Michelle ain't Mezzo Soprano, Mezzo Soprano can't hit head notes without blow tics or falseto, also a Mezzo Soprano when singing change its chest voice (Beyoncé is an example), she is actually Dramatic Soprano
i HIGHLY DOUBT SHE IS A SOPRANO. though her voice is very high-pitched... she is best in her lower register/upper chest register. her voice has some resemblance to dramatic mezzos such as patti labelle/fantasia. they too have extensive ranges! :D
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow the thing is, her voice is in D4 register (while a mezzo soprano, head notes and chest notes which are within its voice base, which are within middle C, e.g.: Beyoncé and Ciara), a mezzo soprano usually ranges from A2 to middle C (C#5 or C6), in contrast sopranos usually range from lower B to high C, F or G (usually C#6, C7 or F#5, F6, F7 or ranging from G5 to G8, which suits Michelle), also the thing is to sustain a note, Michelle sustain notes above middle C
i agree she is a classical soprano but in pop singing, she is defnitely a mezzo. before DC, she was in a gospel quartet with her best friends back then called 'united harmony' she was singing soprano back then. but in DC, she sang alto. her head voice is a bit unrefined probably coz she doesnt use it often. thats why i highly believe she is a mezzo in pop/R&B singing. :)
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow I agree completely. However, there is nothing Soprano about her and the fact that she can hit F5, F#5, G5 and G#5 in her chest/mixed/belting voice doesn't make her a Soprano. Her most natural and comfortable range is Alto. In a choir, she would be placed as an Alto....She would not be able to keep up with the Sopranos.
@richardba Michelle is a Mezzo. It's not just about range but tessitura - where the voice lies most comfortably and where it's most resonant. Michelle's upper range belts Bb4-G5 are where she is most resonant and non-suprisingly where we hear her sing most. She rarely uses her head voice to sing - though she should more as it is good.
Also one most listen to her timbre as it ascends the chest range and how it thins out...
@richardba She is certainly not "Dramatic" anything because he timbre is simply too light. If you want to hear a REAL Dramatic Soprano then type in Jessye Norman. I would say Michelle is a Mezzo-Soprano because of where her tessitura lies and the timbre of her voice. Beyonce has a similar range and yet has displayed much more control and agility in all parts of her range. Does that make her a dramatic soprano?
@JonathanGardnerTV Beyoncé hasn't displayed agility, Michelle I've seen, both studio and live, harmonizing and backsinging or leading, Michelle's voice is often dark and heavy (e.g.: Jennifer Hudson, yet her voice is larger, stronger and more powerful), also Michele belts are within G5 and lying down with Bb4, while Mezzo sopranos lies within A2 up to C middle, she is definitely a soprano, I don't know her comfort zone though, but eventually she will prove what is her voice type
@richardba I am a big fan of Michelle but her tone and timbre really can not be described as Dramatic. It's rather light whereas JHud's is heavy and dark. Michelle can somewhat "imitate" a darker, heavier sound around Bb4-D5 but she can't sustain that any higher.
By agile, I meant, Bey has demonstrated ease and great connection through all her registers. Her technique is impeccable and thus she can create flourishing and complex melismas in most of her range
@jamstrings100 im confused. is she supposed to sit down and stop her JOB for others. shes not Stopping anyone from anything.. the PUBLIC isnt buying into Kelly & Michelle. thats not Beyonce's fault in any way shape or form.. think before you speak such a stupid statement please.
@shooney56 Beyonce wasn't big before Destiny's Child were. She sabotaged her other bandmates by kicking them out of the band, you know, Letoya and Latavia. She forced the other members of DC to lip sync in the background whilst she sung live. Her career was more or less set up for her. Now, if she has given Letoya and Kelly equal singing parts to her (didn't say Latavia because no ones heard her solo) when DC first started Beyonce might be in trouble now.
@shooney56 I firmly believe the other members would be equally, or almost as big, as Beyonce has they all shared equal singing parts. Its the same with Nicole from Pussycat Dolls. People only know her because she STOLE the other girls chance at solo fame.
@shooney56 I'm tired of Beyonce. She's played out. Give the other girls a shot at fame. I know it probably won't happen now but it would be nice to see Kelly, Michelle, or Letoya have a big hit.
@jamstrings100 How did she "cause a lot of the shit in the group"? If she was the LEAD singer of the group, she should take the lead position. In addition to that, she came up with most of the harmonies herself and those harmonies were the core of what made DC unique to all of the other groups. And quite frankly, she was willing to put in all of the effort and work to get where she is. The other girls can easily do the same.
actually, bey has done a lot of dirty shit. and bey was the leader of the group not the 'lead singer'(since DC3 that is) and the only reason why she was lead is coz her dad owns the sub-record label...
IKR!!! her tone is probably the most unique tone not JUST OF DC BUT PROBABLY OF THE 2000s!!! imo, she is the BEST SINGER IN DC because she manages to use her raspy tone(which isnt very pleasing to the ears initially) to her advantage. and she also knows how to balance power VS resonance and also have the ability to sing both light/angelic as well! :D
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow yes her tone was somewhat of an acquired taste for me but after i listened to her gospel songs a few years ago, i fell in love <3 <3
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow lol....She blacked out! lol She proved dat she is NOT a weak link & dat she can hold her own! I mean Ive never heard her sing like that.
Her F#5 makes me wanna slap her! I didnt knw she had it like dat! Her & Kelly was my fav n D.Child. Her voice use to b annoyin to me but wen I heard her gospel cd I was like "Hold up now....". AWESOME F#5..ripped it
I think Kelly Rowland is finally getting SOME recognition (definitely not enough though), but I just feel soo sorry for Michelle. She got the short straw in Destiny's Child :/ she deserves so more fame and respect for that gorgeous voice of hers.
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow OMG. I found a REAL live B2 from Michelle. On the Rotterdam live recording of "Get on the Bus", when they're harmonising at the end, Michelle goes down to a B2 :D
IKR!!! neither did i. initially, i thought her voice was annoying but the more i listened to her the more i fell in love with her she's my favourite member from DC!!! :D
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Same!! I originally thought she was the weak link of the group. Same with Kelly, I thought she couldn't hit high notes. They both proved me WRONG! Thanks for making these vids :D
well, i personally dont like bey coz she has done of a lot of dirty shit in the industry but i cant stand the beyonce stans on YT bashing kelly/michelle calling them a flop etc. when their albums dont get 10% of the promo bey gets. :/ im glad these bey stans are shutting their mouths now though coz 'motivation' has charted higher than 'RTW' on billboard! :D
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow there you go, thats the word i was looking for...unrefined. michelle just has so much more polish compared to fantasia. love fantasia's performance aspects and when she tones it down sounds beautiful like "summertime" on AI. but michelle just has so much more ease throughout her belts IMO
She is my favorite Artist.....where did you get the clip from when she was singing " say yea, yea, say yea, yea" I believe its after stand up for love
LOL at "be-once". I don't really hear that B2 but if you include exclamation you could include F7. I'm not a big fan of her but damn, those F#5s are incredible.
the F7 was not very well-pitched, i only clude exclamations if they are well-pitched/easily heard as notes. otherwise i wouldnt include them in their range. :)
ive watched this vid where it shows when exclamations can/cant be counted. i dont agree with the video entirely but i see the point that the video-maker is tryna bring across. :)
6:27 she shut it DOWN! She was always my fave DC member. Not saying that to bandwagon, or because you like her. She seriously was. Then, there was Kelly that after a while because my fave. She def is a force to be reckoned with vocally. One that would give Beyonce very stiff competition. But. I honestly think all the DC girls are equally gifted in their own way. Kelly is really growing vocally now, she's came leaps & bounds, Michelle & Bey already had it. Those girls are GIFTED! or Trained (B)
3000 views thanks peeps! this is the 2nd vid im most proud of making! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 weeks ago
GO Michelle!
OKzs 1 month ago
I will say that I love that Michelle has a very unique voice and an extremely extensive range.
TheHarmonicDreamer 2 months ago
What is 1:10 from???
KealSpeaks 2 months ago
And at the end of TWL Atlanta performance she hits an upper note, higher than F#5
richardba 3 months ago
Michelle ain't Mezzo Soprano, Mezzo Soprano can't hit head notes without blow tics or falseto, also a Mezzo Soprano when singing change its chest voice (Beyoncé is an example), she is actually Dramatic Soprano
richardba 3 months ago
@richardba
i HIGHLY DOUBT SHE IS A SOPRANO. though her voice is very high-pitched... she is best in her lower register/upper chest register. her voice has some resemblance to dramatic mezzos such as patti labelle/fantasia. they too have extensive ranges! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago in playlist More videos from MimiXtinaChelleKRow
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow the thing is, her voice is in D4 register (while a mezzo soprano, head notes and chest notes which are within its voice base, which are within middle C, e.g.: Beyoncé and Ciara), a mezzo soprano usually ranges from A2 to middle C (C#5 or C6), in contrast sopranos usually range from lower B to high C, F or G (usually C#6, C7 or F#5, F6, F7 or ranging from G5 to G8, which suits Michelle), also the thing is to sustain a note, Michelle sustain notes above middle C
richardba 3 months ago
@richardba
i agree she is a classical soprano but in pop singing, she is defnitely a mezzo. before DC, she was in a gospel quartet with her best friends back then called 'united harmony' she was singing soprano back then. but in DC, she sang alto. her head voice is a bit unrefined probably coz she doesnt use it often. thats why i highly believe she is a mezzo in pop/R&B singing. :)
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow I agree completely. However, there is nothing Soprano about her and the fact that she can hit F5, F#5, G5 and G#5 in her chest/mixed/belting voice doesn't make her a Soprano. Her most natural and comfortable range is Alto. In a choir, she would be placed as an Alto....She would not be able to keep up with the Sopranos.
highnote32 2 months ago
@richardba Michelle is a Mezzo. It's not just about range but tessitura - where the voice lies most comfortably and where it's most resonant. Michelle's upper range belts Bb4-G5 are where she is most resonant and non-suprisingly where we hear her sing most. She rarely uses her head voice to sing - though she should more as it is good.
Also one most listen to her timbre as it ascends the chest range and how it thins out...
JonathanGardnerTV 3 months ago
@richardba She is certainly not "Dramatic" anything because he timbre is simply too light. If you want to hear a REAL Dramatic Soprano then type in Jessye Norman. I would say Michelle is a Mezzo-Soprano because of where her tessitura lies and the timbre of her voice. Beyonce has a similar range and yet has displayed much more control and agility in all parts of her range. Does that make her a dramatic soprano?
JonathanGardnerTV 3 months ago
@JonathanGardnerTV Beyoncé hasn't displayed agility, Michelle I've seen, both studio and live, harmonizing and backsinging or leading, Michelle's voice is often dark and heavy (e.g.: Jennifer Hudson, yet her voice is larger, stronger and more powerful), also Michele belts are within G5 and lying down with Bb4, while Mezzo sopranos lies within A2 up to C middle, she is definitely a soprano, I don't know her comfort zone though, but eventually she will prove what is her voice type
richardba 3 months ago
@richardba I am a big fan of Michelle but her tone and timbre really can not be described as Dramatic. It's rather light whereas JHud's is heavy and dark. Michelle can somewhat "imitate" a darker, heavier sound around Bb4-D5 but she can't sustain that any higher.
By agile, I meant, Bey has demonstrated ease and great connection through all her registers. Her technique is impeccable and thus she can create flourishing and complex melismas in most of her range
JonathanGardnerTV 3 months ago 2
That Through With Love performance>>>>>>
neworleans504fresh 3 months ago
Beyonce pisses me off. She's good, but the other members of DC are good also. Give them a fucking chance.
jamstrings100 3 months ago
@jamstrings100
PREACH!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@jamstrings100 im confused. is she supposed to sit down and stop her JOB for others. shes not Stopping anyone from anything.. the PUBLIC isnt buying into Kelly & Michelle. thats not Beyonce's fault in any way shape or form.. think before you speak such a stupid statement please.
shooney56 3 months ago
@shooney56 Beyonce wasn't big before Destiny's Child were. She sabotaged her other bandmates by kicking them out of the band, you know, Letoya and Latavia. She forced the other members of DC to lip sync in the background whilst she sung live. Her career was more or less set up for her. Now, if she has given Letoya and Kelly equal singing parts to her (didn't say Latavia because no ones heard her solo) when DC first started Beyonce might be in trouble now.
jamstrings100 3 months ago
@shooney56 I firmly believe the other members would be equally, or almost as big, as Beyonce has they all shared equal singing parts. Its the same with Nicole from Pussycat Dolls. People only know her because she STOLE the other girls chance at solo fame.
jamstrings100 3 months ago
@shooney56 I'm tired of Beyonce. She's played out. Give the other girls a shot at fame. I know it probably won't happen now but it would be nice to see Kelly, Michelle, or Letoya have a big hit.
jamstrings100 3 months ago
@jamstrings100 You guys kill me with this... YOU give them a chance. Focus on the others instead of bringing Bey into everything.
TheHarmonicDreamer 2 months ago
@TheHarmonicDreamer Beyonce is the one who caused a lot of the shit in the group in the first place. I can't control that greedy begger.
jamstrings100 2 months ago
@jamstrings100
PREACH!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
@jamstrings100 How did she "cause a lot of the shit in the group"? If she was the LEAD singer of the group, she should take the lead position. In addition to that, she came up with most of the harmonies herself and those harmonies were the core of what made DC unique to all of the other groups. And quite frankly, she was willing to put in all of the effort and work to get where she is. The other girls can easily do the same.
TheHarmonicDreamer 2 months ago
@TheHarmonicDreamer
actually, bey has done a lot of dirty shit. and bey was the leader of the group not the 'lead singer'(since DC3 that is) and the only reason why she was lead is coz her dad owns the sub-record label...
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 2 months ago
she's amazing! i love her tone <3 and yes she is the princess of the F#5
ablackguy123456789 3 months ago
@ablackguy123456789
IKR!!! her tone is probably the most unique tone not JUST OF DC BUT PROBABLY OF THE 2000s!!! imo, she is the BEST SINGER IN DC because she manages to use her raspy tone(which isnt very pleasing to the ears initially) to her advantage. and she also knows how to balance power VS resonance and also have the ability to sing both light/angelic as well! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow yes her tone was somewhat of an acquired taste for me but after i listened to her gospel songs a few years ago, i fell in love <3 <3
ablackguy123456789 3 months ago
ps. she is the princess of F#5 because the queen of F#5 is mariah carey lol! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@ablackguy123456789
do check out my kelly rowland vocal range vid and leave a comment! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 3 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow lol....She blacked out! lol She proved dat she is NOT a weak link & dat she can hold her own! I mean Ive never heard her sing like that.
trillazlady 4 months ago
Her F#5 makes me wanna slap her! I didnt knw she had it like dat! Her & Kelly was my fav n D.Child. Her voice use to b annoyin to me but wen I heard her gospel cd I was like "Hold up now....". AWESOME F#5..ripped it
trillazlady 4 months ago 8
@trillazlady
ripped it? how abt causing a blackout! lol! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 4 months ago
at 5:35 beyonce was like oh shit i didnt know michelle could get down vocally like that, lemme step up my game lmao!!!
wozniacki15 5 months ago
@wozniacki15
PREACH!!! :D
chewerboy 5 months ago
I think Kelly Rowland is finally getting SOME recognition (definitely not enough though), but I just feel soo sorry for Michelle. She got the short straw in Destiny's Child :/ she deserves so more fame and respect for that gorgeous voice of hers.
Snookiiiii 5 months ago 8
her F#5 is amazing!
pyrhum 5 months ago
Michelle is so underrated
iStan4JoAndTK 6 months ago
the first G5 is a fail lol
XgiugioX1 6 months ago
Okay....That C6 @ 8:32 sounded mixed.... somewhat.
highnote32 6 months ago
Amazing vid - apart from the B2 which was a B3.
So her live range is 4 octaves pretty much.
YOU SO WRONG for putting that "Cater 2 You" dance solo in this vid LMAO!
JonathanGardnerTV 6 months ago
@JonathanGardnerTV
michelle dedicating a dance solo to me... = ULTIMATE TURN ON HAHA!!! :P
btw, why did they remove your channel? why did they suspend your account? you have the best michelle medias down there!!! :(
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow OMG. I found a REAL live B2 from Michelle. On the Rotterdam live recording of "Get on the Bus", when they're harmonising at the end, Michelle goes down to a B2 :D
Slaychelle 4 months ago
@Slaychelle
GIMME THE LINK AND TELL ME WHERE IT IS LOCATED AHHHHH!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 4 months ago
I LOVE her F#5's!! I didn't know she could sing like that!
stardusth2o 6 months ago
@stardusth2o
IKR!!! neither did i. initially, i thought her voice was annoying but the more i listened to her the more i fell in love with her she's my favourite member from DC!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Same!! I originally thought she was the weak link of the group. Same with Kelly, I thought she couldn't hit high notes. They both proved me WRONG! Thanks for making these vids :D
stardusth2o 6 months ago
@stardusth2o
you can see why i dislike beyonce now right? haha! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow You don't have to dislike Bey cos you think Michelle and Kelly are better :P
stardusth2o 6 months ago
@stardusth2o
well, i personally dont like bey coz she has done of a lot of dirty shit in the industry but i cant stand the beyonce stans on YT bashing kelly/michelle calling them a flop etc. when their albums dont get 10% of the promo bey gets. :/ im glad these bey stans are shutting their mouths now though coz 'motivation' has charted higher than 'RTW' on billboard! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@stardusth2o
and your welcome! imo, kelly rowland/michelle williams are the most slept on vocalists of our generation haha! :P
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow That's very true. They don't get the recognition they deserve.
stardusth2o 6 months ago
which song at 6:35???
secondtimealive 6 months ago
@secondtimealive
destiny's child 'through with love' live in atlanta
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
quite impressive...i always thought she and fantasia sounded quite similar except michelle was always more controlled and not over-the-top.
agators212 6 months ago
@agators212
agreed, i dont really like fantasia, her voice sounds a little unrefined for me. :/
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow there you go, thats the word i was looking for...unrefined. michelle just has so much more polish compared to fantasia. love fantasia's performance aspects and when she tones it down sounds beautiful like "summertime" on AI. but michelle just has so much more ease throughout her belts IMO
agators212 6 months ago
She is so underrated
daiell09 6 months ago
She is my favorite Artist.....where did you get the clip from when she was singing " say yea, yea, say yea, yea" I believe its after stand up for love
BrianKeithTV 6 months ago
@BrianKeithTV
this is the video:
/watch?v=naOtAJDMIUg&feature=channel_video_title
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
so underrated....
greatmusic1001 6 months ago
LOL at "be-once". I don't really hear that B2 but if you include exclamation you could include F7. I'm not a big fan of her but damn, those F#5s are incredible.
LoveGreatVocal 6 months ago
@LoveGreatVocal
the F7 was not very well-pitched, i only clude exclamations if they are well-pitched/easily heard as notes. otherwise i wouldnt include them in their range. :)
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow well-pitched? would do you mean?
LoveGreatVocal 6 months ago
@LoveGreatVocal
/watch?v=jpYqjm9fDjc
ive watched this vid where it shows when exclamations can/cant be counted. i dont agree with the video entirely but i see the point that the video-maker is tryna bring across. :)
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
She needs to learn a bit about pitch and breath control before we can say she is amazing
moroney1 6 months ago
Michelle was so underrated in Destiny's child
iStan4JoAndTK 6 months ago
That G5 at the end was everything (the belt)
LifeisMusic07 6 months ago
lol. Naw, but seriously. Gifted & talented.
LifeisMusic07 6 months ago
6:27 she shut it DOWN! She was always my fave DC member. Not saying that to bandwagon, or because you like her. She seriously was. Then, there was Kelly that after a while because my fave. She def is a force to be reckoned with vocally. One that would give Beyonce very stiff competition. But. I honestly think all the DC girls are equally gifted in their own way. Kelly is really growing vocally now, she's came leaps & bounds, Michelle & Bey already had it. Those girls are GIFTED! or Trained (B)
LifeisMusic07 6 months ago
@LifeisMusic07
LMAO at trained.... thanks for watching!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Lol, you're welcome.
LifeisMusic07 6 months ago
@LifeisMusic07
yeah, michelle's new single 'OTR' is coming this sept EXCITED!!! :D
MimiXtinaChelleKRow 6 months ago
@MimiXtinaChelleKRow Whoooooop :D
LifeisMusic07 6 months ago
3rd favourite out of ALL DC members!
I love her voice!
Her F#5's --------
TheVocalPower 6 months ago
Her lower registry is everything. She has a really nice voice.
VaunTV 6 months ago