She really sings in the studio. The problem is that it's only for 3 or 4 seconds at a time.I have engineered for artists in the studio. In the studio, you get as many takes as you need to get it right. Sometimes everything but the pitch is right on. In that case, the AUTO-TUNE is brought out. I'm not hating. A lot of famous people use it. A lot of talented people don't sing well. But, you're acting like a 12-year-old girl if you believe that just because somebody is good looking, they're perfect
NEWS FLASH HONEY: BEYONCE CAN'T SING, WHY ARE YOU GOING IN SO HARD TO PROVE THAT SHE CAN. ARE YOU BEHIND THE SCENES. THE FACT IS MOST ARTISTS TODAY CAN'T SING, ITS ALL ABOUT MARKETING AND MONEY AND NOT TALENT. PEOPLE TODAY DO NOT KNOW WHAT IS REAL MUSIC AND ITS SURE ISN'T BEYONCE.
@southernbrooklyngal yes she does!!!!!!! iv been to her concert i was standing next to the line and she came down and i could hear her voice come of her mouth !!!!!
I dare you sit outside your next Beyonce', Madonna, Bitteney, or Miley concert with an industrial wireless mic receiver, As you scan the available channels, you will hear every instrument and voice on the stage in it's raw from. Guitars, Saxophones, anything wireless... listen to the voices.. You will be proven wrong and horribly disappointed. Every current female star lip synchs almost everything.
You call THAT "singing". LOL! Actually, her voice is PERFECT and should be used as a military secret weapon to drive the enemy into suicide and self-obliteration.
Well yeah her voice was edited... But Beyonce really cannot sing.. Like please "Leona Lewis" and "Alicia Keys" and "Jennifer Hudson" and many more are WAY BETTER then Beyonce i am not a Beyonce Hater but it is the truth Beyonce really get by on her looks and she would be better off as a model.. Lol but she can sing better then she can ACT LMFAO!
1st off beyonce can sing. better than alicia and leona but i do think jennifer is a better singer. but the truth is that beyonce is the ultimate entertainer.
Beyonce cannot touch Alicia honey sorry to give you FACTS but Beyonce does not have the intensity or voice quality Alicia has. Alicia could do any of those live vocal performances that Beyonce gets out of breath so easily from without breaking a sweat.
NO IM SORRY TO GIVE YOU THE FACTS but beyonce clearly has intensity in her voice and more. her voice is powerful and commanding. alicia has a strong voice but beyonce has more range. obviuosly you don't hear well or haven't seen beyonce perform much. she is a powerhouse bottom line.
I have seen Beyonce's performances and while she can entertain, her voice is NOT up to anything memorable or unique or strong. She has no range. I bet you I can predict how her next song will sound and I will be right. She is common and predictable. Nothing to be called a legend or icon ever. Just face facts. O and thats why she cracked in EGO. Most singers dont crack on songs. Even when Mariah had a cold, she didnt crack.
her voice is definitely something memorable. she has a lot of range. once again you must have not seen her perform much. she is on her way to be a legend. she has been consistently on top for the past ten years just like alicia keys has. there is no one who sounds like beyonce. she is one of the best singers/entertainer out right now and YOU'RE JUST A HATER!!!!! im quite certain you couldn't match her vocals.
I have matched and surpassed her vocals singing one of her songs, its nothing to me honey, but its a new day and im tired of talking about her. You can but im done go head and waist ur time. Ur dismissed
@GiGiChante18 obviously you haven't surpassed much. last time i check she is the one with hit singles and a sold out tour. she has just won six grammys. and on top of that she has $80,000,000 how much is IN YOUR BANK ACCOUNT? EXACTLY. U R THE 1 THATS DISMISSED!!! TO THE LEFT, TO THE LEFT!!!!!!
@sydni96 "shut up, no one said to open your mouth, shut up, if u do not like me how about, shut up why is your energy on me, SHUT UP is it 'cause you wanna be me".
@GiGiChante18 All of Mariah Carey`s new songs sound exactly the same, and all she does is hit that high note, she might have Bey in that department, but come on the woman (Bey) dances while she sings, and hits every note.! If you`ve seen her live and you still feel this way then something is wrong with you because when I saw her live I was inspired.
@asianpersuasion08 Uhmm ma`m I was just repeating something you said in a previous comment that I thought was funny you told somebody to go "To the left to the left" lol I wasn`t being rude.
OMG girl thank you for saying that! I told my brother that the other day: If Beyonce was ugly nobody would like her! She get by on her looks. And she cant act neither!
yall are some haters, she need to be a soul singer that should be the next step in her career she always have chills going down my back everytime she sing she just have it all
What a dope. Clearly she must be able to sing if this moron says she can! "I seen her in London and Philly, and she wasnt singing to no backing vocals, at least I dont think she was." So there ya go folks, he doesnt think she lyp synchs, so clearly she doesnt
Just because you think she can sing does not mean everyone in the world will have the same view. I don't know if it was her singing, i'd like to think it wasn't but you can't be sure as we don't know her personally. This video was pointless, yeah i know i watched it.
too funny...thats exactly what i said watching this...most of the time? so i guess that means skorpion has no clue when she is or when she isnt singing...what an idiot he is...i'm glad i saw this, now i know never to watch him again...if o do its completely by accident
I'm sorry, I haven't been on youtube in so long. I didn't even know there was a video out saying that Beyonce can't sing. Can somebody give me a link please?
Well, the person who made the alleged tape made a youtube video stating it was a fake. He said he altered her vocals to make her sound bad...He even shows how he did it....
i knew that video was fake when I first saw it even if ur not a beyonce fan u should still be able to tell that the video is a phony i'm glad u made dis video
Wow, if that audio played on Stern's show is real, then that's sad. Too many artists (if you can call them that) today rely on studio trickery to process their voices (they can correct anything in a studio). Well even at her worst, she's still better than most of us LOL.
Yeah she might be everywhere singing songs but she always singing songs she aint have no damn business singing ie. ETTA JAMES. She's steals ppl shit n dont give credit, and she CANT sing she yells too much!
3.that person will ask u out or say they love u tomarrow.
4. heres the thing copy and paste to 2 other vids
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days
LMAO! You hadddd to attach me to Janet, didnt u!? LOL Like she needs any more of a bad rep added to her name. Anyways... check out HALO on the today show... MY VERSION
I didn't say anything about Beyonce. My comment was about Youtube having this video in its featured box. That means possibly more popularity and subscribers for the skorpion show.
Stern got punked by a gay guy from S.F. who made this sound feed on his computer and he actually believed that's how she really sang. Stern didn't do his research...LOL The guy already came out and showed how he did it.
I've seen the video and it is soooooo obvious that the video was altered..... it's messed up how people really dislike her and don't even know her.... but hey her haters are her biggest fans and im sure she knows that.
The same way someone say's they like her and don't even know her? NO, I don't know her, & I don't hate her, I just don't like her music. Her singing does not appeal to me. She can out sing me any day. I have seen the video also and I know it is fake, but it was funny. I feel it is way more talent out here for her to be overrated. That's just my opinion I am not knocking any one else.
for some reason i think Howard stern did it to get sirius satelite radio attention. I mean they are losing money, this might just be a publicity stunt.
Get your story straight, Howard said JD (his employee) discovered someone uploading this to YouTube and he played and talked about it, he's not the one that did it.
I think that it is hillarious how people are reporting on this video saying its real. Its obviously fake. To me it shows how someone will always be ready to throw some dirt on someones image.
talking about guys recording u naked is class. i.e video phone getting on stripper poles is class? suga mama talking about your pussy is class. kitty kat having ur bf spank ur butt and then grab his buckle mimickin oral sex is class. lmao.... i dont care if britney is worst, beyonce is still on that boat to. end of story. a molester is not as bad as totaly raping someone, but they all still guilty of something bad. end of story. toodles. :-D
lol beyonce is a fucking great singer and for people to say she can or cant lol WHAT THE FUCK DO YALL KNOW!!!! lol yall aint a manager or yall didnt set up the stage so how yall know there are computers around to make her sound better i know personally cause she sang at a venue florida and i was there!!! only a mic and michelle and kelly beside her
It is likely she will have to perform in a room without a computer to verify she can sing, unlikely. Her immediate handlers are concerned her career could end up the same as Milli Vanilli. "However, their success turned to infamy when their Grammy was revoked after it was revealed that the actual vocals on the record were not the voices of Morvan and Pilatus".
Like Brittney, Lindsy, Jessica Alba, and most other female celebs... wha'ts your point? She rocks as an entertainer and the money she makes backs that up.
Brittney is a legend for her ability to lead stray prepubescent girls into sex, lies, and video tape... She was originally pushed out as a "pop princess" so naturally with all the cutesy and the pink, those girls would follow. She was already trying to evolve out of that shadow after her first album.. She grew 2 fast for her followers... To say that Lidsay is in any way better than Beyonce, is sad and further illustrates my point. The good and humble are ignored while the crackwhores R praised.
Beyonce was never a promoted preteen idle, dear heart.... Beyonce came out as a sex symbol with Destiny's child... They were singing adult music to young adults and older from the jump... Brittney spears's demographic was much younger... That's the major difference...
I'm not trying to be rude either but in order for what you to say to be true, you have to really know the difference between class and what you're talking about right now. In fact, you're perception is pretty ass backwards. Based on your comments sexuality and singing about grown up things makes you unclassy... Destny's child Singing about Sex and Brittney Spears Sucking off her boyfriend on camera and purposely leaking it for cash is probably a good place to start.
uhm we have seen beyonce "sucking" her boyfriend in public too we have seen her spread her legs open several times her pubic area, and all was showing. like i said beyonce is NOT classy u were trying to say brit started off all innocent and i said no she didnt. none of them did ur arguement is that cause britney is slightly worst that mean beyonce is classy like wtf. lmao thats like saying he killed one person so he is good, and he killed five people so he is bad NO! dont wrk that way
lol... You really need a vocab lesson. I have come to the conclusion that you have no idea word the term classy entails. That's fine. I can accept that. Until you do. We can talk because we'll be going around in circles. Most of your argument revolves around the songs she sing and not who she is as a person. Just because the Paparazzi got a few lucky photos of her vagina, doesn't mean she isn't a classy person... You are very misguided. You've yet to discredit her class. Until you do... STFU :)
y cant u just admit that there is nothing classy about beys ways it is in fact your brain that is mushed, if u think adoring a classless female is cool
wait did u justsay quote "Jus because the Papzri got a few lucky photos of her vagina, doesn't mean she isn't a classy person.
lmao! so this applies to britney lindsay and the rest of them
beyonce as a person? uhm we dont know any of these people personaly so, we go by what we see and hear
no matter how u try to spell it. BEY IS NOT CLASSY!
lol... Fuck what you say... I will say this, though... Beyonce has endorsments... Those other bitches don't...(not real ones anyway)...
Secondly, everything you've brought up, 99.9% of everything you'd said revolved around videos made and performances on stage... Like I said, she's a sex symbol... the way she acts when performing her music is what sells... It's all business... But at the end of the day, when the media catches up... Beyonce is being a lady, while them other girls are not.
LMAo so wtf was ur point here how is britney worst than beyonce if u dont want to bring up videos and songs then there is nothing to discuss cause u also said the papparazzi got lucky with bey vajina shots, so i guess the same goes for brit she didnt purposely show her twat to the paparazzi so wtf u tlk bout shavin ur head, loosing kids dont make u trashy it makes u mentaly unstable bey aint no sex symbol marilyn monroe elvis, eartha kit, lena horne, shakira are sexy bey trashy night
As you can see from my first reply my typing skills are not first rate, yet I try for grammatical correctness when possible. The art of the written word, is it seems in peril. But we are communicating, so it can't all be bad LOL Kudos from a fellow lover of the lexicon.
In comparison to Lindsay and Brittney Beyonce is all class. She's a performer, a dancer, a sex symbol, just as she's always been. Brittney spears has been in and out of rehabs, mental facilities, and custody battles for her to have any kind of custody battles. - How can you compare any of that with the actions of Beyonce?? You can't... You come up with a lame attack on NoNoNo lyrics written FYE only... come on now... get real... Beyonce is the epitome of class compared to Spears and Lohan.
Salma Heyek spread their legs more times than Sasha Fierce ever did... lol... While Beyonce did it on music videos... Salma did it fully nude on video... Not only that, she's taken scantly clad pictures naked, and dancing on "stripper poles" as you claim beyonce did and it wasn't done in a classy fashion. Get your fact straight. I love Shakira, but Shakira has done the pole thing and she gyrates and pops more than elvis presley. Anyway... the whole argument is about Class not... sensuality.
What you hear over the tv, stage, etc. is from a cd. It's not really "live". Nothing you hear on tv even if it's "live" is actually "live" regardless of what you think. Not disrespecting just letting you all know. The track on Stern is 100% real.
Beyonce already confirmed ion MTV and as much as U really want it to be true ut's not. She said if U wanna hear her sing live "u can watch the today show tomorrow and she'll be singing Halo" and that is is great promotion whoever came up with the idea. She also said it was great promotion
i just listened to it and it angered my fuckin soul that anyone wud do that to an artist on top of her game im a huge beyonce fan and do they really think from all her vocal training that she is even capable of sounding like that and anyone who reall wants to hear what her voice really sounds like watch the inaurgaration of Obama and the performance at the tyra banks show
When i first saw it on MTO, i didnt believe it (even tho it was funny) cuz i heard her sing acapella many times and it was beautiful but i KNEW some dumb asses would believe it and make it a huge thing. It sound SO fake too...come on yall...don't be stupid!
Solange said on twitter "If you believe that is Beyonce's vocals that Howard Stern put up you are an IDIOT!" I concur! quit believing EVERYTHING you hear!
People need to stop listening to EVERYTHING! I'm with Solange..I follow her on twitter and she said " If you believe that is Beyonce's vocals Howard Stern put u"
now dont get mad at me when i say this but i know that beyonce can sing and i am a fan of hers but i think that she also lip-synce too with all that dancing she does and she is singing that strong i dont know but if she is singing while dancing that hard then she should be called superwomen lol i dont care is she lipsynce as long as she gives a great perfromance like she always does and when i heard that audio i thought it was funny because i know that she sing it was a great laugh none the less
i heard that back in what november? the single ladies one was funny. but anyone who couldn't tell it was fake, c'mon now be realistic. she does acapella's alllll the time.
Well it's good 2 c that U have some sense Kevin! Anybody with an unbiased ear & @ least 4 brain cells would know the audio had been altered- I mean, it didnt even sound natural! I swear, haters got so much negativity & hate (4 themselves of course), that they cant even think straight! I actually enjoyed the audio b/c it was so CLEARLY a joke! Unfortunately these cave men turned somethin so innocent n2 somethin so corrupt! SMH! Glad 2 c B speak out on it too! Like she said, "thanks 4 the promo"!
When I first heard it I was like Betonce is that really you. I mean i've heard her sing to many times. I knew she was lyping on the Today Show but sounding that horrible. I mean why would you take the time out of your day to make a fake video. Some people need to be in school or get a job!!!I mean seriously get a life!!!
That is soooo stupid!!! Everybody should know that Beyonce CAN sing. Like Skorpion said, better than some of the girls out right now, who will remain nameless.
People just hating cuz B is on top, and whoever they girl is, is not!!!!
im suprised that its being talked about now when it was made months ago. its funny to know that if alot of people talk about something that it makes it gospel.
Who gives a shit? Music these days suck ass. If you enjoy recent music your probably a retard or have no sense of good music.
fightfirewithfire04 1 month ago
cause we masterbat over you hahahahahahahahahahaha
JuniorT695 5 months ago
Apparently a lot of people do not know about studio magic, using autotune. Some of these singers are studio produced, including Beyonce.
Tenorforte 9 months ago
She really sings in the studio. The problem is that it's only for 3 or 4 seconds at a time.I have engineered for artists in the studio. In the studio, you get as many takes as you need to get it right. Sometimes everything but the pitch is right on. In that case, the AUTO-TUNE is brought out. I'm not hating. A lot of famous people use it. A lot of talented people don't sing well. But, you're acting like a 12-year-old girl if you believe that just because somebody is good looking, they're perfect
partysince96 1 year ago
NEWS FLASH HONEY: BEYONCE CAN'T SING, WHY ARE YOU GOING IN SO HARD TO PROVE THAT SHE CAN. ARE YOU BEHIND THE SCENES. THE FACT IS MOST ARTISTS TODAY CAN'T SING, ITS ALL ABOUT MARKETING AND MONEY AND NOT TALENT. PEOPLE TODAY DO NOT KNOW WHAT IS REAL MUSIC AND ITS SURE ISN'T BEYONCE.
southernbrooklyngal 1 year ago
@southernbrooklyngal yes she does!!!!!!! iv been to her concert i was standing next to the line and she came down and i could hear her voice come of her mouth !!!!!
aranamin 11 months ago
she can't sing, all her live stuff is fake backing tracks she has prepared prior to the shows.
RaymondFRevalee 1 year ago
@RaymondFRevalee no she dnt she sings liive and u can hear her breath through the mic
beyonce dnt ever lip sing and she dnt have back up tracks to make her voice sound bigger !
aranamin 11 months ago 3
yah youre right!
blackrose4ur 1 year ago
I'm a full time road crew, technical sector..
I dare you sit outside your next Beyonce', Madonna, Bitteney, or Miley concert with an industrial wireless mic receiver, As you scan the available channels, you will hear every instrument and voice on the stage in it's raw from. Guitars, Saxophones, anything wireless... listen to the voices.. You will be proven wrong and horribly disappointed. Every current female star lip synchs almost everything.
ifixmixers 1 year ago
You call THAT "singing". LOL! Actually, her voice is PERFECT and should be used as a military secret weapon to drive the enemy into suicide and self-obliteration.
Eschatus2 1 year ago
BLAAAHH BLLAAAAH BLLAAAHH
Sure, she can sing, just not always IN THE CORRECT KEY!
DrMotorDude 1 year ago
Comment removed
kanitab 2 years ago
Truth hurts the beyonce-zombies
godscuttingyoudown 2 years ago
Very rarely does she even sing live and when she does, it sounds horrible.
janembasson 2 years ago
Are you RETARDED????????????? You dont know what the hell youre talking about. She sings LIVE AT EVERY PERFORMANCE. Step off.
divatif 2 years ago
Anyone who thinks Beyonce can't sing must be really stupid.She's an amazing singer and everybody knows that.
studyingbiology 2 years ago 3
you've seen her and you heard a tape. she along with madonna, janet jackson & britney lipsynch live
kliff215 2 years ago
Well yeah her voice was edited... But Beyonce really cannot sing.. Like please "Leona Lewis" and "Alicia Keys" and "Jennifer Hudson" and many more are WAY BETTER then Beyonce i am not a Beyonce Hater but it is the truth Beyonce really get by on her looks and she would be better off as a model.. Lol but she can sing better then she can ACT LMFAO!
Aaliyahluva33 2 years ago
1st off beyonce can sing. better than alicia and leona but i do think jennifer is a better singer. but the truth is that beyonce is the ultimate entertainer.
asianpersuasion08 2 years ago 3
Beyonce cannot touch Alicia honey sorry to give you FACTS but Beyonce does not have the intensity or voice quality Alicia has. Alicia could do any of those live vocal performances that Beyonce gets out of breath so easily from without breaking a sweat.
GiGiChante18 2 years ago
NO IM SORRY TO GIVE YOU THE FACTS but beyonce clearly has intensity in her voice and more. her voice is powerful and commanding. alicia has a strong voice but beyonce has more range. obviuosly you don't hear well or haven't seen beyonce perform much. she is a powerhouse bottom line.
asianpersuasion08 2 years ago
I have seen Beyonce's performances and while she can entertain, her voice is NOT up to anything memorable or unique or strong. She has no range. I bet you I can predict how her next song will sound and I will be right. She is common and predictable. Nothing to be called a legend or icon ever. Just face facts. O and thats why she cracked in EGO. Most singers dont crack on songs. Even when Mariah had a cold, she didnt crack.
GiGiChante18 2 years ago
her voice is definitely something memorable. she has a lot of range. once again you must have not seen her perform much. she is on her way to be a legend. she has been consistently on top for the past ten years just like alicia keys has. there is no one who sounds like beyonce. she is one of the best singers/entertainer out right now and YOU'RE JUST A HATER!!!!! im quite certain you couldn't match her vocals.
asianpersuasion08 2 years ago
I have matched and surpassed her vocals singing one of her songs, its nothing to me honey, but its a new day and im tired of talking about her. You can but im done go head and waist ur time. Ur dismissed
GiGiChante18 2 years ago
@GiGiChante18 obviously you haven't surpassed much. last time i check she is the one with hit singles and a sold out tour. she has just won six grammys. and on top of that she has $80,000,000 how much is IN YOUR BANK ACCOUNT? EXACTLY. U R THE 1 THATS DISMISSED!!! TO THE LEFT, TO THE LEFT!!!!!!
asianpersuasion08 2 years ago
@asianpersuasion08 Lmao "To the left, to the left"
sydni96 1 year ago
@sydni96 "shut up, no one said to open your mouth, shut up, if u do not like me how about, shut up why is your energy on me, SHUT UP is it 'cause you wanna be me".
asianpersuasion08 1 year ago
@GiGiChante18 All of Mariah Carey`s new songs sound exactly the same, and all she does is hit that high note, she might have Bey in that department, but come on the woman (Bey) dances while she sings, and hits every note.! If you`ve seen her live and you still feel this way then something is wrong with you because when I saw her live I was inspired.
sydni96 1 year ago
@asianpersuasion08 Uhmm ma`m I was just repeating something you said in a previous comment that I thought was funny you told somebody to go "To the left to the left" lol I wasn`t being rude.
sydni96 1 year ago
@sydni96 oh im sorry!!!!! please forgive me. do u know where i got that from though!!!
asianpersuasion08 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
her voice was NOT edited. she obviously paid the guy to lie and say he edited it to protect her image. dont be so gullible.
thisisfleshka 2 years ago
OMG girl thank you for saying that! I told my brother that the other day: If Beyonce was ugly nobody would like her! She get by on her looks. And she cant act neither!
GiGiChante18 2 years ago
she lips sings. look it up.
xxRawrXSkittlesxx 2 years ago
she doin her thing. she get money!! Real Diva's gettin' money!!
queenmajesty1983 2 years ago
to everyonce whos says she cant sing listen to trust in me, listen etc........
nikkidabest812 2 years ago
yall are some haters, she need to be a soul singer that should be the next step in her career she always have chills going down my back everytime she sing she just have it all
A31319 2 years ago
beyonce is the best female artist of the world, she's the best
belenita84 2 years ago 2
No......i think Leona Lewis is better
FlawlessVicktory 2 years ago
I can't believe people actually believe some dumb shit like that. Come the fuck on now people! Everybody knows Beyonce is a power house singer.
shiree022000 2 years ago 8
who gives at **** either way?
bellevegasj 2 years ago
What a dope. Clearly she must be able to sing if this moron says she can! "I seen her in London and Philly, and she wasnt singing to no backing vocals, at least I dont think she was." So there ya go folks, he doesnt think she lyp synchs, so clearly she doesnt
MirkCoy 2 years ago
Versatile voice, give me a break. You suck more than she does
heavymetalrulz123 2 years ago
it was a prank
misterroyaltee 2 years ago
Just because you think she can sing does not mean everyone in the world will have the same view. I don't know if it was her singing, i'd like to think it wasn't but you can't be sure as we don't know her personally. This video was pointless, yeah i know i watched it.
MrsToddSmith1 2 years ago
"most of the time she sings live." quote of the year
Panchee123 2 years ago 4
too funny...thats exactly what i said watching this...most of the time? so i guess that means skorpion has no clue when she is or when she isnt singing...what an idiot he is...i'm glad i saw this, now i know never to watch him again...if o do its completely by accident
moejonz 2 years ago
Beyonce doesn't sing live all the time!!!
theskorpionshow 2 years ago
I'm sorry, I haven't been on youtube in so long. I didn't even know there was a video out saying that Beyonce can't sing. Can somebody give me a link please?
DaUltimateFan 2 years ago
If you haters think she is so fake then why the hell are you watching a video about her....
See how hating can easily make you look like a dumbass....
Beyonce can sing...And ya'll know it...Stop being in denial...And find something better to complain about...
Give constructive criticism or keep your mouth shut...
Talent, beauty, and success make people so envious...It's ridiculous...
bbeyonce07 2 years ago 9
Or how bout the fact theres a tape of her actual voice and we've all heard it and she is singing terribly on it. Maybe thats it.
MirkCoy 2 years ago
Well, the person who made the alleged tape made a youtube video stating it was a fake. He said he altered her vocals to make her sound bad...He even shows how he did it....
bbeyonce07 2 years ago 2
I can happily direct you to the video if you want....
bbeyonce07 2 years ago 2
hater hater...
KD5651 2 years ago
@bbeyonce07 lol i agree completely
jasmine343b 1 year ago
@bbeyonce07
Most people are watching this video because the decription has the words "Howard" and "Stern" in it you stupid fuck
stonebridge999 1 year ago
i knew that video was fake when I first saw it even if ur not a beyonce fan u should still be able to tell that the video is a phony i'm glad u made dis video
Dezzina19 2 years ago 2
b is ma gal
careykagz 2 years ago
yeah i think she can sing, but i wouldnt be suprised if she had a few slips
raindrop10155 2 years ago
how was that racist just cause your starstruck
thefriendsociety 2 years ago
wtf how funny
rocketman8914 2 years ago
Wow, if that audio played on Stern's show is real, then that's sad. Too many artists (if you can call them that) today rely on studio trickery to process their voices (they can correct anything in a studio). Well even at her worst, she's still better than most of us LOL.
PDXguitarlegend 2 years ago 3
I think she can sing. So i don't care what nobody says.
Jennein 2 years ago
if u really listen to the recording u can tell that she was in tune, only people who wasn't really paying attention to the track believed that crap
blackgal03 2 years ago
Yeah she might be everywhere singing songs but she always singing songs she aint have no damn business singing ie. ETTA JAMES. She's steals ppl shit n dont give credit, and she CANT sing she yells too much!
TWillz17 2 years ago
SHE CAN NOT SING. RIGHT ON
jdwsquare 2 years ago
take ur middle finger and put on ur nose.
2.say a name of someone u like.
3.that person will ask u out or say they love u tomarrow.
4. heres the thing copy and paste to 2 other vids
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days
ycanti65 2 years ago
Damned right!!!
Another example of her being able to sing-- X FACTOR!! duh!!
clumsyflic 2 years ago
nigga get a grip just cause your starstruck ...damn fantasy livin nigga
thefriendsociety 2 years ago
you racist bastard fuck off
clumsyflic 2 years ago
The fact that you've seen her live does nothing to prove she can sing. It's quite easy to fake a live performance
StewieSwan 2 years ago
LMAO! You hadddd to attach me to Janet, didnt u!? LOL Like she needs any more of a bad rep added to her name. Anyways... check out HALO on the today show... MY VERSION
aladdin82 2 years ago
take an english class bro
chimichanga776 2 years ago
yea, bro.
8poseur8 2 years ago
i saw that bull shit video
everybody noes beyonce can sing,even her haters. thats y they're always riding her dick.
if anything, that video should of been entertaining cuz i was laughing mad hard at the comments ppl made thinking it was real. DUMB SHITS LMAO
portugalsgal24 2 years ago 3
you're a fag!!! why care dude. get a life
hendep 2 years ago
Damn dude, a bit too sensitive , aren't we?
IM1deadMONEY 2 years ago
your kitchen is dirty and you've got a loud television playing in the background.
would it really be too much trouble to bring it better than this?
zavierfire 2 years ago
Comment removed
joeyjupiter77 2 years ago
Don't give a shit. I still don't think she belongs in hollywood with her voice. She's trash.
demohunto3 2 years ago
This was another featured video!!!!!!
mishel1220 2 years ago
anyone who will pay to see beyonce live, i'm sure will defend her. Beyonce shouldn't be a singer, just a model...she's fake, that's well known.
bobdylanfanman 2 years ago
I didn't say anything about Beyonce. My comment was about Youtube having this video in its featured box. That means possibly more popularity and subscribers for the skorpion show.
mishel1220 2 years ago
hater.
purplehaze2250 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stern got punked by a gay guy from S.F. who made this sound feed on his computer and he actually believed that's how she really sang. Stern didn't do his research...LOL The guy already came out and showed how he did it.
dfwtexxaas 2 years ago
I've seen the video and it is soooooo obvious that the video was altered..... it's messed up how people really dislike her and don't even know her.... but hey her haters are her biggest fans and im sure she knows that.
DymundPrincess21 2 years ago
The same way someone say's they like her and don't even know her? NO, I don't know her, & I don't hate her, I just don't like her music. Her singing does not appeal to me. She can out sing me any day. I have seen the video also and I know it is fake, but it was funny. I feel it is way more talent out here for her to be overrated. That's just my opinion I am not knocking any one else.
ntihata 2 years ago
for some reason i think Howard stern did it to get sirius satelite radio attention. I mean they are losing money, this might just be a publicity stunt.
jonjosmar 2 years ago
definitely agree with you, because before this popped up I didn't even know Howard Stern had a radio station! lol
brieseptember 2 years ago
Get your story straight, Howard said JD (his employee) discovered someone uploading this to YouTube and he played and talked about it, he's not the one that did it.
nohararara 2 years ago
I think that it is hillarious how people are reporting on this video saying its real. Its obviously fake. To me it shows how someone will always be ready to throw some dirt on someones image.
andeyeandeye 2 years ago
do u realize how retarded u appear. saying im judging beyonces lyrics.
beyonce purposely spread her legs open several times in her concerts where plenty of girls are watching her.
who gives a fuck about her being classy in her personal life. none of us see her then so who cares?
lmao!
u actualy sitting here saying, britney going to mental facilties makes her worst than bey
lmao
this is my last time saying it.
when a women makes her image out to be with spreading legs etc she is a pig.
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
I've said all I care to say... Argue with yourself...
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
lol... You're injudicious logic is laughable. Go read a book. Youtube has turned your brain, or lack there of, into mush.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
And your lack of an arguement against mine is laughable as well.
You're preposterous assertions are weak and you contradicted yourself.
Read a book? I've read just about every book ever written.
You're belligerent.
YOu know im right, that's you didnt respond to my comment with facts.
all u could say is "im laughable?"
lolololol
:-D
toodles.
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
she cant sing it was unedited. face the fact most singers cant sing
DAxKIDx 2 years ago
It's a shame that people are out here saying that beyonce can't sing these beyonce haters will do anything 2 try and bring her down!!!
TIFFANYBUTTERFLY 2 years ago
tell them off.......she can sing get in to it hunney!!!!!!!
drewcld 2 years ago
i cant believe people would think she couldnt sing, even if you didnt like her. i do but i know people who dont who have to admit that she can sing.
ctswright 2 years ago
lol beyonce is a fucking great singer and for people to say she can or cant lol WHAT THE FUCK DO YALL KNOW!!!! lol yall aint a manager or yall didnt set up the stage so how yall know there are computers around to make her sound better i know personally cause she sang at a venue florida and i was there!!! only a mic and michelle and kelly beside her
BrighterThanYours 2 years ago
no ne twitched anything lol, im sure she can sing its just not good when she dances and all that. it was too a tape man.
jefferyklassen 2 years ago
It is likely she will have to perform in a room without a computer to verify she can sing, unlikely. Her immediate handlers are concerned her career could end up the same as Milli Vanilli. "However, their success turned to infamy when their Grammy was revoked after it was revealed that the actual vocals on the record were not the voices of Morvan and Pilatus".
havefunliberal 2 years ago
the guy came forward who edited her vocal howard stern is an ass for beliving it, and puting it on his show
charramaria 2 years ago
SHE FUKIN SUCKS SHES A WANNA BE BLOND
TOPTROUBLEZ 2 years ago
Like Brittney, Lindsy, Jessica Alba, and most other female celebs... wha'ts your point? She rocks as an entertainer and the money she makes backs that up.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
haha britney is a ledgen jessica and lindsay act wayy better than beyonce shes is just umm boring i mean she kind of can sing but...she boring
TOPTROUBLEZ 2 years ago
Brittney is a legend for her ability to lead stray prepubescent girls into sex, lies, and video tape... She was originally pushed out as a "pop princess" so naturally with all the cutesy and the pink, those girls would follow. She was already trying to evolve out of that shadow after her first album.. She grew 2 fast for her followers... To say that Lidsay is in any way better than Beyonce, is sad and further illustrates my point. The good and humble are ignored while the crackwhores R praised.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
beyonce is no diferent.
beyonce sells just as much sex as britney spears.
to say that beyonce has more class than everyone, just cause yall compare her to britney and lindsay is really sad.
Beyonce and britney both had knocked up teen sisters.
bey and brit both spread their legs open.
beyonce has a song talkin bout her pus*y for christ sakes.,
its called kitty kat.
its about a man who doesnt want to fuck her anymore.
i mean realy bey is just as trashy,
only thing is she got sasha.,
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
Beyonce was never a promoted preteen idle, dear heart.... Beyonce came out as a sex symbol with Destiny's child... They were singing adult music to young adults and older from the jump... Brittney spears's demographic was much younger... That's the major difference...
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
not to be rude or anything.
but it never fails to amaze me.
the absurd defenses yall come up with to defend beyonce that is.
"hit me baby one more time"
teen girl wearing sexy school outfit.
Destinys child, you say no,no,no, when its really yes,yes,yes.
boy i know u want me i could see it in ur eyes.
nuff said.
beyonce aint no better as far class.
stop with the lame excuses.
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
I'm not trying to be rude either but in order for what you to say to be true, you have to really know the difference between class and what you're talking about right now. In fact, you're perception is pretty ass backwards. Based on your comments sexuality and singing about grown up things makes you unclassy... Destny's child Singing about Sex and Brittney Spears Sucking off her boyfriend on camera and purposely leaking it for cash is probably a good place to start.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
lol... You really need a vocab lesson. I have come to the conclusion that you have no idea word the term classy entails. That's fine. I can accept that. Until you do. We can talk because we'll be going around in circles. Most of your argument revolves around the songs she sing and not who she is as a person. Just because the Paparazzi got a few lucky photos of her vagina, doesn't mean she isn't a classy person... You are very misguided. You've yet to discredit her class. Until you do... STFU :)
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
y cant u just admit that there is nothing classy about beys ways it is in fact your brain that is mushed, if u think adoring a classless female is cool
wait did u justsay quote "Jus because the Papzri got a few lucky photos of her vagina, doesn't mean she isn't a classy person.
lmao! so this applies to britney lindsay and the rest of them
beyonce as a person? uhm we dont know any of these people personaly so, we go by what we see and hear
no matter how u try to spell it. BEY IS NOT CLASSY!
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
lol... Fuck what you say... I will say this, though... Beyonce has endorsments... Those other bitches don't...(not real ones anyway)...
Secondly, everything you've brought up, 99.9% of everything you'd said revolved around videos made and performances on stage... Like I said, she's a sex symbol... the way she acts when performing her music is what sells... It's all business... But at the end of the day, when the media catches up... Beyonce is being a lady, while them other girls are not.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
lol.....
now you're bringing endorsements.
figures u would take this convo left feild.
and for your info, britney spears, shakira all had endorsements with pepsi and more, they dont have endoresements cause they got there own perfume.
curious is one of the best selling perfumes of all time.
but we're not going to go there, cause thats not what we were talking about.
argue?
i dont argue, i discuss.
toodles
:-D
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
GypsySiren911 2 years ago
OMG!!! How old are you? Can you spell? I mean, at all... Reading that was brutal. I realized in mid-reply, I didn't care anymore. I'm done.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago 2
LOL that my frequent response, glad a fellow tubber has the same reaction too inarticulate fellow tubers.
SMoldie 2 years ago
It's like, the personal computer has given us many many tools. You'd think after a while people would learn how to spell before using one.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
As you can see from my first reply my typing skills are not first rate, yet I try for grammatical correctness when possible. The art of the written word, is it seems in peril. But we are communicating, so it can't all be bad LOL Kudos from a fellow lover of the lexicon.
SMoldie 2 years ago
PS PhantomLyric it is a great instaneous mechanism for responding to and giving out your opinion to a worldwide audience.
SMoldie 2 years ago
lol... True. Much respect.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
In comparison to Lindsay and Brittney Beyonce is all class. She's a performer, a dancer, a sex symbol, just as she's always been. Brittney spears has been in and out of rehabs, mental facilities, and custody battles for her to have any kind of custody battles. - How can you compare any of that with the actions of Beyonce?? You can't... You come up with a lame attack on NoNoNo lyrics written FYE only... come on now... get real... Beyonce is the epitome of class compared to Spears and Lohan.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
honey, no,no,no lyrics is nothing compared to her mordern stuff.
beyonce is not sexy she is trashy.
a sexy confident women like shakira,salma heyek, earth kit,etc dont need to spread their legs open talk about sex and dance on stripper poles.
lmao at u trying to say britney being in mental facitlities make her bad.
bey is the same catagorey except she didnt loose two kids and shave her head.
thats the only thing different from the two.
GypsySiren911 2 years ago
Salma Heyek spread their legs more times than Sasha Fierce ever did... lol... While Beyonce did it on music videos... Salma did it fully nude on video... Not only that, she's taken scantly clad pictures naked, and dancing on "stripper poles" as you claim beyonce did and it wasn't done in a classy fashion. Get your fact straight. I love Shakira, but Shakira has done the pole thing and she gyrates and pops more than elvis presley. Anyway... the whole argument is about Class not... sensuality.
PhantomLyric 2 years ago
lmao.
shakira sure does pop her hips.
but whens the last time u see her pubic area.
unlike beyonce.
GypsySiren911 2 years ago
beyonce is no diferent.
beyonce sells just as much sex as britney spears.
to say that beyonce has more class than everyone, just cause yall compare her to britney and lindsay is really sad.
Beyonce and britney both had knocked up teen sisters.
bey and brit both spread their legs open.
beyonce has a song talkin bout her pus*y for christ sakes.,
its called kitty kat.
its about a man who doesnt want to fuck her anymore.
i mean realy bey is just as trashy,
only thing is she got sasha.,
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
correction salonge was legal though not 16
BrighterThanYours 2 years ago
so..and.
18 is the legal age.
not seventeen. there were both minors in ALL STATES.
unwed, teenagers with super famous sisters.
KeepTrue56 2 years ago
she was 18 when she had him
BrighterThanYours 2 years ago
LMAO sis HOW did i know your hoe ass would comment on this video?
cierra1993 2 years ago
what video kevin cuz never heard this before
Skorpionfan23 2 years ago
she cant sing she was on a radio 2dai in a live studio n they left her mic on and she sings awfull she mimes the words
omegajano 2 years ago
EPIC FAIL! LMAO!!!!
TrashTalkingTV 2 years ago
Beyonce said in MTV yesterday that is great promotion.
DatBitch009 2 years ago
the video responses have been almost as funny as the original joke. Stern knows how to stir it up! keep up the good work people :)
Moodymongul 2 years ago
What you hear over the tv, stage, etc. is from a cd. It's not really "live". Nothing you hear on tv even if it's "live" is actually "live" regardless of what you think. Not disrespecting just letting you all know. The track on Stern is 100% real.
footballceez 2 years ago
Beyonce already confirmed ion MTV and as much as U really want it to be true ut's not. She said if U wanna hear her sing live "u can watch the today show tomorrow and she'll be singing Halo" and that is is great promotion whoever came up with the idea. She also said it was great promotion
DatBitch009 2 years ago
What channel is the today show on, like, whats the name of the channel?
doob234 2 years ago
Beyonce can sing, but I think Alicia Key and Chrisette Michele sings bet. They sound exactly how they sound on a CD, live.
Lonelyeco 2 years ago
i knew yall janet fans hate beyonce lol
tdottle246 2 years ago
I know it's isn't true, but lets say it is true, then that mean Rihanna sings better,lol(I better stop before a stan pop up here)
GAMEBOIMARCUS 2 years ago
i just listened to it and it angered my fuckin soul that anyone wud do that to an artist on top of her game im a huge beyonce fan and do they really think from all her vocal training that she is even capable of sounding like that and anyone who reall wants to hear what her voice really sounds like watch the inaurgaration of Obama and the performance at the tyra banks show
jazzfunkjunkie 2 years ago
When i first saw it on MTO, i didnt believe it (even tho it was funny) cuz i heard her sing acapella many times and it was beautiful but i KNEW some dumb asses would believe it and make it a huge thing. It sound SO fake too...come on yall...don't be stupid!
VRM291 2 years ago
I just post her performance. COME WATCH! Her best performance of Halo. I love it
Angelfully 2 years ago
please...everyone knows beyonce can sing her ass off..of course that shit was fake!
Pharrellsnumber1 2 years ago
Solange said on twitter "If you believe that is Beyonce's vocals that Howard Stern put up you are an IDIOT!" I concur! quit believing EVERYTHING you hear!
pleaseh8 2 years ago
When I saw it on the news I knew you would comment on it...LOL! U on top of it though!
messenger333 2 years ago
People need to stop listening to EVERYTHING! I'm with Solange..I follow her on twitter and she said " If you believe that is Beyonce's vocals Howard Stern put u"
pleaseh8 2 years ago
The bitch is SUPERWOMAN when it comes to performing.
Don't discredit her for something that she can do above everyone else.
You hear her panting and changing notes because she's out of breath but that justr makes her push hard,. She is the Professional!!!!
SkyVic03 2 years ago 2
OF COURSE BEYONCE CAN SING! --the best part of this video tho man, is when u look 2 the side & say, its just kinda stupid! haahaha, HILARIOUS!!!
nickd98 2 years ago
Whether you like Beyonce or not, i think it's safe to say that she can sing. IMO, her voice has improved alot in the last year or two.
<3 Marissa
mike198932 2 years ago
I'm not a Beyonce stan, but it was fake. HATERS MAKE YOU GREATER! =)
SunnyStorm21 2 years ago
a man told tmz he made it and its fake i know she can sing trust me
htowngurl17 2 years ago
now dont get mad at me when i say this but i know that beyonce can sing and i am a fan of hers but i think that she also lip-synce too with all that dancing she does and she is singing that strong i dont know but if she is singing while dancing that hard then she should be called superwomen lol i dont care is she lipsynce as long as she gives a great perfromance like she always does and when i heard that audio i thought it was funny because i know that she sing it was a great laugh none the less
chantellemonique88 2 years ago
HOWARD STERN IS WINNNNNNNNNNN
Gh0sty1 2 years ago
Yea..that video is suuuuper old
VizionWarp 2 years ago
i heard that back in what november? the single ladies one was funny. but anyone who couldn't tell it was fake, c'mon now be realistic. she does acapella's alllll the time.
Taye2008 2 years ago
i know u laughed just like everyone else
AlbGurl 2 years ago
I know I can't believe everybody's tryna act like that mess is real! Beyonce can blow.
likemic05 2 years ago 2
Well it's good 2 c that U have some sense Kevin! Anybody with an unbiased ear & @ least 4 brain cells would know the audio had been altered- I mean, it didnt even sound natural! I swear, haters got so much negativity & hate (4 themselves of course), that they cant even think straight! I actually enjoyed the audio b/c it was so CLEARLY a joke! Unfortunately these cave men turned somethin so innocent n2 somethin so corrupt! SMH! Glad 2 c B speak out on it too! Like she said, "thanks 4 the promo"!
radeanca 2 years ago 3
When I first heard it I was like Betonce is that really you. I mean i've heard her sing to many times. I knew she was lyping on the Today Show but sounding that horrible. I mean why would you take the time out of your day to make a fake video. Some people need to be in school or get a job!!!I mean seriously get a life!!!
kmcru 2 years ago
The guy that made it contacted TMZ and said that was a fake and he made it as a joke
da3bool 2 years ago 3
everyone know Beyonce can sing.....don't forgot President Obama and Michelle first dance!
eguonoeduvie 2 years ago 3
that video is such bullshit. i was made in november and why we hearin bout it now. if it was real it would have been talked about a long ass time ago
purchik3 2 years ago
That is soooo stupid!!! Everybody should know that Beyonce CAN sing. Like Skorpion said, better than some of the girls out right now, who will remain nameless.
People just hating cuz B is on top, and whoever they girl is, is not!!!!
LOVE BEYONCE!!!
Brimo8908 2 years ago 2
she can sing but i don't think she is above the lip sync.
studkingsTVee 2 years ago
im suprised that its being talked about now when it was made months ago. its funny to know that if alot of people talk about something that it makes it gospel.
termaraclarke 2 years ago