Added: 5 years ago
From: macmaghnusa
Views: 130,976
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (178)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Love paul brady-glad he's still playing & moving around the country-Of course his guitar playing has gotten much much better over the years! If it wasn't for him, i would have never even heard of this song-I'm glad of that-thank you for posting this

  • Magnifique !! - Vive La Belle France et les Creoles !!

  • to nickorourke.wrong.a variant of DADGAD with the G down to F SHARP known as open E used by robin williamson for " october song" circa 1966.

  • @reevedavey DADGAD with the G down to F# is called open E? I honestly don't think so...

  • @reevedavey I know, love, and play some of Robin's songs. He probably did tune his A D and G up to B E G#, but that gives the same relative string tuning as open D - which is the usual generic term for this tuning - where one uses a capo for playing E or whatever. I sometimes tune down to open C# or even C: not to be confused with the "other" open C used by Dougie Maclean: CGCGCE (Caledonia) or CGCGCEb (Ready for the Storm, Robin's "Womankind"), or CGCGCD ("Waltz OTNM", Zeps "Rain Song")

  • Really nice to see this done in a no-frills setting.

    This is the accessbility aspect which YouTube encourages even well-known artists to subscribe to.

  • as the spanish say mrs jaycloth, opinions are like colours, there's lots of them, and you're most welcome to yours! :-)

  • @macmaghnusa nicely put mac, nicely put !

  • Not a great version at all, Christy moore and Eblana have much better versions on you tube

  • @mrsjaycloth Are you deaf? This is one of Irelands Greatest musicians

  • @chipper30uk \not everyones music tastes are similar, and i would be ashamed to be Irish if this was the best musician we ever produced. He is good, but I have heard better versions

  • I prefer the version by Christy Moore, Eblana and the version made when Brady was younger. This version does not do the song justice

  • @mrsjaycloth Horse manure. This is beautiful; achingly beautiful, and he's a great guitarist.

  • @runtsworth Horsemanure, big steaming piles of it right back @ you

  • Comment removed

  • exelent

  • Oh, no, looks like he plucks with the second and third fingers.

  • @brelfan Thats the 'dagda' way of playing-its a recognised method of playing, apparently. I know little about music styles, but someone who knows these things said that was probably the method used here!

  • @mrsjaycloth its played in open g tuning

  • @nickyorourke mrs jaycloth obviously misheard "dadgad", but "dagda" sounds nice: like an Irish legend!

    It's actually open D, as any good guitarist will confirm.

  • @PeterOzanne its tuned d b g d g d i always thought it was open g but i stand corrected if im wrong it is not tuned dagdad as i,ve seen paul tune his guitar this way for this song and many other songs like arthur mcbride and mary and the soldier.if you play guitar this is a great tuning for playing the blackbird by the beatles although the beatles use standard tuning for the blackbird

  • @nickyorourke I was a little confused at first - then I realised you quote your tunings in reverse . Tunings are counted from the 6th string to the first, not vice versa. So people count from the 6th - ie thickest - bass string, which gives DGDgbd for open G, which Brady plays for Arthur McBride. However, here he's definitely playing Open D, which is DADF#AD - one string off DADgad. I play Blackbird standard, but I worked out Solsbury Hill in open G :-)

    Have fun

  • @PeterOzanne i should have looked at the video first it is open d, confused myself now cause i forgot i play this in open g myself as its suits my voice in this key anyway happy listening

  • I'm guessing he's self trained on the guitar, doing it his way. That pick plus the plucking with, I think, his third finger only?

  • If it hadn't been for paul singing this on trans-atlantic sessions, i would never have heard the song--i'll drink a health to paul brady for acquintain. me w/this song

  • \\\\greatest pick-up line ever written... If it were not for the alligators, I'd sleep out in the woods. Yeah right!! PB is Ireland's finest exponent of alternative guitar tuning. Many have tried imitation but failed miserably!

    Great song..

  • Fine song ...have been hearingPaul since 1960s ...great days!

  • give christy moor's version a listen,........softer, as only christie can!...:-)

  • one of Irelands best singer songer writer's to ever live. Listens to these tunes my friends

  • i love this man soooo much :D

  • Amazing version. Paul is a great talent. I actually like the Peter Case version better...but, still. This is amazing!

  • WOW!

  • This is off an Album called Welcome here kind stranger. Pauls first ( I think ), every track is solid gold. Great singer/Songwriter, can only wonder what he would have done for irish traditional music if he'd stayed at it. Great Man !

  • A two hit wonder? Living off past glory> Aren't we all?

  • @jimdruid

    A dissenting voice! You're about the first one, notwithstanding the Hothouse Flowers fan. By 'hits' I suppose you're referring to an assault on the pop charts 'All Around My Hat' style, right?

  • @jimdruid at least he has a past glory... you dont and you wont

  • His song,:The Island:will last a few hundred years if not forever.

  • try the Hot House Flowers version,  it is exceptional, not uploaded on you tube yet, it is rare, it was recorded on the Bringing it all back home compilation

  • Really inspiring. I love to emulate paul Brady.

  • macmaghnusa,Thanks for this video I love every thing that Paul does,heard this first by the McGarrigal sisters,good,but this is magic.There are some great Irish singers,Luke Kelly,Sean Keane and I put Paul in the same class.

  • Though living here in Argentina, so far from the green Ireland and its culture, this great singer moves me deeply.

    Long live to you Mr. Brady!!

  • Quelle belle version... Merci Monsieur Brady.

  • This is an awesome version of this great song.

  • frickin lethal the mans a legend!! dont know how more people havent heard of P.B

  • i nearly agree dmoojunk. so beautiful but 77 version is still the best. so glad people listen to real musicans.

  • I've stood on the shores of lake ponchartrain near New Orleans or so, it was maybe a couple years ago now. just thinking of this song and of being there (and being drunk) makes me... I dunno... emotional?

  • the best version I have heard is on the Transatlantic sessions along with Jerry Douglas ,Aly Bain etc.

  • This version has really grown on me over the 1977 original, didnt think it got any better

  • Just fantastic

  • This is so cleanly played and sung that is a true masterpiece depicting just how folk music should be performed. It is exceptional.

  • that sound of the strings in the first couple of seconds is majestic. what a guitarist

  • What's Vernon Kay doing at the end there? :-)

  • Great song - great rendition by a great seasoned performer. Guitar not too bad either!

  • The argument seems futile to me. Many songs went over, came back and went back over again, sometimes within the same generation. It's part of the folk process. Restless Farewell is as valid as The Parting Glass and vice-versa. Just enjoy the song for god's sake...

  • OK, lads, Im gonna end this argument, this song WAS written in america (obviously), however it was written by FIRST generation diaspore that were there at the time, so obviously it's an irish song with american history. Anyway, either way, it's a super song, and done justice by Paul Brady!

  • The version of Lough Erin Shore that wordstreet inquires about is on the classic album called 'Andy Irvine & Paul Brady' which is available on CD.

  • lowdens are a fine guitar :D wata man,great voice

  • Have you every heard of irish americans? That means Americans of irish descent. My great grandmother was a irish catholic who came here as a mail order bride. She married a Choctaw man. It was marry a stranger or starve. So now I am a third generation Irish American.

  • I love this song and this is a beautiful rendition.

  • Christmas 2009 . . I'm listening to Paul Brady . . as good today as when I first heard him in '77... absolutely brilliant. . . .God Bless you Paul. Mike Kelly

  • Ah, that was very nice. And what a fine performer this gentleman is. Someone mentioned that he has done a version of Lough Erin Shore, but I haven't found it yet.

    5/5 anyway for your trouble.

  • Agree. He is a genius with the guitar...but we need a song that will last for few hundred years

  • would you like to expand on that?

  • Comment removed

  • ?........?

  • @akku2222 Don't get your point. This song HAS lasted 100 years or more, and being a great folk song, will surely last a few more hundred......?

  • GENIUS!

  • A prober song that tells a story as music should be irish folk songs are amazin

  • my favorite Irish folk songs are the ones written in America by Americans, like this one

  • IF a song is written in America by an American it is not an Irish song ! you can try to copy the Irish style but you'll never achieve it!

  • Yes u can!

  • 5.55

  • steeleye span me arse

  • could you elaborate on that ?

  • fuck me, he sounds even better! magic

  • he's at one with his g tar. lovely pablo.

  • He sounds exactly the same as he did back in 76

  • Beg to differ he has only gotten better :)

  • i think 76 his voice was better ;-)

  • go on paul ya ledge

  • beautiful song and beautiful version nearly as good as gallagher sinnott and the gibson what you think?

  • Omg, this is beautiful. Just beautiful.♥

  • Indeed it is. Have u ever heard it played by The Hothouse Flowers? Saxaphone gives me shivers...

  • hmm, not yet. But I will :)

  • Fantastic - Paul played tonight in Navan and brought the house down - fantastic gig !!!!

  • I was there on Thursday night nannerbj - brilliant stuff. Good venue too.

  • Ah just brilliant - he gave it his all but then anytime I have seen him he does. It was great to see him in such a small venue - compare to the gigs in Dublin. I was over the moon when he sang this - one of my favourites!

  • 2.18 til 3.02 unreal!! mind you the whole thing is unreal!

  • can anyone tell me if this is in open G?

  • No it is in Open D (DADF#AD) capo third.

  • Beauty such as this almost brings tears to my eyes. Amazing, amazing Paul Brady. Always.

  • Exquisite.

  • fantastic.

    i was in this tuning at one point but theres no point unless you can sing as great as paul brady

  • pretty much awesome as always!

  • as beautiful tonight as the first night I heard it

  • funny ending why did it go to tv program.

    Paul brady sings great song Homes of donegal!

  • Crap editing basically. It was part of a BBC4 production on the British Folk boom. The next to appear were an English group called Steeleye Span with a naff version of All Around My Hat. Naff to me anyway...

  • thats a fuckin great song

  • @beziersdude I just watched a BBC documentary on many folk singers and songs that performed on the BBC over the years- this song was from that documentary

  • One of my favorite singers. Thank you for posting.

  • Check out the video from Sportymike of Paul singing this in Gaelic.

  • think his 1977 version is better - seems to feel it more

  • big difference playing to a camera in an empty room. in 77 he was in front of hundreds of people, playing with Andy Irvine. If this version was better there would be something wrong! He looks well as he's getting on mind u

  • What a great pick-up line..."If it wasn't for the aligators, I'd sleep out in the woods"!!!

  • without a doubt the best version of the song, Paul is a legend.

  • ... great music! love it!

  • Wicked version of a great song. If you're into this you'll want to check out our profile, ta.

  • haha this is great!

  • Good man! I see you like Dick Gaughan. I remember seeing him at Cambridge Folk many moons ago. Incredible stuff.

  • ..re; MacghMaghnughsagh...McManus are another lot of blow-ins/invaders like the Nixons etc, and most other beings in Ireland. There ain't an Irish name for an Anglo-Saxon name. Slán.

  • that suits me fine damian, we're all mongrels after all, though I've plenty of other Irish surnames to call upon should things get tough. what do you think of malone, o' loughlin, o ' carroll, regan & mccann? bound to be an invader there. :-)

  • Multi-anonymous eh?

  • Multi-anonymous? I don't think so.

    Adrian Joseph McManus, formerly of Peterborough, now of Pontevedra, Galicia, at your service. You might call MacMaghnusa an artistic name, rather like Dylan. :-)

    Saludos,

    AJM

  • The Guy Is Just Amazin

  • Lovely man, I will dedicate my next few weeks to learn this beautiful tune on my concertina.

    Thanks. Tom from Oregon

  • this is amazingly beautiful!

  • wats up withh the bit at the end

  • Bad editing. It's English folk rock group Steeleye Span about to sing 'All Around My Hat' on an early 70's UK children's programme.

    It's was a UK hit for them, which is ironic considering it's a rebel song.

  • Hiya MacMaghnusa (isn't and never was a Gaelic name) Stop hiding and tell everyone your name is really David Lean!

  • Enlighten me Mr. Nixon. :-)

  • Hi boy....da mbeadh giota beag gaeilge agat, beadh 'fhios agat cad é atá mé a' maoimh! Olé.

  • Olé tu!

    Ojalá que yo tuviera la soltura que tienes tu con la lengua de mis antepasados en Fermanagh. Mi padre tampoco la habla, y el nació allí. Yo tengo que conformarme con otra segunda lengua, y menos mal que tiene casi quinientos millones de hablantes. A terceira lingua que falo, chámase galego. E a lingua dos galegos, un pobo de orixe celta aqui no noroeste da peninsula ibérica. A coñeces?

    Coídate,

    Mac.

  • I could never bring myself to learn the language Franco spoke. Sorry.

  • So you would condemn a whole culture because of Franco?

    Franco was also from Galicia.

    Does that rule out Galego in your eyes?

    I took the trouble of translating your message.

    Did you do the same with mine, I wonder?

    We 'plastic pats', as you might call us, are not lesser people for having committed the heinous crime of not knowing the Irish language. If you had just a scant knowledge of Spanish/Gallego, you'd understand that I was actually praising your bilingual skills.

    Never mind,

    Mac

  • Hey Mac...I didn't condemn anyone.

    You took the trouble of translating my message? I didn't realise it would be putting you to trouble to translate one sentence.

    No, I didn't translate yours.

    'Plastic Pats'? Who used that term?

    You think it's a heinous crime not to learn Gaeilge? I wouldn't say that nor do I think it. (more..)

  • (cont)There's NO CHANCE of me learning Spanish/Gallego as I will never be in Spain but thanks for praising me for speaking my own language and the 'foreign English'

    .Never mind what? You could have just as easily NOT sent the blinkin message if you didn't want me to read it. Olé.

  • OK Damian, but you're initial comments here about me hiding behind David Lean were a tad caustic, no? Or is it just your sense of humour I don't get? 'Plastic pats' comes from my old flat-mate Neil, a Galway man who never stopped reminding me of my pitiful 'diaspora condition'. You could call it paranoia. 'Never mind', was off the cuff. I was just thinking that any explanation I attempted probably wouldn't be good enough for you.

  • I was clearly wrong. This isn't the best medium for holding a real conversation, is it? Hadn't thought that praising you for being bilingual could sound patronising. Apologies.

    Mac.

  • Hi Mac...The David Lean comment was a joke about your film editing. Damian

  • I was patently a victim of a humour bypass this week. :-)

    M

  • lol. I thought you were winding me up. I'm uploading my version of this at the moment. Should be there in an hour. D.

  • come on the irish boy,this performance id fukin AMAZING.

  • Aye. Brady. Still my hero. Magic..

  • i heard this song in '80, climbed down from the roof and called the dj at the station and headed to the record store. took a few months to track down. fantastic singer.

  • wonderfull, amazing

  • Oh my god, Brady plays and sings so damn well.

  • gotta love paul brady. one of the best.. although i like his versions of this song from the 70's better!

  • Beautifull song, beautifull voice. i have done version ofthison my site , please check it out and tell me what you think. Thankyou . Peace .

  • one of the best songs I've heard in a long time

  • I'm not into Paul Brady's more contemporary works, but I do love to hear him sing the good old traditional ones. He has such a great voice. Check out his Liberty Tapes album. Choice.

  • wonderful player and singer....

  • excellent song....pure quality

  • If you search for Mark Knopfler of Dire Straits singing Lily of the West on the Long Black Veil album with the Chieftains, it is the same song. That is my favorite version with the uillean pipes. But Paul Brady has the best voice.

  • Change the cadence and you also have "I'm a good old rebel", the viaticum of the old South

  • Take a listen to" The one I love",bust a string nearly everytime I play it..E,is a sweet chord.

  • I enjoyed that song.. located in southeastern Louisiana. It is the second largest salt-water lake in the United States, after the Great Salt Lake in Utah, and the largest lake in Louisiana. Paul Brady has a very good voice. Justin :)

  • Wonderful Job! Thanks to Directjinxy for sharing.

  • anyone got The Homes of Donegal? - dynamite!!

  • I think the song ure looking for is the hills of donegal, hope that helps!! xo

  • Found it - look under

    Donegal (homes of donegal)

    great old photos

  • brilliant brilliant song :)

  • I'd never even heard of this song before a friend mentioned it and sent me to this link - Wonderful!!!!

  • Paul Brady again manages to play the definitive version of this old song, as he does with a lot of his repertoire. What are the last few seconds tacked on to this video?!--I don't get it.

  • Bad editing. It's Steeleye Span about to sing All Around My Hat on an early 70's UK children's programme.

  • It s amazing he still having the same voice as 20 years ago, great artist

  • Ah, this is a great version of a great song. I always like how Brady manages to incorporate small details in either singing or guitar (in this case especially the latter) that add something special to the songs, which are already good to begin with.

  • One of the most brilliant acoustic artists out there, period.

  • A truly great artist.........

    wonderful

  • ... an awesome take. I had been looking at old, beloved Planxty stuff... which then led to the Pontchartrain duet with Andy... which then led to this... and then, hey, whoa, the man's lost none of his old magic... in fact, he seems to have gained a whole lot more besides... simply one of our greatest singer-songwriters - Wonder Full stuff, Paul... rock on...

  • I think Paul very kindly put detailed tabs of this song

    on his website. I have seen him twice - here in Texas -

    amazing guitar player and singer.

  • well done!

  • watch tommy emmanuel,, genius,,

  • While I agree that TE is an amazingly talented man, I've come to view Paul Brady in a different light. I just don't see the need for a comparison between the two. To me, Paul Brady's music comes from a different place and regardless of the virtuosity of TE's playing, Paul Brady is certainly his equal. I can't imagine a performer with more expressiveness, passion and soul than PB. He's the real deal, just like Mr. Emmanuel.

  • Hello Skara, the tuning is open D.I play the tune myself so im sure of what im talking about, cheers ps. DADF#AD.

  • yep, open D.

  • great; I'd agree that his 76' version is probably the best ever. Tuning NOT dadgad but open G (Same as in Mary and the soldier)

  • i'd rather hear The Be Good Tanyas sing this song..not 2 b found though..dissapointed

  • Really? I like the Tanyas, and I like the song, but I can't get into their version of it.

  • the tuning is actually dadgad

  • have to agree with other replyer the g has to be tuned to  d(unlike the tuning you have sugested,sorry) unless you have followed the track when he is playing with the other musician (watch version)

    cheers

  • Nice, but it doesn't compare with his '77 version.

  • Keine Chance gegen Dylans Version. Weder Gitarre noch Gesang. Dylan wirkt glaubwürdiger, intensiver.

  • hot house flowers version i think is the best ive heard.

  • is that open g??

  • thank you teech

  • is he playing in normal tuning or is it dadgad tuning?

  • The tuning is DADF#AD

  • im glad someone uploaded this version by Paul Brady. Is this the one he recorded for the BBC 4 folk season?

  • up strabane!!!

  • Powerful as usual !This guy was a huge influcence when I was growing up .

    Thanks for posting this video!

  • does antone know the make of guitar he uses?