Honestly, Carah was my favorite, but they're both amazing. They both have AMAZING voices. At least Chad stayed in the band still because if carah AND chad left, it would prolly be awful. And, with carah back, i'm so excited for their new album, :D !!!!
I've been in love with Shiny Toy Guns for years. I think its been over 5 years.
i remember doing a project in highschool and we had to make a soundtrack for the Great GAtsby and i chose this song..fits perfectly..amazing voice Carah had :)
@shadowscrawl Uhh? I'm talking about Sisely Treasure, who was in the band when Carah was not. The girl who sang all of their Season of Poison album, that singer...
@TLC4me333 ok but this song is NOT off of season of poison it is off of we are pilots version 1 which was recorded in 2005 LONG before sisely treasure had even thought about joining the band
the singer on THIS song from THIS video the one that you are posting on IS carah
@shadowscrawl This VIDEO (as i read: Sep 22, 2008) is not 2005. Sisely sings Frozen Oceans, it is AS A FACT on Season of Poison (as i read my STG songs on ipod) not on We Are Pilots. and as u can see by the #1 thumbed up comment, Kerocola agrees with me, this is Sisely. And as i listen to this song and the Frozen Oceans on my ipod from Season of Posion, there is no difference i can hear... at all... what so ever...
@TLC4me333 I can hear a difference actually. I admit it's not much of a difference, but I do like Carah more, it's like her voice is louder, and has slightly better harmonics at millisecond increments, and sometimes more on the longer notes.
@shadowscrawl hahaha you know what you are absolutely right i had two different videos open and i got mixed up as to which i was posting on for some reason i thought that this was the sky fell over me (open in another tab
im not too big a chicken shit to admit when im wrong
While on duty last night I was forced to shit into a plastic sandwich container, as there was no bathroom. It was a big heavy clumpy shit, and it felt a lot better to finally evict the turds that had taken up resident in my lower intestines.
Here is a haiku I pulled out of my ass (no pun intended) to commemorate this occasion.
I wish both Carah and Sisely sang together in this great band - they could share leads and harmonies. Plus, Chad also has such a strong voice. You can never have too many singers!
cant they keep both:-) they are both shiny toy guns to me now. they are both so talented and sound great. they both give me the chills when i listen to them.
Liked carah faye voice better. It just echoed more. I don't think the problem is really either girl but the fact that the other guy in the group acts like a lil bitch.
Im sure this girl will tell em to go fuck off to and find a better gig eventually to.
The most beautiful song my ears have ever heard. Let's embrace our voices on the edge of the ocean for they are part of who we are. I love her voice it's elegant. Gorgeous..gorgeous..gorgeous..
We are part of each other even when one lies on the edge of the ocean's shore. It's sad but they are still connected and we are joined. We will meet again. <3
I used to judge this band by their decision letting Carah go and thought it was rubbish. but since last week when I first actually listened to the whole album I found out that it's all full of strong meaning. I love it E>
I thought her new band was Versant? Hm. I haven't been updated recently.
Anyway, I absolutely love this song. Its not Carah, but the new girl has a great voice as well and i will stick with Shiny's regardless of such change. They've got talent that should be appreciated.
Artists tend to like to experiment, at least the good ones do. Look at U2, they're popular as hell, and every album they tweak something.
Why can't Shiny Toy Guns do that without getting shit from it's so-called "fans"?
If you're that die-hard of a fan, you'll accept change, because the songwriters (the people who matter here, guys) are still in the band. If Chad or Jeremy left, Shiny Toy Guns would've gone to shit.
True Carah was the voice and face of STG, but its time to move on folks. She ain't coming back. If they can still produce tracks like this, they're golden.
@KlydeVividarium well yeah, i know that, haha. but Ursala wasn't even in the band for that long. Carah pretty much took over. I like to think of her as the original. :)
I think it's a good thing that they didn't have Sisely until now, though. Carah was so good; it was good for the band. :)
Not that Sisely isn't, of course. But Carah just fit the part at the time. :)
@dirtydiana49111 Carah was fired from Shiny Toy Guns cuz they found the sound they were looking for ( Sisely ) , Carah's in a a new band called Versant now .
I agree...Carah was we better than the new singer..Sisely I think is her name or however the hell you spell it...but I just have one question...why would you make a tribute video to Carah, ex front woman from Shiny Toy Guns and put in Frozen Oceans, sung by the new front woman from Shiny Toy Guns?
Is this punk rock? Or electro punk? I like they songs, but i from holland, and i have never heart about they Shiny toy guns. Where are they from? Canada?
I don't spend too much time worrying about labels but this is from the Shiny Toy Guns Myspace page: "Indie / Rock / Electronica "
They are from the US. Oklahoma to be a little more specific. Lately, One of the few things that makes me proud of my country again. I've yet to see them live but I intend to next time the come to my city!!!!
Carah's new band Versant will be releasing their ep this summer! Took me a while to adjust to their new album but I like it now, and their new singer is good too.
Get ready to have ur minds blown sisley haters, Sisley was going to be the original singer for stg, but she was already signed on another label, and Carah decided to leave because she wanted to start a band of her own, and everyone is still friends. ur all welcome.
@MouseEatsSnake That's called "lip syncing". Artists do this for music videos among other things. I don't see exactly how that makes her unable to sing, seeing as plenty of artists do this regardless of their talent. Have you ever been to a STG concert with Sisely as the singer and heard her sing? Sisely has credentials behind her - she was in the music scene prior to STG with her own music, and was a contender to be in the Pussycat Dolls.
Er. Epic fail. This song is on the album "Season of Poison". What's worse. That's not even Carah. =\ It's that Treasure chick that only wishes she could level up to Carah's awesomeness. VIVA VERSANT. <333
ok sisley was the original pick, but couldnt because she was in a different band, so they got carah, i think sisley fits in with shiny toy guns, and as for shiny toy guns themselves, they fuckin rock. so does sisley.
Face it meat puppets......Sisely sucks. She's got no range. She screams the notes she can't hit. Carah will always be the perfect fit for this band and they'll never be as good as they can without her. They'll be very good....just like a hundred bands out there. Sisely couldn't cut it as a Pussycat Doll and she can't cut it now. Wish STG would just wake up and correct the mistake they made. Carah made this band by networking and getting Pilots into the right hands, like Tommy Lee. It was all her
i LOVE this beautiful, powerful song!! Sisley has a wonderful voice. Carah was unique, sure, but *don't shoot me* I actually prefer Sisely's voice! There's no need to make such a big fuss about the members of the band... you should love the song for the musical qualities and how it moves you, makes you feel! Stop judging & hating, start appreciating & loving! :)
ps. that said, i think the song 'when did this storm begin'.. would have been much better without the punk/rap thing in the verses... nearly ruined the beauty of the chorus!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
mattjmd - Ghost Town is BY FAR my favorite song on Season of Poison, and I really think this song is TERRIBLE. Sisley sucks donkey balls, Carah rocks my socks, and I like We Are Pilots better.
How can I obtain this DVD? My Season of Ppoison album did not come with a DVD - I'd love to see it. I loved Carah. I always felt that a drummer is a drummer, but a singer is quite literally the voice of a band. STGs are still good, but I don't like to reference them as STGs anymore - I wish they woulda changed their name.
STG songs like this are awesome, but that ghost town one and the other single are pure shit. this sounds like the STG i know and love, albeit without the better singer.
the new band shes in isn't good either, i liked shiny toy guns, that was it. Versant, isnt good, shiny toy guns was it, they worked, the music, the voice, it was perfect. The music doesnt fit her with the new band its not the same, and the singer of shiny toy guns isnt the same without her. :(
Yea this is one of the only few songs I like on there new album. Quiet disappointing, STG doesn't sound as unique anymore (less funkiness) like they totally changed styles to wanna be mainstream rock. I have nothing against Sisely but Carah is 10x better. *misses Carah* She just fit in with STG's old style more and had a stronger voice. Carah's also hotter :P
i get angry thinking about how Shiny Toy Guns was (and is kind of) my favorite band and how I was anticipating some of their new songs; but with this new girl, my interest for STD has slightly faded :(
So it is Sisely? Either way I'll always be pretending that it's Carah. Sisely absolutely sucks, sounds like a cat getting strangled in most of her songs. Crock of shit.
i like to pretend all the sisely songs are sung by carah too haha... but hey as most of us know carah is a part of versant now and they have an album coming this year.
its kinda not my problem, cuz i knew it was sisely, but anyway, nice way to avoid admitting that ur comment didnt make any sens, but oh well, lets just quit this stupid discussion
This is like the only good song on the album imo... All the others are too different. Change is fine, but they are steering away from the reason I enjoyed them. =( Makes me sad.
Sisely did a good job here of emulating the way Carah sang. Def helps that this song is really pretty too.
it wasnt anyway near my point i was trying to state in my 1st comment, but to talk about the description, that doesnt make clear whether this is carah or sisely singing rly
Honestly, Carah was my favorite, but they're both amazing. They both have AMAZING voices. At least Chad stayed in the band still because if carah AND chad left, it would prolly be awful. And, with carah back, i'm so excited for their new album, :D !!!!
I've been in love with Shiny Toy Guns for years. I think its been over 5 years.
LadyWhoLikesCheese 3 months ago
Carah came back! :D <3
xXchelsearoxXx 4 months ago 4
Comment removed
MrKruk666 5 months ago
love this song
kimmishler 5 months ago in playlist listen
i remember doing a project in highschool and we had to make a soundtrack for the Great GAtsby and i chose this song..fits perfectly..amazing voice Carah had :)
DURAMATRIX112 5 months ago
I love this band, none of their songs ever get old for me. Every time I listen to one it makes me feel fucking amazingggg.
VanGogh202 6 months ago
This.. is a truly amazing song.
Insanegillane 6 months ago
What i dont understand about this video is why there are pictures of Carah when she's not the one singing the song...
TLC4me333 7 months ago
@TLC4me333 then who was might i ask
surely your not implying that original stg singer Ursula Vari sang this when she was out of the band in 20054 and this album was recorded in 2005
shadowscrawl 6 months ago
@shadowscrawl Uhh? I'm talking about Sisely Treasure, who was in the band when Carah was not. The girl who sang all of their Season of Poison album, that singer...
TLC4me333 6 months ago
@TLC4me333 ok but this song is NOT off of season of poison it is off of we are pilots version 1 which was recorded in 2005 LONG before sisely treasure had even thought about joining the band
the singer on THIS song from THIS video the one that you are posting on IS carah
shadowscrawl 6 months ago
@shadowscrawl This VIDEO (as i read: Sep 22, 2008) is not 2005. Sisely sings Frozen Oceans, it is AS A FACT on Season of Poison (as i read my STG songs on ipod) not on We Are Pilots. and as u can see by the #1 thumbed up comment, Kerocola agrees with me, this is Sisely. And as i listen to this song and the Frozen Oceans on my ipod from Season of Posion, there is no difference i can hear... at all... what so ever...
TLC4me333 6 months ago
@TLC4me333 I can hear a difference actually. I admit it's not much of a difference, but I do like Carah more, it's like her voice is louder, and has slightly better harmonics at millisecond increments, and sometimes more on the longer notes.
GeneralZap 6 months ago
@TLC4me333 you do realize that the video could be uploaded AFTER the singer left? derp
FlyingAce1016 5 months ago
@shadowscrawl hahaha you know what you are absolutely right i had two different videos open and i got mixed up as to which i was posting on for some reason i thought that this was the sky fell over me (open in another tab
im not too big a chicken shit to admit when im wrong
you win :P
shadowscrawl 6 months ago
@shadowscrawl Hey, no biggy. We all screw up from time to time. No sweat :) (trust me, i am the same way when i think i'm right x) )
TLC4me333 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
While on duty last night I was forced to shit into a plastic sandwich container, as there was no bathroom. It was a big heavy clumpy shit, and it felt a lot better to finally evict the turds that had taken up resident in my lower intestines.
Here is a haiku I pulled out of my ass (no pun intended) to commemorate this occasion.
"Brown steaming man mess
Rectum broken but empty
I shat out honor"
Iwonderwotsfordinner 7 months ago 4
I wish both Carah and Sisely sang together in this great band - they could share leads and harmonies. Plus, Chad also has such a strong voice. You can never have too many singers!
willveda 8 months ago 5
I love this song. It's so beautiful
Xolramuh 8 months ago
both sisely and carah are amazing!!!!
awesomesauce2896 9 months ago 9
@awesomesauce2896 YES!!
desamator11 8 months ago
@aliceduke94 Go to Shiny Toy Guns.com and look at the video "shiny toy guns together again". :)
elidaterrero 10 months ago
They kicked Carah...took sisely...kicked sisely....and took Carah ._. Those two guys are total assholes....<3 Carah and Sisely tho ._.
NinjaBoyShu 10 months ago 7
Quit whining anyway. Carah is back on board!
MsTwiggyIggy 10 months ago 3
@MsTwiggyIggy shes back in shiny toy guns?
aliceduke94 10 months ago
@aliceduke94 Yeah, their (i think) most recent song is "The Sun"
TLC4me333 7 months ago
I honestly don't know who's who in this band, but this song it freaking awesome. But I feel like it would be better as a duet.
clarkispotamia 10 months ago 3
cant they keep both:-) they are both shiny toy guns to me now. they are both so talented and sound great. they both give me the chills when i listen to them.
dnut6981 10 months ago 3
I dont care what anybody says. I'll always like Carah Faye's voice better, but i guess Sisley's okay too :/
MileyLuver627 10 months ago
isnt she coming back or is it someone else?
Duff1124 11 months ago
wow....just found these guys.Awesome....
DescartesDooley 11 months ago
Liked carah faye voice better. It just echoed more. I don't think the problem is really either girl but the fact that the other guy in the group acts like a lil bitch.
Im sure this girl will tell em to go fuck off to and find a better gig eventually to.
shade231 11 months ago
She is so pretty!
0BrokenAnimeDreams0 1 year ago
howling wolves. Roaring Lions. I see what you did there.
n00bling136 1 year ago
I've been wanting to play Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep so bad lately, all I hear is "I can't wait to meet you Ven." ._.;
assassinAmber 1 year ago
Thumbs up if you thought of someone the entire song :)
OoFreakOfNatureoO 1 year ago 43
@OoFreakOfNatureoO or the minute the song started you just had that persons face set in your mind
kimmishler 5 months ago in playlist listen
love this song no matter who sings it. and plus both of the singers are hott!!! how can u complain??
coolbrandon92 1 year ago
The most beautiful song my ears have ever heard. Let's embrace our voices on the edge of the ocean for they are part of who we are. I love her voice it's elegant. Gorgeous..gorgeous..gorgeous..
We are part of each other even when one lies on the edge of the ocean's shore. It's sad but they are still connected and we are joined. We will meet again. <3
g1owstiCksxNxTeChNox 1 year ago 5
@g1owstiCksxNxTeChNox deep stuff
coolbrandon92 1 year ago
I used to judge this band by their decision letting Carah go and thought it was rubbish. but since last week when I first actually listened to the whole album I found out that it's all full of strong meaning. I love it E>
ShinyToyGuns101 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sisely fucking sucks ass live BTW, like reallly realllllly bad, to the point where they had to turn her down,....
togos 1 year ago
I thought her new band was Versant? Hm. I haven't been updated recently.
Anyway, I absolutely love this song. Its not Carah, but the new girl has a great voice as well and i will stick with Shiny's regardless of such change. They've got talent that should be appreciated.
WaywardRatx 1 year ago
Enough with the comparisons. It's not like Carah died. This gal is decent.
I guess some of you might still be debating the merits of David Lee Roth vs Sammy Hagar in Van Halen.
mus1cat 1 year ago 3
Sisely works for what they're going for in SOP.
Artists tend to like to experiment, at least the good ones do. Look at U2, they're popular as hell, and every album they tweak something.
Why can't Shiny Toy Guns do that without getting shit from it's so-called "fans"?
If you're that die-hard of a fan, you'll accept change, because the songwriters (the people who matter here, guys) are still in the band. If Chad or Jeremy left, Shiny Toy Guns would've gone to shit.
eastermoose 1 year ago 5
this is by far their best song on the album the first album was way stronger. Carah made them/
dfstarborn 1 year ago
@dfstarborn Carah didn't make squat. She sang. Jeremy and Chad write ALL of the lyrics. For both albums. Including their new band Mirror Machines.
Enuf3 1 year ago
@Enuf3 whats mirror machines?
S3HSIM 1 year ago
@S3HSIM Mirror Machine is new band. Founded by Chad and Jeremy from STG.
hernandeznathan50 1 year ago
0:46 - 0:54 i could listen to that part all day
xDemonVampireGirlx 1 year ago 2
True Carah was the voice and face of STG, but its time to move on folks. She ain't coming back. If they can still produce tracks like this, they're golden.
joey8119 1 year ago 2
I feel like I'm dying when I listen to this song.
I love it.
StateOfMind119 1 year ago
whoi or what is sisely?
7bruno98 1 year ago
WHO is carah?
7bruno98 1 year ago
@7bruno98 the original singer of the band..
Shaniquaababyy17 1 year ago
@Shaniquaababyy17 Actually, IIRC, the original singer was some girl named Ursala or something.
While they did originally want Sisley, she was busy, so they settled with Carah, got famous with Carah, then dumped her when Sisley became available.
Then they started to suck. ._.
Carah's new band, Versant, is pretty good, though.
(:
KlydeVividarium 1 year ago
@KlydeVividarium well yeah, i know that, haha. but Ursala wasn't even in the band for that long. Carah pretty much took over. I like to think of her as the original. :)
I think it's a good thing that they didn't have Sisely until now, though. Carah was so good; it was good for the band. :)
Not that Sisely isn't, of course. But Carah just fit the part at the time. :)
& yeah, Versant is really good :)
Shaniquaababyy17 1 year ago
@7bruno98 lol wow....u are a loser
2121dillon 1 year ago
ww.youtube.com/watch?v=RltO5RJxAVk
Vox572X 1 year ago
what happened to carah?!
dirtydiana49111 1 year ago
@dirtydiana49111 Carah was fired from Shiny Toy Guns cuz they found the sound they were looking for ( Sisely ) , Carah's in a a new band called Versant now .
wwearepilots 1 year ago
You do realize that by playing a song sung by SISELY you're kinda destroying the whole purpose of remembering Carah... Right?
I swear, some of you Carah leg-humpers aren't too bright.
Enuf3 1 year ago 7
bring back carah a+.... this is c-...
nagzul 1 year ago
wut happened to carah???
redmanop 1 year ago
I agree...Carah was we better than the new singer..Sisely I think is her name or however the hell you spell it...but I just have one question...why would you make a tribute video to Carah, ex front woman from Shiny Toy Guns and put in Frozen Oceans, sung by the new front woman from Shiny Toy Guns?
NurseBellum 1 year ago
<.< this is sissy singing!
sakurauchiha03 1 year ago
@sakurauchiha03 Sisely*
sakurauchiha03 1 year ago
I'd.like.this.song.better.if.Sisley.sang.it.with.more.conviction.
XhaleyxovercastX 1 year ago
Very good song, Sisley is very talented. Carah may be better, but Shiny Toy Guns is still awesome.
jjgjjjgjjjgjjgjjg 1 year ago
i like this song so very much! Corah has a great voice <3
siep4 1 year ago
Is this punk rock? Or electro punk? I like they songs, but i from holland, and i have never heart about they Shiny toy guns. Where are they from? Canada?
siep4 1 year ago
@siep4
I don't spend too much time worrying about labels but this is from the Shiny Toy Guns Myspace page: "Indie / Rock / Electronica "
They are from the US. Oklahoma to be a little more specific. Lately, One of the few things that makes me proud of my country again. I've yet to see them live but I intend to next time the come to my city!!!!
Suorrel 1 year ago
@Suorrel
Thank you ;-)
siep4 1 year ago
What happened to the other girl?
plinton876 1 year ago
Sisely's voice is cool, but Carah's was unique
carlossilva1 1 year ago
So this was Sisely singing? I love this song! In which songs does Carah sing and what happened to her?
Hekezus 1 year ago
@Hekezus
Carah sang on the first album.
scissorknot 1 year ago
i like this song
xxGummyCatxx 1 year ago
I MISS CARAHHHH! D:
omgkimberlyy 1 year ago
carah got kicked out
rubynightfalls 1 year ago
This is my favorite Shiny Toy Guns song. Hits home in so many ways.
TiffatHU 1 year ago
Carah's new band Versant will be releasing their ep this summer! Took me a while to adjust to their new album but I like it now, and their new singer is good too.
GaxAngel 1 year ago
I prefer Carah, but Sisley is great too. This song is just so amazing.
aggiematt86 1 year ago 2
i love sisely and carah! they are both amazing!
EmoCrazyification 1 year ago 4
i can't stop listening to this
MarisaPenguin 1 year ago 2
I don't know either of those singers, I just listen to the voice.
And it's beautiful...
So Don't bitch !
coolcatvampire 1 year ago 25
no she is still alive like skyccarp said
7thgradeviolin 2 years ago
this song is beautiful<3
amandaleighhoee 2 years ago 2
Beautiful.
chooseillusions 2 years ago 2
love this song . don't care who sings it. just embrace the music ;)
meandmytiger21 2 years ago 123
Comment removed
Lemontrap46 1 year ago
@meandmytiger21 i agree!
clydeford32 1 year ago
Get ready to have ur minds blown sisley haters, Sisley was going to be the original singer for stg, but she was already signed on another label, and Carah decided to leave because she wanted to start a band of her own, and everyone is still friends. ur all welcome.
skyccarp 2 years ago 18
How can you say Sisely is bad when you listen to this song?
People diss her because she's not Carah, but both of them kick major ass.
Kerocola 2 years ago 208
I agree 100%!!!!
KeyLargo67 2 years ago
@Kerocola Sisley can't sing live.. or doesn't try. Look at the major time live lincoln theatre video. It matches the actual song completely.
MouseEatsSnake 1 year ago
@MouseEatsSnake That's called "lip syncing". Artists do this for music videos among other things. I don't see exactly how that makes her unable to sing, seeing as plenty of artists do this regardless of their talent. Have you ever been to a STG concert with Sisely as the singer and heard her sing? Sisely has credentials behind her - she was in the music scene prior to STG with her own music, and was a contender to be in the Pussycat Dolls.
Kerocola 1 year ago
@MouseEatsSnake ...That's because it's a music video, genius. Who the Hell actually sings in a music video?
Sisely sings live and does so very well. She's had a few bad performances but so has Carah.
Enuf3 1 year ago
@Kerocola her singing in here is c-... it's not bad. but it's pretty mediocre
nagzul 1 year ago
Comment removed
Lemontrap46 1 year ago
@Kerocola: I agree.
Sometimes people are TOO picky.
If someone is not a specific person, then they automatically cannot be better.
I think it's ridiculous.
Romeighla 1 year ago
@Kerocola no no, they kick Major Tom
merkfools13 1 year ago 6
@merkfools13 i see what you did there
XxGuardian337xX 1 year ago
@Kerocola Finally someone deffends both sides! So sick of hearing who is better when they are both just as good.
tinkertoes1000 9 months ago 2
@Kerocola i agree.
desamator11 8 months ago
Sisley is good as well as Carah.
She's even better >>
cicisbeolo 2 years ago 7
whos carah ..did she die
1poptart36 2 years ago
ROFL! I hope not xD
cicisbeolo 2 years ago
no she didnt die..she just quit Shiny Toy Guns to go on her own.
FunkeyMunkeyBrains 1 year ago
I'm more of a Carah Faye fan, but Sisley is amazing in this song.
Silmarien 2 years ago 9
love dis song xxx
jaddlemcpaddle 2 years ago 6
What happend to Carah?
sissiegurl 2 years ago
The "Season of Poison" Album featured Sisley Treasure. This is her singing
thatcanadianguy14 2 years ago 4
what happend to Carah? Wikipedia says, that she was bandmember till 2008?
Ottery2310 2 years ago
She now sings in a Swedish rock group. I was worried she had croaked but she is alive and well
Lemmingologist 2 years ago
lol
PlainOldAshLeY101 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Isn't this Sisley singing...
Fail. Haha.
KillerOctopusss 2 years ago
This may not have been sung by Carah, but its still damn good.
gnss4evr 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
Er. Epic fail. This song is on the album "Season of Poison". What's worse. That's not even Carah. =\ It's that Treasure chick that only wishes she could level up to Carah's awesomeness. VIVA VERSANT. <333
Eroticaify 2 years ago
i love you carah
MrMarkypoo007 2 years ago
YES thankyou... vvvvvv
MrMarkypoo007 2 years ago
she will be missed
Zakhar10203 2 years ago 3
she was replaced wit a gurrl name Sisely Treasure she was on Search for the Next doll and got like voted off when it was top seven.
dymiedoo 2 years ago
what hapened to carah anyways???
xoduchessxo 2 years ago
She went to Versant
unknown3333333333333 2 years ago
Uh, this is not Carah's voice.
chicalatina665 2 years ago 3
Did Carah actually sing this song even though she's not with STG anymore?
RobynHood777 2 years ago
No, she actually stated herself that she did not participate in any way shape or form in any of the new STG stuff.
chicalatina665 2 years ago
I like this song very much, butt is thit elektro punk? that sad my friend, but i don't believe here ahahah =)
siep4 2 years ago
omg the music starting at 2:50 reminds me of super mario 64 xD
love this song.
dkarinita 2 years ago 2
Weather Girl is amazing as well though
Arkanix 2 years ago
I really wish i had gotten to see them live while Carah was still part of them.
RachelxxRampage 2 years ago 3
wht happend???
suicuna18 2 years ago
My 2'nd favorite song from STG!
The first one would be Season of Love :)
I LOVE YOU STG!!! <3
TommyWommy09 2 years ago
check out rainy monday and dont cry out... 2 of my favorites by dem
wendyspwnsu 2 years ago 8
check out le disko and you are the one, those are their best, dont cry out is after that, i dont really like rainy monday
HenryDogProductions 2 years ago 2
Rainy monday and starts with one are the best XD
JuOwned 2 years ago 3
ok sisley was the original pick, but couldnt because she was in a different band, so they got carah, i think sisley fits in with shiny toy guns, and as for shiny toy guns themselves, they fuckin rock. so does sisley.
kingofspades34 2 years ago
they're assclowns for getting rid of her
emilythe11emo 2 years ago 4
this song is amazing <333
13uNbReAkAbLe13 2 years ago
i luv this song...it makes me all dreamy
bloodykissxox 2 years ago 2
Who is the lead singer in Rainy Monday?
mikect26 2 years ago
Face it meat puppets......Sisely sucks. She's got no range. She screams the notes she can't hit. Carah will always be the perfect fit for this band and they'll never be as good as they can without her. They'll be very good....just like a hundred bands out there. Sisely couldn't cut it as a Pussycat Doll and she can't cut it now. Wish STG would just wake up and correct the mistake they made. Carah made this band by networking and getting Pilots into the right hands, like Tommy Lee. It was all her
sammy5279 2 years ago
Carah is indeed a perfect fit for the band but I dont think Sisely is that bad.
Ajmauritz 2 years ago 3
its such a moving song (: and it makes you happy (:
shuey11 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song. <3
YourAngelicRose 2 years ago
Is frozen oceans sung by Carah or by Sisley? . . Sorry I am confused ):
shuey11 2 years ago
Sisely sang this song! She proves in this song that she can sing!
hernandeznathan50 2 years ago
Chemistry of a car crash is their best song
scottio23 2 years ago 2
no... dont cry out is... and this is second and ghost town is third and ledisko is forth
wendyspwnsu 2 years ago
ur so wrong! its all bout 'Chemistry', 'You are the one', Ghost town and rainy monday. choke on that
scottio23 2 years ago
I liked their cover of Stripped
Ajmauritz 2 years ago 6
i LOVE this beautiful, powerful song!! Sisley has a wonderful voice. Carah was unique, sure, but *don't shoot me* I actually prefer Sisely's voice! There's no need to make such a big fuss about the members of the band... you should love the song for the musical qualities and how it moves you, makes you feel! Stop judging & hating, start appreciating & loving! :)
AnonymousNoNamer 2 years ago 11
ps. that said, i think the song 'when did this storm begin'.. would have been much better without the punk/rap thing in the verses... nearly ruined the beauty of the chorus!
AnonymousNoNamer 2 years ago
:) yes sir
gothy8 2 years ago
EXACTLY!
darkhaven33 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mattjmd - Ghost Town is BY FAR my favorite song on Season of Poison, and I really think this song is TERRIBLE. Sisley sucks donkey balls, Carah rocks my socks, and I like We Are Pilots better.
rarimagiraffe 2 years ago
this song is the shit... i love this song.... i like new and old shiny toy guns
wendyspwnsu 2 years ago
My Season of Poison album came with a DVD. They said Carah left of her own free will. They didn't kick her out or anything.
Personally, I liked We Are Pilots better as an album, but I like Sisely better as a vocalist.
413CojoProductions 2 years ago
How can I obtain this DVD? My Season of Ppoison album did not come with a DVD - I'd love to see it. I loved Carah. I always felt that a drummer is a drummer, but a singer is quite literally the voice of a band. STGs are still good, but I don't like to reference them as STGs anymore - I wish they woulda changed their name.
Comisado86 2 years ago
STG songs like this are awesome, but that ghost town one and the other single are pure shit. this sounds like the STG i know and love, albeit without the better singer.
mattjmd 2 years ago
I loved carah, but i think i love sisely more, she has the most amazing sound. its magical.
4Keizer 2 years ago 2
the new band shes in isn't good either, i liked shiny toy guns, that was it. Versant, isnt good, shiny toy guns was it, they worked, the music, the voice, it was perfect. The music doesnt fit her with the new band its not the same, and the singer of shiny toy guns isnt the same without her. :(
nfl49ergirl5 2 years ago
Yea this is one of the only few songs I like on there new album. Quiet disappointing, STG doesn't sound as unique anymore (less funkiness) like they totally changed styles to wanna be mainstream rock. I have nothing against Sisely but Carah is 10x better. *misses Carah* She just fit in with STG's old style more and had a stronger voice. Carah's also hotter :P
aethynyc 2 years ago
I love this song
Pamela501982 2 years ago
What the hell is this Sisely bullshit?
she sounds terrible.
But Chad sounds phenomenal as usual.
Carah's voice was irresistible and captivating.
i get angry thinking about how Shiny Toy Guns was (and is kind of) my favorite band and how I was anticipating some of their new songs; but with this new girl, my interest for STD has slightly faded :(
brucasluvaa37 2 years ago
dude I must say i have to AGREEEEEEE ... new girl is just not carah... her and chad had this voice chemistry and just idk now... :/
THaZard007 2 years ago
I think she actually sounds good in this song. I liked Carah more, but Sisely did nothing wrong in this song. She actually sounds good!
Arkanix 2 years ago
if im not mistaken all of them had sung something of their songs, maybe they just have certain ones that work for each member?...either way i luv em
svenswiftwind 2 years ago
I heard siseley's two mom's flunked out of the univesrsity of phoenix online
mattjmd 2 years ago
So it is Sisely? Either way I'll always be pretending that it's Carah. Sisely absolutely sucks, sounds like a cat getting strangled in most of her songs. Crock of shit.
mattjmd 2 years ago
i like to pretend all the sisely songs are sung by carah too haha... but hey as most of us know carah is a part of versant now and they have an album coming this year.
GO CARAH FAYE! =]
xxjazzyphaxx 2 years ago
wat hap 2 carah?
Thatpreppychick 2 years ago
sense***
jvv93 2 years ago
its kinda not my problem, cuz i knew it was sisely, but anyway, nice way to avoid admitting that ur comment didnt make any sens, but oh well, lets just quit this stupid discussion
jvv93 2 years ago
This is like the only good song on the album imo... All the others are too different. Change is fine, but they are steering away from the reason I enjoyed them. =( Makes me sad.
Sisely did a good job here of emulating the way Carah sang. Def helps that this song is really pretty too.
hchano 2 years ago
it wasnt anyway near my point i was trying to state in my 1st comment, but to talk about the description, that doesnt make clear whether this is carah or sisely singing rly
jvv93 2 years ago
That's your own problem.
Kinga0069 2 years ago