Added: 2 years ago
From: anon1987ify
Views: 132,214
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,252)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Milo is now in the movie "Mars Needs Moms!" LOL!

  • Microsoft always stages their dumb kinect "demos"

  • Just a prime example of shady marketing. This made kinect look like some futuristic star trek tech, and M$ know their target audience (teenage boys with limited tech knowledge and same sort of gaming journalists) buy into this sort of hype everytime. Sony is not much better tho.

  • This fake thing was made to diss other consoles

  • People, AI's these days can't even notice when they are getting shot at, nearmind talking back to you and understand what your saying. This was staged, but in 30+ years or so, something like this could be possible, but not yet. Not for a long time.

  • @FunnyAssShizz especially not on a console made in 2005

  • @MashedAvacado excatly

  • @FunnyAssShizz I think it was just scripted to make the ps3 and wii look bad

  • @anon1987ify He's not looking at her correctly because at the time it was still be tested which makes sense!! So it wasnt staged, but still working out the bugs and glitches.

  • Dude seriously reasons why u are wring i know it is fake and all but the reasons arnt real heres answers.

    1.Well do u look at som1 constanly and just stare no u look around and u cant get every game perfect can u

    2.the game isnt a mirror it does contain lag

    3. i know its fake cause if it wasnt fake why havent we got it yet and how is it so accurate ok bye.

  • AI development only serves to empower SkyNet. Autonomous computers will be our greatest threat.

  • ur a idiot and so are all of you who agree whit the person who made this vid. i would explain why but no point in talking to dumbasses.

  • Staged yes, like most marketing. Point #2 and #3 of your video are good points, but I disagree with #1, I think it's reasonable for the game to detect the user's position and alter the character's gaze accordingly. Just because it's not 3D doesn't mean our brains can't impose some sense of 3D upon a scene.

    And this kind of AI technology does exist, but it doesn't make commercial sense for games companies to pay the kinds of salaries expected by the people who know how to do it convincingly.

  • I think you are just jealous.. idk why you are, but i can just sence it. i was looking foward to milo, but he got cancelled, and for the record, that demo was real.

  • @joggnnn063 And also to all those people who say "We don't have that technology yet!", how do you know? we are pretty damn advanced people, how do you know this isn't real?

  • fucking a... I was fooled...

  • It's clearly staged, but not for the reasons you state, which could be attributed to lag/imperfections. The technology is so far beyond what we have now. Even the ability to accurately transcribe natural speech is a fantasy (turn on YouTube's automated captions for a demo of how well that works) - let alone actually make sense of it and respond.

  • @pib712thesecond siri got pretty close

  • and Claire is too close. Kinect needs more space

  • Claire should have rehearsed more. :P

  • It's clearly faked, but you didn't have to look for those inconsistencies to know it. In reality. games designers are still struggling to get AI on modern to pc to use 'cover' dynamically if someone points a gun at them, never mind respond to a conversation about fish or homework. The leap in technology required to be able to hold such a conversation plausably is at least 20 years + in the future

  • @magrathean0

    No it was real the kinect back in this video was hardware based.  If a stupid iphone can respond to you and stuff then so can this (when it was hardware based) except on a whole nother level.

  • Ofcourse Milo was fake! Are you stupid enough to believe they had that finished in a year. This may come out sometime in 2013-14!

  • @xRedStingx Limitations of hardware don't just change. This game was never intended to be released and never will be. It was just a tool to get hype up for the Kinect and show basic premise.

  • kinect you cant play football properly on it

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @MrXeXoN1234 haha! you dont need to believe me lol, I know I worked on it.

  • of course it was staged, its an advertisement, they want the conversation to go well!

  • Also, no AI can answer so fluently and perfect without the "GLaDOS voice," at least not yet.; However this is a very well done fake, and Lionhead better pull through with this. Even if it's crap, I really want to see how it ends up

  • @Jamaicobs

    Well it did the kinect is based on software and not hardware in this video they had a separate add on as you can see but to keep costs down they had to scrap it and thus limiting the capabilities of the games.

  • @Jamaicobs siri is pretty close....

  • also, THERE WAS NO DRAWING OF A FISH... she turns the paper around and it is blank... clever...

  • dude, even the game was fake

  • Omg i wos looking forward 2 milo -.......-

  • @PureEpicScoper it wasnt gonna come out anyway o.o

  • 2 years later...lie. fucking assholes fuck you xbox fuck you

  • its because they spent more time on fable.

  • This takes conspiracy theories to a whole new level...

  • @Androsss4pkmn1996 Nothing about this is a conspiracy. 

  • when she was playing in the water her hands were too close to the screen so theres no possible way the kinect could have noticed her hands there also becauase with the real Kinect you need to be at least 3 feet away for it to notice you

  • The XBOX was fake,there was no detail on it plus it wasn't on.

  • you talk too much crap

  • if u look at the drawing there is nothing on the page lol

  • Soon...Soon... We'll get there...

  • thx xbox is not on maybe claire doesnt want to turn it on..she'll lose some money,instead of paying for electricity she's absolutely gonna buy with those money some absolute vodka with some men..fuck u the creaters of milo

  • Its just for concept, they did that (staged it I mean) because they was still bugs and such. It obviously very complicated and in this video it's in its very early stages, which is why it wasn't released with kinnect

  • I hope there will be a Claire Demo.

  • The Xbox isnt even on?

  • i agree some parts make sense but the first reason is messed up. Imean come on the screen is 2d but the screen doesn`t matter cause kinect has 2 cameras and two cameras make it 3d like the htc evo 3d. come on man at least know what 3d is before saying its fake. So maybe the presentation was fake but microsoft may actually be working on milo

  • whats the song u used?

  • the kineckt isnt on either

    no green light :/

  • Hahhahha awesome :D

  • Maybe the game was preparing itself to let Milo take the paper from Claire. Maybe that's why the camera zooms in...

    And it's the water wich moves earlier than Claire... not her reflection.

  • everybody knows everything microsoft is scripted

  • sprry to say, it,but the one of the inovative thngs is that it looks directly at you...so the first point issn't true,it might as well have recognzed claire and looked at her

    wow point 2...how did you see that? :D

    point three...quite probable but there is only one thing...it happens after claire says "and",mlo's A.I. might have recognized "and" as: i finished my drawing,even though its most likely to be a setup,but,who knows,many things are posible

  • also when she was swishing through the water she wasnt doing it directly at the camera so how could it recognise her movements from a first person perspective?

  • I worked on this video directly and I can confirm it was not 'fake'.

  • Lol why a tour fuck this system up!!! Du keder dig!!

  • wau :)

  • Digital preteens meet digital bruin

  • Although it is clearly faked, your evidence for why it is fake is a joke.

  • can i save milo from my xbox?!?

  • /watch?v=rd11AmpRbXQ

    Get free:

    Xbox live/Ms points

    PSN cards

    Amazon.com cards

    Any ps3 game that was released in the last 1-4 years

    ^^^ Same with xbox 360 games and pc games

    Only in Canada/Europe/USA/Australia

  • it ended up as fucking kinectimals anyway.

  • Of course its fake....

    First of all you would need to record 99999999 of voice samples, and this is clearly not made with Microsoft sam....

  • now i can say its true cuz i have a kinect

  • @khan2234 do you have this *milo* game, and does it work perfectly like this

  • I would purposefully draw dicks for milo.

  • it is not a fake man , thrust me. Microsoft doesnt lie

  • @livexbox77 EEEEERRRRMMMM o rly?

  • @livexbox77 LOL!!! M$ doesn't lie =) you are a funny man.

  • with the drawing, he reaches up to be ready to take the paper, ur just blown away at how AWSOME this is and have NO imagination. this is epic, i think this is the MOST MAGNIFICINT gaming thing ever to be descovered

  • scan objects into the scanner and show it to a little virtual boy.... too bay michael jackson is dead he would have LOVED this :)

  • Milo isn't a fake, he was looking at clear because you attach a Xbox Camera

  • I have Xbox at home and that us real technology you think you are genius but to tell you something you are the most stupid i have ever met

  • @MrHouta88 you are the most stupid lmao

  • @MrHouta88 HAHAHAHA

    Please don't be trolling, the fact a person like you might actually exists is great.

  • so sad how far the stupidity has went. i mean how can someone look at the milo video for first time and not laugh how fake it is?

  • omfg you dumbass with tha drawing he reaches at the sameb time

  • I am not sure if you know this but the camera and Milo follows where your body is. So if you move around he follows you whether it be with eyes or walking with you.

  • @jjnonkey i got this but on facebook

  • Ok so you spent alot of time, trying to figure out how a video on the internet is fake, JUST so you can troll about the Kinect?

    Congratulations!

    You are now officially a douche!

  • plus when she has her hands in techniqually they shoudnt pick up her hands because the camera is ontop of the tv bt clearly her hands are almost touching the tv

  • urrr its easyer to say its fake by saying the bloody xbox is not even on!!! come on guys!!!!

  • @WndR100 you dont see the green light on the xbox?

  • @WndR100 it is on...

  • @WndR100

    lol i didnt notice that xD

  • @WndR100 It is on, but the controller isn't.

  • @WndR100 yes it was

  • @WndR100 yes it is

  • @WndR100 The XBox is on dumbass look at the center light, its green. It just doesn't show that any players are hooked up. Just because there is no outer ring on does not mean that its not on. As far as everything else it was staged for the promo but the project can do almost everything said.

  • Guess what's better than this game. You might as well as be talking to a real life person than play this.

  • Is that Molyneux?

  • 3:08 Obvious explantion - Infrared depth camera translates deeper 'depth' into the pond with more wave creation.

  • he wasn't looking at claire's eyes.... he's looking at her HUGE BOOBIES if uknow wat i mean milo.. UPLAYER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I don't think milo is a real project, where is it?

    Also, everything is BS you've said. except maybe the first point. If anything in the second part her image on the TV is moving slower or on time. And I know my phone can scan a high quality image in a second just using the camera, infrared can do it faster. Do some research.

  • I don't think milo is a real project, where is it?

  • last point is fail in fact EPIC fail milo reacts to what her hand is doing EXACTLY

  • if you believe this video you really have to be stupid the demo is not staged the facts that you point out are stupid take a closer look and keep in mind that the Kinect uses infrared to measure the distance between the players hand which means it will move before she does and he is not looking at her he is standing on her side of the screen and because of the camera angle it appears as if he is looking at her look at the edge of the screen in comparison to her he is actualy looking past her

  • Such a shame this isnt real, looked fantastic. okai look i know its not real , but watch in slow motion the one where she give him the paper this is meant to happen if its really good technology because milo knows that claire is just about to hold the paper to the kinect sensor,so he moves his hand to it, this is what you want surely ? just watch it honestly its true.

  • @ashleymason007 thats infrared technology for you

  • Milo isn't a real project. It was never ment to come out.

  • the worst thing is that the kinect was not even ON

  • Whatever it's not a super conmputer try to construck computer like this and then talk

  • if this were to ever be real it would be sad. If the computer thinks for himself, he'll eventually learn that hes not real. That he doesn't posess any feelings and lacks a heart. Imagine just how alone he may feel if he were smart enough to figure this out. Us somebody's can never make a Nobody have a heart no matter how much money is invested to making milo real as can be. He will long for one but he could never truly exist. I feel kinda sad for him. :(

  • @RoxasC08 You're fucking stupid

  • Kate: "You have finished your school projects...?"

    Milo: ):

    Seriously...? it doesn't take a genius to notice this was all scripted... advanced AI... for a fucking videogame... that's just way too ambitious and expensive for today's technology... so hell no this wasn't going to happen yet... sorry for the pedophiles wanting to get their hands on this...

  • you cant even be that close to the kinect!!!!

  • Who else thinks that this is creepy as fuck..?

  • This was pretty obvious

    only a 3 Xenon processer, No way it could process something like milo

    you'd need playstaion 3's 8 dual core processer :o

  • ur just an ass. natal was (excuse me, kinect.) a work in progress. it would take another 6 months before it was ready to be sent out. all i am saying is SHUT THE FUCK UP!

  • @L0g4n8or um, released in 2009 much?

  • i think this is all fake.

  • dude kinect isnt reading ur movements exactly right, and remember this was an early model. its not perfect yet. but who knows maybe it was fake, ur arguments are just a bit weak bro,

  • Haha fail... Who wanna speak to a god dam TV anyway?

  • Only good of the Milo video was that godly ass.

  • ok get a life, all the eyes and paper thing is just unnoticeable, u just imagined those,

    and about the water thing , did not go through your mind that the sensor needs a bit of movement towards the screen and she just moved her hands soo forward that the reaction had already began?. get a kinect and then you will know, the technology is so amazing that anything you try to point out even if it is bug or not well developed, it totally worth the money! makes people laugh and have good times,

  • @kostas00120002

    he isn't saying that anything else on the kinect doesn't work or anything he is just trieing to help prove that this demonstration was staged.

  • @kostas00120002 is milo a real game for the kinect?

  • Ofcourse it was fake, everything in that video was stilted. All you had to do was look at how janky the release projects were. Kinect could never of done that.

    Also peter molyneux always bs his stuff.

  • why is every one companing u just dont want people to get it because u dont have the fucking money

  • you sobs got 2 stop bitchin about this its a good console besides i dont see you makin any fucking games so when you do create a new game start bitchin ok so for now stick with fuckin yourself

  • LOL Good vid!!!!

  • LOLOLOL Good vid!!!!

  • Why would anyone even want this game?

  • @SpartanElite095 because your mom touches me at night

  • @GraniteGrenade909 Well that doesn't sounds like a very good reason.

  • @SpartanElite095 i know but its true and if you buy it shell touch me moreee

  • #2 reason, the kinect reation aint the best... i know cus i have kinect xD

  • another fun fact, Microsoft sabotaged ps3 because Microsoft told game makers of ps3 don't make games anymore for ps3 on a Microsoft computer. so suck it up ps3!!! you are finished..

  • @kelvin656 Ever hear of a Mac you Dumbass. Sabotaged? Sure

  • thats why you don't have any clue what technology is all about stupid!!!

  • @funnystickman119 she is to close lol

  • Why did Microsoft had to pretend the technology to be more superior than it accually was or is.

  • hahaha awesome

  • It seems that people don't know the word "Illustration".

  • and another reason is that you need to stand about 6-8 feet from the kinect. If you don't it wil not work

  • THE XBOX IS OFF!!!

  • I heard they scrapped this project for kinectimals

  • who ever made this video is a dumbass!!!

  • kinect is awsome!

  • u do know at the part with the fish drawing being scaned that before claires hand gotos the camera but ur sooooo wrong xbox knietic has a widescreen vision so it can see it before u put it infront of the camera dumbass!

  • its kinect you idiots! its scanning the body telling milo to look over where the figure is!

  • responding to lyonzy90: if that statement was true about no matter what your position in the room you are, why wouldnt it appear to be looking at "us" or the camera. clearly in this video he is looking at the girl not at "us" or that camera.

  • @imfat008 @GamerElemental - I agree with you both. It's impossible that the kid could be looking at the woman, and therefore the video must be fake :)

  • U are right because in the instructions it clearly says that u got to be far from the camera so the kinect can detect u and shes not shes close

  • @Jonyo25 for correct movement, yes, but for facial recognition and speech kinect should work fine

  • You're right, this is staged, but I thought that was obvious.

  • she is nerves in a not live video explains it

  • ye becus the kineckt folows you and no moire so he looks at you it isant fak belive me :))

  • this is just fucking creepy

  • To be honest, all of your points can be reversed.

    1. Milo is looking out to the side because Kinect has detected that Claire is standing to one side of the sensor bar.

    2. I can't really see a problem with the puddle, maybe I'll watch it again.

    3. The camera zooms in and Milo reacts to Claire because she was actually saying "And there you go" or something like that, which, I think, would be a phrase that the system was looking out for it to kick in the animation and the scanning.

  • he knows where she is thats why kinect appeared

  • I swear almost all of the stuff they promised this "amazing" thing could do and would be doing is complete bullshit. I don't see why so many people needed anything like this as proof to clue them into how this was bullshit. Now i may be a tad bit cynical at times but i would think the moment people heard them say A.I. and Xbox 360 in the same sentence peoples BS alarms would start going off instantly.

    I understand the tech in kinect is amazing, but seriously stop drinking the koolaid people!

  • @CrypticSilhouett

    Your just jealous you weren't the one who invented this. If it was you; you would be 2 things! Happy and Rich!

  • @rcnb01 Jealous? no. Would i be happy and rich if that were me? Yeah, but not because i created something amazingly technologically advanced, but because i lied through my teeth about the products capabilities. The camera can't see the inner-workings of objects either - meaning no moving parts for scanned objects, even extremely simple things like wheel and axels. Also there are legal complications involved with the scanning of designs like copyright laws. Prove me wrong on any of these, please!

  • Lol it would be funny if you write bitch instead of drawing a fish

  • so in kinect I can talk to some random little kid and play in a pond..... I question why someone would want to do this. Its like real life! Execpt worse!

  • Peter Molyneux just oversells everything, he's a silver-tongued gaming politician, and everybody seems to just buy his crap anyway.