Let's not forget Hoagy Carmichael who wrote this and other great songs like, "How Little We Know" sung by the sexiest and most beautiful woman in the world Lauren Bacall - and if you're watching Lauren give me a (Ba)call ---sry sry sry. Back to our muttons. Dinah Shore. Lovely voice and sensationally beautiful woman. Not a patch on Lauren though.
I still remember the day she passed away. The TV announcer (cant remember his name) had to stop and compose himself after the 1st few words. The passing of an era and a nice lady.
It doesn't get better than this. THIS was real music- classy, soothing, romantic. Music in this day and age will NEVER compare to this, it's all just noise now.
The best recording ever of this song from May 1942 - the Amazon re-mastered recordings are excellent, but don't get the itunes recording - it's terrible - much too harsh and distorted
As far as I'm concerned I LOVE the "scratchy" sound in this recording - so it's not "perfect" studio quality - it lends a sense of "time" to the recording that brings back all kinds of memories of LONG ago days gone by. If you grew up in the sixties or the seventies, these kinds of recordings were around your house.
I can't believe that people still talk about her being part black...LOL...who cares...she was a beautiful lady...and so if the black people liked her or she played to them who cares....her voice and musicality showed that she is talented...but, I had heard those stupid rumors when I was a child, too....but, who cares...I don't she's my favourite singer of the 40's.
The scratches add charm to this beautiful interpretation which was in fact used by Clint Eastwood in one of his films: thank you for posting, I surely love it.
from winchester tenn .when she was little her dad would bring her into a little cafe there ;put her on a table and say '''sing Marie Rose'''..judy garland also lived down the road in murfreesboro tenn..[THE GUMM SISTERS]
"Skylark" is a bitch to sing. It has great lyrics, but that fabulous melody is complex. So here's Dinah Shore making it all sound easy and too beautiful. Best version I've ever heard.
One of my favorite "canary" songs. Until now I had not heard it by Dinah Shore. Her voice has such a comforting feel about it, not unlike Bing Crosby's. Thank you for this beautiful upload.
What year was this recorded? I have to admit that I've neglected listening to Ms Shore's earlier recordings. I only remember her as a more mature singer when her vibrato was much wider and I found her more difficult to listen to. I should have known to listen to her earlier days..... I have, however, always respected her as a fine artist. I'm glad that I stumbled on this recording. Thanks for the post!!
it's a lovely version of that song .. and yes that is what matters , thanks for posting it .. even the scratches are good to hear .. I love them .. hehe .. :)
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.. Les & Larry Elgart recorded some amazing instrimentals that make anyone just want to get up and dance! thanks for the memories!
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.. Les & Larry Elgart recorded some amazing instrimentals that make anyone just want to get up and dance! thank you .
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.
I've never listened to this before, but it strikes me what a singer from the South can do with melodies arising from tradition there (and of course, Johnny Mercer & Hoagy Carmichael)... can't say I've ever heard Billie Holiday sing this song but I'd love to hear it. So much of our hearing is from language inflection... singing truly reflects that. She's perfectly wonderful here.
Beautiful---thank you so much for sharing this. I loved Dinah as did my parents--who would have heard this playing just as we have here. What a nice thought.
Thank you for all of you have commented on this video. I am removing all comments about Dinah Shore's race. While that has been a hotly debated issue for many years, this is not the place for that discussion. The beauty of the voice and the talent of the singer are really all that matter. Dinah Shore was a lovely and talented woman and I think that is what she would like to be remembered as.
@jackgardner13 As others have said already, there's no need for apologies. You've done a big favor for many of us. I believe I was a pre-teen when I first heard this, and can't remember who the singer was, but that was more than 50 years ago. I just remember that it touched me then and still does. Thanks!
@jackgardner13 ---------- :)) hearing the scratch of a REAL record made this song - that I adore - more beautiful. I miss those old records, havent owned a record player in forever. Thank you for this lovely recording :) posting it on FB <3
I'm so glad you uploaded this. It's really difficult to find a version of this song that is true to what was written! And she, of course, has an amazing voice. I agree that the scratchy quality of the recording just adds to it
You're are absolutely right about her interpretation. Most contemporary singers butcher this song with jazz cliches. I grew up watching her TV show and I never knew how good of singer she was.
From first note to last, perfect. Such control of her tone and vibrato, such ease in the high register. So beautiful. THIS is the kind of singing to listen to and learn from. No sweetening, no composite tracks, no doubling, no mistake-disguising reverb. Just the voice.
Crackles, who cares. Unmistakable technique shines through.
This was recorded in 1941, around the period she was starting to be noted as a vocalist in her own right (at the time, she was getting recognition for her appearances on NBC Radio's "CHAMBER MUSIC SOCIETY OF LOWER BASIN STREET").
Thanks so much for this video response; you are absolutely right this is a wonderful interpretation too. After the references made to it in the comments I had got curious, so I'm very happy to hear this gem.
Let's not forget Hoagy Carmichael who wrote this and other great songs like, "How Little We Know" sung by the sexiest and most beautiful woman in the world Lauren Bacall - and if you're watching Lauren give me a (Ba)call ---sry sry sry. Back to our muttons. Dinah Shore. Lovely voice and sensationally beautiful woman. Not a patch on Lauren though.
rlneesam 6 days ago
Loved her voice for as long as I can remember. Thanks for sharing,
abcd0123504 2 months ago
I still remember the day she passed away. The TV announcer (cant remember his name) had to stop and compose himself after the 1st few words. The passing of an era and a nice lady.
saullouis 3 months ago
It doesn't get better than this. THIS was real music- classy, soothing, romantic. Music in this day and age will NEVER compare to this, it's all just noise now.
anarchy4sale 4 months ago
what turntable do u use for recording this? a normal 33rpm turntable?
RegalPCS 4 months ago
I was only 4 or 5 when this was popular. It makes me nostalgic, wishing the times with my family in the 40s would come back. Beautiful version.
Dinah Shore paper dolls were very popular.
Patmend38 5 months ago
The best recording ever of this song from May 1942 - the Amazon re-mastered recordings are excellent, but don't get the itunes recording - it's terrible - much too harsh and distorted
Jamesmac30 5 months ago
Comment removed
Jamesmac30 5 months ago
As far as I'm concerned I LOVE the "scratchy" sound in this recording - so it's not "perfect" studio quality - it lends a sense of "time" to the recording that brings back all kinds of memories of LONG ago days gone by. If you grew up in the sixties or the seventies, these kinds of recordings were around your house.
paulakaye5 5 months ago
Dinah Shore----what a fantastic woman...Chevy show...her talk show...women's golf....to mention a few. Thank you.
3641435 5 months ago
I can't believe that people still talk about her being part black...LOL...who cares...she was a beautiful lady...and so if the black people liked her or she played to them who cares....her voice and musicality showed that she is talented...but, I had heard those stupid rumors when I was a child, too....but, who cares...I don't she's my favourite singer of the 40's.
jdcc061 6 months ago in playlist duomo
Just beautiful!
maestosomajestico 6 months ago
Still my favorite female version of this song - Dinah makes me get all misty-eyed...
odantoro 6 months ago
PERFECT! (:-D)
Noshirm 6 months ago
She also recorded it with Red Norvo in a late 1950's album for Capitol..
jbet1941 7 months ago
:) So wonderful. :)
prissy007hotmail 7 months ago in playlist Dinah Shore
mighty purty
666caimbirdofhell 8 months ago
The scratches add charm to this beautiful interpretation which was in fact used by Clint Eastwood in one of his films: thank you for posting, I surely love it.
ginolight 8 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Recorded on February 10, 1942.
fromthesidelines 8 months ago
from winchester tenn .when she was little her dad would bring her into a little cafe there ;put her on a table and say '''sing Marie Rose'''..judy garland also lived down the road in murfreesboro tenn..[THE GUMM SISTERS]
mlkemper 8 months ago
@mlkemper my dad was from shelbyville.
tranurse 6 months ago
I like the scratchiness!
ydabom 9 months ago
"Skylark" is a bitch to sing. It has great lyrics, but that fabulous melody is complex. So here's Dinah Shore making it all sound easy and too beautiful. Best version I've ever heard.
unclealand 11 months ago
the sound like burning bondfire;s remind me the longplay. Perfect song.
Melvin1221 1 year ago
Thank you for this beautiful rendition!
conchaperez 1 year ago
One of my favorite "canary" songs. Until now I had not heard it by Dinah Shore. Her voice has such a comforting feel about it, not unlike Bing Crosby's. Thank you for this beautiful upload.
CHASxWILSON 1 year ago
She sure was beautiful and had a great voice.
stevescissors 1 year ago
Thanks - Youtube is opening up a world of recordings I have never heard - I love this version of Hoagy Carmichael and Johnny Mercer's 1941 song.
Jamesmac30 1 year ago
This is such a beautiful interpretation of a wonderful song.
Thank you for sharing.
Corrie121 1 year ago
Thank you for uploading this- this is awesome.
violin1957 1 year ago
It's awesome...thanks for uploading it.
violin1957 1 year ago
Beautiful
coltonkelling 1 year ago
What year was this recorded? I have to admit that I've neglected listening to Ms Shore's earlier recordings. I only remember her as a more mature singer when her vibrato was much wider and I found her more difficult to listen to. I should have known to listen to her earlier days..... I have, however, always respected her as a fine artist. I'm glad that I stumbled on this recording. Thanks for the post!!
lovelytrix00 1 year ago
it's a lovely version of that song .. and yes that is what matters , thanks for posting it .. even the scratches are good to hear .. I love them .. hehe .. :)
loranalary 1 year ago
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.. Les & Larry Elgart recorded some amazing instrimentals that make anyone just want to get up and dance! thanks for the memories!
franciepj10 1 year ago
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.. Les & Larry Elgart recorded some amazing instrimentals that make anyone just want to get up and dance! thank you .
franciepj10 1 year ago
you, jackgardner13, have achieved what I hope wil inspire future music producers to realize those of us who have grown up with and thouroughly enjoyed talent such as Dinah and Frank and Hoagy to get over the marketing of what makes them money and give us back music, not screeching, screaming angry people making unpleasant noises accompanyed by dreadful electric amps.
franciepj10 1 year ago
lovely singer and great song
urracal 1 year ago
This is just pure, unadulterated loveliness
FlamingFairy 1 year ago
To Urracal..., Do try and sing this melody before you dismiss it as "simple".
chanteurps 1 year ago
Simply...honest, gorgeous singing.
chanteurps 1 year ago
im only like 14 and i still think this is really beautiful.! :)
Ericalovesu23 1 year ago 3
I've never heard of her until now. I'm fan now.
ClassicDamefan 1 year ago
I love the scratchy sound sounds like a real record
jahlaune 1 year ago
great song, very evocative.
urracal 1 year ago
beautiful rendition of this classic, but simple song. Thank you for posting it.
urracal 1 year ago
Stunning!
moorethanart 1 year ago 2
Johnny Mercer, unsung hero /lyricist of movies' music 40s-60s. Saw a docci on him last week and cant get this song out of my head.
micheleaime 1 year ago 2
One of the best vocals I've ever heard. Simply beautiful.
odantoro 1 year ago
Lovely Dinah Shore.......
Quite possibly the very best version o this song.
tracyb934 1 year ago
Love this version. Thank you so much for sharing.
oneoriginalthought 1 year ago
Dinah, ahh! Her voice is like butter that just smooths those scratches right over.
thank you for posting this.
Drumgirl1148 1 year ago 3
Very very nice,
I prefer Helen Forrest version though, with Harry James on trumpet.
uostman 1 year ago
I watched a ton of other singers sing this song but I like her's the best. So soft and sincere, I love it.
TheKuroshikyo 1 year ago
It's beautiful, thank you! Brings tears...
gypcnme 2 years ago
The quality of her voice is matchless. The best!
rlneesam 2 years ago 2
I think this is my favorite version so far. So beautiful. Thanks very much.
odantoro 2 years ago
So many versions.
Thanks for posting this.
4eva68 2 years ago
Gorgeous version of Skylark.
StereoSpace 2 years ago
I've never listened to this before, but it strikes me what a singer from the South can do with melodies arising from tradition there (and of course, Johnny Mercer & Hoagy Carmichael)... can't say I've ever heard Billie Holiday sing this song but I'd love to hear it. So much of our hearing is from language inflection... singing truly reflects that. She's perfectly wonderful here.
Janine11155 2 years ago 2
Beautiful---thank you so much for sharing this. I loved Dinah as did my parents--who would have heard this playing just as we have here. What a nice thought.
gapeach7355 2 years ago
JCMarra: What an insightful, intelligent comment that gets to the heart of just how darn GOOD this is. Wish there was more of YOU on YouTube! Thanks!
jackgardner13: Thanks for this yummy post! And DON'T YOU APOLOGIZE for those scratches! We don't care!
Mothra is sincerely pleased..!! Peace to all!!
1mothra 2 years ago 3
she is exceptional-she is SUCH an underrated vocalist!!! thanks for posting--scratches and all!!!
cuddlebuttons 2 years ago 5
I first heard her singing sleepy lagoon wow wonderfull !
4Dspacetime 2 years ago
Thank you for all of you have commented on this video. I am removing all comments about Dinah Shore's race. While that has been a hotly debated issue for many years, this is not the place for that discussion. The beauty of the voice and the talent of the singer are really all that matter. Dinah Shore was a lovely and talented woman and I think that is what she would like to be remembered as.
jackgardner13 2 years ago 16
@jackgardner13 As others have said already, there's no need for apologies. You've done a big favor for many of us. I believe I was a pre-teen when I first heard this, and can't remember who the singer was, but that was more than 50 years ago. I just remember that it touched me then and still does. Thanks!
ICit4U07 1 year ago
@jackgardner13
Truly so!
helluvagun 6 months ago
@jackgardner13 ---------- :)) hearing the scratch of a REAL record made this song - that I adore - more beautiful. I miss those old records, havent owned a record player in forever. Thank you for this lovely recording :) posting it on FB <3
boogieshmoo 2 months ago
I'm so glad you uploaded this. It's really difficult to find a version of this song that is true to what was written! And she, of course, has an amazing voice. I agree that the scratchy quality of the recording just adds to it
TaeDanielle 2 years ago 16
You're are absolutely right about her interpretation. Most contemporary singers butcher this song with jazz cliches. I grew up watching her TV show and I never knew how good of singer she was.
hsfile 2 years ago 4
Unvergesslich. Vielen Dank.
sruotecnarf 2 years ago 2
jackgardner13, the sratch gives it lil' somthing extra, I just love this recording btw, thanks for posting it
~jd
justinian693 2 years ago 4
From first note to last, perfect. Such control of her tone and vibrato, such ease in the high register. So beautiful. THIS is the kind of singing to listen to and learn from. No sweetening, no composite tracks, no doubling, no mistake-disguising reverb. Just the voice.
Crackles, who cares. Unmistakable technique shines through.
JCMarra 2 years ago 20
one of the most beautiful interpretation of this song, /bow Dinah and thx for uplaoding!
passemoilaisselle 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
beautiful woman of color... it's a pity in old hollywood one had to 'pass' to be successful... but be that as it may, Dinah was awesome
gigimc 2 years ago
This was recorded in 1941, around the period she was starting to be noted as a vocalist in her own right (at the time, she was getting recognition for her appearances on NBC Radio's "CHAMBER MUSIC SOCIETY OF LOWER BASIN STREET").
fromthesidelines 2 years ago 2
dinah shore was my brothers favourite singer now i see why!!!
bingcro 2 years ago 2
this is almost the perfect amount of crackle, just need to turn it down a little. records like these aren't right if there's no crackle at all.
KrazyTea8 3 years ago 5
Dinah. When she passed on I remember the newsmans shocked expression. She was so alive.
saullouis 3 years ago 2
how did she die?
hillsidebeesknees14 3 years ago
Dont know, but she seemed eternally young.
saullouis 3 years ago
She passed from cancer.
Waldo99 2 years ago
Kudos for the Maxine Sullivan and Dinah Shore dialog. Beautiful rendition.
ancestralyuba 3 years ago
I love Dinah Shore and this is terrific, but check out Maxine Sullivan's more personal rendition; that one is very, very special.
billyguns2 4 years ago
Thanks so much for this video response; you are absolutely right this is a wonderful interpretation too. After the references made to it in the comments I had got curious, so I'm very happy to hear this gem.
kspm01 4 years ago 2