THE GREAT BOOT FIASCO OF 2008!

[munn2006]

This is how I will always remember Shay Carl. RIP Shay.

[glamxglitter]

i liked the ones mommytard got

[xoluciee]

Light brown are nicer

[cireouslyme]

The kids were so little

[MarshDonky]

I like these old vlogs 

[DanaMarie54]

I find it hilarious that Shay has referenced this day, like, 10 times.

[swisscheese275]

I like mommytard's choice of boots better.

[SaskiaAndJessica]

@swisscheese275

I don't think they are still deciding, LOL :)

[Dadiddy97]

I tried to watch Shaytards vids before but I never really understood why there were so popular, so yesterday I was like "you know what,there has to be a reason, I should watch it from the start!" And now I'm hooked! Shaytard marathon!

[skyec2003]

brown boots and the black boots are gorgous and i can't decide?:I

[ShowWizard104]

I like the black ones....I don't think it matters now.

[pickle4432]

i like the black ones

[ElleCue93]

i like the brown ones

[kirbykickbut]

links in the side bar haven't heard that in a while!

[MonkeyWeasel22]

in one of katilette's videos didn't she say she got to keep both though?

[jaudue12]

@MonkeyWeasel22 yea she got to keep both pairs :P

[MonkeyWeasel22]

Sorry Shay, but i like the "garbage bag" ones better

[baconimos123]

i like the black ones betr!

[24torirox]

the sweet romantic shaycarl boots! :P sorry colette BUT HIS BOOTS ARE COOLER!

[funnylady2awesome]

Sorry kattilett but I have to go with shays boots.……

[PinkkSkittle]

lmao i love mommytards attitude about the boots. shay, they were $34 really? let the woman keep both! lmaooo he's such a goof

[CutieAsianChick]

omg sontard looks soooooooo young

[jimmyyao2010]

thumbs up if u r watching this in 2012

[jellibean41231]

@jimmyyao2010 no one is watching it in 2012 cause its not 2012 yet..

[FatThoughts]

Do you remember if She got to keep both pair Shay?

[xXstarburst00Xx]

aww the kids are so smaalllll!!! <3

[ThePetrucia]

I like the black ones :)

[peace1238ify]

i want some of the tan ones

[peaceloveemma2018]

I like the boots that Shay picked

[Bluesilvis]

shay has lost a lot of w11111eight!!!

thumbs up if you agree

[juice4life20]

lol ive been putting off the shaytards marathon for a long time.

[Chinkeyes78]

Shaytards<3

[ThePotatoescangiggle]

Just re-whatched this video :D Sontard and Princesstard are so cute a small :D They're still cute though...

[ChloeAnnamarie]

i remember this video!

[kabobman99]

i laughed so hard

[Moneeshy]

"you're not keeping both pair" LOL awww

[miaaa549]

I thought the ones that shay picked out were cuter! haha.

[Seventweengymnast]

black boots



[chole913]

iAd the same black boots!

[thickpooxbox360]

''You can smoke these if you're in a bind'' bahaha this dad is a hero!

[ThatAwesomeChick55]

black



[gymnasticsgirl1202]

Ppl u don't have to say which ones you like better now I am positive they picked already sheesh people r dumb

[jukey823]

lol katilette obviously likes the ones she picked out better but says she likes them both so she wont hurt shay's feelings. amirite?

[raayneboow]

thumbs up if your watching this in 2011 ! :D

[Sternhof]

@raayneboow try being more original next time.

[Aussiegirl265]

@raayneboow *you're

[sophiebridge988]

@raayneboow i would like but im finding the 69 likes pretty amusing :L

[baconimos123]

@raayneboow ok u know whats funny? i am starting to watch to shaytards like at the same time as everyone, like im watching ALL of them!

[BEASTYMUZIK]

@raayneboow im watching in 2012

[clunied]

Those are gaaay! haha

[xCookiexMonsterx15]

Shay curses nd uses dirty references more in his old vlogs

[ladielike12]

I have those boots that Shay bought! wow thats coool to know(: Hopefully Mommytard kept them so i can say i have the same boots as her

[lilahbell]

I liked the boots that Shay picked best :)

[MrDinosour97]

I had the fuzzy ones

[glamgorgeousxo]

was babytard born here?

[philpalmer4]

@glamgorgeousxo babytard is in the car seat next to son tard.

[AddieApple]

Brown

[jennieandpeterfan]

she gets to keep both so spoiled lol jaykay ily katilette

[AandW5454]

I don't get it, Shay weighs less now, and he doesn't wear his wedding ring. It should fit him right??

[samm2412]

but...i love both of them:)

[sparklebox11]

i hope mommytard got to keep both pairs of boots .. mommytard is so sweet 

[breeship]

@sparklebox11 ha yeah she kept them both

She said on her channel ha

[sparklebox11]

@breeship gr8! tnx for commenting :)

[PearlsAndGemz]

lol i remember when their use to be a "side bar" instead of the "description below" xD



[MagicalMaddi]

black ones

mommytards

[jordanthehunn]

what the!? i've been looking for this video forever and finally i found it. all i had to do was type in "shaytards boots" :p

[cupcake10120]

I had thoes brown boots

[Foreverlove2212]

I had those black boots!!!

[Jaroon88]

lol I didn't see the newest vlog yet :P this is actually the second time that I'm going trough his vids lol there is just nothing on tv :ddd

[ekepandadragon98]

Black boots

[brunette427]

black boots

[elizabethnmeilson]

I was so hoping they were the same

[AutomaticOcelot]

Spoiler alert: They're not the same boots.

[balleteveryday19]

i like shay's boots better :)

[Mr000410675]

the black ones

[LiLAngel1622]

Aww the kids look soo young here

[TheKkowalski65]

Shay's boots are cooler

[animalface327]

this was my first video of the shaytards and now i am hooked for life dont ever stop making videos. you rock and your my idol.

[ZeFreakLizard]

I like mommytards boots better (the black ones)

[mrsesme12345]

the one shay got r my favorite and i know this is old vid so do not say anything about it

[TheJacksonJR]

omgg ur kids are soo uteee back then lol

[juicymkluver]

firstt shoe sniffinggg

[juicymkluver]

firstt vlog on the old truckkk

[myb3ll3]

beige! haha

[iluvcharmed77]

Day 1 of "Watch all the shaytards videos from the beginning": 5/27/11 at 9:32 p.m!

[ArynneVengeance]

blackkkk :P

[michaeljacksonator]

black ones are better

[AnnaBananaHead11]

she ended uo with both of them soo ... :) love both of them :D but prefer the black one more ,, :D

[nati8408]

the black one is better :D

[musicjunkie4]

I have those boots.

[TANYATHESHAYTARDNOOB]

Both.

[TheLifelesslife]

i think she should have both

[fronkfam1]

andraiasidebarshirt

[GiovanniRose277]

I think mommytard should have both! love boots of any kind =D

[10meijuan]

i like the garbage bag boots better!!!

[xzaz2]

Black ones!!

[maayanoka]

0:23

thats so weird that from these SHAYTARDS vlogs i know he like the smell of new shoes [me too] so it wasnt bizzar for me when he sneffed the boot

[caddog0sugar]

I LOVE the tan boots! I like both and I think Mommytard should have both. Which did she end up keeping? Both, right?

[TheHandyTutorials]

no intro?



[alexafhal]

@TheHandyTutorials this is back when they weren't that big on youtube

[TheHandyTutorials]

@alexafhal ahhh ok =)

[crazyredsimpkins]

8/1148?

If the boots are the same, it's Fate. If the boots are different, then you got a nice gift for your wife.

The brown ones are cute, the black ones are sexy.

[nikkimouse252]

when they were about to open the shoes im thinking.. please be the same!... haha

[laveen13]

i like both



[laveen13]

i like both

[daddysgirl819]

I LIKE BOTH!!!! (but I like the hemp better ;))

[katzize26]

This is the first video I think I ever watched on the Shaytards channel. I found it from katilette's channel though.  Ah, memories. :-)

[emavix3]

tan boots

[coffeestainedphotos]

my sister has the brown ones.

[JessieGirl933]

i like the brown ones

[smercer75]

Totally like your pick Shay.....sorry Katilette!

[CatherinaArter]

i like the black one better

[mra2zee]

FTC'd

[avgscholar]

That is soooo sweet!!

[juliarose1224]

haha I know this is like two years later but I like the black ones better, sorry shay ]:

[kiaraguy]

I THINK MOMMY TARD GOT SOME GOOD BOOTS YET I LIKE SHAYS TO.

[rex1x1]

I think shays boots thumbs up if you agree

[amanysplendoredthing]

That is such a crazy coincidence! And how nice of you for getting a random present to surprise your wife with.

[djsux0rz69]

the black ones shay. sorry.. :) mommytards look better

[LanaBanana130]

I wish Shay hadn't said gay that way :(

[GreyMercury]

@LanaBanana130

You can't really be so uptight that you get offended by something a comedian says in jest?

[SpeCaro]

It would have been so epic if the boots where actually the same!

[THEREALBARBIE89]

okay i know this vid was forever agooo but i like the pair you picked shay! and i see there from payless i wonder if you guys still shop there.

[haleyweisman123]

keep both!!! lol

[kla0189]

It's been 3 years and he still making weed refrences. Lol. I love it! :D

[coliwood]

I guess this is when he realized the KIDS were the source.

[basicbooknerd]

i would always say the brown ones but the slouchy knee high boots are SO SO SO so in this 2010-2011 winter! but when they were in 2008 brown ones all zhe wayy

[iknowright1322]

Swet thought but black ones all the way

[PipaWonderland]

Such an young sontard! :D and the p-h-a-m-o-u-s boot fiasco! ^^

[beanibabieful]

Blck onesss

[cbboom]

i love the black ones there awesome

[cbboom]

i love the black ones

[Letmegotowonderland]

i totally forgot this! hahaha

[CJAllin]

Hey ShayCarl! Colintard here. FTCin' it up. Just pretend like the last few comments weren't so whiny! I've gotten over it, just gotta learn to choose to be happy, you know? Happiness is a choice! That's something I learned from a very wise man... I think it was Will Smith in that movie The Pursuit of Happyness, right?

[TheCindy210]

Sontard and Princesstard look so young

[AmandaMoo96]

Both boots are cute :]

[emmygerard]

I like the black ones better. Is it too late to take the other ones back?? LOL

[TheAppleGirl100]

HE NEVER DID DAILY VLOGS IN 2008 DID HE?!

[TheKkowalski65]

@TheAppleGirl100 of course he did!

[DespicableJessica]

Theblack boots are actually really hot lol =]

[1996missamanda2010]

the black ones :D

[8797mppau]

i have the black boots lol

[bellesmee]

I like the black ones

[livinlovinlifexoxo1]

I member this haha, wow I've been watching them for so long ha, love them!

[brookeosiel]

BLACK BOOTS!



[Bacoobs]

I HAVE THE BROWN BOOTS!!!!! I'm glad she kept them.

[cinnamonbuns121]

lol they're both ugly lmao

[remotecontrolaholic]

the brown boots

[1andonlyNatalieX]

@sillybabysinger I did the exact same thing!!

[forevernerds]

:D I love how so many people came because it was in a recent vlog.

[meeroar]

THUMBS UP IF YOU'RE WATCHING THIS BECAUSE MOMMYTARD WORE THESE BOOTS IN THE VLOG TODAY!!!

[mkarcherr]

sontard and princesstard are so cute 

[cindyluvsdemselandjb]

sorry shay, but the black boots are better.

i wonder if mommytard got to keep them both. i know she kept shay's, from the recent vlog. duh.

[MaddieMusic42]

Shay said it was the great boot fiasco of 2009 o_O

[muji2k6]

@MaddieMusic42 no he didnt

[xcarriejx]

Shay has good taste in boots, even though he hates them. lol

[bobisahappypony]

The only reason i watched this is cuz of da newest vid :)

[TheCupcakelova512]

i came cause of your newest video :)

[Benjamin723]

I, like many people, am only here because of Shay's newest video. :)

[Everydayfan101]

I bet everyone came to check out this vlog because of the recent vlog of shaytards

[tacosrule17]

@ porkypine1888 lol me too omg we did the same thing @ the same frikin moment

[kuroru07]

The great boot fiasco was mentioned last January 4, 2010 and then again with his recent vlog (November 24, 2010). The boots has sentimental value to them :D

[porkypine1888]

omg after i saw your resent video i had to watch this@!@@

[simplyme4815]

I want an egg mcmuffin.... O ya hemp boots :)

[hahaLOL360]

I came because of today's vlog... Like many others hehehe(:

[laurenandmaeve1026]

Ew fuggs

[benjyp1223]

I wanted to be a true shaytards fan... so i came to check it out!!! :)

[xFunkyGirlzx]

@benjyp1223 me2!!! haha