The green hex looks like a bomber placement, but I would be weary placing this in the flake. I would trust body weight and then some, however, if this is your anchor and the leader takes a factor 2 fall, it may blow the flake. What does everyone think?
Just some constructive criticism, it's generally very bad practice to clip a screwgate straight into a wire, as when loaded the wire can make sharp grooves. If this is then clipped, say into a sling, the sling can be cut by the grooves. Therefore it is better to use a quickdraw so that the damaged screwgate is never in contact with the rope or a sling, thus avoiding the problem. A great, beginners introduction though. Well done!
Firstly, a great video. Just one clarification of the friction forces of the hex. Although what you say is true, a larger surface area is a good thing, there's still (surprisingly) the same *friction* force if you have a small surface area. The difference is that the force exerted on the cam (the normal force to be technical) is concentrated on a smaller area. This means that the hex is more likely to fail. Also, the force is more concentrated on the wall, so the wall is more likely to fail.
The advice about how to use a camming device is correct, but the reasoning is wrong. You say in your video "If the cam is too small, the camming arms are too open to exert significant force" and "overcamming is less secure". Neither of these are true. An undercammed unit exerts the same amount of force as an overcammed unit, however if the rock fractures the cam will rip. With an overcammed unit, the force is also still the same (please google "logarithmic spiral of camming devices")
Many thanks for the correction, I did my best with the knowledge I had and tried to keep things simple and within the time limit, so it is a shame that I got that bit of info wrong, thanks for taking the time to comment!
One thing in the video you're not using hexes but hexentrics. Hexentrics have a curved face and IMO are much better than the old Hexes. The kind in this videos are on slings, this is a good thing for security of the piece. Wired hexes and sling can fail due to the see-saw motion of the rope as you continue you climb. Big passive gear on slings doesn't have this problem but it does mean it can be trickier to remove... but that your seconds problem :)
It would be good to emphasize that cams can exert up to twice the downward force of a fall in the outward direction. Hence cams, tri-cams, and hexes can punch through rock that is flaky or otherwise rotten. Always evaluate the quality of the rock before placing your gear!
Hi there, thanks for the comment. It appears as though I have been marked very poorly actually, quite disappointing really especially as the feedback i was given seemed to be really positive. But ahwell, many things in life are inconsistent. Thanks again
The green hex looks like a bomber placement, but I would be weary placing this in the flake. I would trust body weight and then some, however, if this is your anchor and the leader takes a factor 2 fall, it may blow the flake. What does everyone think?
007Variable 1 month ago
@mountainguide77 Ok then, what's wrong?
guitarrules762 1 month ago
Just some constructive criticism, it's generally very bad practice to clip a screwgate straight into a wire, as when loaded the wire can make sharp grooves. If this is then clipped, say into a sling, the sling can be cut by the grooves. Therefore it is better to use a quickdraw so that the damaged screwgate is never in contact with the rope or a sling, thus avoiding the problem. A great, beginners introduction though. Well done!
guitarrules762 3 months ago
@mdwykurz wat type of cams are those
51629jbgemu 4 months ago
@51629jbgemu They're Wild Country Technical Friends, a type of spring loaded camming device or SLCD as the Amercians like to call them :P
guitarrules762 3 months ago
Nice effort.
jvballatore 5 months ago
Firstly, a great video. Just one clarification of the friction forces of the hex. Although what you say is true, a larger surface area is a good thing, there's still (surprisingly) the same *friction* force if you have a small surface area. The difference is that the force exerted on the cam (the normal force to be technical) is concentrated on a smaller area. This means that the hex is more likely to fail. Also, the force is more concentrated on the wall, so the wall is more likely to fail.
DeShark88 5 months ago
The advice about how to use a camming device is correct, but the reasoning is wrong. You say in your video "If the cam is too small, the camming arms are too open to exert significant force" and "overcamming is less secure". Neither of these are true. An undercammed unit exerts the same amount of force as an overcammed unit, however if the rock fractures the cam will rip. With an overcammed unit, the force is also still the same (please google "logarithmic spiral of camming devices")
chokeonaloaf 10 months ago
Many thanks for the correction, I did my best with the knowledge I had and tried to keep things simple and within the time limit, so it is a shame that I got that bit of info wrong, thanks for taking the time to comment!
mdwykurz 10 months ago
Nice vid. Well done.
RSTeamFilms 11 months ago
whats the name of the song? thx
Pethem 11 months ago
It is '8 Ball' by Underworld
not radiohead which for some stupid reason I wrote in the credits.
mdwykurz 11 months ago
I very much enjoyed the video. Good presentation skills and clear pictures and demonstrations. Good luck. Get high, keep climbing. Jim
JamesPliny 1 year ago
good video
Jolinator 1 year ago
Nice video, lots of good info.
One thing in the video you're not using hexes but hexentrics. Hexentrics have a curved face and IMO are much better than the old Hexes. The kind in this videos are on slings, this is a good thing for security of the piece. Wired hexes and sling can fail due to the see-saw motion of the rope as you continue you climb. Big passive gear on slings doesn't have this problem but it does mean it can be trickier to remove... but that your seconds problem :)
WorldClimb 1 year ago
Too right! Thanks
mdwykurz 1 year ago
It would be good to emphasize that cams can exert up to twice the downward force of a fall in the outward direction. Hence cams, tri-cams, and hexes can punch through rock that is flaky or otherwise rotten. Always evaluate the quality of the rock before placing your gear!
pigglesworth000 1 year ago
Hi there, thanks for the comment. It appears as though I have been marked very poorly actually, quite disappointing really especially as the feedback i was given seemed to be really positive. But ahwell, many things in life are inconsistent. Thanks again
mdwykurz 1 year ago
Turns out it was an administrative mistake and I did in fact do as well as I'd hoped! :-)
mdwykurz 1 year ago 2
Nice video really well thought, Out how did the assessment go?
AsboxCore 1 year ago
screw down so you don't screw up
dukeu2gmail1 1 year ago
haha 'generally it is better to avoid trees that are dead'
sefjaguar 1 year ago
Great video! everything is so well explained. Thanks!
yggtree 1 year ago
its the 'phantom jacket' by Rab, I think it might be available from cotswold outdoor, well worth getting, I've had it for almost 6 years now.
mdwykurz 1 year ago
Where did you get that black jacket/sweater?
LNLshow 1 year ago