Added: 2 years ago
From: mannie1952
Views: 4,338
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (25)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • no man gets left behind 

  • MrGazrp,

    Actually, me too.

    Mannie

  • Wow....thats all I can say.

  • Mannie, thank you for making this video. very moving.

  • Excellent Video Mannie. Done very well.

  • Amazing video. Well done.

  • Really nice job, Mannie. You caught the beauty of the ceremony really well.

  • Many a good man lost a young and promising life that day, some wore blue, some wore gray.

  • As a Navy veteran this was one of the most moving events I have ever seen on You Tube that honors servicemen. In all wars though out history so many fall and this becomes their final resting place. This soldier is going home now. The good Lord knows who this young man was. His name is lost to the world but not to the world to come.

  • Well done Lads..

    MB

    11B-11M

    US Army retired

  • Thanks for posting this. The Maryland National Guard Honor Guard was honored to be part of this transfer ceremony. Great choice of music. It is one of my favorite songs. It was used at the departure ceremonies in Washington for both Presidents Reagan and Ford.

  • I rode from Missouri -to- Antietam & rode the 1st couple hours towards NY until my beeper went off, calling me back home. Wish I could've completed the whole trip. The folks @ Antietam could not have been any more professional -or- respectful in the way the soldier's remains were treated. Being a funeral director for 35+ yrs, I watch these things probably closer than the avg. bear & I was very, very impressed w/Mr. Roy and his demeanor performing his task(s).

  • Mannie - I was the PGR Ride Captain in charge of this mission - Words can't express how moving this tribute is - especially for those of us who were with him from Antietam to his grave site in Saratoga National Cemetery. Tha bagpipers played this piece as they moved him to his final resting place. Welcome home young soldier..

  • Nice work, as always, Mannie. How often are artifacts of other kinds discovered at Antietam? Are there any on-going archeological digs in the Park like they have at some other historic sites, or was it not occupied long enough to produce that kind of deposit?

  • Rotterdam,

    The song is "Going Home" made famous by Paul Robeson and sung at the funeral of Franklin D. Roosevelt. I found this particular rendition on an uncredited track on Youtube I wish I knew who the artist was so I could provide credit.

    Mannie

  • Mannie, I've only just seen your kind reply. Thank you very much,

    Arthur

  • @mannie1952 That in turn is based on the "Largo" movement of Dvorak's New World Symphony (No. 9).

  • You can hear a recording of Paul Robeson singing Goin Home by Googling Paul Robseon Going Home Augusta Cemetery.

  • Mannie, could you please tell what beautiful and haunting music it is?

    Many thanks,

  • Thank you for this. i am truly choked with emotion.

  • Arguably the most poignant, moving, and inherently relevant piece of footage on all of youtube.

    May you finally rest in peace, young lion.

  • How was his grave undiscovered? How was it discovered now? Are all those photos of the kid? I would be interested in more details!! Thanks. xo

  • There were 23,000 casualties (mostly wounded) - far too many dead and dying to keep total account of. Hastily buried in a makeshift grave, one's resting place is easily forgotten. As for the pictures, they are random photos of union soldiers. This poor lad's identity remains unknown - all we know is that he fought in a NY regiment and died (I believe) near Miller's cornfield.

  • MG

    This soldier was killed in the Cornfield on the northern end of the battlefield. The action there took place between 5:45 a.m. and 9:00.

    He was probably buried that day (Sept 17) or the following by men from his own unit. Although there may have been some makeshift identifying information scratched on a board to make his grave, that was soon lost through time and circumstance. As years past his shallow grave became forgotten and lost. Discovered again, by accident, last October.

    Mannie

  • Class.

  • Chimmy,

    I think the power was in the simple elegance of it all.

    mannie1952

  • Amazing, I don't even have words to say to truly honor this soldier, I'm sure the ceremony was powerful!

  • Wow! What a poignant moment, indeed. What a beautiful thing to witness and be part of. He will finally be properly laid to rest after nearly a century and a half. Amazing.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more