Added: 3 months ago
From: earMUSICofficial
Views: 59,304
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (224)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • How many songs are from this dvd'

  • ihana ääni,aivan ihanaa,vilun väreet menee aina kun kuuntelen tätä.pidän todella paljon tästä.

  • Тарья - супер!!!!

  • I just love Tarja!!!

    

  • esa cancion no es de nightwish acaso... o Tarja la compuso??

  • Regret that i didnt go to the "End of an era" consert.

    Dont feel like going to watch Nightwish without Tarja:-/

  • @sithlevi You're right... those two ladies are uncomparable...

  • I LIKE THIS,AND TARJA IS THE BEST

  • ihana olla suomalainen,kun on näin HYVÄ,KAUNIS NAINEN LAULAA,JA TODELLA HYVÄ ÄÄNI.hyvä Tarja.

  • What a beautiful voice! She sings like an angel!!

  • Comment removed

  • Как всегда на высоте!!!!!!!

  • Tarja is GREAT but backing music is pure blasphemy, a kind of music that you will expect at amusement park

    .

  • her voice overpowers the instruments.... still

  • She was much better early but that's ok - we all are older and the voice also.

  • owww hermosisima cancion!! y la voz de tarja no se diga :3

    y no se lo q haya dicho el ruso pro se ve bn xD

  • :)

    

  • Perfect! What a magic voice! Waiting Tarja in Vilnius!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

  • This version of Walking in the air was recorded two years ago. IMO, Tarja sings the same song better in the new videos recorded during her 2011 Christmas tour. E.g., in the video recorded in her ex-home town church Kuusankoski 14.12.2011 I cannot hear the annoying articulation I hear in the present video, there she sings beautifully.

    Tarja´s Christmas tour with Harus was successful with outsold venues.

  • ЭТО ПРОСТО ЧУДО ФАНТАСТИКА! Я ЕЁ ОБАЖАЮ! ХРЕН КТО ЕЁ ПЕРЕПЛЮНЕТ!

  • Comment removed

  • En tiennytkään että Seppo Suppo Taalasmaa soittaa tässä urkuja.

  • -What's that?

    -where?

    -up in the sky.

    -I guess it's a plane.

    -no, it's a pigeon.

    -no - fly !

    -No! it's Tarja walking in the air :)

  • this song is a Christmas song that is played every Christmas in Finland. It is originally British, but it is a household name in Finland:)

  • to me this sounds 10 times more nightwish than imagenaerum...

  • @wiltzer1 haha the joke of the year! i bet she'll sing Slow, Love, Slow in operaric style! so pathetic :( Nightwish are 100 times better without her.

  • @viikatee do you believe in your own words?

  • 100 times better.....!!!! malaka you are THE JOKE OF THE CENTURY::go listen to justin bieber now

  • @viikatee hahahahahahahahahaahahahahahaa­hahahaha looks WHO'S talking hahahahahahahahaahahahahaahaha­hahahahahaahahahahahahahahahah­ahahahahaahahhahahahahahaahhaa­hahahahahahahahhaahahahahahaha­hhahahahahahahahahahahahahahah­ahahaahhahahaahahhaahah OH MY FUCKING GOD hahahahahaa THIS GUY IS HILARIOUS ....... i understand you having a lot of complexes..its ok..i understand....goodnight WC Boy

  • @wiltzer1 Ελεος ρε....

  • @77elvistheking τι ρε

  • @wiltzer1 Τον ειπες μαλακα!

    Back in Topic! Tarja FOREVER!

  • @77elvistheking σιγα μη τον αφηνα τον ριρικο χεχε Tarja re!!!

  • @wiltzer1 XAXAXAXA Ετσι ρε. Πανε κανε ενα like στο Ελληνικο Top Comment στο phantom of the opera των Nightwish με τα 10.000.000+ views.

    Ετσι να γινει Greek Invasion!

  • Comment removed

  • Sure is better because Nightwish have a pop singer now with averege voice potential! Listening Anette during concerts proves it precisely! hahaha! Now Within Temptation, Epica, Leave's Eyes, Lacuna Coil are rule with the singers with great voices!

  • @Buenovista73 hope simone from epica sings better than she did in their last tour, her lyrical voice wasn´t good enough most of the times (some exeptions like paradiso)

  • @viikatee HHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHA That comment will make 90% of Nightwish fans laugh their asses!

    Tarja Forever!

  • @wiltzer1 Why don't you stop comparing Tarja with Anette? Different doesn't mean worse!

    If you don't like the new Nightwish' style don't listen to it!

  • @wiltzer1

    Imagenaerum is an interesting experiment. It's kinda nice, Anette has her moments. But I'm not about to start an argument here. Nightwish was A LOT better w. Tarja. Anette sounds like a child next to her. Tarja is lightyears ahead of Anette...

  • @TheSirOrion Agree but I can't go against Anette anyway, if someone is to blame it's Tuomas and other members that didn't even try to help Tarja as they do with Anette now.

    Anyway, Tarja is awesome at whatever she do! Love her!

  • @wiltzer1 For me too

  • Tarja doesn't do magic with her voice. She has magic in her soul. <3

  • Comment removed

  • OOHHH HOW I LOVE HER!!! IM HYPNOTIZED!!!!

  • stop to talk! my angel is singing <3

  • @RashHunt Yeah, they have a composer but don't seem to have a great, powerful female voice. Sad, but true.

  • @RashHunt This IS NOT Nightwish song asshole....!!!

  • @MyloveforTarja I never claimed it was, you illiterate shrew

  • I really cannot see or hear, how in the world (we must be living in the different planets) this so called performance is a beautiful one.

    THIS IS A DISASTER ! GOD HELP US !

  • This version is so quiet and mellow, I like it

    It really sets the mood for a lovely xmas

    Ps Tarja has always sung this song this way, only difference is that this version is slower paced and with fewer instuments. But its a great version imo

  • Hmmm.... i'm not sure this song can support her vibrato range. This song is supposed to be still and stay on pitch. I think its an interesting adaptation but i'm not sure it works. This song is designed for a "silver" voice.

    Love Tarja :)

  • @UrMYM0nk1e

    She has perfect control over her vibrato and could use less, but this is the way she saw this performance. This is what a true artist does and this is what I like mostly about her.

    Here's a "bluesy" one with a shorter vibrato /watch?v=vRqdrTxrcq0

    And an "operatic" one with full vibrato /watch?v=oEqlToqluNs

    A "pop-ish" one with a light vibrato /watch?v=PfVJu4ERDBQ&feature=r­elated

  • Tarja does not even know what the music is anything but soap opera squeals

  • @mikke11223 And you're saying this about the person who studied and trained herself about music before, meanwhile and after Nightwish? And writes her own songs these days?

  • Tarja makes any song sound beautiful. its not just because she can sing, its her voice aswell. There are no tones or notes that are not pleasing to hear.

  • Nightwish would be regret to lose Tarja DEARLY.

  • I'm getting tired of all this orchestra versions,I prefeir the original one,this could only be good

    for one night and the satisfaction of the singer.Where is All the power and the epic of the original version?

  • @CRZ4QR

    "All the power and the epic of the original version?"

    POWER???

    "Walking in the Air" is a song written by Howard Blake for the 1982 animated film of Raymond Briggs' 1978 children's book The Snowman. In the film the song was performed by St Paul's Cathedral choirboy Peter Auty"

    Original

    watch?v=ubeVUnGQOIk

    "tired of all this orchestra versions"

    :)  :P

  • Must have been a magic night. Classic Tarja is so beautiful. <3

  • estou mto feliz pela a tarja por esse belo concerto classico que ela fez com harus parabens tarja belissimo trabalho abraços

  • Hay no me muero me muero, que hermoso, es mucho mejor que cuando la cantaba con NW

  • Todos sabemos la genialidad de Tarja, y a todos nos gusta la musica que canta. Pero lo novedoso, y la reinvencion de un artista, sin perder su escencia (LO CUAL TARJA SABE HACER DE LAS MIL MARAVILLAS) es lo que decide su permanencia en entre los gustos del publico, y el aumento de su exito. Asi, Tarja se reinventa con cada disco de rasgos en metal. Pero tambien cuida de su carrera Clasica sin, por ello perder seguidores. Por el contrario !LLAMA LA ATENCION DE FUTUROS ADMIRADORES!

  • Me Gusta Mucho como compone Tarja, y sinceramente considero que ella es, de por si brillante en cuanto a desempenio vocal, y tecnica. Sin embargo vuelvo a coincidir con varios, y es obvio que a muchos les incomoda esto, pero es veridico> Un artista estancado, que reutiliza y reutiliza, y reutiliza los temas, como (consideramos que aun no sucede, pero puede pasar) a Tarja le empieza a ocurrir, sencillamente deja de llamar la atencion del publico.

  • Tarja the best, this music is magic.

  • Тарья просто великолепна!

  • I know, that I do not have to say this, but I do it anyway...The Original is Peter Auty !

  • LINDA, TARJA DEUSA DO METAL OPERA ^^

  • mira tarja , cantas muy bien, pero seguis robando con los mismos temas. ya se, algunos me putearan por decir esto, pero asi es. ojo ahora me van a decir que nightwish hace lo mismo, lo hace pero ahora no creo, pero tarja se sarpa mas, no digo que cante mal, solo que sige metiendo temas viejos y haciendose lucir con otros cantantes, tarja no sabe componer, ni tampoco es profesional, osea una opera es mas heavy que esto XD bueno, fue mi opinion, si no te gusta, ignora,pero algunos se gastaran..

  • @dark7700 a la gente le gustan los temas de nightwish, por eso los canta, compuso la mayor parte de What Lies Beneath, y canta los temas de nightwish porque anette no lo hace bien, 2 o 3 temas de nightwish a lo mucho en un concierto y eso te parece demasiado???

  • Yes. really nice voice from Tarja. She dont need to be part of Nightwish. This voice is here in the right place!

    Anette and the song Storytime is amazing and Anette is better for Nightwish.

    Good luck to Tarja.

  • Дякую Тарья !

  • This is Real Music ! Thank you Tarja <3

  • TARJA! <3!!!!!!

  • Grande Tarja!!!

  • B.E.A.U.T.I.F.U.L!!! *-* Love her!

  • Tämä on helvetin ruma esitys. Alkuperäinen on PALJON parempi !

  • მიყვარს ეს ქალი,ციდან გამოგზავნილ ანგელოზს ჰგავს

  • Excellent !!!

  • she sang well,dressed well, and beautiful..it's just so amazing..if you still complaining or dislike the video..just shit on your pants as you don't know what is music and melody.

  • IMPECABLEEEEEEEEEE,,,,,,,,!!!!­

  • @ISeeAnIdiot: Stealing? Walking in the Air is a fair cover. And if you refer to Imaginaerum - it has nothing to do with the Imaginarium of Doctor Panassus or something like that.

  • Nose porque pero esta version me gusta mucho mas que la de nightwish, tiene un toque magico, relajante nose esta version es especial

    me encanta.

  • Tarja is an outstanding vocalist, but... sorry, that's by far the most bad version of this song I've ever heard. Where's the power the Nightwish version has? I don't say that she should do always the same, but she could use her voice far better than that, and I guess we all know it, even the die-hard Tarja fans.

    Sorry, but in my humbe opinion Tarja's nothing without Nightwish while Nightwish can stand their ground without her.

  • @EndOfDeceive are you stupid or what? This is NOT NW version at all and it's for a CLASSICAL project of hers. CLASSICAL, not metal and she is using her vocals better than in her time with NW. So stick your humble opinion in your ass, douchebag. Tarja without Nightwish is still Tarja and she is not interested in repeating what she once had with the band.

  • @TheAmaranthObsession do you even bother replying to such an opinion? what you said was so obvious that i can't believe someone can say something in opposite! :) do not care, simply. ;)

  • @hissingatrocity yay! you're right but i'm fed up with people criticizing her with no argument other than "NW version was better". -.-

  • @TheAmaranthObsession if you consider that in my opinion most of her versions are better than the "original" ones... ;) not to mention "her" songs which, no secret for anyone, i can't even compare with the same ones played nowadays. no offense attached, of course. :) fact is that,sadly,nightwish fed through the years a solid group of fanbase mostly in their teens and who mostly don't know anything about real music, meaning the fact that almost EVERY musician out there plays songs of his/her(...)

  • previous band, and has all the rights to do it - besides the "emotional" rights since he/she played those songs before and they are in his/her heart as well in his/her fans's. a little knowledge in music that is not 2000's commercial pop would be enough to understand it but hell. let them play with their roles if they enjoy it that much.

  • @hissingatrocity excellent!! you've really spoken for many others who think like you do! =) your comments made my day!

  • @TheAmaranthObsession glad about it, friend. :) and now let's stop all this us ourselves and just enjoy what we like.

  • @TheAmaranthObsession: I don't know where you come from, but here in Germany it's allowed to express your own opinion. You're free to see things different ;)

  • @Feanor2345

    You are right, I also noticed it's a fake account.

    What can you do, just press "spam"

  • The organ makes this song so epic!!!!! LOVE!!

  • nightwish version is better :)

  • @MarioMojsoski

    Storytime is SHIT!

  • @Feanor2345 lol, i didnt meant on storytime i meant on walking in the air fool when Tarja was singing there.And im not here to argue like others whos better singer

  • Ou nou, terrible. My ears :-O

    Tarja venyttää ääntään, joka ei kuulosta hyvältä. Liian mahtipontista, joka tekee koko esityksestä liian teennäisen. Ei hyvä.

    Harmin paikka :-(

  • @cttnjrry The best version of Walking in the air I have ever heard was by a Finnish opera singer Johanna Rusanen-Kartano. We attended her Xmas concert some years ago. Her powerful voice (without a microphone) filled the church and really lifted us to float in the air.

    Johanna´s different version with a choir and orchestra is available on youtube. She doesn´t stretch vowels and change back vowels to front vowels as Tarja does here, Johanna´s voice and singing sound just beautiful.

  • @MetalHeel479 I appreciate your civilized comment, thank you! Johanna is indeed a far more better than Tarja, but I still go for Peter Auty. And sorry for my "mute" yt-channel, it used to be full of colours, but haters won. Maybe someday the colours will be back... ;-)

  • @cttnjrry I understand your point of view. A boy soprano´s voice or a children´s choir suits so well the fairy-tale theme of Walking in the air. Still, we can give adult singers, whether they are classically or non-classically trained, a chance to sing this lovely song.

  • @MetalHeel479 Its all in the ears of the beholder, some ppl would agree and some would disagree, I would disagree. Tarja makes a superb version of this song:)

  • @Pervypriest I agree with you, the beauty lies in the ears and eyes of the beholder. In Finland, any classical singer´s Walking in the air is inevitably compared with that of opera singer Johanna Rusanen-Kartano, she has set a very high standard for the presentation of this song.

    Merry Christmas to everyone!

  • @MetalHeel479

    I know and appreciate Johanna Rusanen's interpretation and I consider Tarja surpassed her.

    Not only in sensibility and voice quality but also in technical aspects.

    I am not a fan of this version of Tarja + Harus it's a bit too experimental for my taste. My favorite is the old one with NW and her usual one done in churches and such.

  • @MetalHeel479 I've just listened to that opera singer version and it is no better than this. plus Tarja sings this all by herself unlike that opera singer who has a chorus helping her

  • i like more the version when she was in nightwish o.o

  • actually i'm an atheist but my first thought after watching this video was: thank god for bringing us Tarja

  • 28 dislikes -  it's too much !

  • Beautiful, Bravo!!!

  • Does anyone know when we can buy the DVD? I don't think I'll live for very long without it...

  • @myhappyending546 november 25th

  • @myhappyending546 Try to find it on ebay !

  • That vibrato - horrible.

  • @omnislo1 so go there and make better

  • Amazing !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Eu queroooooooooooooo esse DVD! Mais 4 dias de espera ai que agoniaaaaaaaaa

    PS: Ainda me caso com essa mulher....(pena que depois tenha que acordar)

  • My whole life i really disliked classical music, classical singing, until i listened to Tarja. I really don't care who you sing with, Harus, Nightwish, Angra, Liv, Scorpions, just never stop singing, please. We love you Tarja.

  • Does she sing wrong lyrics at the end of the video: "We're floating in the midnight SKY (not 'Blue' this time)..."

    I haven't listened to Tarja for a long time and I really can't imagine her singing in Nightwish anymore. She has her own career now and I think she is even happier now than then in NW. Tuomas made the right decision... People, why you don't just enjoy that we have both of them: Tarja and Nightwish. But there will be no "Tarja's comeback"... Just get over it. :)

  • @jube91 I enjoy both, Tarja is my favourite solo artist, and Nightwish is one of my favorite bands, i love both, but still i miss the old stuff, and i can't help by "dreaming" that one day they will come back, I like the way things are but also the way things were. Accepting that some stuff will never change is called surrendering not getting over. Btw forgive my english if i said something bad.

  • there's no doubt that this is extraordinary music. Tarja's voice is perfect. But they could pick another song to play. This is magical song from Snowman and Holopainen did its fantastic remake (or what's the word for it) so I think they shouldn't play particulary this song because people will always connect it with Nightwish. There is a great number of fantastic songs they could pick...

  • peola

  • I do find the specific version quite boring. She sounds a bit..sloppy here, plus, the editing is god awful but I loved "you would have loved this" and I'm gonna buy the dvd either way :D

  • BORING????? excuse me,do you know what real music is?

  • Tarja, the name of perfection!!!!!

  • 21 ppl will never walk in the air)

  • @thunderboltification

    those 21 people probably think Tuomas wrote this song. Idiots.

  • Marvelous. This is a piece of art. Treasure the excellence, listeners.

  • I realy love Tarja A LOT,but this is just so boring.

  • It's a good performance, but her voice has changed so much! She still sounds good, but different. I no longer associate this voice with Nightwish (whom I still like as well). Perhaps it's better this way. It gives her solo career a proper identity. Looking forward to watching the entire show.

  • I want to say something her have so much very telent. this video was great I loved it all very well done congratulations

  • 18 people can't walk in the air

  • Oh my god she's a angel D:

  • im not crying and i lot of people are not crying, nice she left, get a life!

  • Compared to this, storytime is pure rubbish!

  • can't stop listening

  • This is wonderful !! Tarja has such a beautiful voice and she never stops !! thanks for everything, dear Tarja :-))

    L ~

  • Oh How I love Tarja!! So glad I discovered her!!

  • listening to this is like walking in the air *_* <3

  • Who is Harus?

  • @ibainesy It's Tarja's other band, with whom she makes christmas concert and classical stuff.

  • @ibainesy

    Her boyfriend.

  • @NightDreamer88

    I thought that guy from argentina, Marcelo something was her boyfriend. Hope she found a better one ^_^

    btw excellent version of the song

  • @Derrymaine148 he´s called Marcelo Cabuli, and now Marcelo and Tarja have officially started the process for demanding Nightwish because Once Upon a Nightwish "slanders Marcelo".

  • @agominator

    oh, no dude! what do they demand? what does the book say? and why the new project is called Harus anyway?

  • @Derrymaine148 the book says that Marcelo only cares about money and that is the serpent on Tuomas´ paradise as far as I know. And the project is called Harus because of a finnish tradition, it´s the name of a child

  • @agominator

    thanks dude. I wonder if what the book says is true...

  • @Derrymaine148 i think it may be true, but yeah, if they wrote such things is ok for Tarja and Marcelo to be pissed, but I don´t know what´s the point of demanding nw when Tarja and Marcelo, each one alone, actually crap money. how sucking, by the way, where are you from??

  • @agominator On 7 April Marcelo's sue was presented in Helsinki. In 2007 Marcelo sued the writer Mape Ollila and the managing director of the publishing house for the insults and lies that were written in the book (Marcelo's business activities and other stuff). Also three Brazilian partners who were blaimed for doing illegalities sued the publishers. so Marcelo SUED TO MAPE OLLILA NOT TO NW...!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Adrianabunbury you´re talking about stuff which happened in 2007, I´m talking about stuff that´s happening right now

  • @agominator sweety is the same, Marcelo sued to Ollila in the 2007 and ultil this year this "demand" will be resolved.. :D....

  • @agominator

    true. from Greece. u?

  • @agominator About the name Harus: "There is an old Finnish tradition when it comes to newborns – the baby is not to be named until the baptism ceremony, when he or she is presented to the family with the chosen name...HARUS is a rather peculiar, uncommon Finnish word that describes the four tensors that keep a tent together or the tensor that keeps the mast from falling in a sailing boat...part 1 :)

  • @agominator ...about the name Harus part 2: "...Both of the meanings apply to this musicians line up: four members, four equals, four different backgrounds to tie together exquisite classical music developed strongly and in a very stable way, with a taste of experimental, modern feeling..." (source: TarjaTurunen official site)

  • @Enidan1111 yeah, i had already read that :-D

  • I love Tarja's voicee!!

  • Hermosa ... Si puedes escuchala Manuel

  • exelente xD una cosa barbara

  • Excelente!!!!

  • j'ai adore Taja avec Nightwish la je suis encore plus conquis !!