Added: 2 years ago
From: townie42
Views: 55,440
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (57)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Geez, people. Geez. In MY opinion, both versions are good. Amy gave a little more depth to the song with her voice performance, sounding like she really meant the lyrics and she tried to make it sound as good as possible. BUT, the instrumental was WAY off. TSP was better with the instrumental, but the voice was a bit off. I dunno, I just didn't FEEL the lyrics like I did when I heard the Evanescence version. Whatever you think, don't diss an artist just for a cover. IT'S NOT WORTH IT!

  • Love this song

  • why the fuck are we all talkign about Evanescence?! (never thought i would say that, i love them! and i actually do know, and as much as i love Amy, she ruined the song) This is Smashing Pumpkins! So listen to the amazing music and shut up!

  • @3BsAlaska hmm

  • fighting on the internet is like the special Olympics, wait....never mind even they are smarter

  • I think evanescence is more know for bad covers than they are for there own music. Not to mention they've stolen song titles from like 80 different people.

  • @DontOrderTheSoup They haven't stole any song title, and if you reffer to lithium,, it has nothing in common with nirvana's lithium song.

  • I love both versions of the song, so to the people fighting about who did the song better (TSP or Evanescence) please shut up. I love both bands, and they both did a great job.

  • I like the Evanescence version...

  • AND I always have to think about Zero Kiryuu while listening to this epic song :/

    and nooooo...I´m not some crazy Zero fangirl....don´t think that. XD

  • I LOVE this song & Smashing Pumpkins :)

  • Billy Corgan is a genius. Evanesence shouldn't even be allowed to play this.

  • i like evanescence better :)

  • @estefiborges STFU

  • @jumpinjoe88

    um im not here to pick a friggen fight, this is my opinion, i like this song but i like evanescence better im not trying to diss anyone but i do like evanescnece better:) ok bye

  • Gooooooooooooood. I love Smashing Pumpkins.

  • who cares who did it better?? this isnt twilight they both did an awesome job anyway ENJOY THE MUSIC :P

  • @EvFansOfficle Couldnt agree more

  • Who cares who did it better?

  • I like the smashing pumpkins version instead of evanescence

  • Mmm i like the smashing pumpkins version better :)

  • Two fat Evanescence fans watched this video and disliked it.

  • pretty much sums up the last year of my life...

  • This is EPIC.

  • Evanescence covered it SO better!!

  • @nibluana No actually, the singer from evanescence completely and utterly massacared a very good song, and i sincerely hope she never covers another smashing pumpkins song because i may just slice off my ears so i will never have to hear a sad excuse of a cover song like the one she already did.

  • @bigfatmac93

    LoL... I just dont like voice from this singer its really...ugh... But i LOVE voice from Amy... and nope...every song Amy made or covered it's good..... awesome! And I will never change my opinion about it... soo....

  • Evanescence cover it SO better!!!!

  • Smashing Pumpkins makes me wish I was born eariler.

  • I love both versions, but I think Amy Lee does it better. But maybe it's just because I love everything Amy does....... :)

  • @DivaOfDarkness101 i take covers as tributes. And Billy is master in emotional songs. Full of hatred, sadness, alienation. I guess Elvis Presley for my generation....

  • Smashing pumpkins, I love them.

  • i love evanescence, but the original is always better

  • The Solo is six string heaven

    addictive really and I need more!

  • Song is awsome

  • Cool song, love it. I like Evanescence, but I like this version better. Honestly, I don't really like cover songs all that much period. So whatever...

  • @woundedrebel117 This is actually a cover song and evanessence is the original artist of the song??? wow I had no idea. cool

  • @jebman18 No. Evanessence covered this. Terribly. But thats what you get for letting radio bands cover real bands songs

  • @XxriflexpertxX me 2...

  • i like it but the remake by evanescence is better.

  • @Ochibobogal I thought she fucked it up

  • @Kabucow she did

  • @Kabucow no evanescence cover is better!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @guyanaboi122 I will... hahaha come on dude its just my opinion doesnt mean its true ;)

  • @thanosls1 she ruined it

  • @Kabucow she did

  • @Kabucow I agree.

  • @Ochibobogal yeah its better than this...

  • @Ochibobogal how can you the cover man thats cover was bullshit

    so taylor gang or listen to the cover while suckin a dick!!

  • @Ochibobogal

    No.

  • this is GREAT song

  • awesome song

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more