My Second Story Ever!

[MasturbateDestroyer]

talent, lol

[96alyssaa]

Watching this on Christmas day!

[SheilaghLesarge]

Awesome****!!!!

[maggiejbm]

i loved seeing your face's shadow on the left page while you read the story!! was it on pourpose!? love you so much you're amasing kiss from portugal <3

[lewlewchoo]

Skrillex bwob ending FTW!

[Sangkikyo]

i luv this story. but as much as this 1 is awesome, i luuuuuuuuv yur first one better. kitty was amazingly kool. :D

[MintyPookieBear52]

I love how it seems like everybody has the same handwriting when they're a small child

[jabbanike]

:D you like skrillex! I just ordered some of your shirts last TEEoosday.

[MultiDjfa]

@jabbanike IKR!!!

[allykennedy]

Where did the presents go at 2.20 ?

[cyoachim10]

You should dig and find your third story ever!

[Bieberisonfire]

The presents disappeared aswell! What happened?

[lautnergirl914]

I love these stories. My favorite has to be the quick unfortunate story times. They were awesome.

[manatyson]

Lets read stuff I wrote as a little kid and be a critical jackass about it cuz its funny herp herp derp ._.

[TheNakedWombat]

The tree grew because the tree ate his hands.

[stinkeepumpkin]

I'd say John and Mary had a very eventful Christmas. A mysterious river flowing through their living room...stairs that changed from brown to green...the incredible shrinking/growing Christmas tree.... John losing his hands... Oh! And a banana stocking!

Excitement!!

[0308Lozza]

This had me in stitches. I found my old stories from Kindergarten.. I know where I pulled those stories from.

[ceresevakmoon]

I honestly just found you and this had me in stitches!!

[leeflailmarch]

We also say "grade 1"...in the Philippines. Haha. You are the best storyteller ever. If you write a novel, I'll make sure to attend your book reading.

[JessicarReads]

Haha I have old stories I foun like that too, I love finding out how funny I was as a child :)

[scarybossthepenguin]

this reminds me of smoshes "the ufo" that ian wrote in second grade

[suckitdelaware]

this literally made me laugh so hard that my eyes watered & mascara fell in to my eye.

i hope your happy.

[swinnie93]

I love how your shadow is on the other page! Would also be perfect for a horror story or something!

[narwalluvr]

Either you or Jessica had very nice handwriting for first graders....

[mrlovettz]

HAHAHAHA! this was AWESOME! i'm still laughing about John's excitement & Mary's incredible bright comments! xD

[zoeruls]

how did John chop both his hands off?

Mary must have helped him...

[TheTaytay2296]

We were so confident about those stories..what a fail they were when you read them after a couple years

[3diot]

Watched the Open letter.. had to watch another video to reassure myself subscribing is the right thing to do. Because you're good

[purpleukulele]

Talking about christmas cheer, I ran into a man dressed up as santa.. even though its april.

you're brilliant

[carollily10]

YOU ARE SOOO FUNNY <3

[PotterHarryTwilight]

amAAAAAzing :D

[amanduh111112]

so i tried uploading a video response to abtoday of the looovely shirt i receive a while ago buut i don't think it worked so i hope you don't mind if i post it on here...i was just super excited to receive it :p

[TheDumbassDude]

You. Are. Amazing.

[SNBeall38]

Yesterday was a terrible day for me. I woke up this morning thinking that today was only going to get worse.

Then I found your channel, and this video...It entirely made my day; I got a good laugh out of it. Thank you<3

You found yourself a new sub:)

[Amarox3000]

That chopping off his hands part killed me xD Why was there like a tube of some kind under the floor?

[Cowpoww]

O my god. Thank you for making my day.

[patcoston]

It's not kidney-garden. It's kindergarten. It's German for children garden.

[iDislikeNames]

You say "good" funny. But I digress...Marry me?

[KitKatRaaawr]

Hahahaahahahahaha I love how your little kid self was a tad illogical.

[itzzXlizz01]

not as good as andrew + the cat

[firehidrentliars]

i love john's night light



[Meyellows]

Okay. Now that was a hardcore ending.

[musicandlove516]

If I don't end up marrying somebody like you I will be very sad.

[xxxprincessforlifexx]

geez its been a while since i've watch your videos but omg these stories always make me laugh >.< especially ur comments about ur drawings hahha -catches breath- hilerious :)

[themary821]

I have never been more proud to be named Mary

[EmilayBemilayDisaray]

I can't WAIT to see you this weekend! Count me in on your performance! :-D

[QLFILMS]

The shadow of you reading makes the story even more EPIC. haha

[rondachewarrior]

That was the gayest intro ever XD

[papas5428]

u kno ur fucking awsome!!!???riiittteee haha yea u do lol

[hivetyrant36]

I lolzed at ur first one, I lolzed at your second one.

[456werewolf]

this is sooo funny! i love your videos! :)

[ParanoidPopRox]

lol the presents also dissapeared when they went back into the stair/tree room :O

[insanealleykat]

...i just got so confusy xD but i loved it

[ImOnThaCobraStarship]

I almost peed my pants watching this!! it was freaking HILARIOUS!! you were quite...special in grade 1 HAHAHAHA...ohhh...dying...of..­..laughter....your funny.

[Mezzaluna]

WHAT WAS THAT NOISE

[Mezzaluna]

Man you have like a hat of every colour :)

[AARONinsomnia]

i love their shoulders[:

[Taytoh]

Was that Skrillex I heard at the end!?

[samfitz9]

These always make me laugh until my stomach hurts.

[Muswaddique]

HOLY SHIT SKRILLEX!!!! please tell me im not the only one that noticed

[TwilightCullenist]

I love when you do things like this. I still remember shit I did like this in Grade 1.

[almaca728]

this is random but today we got our physic text books, and i got your old one!!! i got a little excited :)

[g1Na12]

and now the stairs are green... ahaha i love your stories andrew. <3

[cuppas0ups]

cute!

[liorez]

i love how your shadow can be seen while you're reading the story.

[kintzo1]

SKRILLEX!!!

[UndeadCrayon]

lol, Andrew it appears as though in the beginning you are attempting to hype this up, but its just waiting to open presents, and it was apparently AWESOME. O.<

[crazierthanyou]

BUT WHAT WAS THE NOISE?!?

[Aryes22]

Youre hand writing back then is better than mine now!

[SofiaWINS]

ahaha is 'mary' code for 'aubrey'? ahahahhahahaha ahahah....ahah ... sigh.

[Luvjlynn]

YOU. JUST. MADE. MY DAY. <3

[moeysmilez]

LOOL All Canadian's say Grade 1.

I'm a Torontonian haha :D

[OfficialCass]

I laughed, I cried. It was a very insightful story. When Mary said it was santa claus, I was just like "OMG OFCOURSE" And when John said it was the puppy , I was like "Hmm..interesting. New point of view." Overall, bravo.

[goodmorningfire]

You had good handwriting for a first grader.

[keithzworld]

That was awesome Andrew, love your sense of humor :)

[sammyammyantha1011]

lmao

[QspadeofheartsQ]

That was a good Christmas.

[RDBrilliance]

It also appears that the mother is floating on a river staircase in the last scene...

Best Christmas ever, I think SO.

[noneness]

i love how the title is "The Good Christmas" but it ended up not ONLY being good..but the BEST!! =D loved it LoL

[TaraB972]

I must say andrew, your artistic and writing style have both significantly improved since your last story. Maybe this was due to the partnership of jessica? which brings up a question- why did you get to keep the story and not jessica...hmmm? haha.

[5k0ty]

When I touch the mic I see the men scatta

Scatta, as if I had a clutch on a magnum!

(The song at 3:16, Skillex - Scatta for those not in the know (: )

[aznjane]

I'm sorry but I couldn't help but think through out this entire story of John as John from Vlogcandy...ohh I laughed.

[MelissaRaptor]

'it have been the puppy' & 'but there is nothing the table,everything is is on the table'

Lol, just lol.

[thepianoaddict]

:\ the presents are gone at 2:20 :O and first there were like 5 presents and in the end only 2 ;O lol

[zanessatilidie]

the presents disappeared when they went back to the tree aswell. js. :)

[KrystaandMandyshow]

I enjoyed seeing your shadow whilst you read. lol

[mikky120894]

LOL, now when i have bad days, I think I'm going to watch this video (and Andrew + The Cat) to make myself feel better! :)

[crystalmochi]

LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!! i love how you added your "adult" comments to you previous work.....,haha .....like the river in the room part.

[oohlookacat]

i see you got "there" and "their" wrong. i'll let that go because you were in grade one.

[hellokrust]

Hey Andrew, be my valentine?

[CGWacko]

You were a very creative 6 or 7 year old. And you're handwriting is impeccable.

[Reedg333]

Andrew you are so awesome! This was hilarious! I was cracking up at the accent it the beginning xD You were so good at it. hahaha

[AlyssaVWilliamson]

OMG I'll never know what the noise downstairs was!

[hopelesslyxxhopefulx]

hahaha, that knife thingy looked like part of the shards of narsil. yay for dorky observations lol

[turkolicious]

Grade 1. You must mean First Grade.

[AndrewBravener]

@turkolicious Nope, thats what we say in New Brunswick.

[j3n14]

@AndrewBravener yay canada :)

[aimeebaines]

@AndrewBravener HOHOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO rofl

[lysol0or0axe]

@turkolicious that's what pretty much everyone says, but Americans

[3diot]

@turkolicious

We also say "Grade 1" in Ontario, so it's probably a Canadian thing.

[sophiaathina]

SO. MANY. LOLS.



[tiffanymondesir]

subliminal dubstep with you name at the end. i like.

[TeeeealBalls]

Andrew idk why you aren't an author already. BRILLIANT hahaha :]

[lalila100]

This made my night. Funniest thing ever, and I love how you explained it. hahahha

[samadusax29]

the presents disappeared on the page where they decide to go back to bed

[alienmachiine]

i did not stop laughing through the whole thing

[theatregeekmania]

That story is the most brilliant piece of literature ever devised.

[spintopbikes]

Amazing Video ! These Aspires Me To Make Videos

Want Me To Check Out Your Channel?

Just Comment On My Page!

[xxjanzxx]

Scatta!

This is my favourite video of 2011.

[amanduh111112]

that was a truly lovely story!

[xNickJisOffTheChain]

"Maybe this is a story about elves." bahahaha You should publish these stories with footnotes on each page :D

[HiEndLive]

everything is is

[hopey5678]

Where did you get your hat from? :)

[AndrewBravener]

@hopey5678 West 49 I believe.

[HarmonicaPlayingTrek]

We still have our Christmas tree up...

[KyrstSings]

either that's a teacher's handwriting or that 1st grader has really nice handwriting

[HEDoLEY1234]

you and josh sound/act so alike :)

[orbital151]

The noise was never explained! Ha! Love it! 

[goodbye2you]

"It appears they live in a lake!" Ahaha, this video made my day :)

[KingAlverson]

you had fantastic handwriting for a first grader

[SkullRAWR]

This was SO funny xD

[kimyuie]

I enjoy these stories. They always make my day. lol

[happygurl37]

I laughed soo hard, you should get all the literature you've written and publish it, then the world will know of the story of that brave kitty that conquered 5 mountains and pushed through to find his neighbor and now the incredible Christmas story full of adventure and mystery to keep you at the edge of your seat.

[urbanburglary]

I tried to look at all your quaint little illustrations, but I was entranced by your talking shadow on the page the entire time.

Oh, and btdubbz, your outro scared the shizzle outta me.

[superchawa675]

Oh my god... please do more of these.

[RoRoTheGreat96]

The way you say Andrew Bravener at the beginning makes me laugh.. EVERY tiiime.

[celtichero9]

Great Story!

God Bless

[UhmmSaraaa]

hahaha. that was awesome.

[megslev3451]

your really attractive

[GemmaIsQuiteOriginal]

I like how different the stairs are on the last page. Tge elves painted them green and squished them up.

[EmOUchihaHime]

That was another funny story.

[SilverAukahzy]

I love you ^^

[PADavid12]

I laughed so loud. You have always been so funny when you do things like this. Love it

[AndrewBravener]

@PADavid12 Thank you so much.

[blondiexx137]

"But there is nothing...the table." Haha :P

[emmfan09]

Were any Bravener Christmases similar to this?

[AndrewBravener]

@emmfan09 Sadly, no knives were ever given at a Bravener Christmas.

[hplvr17]

not as funny as Andrew + the cat, but still pretty good lol! do more!!!

[YOSHD13]

Lol i was expecting it to keep going but then it just ended D:

Kinda like a cliff hanger i think.. :o lol

[ReidYo]

haha i loved the Skrillex samples at the end(;

[wrinkledforehead]

You probably get this a lot, but you have perfect facial hair.

[AndrewBravener]

@wrinkledforehead No actually, but thank you :)

[raziasshadow]

I swear you already made a video about this...

[AndrewBravener]

@nuggetemotubby Love you too.

[robynmbabe]

it was the puppy.

[konohamarutard]

LOL

[ImSamStarscream]

How do your hands turn 90 degrees? D:

[AndrewBravener]

@ImSamStarscream Like a boss.

[ImSamStarscream]

@AndrewBravener Teach me how to be a boss o.o

[nothingspecial1205]

I laughed so hard at this. you were one cool kid Andrew

[theoneudonotspeakof]

3:15 you listen to dubstep?!

[ImSamStarscream]

@theoneudonotspeakof I guess he does.

[AndrewBravener]

@theoneudonotspeakof Oh yeah.

[TheCryandry]

Just throw in some vampires and romance and you've got yourself a bestseller! :)

[mychemicalwhatever]

john @ 3:09 looks like gerard way. rofl.

[LaDementedCookie]

best Christmas Ever = Best story ever

[thefoolofsup]

i love memory boxes =]

[loredo2000]

I remember making a story book in school too.

[Leafdapple]

You never pointed it out but... there were presents under the tree when they went down, but they somehow determined Santa had yet to come and then the presents were gone.

[AndrewBravener]

@Leafdapple There were a lot of things I failed to mention, think of them as treats for you to find.

[EightTobiins]

its 4:30 in the morning and I laughed way to hard.

[Chainmail]

I like the turtleneck pajama's :]

[poniesinashed]

I believe!

IN ANDREW!

[NicklyFraggle]

@poniesinashed I believe in love!

[AndrewBravener]

@NicklyFraggle Just listen to the rhythm of my heart.

[jumper1294]

Worst 2nd story ever

[scarletkitty1999]

the trees magic! and that little kid got a knife! o.o

[deadchildstar]

that's actually pretty impressive for grade 1.

oh and where did you get your sweater?! it b awesome.

[keeptheareaclear]

dude, you said "check oout." haha.

i spent a week in minnesota last summer and they kinda have your accent. i love it.

[CandiGirl616]

I am gonna make one of them (I was 7 years old when I made the story I wanna show) but is it copyright if you show a story that is already made???

[Mlie]

Oh wow, now that story could be a best-seller, no doubt XD

[AshRandom1]

Wow that was hilarious! i was laughing so hard I wasnt making any noise....yes that really is how hard i was laughing:)

[themysteriousmovie]

epic story ive written one when i was in year 2 bout space! so when i get a recorder of somekind ill post a video

[TheEmolla]

The tree took some Viagra

[plostellum]

Your shadow just adds even more literature(y)-art(y)-ness.