This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i think it's so funny how my comments get marked down so fast. oh yea that's right the democrats don't like the truth. they still think 9/11 was an inside job and jimmy carter wasn't bad and they think obama is QUALIFIED. HAHAHAHAHA democrats are like retards, you don't want to laugh at them but you cant help it. democrats are for killing babies but not terrorists!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Miss Palin Flip Flop of Republican Party. she is a 2 face lier. Last week she was saying same thing what Obama has been saying about Al Qaida and Osama bin Ladan go after them with out paksitan permision and this week she change her views on that. Vote for Maccain and you will Vote for KKK Period! we have seen last 8 years of Republican party in power Maccain is 3rd turm of Bush and American dont need an other Bush. Change We Need , Obama best man and Hope for USA. God Bless USA and Obama.
I hope americans are going to vote for a true leader of the first world. Connecting with people and connecting with the world is very different. Vote for a president, A PRESIDENT, not someone whom you think is "warm and nice" and you can have a good time over the bloody dinner table.
well...you might like to know that most outside of US think you guys are better off calling your country DUMBFUCKISTAN filled with obnoxious arrogant ignorant dumbwits like yourself..... no offense for those whom i think are smarter than this insulting prick, you deserve better. Yeah let's start name calling.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Sometimes we don't have a choice for who we want as president. This time we have the choice of the lesser of two evils. Obama has some pretty radical friends in the showdows, "Mentors" if you know what I mean. Palin is important because she will bring about reform. Obmama is going to break us all. We can't afford the tax hikes he will bring. If we could, most Americans would clean house in the government. There is not a single person left who is looking out for us. We are FUCKED!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Do you really think Americans are that stupid? Wise up! Sometimes our hands are tied. What single American do you think can change what the government is going to do? Obama is a wind bag. I listen to his speeches and feel like he thinks he's Moses! Good Lord, save us from ourselves. Don't be fooled by Obama and the warm fuzzy feeling he inspires. He sat twenty years in Rev Wrights church listening to is "GOD DAMN AMERICA" sermons. Would you want that man for a president?
I'm glad you didn't take my bait. I hear you. I wish you well. Just know that whoever you guys vote out there affects the rest of us in the world. Judge on merit not on affiliation please.
Republican party got Flip Flop this time Miss Palin you are greatest Flip Flop ever first you were against Bridge to no where then you were for that. you cut funding for special kids and you have special kid in your own home you diney them there rights. Last Week you said what Obama have been saying over months if us need to kill Al Qaida then so be it and attack on them in side Pakistan. I am pakistani born american i am agree with Obama but Maccain is against that.
Please learn about was Teddy Roosevelt valued. I great Republican - Peace through Strength and pass the environmetn onto the next generation with more value ie drill, baby, drill. Please vote McCain - Obama is a populist-socialist.
What can i say i came to usa 8 years ago for better life 4 more years to Republican party in white house then maybe you might need to go to India or China for good job. look at the wall street. before that Air line Crisies. sorry Republican party un fit for white house.
34FirNaTine who the hell you think you are i came here by my choice not like your forefather skum of Europe they dump Garbige in this land to keep clean there land form your filthy forefathers. and i did not gave small pox to local like your ass hole forefathers did. Fuck your Republican ass hole Fuck KKK
Vote Palin! She is more qualified than Obama the fraud. Obama/ Rezco/ Wright/ Ayers/ guilty by association!! Obama cant pay for his trillion dollar annual budget and only the fools believe him. Go McCain:)
Palin is more qualified than Obama? What are you smoking? There are more students in my local school district than the town she was mayor of; there are more people in my town than the entire state of Alaska! She has little experience and her interviews reflect that. Obama has outstanding policies for this country. gop only uses scare tactics to get elected. Go Obama! bye bye gop :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
obama is only a senate for three years, how does HE have any experience? he never was the HEAD of a state or local budget, never in control of a national guard service, never did anything beneficial to real americans (just radical muslims), and the list goes on about what he didn't do. now tell me, how does he qualify to president? palin is only vp choice and she is more qualified then the retarded liberal democrap ticket.
His current budget for running for Pres is lareger than her budget for Alaska, and he is in charge of more people. He's put forth more legislation and more of an impact as state senator than she has. Please, if being a state governor is the only experience necessary it'd be in the Constitution. We should have an amendment keeping governors from the White House after Bush!
If that's all you can see then you're the idiot and haven't done your homework pal. Obama is highly qualified and ready to lead. McCain the 'non-maverick' has sold out to the gop conservatives & will run his office with the same Bush policies. That's not what the country or the world needs right now. 'Country First' give me a break! It should read McCain First, Country Second.
Palin believes that man coexisted with dinosaurs only 6,000 years ago, she is presently under investigation in Alaska for abuse of power, offered a bounty of $150 for each left front leg of freshly killed wolves, promotes aerial hunting of wolves even though Alaskans voted twice to ban it, she believes man-made global warming is a farce, she is suing the federal government to prevent listing the polar bear as an endangered species. My vote will be fore Biden.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
thats a religion based idea. what does that have to do with politics? oh yea that's right, it's just another failed attempt to put the republican party down because the democrap ticket is useless.
Religion is the relationship between men and God, and even though I believe we should always have God's lessons present in our lives, nothing I have mentioned have anything to do with God or religion. The Republican party does not need me to put them down, they already did that by themselves by ruining our economy. Sorry if the truth offends you.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
yea so i guess jimmy carter didn't ruin our economy because he was a democrap. and what presidential nominee looks a lot like carter? the answer is obama. he will absolutely destroy everything american about america. it will be more like south central, ca/camden, nj meets the middle east in mexico.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i'm not saying he's good you illiterate dumbass, i'm saying i like him because unlike democrats (who do nothing when terrorist attacks happen on u.s. soil[1993 bombing of wtc]) bush actually stepped up and actually did something, which was fight them back.
I'm still on the fence, but I think Biden clearly won this debate as far as substance is concerned: he answered the questions and added relevant info I thought supported his stance. I think he also did a good job in deflecting sticky points about him&Obama. both sides gave out half-truths and false statements (you're kidding yourself if you don't think so...) but this VP debate didn't sway me to vote either way THAT much...
watching the debate, people were expecting Palin to fall flat on her face against a very experienced politician in Biden. I thought she barely held her own. I agree that all the winking and smirking was a little annoying. she just didn't come across to me as very knowledgable in some of her answers and counter statements. some of her statements just 'sounded' like she was just regurgitating what she practiced at McCain's house before the debate. not a lot of depth to her answers.
Couldn't agree with you more, aznsketcher. Many of us outside of America cringed when she speaks. I 'betcha' if both of them did not have a script/notes in front of them, Palin might provide the most embarrassing moments in American political history. We are all very concern what Americans will vote because it affects the rest of us in the world whether we like it or not.
I hate how it can come to this. A knowledgeable principle like gentleman debating with a cheerleading, pleasant prefect like simpleton for the second highest office in the most powerful country in the modern world!
Palin said "hocky mom" as many times as Obama legally funnelled millions of tax Illinois tax dollars to land developers like Tony Rezco. (that would be SIX times). These developers (all his cronies) were the ones that funded Obama's early campaign and got him out of the Chicago machine. Obbama is a fraud and only the fools believe him.
There is absolutely no proof of this, only speculation. On the other hand, there's plenty of proof of McCain's and Palin's wrongdoings. Regardless, the Obama/Biden policies will be FAR better for this country than the gop alternatives. They've led this country down a horrible path. Go Obama!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
yes american corporations who help build america and give people jobs(wow you're really comparing corporate america to terrorists who hate america but love obama). terrorists/terrorist organizations/evil lears who support obama:
-hamas(they make calls to the u.s. convincing people to vote for obama while suicide bombing the shit out of israel and iraq)
-al Qaeda
-hugo chavez
-william ayers
the leaders of iran
-and more but i was writing about it last night in detail and i'm sick of writing it.
They don't support Obama; what they support is American leadership that will actually have diplomatic relations with heads of foreign nations. I agree with that. What the gop has been doing the last 8 years has NOT worked. That is a fact. Wake up! And stop trying to appeal to everyone's emotions instead of using facts. That's the only way the gop can get elected. Well, it won't work this year!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
THAT'S SUPPORTING OBAMA! by us having a president that has balls (republicans) they are scared of dying because they don't take responsibilities of what hundreds of thousands of people in their country do (support terrorism & act it out)so if by not having relations with shitty countries is the only bad thing about having republicans, i say more republicans. i see why people vote democrat, it's easier than working. democratic slogan-making people lazier more and more one welfare check at a time.
More scare tactics to get the gop elected. It won't work. Obama has 'balls' as you so eloquently put it. He'll actually speak with leaders of foreign nations. NOT talking to them HAS NOT worked, it's time for a change!
Saying it doesn't make it true. Where's your source other than McCain/Palin saying it. It's nothing but defamation of character. Your anger shows how desperate the gop is to get elected. They blew it the last 8 years (not to mention that the had control of the House since 1994)!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
actually mccain/palin never said it, so you fail again there. my anger is not anger, it's me laughing at how pathetic obama lovers are. gop had control of the white house since 1994?!???? the bill cunt fag guy had control from 1992-2000, again you FAIL!!!! go back to elementary school to learn your presidents little boy.
Wow, you are so uneducated it is ridiculous. You'll look back at your postings a year from now and realize how pathetic you sound. I wasn't talking about the White House; I was talking about the House on Capitol Hill! Now what was that about elementary school? And yes, Palin just said it at a rally and news organizations have proven it false. Bye gop!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ok so shoot me because i accidentally misunderstood what you said. but that's a typical democratic thing to do. which is totally shoot someone down for such a minor thing but let themselves commit the biggest mistakes and hope no one cares. hahaha hope.
If the GOP is in the White House next year... I might move to Canada.
woodevlin 3 years ago
no need to
zzfour 3 years ago
343 = idiot
AuthenticIdiot 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think it's so funny how my comments get marked down so fast. oh yea that's right the democrats don't like the truth. they still think 9/11 was an inside job and jimmy carter wasn't bad and they think obama is QUALIFIED. HAHAHAHAHA democrats are like retards, you don't want to laugh at them but you cant help it. democrats are for killing babies but not terrorists!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
do the research. democrats and republicans receive money from the same places.
imback18 3 years ago
Comment removed
donnyjayw 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
exactly. they say bush's third term, i say better than carter's second!!!
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
I like when that female said offensive but kinda funny what have you done for this country asshole. MCCAIN/PALIN 08
311gundog 3 years ago
Yeah that's what it is, they just haven't given her a place where she can get into those nitty gritty details!
Palin seems like a 8 year old trying to lie and make excuses to her parents.
In other words, not very effective at it.
Question -> Blank Stare -> Spew Rhetoric -> Success
Shisho2k 3 years ago 3
Miss Palin Flip Flop of Republican Party. she is a 2 face lier. Last week she was saying same thing what Obama has been saying about Al Qaida and Osama bin Ladan go after them with out paksitan permision and this week she change her views on that. Vote for Maccain and you will Vote for KKK Period! we have seen last 8 years of Republican party in power Maccain is 3rd turm of Bush and American dont need an other Bush. Change We Need , Obama best man and Hope for USA. God Bless USA and Obama.
flurto 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i'd rather a 3rd term of bush than a second term of the worst president in us history (jimmy carter)
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
i would do her
spacexploder 3 years ago
Sara FAILin got owned
bevon17 3 years ago 4
Fecking retardicans! Don't let your lemming/masochistic mind set ruin my country any longer. Be more productive in society and get a lobotomy.
BunyPunter 3 years ago 3
Obama is a fraud - If you dont like a country that values free markets you & Obama can leave any time.
njuhli 3 years ago
I hope americans are going to vote for a true leader of the first world. Connecting with people and connecting with the world is very different. Vote for a president, A PRESIDENT, not someone whom you think is "warm and nice" and you can have a good time over the bloody dinner table.
alviphua 3 years ago 2
I will try not to judge those outside the US as being as stupid as you.
confederaterose01 3 years ago
well...you might like to know that most outside of US think you guys are better off calling your country DUMBFUCKISTAN filled with obnoxious arrogant ignorant dumbwits like yourself..... no offense for those whom i think are smarter than this insulting prick, you deserve better. Yeah let's start name calling.
alviphua 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sometimes we don't have a choice for who we want as president. This time we have the choice of the lesser of two evils. Obama has some pretty radical friends in the showdows, "Mentors" if you know what I mean. Palin is important because she will bring about reform. Obmama is going to break us all. We can't afford the tax hikes he will bring. If we could, most Americans would clean house in the government. There is not a single person left who is looking out for us. We are FUCKED!
confederaterose01 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Do you really think Americans are that stupid? Wise up! Sometimes our hands are tied. What single American do you think can change what the government is going to do? Obama is a wind bag. I listen to his speeches and feel like he thinks he's Moses! Good Lord, save us from ourselves. Don't be fooled by Obama and the warm fuzzy feeling he inspires. He sat twenty years in Rev Wrights church listening to is "GOD DAMN AMERICA" sermons. Would you want that man for a president?
confederaterose01 3 years ago
I'm glad you didn't take my bait. I hear you. I wish you well. Just know that whoever you guys vote out there affects the rest of us in the world. Judge on merit not on affiliation please.
alviphua 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Point well taken. Thanks, we need all the help we can get.
confederaterose01 3 years ago
Republican party got Flip Flop this time Miss Palin you are greatest Flip Flop ever first you were against Bridge to no where then you were for that. you cut funding for special kids and you have special kid in your own home you diney them there rights. Last Week you said what Obama have been saying over months if us need to kill Al Qaida then so be it and attack on them in side Pakistan. I am pakistani born american i am agree with Obama but Maccain is against that.
flurto 3 years ago 2
Please learn about was Teddy Roosevelt valued. I great Republican - Peace through Strength and pass the environmetn onto the next generation with more value ie drill, baby, drill. Please vote McCain - Obama is a populist-socialist.
njuhli 3 years ago
What can i say i came to usa 8 years ago for better life 4 more years to Republican party in white house then maybe you might need to go to India or China for good job. look at the wall street. before that Air line Crisies. sorry Republican party un fit for white house.
flurto 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if you don't like it, go back to where you came from.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
34FirNaTine who the hell you think you are i came here by my choice not like your forefather skum of Europe they dump Garbige in this land to keep clean there land form your filthy forefathers. and i did not gave small pox to local like your ass hole forefathers did. Fuck your Republican ass hole Fuck KKK
flurto 3 years ago 5
Does she have what it takes? Absolutely not. Her performance was evidence of that. She did notd give one coherent answer to any question. Abyssmal.
celticmarine1 3 years ago 3
Vote Palin! She is more qualified than Obama the fraud. Obama/ Rezco/ Wright/ Ayers/ guilty by association!! Obama cant pay for his trillion dollar annual budget and only the fools believe him. Go McCain:)
njuhli 3 years ago
Palin is more qualified than Obama? What are you smoking? There are more students in my local school district than the town she was mayor of; there are more people in my town than the entire state of Alaska! She has little experience and her interviews reflect that. Obama has outstanding policies for this country. gop only uses scare tactics to get elected. Go Obama! bye bye gop :)
celticmarine1 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
obama is only a senate for three years, how does HE have any experience? he never was the HEAD of a state or local budget, never in control of a national guard service, never did anything beneficial to real americans (just radical muslims), and the list goes on about what he didn't do. now tell me, how does he qualify to president? palin is only vp choice and she is more qualified then the retarded liberal democrap ticket.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
His current budget for running for Pres is lareger than her budget for Alaska, and he is in charge of more people. He's put forth more legislation and more of an impact as state senator than she has. Please, if being a state governor is the only experience necessary it'd be in the Constitution. We should have an amendment keeping governors from the White House after Bush!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 7
obama is just a great speaker. unfortunately, you were idiotic enough to fall into his trap
xanafanadu 3 years ago
If that's all you can see then you're the idiot and haven't done your homework pal. Obama is highly qualified and ready to lead. McCain the 'non-maverick' has sold out to the gop conservatives & will run his office with the same Bush policies. That's not what the country or the world needs right now. 'Country First' give me a break! It should read McCain First, Country Second.
celticmarine1 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bullshit.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Palin refuses to answer the question. Does she not know that cnadidate debates are similar to job interviews.
Answer the damn question! If you don't know the answer just say so.
Seriously, if Joe Sex-Pecks were to act like her on a real job interview, he would be told to get lost.
And some people still think she is the next best thing since Bush Jr.??
satzaidi 3 years ago 3
Palin believes that man coexisted with dinosaurs only 6,000 years ago, she is presently under investigation in Alaska for abuse of power, offered a bounty of $150 for each left front leg of freshly killed wolves, promotes aerial hunting of wolves even though Alaskans voted twice to ban it, she believes man-made global warming is a farce, she is suing the federal government to prevent listing the polar bear as an endangered species. My vote will be fore Biden.
zahnyx 3 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thats a religion based idea. what does that have to do with politics? oh yea that's right, it's just another failed attempt to put the republican party down because the democrap ticket is useless.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Religion is the relationship between men and God, and even though I believe we should always have God's lessons present in our lives, nothing I have mentioned have anything to do with God or religion. The Republican party does not need me to put them down, they already did that by themselves by ruining our economy. Sorry if the truth offends you.
zahnyx 3 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yea so i guess jimmy carter didn't ruin our economy because he was a democrap. and what presidential nominee looks a lot like carter? the answer is obama. he will absolutely destroy everything american about america. it will be more like south central, ca/camden, nj meets the middle east in mexico.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
So according to your theory idiot Bush is a good Presidient?
gabrielahermosa 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i'm not saying he's good you illiterate dumbass, i'm saying i like him because unlike democrats (who do nothing when terrorist attacks happen on u.s. soil[1993 bombing of wtc]) bush actually stepped up and actually did something, which was fight them back.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
I'm still on the fence, but I think Biden clearly won this debate as far as substance is concerned: he answered the questions and added relevant info I thought supported his stance. I think he also did a good job in deflecting sticky points about him&Obama. both sides gave out half-truths and false statements (you're kidding yourself if you don't think so...) but this VP debate didn't sway me to vote either way THAT much...
aznsketcher 3 years ago
watching the debate, people were expecting Palin to fall flat on her face against a very experienced politician in Biden. I thought she barely held her own. I agree that all the winking and smirking was a little annoying. she just didn't come across to me as very knowledgable in some of her answers and counter statements. some of her statements just 'sounded' like she was just regurgitating what she practiced at McCain's house before the debate. not a lot of depth to her answers.
aznsketcher 3 years ago 5
Couldn't agree with you more, aznsketcher. Many of us outside of America cringed when she speaks. I 'betcha' if both of them did not have a script/notes in front of them, Palin might provide the most embarrassing moments in American political history. We are all very concern what Americans will vote because it affects the rest of us in the world whether we like it or not.
alviphua 3 years ago
wow, why was every person they talked to in this video a complete tool
dadadevo 3 years ago 2
I haaaate how she tried to "charm" the viewers with her little winks and that constant smirk on her face.
ChizzyO 3 years ago 6
I hate how it can come to this. A knowledgeable principle like gentleman debating with a cheerleading, pleasant prefect like simpleton for the second highest office in the most powerful country in the modern world!
alviphua 3 years ago 2
anybody count how many times she said "hockey mom" or "maverick" ???
69slime69 3 years ago
Palin said "hocky mom" as many times as Obama legally funnelled millions of tax Illinois tax dollars to land developers like Tony Rezco. (that would be SIX times). These developers (all his cronies) were the ones that funded Obama's early campaign and got him out of the Chicago machine. Obbama is a fraud and only the fools believe him.
njuhli 3 years ago
Glad 2 be a fool then!
69slime69 3 years ago
There is absolutely no proof of this, only speculation. On the other hand, there's plenty of proof of McCain's and Palin's wrongdoings. Regardless, the Obama/Biden policies will be FAR better for this country than the gop alternatives. They've led this country down a horrible path. Go Obama!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
at least the republican's party ticket isn't sponsored by terrorists.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Show me one piece of evidence for this outrageous claim. You can't. Yet another ignoramous.
celticmarine1 3 years ago 6
No, the gop is just sponsored by corporations, the only constituency they care about.
celticmarine1 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
who do you think sponsors democrats idiot.
imback18 3 years ago
More intelligent, factual conversation from another gop ignoramous. You're blind!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yes american corporations who help build america and give people jobs(wow you're really comparing corporate america to terrorists who hate america but love obama). terrorists/terrorist organizations/evil lears who support obama:
-hamas(they make calls to the u.s. convincing people to vote for obama while suicide bombing the shit out of israel and iraq)
-al Qaeda
-hugo chavez
-william ayers
the leaders of iran
-and more but i was writing about it last night in detail and i'm sick of writing it.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
They don't support Obama; what they support is American leadership that will actually have diplomatic relations with heads of foreign nations. I agree with that. What the gop has been doing the last 8 years has NOT worked. That is a fact. Wake up! And stop trying to appeal to everyone's emotions instead of using facts. That's the only way the gop can get elected. Well, it won't work this year!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THAT'S SUPPORTING OBAMA! by us having a president that has balls (republicans) they are scared of dying because they don't take responsibilities of what hundreds of thousands of people in their country do (support terrorism & act it out)so if by not having relations with shitty countries is the only bad thing about having republicans, i say more republicans. i see why people vote democrat, it's easier than working. democratic slogan-making people lazier more and more one welfare check at a time.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
More scare tactics to get the gop elected. It won't work. Obama has 'balls' as you so eloquently put it. He'll actually speak with leaders of foreign nations. NOT talking to them HAS NOT worked, it's time for a change!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how is this "scare tactics"?!?! this is true shit.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Saying it doesn't make it true. Where's your source other than McCain/Palin saying it. It's nothing but defamation of character. Your anger shows how desperate the gop is to get elected. They blew it the last 8 years (not to mention that the had control of the House since 1994)!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
actually mccain/palin never said it, so you fail again there. my anger is not anger, it's me laughing at how pathetic obama lovers are. gop had control of the white house since 1994?!???? the bill cunt fag guy had control from 1992-2000, again you FAIL!!!! go back to elementary school to learn your presidents little boy.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Wow, you are so uneducated it is ridiculous. You'll look back at your postings a year from now and realize how pathetic you sound. I wasn't talking about the White House; I was talking about the House on Capitol Hill! Now what was that about elementary school? And yes, Palin just said it at a rally and news organizations have proven it false. Bye gop!
celticmarine1 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok so shoot me because i accidentally misunderstood what you said. but that's a typical democratic thing to do. which is totally shoot someone down for such a minor thing but let themselves commit the biggest mistakes and hope no one cares. hahaha hope.
343FirNaTine 3 years ago
Palin is an airhead and her voice is very annoying.
If they win, the republican party will give her a lot of money and send her on a 4 year shopping spree.
ronsworld1177 3 years ago 6
Gov. Palin appeared to be giving a speech in a beauty contest; the smiling when the subject called for seriousness....the winking. Give me a break!
repoocdoug 3 years ago 6
Every time Palin says that Obama raised taxes, she LIED LIED LIED!!!!
imtang0708 3 years ago 7