If I had wanted to just hear the song I would of put my Waterboys CD on, as it was I found myself on this video sharing site in search of a little more.
'Mike' Scott (born 14 December 1958 in Edinburgh, Scotland) is the founding member and chief songwriter of rock band The Waterboys. ... Also a good friend
@Prancer1231 Yes, the best song, but not the best version. I'm sure you did not hear the SCAFELL PIKE version, which is very rare and absolutely the BEST version of this song ever. So unfortunately noone posted it on Youtube yet. I tell you, after hearing it, you will reevaluate your opinion. Anyway the second best is the WATERBOYS version ! That's true.
@sue8765 the song is scottish but the waterboys aren't. correct they were formed in edinburgh but they're a mixture of scottish irish and english musicians
Setim se uvek jednog dobrog kluba u kojem se pre 20-tak godina slusala izvaredna muzika,negde u Srbiji,a zvao se Bahus.Tamo sam i cuo ovu divnu stvar.Prepoznace neko ovo o cemu pricam !
Just looked up Celtic Thunder there cos everyone seems to be talkin bout their version of the song. Plastic paddy bullshit. If ya wanna hear a decent version by a true Irish artist, Christy Moore is it. Much respect to the Waterboys too. Love Stolen Child.
Wow - I just watched the Celtic thunder one - what Americanised weirdness! How can you preffer that psudo-folk over the Waterboys? Sorry if the Scotish rr's trouble you (actually i'm not). There is no orchistra, its folk music - it has a band. Try mad dog mcrea version...
I like the version from Somerset, England - the lyrics are more bloody.
unlike the idiots, celic thunder has to appeal to audiences all over the world. and unlike these people they have talent. This version puts people to sleep. Celtic Thunder version gets people up and clapping, so everyone dissing celtic thunder get your shit together and learn what some real music sounds like.
Barely understand? You can't make out a Scottish accent in Celtic music?
You're listening to Celtic music why?
My main problem with Celtic Thunder's version is there's nothing Celtic about them. They managed to take away the waltz beat this has and make it a decidedly non-celtic song.
They're good vocalists, but they should stick to Broadway, where they belong.
celtic thunder is about appealing to everyone. If they sang their sogns like these idiots, they would never get past ireland. and i severely doubt you can classift celtic thunder as "pop" considering they have a 50 peice orchestra.
But were proud of all our small little celtic acts there more us... celtic thunder are a big joke to any irish man/woman that likes there celtic music... As someone else said before me theres nothing celtic about them... I'm not dissing there work as such but for people to come on and say celtic thunder are better obviously don't know or appreciate proper celtic music!!
what you make in 40 minutes outstrips what many make in hours. I quite like the video. Until about half an hour ago, I'd never heard of the waterboys, but they are the awesomeness :-)
I think the scots accent adds something to this already brilliant song. The song originated after all I believe in the North-East of Scotland, home of so many great ballads.
@Slievedubh no its a border ballad from dumfrieshire recorded in the 18th century skene manuscript, 1740 Tea Time misulleny both of which are scottish and in 1840 Childes Border ballads of england and scotland where Childe said it was a very old scots tune. The events were recorded as happening in 1640 when Lady Jane Cassiles of Ayrshire ran off with a border gypsy called Davie Faa. Faw is of course still a well known border gypsy surname even to this day.
they dont coordinate outfits! their all all dressed similar so that he focus doesnt go on one member more than the other. Wearing suits represents them showing effort and class. If you wanna be a sloppy musician, by all means dress like the bafoons.
Careful who you're insulting there, fella. There's a whole host of actual musicians, The Dubliners, The Chieftains, Planxty and all many more besides were by no means sloppy or unclassy and they wouldn't need a fancy wardrobe to put that boyband of yours to shame on every front.
I couldn't be arsed with the Celtic Thunder version; it wasn't as lively as this song at all and that huge drum inclusion was taking the piss. This is the best and sounds as it is originally intended.
Kale Lad, it has always been so. Throughout history there have been many songs/ stories and poems that romanticize the lifestyle of the Rom.
My family is Ruminschell. They found peace in the US running horse auction barns. I find thr song whimsical and amusing. My grandfather went on to write more stanzas for it as a joke about how the gypsy then turned around and offered the lady back to her family for ransom and the hilarity that ensued.
strange how the celt sings about gypsy yet as Kale Gypsies(my family and i)were hated throughout Ireland and U.k we found peace in Australia...australians just see us as 'aussies'..
A few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the babysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this letter on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand(SORRY BOUT SPAM THIS REALLY FREAKS ME
Det er keltisk musik så det "batter - det dur bare"
kenetha123 1 week ago
Someone uses Videostudio xD
kowetas 2 months ago
@kowetas
...very, very badly
MrPaddyelvis 1 month ago
Here's a video I made that has no relevance at all
MrPaddyelvis 5 months ago
@MrPaddyelvis What does it matter you get still get to hear the song
pinkixtheEMO 1 month ago
@pinkixtheEMO
If I had wanted to just hear the song I would of put my Waterboys CD on, as it was I found myself on this video sharing site in search of a little more.
Thanx for your concerns, big love, Paddyx.
MrPaddyelvis 1 month ago
The best version I ever heard of this song is from Rapalje!!! <3
Salzblut 6 months ago
It's almost sick how good this damn track is
Flexipop76 8 months ago
anyone else notice the similarities (sp) between this song and scallliwag by gaelic storm? haha
2DCin3D 9 months ago
i love the video, it is every clip with the corel video shop haha
grimjimmy 1 year ago
you cant bate class
seanamhoinin 1 year ago
'Mike' Scott (born 14 December 1958 in Edinburgh, Scotland) is the founding member and chief songwriter of rock band The Waterboys. ... Also a good friend
lozannii 1 year ago
best song ever
Prancer1231 1 year ago
@Prancer1231 concur fine version were ye danc'in ?
nalla3 1 year ago
@nalla3 Were ye askin?
Johnny89Bravo 1 year ago
@Johnny89Bravo if ye were danc'in to the tune !
nalla3 1 year ago
@Prancer1231 Yes, the best song, but not the best version. I'm sure you did not hear the SCAFELL PIKE version, which is very rare and absolutely the BEST version of this song ever. So unfortunately noone posted it on Youtube yet. I tell you, after hearing it, you will reevaluate your opinion. Anyway the second best is the WATERBOYS version ! That's true.
levediagyermeke 11 months ago
Bloody fantastic, from my favourite album 'Room to Roam'
Scots accent - IRISH ya numpty!!!!!
happeecow 1 year ago
@happeecow no it's Scottish--Waterboys are Scottish
sue8765 1 year ago
@sue8765 at least the singer is
sue8765 1 year ago
@sue8765 the song is scottish but the waterboys aren't. correct they were formed in edinburgh but they're a mixture of scottish irish and english musicians
splodged1986 1 year ago
@splodged1986 Well Mike Scott is the only founding member left in the band and he's Scottish so... Hm...
aliencheesemaker 8 months ago
this for me would be the definitive version.
MrBowsmith 1 year ago
My favorite version of a song I have know all my life!
dryadStone 1 year ago
Bestial música do álbum "Room to Roam", de 1990. A versão single de "Fisherman`s Blues" tinha no lado B esta música ao vivo!
matramoura68 1 year ago
really fine, one of the best tracks on there apart from upon the wind and waves, really the best track, wickham brought something to the band
janfreidun 1 year ago
when did this song came out?
kvitekristus 1 year ago
I have heard many versions of this tune and this is, musically and lyrically the most delightful and enjoyable of them.
(it took another version of the song to actually understand what was the words to the song were).
ztall 1 year ago 2
I am of gypsy desent and I love the song!
TheClassicgeek 1 year ago
video is rubbish...but a song SO GOOD ,it doesnt matter,love that song so much!! brilliant
MsBatkat 1 year ago
Ah, me bullocks (LOL).
This video rocks (ROFL)!
The song is better, though.
:-)
ObaNarayanShivaji999 1 year ago
can I see U do better ???
Tomorer 1 year ago
I like this version much better.
rositante 2 years ago
Setim se uvek jednog dobrog kluba u kojem se pre 20-tak godina slusala izvaredna muzika,negde u Srbiji,a zvao se Bahus.Tamo sam i cuo ovu divnu stvar.Prepoznace neko ovo o cemu pricam !
vrangel71 2 years ago
Is the gypsy supposed to be a man or a woman?
xxXxSiLeNcExXxx 2 years ago
@xxXxSiLeNcExXxx The gypsy is a man and he run away with a wealthy wife.
knkmary 2 years ago
Beautiful music. I recently discovered Waterboys. I like them!!!
knkmary 2 years ago
One of their best
timdalf 2 years ago
Classic
jmulhall86 2 years ago
first of all... Celtic Thunder is not a boyband. second of all, i love this version too because they have all the verses!! i wish CT did
celticgirl91 2 years ago
Why is this song so addictive?!
nwsbysboomerang 2 years ago 4
Because its excellent. :)
sidensvans67 2 years ago 4
it is addictive isn't it? Carlos' version is excellent too
DeliaFBable 2 years ago
I really love this song!
Greetings from Sweden
Tenahio 2 years ago
Mike Scott with Sharon Shannon (on squeezbox) version, is truely the best version ever of this song.
SeanMcGurk 2 years ago
Checked out Celtic Thunder.What a joke! was waiting for Flatley to prance down the stage ha ha.Rock on Waterbo'ys.
tqued25 2 years ago
Just looked up Celtic Thunder there cos everyone seems to be talkin bout their version of the song. Plastic paddy bullshit. If ya wanna hear a decent version by a true Irish artist, Christy Moore is it. Much respect to the Waterboys too. Love Stolen Child.
cailinaschilldara 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like Celtic Thunder's version better. This one has too many rolled "r"s. And the orchestra in the background is too folk music-y.
Chewby92 2 years ago
Wow - I just watched the Celtic thunder one - what Americanised weirdness! How can you preffer that psudo-folk over the Waterboys? Sorry if the Scotish rr's trouble you (actually i'm not). There is no orchistra, its folk music - it has a band. Try mad dog mcrea version...
I like the version from Somerset, England - the lyrics are more bloody.
nd017 2 years ago
unlike the idiots, celic thunder has to appeal to audiences all over the world. and unlike these people they have talent. This version puts people to sleep. Celtic Thunder version gets people up and clapping, so everyone dissing celtic thunder get your shit together and learn what some real music sounds like.
kelseyhaha 2 years ago
ya know, if you're being PC, this should be called the raggle taggle traveller.
my ass, it should! lol
sugarpuffsandwich 2 years ago
i love The Waterboys
bansheetwin 2 years ago
I could swear they wrote a version of this that was slightly faster... or maybe it's my imagination
MrMoneymadManiac 2 years ago
nope, you are right, it does sound a little slow
ZeDollyDots 2 years ago
what does the video have to do with the music??
joelpi47 2 years ago
@Celticthunderrules:I´m from Germany and I haven´t got any problems to understand... Where´re you from?
svfkeeper 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
celtic thunder makes it sound better these guys u can barely understand
CelticthunderRules 3 years ago
Yes, because this is REAL celtic music and Celtic Thunder is pop. This is how it's supposed to sound.
Whoo, sorry, slightly bias.
notthefrenchman 2 years ago 17
@notthefrenchman aye, and the album would be... 'fisherman's blues'? it's been so many a year I hardly can recall, me lads and lassie-ohs
MrThomasdrewsen 1 year ago
@MrThomasdrewsen this is Room to Roam, but Fishermans Blues is another great
430CurlyJo 11 months ago
Barely understand? You can't make out a Scottish accent in Celtic music?
You're listening to Celtic music why?
My main problem with Celtic Thunder's version is there's nothing Celtic about them. They managed to take away the waltz beat this has and make it a decidedly non-celtic song.
They're good vocalists, but they should stick to Broadway, where they belong.
jacksquat3 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
phoenix1916 2 years ago
Bullshit u wont ever beat the original and at least these guys sing live not like the pansys on some of ur vids were they mime the words!!!
phoenix1916 2 years ago
your off your head if u like celtic music you'll like this celtic thunder are just all about a stage show...
djdarren40 2 years ago
celtic thunder is about appealing to everyone. If they sang their sogns like these idiots, they would never get past ireland. and i severely doubt you can classift celtic thunder as "pop" considering they have a 50 peice orchestra.
kelseyhaha 2 years ago
But were proud of all our small little celtic acts there more us... celtic thunder are a big joke to any irish man/woman that likes there celtic music... As someone else said before me theres nothing celtic about them... I'm not dissing there work as such but for people to come on and say celtic thunder are better obviously don't know or appreciate proper celtic music!!
djdarren40 2 years ago
fabulous Waterboys.....Mike Scott in concert is FANTASTIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hokahey65 3 years ago
So, what does this video have to do with the song?
Irishflyboy255 3 years ago
this video is brilliant
joeymustardlips 3 years ago
what you make in 40 minutes outstrips what many make in hours. I quite like the video. Until about half an hour ago, I'd never heard of the waterboys, but they are the awesomeness :-)
PS89 3 years ago
Old skool, people...old skool...
PLANXTY!
neilandfi 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this isnt bad but Celtic Thunder is better
sebsgirl78 3 years ago
cetic thunder? pah.
simyan2008 3 years ago 5
Pfft, Celtic thunder do the best version of this song!
celticbabbe 3 years ago
I like the music from Celtic Thunder's Version, I just wish they had all these lyrics to that music.
joelpi47 3 years ago
FINALLY people that arent going to diss celtic thunder. thank god, i was beginning to lose hope! :)
kelseyhaha 2 years ago
I really like both versions. I too would love to hear Celtic Thunder add the other verses!
oliviabradshaw88 2 years ago
I think the scots accent adds something to this already brilliant song. The song originated after all I believe in the North-East of Scotland, home of so many great ballads.
Slievedubh 3 years ago 19
@Slievedubh no its a border ballad from dumfrieshire recorded in the 18th century skene manuscript, 1740 Tea Time misulleny both of which are scottish and in 1840 Childes Border ballads of england and scotland where Childe said it was a very old scots tune. The events were recorded as happening in 1640 when Lady Jane Cassiles of Ayrshire ran off with a border gypsy called Davie Faa. Faw is of course still a well known border gypsy surname even to this day.
seonidh 8 months ago
@Slievedubh , Right on.
I copied your comment and notthefrencman's and added it to the comments to the video i captured at Waterford's Tall Ships and posted to youtube.
Hy
RedKruzer 6 months ago
Celtic Thunder has a better beat! but no harm to this song...its pretty good too?
Ashababy0697 3 years ago
Celtic Thunder actually makes this song less Celtic...funny how that works, eh? They're a pop group, not a Celtic band.
jacksquat3 3 years ago 6
yeah too many gimmicks and dance routines. They co-ordinate their outfit for gods sake!
sirius711 3 years ago
they dont coordinate outfits! their all all dressed similar so that he focus doesnt go on one member more than the other. Wearing suits represents them showing effort and class. If you wanna be a sloppy musician, by all means dress like the bafoons.
kelseyhaha 2 years ago
Careful who you're insulting there, fella. There's a whole host of actual musicians, The Dubliners, The Chieftains, Planxty and all many more besides were by no means sloppy or unclassy and they wouldn't need a fancy wardrobe to put that boyband of yours to shame on every front.
sirius711 2 years ago
weird comment
nd017 2 years ago
Damh the Bard's version is so much better. Or even The Dolmen's!
alosel2 3 years ago
wow...i used 2 like celtic thunder but then i heard this...WAY better! :)
rocketscientist36 3 years ago 2
Raggle taggle gypsy is a scots ballad .. this is the best version sung by Mike Scott who is a scot.
Fraterculae 3 years ago 3
sounds like he is singing in a shitty bar in the bogs. Bad job.
gobsmackedpaddy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is HORRABLE!
Celtic Thunder can out sing these people any day!
jenjen135 3 years ago
By far the best version. Mike´s accent is so perfect.
mgillving 3 years ago
I couldn't be arsed with the Celtic Thunder version; it wasn't as lively as this song at all and that huge drum inclusion was taking the piss. This is the best and sounds as it is originally intended.
hayleybaileys 3 years ago
celtic thunder does it better.
:)
childoftheking568 3 years ago
i couldnt agree more with childoftheking568
jenjen135 3 years ago
Kale Lad, it has always been so. Throughout history there have been many songs/ stories and poems that romanticize the lifestyle of the Rom.
My family is Ruminschell. They found peace in the US running horse auction barns. I find thr song whimsical and amusing. My grandfather went on to write more stanzas for it as a joke about how the gypsy then turned around and offered the lady back to her family for ransom and the hilarity that ensued.
jhilhan 3 years ago
il video è di una povertà allucinante
indo1091 3 years ago
love this song.
loopydoug 3 years ago
in song that is
KaleLad 3 years ago
i love this songwriter and his band waterboys...no offence to the celt..i just interested how there is fascination with the gypsy//
KaleLad 3 years ago
strange how the celt sings about gypsy yet as Kale Gypsies(my family and i)were hated throughout Ireland and U.k we found peace in Australia...australians just see us as 'aussies'..
KaleLad 3 years ago
Exactly, the Lord inquirin' for his Lady oh! Because The Gypsie "Stole her"
chrisvscrispychicken 3 years ago
Fantastic! its Grand!
Sp1tf1r3p1l0t 3 years ago
this song you remember all your life ......i know
WANKPANKAKE 3 years ago
Aww i love this song, it makes me so happy!
cutencurly29 3 years ago
Great song, Intresting video with it?:)
thewaterboys1989 3 years ago
when me n my friend first heard this song we thought it was in swedish or something XD awesome.
fuzzystrange 3 years ago
Thanks for posting.
trejos28 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the babysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this letter on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand(SORRY BOUT SPAM THIS REALLY FREAKS ME
CPR9532 3 years ago