I wish there was a button that would automatically replay this song instead of always having to click the replay button which I find, I am doing a lot lately. Very beautiful. :)
I have always been fascinated with the cello. I never got the chance to learn because I was always moving. That is why I take such joy in listening to pieces such as this. So thank you for providing such wonderful music that I can enjoy.
I LOVE how you slowed the tempo. I love this song in a much less adagio like tempo. For me personally one cannot truly enjoy this song unless it's slightly more legato and not so choppy. I love this!! Thank you for posting!! <3
Hi all, Many of you will be used to the bowing starting with 8 slurred. I just uploaded the Prelude in G with this bowing (as "video response"). Certainly not original, it certainly sounds smoother. Tell me what you think - keep enjoying cello music. regards, Georg
I would just like to clarify, you said that the B in measure 23 is correct? My apologies as this is probably something you've been asked many times as its a point of contention between me and my teacher.
@Christherpiper, Yes (it is actually bar 26), there was a mistake in the first printed edition c 1824, who printed a Bb. ALL manuscripts of the 18th century wrote B. Cellists got used to play Bb published in the common editions of Dotzauer, Becker and even the former Baerenreiter/Wenzinger; they either didn't question it or liked it more. You can see the print of manuscripts on my sheetmusic website and click on the "see the manuscripts" button (I just added a link in the youtube text above) G.
The phrasing in this piece is superb. I like this rendition much better than DuPre's, Rostropovich's, Yo Yo Ma's, and Casals' versions of the same. This video also inspired much praise from two very serious classical musicians with whom I shared it; one a cellist/classical vocalist, and the other a violinist who is auditioning for the Paris Philharmonic. I am a cellist in training, so it is of unending value to me to have videos such as this to study phrasing and technique. Thank you, sir!
@PatTheStalker. You are right, I play a modern bow. I play an old cello not because I am a Baroque fanatic, but because I like the instrument. What is today in general portrayed as "Baroque" I find certainly wrong. Bach had reputedly a remarkable feeling for rhythm and structure - but just these two elements are missing in "modern Baroque" imitations. I rather think, the modern imitations are born at a time, when Romantic just got out of fashion - so they turned Baroque romantic!
I play saxophone...i always wanted to learn cello or violin, but i'm so used to put my fingers straight for playing saxo that it makes it more hard than i though :(
I just have to say that I love the Cello and I have always wanted to take lessons and I always dreamed of learning on how to play this piece of beautiful music and right now You have made me happy by playing it thank you :)
I have been studying this piece for the last 4 months I can play the song ok but you make each phrase sound more beautiful then the last. I feel that i need to work on my fingering, every time i play this song my hand is in so much pain during and after. Do you have any tips on the pain in my hand?
Hi @lilZoned, It is virtually impossible to give tips without witnessing you playing. Best take at least one lesson from a professional orchestra player, who has to play several hours a day. You surely do something wrong. Cello playing should not hurt anywhere.
In general, if the right hand hurts, you probably push the thumb to hard. In the left hand you may push all fingers too hard, watch that the wrist is always straight. But best, play for some one.
@lilZoned I agree. Granted this is coming from someone who has not touched their cello is almost six months, but for one exercise you can do to help this problem and try removing your left thumb from the neck all together. Do this and force yourself to relax your whole left hand. Let your thumb hang out behind the neck, but do not use it to apply pressure with your other fingers. You will not play good music as you do this, but it is a drill that will help you relax your left hand. Just try it.
@lilZoned I remember when starting playing violin at 12 i got pain in my hand ,but after 18 years old. I started swimming and swim crawl and so on hard 4 times a week. Play theese after worc and have 6 of them out in my account in the tube. Espesially in the prelude you can listen my fingers smashing down on the instrument ,i mean thats from the swimming :) To learn theese pieces time is the key, dont rush and say, i must learn it in two mounts. Just take the time and have fun in them :)
a few weeks ago when it was thunderstorming out at like midnight i played this and it felt totally surreal with all the thunder and lighting and the darkness... it was amazing!
There's this thing with classical music...sometimes it is played far from what the original piece was. I hate that. I'm always searching for the original version for every one of the songs I like, in this search is that I found your videos, u do try to play the original right?
The original manuscript of this piece hasn't been found. So I put all available sources of the time side by side and studied also the real originals of Bach's violin works. This is the closest you could come up with by comparing everything for years and consider all the possibilities.G.
@007Theeddie O'rly? Maybe if you would shut the fuck up and post your own response to this "SONG" so we could hear the right tempo and dynamics? You clearly don't know anything about classical music, and stop trolling. This man is really great, I doubt you could do any better.
@007Theeddie Only Bach himself could stand for the so called original version. That is the beauty of classicals, no one knows the original sound, yet, everyone can play, better or worse than others.
I've only been playing cello for about two and a half years, but I'm better than most who have been playing for just as long as I have. I've been practicing this piece for about a week but I can't get through the part where it alternates from the D to the A without messing up >.<
I've been playing Cello for 3 years, and I just got this piece about a month ago, but I still don't understand how to play it. I have been playing it in first position throughout the piece, and now I see your shifting. How do you know where to shift?
It is a Baroque cello, the bass bar is still the original one from pre 1800. I need to play this cello lighter than others, but it's beautiful, I love it (you can see a close up in the Erh Hu improvisation).
By dear Go-shh ! your amazing i hope some day I'll be just as wonderful as you are music is my PASSION ! thank you for inspiring me ! this is AMAZING !
DAAAAAMN...this guy is one of the few that I've heard play this in G Major and still be in tune! I"ve looked up a few others, and they all CLAIM to play it in G Major, but they're playing it in a completely different key...not this guy, though! Bravo!
An interesting and individual version - this is how I like this prelude - everyone can make his own work with Bach...listen to the Theorbo version by Pascal Montheilet too
Heh. First I heard in in Evangelion: Death and Rebirth. Then I heard it in Hitman: Blood Money. Perhaps a more unconventional method of discovering this piece, but it captured me from the moment I heard it.
these cello suites are played on violin? Wellwe already have six violin sonatas adn 6english and 6french suites for keyboard andGodowsky transcr these cello
(all of them) for piano.
But on Violin.Well,I liked to hear them on violin.too high is my thinking.butr Bach himself was always transposing he would have loved Tausig and Busoni .and yes he sold pianofortes even if he didnt own( as every1 should know by now).He always played at his masters' homes so he wouldnt need to own one.
It is olmost like Pablo Casals, maybe better. It is more natural and near to the original, than the play of the "great" ones of Cello olay, like Rostropovich.
mannycabrito, your idea about Bach and rhythm is a bit too simple. In a suite of course the dance movements are rhythmical, but the Prelude is freer. Many of Bach's contemporaries wrote Preludes even without bar lines.
Very interesting variation... I like it a lot, it indeed sounds very Bach. My most sincere admiration for this performer, and if this is really the way in which Bach would have liked to have it played, double kudos for him!
I'm a viola student, just starting this piece.. I can't find a recording or video of a professional viola performance, anyone know of one? This is great though.. it helps (just an octave lower). Gotta love Bach ;)
TheHodrod, after all my research this is the closest to the original I could figure out. To learn more about it I recommend to study the early facsimiles published by Baerenreiter / Schwemer (which includes an excellent resource of Baroque performance practice), plus the bowings and markings in Bach's originals of the violin Sontas & Partitas published by IMC / Galamian. The conclusions are a lifetime work, never ending changes, never boring!
Hi, For the left hand this piece is quite easy, you just need the first 4 positions and play in tune. For the bow I imagine this piece always even more perfect than I last played it, a never ending process.
Anyway, with some talent you should get the notes after a few years of playing cello with good practice.
This is so great, awesome, superb, i love it very much. this is the best of the best. i never heard a solo cello performance this good. great performance Georg-sama
Hi everyone i was wondering if you guys knew some good pieces for electric guitar that are semi fast tempo and kinda dark sounding not to light. I am learning neo classical and classical thanks and btw i wish my guitar was a synth so i could sound like a violin lol. Good job though!
The answer is simple. In this particular concert I played only two movements of the first suite, all other pieces were with piano. As I don't play steal strings, where you can retune just by using fine tuners, retuning means usually ending up with an unsettled intonation. I often performed with Baroque tuning and recommend it to everyone. Most cellos sound a lot warmer in the lower tuning. - G.M.
i see, you didn't want to re-tune the whole damn piano. I can understand that, four strings is a lot easier than one hundred and sixty some odd strings in the piano.
You obviously know your stuff. So what do you tune concert A, in baroque tuning? In modern tuning, it's 440 hz, so do you drop it a whole semitone, or not quite a semitone?
I performed a lot with Baroque recorders (like the Handel Sonata I recorded on the CD 'Sounds of Timber), who supply you with the Baroque pitch. To my surprise it was more than a semitone lower, lets say 2/3 of a tone.
The word song actually goes back in all Indoeuropean languages to the word 'swan' (sanskrit svan). I heard a swan singing and he could only sing in natural harmonics - the major 7 chord following with the major scale! The early makers of language decided, they 'do the swan' when they sung, hummed and played according to the major scale, c 20 000 years ago.
So Mendelssohn was correct to call pieces: songs without words.
Music song was first, words came second. Existing music was named. - G.M.
look a song doesn't have to have lyrics a peice of music and a song are the same thing, just as inspiring, sometimes you must listen and not look to whether it has a good dance beat, prelude is a classical piece, and it sounds amazing :D
Not necessarily. A song is music and this is music so it could be called a song. What you refer to it as doesn't matter, it's all the same beautiful notes :)
Primero que todo aunque Rostropovich sea uno de mi violoncellistas favoritos, lamentablemente no es conocido por su interpretacion de las suites de Bach. Cada quien tiene una manera diferente de ver las cosas. En mi opinion el Bach de Paul Tortelier es el mejor sin embargo no dejo de dar credito a distintas interpretaciones. : )
Por qué no, antes usted hace comentarios acerca de música Barroca, consiguiendo un encendió un pedacito diminuto para saber de ello. El metrónomo fue inventado después del período barroco.
jajajaja ¿y quien dice q no se puede cambiar el tempo?. ¡por dios hombre! la musica se trata de expresion. no miremos tanto el aspecto tecnico, y menos aun teorisemos todo lo que escuchamos. por mi parte digo q lo hizo muy bien, sencillamente se expreso
Aqui hay un punto interesante de discusion el de si hacer de estas suites una pieza para interpretar o si hacerlas una pieza para bailar (que de hecho es para lo que fueron creadas). El cellista debe buscar una interpretacion propia. De hecho muchos critican a los cellistas que se expresan demasiado en las suites, pero realmente todo es valido por que como bien dices es expresion.
This is really good. -Nod nod.- My first cello lesson is tomorrow. Ha I'm such a noob. But this is like superly good. Keep up the good work?o_o; or something like that.
this song is fantastic... we return to our classical culture
sgfmify 2 months ago
I love this song and think you are amazing i hope to play the cello like that one day and hope to be a pro in no time!
SnakeJones11 3 months ago
I remember one TV commerical that has that song in it.
khangphan00 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nicely done :)
louisianahhh 4 months ago
how does this have ANY dislikes!?!?
wafflelover52 5 months ago
Well, its another interpretation but, it was fine.
CreamDry 5 months ago
Great to hear a different take on a well-known piece of music. All interpretations are valid because Bach forgot to leave us metronome settings! lol
peteacher52 6 months ago
I wish there was a button that would automatically replay this song instead of always having to click the replay button which I find, I am doing a lot lately. Very beautiful. :)
ciciramz 6 months ago
I have always been fascinated with the cello. I never got the chance to learn because I was always moving. That is why I take such joy in listening to pieces such as this. So thank you for providing such wonderful music that I can enjoy.
xiiimerow 6 months ago
I LOVE how you slowed the tempo. I love this song in a much less adagio like tempo. For me personally one cannot truly enjoy this song unless it's slightly more legato and not so choppy. I love this!! Thank you for posting!! <3
Crystilwyn 6 months ago
dá até vontade de chorar quando escuto isso.....
RobertoJunior87 6 months ago
Hi all, Many of you will be used to the bowing starting with 8 slurred. I just uploaded the Prelude in G with this bowing (as "video response"). Certainly not original, it certainly sounds smoother. Tell me what you think - keep enjoying cello music. regards, Georg
georgcello 7 months ago
Wonderful, really enjoyed your playing!
djmob007 7 months ago
you'r a genius!! D:
panxocreed 7 months ago
superb!
alaric415 8 months ago
Listening to this just brings tears to my eyes.. It is so beautiful.
LiveStrong350 8 months ago
This is one of the most beautiful interpretations of this piece I have ever heard! I love how you don't rush through it as many other cellists do
Cellolife97 9 months ago
beautifull.......
apaiged 9 months ago
I'm a cellist, it's quite exciting!!! anyway less talk about me....
apaiged 9 months ago
Gyönyörű! Tökéletes! Perfect!
Vandababa93 10 months ago
I would just like to clarify, you said that the B in measure 23 is correct? My apologies as this is probably something you've been asked many times as its a point of contention between me and my teacher.
Thanks Chris.
Christherpiper 11 months ago
@Christherpiper, Yes (it is actually bar 26), there was a mistake in the first printed edition c 1824, who printed a Bb. ALL manuscripts of the 18th century wrote B. Cellists got used to play Bb published in the common editions of Dotzauer, Becker and even the former Baerenreiter/Wenzinger; they either didn't question it or liked it more. You can see the print of manuscripts on my sheetmusic website and click on the "see the manuscripts" button (I just added a link in the youtube text above) G.
georgcello 11 months ago
This is absolutely amazing. You are the man.
Anything716anything 11 months ago
The phrasing in this piece is superb. I like this rendition much better than DuPre's, Rostropovich's, Yo Yo Ma's, and Casals' versions of the same. This video also inspired much praise from two very serious classical musicians with whom I shared it; one a cellist/classical vocalist, and the other a violinist who is auditioning for the Paris Philharmonic. I am a cellist in training, so it is of unending value to me to have videos such as this to study phrasing and technique. Thank you, sir!
Mestena87 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ouçam Larissa Mattos com apenas 20 anos(e apenas 05 de aula). youtube.com/watch?v=BSjE9YCHyco
Mau12123 1 year ago
absolutely beautiful thank you for sharing :)
stormcloud7999 1 year ago
My ears just orgasmed
MMAenthusiastUHHE 1 year ago 2
Hey you play really well I actually am going to take cello lessons next semester in college
kittyanime7 1 year ago
Fantastic playing.
screeemingatawall 1 year ago
Quick Question, you said you played on a Baroque cello, but it doesn't look like you're playing with a Baroque bow, why is that?
PatTheStalker 1 year ago
@PatTheStalker. You are right, I play a modern bow. I play an old cello not because I am a Baroque fanatic, but because I like the instrument. What is today in general portrayed as "Baroque" I find certainly wrong. Bach had reputedly a remarkable feeling for rhythm and structure - but just these two elements are missing in "modern Baroque" imitations. I rather think, the modern imitations are born at a time, when Romantic just got out of fashion - so they turned Baroque romantic!
georgcello 1 year ago
I play saxophone...i always wanted to learn cello or violin, but i'm so used to put my fingers straight for playing saxo that it makes it more hard than i though :(
sofiawing 1 year ago
this is my favorite piece by Bach. awesome job
crazyelyxoxo098 1 year ago
Good on you, mate!
iassenzahariev 1 year ago
I just have to say that I love the Cello and I have always wanted to take lessons and I always dreamed of learning on how to play this piece of beautiful music and right now You have made me happy by playing it thank you :)
Jonas96forev 1 year ago
I have been studying this piece for the last 4 months I can play the song ok but you make each phrase sound more beautiful then the last. I feel that i need to work on my fingering, every time i play this song my hand is in so much pain during and after. Do you have any tips on the pain in my hand?
lilZoned 1 year ago
Hi @lilZoned, It is virtually impossible to give tips without witnessing you playing. Best take at least one lesson from a professional orchestra player, who has to play several hours a day. You surely do something wrong. Cello playing should not hurt anywhere.
In general, if the right hand hurts, you probably push the thumb to hard. In the left hand you may push all fingers too hard, watch that the wrist is always straight. But best, play for some one.
georgcello 1 year ago
@lilZoned I agree. Granted this is coming from someone who has not touched their cello is almost six months, but for one exercise you can do to help this problem and try removing your left thumb from the neck all together. Do this and force yourself to relax your whole left hand. Let your thumb hang out behind the neck, but do not use it to apply pressure with your other fingers. You will not play good music as you do this, but it is a drill that will help you relax your left hand. Just try it.
oliverleehornbake 1 year ago
@lilZoned I remember when starting playing violin at 12 i got pain in my hand ,but after 18 years old. I started swimming and swim crawl and so on hard 4 times a week. Play theese after worc and have 6 of them out in my account in the tube. Espesially in the prelude you can listen my fingers smashing down on the instrument ,i mean thats from the swimming :) To learn theese pieces time is the key, dont rush and say, i must learn it in two mounts. Just take the time and have fun in them :)
kaavest 7 months ago
a few weeks ago when it was thunderstorming out at like midnight i played this and it felt totally surreal with all the thunder and lighting and the darkness... it was amazing!
say3you3wont 1 year ago
Oh I got the cello, just haven't had time to practice..
jdole41 1 year ago
I love this piece, and the clothes :)
S7VIIN 1 year ago
There's this thing with classical music...sometimes it is played far from what the original piece was. I hate that. I'm always searching for the original version for every one of the songs I like, in this search is that I found your videos, u do try to play the original right?
Thanks for posting this kind of stuff.
007Theeddie 1 year ago 3
The original manuscript of this piece hasn't been found. So I put all available sources of the time side by side and studied also the real originals of Bach's violin works. This is the closest you could come up with by comparing everything for years and consider all the possibilities.G.
georgcello 1 year ago
@007Theeddie O'rly? Maybe if you would shut the fuck up and post your own response to this "SONG" so we could hear the right tempo and dynamics? You clearly don't know anything about classical music, and stop trolling. This man is really great, I doubt you could do any better.
Very nice (-;
Lity10 1 year ago
@Lity10 I was just asking if he tries to play the original or not, some musicians prefer to speed up a piece or change some notes.
He already answered the question, why do you bother writing this for me?
Fuck off, fagott
007Theeddie 1 year ago
@007Theeddie OFC, fool
Lity10 1 year ago
@007Theeddie Only Bach himself could stand for the so called original version. That is the beauty of classicals, no one knows the original sound, yet, everyone can play, better or worse than others.
GIFPES 3 days ago
you are very talented!
JadeInBlack777 1 year ago
I've only been playing cello for about two and a half years, but I'm better than most who have been playing for just as long as I have. I've been practicing this piece for about a week but I can't get through the part where it alternates from the D to the A without messing up >.<
Iarethedunecat 1 year ago
anyone ever notice how the people who are realy good at instruments or math look borderline insane? this guy.. newton...etc.
gravew0lf 1 year ago
@gravew0lf
Intelligence begets insanity. Also depression, but you didn't mention that.
xUselessThoughts 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing your interpretation, I enjoyed it a lot! Check my guitar rendition on my page!
MustafaGitar 1 year ago
Its very very good. Good sound, good speed, realy you can feel the melody of the music. Congragulations.
cordasdivinas 1 year ago
this is one of my fav melodies ever if only i could learn it on guitar
onixtheone 1 year ago
Well done, Georg
Tubatoofpaste 1 year ago
Unlike many of the videos out there, this is actually an interpretation rather than merely a performance. Beautiful, beautiful playing.
nrubdarb 1 year ago
I've been playing Cello for 3 years, and I just got this piece about a month ago, but I still don't understand how to play it. I have been playing it in first position throughout the piece, and now I see your shifting. How do you know where to shift?
MegaFather123 1 year ago
This sounds like Little Bear :) !
AlyBeez 1 year ago 2
@AlyBeez
That's funny, that's what I always think of when I hear this piece. Was it used in Little Bear? :D
P14N157cat 1 year ago
too slow I think.
dj12120 1 year ago
Nice... Is this a baroque cello? it seems so.
feydust 1 year ago
@feydust
It is a Baroque cello, the bass bar is still the original one from pre 1800. I need to play this cello lighter than others, but it's beautiful, I love it (you can see a close up in the Erh Hu improvisation).
georgcello 1 year ago
By dear Go-shh ! your amazing i hope some day I'll be just as wonderful as you are music is my PASSION ! thank you for inspiring me ! this is AMAZING !
mariahsworld17 1 year ago
I enjoyed this version very much.....
irondawson 1 year ago
Délicieux.
Spashley13 1 year ago
DAAAAAMN...this guy is one of the few that I've heard play this in G Major and still be in tune! I"ve looked up a few others, and they all CLAIM to play it in G Major, but they're playing it in a completely different key...not this guy, though! Bravo!
Metroidguy94 1 year ago
You play it so well
TheJade16 1 year ago
genial! my favorite!
solou4 2 years ago
Bravo!
exploitedk 2 years ago 2
Very beautiful song! I love to play that song on my cello
ghostgirl54701 2 years ago
An interesting and individual version - this is how I like this prelude - everyone can make his own work with Bach...listen to the Theorbo version by Pascal Montheilet too
DuoContinuo 2 years ago
good job
ThePunisher1978 2 years ago
Heh. First I heard in in Evangelion: Death and Rebirth. Then I heard it in Hitman: Blood Money. Perhaps a more unconventional method of discovering this piece, but it captured me from the moment I heard it.
Columbianbacon 2 years ago
true:D
Ayalachan 2 years ago
absolutely breathtaking.
subrock86 2 years ago
I've always wanted to learn the violin or cello, but at least i know how to play the piano
Nyahchan1 2 years ago
awesome! I love it!!!!!!
pligana 2 years ago
This is the reason that I wanted to play cello
jdole41 2 years ago 43
@jdole41 ha i was totally gonna get a cello and start lessons when i heard this piece years ago :)
ninetiesrule 1 year ago
@jdole41 me too, and i bought one. 2-3 hours of practice per day.
skyd171 1 year ago
absolutely brillient!!
peoplescrews 2 years ago
This is a beautiful song to play on the cello!!
Slixnixxay 2 years ago
this song was made for the cello and the cello was made for the song
just love it ! awesome played !
robbe8889 2 years ago
I love the timbre of your instrument, sir!
pressyboy 2 years ago
this is a very butieful peice of music in fact i made a kitten fall asleep to it (it was so cute!)
MrTableturns 2 years ago 11
Esta chisisima la canción
mortalsparkimetalic 2 years ago
Beautifull instrument, hoping to learn to play some day this song and the Cello :)
Napoleon3535 2 years ago
This is a lovely piece. I prefer Yo Yo Ma though.
awesomewelles90 2 years ago 3
ultra perfect...omg tears in eyes ;)
dazorz123 2 years ago
these cello suites are played on violin? Wellwe already have six violin sonatas adn 6english and 6french suites for keyboard andGodowsky transcr these cello
(all of them) for piano.
But on Violin.Well,I liked to hear them on violin.too high is my thinking.butr Bach himself was always transposing he would have loved Tausig and Busoni .and yes he sold pianofortes even if he didnt own( as every1 should know by now).He always played at his masters' homes so he wouldnt need to own one.
lovesGenet 2 years ago
Anyone knows where i can get his song notes ??I want to play it on my cello too ^__^(sorry if i said something weird , i'm not good at english -___-)
MarshmallowJumminess 2 years ago 2
Try 8notes. com. Just search "Cello" And "free Cello Music".. It should be there.
Babsx129 2 years ago
I think, it is not a variation, it is the Thinkink of Bach.
ipolit123 2 years ago
It is olmost like Pablo Casals, maybe better. It is more natural and near to the original, than the play of the "great" ones of Cello olay, like Rostropovich.
ipolit123 2 years ago
this was on the new episode of house! I think.......
cereberus4756 2 years ago 2
it was. season 6 episode 1: Broken
UrbanAnarchist44 2 years ago
who else cried when she started playing it?
sijas 2 years ago
no, but i thought it was a guy with long hair.
bluemonolith88 2 years ago
oh lol i was replying to a guy that said this was the same piece they played in the first episode of house in season 6.
sijas 2 years ago
It doesn't sound this great on violin
Makes me want to study cello too...
IdiotViolinist 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
CAN I KNOW WHERE TO DOWNLOAD
Jaqualine10 2 years ago
hmmmm. not very even, sounds sometimes like a dotted rhythm. you can take liberty, but bach is mostly about rhythm.
mannycabrito 2 years ago
mannycabrito, your idea about Bach and rhythm is a bit too simple. In a suite of course the dance movements are rhythmical, but the Prelude is freer. Many of Bach's contemporaries wrote Preludes even without bar lines.
tom44c 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is totally used on Battlestar Galactica! But I can't find the name of the track, and that annoys me.
emmasspace 2 years ago
Very interesting variation... I like it a lot, it indeed sounds very Bach. My most sincere admiration for this performer, and if this is really the way in which Bach would have liked to have it played, double kudos for him!
kroaal 2 years ago 2
nice bow hold : D
i like the variation
soulfire139 2 years ago
The most beautiful version of Bach's prelude in G I have ever heard! Wirklich fabelhaft gespielt.
MevrouwSluitspier 2 years ago 3
I'm a viola student, just starting this piece.. I can't find a recording or video of a professional viola performance, anyone know of one? This is great though.. it helps (just an octave lower). Gotta love Bach ;)
ThatOneViolist 2 years ago
You'll find an example here on youtube it self just key in:
Bach : cello suite number 1 mvts. 1(for viola)
Good bye and good luck.
BLNTBRGSFLBYMCLN 2 years ago
just notice, you hold your bow quite perpendicular...very good as rossicus1 said.
ssstar4ever 2 years ago
This is different than every other rendition of this piece that I have ever heard, with the possible exception of Pablo Casals.
I am studying this music myself and am interested in learning all I can about it as a cello student.
TheHotrodf100 2 years ago
TheHodrod, after all my research this is the closest to the original I could figure out. To learn more about it I recommend to study the early facsimiles published by Baerenreiter / Schwemer (which includes an excellent resource of Baroque performance practice), plus the bowings and markings in Bach's originals of the violin Sontas & Partitas published by IMC / Galamian. The conclusions are a lifetime work, never ending changes, never boring!
georgcello 2 years ago
This is absolutely incredible. Something about the way you play it just makes goosebumps run up and down my arms.
leonkennedy74 2 years ago
wow so awesome great job. i'm currently learning the song on electric bass, but it sounds much better on cello!!
MrNewmaneh 2 years ago
is this song difficult?
BobbyMez09 2 years ago
Hi, For the left hand this piece is quite easy, you just need the first 4 positions and play in tune. For the bow I imagine this piece always even more perfect than I last played it, a never ending process.
Anyway, with some talent you should get the notes after a few years of playing cello with good practice.
georgcello 2 years ago
Beautiful!
unusualmusician 2 years ago
that was beautiful, i prefer this to the original, has a lot warmer sound
jonobonnowonno1 2 years ago
fantasic job:)
thehellsyeah123 2 years ago 2
This is so great, awesome, superb, i love it very much. this is the best of the best. i never heard a solo cello performance this good. great performance Georg-sama
angelinrachel 2 years ago
beautiful...
whodathurdler05 2 years ago
Hi everyone i was wondering if you guys knew some good pieces for electric guitar that are semi fast tempo and kinda dark sounding not to light. I am learning neo classical and classical thanks and btw i wish my guitar was a synth so i could sound like a violin lol. Good job though!
thegarrettmw 2 years ago
Why didn't you use baroque tuning? You were obviously striving for originality.
mortson978 2 years ago
The answer is simple. In this particular concert I played only two movements of the first suite, all other pieces were with piano. As I don't play steal strings, where you can retune just by using fine tuners, retuning means usually ending up with an unsettled intonation. I often performed with Baroque tuning and recommend it to everyone. Most cellos sound a lot warmer in the lower tuning. - G.M.
georgcello 2 years ago
i see, you didn't want to re-tune the whole damn piano. I can understand that, four strings is a lot easier than one hundred and sixty some odd strings in the piano.
You obviously know your stuff. So what do you tune concert A, in baroque tuning? In modern tuning, it's 440 hz, so do you drop it a whole semitone, or not quite a semitone?
mortson978 2 years ago
I performed a lot with Baroque recorders (like the Handel Sonata I recorded on the CD 'Sounds of Timber), who supply you with the Baroque pitch. To my surprise it was more than a semitone lower, lets say 2/3 of a tone.
georgcello 2 years ago
wow.
mortson978 2 years ago
great really that's great, when i get upset i play this tune , it feels like music raining from heaven georg-sama
angelinrachel 2 years ago
The word song actually goes back in all Indoeuropean languages to the word 'swan' (sanskrit svan). I heard a swan singing and he could only sing in natural harmonics - the major 7 chord following with the major scale! The early makers of language decided, they 'do the swan' when they sung, hummed and played according to the major scale, c 20 000 years ago.
So Mendelssohn was correct to call pieces: songs without words.
Music song was first, words came second. Existing music was named. - G.M.
georgcello 2 years ago
look a song doesn't have to have lyrics a peice of music and a song are the same thing, just as inspiring, sometimes you must listen and not look to whether it has a good dance beat, prelude is a classical piece, and it sounds amazing :D
nutellalove16 2 years ago
Hmmm,well true that, sorry for being a dick! This is quite possibly one of the most gorgeous piece(song) I've ever heard
Aidref 2 years ago
@ Anime Lover,
this is not a SONG it's a PIECE of music, songs have lyrics
Aidref 2 years ago
they don't have to
1rstrombone 2 years ago
Not necessarily. A song is music and this is music so it could be called a song. What you refer to it as doesn't matter, it's all the same beautiful notes :)
Laila93 2 years ago
this is my favorite song!!!
666AnimeLover 2 years ago
Primero que todo aunque Rostropovich sea uno de mi violoncellistas favoritos, lamentablemente no es conocido por su interpretacion de las suites de Bach. Cada quien tiene una manera diferente de ver las cosas. En mi opinion el Bach de Paul Tortelier es el mejor sin embargo no dejo de dar credito a distintas interpretaciones. : )
Apalexpe 2 years ago
Por qué no, antes usted hace comentarios acerca de música Barroca, consiguiendo un encendió un pedacito diminuto para saber de ello. El metrónomo fue inventado después del período barroco.
georgcello 2 years ago
jajajaja ¿y quien dice q no se puede cambiar el tempo?. ¡por dios hombre! la musica se trata de expresion. no miremos tanto el aspecto tecnico, y menos aun teorisemos todo lo que escuchamos. por mi parte digo q lo hizo muy bien, sencillamente se expreso
sacopelota 2 years ago
Aqui hay un punto interesante de discusion el de si hacer de estas suites una pieza para interpretar o si hacerlas una pieza para bailar (que de hecho es para lo que fueron creadas). El cellista debe buscar una interpretacion propia. De hecho muchos critican a los cellistas que se expresan demasiado en las suites, pero realmente todo es valido por que como bien dices es expresion.
tyr12345yurty 2 years ago
ThoSE taKe CenTUries To PraCTice THose SOnDs...Go CEllO!!
Cutie1079 3 years ago
This is really good. -Nod nod.- My first cello lesson is tomorrow. Ha I'm such a noob. But this is like superly good. Keep up the good work?o_o; or something like that.
LlamaHayley 3 years ago
Beautiful.
MissNose 3 years ago
I absolutely love hearing this solo
vaxshin 3 years ago 2