The Red Badge Of Gayness (Commentary)

[kermicheo]

god bless those gentlemen. and god bless the confederasha.

[pimpedpope]

There was a girl voice the snops girls

[nerfvideos96]

wat is this episode called

[waylonbloodskull666]

@nerfvideos96 "the red badge of gayness"

[johnnypocketable]

basically no female character has been important or the same since mary k

[MegaRattlehead666]

i love how lightly they talk about it: she did all the female voices on the show, then she killed herself, that was weak

[groovylocks]

I feel so sad for Mary K.. doing voices is my dream job (and yes. I am a woman and I do accents and have about 25 voices in my regular repertoire - and i work currently as a fucking programmer..) and i often wonder what depressed a successful voice-over actor so much.. that if hanging out with these guys wasn't enough to keep her loving life.. what must have been wrong? Sad stuff.. weak.

[demonella]

@groovylocks She had bipolar disorder.

[shadowhexogram]

Who's mary K bergman? Seriously I've been watching south park episodes for years and none of the voices sound different.

Nice that people care but it doesn't really mean anything to care.

[groovylocks]

@shadowhexogram she used to do all the girl voices.. almost.

If you listen to wendy now and wendy back then, or sharon now and sharon back then, there is a WORLD of difference between them.

[gallowspole]

@shadowhexogram you can notice the voice change in Season 4. Mrs Cartman and Kyle's mom sound waaaaaaaaay different than they did before.

[NewYorkS4U]

@shadowhexogram I've heard that name a billion times when this first aired and one year after this aired, the Simpsons had a Mary Kay character in a short, three-second scene. I've never heard of the name "Kay" as a middle name.

[DiogoAlmeida95]

@shadowhexogram seriously, you never noticed wendy's voice change?

[shadowhexogram]

@DiogoAlmeida95 Nope but don't worry. I was the only one who didn't notice.

[DiogoAlmeida95]

@shadowhexogram dude I can't believe it, watch tom's rhinoplastic (or something like that) from season 1 and then watch breast cancer show ever from season 12, you surely will notice how really thick was Wendy's voice...

[Spokker]

To say that they needed to hire three more bitches just to replace the bitch who blew her head off is the greatest fucking compliment. Had Mary Kay lived the voices of her characters would have likely changed as much as he male voices. Wendy wasn't going to be so high pitched forever probably.

[cookiesodas]

wendys new voice is better

[RandomCowProductions]

@cookiesodas That's your opinion. I hate her new voice. I thought her old voice was strange too and that's why I loved it. I LOVE Mary Kay Bergman and she was a great talented woman!

[MetalBru01]

@cookiesodas Yeah I agree.

[cookiesodas]

okay, people have been saying they messed up wendys voice i cant take that high pitched f'ing voice in my ear

[Hamhark98]

@cookiesodas Well the actress killed herself and they got another person. The new voice is better but its a huge shame she killed herself.

[tejr93]

hahahahhaha 'that was the day mary k bergman killed herself, it was weak.'

[WolfieboyMachi]

I love Cartman's accent. ^^

[conejwsr]

I just love listening to them talk. They have such light personalities, it puts me in a good mood to hear them bullshit with eachother

[Arcand651]

that was weak

[cartmanxclydefrog]

thats sad! she was so good at all the voices! now wendys voice is really annoying

[MartinPerssonDotName]

This is my second favourite episode.

[quantumdude]

Some nerve she had killing herself and all......a new season was about to come up for crying outloud !

[SoJustCool]

Mary K was the best for the voices. Way to sound respectful Trey...but hey in the end they're pretty level headed dudes.

[TheAdmirableAdmiral]

lol gettysburg did indeed suck

[RennanizedRen]

Hey, next to Mary, I actually liked that second lady. What was her name? Schneider? I wish she wouldhave stayed longer. And Mona's all right I guess...

[emerlou32]

Why she killed herself? WTF?

[tottle91]

@emerlou32

She was manic depressive, and kept it to herself

[f0nn1x]

this was my favorite episode

[Gloryboys17]

I'm going to make schmore flavored schnapps this weekend coming up, followed by a civil war reenactment with paintball guns.

[hhh4evur]

Does anybody know which episode commentary it was when they were talking about that 1st grader who runs around talking about santa is fake and they go "dude Fuckin Chill Out"?

[Flailwielder]

@hhh4evur Go God Go part 2

[Filipjphry]

@hhh4evur go god go

[lukbro567]

mary kay bergman was so talented why did she have to commit suicide its so sad

[caseyb889]

@CraigxTweek a lady called april stewart does most of the female voices now. and i think mary kay was depressed and that's why she killed herself.

[AColonDashSix]

After Mary K killed herself...that was weak.

[thestaffsarge]

I love this episode and I also love re-enacting of a different period, sadly it is true, we do get into it hardcore XD

[Gloryboys17]

this is my favorite south park episode everrrr

[MdudeCY]

I remember the Schmore Schnapp girl.

"Yes please! Do shots out of my breasts!" lol

[Riseofthepoorkids]

@CraigxTweek She was mentally Ill, some other woman took over, I can't remember her name.

[Proudnewfoundlander1]

Gettysburg was wicked.

The Ken Burns styl letters were funny though haha

[steelJ4RV1S]

XD cartman going apeshit on the drums

[hannibalbrown]

There was a civil war battle in Colorado against Texas

[FBFTheRagingWarrior]

This episode made Eric cartman my favourite character.AND AN EPIC HERO!

[batrama310]

I completely lost it when Eric starts to rock out with the drum.

[toxic2k7]

Trey and Matt and too cool for peoples opinions lol that is why they fucking rock

[likeastarbaby]

I dont get this. So there are 14 episodes in a season, so thats 7 every six months. matt and trey say that they only get around a week off a year when they arent working on south park in some way. why do they always talk like they literally write an episode in 2 days, have someone animate it in 3 days, and then it airs like a week after it started to be created? it doesnt make sense! why does everything need to be done so quickly?

[TheIraq4life]

she killed herself :( 

[ronjon2565]

KENTUCKY!!!

[Paperbagman555]

lol i watched this episode just before my speech on why Jefferson Davis failed, lol. Great episode wow that's the first i've ever heard of the creators mentioning that tragedy.

[metalheader415]

dude

weak

[matthewmch]

this is one of my favourites

[R8erNation636]

You know, I was watching this episode the day I met my girlfriend. She actually watched the second half of it with me. She didn't really get it (she's from Japan), but she thought it was funny.

[Pwill45]

is she still you girlfriend? I imagine she'd be your wife from now. haha.

[Xzeleous]

Gettysburg was an awesome movie :(

Gods and Generals sucked.

[zaengo]

general lee was completely against slavery. but he had to defend his home, he didnt care about anything but protecting his home and family. he seriously considered working for the north but his relatives started working for the south so he did to, so he wouldnt break the family up. in fact, many southerners were against the war. they called it a rich mans war, and many didnt have slaves and didnt want them. many were forced or had no other choice. just wanted to defend my peeps in the south.

[mattyk106]

why did you know him or something ?

[zaengo]

no, i just happen to know quite alot about the civil war. and ww2. and anciant (spelling fail) greece. you know, just wanted to show off.

[bullyboy1863]

yeah. This is a complete stereotype of the civil war. Everyone blames the south. When really not many of them didn't want slaves.

[Kelvinian]

@zaengo Many soldiers under nazi-germany were conscripts. Victims of circumsance, caught up in patriotism and propaganda. I agree, it sucks for people who are in the wrong place at the wrong time.

[ScottTenormanMustDie]

Well Trey Parker has a wife and Matt Stone has a girlfriend, so no they aren't gay. Sorry to disappoint you :(

[BRATZStarProduction]

I thought Matt was married?

[edwinshap1]

@ScottTenormanMustDie they're just really! close friends :P

[oliFreestyle]

they're NOT gay

[buckcommander23]

gettysburg was bad hahahahahaha YES!

[Laser174300]

everyone calling them assholes need to understand that this is matt and trey. you think they give a fuck?

[KiraJ202]

@Laser174300 Clearly they didn't care that their friend died either, if the most they can say about it is "That was weak."

[codyc67]

@KiraJ202 umm they all said "very sad day"

[ConbonJD]

@KiraJ202 Thats not fair. What should they have said?

[BunsterByne]

@KiraJ202

You realize some people deal with grief by making jokes right?

[JiMMyJaM08061991]

it sounds disrespectful but its not tht the way they deal with things,there an interview on youtube were they go in depth on her death and u can tell they cared a lot.

[iceguy0077]

@ppyyoonnii sorry they didn't go in depth with a bunch of random people over their associates, tell you what why don't you share with youtube your thoughts on one of your family members dying whenever that comes, i'm sure you'll have more to say

[dionysus17]

Says someone who subscribes to fail blog, a site that makes fun of bad things happening to people.

[bullbunnies]

yeah but that's only b/c i like to feel bad for the poor people

[xcsemtex]

cry about it.

[bullbunnies]

i actually crasterbated about it

[Sledge4BYW]

Mary Kay died? that is week man.

[isaacsitton]

whos voise did mary kay do

[Sledge4BYW]

almost all the women

[blazed24sevn]

ya, i think she killed herself

[Ricktomasson]

General Cartman Lee!

[lupoistheman1]

I miss Mary Kay Bergman so much!

[nosaj4480]

Womens' voices on South Park seem out of place since Mary K Bergman Killed herself :-(

[populvuh02]

@nosaj4480 no, not really

[likeastarbaby]

i would probably say that a woman who you've worked closely with on a personal project for years shooting herself due to severe depression is slightly more than 'weak'

[Nabo00o]

@likeastarbaby

It might be their way of dealing with it...

[lygophile]

@likeastarbaby. whom*

and yeah i agree, however, if you see enough south park episode, you'd notice Stan and Cartman (both voiced by Trey Parker, obviously) often say "weak" or "lame" for a pretty wide range of meanings like "sad" or "damnit".

[likeastarbaby]

@lygophile Huh? Thats not related to anything I said...and actually both ways of spelling are correct. But thanks anyway grammar police :/

[lygophile]

@likeastarbaby. it's related to the same thing you made a comment about. about him using the word "weak" in a way that might seem a little inappropriate. i was explaining how he seems to commonly use that word.

and yeah i should have a grammar police badge somewhere around here. *searches*

[hampusheh]

@likeastarbaby

What, are they supposed to sit and cry about it on a cartoon-commentary just so you can feel good about it? It's their friend and I'm sure they've dealt with it the best they can. I mean what the fuck do you say to someone killing themselves? Yeah, it's tragic, but words can't really describe it.

[likeastarbaby]

@hampusheh Has anyone you've known died? I don't cry when I sit and think of someone I know whose died, but there are plenty of words for it. Sad, tragic, a bad time for me, upsetting, horrible, terrible. Because they use weak in South Park as a kind of jokey word it sounds insincere and uncaring. I'm not saying they should break down and cry, but show a bit more respect.

[hampusheh]

@likeastarbaby

Well then that might be your way of dealing with it, I don't get why you're telling other people what to feel and how to react. As matt and trey have said before, people without humour think that just because you joke about something means you don't care, but actually it's the opposite.

[likeastarbaby]

@hampusheh I'm not telling anyone how to feel. I said that they come off insensitive, which they do. Their bad. Thats the end of it. I don't know what you're talking about.

[hampusheh]

@likeastarbaby

What? That's not the end of it, and it's not their bad either. If you feel that it's insensitive, then keep it to yourself, it's their friend. Why are you getting involved?

[GyalisAndino]

@likeastarbaby There is a difference between someone dying and someone taking their own life. They chose to die. They said it was very sad. It is also weak that someone chose to leave all their love ones behind for selfish reasons. Its hard to feel sorry for such persons.

Ps. This is a commentary not a memorial. You dnt even know what happened or what they said abt it so dnt speak.

[KingPiccolo001]

@GyalisAndino the outcome of life is death anyway so I don't see the difference.

[tottle91]

@nosaj4480

Nah they're okay

[bizzare3]

60th! AWESUM VIDS, post more! 25 stars...!

[hunhs]

thx

[CloudStrife1038]

lol, thx again for putting all these up!

[anon2999]

in before "first"

[TJH47]

you know your still " first " right? lol

[anon2999]

was just commenting to foil spamsamman :)

[TJH47]

i know its just a tad ironic