Added: 5 years ago
From: james354
Views: 202,169
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (741)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you should really make a tutorial!!!!!!!!!!!!! please

  • this is the best one... love the live version

  • Comment removed

  • goth?

  • Ohh <3 i need this cover XP

  • marry me!?!

  • What notes did you use for the left hand?

  • 46 people are stupid. Its's so beutiful. I've cried, I remembered my boyfriend. He is dead :(

  • You are really amazing :) Thanks for sharing :)

  • Blessed are you that you're capable of playing an instrument so well as I have always dreamed of! However compliments you're really good and I love this song!

  • Soo amazing (: could you send me the notes ? It would makes me very happy (: if you want you can send me the notes per mail^^ denise12121994@aol.com

    thank you^^

  • 46 people don't have ears :/

  • i like ur bracelets. . :))

  • it´s very good

  • :O OMG THIS ROCKS. did u get this by ear? or do u have sheet music?! if you have sheet music, can i PLEASE have it? if by ear, PLEASE make a tutorial!! it's awesome :)

  • is it My immortal ?!!!

  • can you send me the notes for this? PWEEZE! i cant find it anywhere D:

  • i cant find any good piano sheets

    in vids ppl play it perf...but when u play like they tell u in the sheet it just sound like some chords played after each other

  • This is the version Amy plays live if you listen to it especially on Anywhere But Home you will see it's pretty accurate :P

  • This is fantastic, but i have one coment. it's really good but if you listen to my immortal, The band version (the one on the music video) the bridge is a little wrong, i'm not insulting it tho i absolutly love it and ur fantastic at playing the piano well done :P

  • I wish youtube had a love button <3

  • Very well done, you didnt miss any parts, i could sing the whole song with any mistakes on your part, GOOD JOB

  • why the heck dont u ever show ur face? haha :P

    I think you might have short straight black or curly hair, brown eyes..idk, just guessing. LOL

  • I did a version of this song. feel free to comment and rate it.. you can check my videos and subscribe as well. I'm just starting though. Thank you.

  • GREAT!!!!! REALLY GREAT!!!!

  • Very good

  • any money shes an emo bitch

  • OMG u made my day with this it was great!

    

  • wow u did really good im learning how to play this song .... wich every 1 is shocked kuz ive only been playing for like 2 months sooo yea but thats awsoume :)

  • can you send me the notes please?

    and great video btw

    :)

  • great speed!! i watched another cover of this song before, and it was sooooo slow!

  • Thats Amazingg :D

  • i have been learning this song and i think i am doing it the hard way .... u play it differently than what i have learned could u give a tutorial or send me the notes that would be great thanks so much

  • great song great piano play

  • really good

  • this is sad and beautiful. congratulations!

  • Tempo may be not the best but it's ok..good piano

  • its a little to fast i play it a lil slower but sounds really good

  • beautiful!

  • just beautiful, thank you for that, its a great song and you made it better :)

  • ich liebe es (:

  • i hav seen alot ofthe same song on piano and your probably one of the best great job:)

  • do u do tutorials?

  • your a good musician

  • i like it

  • very good!

  • yeah... you're a good pianist i might say...but lack in expression.. maybe on the instrument? anyways,,you're good ... nice job!

  • Yeh my piano is rather shit I apologize, and the sustain pedal is infact on just rather unnoticeable in the videos perhaps it's the acoustics in my house lol.

  • I've been using this to sing to I might be doing this song for solo and ensemble for school! well this or popluar from wicked... I know to diffferent ends of the spectrum right?

  • Creo que sí.

  • well done... bridge and chorus aint wrong luv... ders jus different version buh dis one is de real one... (da 1 dat amy lee plays live) soo yhh great job....:)

  • nice :)

  • gosh you play brilliently i might be makeing one soon so plz grade me lol oh and well done!! p.s i havent posetd my vid yet but i will soon!! =)

  • Pretty amazing!

  • you are so amazing

    this song is so beautiful

    and i repeat: you play greatly the keyboard

    x)

    *****5

  • the bridge and chorus is wrong notes :/

    great job though

  • If theres a pedal or sustain function on that keyboard, it's probaly worth giving a go, some of the opening parts sond a little too stacatto for such a melodious piece...

  • just practice >_> that song is graded as low difficulty if you want to try something where you have to think , learn playing to zanarkand >_> its mid rated but it comes near to pieces you have to think what you play

  • how did you playt so well? i mean, did you get sheet music on line or did you just figure the notes out by ear??? plz reply!

    great job!!

  • mee encanta:)

  • simply brilliant xxx

  • wonderful

  • nice :D

  • You Are Amazing

  • i like the end C:

  • damn that's bad ass. i need to learn this song.

  • freaky awesome :P

  • way fats but cool ;D

  • o.0 WOOOW!

  • This is the most amazing thing I've ever seen this is the best piano version of this song in youtube. You are amazing, I wish I could be even half as good as you. This is so beautiful! Amazing job on this and everything else you play!

  • verry gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooood!!

    i wish i could play as you do , but is verry difficult XD

  • wow, that piano has a wonderful sound.....what kind of piano is that?

  • Yeah, what kind is it?

  • wow like the wrist band, lol. i wish i could play with my left hand. im just beginning to play piano and im still in the right hand only still.... : (

  • Comment removed

  • very good

  • i love that ur all gothic and u play piano i think it is the cutest thing

  • good job :)

  • if i only culd read de whole sheet i wuld b vable to play it but without no sheet ifink its easier but u have to learn harder man i wish i culd play lyk u ionly play hlff by a tuition in youtube but different version.... how many version do they ave of dis song im confusedd... but u play awesomenessQ!!!

  • this is really good! keep on playing!

    your awesome!

  • we have the same piano!! XD

    if only i could play the same..

  • great Job! You Rocked it all the way! I love all kinds of music and Evanescence rocks too! I also like ColdPlay can you play anything like that?

  • That's really amazing!

  • Comment removed

  • Absolutely beautiful. I love piano-music and you did a great version of the original song, truly :)

  • if you want the sheet you can pm me and i will send them to you

  • uhhmm m.can u kindly send it to me pls?

  • Do u have the sheet for My Immortal?

  • Try evanescence reference. ;)

  • Wow dude you're really good. Sounds like you made a few mistakes, but i mean i can't say anything, it's gonna take me a lot of practice to learn that. So well done, i love you're other vids aswell. Keep it up =)

  • Hello James354 you plays very well I love this song, You did an great version congratulation!!!!

    ( I fell in love with your hands XD!)

    Sorry for my English it's not perfect...

  • wish i could play that way!

    if you hear me play my immortal you would freak out!and i'm playing piano for five years:(

  • <33333333333333333333333

  • im guessing you played this by ear? because it's different than the sheet music well it's the same pretty much but there's more notes than what you played but it was still really good

  • oh never mind i just looked at your profile...

  • that was great! how long did it take u to learn to play this?

  • Pretty damn good ö

  • u use sheets dude ? no chance to play this all without sheets :O :O !! but still amazin 5/5 !

  • just forget the last comment!

  • you are so great I love your klav ´nd you

    how old are you let´s met no joke :P

  • i don't understand why you don't answer

  • Why don't you read my Profile.

  • @james354 guy/girl (srry i just cant tell by ur hands) this is amazing! ur rlly good and i love ur baclets were did u get them?

  • You are the best man.

  • so nice^^

  • hi! do you play it by ear? its just like the original. till now i've found 3types of piano sheets and neither of them are original and i can't find it anywhere.

    If you have the sheets could you please send me somehow? but if you don't have them, then sorry for disturbing you.

  • thats so awesome! good job ;).

  • Amazing.

  • bravo! i sang along;) nice hands too. could be a hand model heehhe

  • you did a very very great job...support you!

  • do u give out the music sheets??

  • greaaaaaat well done u play realy good .........keep on playing coz ure realy good

  • you're so incredible

  • beautiful

  • WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!!!!

  • i dont know about flawless but that was without a doubt the best keyboard cover yet

  • you have some real talent because that was beautiful!

  • wow!! You're amazing!! I think this is probably the best my immortal cover ive seen so far :)

  • yo did a great job, flawless!

  • Great xD

  • Perfecto!!

  • not a very good electric piano....you could hear your fingers banging away lol....but it was very good!

  • well done!

  • great video! could it be possible to send me the sheet music of this song? thanks in advance

  • wow...its sounds like in the music video of evanescence.....

  • You are so awesome! I love this song, but I can't play it worth a flip!!!!!!!!

  • wow, well done..that was awesome:)

  • it sounds amazing, but still u have some technique issues,,, just relax ur hands. =)

  • you should watch scott D. davis playing this songs

  • Very well done bro=)

  • it's cool but you playing quite fast.

  • wow, amazing.. playing very well. wish to could play this 2

  • WOW, please teach mee!! :)

  • You are a very good player. It is such a shame that you don't have any tutorials!

    Take care...

  • nicely done. sounds better on an electric piano than a normal one like mine :P

    i'm thinking of uploading me playing my immortal, but i'm not that good xD

  • awesome!! =D

  • that was awesome!

  • this is the live version amy lee uses isnt it?

    very very good by the way

    :)

  • heeeey you play it so well! can u share the sheet? i never managed to find this version!

  • are you... amy lee??? you play the same same sooong i mean... same rithim :D

    GOOOOOOOOOOD JJJJJJJJOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB :D : D

  • amazing, good job!

  • 3 notes sorry

  • you miss 2 notes at the biginning..

    listen to the music again and loudly and you´ll see it!

  • I luff ur wristbands...and I want them lol and you did really good with My Immortal...I want to learn it soooo much =)

  • i love it. nicely played ^_^

  • nice wristbands xD

  • Do you have any sheet music ? I've got a one but it isn't as good as yours XD

    PLease ?:(

  • How long did it take for you to learn it?

    Its awesome xx.

  • did u played by ear ... 'coz it look like copied .. u know different keys from da real sheets .. but ur version its better dan da sheets ^_^

  • your playing makes me sing every time thanks so much im learing this song on the piano right now and you made me want to thanks!!

  • Wow, you're amazing...

    I play this song, but your version sounds different.

    Did you use the official sheets?

  • i have the sheets and i can play this, but the version i can play the notes are different, but it sounds the same !  hmm.!?

  • i have the sheets if any one wants them message me!

  • you are amazing<3

  • relly good but at the refrain the notes are higher on 1 octave^^

  • lol wish i could play that song

  • You Pwn fayce!!

  • I can only play the beginning. Love your wrist bands by the wayy. very cool

  • I finished the song!!!! Still not as good as u..... :P

  • try singing to it while u play. TRUST ME it helps a lot...u can tell what you're doing wrong. try playing it with the actual song. (u may have to rly turn it up to hear it) i could hardly sing to this :S i think it needs work :) work on keeping a steady tempo. note: the song doesnt get slower and faster, ur just playing more/less notes :)

  • oooo i love it you did an awsome job!!!!

    could you message me the notes to what you played please? i would really love to learn and you just did an amazing job!=]

  • beautiful....i can only play the beginning =( lol =)

  • WILL YOU MARRY ME? (i am serious) I LOVE YOU <3

  • This is really good

    xoxox

  • geez the bridge is hard XD I'll get it eventually. ;) great job!

  • i Have the sheet music

    i can tell u the website but u have to subscribe to me

  • no words!

  • Lol... cnt master that bridge and ending like you.... close though!!!

  • Wow! I'm just practicing but this really helped a lot, also, you gave the song the emotion it's actually played with, you play really good James! Keep on playing, you do an awesome job.

  • Sorry that last comment was from me.... Was on wrong account...

  • Yo James!!! I've started learning it!!! AND I LOVE IT!!!

  • Nice Piano

  • oh maaan!could u plzzzzzzz tell me where u found the notes?

    plzzzzzzzz!it's so awesome!!you r great!

  • This is really great, not missing any parts. I'm really glad to hear this ^^ It's beautiful!

  • this is the version i have being lookign for !! the live one I love you !!!!!

  • your so good on it.. please make a tutorial... share your talent.. please....

  • till so amazing... I love to watch this video

  • Amazin... All those negatives dnt understand wat piano's really bout. Your supposed to create the mood accordin to the song, and u nailed it!!! Well done!!! I myself have a different version and would love to play this version... could u plz send it to me? Again it was brilliant!!!!