassed by what they "learn" from her.

  • @xktgx33. There's a saying. "It's not mean if it's true." Presenting the facts, and exposing her as false, isn't mean. It's just truthful. Personally, when someone bothers to inform me of the truth, rather than let me remain ignorant, I am grateful.

  • @Banerika But calling you a laughing stock in the progress of letting you know that you're wrong is okay with you? That's a little hard to believe. I highly doubt you'd appreciate that. And it's okay to let people know, but numerous times on a single video is a little much, especially with more than one person already confirming the same thing.

  • @xktgx33, when someone is blatantly and knowingly making money at other people's expense, while foolishly making numerous blatant errors, she is a laughing stock. Pointing it out saves others the embarrassment of believing in her false advertising. Few people look past the first few comments, so that's why it's necessary to keep commenting. Personally I think she is exploitative and should pull her videos from YouTube voluntarily.

  • @Banerika she has big boobs

  • @BYUFanatic I apologize for using the word 'it'. A very unspecific word that did not get my point across. I meant that you still have to pay to learn sign language as a whole from your website. I deserve to have the bad choice of words to be picked apart like that, but what I do not deserve is for you to shove assumptions in my mouth. I realize that sign language is a full-on language with it's own rules and history and that it should be respected as such.

  • xktgx33, what do you mean that he is "taking advantage of knowing" his language? Did you know that he has three degrees in the subject area, years of experience teaching ASL, and has dedicated his career to helping as many people as possible learn it? While Melissa is a broadcast personality/weather girl who is using *your* unfamiliarity with ASL to her advantage in order to make money. She's not teaching ASL, and BYUFanatic is doing EVERYONE a favor by informing them of this fact.

  • this is hard but i still want to learn!!!!

  • thanks chick. u were a big help. i learned the whole thing! :)

  • this crap is hard.

  • Thank you for posting. Very useful.

    BSL stage 3 me.

  • its the same signs for all LAtin-influenceeedd lagnguage s?

  • i can sign to the song my heart ur home

    i did it for the talent show but in not deaf

    i just did it for fun!!!!

  • She makes constant mistakes and is not teaching ASL. See also BYUFanatic for someone who knows what he is talking about.

  • Don't learn from this "expert." Don't tell me it's an accent. Accept that she is often wrong and find a better reference out there. For the manual alphabet, I suggest CreativeHandsASL. You can find her on YouTube. She is a CODA, meaning child of deaf adults.

  • Sorry, that's CreativehandsASL. The video is entitled: Learn the manual alphabet in sign language (ASL)

  • i like it . god for you

    i reaaly thanks you for teaching you

    mis

    i want you take care for you

  • she does the "K" kinda weird

  • Your a is also worng. I am ateacher of the deaf and have worked with many deaf individuals. You shouls be careful of the "experts" you use.

  • I learned sign language when I was 12, from my best friend whos parents were both deaf. It really helped. This isnt exactly the way I learned but I learned a long time ago. I could be wrong. Good luck!

  • thatss not how you do K. sorry but your wrong lady. expert village, every video i've seen has all sucked. not just sign language.

  • yes that is not a k, a k looks more like a peace sign, and some others are of like g and h there the right shape but the person recieving the signs wouldnt be able to tell the difference

  • true but people will sign a k like that i know. My bf does sign language and well know a bunch of people who sign ad some do sign like that the k.

  • O MY GOODNESS SHE IS HORRIBLE!!!!

  • Thanks alot with this it helped alot

  • no no no she is doing stuff wrong don't watch this to learn

  • Are BSL and ASL kind of the same or are they way different?

  • bsl is Britain sign language i think and asl is american sign language but hey i dont know

  • Although some of the signs are similar, they are completely different languages. One major difference is fingerspelling. In ASL every letter of the alphabet is done with one hand and in BSL every letter besides "C" is done with two hands. Also, most of the signs are completely different.

  • A, G, and H are all wrong. Close, but turned wrong. Good try and good for starters.

  • im sorry to say she is not as fluent and the way she says A is wrong should be seen visiable

    Im sorry but teach music will ya!

  • this is great for beginners like me i have to keep on practacing

  • Apparently she's not fluent in ASL, since she's horrible and the alphabet should be the easiest to learn.

  • thank you for teaching me that!

  • that was crap.

  • I think this is ASL because the BSL signs are very different to this.

  • What's BSL?

  • british sign language.

  • good .. behind the right side of the charming lady graphics A B C D if mixed it will be better vdo ...A E S actions slow down a little . as they are mimicing very much look alike in fast motion

  • is this the american version

  • @Romily205 no, it's the i-have-no-idea-what-i'm-doing version.

  • wow this was a really good tutorial... i learned to do it in less than 5 mins!!

  • wow i learned alot !!

  • awesome

  • Great! Thank you!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more