Added: 2 years ago
From: Irategamer
Views: 69,482
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (586)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I thought this was a really good movie

  • A prequel to a prequel what is this zelda

  • fucking hated that abominable movie and all its retarded teenage fanboys who have no clue about star trek at all

    GOD-AWFUL flick

  • Let me just point out that I do like bad movies, they can be fun. This movie is not what I call fun. This movie is so bad; I can't stop commenting about it. To me it's like inching powder in my shirt. The story has so many coincidences it killed the feeling of reality, the acting was substandard, the villain was shallow and the heroes were jerks and morons. It was the only hero movie I wished the villain would win so there would be no more movies.

  • @Trekfreek

    Well said my friend...well said

  • Yup, that's what I'd like to see too, a new TNG movie and probably a DS9 movie as well. I'd like to see what happened afterwards. Some how it just isn't the same when reading the books.

  • When he says the film had a "Star Wars-like feel to it," is exactly the reason I wasn't impressed by the film. It seemed too much like a rip-off of Star Wars. I like both Trek & Wars, but I like them for different reasons. One should not feel it has to copy the other. If you liked the new film, I respect your opinion. However, I thought it was a major disappointment on many different grounds.

  • Of course it felt like Star Wars by design, for better or worse. The crew says they were going for that feel on the DVD commentary too.

    Spoilers:

    Yeah, just as soon (in the TNG era) as the Federation may possibly be opening up better diplomatic ties to the Romulan Empire, boom some new guy comes along and blows their planet up. So much for respecting established continuity. And the alternate reality is probably worse off with the destruction of Vulcan sure to weaken the Federation greatly.

  • I hope they do.

  • "all i can say is bring on more star trek movies"

    "i was never a big fan of the original series"

    "jj abrams did a tremendous job"

    you fucking idiot ..... what movie where you watching? did you go to the wrong cinema

  • Kirk happens to outrun the raging snow beast and meetup with grandpa Spok? stupid

  • This was my least favorite Star Trek movie. It felt like Star Trek Lite made for non Star Trek fans with too many unbelievable scenes

  • @audiowiz Ha ha! Star Trek Lite. I'm gonna have to call it that now. I'm not against having a Trek film with lots of action, however, this film seems to substitute action in place of plot & depth. The way I see it, if you like action, you'll probably love the film, but if you really like Star Trek, you may not.

  • now we need a prequel to the next generation series

  • That would be awesome, maybe something from the Enterprise-C/ Stargazer period.

  • Some people loved the whole movie.

    Some like AVGN thought the second half of the movie was very good and compelling, but the first half was to slow with to much extra footage that was not necessary.

  • "Excellent storyline"? What film were YOU watching? Sure, it was an entertaining film and all, but full of cliches and coincidences.

  • @SeansShowStudios I agree. Nero's motivations seemed weak at best, & the entire Delta Vega sequence was one HUGE coincidence upon another.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!

    what happened to romulas was that the nova that was created by the star of that galaxy, destroyed Romulus, and that is why the Romulans attacked the enterprise

  • thanks for the info on what happened to data, i was wondering about that.

  • chekov should have been like 9 or 10 in this film, since he would have been 17 in 2266, when the first star trek episodes in TOS started

  • Why do all the characters have to be so young? Would they send out so young and unexperiented people into missions in space? No they would never do that!

  • i wanna see this movie so badly xD

  • if your stupid it makes no sence

  • If you're familiar with the series it makes no sense. You're the stupid one... and learn to spell.

  • dont you understand they made it so they could make more storys without the characters being old and just doing a series with different people

  • Comment removed

  • You show less intelligence than him, when you go all the way to this part of Youtube, and spew all your fucking menstrual fluids all over the place.

    You, are a fucking disgrace. Learn to not speak.

  • Did to me, sorry it didn't for you.

  • only one thing to say about star trek........my number one favorite movie!!!!!!!

  • JJ Abrams redefines Star Trek

  • This was actually very informative, good job I'm going right out to get that comic

  • i just got to say but the main charchter never actuly won a fist to fist combat fight lol

  • Spock *drools*

  • thank you irategamer so much for saying that about the movie bcus i loved my mom loved it and i think my dad is gonna love it once he sees it

  • this was a great movie

  • this movie pwned because it was hilarious, the action pwned, and it wasn't like the other gay ass stark trek movies. (Sorry if I offend any fans by saying that, i just didn't enjoy the previous ones)

  • agree jj made a good trek

  • i dont care what the haters say i dont care who is better who the fuck spends the time to type on their keyboard saying "you suck, AVGN rules!!" well those guys can go stalk him ur still great those comments dont make AVGN better it just makes him worse having his fans try to take down his competition, and i say who the fuck gives a damn its youtube a site where you express what you think via video thanks for reading this long comment and hope u think the same thing sry for the long comment

  • i agree its so fucken funny how these low lifes put people down

  • this douche is a fucking loser, needs to stop making reviews cause its a waste of YouTube bandwidth

    AVGN 4 Life

  • Hey fuck you man avgn can suck my hairy sweaty ball sack

  • sounds like you want some dude to suck your dick, do you also want him to cup your balls too you gay fuck?

  • If you hate him why did you subscribe to him?

  • I don't hate him I just think people who just go to peoples pages and bitch about how much they suck should just go watch something else but no they don't so I argue with them

  • Because you know. Youtube Bandwidth is limited. Being that it's owned by Fucking google. You're a fucking moron and I hope you DIAF. IG ftw. Not only is he fucking hilarious. But what kinda douchebag are you to come on here and insult the man's work? Least he does shit , unlike you Mr. Kissassfanboybitch.

  • Great movie.. but excellent story line??? Someone is trying to destroy the federation and planet earth.. whats new?Thats what made TNG Stand out above the other Star Treks. The stories were made you think. It wasnt a shock and awe campaign like this.

  • i didn't grow up with star trek, and im afread that i may not understand every thing, should i go see it?

  • Nice, data is not dead!

  • I thought it was really good. It kinda scares me though how they pretty much changed the story. I really don't know how this is going to turn out.

    Kirk: Pull my cord!

    Sulu: Okaaaaaay!  Oh my.

    lol

  • STAR TREK is awesome and the best movie.

    Transformers is a god awful piece of crap.

  • hey, i liked it

  • Then you must like comedies.

  • Doesn't everybody?

  • The 2nd one anyhow..

  • if any,that was a star trek fan,attending at my school,you would be target practice for the crountry boys.we would drive out to the bog and finish the job there!

  • did you see transformers revenge of the fallen?

  • i´d like to see a sequel focused of the picard crue

  • Welshie!!

  • you know irate gamer is not the best but I think he relates to people more. also sometimes you gotta take what you can get

  • Actualy i was dissapointed about this move=(

  • lmao at the end, oh my

  • Just watched a few of your reveiws, it seems you dont Give your own opinion, seem to repeat what everyone else seemed to say. if its been said, dont say it.

  • thats his gimmick. he steals everything from others.

  • too bad this movie showed an alternate reality version of star trek

  • rofl george takei

  • I love the Irate Gamer's YouTube posts, his movie review of the new Star Trek movie is spot-on! Keep up the good work, IG!

  • Best Red shirt ever!

  • I know people hate this type of advertising but please watch my videos.

  • That's right, we do hate that type of advertising. You are actually breaking the law by advertising on a video that people have to pay to get ads on, because he's a youtube partner.

  • the movie was ok to me

  • dick

  • explosionsfrommybutt, Stfu you freakin' retard. It shouldn't matter whether he says pan out or not. It's a real phrase, and what really matters is that he's giving a good review about this movie.

  • i agree

  • Stop saying pan out you fucking retard.

  • its real u fuck

  • See the movie its bad!!!!!!!!!

  • its good

  • that huge thing in the beginnning just makes you say HOLY SHIT!

  • I finally saw it y'day & it was brilliant. Gotta c it again.

  • NERDS

  • I gotta tell ya, this new "Star Trek "movie didn't just miss the mark, it gobbled the mark's balls.

    In a nutshell it was a CGI-fest of weak charecter development and had so many conflicts with the real Star Trek timeline it isn't even funny.

    Sheeple may like it for all the opiating CGI and brainless action, but real Trek fans know that Gene Roddenberry is rolling in his grave at this abomination-to-make-a-cheap-bu­ck.

  • See another awesome fact about the Genius of J.J. Abrams, He made the new Star Trek without leaving out the older Star Trek The Next Generation and Voyager, because it perfectly reasonable that We didn't know about Romulus being destroyed, Next Generation and Voyager happen 90 years after the original and and the older Spock was from 110 years from the original, Jeez I just hope Tuvok from voyager didn't get wiped from History.

  • A supernova doesn't just happen. It's a very gradual process of a star running out of fuel. Whether it was Romulus' sun or another star, they would've seen it coming decades, if not centuries in advance. It's not 'perfectly reasonable' at all.

    PS. I don't hate the movie, but I don't think very highly of lazy storytelling.

  • Not to ruin your scientific explanation (which is completely correct, by the way) but I'm sure that something triggered the supernova quicker than in nature. And if it didn't, the star could've been too far away to detect; a supernova covers an enormous amount of space.

  • I suppose something could trigger an unexpected supernova (although I don't know what!).

    A star massive enough to supernova would have a very hard time going undetected if it were at a distance close enough to ruin the Romulan's day.

    Furthermore, yellow stars aren't generally the kind to supernova. That's red/blue supergiant territory.

  • J.J. Abrams is a FREAKING GENIUS! First Lost now this, Star Trek is the perfect fusion of Remix and Original that I've ever seen and of course the Red Shirt gets blasted first.

  • 4th. What the hell happened to that spider thing they put in pikes mouth. Also when nero is getting the information for pike the code or whatever. Total retardation I mean its like trying to take a code from a general today. He wouldn't know it and second it changes every hour or day. 3rd when spock says that only a couple thousand survived and they had become an endangered species is total bullshit I mean come on there has to be hundereds of thousands on others planets and outposts

  • By the timeline given by Spock Prime Nero attacked him just after Spock failed to save Romulus, so Nero didn't have time to refit his ship with state of the art military weapons before being dragged through time. They must have some mean ass rocks in the Romulan empire. .

  • NERD!

  • ur mom

  • nerd

  • yur moms ass is fat :^)

  • I am not sure what number i'm on but Also, not exactly a plot hole, but how come the humans showed a Vulcan-like complete absence of emotion at the deaths of all their classmates. Kirk didn't even care that the hot green chick was apparently killed in battle! I get that technology has improved in the last lets say 150 years but to the point where a MINING ship can not just beat but overwhelm 7 Federation WAR ships at the same time? Not to mention the "47 Klingon ships" Uhura mentioned.

  • bring on the sequel to the prequel

  • THAT WAS THE COLLEST MOVIE IVE SEEN!

  • Mr. Irate... I am one of your fans and personally i would always defend you... however JJ abrams

    A. Made the enterprise retarded with a beer brewery inside... (no seals/walls in a spaceship = dead crew btw)

    b. Had crocomire from SM on hoth....

    c. you can't do instant conversations across a black hole

    d. klingons couldnt cloak till during kirk's 5 year mission

    e. kirk is implied to be an only child... when he had an older brother (though kirk could actually be the older brother in the film)

  • f. Nero's plot involves a miner... just a normal joe... getting borg tech... "shakes head... Bwah?!" Borg tech is hard to find/use and hella secured!

    g. no consistancy in travel times... period

    h. no consistancy in the use of the plot device... at all

    i. black holes eat planets.. why drill a hole into it when you could pop a hole open in the upper atmosphere and do the same thing.

  • j. THERE IS NO WAY TO MAKE THAT MANY LENS FLARES IN NATURE!!!!

    k. not polarizing the screen till up the rump of a yellow star = a blind crew... period...

    "L." scotty is significantly older then the rest of the crew... in the movie he was the same age (and though i loved the preformance... it wasn't scotty)

    m. warp mechanics were laid down by rodenberry... warp drive Nacels(spelled wrong) must come in pairs.. no odd numbers... you CANNOT have a warp reaction with out that... just fyi...

  • o. Phasers in the movie are more like toys the actual weapons...

    p. a laser like was used by the ship could kill planets anyways... it would completely destabilize the internal balances within a planet.

    Ok i could tear it even more holes... but this movie is already making swiss cheese look bad...

    Trust me.. this movie is a slap in the face to old school trekkies... it was poorly executed, poorly researched, and follows none of the deep lines of cannon...

  • You think a retard like irategamer can appreciate anything you've said?

  • i for one could care less about that.. it was a good movie and i enjoyed it immensely.. not very many ppl care about what you pointed out.. seriously.. you shoulda just left it alone.. it was an amazing movie

  • Did you some how miss the part where it's a completely alternate story simply containing the same characters?

  • Okay. So then how do you explain that Leonard Nimoy liked this movie so much, then?

  • look, did Scotty look young to you? I mean that guy plays the maine character in "Run fatboy run", where he's about 38 or something?! The rest of the crew is like 20years old or something...

  • While I agree with most of your points about the movie, there are actually a number of Federation ships with an odd number of Nacelles (Nebula Classes had 3, for example).

    To me, Scotty always seemed older than the rest of the crew anyway, so I didn't mind Simon Pegg. (Found him quite comical, actually.) My main gripe was Uhura; she was never such an entitled snot in the original series or movies.

    Uhura + Spock = WTF MATE?!

  • I found Pegg to be very funny - well my friend and I lol'ed. I agree with Uhura and Spock, that was uncessary and confusing I think but I'm pretty sure it was included to dash people's expectations that Kirk would be the one doing the scoring. Nice score Spock!

  • No one gives a fuck how many holes it had! You need to be less picky and go fuck a tribble.

  • Are all the positive reviewers related to JJ Abrams or do they all work as Paramount dupes?

    Character development? WTF. There was nothing new added to any of the characters that we didn't already know. Unless Kirk being an asshole, that's new.

    Not to mention it had a very weak story line. The biggest plot hole...why didn't Nero fly to Romulus, while in the past, and warn his government of the impending doom. And save his world and family?

    Answer: can you say contrived plot.

  • hey i have advice for you should interview mmorpg's you just review game system games like mario, sonic, and more but ive bin hopeing you would review mmorpg's like my favorite the most played mmorpg 4 years in a row runescape im not even shure youll even read this but if you do please take my advice! but even if you dont your reviews are still awousome!

  • what are you talking about i saw the movie and still don't know what you're talking about

  • get

    back

    to

    the

    games=]

  • The movie was well executed, but the premise for Nero's anger is stupid. Spock tried to help and failed. So what? Now, if Spock saved Vulcan instead of saving Romulus...THEN Nero would have a good reason to be pissed off.

  • A new movie fans will suck it a lot... *slurp, slurp, slurp* Suck on, little bastards, I know you like it...

  • go back to reviewing the fucking games. if we want to know about the movie we will see it our self

  • Get Back To rewiwing GAMES please i hate this but i like your GAME rewiwes a LOT!!!

  • your a video game reviewer not a movie reviewer

  • It's not the best one so far. Star Trek 2 wrath of Khan is. It's a better film than I thought it would be. Eric Bana is shit! As usual he was the weakest part. I feel that based on the actors in this movie JJ may attempt to go for a series either TV of cinema, much like the old style flash gordons, frequent fuilms churned out on a regular basis

  • Well I can say I was suprised with Star Trek, didn't expect it to be that good! The best one so far.

  • nice review, i totally agree with you. this movie kicks ass and i wanna see more ^^

    i also never was a great fan of the tos crew until this movie came out but i changed my mind and began watching the old vhs tapes from my dad xD

  • I loved the original StarTrek series, and the other more recent series. But I will say this, the movie IMO sucked. I was hoping more for a beginning of how earth came into contact with vaulkins, and started to get into space exploration. But I CAN NOT STAND the little girls and boys, that are barely able to comprehend anything talk about this movie. All I hear is, omg, he is so hot, or omg dude, she has some great ass tits.

    Anyways, ok movie, but not worth buying.

  • well ive never really been a fan of star trek so im seeing this from a different perspective, but can you really say that it sucked? i mean it had to be one of the greatest movies ive seen in years. for someone like myself that only knew a few things like who main characters were (spock and kirk) and pretty much nothing else, the movie really didn't rely on viewers knowing anything about star trek at all. it did a job of showing the characters of vaulkins and romulans.

  • hey dumbass. they already had a movie AND a series that took place directly on or NEAR first contact. pay attention. Star trek first contact and star trek enterprise.

  • agreed

  • power to ya CheeZanimation!

  • agreed x2

  • hey dumbasses.. without star trek star wars wouldnt be here. george lucas worked on this film and many other star trek sets. they arent meant to be compared. star trek came out first, star trek is more realistic. star wars is about pure fighting. come on stop being such a dumbass i mean really.

  • Star Wars is opera not fighting. The story revolves around a war, but it's not what the story is about.

  • Guys, I'm loath to do this, but ditch this review and watch mine for FUCK'S sake ...

    This is just some jerk with a mouthful of Cheetos with his hand in his pants.

    He's not even thinking about what he's saying. This isn't analytical. He doesn't back up what he's saying. It's not a review. Come on, folks!

  • dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days

  • this is funny

  • Yeah, I did it because I hate those chain messages on youtube.

    Cheers, mate.

  • rip off drom AVGN!!!!! :@

  • drom ?

    and if you want to say it right it's your a AVGN rip off i think hes a dick aswell but if your going to tell him that learn english

  • luv d moovy (lolololololololololololololol­ololololol)

  • omfg. jj abrams should stop making movies after that screw up with "cloverfield"

  • I dont think cloverfield was perticularly bad..it was just hyped way to much, building our hopes up, and letting us down a little bit.

    i think if they didnt bother with all the virals and stuff, and just sold it as a "movie"

    it would have been fine.

  • and it would have been nice if we where told wtf was going on. the creators where too fucking lazy to figure this shit out before they made the peice of shit.

  • But... thats the whole idea of the movie... if a real alien attack happend do you really think we would know alot about it?

  • I loved this movie too

    but this review is just alright.

    Chris you can do better than this!

  • IMO they wrapped everything up in that movie too quickly, as soon as kirk meets future spok the entire plot is cracked right open in 15 minutes its kinda bullshit.

  • Yeah thats great and all fucktard.

    But your fans want a video game review not a another movie review.

    AVGN has a new review out every two weeks. I was a fna of yours but your unwillingness to listen toy our fans and your ability to steal non stop from AVGN. Makes yout he complete worthless scumbag. I have wrote you 9 million times over and ove to debate with me. But your a fucking chicken shit.

    CHRIS BORES HATES HIS FANS!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I don't think he makes videos for his fans, just to voice his opinion. Just leave him alone...

  • well shut up and watch both cuz both are good

  • On the startreck movie, Thank u!!

    Thats exactly what i thot it didnt have any original story from, well- the original! they cudve done alot better on the story but the action was AMAZING! thanx for pointing that out its a good point!

  • After his review of X-Men Origins: Wolverine saying it was good and that he liked it. I can't take any review of his seriously. In other words I feel his reviews are suspect. And IG please allow us to give thumbs up and down on these comments

  • I hate trolls!!!!

  • i just passed like half the comentaries and its so sad to read all what pplz write...comparing...trolling..­.and the funny attemp to try to feel more than the other....

    i mean, how hard is to:

    1.- watch the video

    2.- post ur opinion

    (didnt liked it look for another video that u liked)

    3.-continue what u were doing....

    i liked the video...avgn its also good...

    but hey....no one is more than the other

  • no he doesnt faggot

  • This movie sucks balls.. YOu suck balls..

    Hell what happened to videogame reviews..

    You started to re post old reviews to get subscribers? or just to erase bad comments?

    Damn man.. what tha hell!

  • BORING

  • That's pretty lame that Data's resurrection is regulated to a comic book.

  • seriously he deserves some fucking screen time, no-one respects data anymore lol

  • Star Trek is for GEEKS.

  • no shit

  • Fuck you.

  • Why do people have to tag things?

    Why can't it simply be that Star Trek is for true sci-fi fans?

    Or Star Trek is for intellectuals?

    The word geeks and nerds is so outdated & so overly used.

  • No they´re not. No words are overused. There excists nothing such as an overused word. And if there ever was one, it would be the word "The". Every fucking comic book hero, movie villain, mysterious location and video game starts with the word "The".

  • You are misreading what I said. I am talking about people being referred as a geek or a nerd. And they are outdated and over used. OBVIOUSLY the most common used word in language is THE. FFS I was talking to gunnarernbald and their comment made. No word is over used? Hahaha. How about gay? The word gay is overused. OMG that is so gay. That word gay is over used.

    Now this will get the comments rolling lmfao

  • I knew what You were saying, but I couldn´t disagree more. "Nerd" and "Geek" are fantastic words. I think They need to be used way more. Then we may become more accepted by the public. I´m proud to be a nerd, and so should You.

  • I know by the true definition of the word nerd, that I am one, and I would proudly say i was one IF and WHEN there comes a time when nerds and geeks aren't treated like freaks and looked down upon. When I mention that I passionately love Star Trek, Star wars & even Doctor Who, I get treated differently, and not as an equal. Did you know that people get killed for being different? For dressing out of the boundaries of conformity?

    Proud to be a sci-fi fan :)

  • it beacuse at your age( or any age) you should be sleeping with girls

  • poor guy