Alicia Keys vs. Lisa Lavie - No One

[ann2347]

lisa lavie

[deltaguy28]

Lisa Lavie! BY FAR! Alicia has Computer HELP! Lisa Dont

[TheNinapasaway]

alicia has a clear voice no one can sing no one like the way she sang it

[tahtahh333]

Um ALICIA! lol Lisa is is to jumpy in the song and less soulful. She over sang it. I wouldn't have that song on my ipod if Lisa sang this

[s2luvv]

Alicia

[Pedroal0]

perfect... better than the original.....I liked this british accent.

[ke4uyp]

I AM just curious do you have a licensing agreement to play Alicia Keys videos on your channel?

[brilliantbrunette1]

Lisa Lavie hands down.....she has great voice..!!!!!!!!!  keep up the great singing

[RAJEANF]

lisa has more soul

[hilariousfilms]

While I LOVE Lisa (I bought her song "Angel on iTunes and everything) I'm going to have to go with Alicia on this one. It's her song, how can I not? But I'm a huge supporter of Lisa.

[Doctors2Advocate]

I think Lisa outsang Leona in Bleeding Love... but it's pretty much impossible to outsing Alicia Keys on her own joint here. All opinion of course.

[fangirl4ever2007]

lisa lavie definately has more soul . She's awesome! go look at her new cover song Mariah Carey's Vanishing.. It's awesome jaw dropping!

[babybellagrace]

LISA YOU ARE MY NUMBER 1 GIRL, BUT IN THIS CASE I MUST GIVE JACKET HIS JACKET....

ALICIA'S VOICE HAS THAT RUSTIC SOUND THAT WITH THIS BASE LINE, SHE IS DEFINANTLY THE SHIT....

BUT!!!!! LISA'S DICTION, TONE AND PASSION IN EVERY WORD SHE SINGS, JUST CAPTIVATE AND COMMANDS YOUR ATTENTION......(don't stone me people, just a humble opinon)

[colorfulcrayon24]

i love lisa's voice she seems to sing ith way more emotion. it brings out the songs lyrics more to me.

[PCF5672]

She is a copy cat, she can sing but she copyin other singers styles 2 much, she should try being herself...........

[yho232002]

Lisa tries so hard to stylize an already stylized song...Lisa tries to mimic, shakira, leona and Mariah's singing style....just my two cents...

[Reva10835]

both great singers. but this is alicia's song. lisa is amazing with her originals

[princesslovely800]

both voices fit the song good but Alicia Keys voice fits it better

[deryaYP]

Lisa are here looking like LEona LewissS!!

Aber richtigg

[deryaYP]

Lisa look here like Leona Lewisssss!!!!

Aber richtigg

[kbayito]

i don't know why i don't like alicia's voice here...

its weird to me!!!

PS: i don't know if u understand my cmmnt! because i'm not a nate english speaker!

[dablicek124]

I think Alicia is better, it´s her song for her voice. However Lisa is great singer too.

[Kerdex]

People will say Lisa because she's less popular(indie?). I think it could go either way, Lisa sorta over exaggerates it..

[luxcretia2]

Lisa is great, but it`s hard to say who`s being better.They both have great, but very different voices.

[MelaniePortrip]

Lisa needs to quit with all of the exaggerated vibrato.

[Kerdex]

Agreed. *thumbs up*

[ryotiyken]

Leonas voie is too depp and too rough alicas is fluent and perfect and awesome

[ryotiyken]

i dont knw who the hek would vote for leoa i think ..... i KNOW ALICE IS BETTER!!!! Her voice is way extream and spirit and soul JUST BBETTA ALL AROUND

[firemurphy1]

alicia keys is better, but i would give it to lisa lavie because alicia keys invented the song.

[DJVideoMusicMixer]

Lisa Lavie!

[GianMarco241]

Lisa Lavien wins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[hasifa1234]

omg man cum on alica keys is so much better man but lisa is good but cum on

[luzzy321]

Alicia keys is much better ! she have so good voice for this song !but Lisa Lavie have a very good voice too !!...

[Fancy172]

lisa has too much own voice pieces..

[18357818]

sounds like some one trying to sing along to a record

[ih8thejobros1]

Its Alicia Keys song & I think she is better her voice is absolutely amazing. I love Lisa Lavie too but to compare her with Alicia Keys is wrong, because Alicia wins fair & square. Im a big fan of Lisa but this isn't her song.

[kodyboye1]

Lisa isn't trying to compete with anyone; she's covering the songs because she likes the artists.

And by the way, their voices REALLY compliment each other. Put these two together live and they'd be DYNAMIC.

[elvickRULES]

I agree, they sound great together. It would be interesting to see them preform together! I would die of happiness.

[tvrotsurmind]

Alicia won that, if only because Lisa still has an accent that sneaks into her singing. Some more training and she'll be able to kill that.

[JuztPaultje]

they are both great, but i love lisa's voice so much. She got evrything what a person needs so ill go for lisa.

[xxanimedude]

The thing you need to think about to is that one of them is live.

so its a little different.

if you really want compare find a live video of Alicia Keys to fully know.

[sakenny]

I like Alicia Keys more. but Lisa is so amazing too.

[soapandbubbles1993]

Holy crap iloveinu2death you write way tooo much!!! JESUS!!!

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993: Yes, I plan to be a writer when I'm older....gotta problem with that??

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993:...and I love writing, and when I get an idea or a fling of inspiration, I write a whole lot...due to my opinions being very strong...get the drift? got the drift? Good.

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993: One time I wrote about 15comments on a Youtube video one after the other...so, do you see what I mean by, "strong opinion?"

[soapandbubbles1993]

well you see, not alot of people here on youtube want to hear your long stupid opinions, ever think that? Huh? GET IT, GOT IT, GOOD

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993: Um...how do you know that?? Do you have proof or legitimate evidence of that??...because I've chatted with a lot of people on Youtube who agree with what I have to say. So that assumption you impose is inaccurate....and besides I don't write things for other people....I comment on videos..like everyone else does....so who cares, if people don't agree..actually in some instances, it's more interesting to talk to people who have different views than I do, it could result in...

[SaraLouise1989]

no im not bothered bout essay length comments either....im just watching the video :)

[iloveinu2death]

SaraLouise1989" Um....okay..thanx..I guess. *scratches head and shrugs.*

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993:...me learning new things..and I LOVE learning new things. Get the drift??

[iloveinu2death]

Okay..I think I've commented enough and have made my point clear...l8erz you all.

[iloveinu2death]

...because she could have easily been booed and had people hating her music..that can happen..and in short..she's one lucky and gifted woman as well...so WHY ARE WE COMPARING??..BOTH THESE WOMEN ARE AWESOME!! GEEZ!

[girlinemptyroom]

Despite our earlier disagreement- I wholeheartedly agree with you here...

[iloveinu2death]

girlinemptyroom: Oh, so you agree?? Well that does make everything easier.

[iloveinu2death]

...some people will prefer Lisa's version....because she rox too, she has an amazing voice, she doesn't even have a record label and she is already soaring with fame, she replies and reads almost all of her comments and messages, she's not arrogant about her fame either...and in short she's a real good role model, she chased her dream and put her songs on Youtube for everyone to see...and that takes guts...

[iloveinu2death]

I don't even understand why people compare people...everybody's different..singers and fans..of course some people are going to prefer Alicia's version because she rocks, I mean she can sing, play excellent piano, she loves to read, she was valedictorian of her Senior year at 16..in short Alicia is one smart, sharp, strong woman....and then on the other hand...

[iloveinu2death]

...Extra p.s. Actually there was one girl who, didn't sing it as well as Alicia of course, but I think she sang one of the best, if not the best version of "No one," on Youtube, her name is Ailee...and she sings this song really well. :)

[iloveinu2death]

Sorry..I love Lisa and her voice..but she can't touch my Alicia Keys...no one can..the girl is too damn talented...Lisa can sing...but I don't like how she did this song..it just doesn't do it for me...Alicia wins this rounds..hands down.

Guys...it's Alicia Keys..come on..Ms. Alicia Keys.

p.s. Please...nobody spam me or whatever, it's my honest opinion..do you want me to lie?? LISA ROX AND HER VOICE ROX!!! But Alicia Keys rocks way harder when it comes to this song...

[ClearWalls]

I just like LisaLavie better than the original. Its just that Lisa just sounds more FULL than Alicia's beautiful hollow voice.

[girlinemptyroom]

I think Lisa just shows she can do as well as anyone out tehre.

People like Alicia better, cos it's Alicia's song.

How many songs has Cascada ripped off???

And she gets the credit for it!!

How many people know that her version of 'What Hurts The Most' was written by someone from S CLUB 7???!

So yeah, judge on merit, not preference.

[iloveinu2death]

girlineemptyroom: That isn't true, I for one like how Alicia sings it, not because it is her song..just because her voice just sounds better with it than Lisa's...there's many songs I've heard where people sing them better than the original..and if you say that, you're insulting Lisa...what you're saying is that Lisa can't sing any covers at all, because people only like original songs because the person singing it wrote and created the song...so go toot a horn somewhere else.

[girlinemptyroom]

WTF?

You talking backwards 'my friend'.

I love Lisa Lavie's version of this song. That's what I said. I do not see how that equates to insulting Lisa.

At All.

What do you think this line means???

'I think Lisa just shows she can do as well as anyone out tehre.'

Read!!!

[iloveinu2death]

girlinemptyroom: Yes, I did read, and I do read alot for your information, I adore reading...I read that line and I also READ the line you put in about the only reason people prefer Alicia's version is because it is her song. So to answer your question. Yes, I did READ.

[reyna1216]

alicia keys is better

[soapandbubbles1993]

sorry lisa, but dont try and compete with the greats....not a good idea, you just end up making yourself look bad and overexagrerated...not that your bad, but she better :)

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993: I don't agree with that, Lisa's just trying out different songs to see if she can pull them off, it shows versatility because she can sing a number of different songs in different ways & on top of that, she never sings a song exactly the same way the original artist did, so that shows individuality..so don't diss Lisa..I think Alicia sings this song better, but I still think Lisa pulled off the song well...

[iloveinu2death]

soapandbubbles1993:...she wasn't flat, off-key, too low, too high, shy, or etc. she sang it well...but I just prefer Alicia's version.

[Karola2277]

Im not being mean to Alicja, but Lisa is waaaay batter than her !! Plus lisa is better in everything .. I love your videoos !! I would love to see one : Lisa Lavie vs Esmee Denters ^^ or mia rose :D

[aaronooi]

I prefer Lisa than the original honestly..

[mirtill05]

Alicia! More Clear Voice

[Ceniale90]

Alicia's voice in this song is already tampered and Lisa's voice is live. You should hear her mp3s.

[mirtill05]

ok....yes... Lisa is very big talent!

[deltaguy28]

Lisa by A Land Slide~

[sursid13]

wtf are u serious!! alicia keys!!

[usgirlsrulexxx]

LISA is like.. much better haha

[dan1818dan]

Lisa is better

[charmedjames]

Id personally say LISA LAVIE wins this one! :)

[angel203]

The versions are incomparable IMO, Lisa put her own twist on it.

[maximefimov]

I don't really like any of them, but who is this Lisa anyway?

[JuztPaultje]

WOW there both Amazing but i will go for lisa !!! check her album on iTunes now!

[mimi2boys]

They're both SUPERB! But I like the lower tones better, so for me it's Lisa...

[AanotherMistake]

I think that alicia is the best. But in duet they are best =O

[vsxgirl]

Alicia Alicia Alicia Alicia

[CGA214]

Wow, that's Lisa's unedited voice? It killed Alicia's edited voice. Awesome.

[rebellauniverse]

haha, I always loved this song when alicia sang it, but when Lisa did it, I felt I was on the northpole without clothes on with all the goosebumps that suddenly appeared all over;D They are both great, but LISA IS NOTHING SHORT OF A MIRACLE!!!!!!

[musicismylifestory30]

WOW! what a great video! two beautiful voices in one vid! hehe :)

they are both incredible.

but i gotta go with Lisa!!!

♥

[LisasForkedChicken]

wow, this video rocks!

lisa is clearly a better vocalist!!! this video shows that!!

[danny200333]

nice video, but I liked the Lisa lavie parts better..

[lisalaviesmom]

WOW! There both amazing.

[basketballstar1014]

oh yeah ur right she does i like lisa better

[Ceniale90]

Ditto.

[bycris3241]

lisa is way better....and alicia keys is so much good so just imagine.

[lisalavie1]

I REally LOVE THIS VIDEO, tHANK YOU FOR CREATING IT! :) What program did you use. Grrr I want it! :) hehehe THANK YOUuuuuuuuuu!

[Ceniale90]

Thanks for checking the video out Lisa.

[Iwannamakeulaugh]

it was awsome :D :D what programme did you use??:P:P