Added: 4 years ago
From: RTHK
Views: 41,053
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,434)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @undertakerRach Nanking Massacre was fake? Lol.

    So as human landed on the moon is fake then.

    You are seriously retarded. I strongly suggest you should see a fucking dr.

    What's more pathetic than those Jap did Nanking Massacre is people like you with such an evil speech that trying to get rid of the responsibility of such a crime for Jap by saying it was FAKE.

  • @wingwing0404 (Part1)How can Japanese admit the wrong history such as the Nanking Massacre? No evidence of the Nanking Massacre. The Nanking population was increased after Japan controlled the city. Many witnesses confessed they had not watched any crime scenes about Nanking Massacre. Chinese government reported the documents written on the number of dead bodies were 20,000, which number was the same number of Chinese soldiers. Also China fabricated 143 pictures of the Nanking Massacre.

  • @undertakerRach i wanna send you some link that is regarding Jap making FAKE history up just to avoid taking the repsonbility of that crime that have commited in Nanking. However youtube won't let me post it.

    If you read online, you will see how much they try to make up just to cover the real history and the harm they have done to Chinese in the past.

  • @wingwing0404 ■(Part1)The "Gyoza" dumplings imported from China into Japan have caused sickness at least to ten people among the Japanese population who had eaten the food in 2007. The symptoms reported by them were nausea and dizziness. One five year old girl went into a coma. However the Chinese government strongly denied any involvement to the incident by China in 2008 and the Chinese media had pointed fingers to the Japanese criminals as the culprit.

  • @wingwing0404 (Part2) Later it was found that this criminal act was committed by a Chinese after all. Did you know that there was a great debate among the Chinese government officials whether or not to announce the fact that the crime was committed by a Chinese, and that many officials there were against the idea of making it public. Only after the Japanese police were strong urging that the Chinese government relented to allow the news to become a public knowledge.

  • @wingwing0404 (Part3) The secretive nature of the Chinese government has not changed much after so many years. China is a liar. They fabricated many pictures and videos about the Nanking Massacre too. The truth of Nanking Massacre will be opened soon.

  • @wingwing0404 (Part2)Moreover, China paid some foreigners to write false stories in newspaper articles and a book. Chinese victims couldn’t receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chinese injured wanted to get treatments in hospital and Chiang Kai-shek wanted to have many victims who were hurt by the Japanese because Chiang wanted to appeal the Japanese false brutally acts to the world.

  • @wingwing0404 (Part3) Chiang wanted the Chinese people to say they were injured by the Japanese. That’s why; the Chinese claimed “we were injured by Japanese.

    How can people believe the massacre was caused by Japanese?

  • @wingwing0404 calm down bro hes just a little japanese he cant change anything hes just a piece of shit

  • @Opzerp True but I can't stand with those Jap trying to avoid and take responsibility for what they have done.

    I mean what has done is done. It's time for them apologize but they are making up shit to say its fake. that's just crazy

  • @wingwing0404 if these jap dogs are trying to say the nan-king Massacre is fake then i say when the U.S dropped 2 atomic bombs on japan is FAKE

  • @Opzerp so true. That undertakerRach is clearly retarded.

  • 如果有一日,日本首相訪華,他特意去南京,在南京大屠殺紀念館面­去下跪,然後起來話:

    剛才下跪的人是我,起來的是全體日本人,是日本人肯面對自己以往­所犯下的大錯!

    相信全中國以至全世界都會為他鼓掌

  • The bad deeds of Chinese soldiers may amounted to a couple of cases non-comparable to Japanese crimes amounted to thousands.

    Witnesses of Japanese crimes were much more than witnesses of Chinese soldiers' wrong doings.

  • (Part2)When Japanese surrounded the Nanking city, the city was completely fallen into a state of anarchy by Chinese soldiers. They in holy terror came to be out of control and began looting and killing. In addition, NY Times Jan 4, 1938 said, the ex-Chinese officers in the presence of Americans and other foreigners confessed looting in Nanking and also that one night they dragged girls into the darkness and the next day blamed Japanese soldiers for the attacks.

  • (Part1)Chinese always say the Nanking Massacre which means the Japanese soldiers stole from the Chinese and killed them during the war were bad. However, the massacre was caused by Chinese soldiers. Chinese government pinned their crimes on Japanese soldiers. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy at Hankow concerning the aspect of the city right before the fall of Nanking as follows.

  • @undertakerRach ur funny man i mean like seriously? the fucking massacre was caused by our own people? stupid shit japanese

  • @Opzerp (Part1)Minnie Vautrin, a professor at the college, wrote 100 girls were raped by Japanese soldiers in her diary on Dec 16, 1937. Also, John Rabe, the leader of the Nanking Safety Zone, wrote in 17th that 1,000 women and girls are said to have been raped last night. James McCallum, a medical doctor in Nanking, wrote about rape crimes in his diary in 19th. However, these cases of rape were what these Westerners heard about from Chinese people.

  • @Opzerp (Part2)About two weeks later, as mentioned in the New York Times on January 4, 1938, Vautrin and other Ginling College professors got to know that the Chinese officers harbored by them had repeatedly raped in the Nanking Safety Zone and then blamed Japanese soldiers for their attacks. The New York Times reported, “(the) American professors…were seriously embarrassed to discover (it).” So would Rabe and McCallum have been.

  • @Opzerp (Part3)In Feb, as the Osaka Asahi Shinbun reported, the Japanese military arrested eleven hiding Chinese soldiers who had committed numerous atrocities in Nanking, speaking Japanese and wearing counterfeit of Japanese translator's armband to pose as Japanese. After they were caught, conspicuous cases of rape, looting and other atrocities did not take place. The Chinese have accused Japan about the rape crimes during the war. However, these crimes were definitely caused by the Chinese.

  • @undertakerRach So ur saying our ppl did everything to our self?? So why was Japan invading China????? why were they killing Chinese soldiers????? umm funny right???? invading& trying to take over China........OMFG ur gonna say China started invading Japan first??????ur insane man with ur comments i strongly recommend u to see a doctor Nanking Massacre was caused by Japan if ur denying for wat ur country has done... u shall die hard

  • @Opzerp I want to ask you six things. How did the Japanese invade China? The Japanese troops came from Japan with arms? Do you know the Second United Front, which means the alliance between KMT and CCP during the Second Sino-Japanese War in 1937? Do you know Liu Shaoqi (劉少奇), he was Chinese guy, ignited the Marco Polo Incident? At that time how many countries stayed thier militaries in China? Do you know the reason of that?

  • @undertakerRach ur not answering my question little japanese afraid to answer? ok cool lets fly back to Japan

  • @Opzerp What is your stupid questions? Too many ?????, so I don't want to read your crazy comments.

  • Comment removed

  • @undertakerRach Sir we dont cry here i wont reply to ur stupid comments anymore all i know is u need to go see a doctor for denying everything about Nanking Masscre

  • @Opzerp 照片都是捏造的.

    埋葬紀錄也是捏造的(崇善堂的都是捏造.紅卍字会的4萬-5萬左­右才對).

    就是南京大屠殺的是4萬左右.但是大概99%是戰死.100個人­左右的女生跟小孩的被害者也有. 我希望中國政府承諾自己的捏造. 日中戰爭的原因很複雑。

    因為中國對英國輸了.發生義和団事件了.駐留権給外國軍隊.

    3000-5000左右的日本軍去了中國.那個時候中國是內戰的­時候.

    共產軍的劉少奇自己說,他們用北京大學生引起七七事変(戦史政治­課本.當時的共產軍的資料).劉少奇成功引起在日本軍跟國民軍的­戰爭。

    幾個證言都是中國政府叫很可憐的中國奶奶,爺爺說謊,表演.

    他們的證言每次都有矛盾.而且一次也沒有檢查他們.

    中國政府真的喜歡這種戰法. 從三國時代沒有變.

  • @undertakerRach 诶你没有资格用中文在一个中文视屏上面和我们中国人说话懂吗?捏­造?搞笑?我看过不要脸的没看过像你一样怎么不要脸的日本狗。你­要是说南京大屠杀都是捏造的那美国炸了你们,美国不承认你什么感­受?你爷爷奶奶一家人被强奸被杀死炸死你什么感受?我忘了狗没有­家人也没有人性的。

  • @Opzerp (Part1)John Rabe, the Safety Zone Committee (TSZC) member, wrote in his diary in Dec 10, when the Nanking battle began, the Nanking population was 200,000. TSZC described in the Document No.9 dated in Dec 17, "On the 13th when the Japanese entered the city, we had nearly all the civilian population in the Safety Zone, so the number 200,000 is no doubt. TSZC documents read that in January 1938 the population was 250,000.

  • @O (Part2)Smythe investigated the population with the help of many Chinese staffs on February 1938. He wrote a report which shows the population of Nanking was 250,000 or 270,000 as of the end of March 1938. Furthermore, The Nanking City Administrative Office of the Nanking Restoration Government, which was established on March 28, 1938, registered 277,000 inhabitants. Japanese soldiers killed 300,000 Chinese people in Nanking city? I don't want to hear Chinese people stories which they hope.

  • @Opzerp It is obvious that Japan invaded China and the main reason was they wanted the resoucres of China. That undertakerRach is a retarded. Don't even have to spend your time to argue with him.

  • @wingwing0404 ur right bro..i would drop an atomic bomb on Japan someday for talking shit for nanking

  • How could the Japanese kill 300,000 citizens in a city that held only 200,000 people?

  • @MrKokomo1124

    Your arguement was wrong, no true evidence supported. The population of Nanking just before its fall was more than 600,000.

  • The Chinese really want to spread Japanese bad rumors to the world. In youtube, they have written lot of groundless rumors about Japan. The rumors don’t have any conclusive evidence. The cause of this fact is the anti-Japanese policy of the Chinese government.

  • @MrKokomo1124

    If you say it is rumors then these rumors were supported by nearly a whole world of people at that time. It was not rumor.

  • After the U.S dropped two atomic bombs, they visited Japan for taking scientific research. Therefore, the result of the atomic bombs and the number of victims were purely accurate. However, about the Nanking Massacre, which Chinese government has been claiming since 1937, there were no witnesses; not only that some foreigners were paid by KMT, and they wrote faked news topics and books. The Nanking Massacre was a fake story.

  • @MrKokomo1124

    Show me dead bodies in accurate numbers otherwise it was a fake story that the atomic bombs killed so many people, you don't have evidences so the casualties were fake, make up story only.

    What kind of scientific research was it ? No actual record of dead bodies found to support the claim. It was fake.

  • @MrKokomo1124

    At present we still have 200 Nanking Massacre survivors who can witness Japanese criminal acts there.

  • Why Mao didn't announce about the massacre in the international mass media conferences from 1937 to 1938?

  • @MrKokomo1124

    Many Chinese newspapers at that time from 1937 to 1938 already mentioned the Nanking Massacre. KMT also sent representatives to Japan with evidences of Nanking Massacre to show to some Japanese there in 1938.

  • Why Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for writing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?

  • @MrKokomo1124

    Chinese KMT only bought the right of translation of Timperley's book " What war means : The Japanese terrors in China." into Chinese for Chinese to publicize Japanese war crimes to get international help. There is nothing wrong with that.

  • Why Chinese government edited at least 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum?

  • @MrKokomo1124

    What about the genuine pictures which you don't mention.

  • The Nanking Massacre was a false story.

  • The Japanese govt ignored all the Chinese demands with no response.Not until April the following year the Foreign Affairs of Japan govt notified an apology to the Chinese embassy in Japan not mentioning any compensation or punishment to the criminals anymore.

    You see it is worthless to show any kindness to the Japanese authorities controlled by the Ronnins /Rightists political groups.

  • Besides 4000 Koreans were murdered by the ronnins and local police too in similar conditions.

    The ironical part of history is here :

    The Chinese govt and people felt sorry for Japan and on 3rd Sept., decided to send money, medicine , food and medical helper to Japan by Chinese vessels not knowing Chinese in Japan were murdered in large scale.

    When the fact of massacre was exposed, Chinese govt protested and demanded apology, punishment to the criminals, compensation to the Chinese victims.

  • On 2nd September, the Japanese found 400 Chinese in Tokyo area and hacked them to death with knives and clubs, their bodies were burnt.In the evening about 9 pm, 300 ronnins with weapons went to an inn where Chinese labours and traders lived and forced them to tell where their belongings and money put then asked them to go outside to sleep in the open area. Those ronnins then shot 174 Chinese in the open area and looted all their belongings.

    More siimilar cases of murder of Chinese happened.

  • In 1923 September 1st, a disastrous earthquake strike the Tokyo plain area,casualties and injuries amounted to 140,000, 2/3 buildings of Tokyo were estroyed. The authorities spread the rumors that it were the Korean and Chinese immigrants who had angered the Japanese god and they also burnt and looted the ruined areas (in order to find scape goats for the disaster). The local police and members of the ronnins societies like the Black Dragon searched for the Chinese and Koreans .

  • (Part2)The majority of women were raped and some were brutally killed. Only around 60 Japanese civilians survived, but much of the city was destroyed in the fighting. This massacre was occurred in July 1937, which means before the so-called Nanking Massacre. How much Chinese killing way of the Tungchow Mutiny is similar to the so-called Nanking Massacre?

    The Nanking Massacre was born from Chinese imaginations and created by Kuomintang of China.

  • (Part1)The Tungchow Mutiny (Chinese: 通州事件) was an assault on Japanese civilians and troops by East Hopei Army in Tungchow, China on 29 July 1937. Shortly after the Marco Polo Bridge Incident that marked the official beginning of the Second Sino-Japanese War. 250 civilian residents of Tungchow were killed in the uprising (predominantly Japanese reserves, including police and ethnic Korean-Japanese).

  • This was really ah, do not have necessary fabricated

  • (Part1)A Japanese whose name was Tokuyasu Fukuda, he was Japanese embassy staff, visited to the committee, he was surprised at the situation because John Magee and George Fitch was writing reports, which were reported by some Chinese young guys.

    The guys rushed into the committee office, and they told, “Japanese soldiers were raping women”, and “Japanese soldiers were seizing commodities from Chinese family”.

    Magee and Fitch typed the stories without any inspection.

  • In Japan when some people speak the truths about Nanking outright they must prepare to behave like fugitives , - change their hair styles, wear sun glasses so they cannot be recognised when going out or even move to live another place in Japan and mask their identities to avoid troubles.

    "And they are not protected to speak the truths!"

  • @Thak11

    The Japanese rightists / military sectors also put on intimidation, assassination to eliminate opponents' voices before and during the WW2 era.

    Is Japan going back the same track now ???

  • 現在的中國亦是大中國主義,軍國主義,和過去的日本有何不同?

  • @crazywei20111 沒有相同, Completely different.

  • @ec97531 相同

  • @ec97531

    I agree with you.

  • Sook Ching massacre

    The figures of the death toll vary. Official Japanese statistics show fewer than 5000 while the Singaporean Chinese community claims the numbers to be around 100,000. Lee Kuan Yew, the founding Prime Minister who ruled Singapore from 1959 to 1990, said in a Discovery Channel programme that the estimated death toll was, "Somewhere between 50,000 to 100,000 young men, Chinese".

  • I promised to you Japanese, I must do the same to you Japanese one day in my life. Just wait and see.

  • @undertakerRach LOL!!! I see an Idiot trying to whitewashes Japanese bloody militarism history with an edited picture.

  • @undertakerRach

    Japanese's invasion in World War 2 is a crime, this is judged by Tokyo War Crime Tribunal with evidence back than and witness by the world's peoples. It is necessary for the modern Japanese to realize that so the tragic case won't happen again.

  • @undertakerRach

    You just keep convince yourself. I believe in Ex-Japanese soldier, I believe in people who had lost their family, not in you. Who are you? What give you the right to saying that they are liars?

  • @undertakerRach "...a teacher"? who is that teacher? You're cooking up story again, 日本女.

  • @undertakerRach The followings are all well documented massacres and war crimes committed by the Japanese Army during WWII: Alexandra hospital Massacre in Singapore. Bangka Island Massacre in Duch East Indies (now Indonesia). Bataan Death March in Philippines. Benxihu Colliery in Liaoning, China. Changjiao Massacre in Hunan, China. Kalagong Massacre in Burma. Laha Massacre in Duch East Indies (now Indonesia). Manila Massacre in Manila, Philippines. Nanking Massacre in Nanking, China.
  • @undertakerRach Palawan Massacre in Palawan, Philippinnes.

    Parit Sulong Massacre in Johor, Malaysia.

    Sook Ching Massacre in Singapore.

    SS Tjisalak Massacre by Japanese submarine I-8.

    Tol Plantation Massacre in the Australian Territory of New Guinea.

    Wake Island Massacre in North Pacific Ocean.

    Xuzhou Massacre in Jiangsu, China.

    The Three Alls Policy of Japanese Army was to massacre an entire village if they suspected an enemy hiding in the village, such as the Panjiayu Massacre in Hebei, China.

  • @undertakerRach Various Japanese Army Units (100, 200, 516, 543, 731, 773, 1644, 1855, 2646, 8604, 9420) researched and developed chemical (potassium cyanide, phosgene, chlorine, hydrogen cyanide, arsenic trichloride, sulfer mustard, lewisite etc.) and biological (anthrax, glanders, rusts, bubonic plague, typhoid, typhus, cholera, smallpox, botulism, tuberculosis, malaria, etc.) weapons, and conducted lethal human experimentations on the general population in Japanese occupied territories.

  • @undertakerRach At least six different chemical and biological attacks were conducted in China, such as Changde chemical and biological weapon attack in Hunan, and twice Kaimingjie germ weapon attacks in Zhejiang, chemical weapons attack in Battle of Wuhan and Battle of Yichang.

    Cyanide gas was tested on Australian and Dutch POWs on Kai Islands of Indonesia.

  • @undertakerRach You are doing your copy paste spam shit in here again. LOL!!! Have you finished with your AV filming yet? You're getting better pay by performing as AV 女優, aren't you?

    Typical Japanese have no guts facing the atrocities their ancestor did.

  • 又要有證據 好 比左你睇又吾信 又要自欺欺人話相系假既.

    你話你地班日本人想點.

    好好咁用腦諗下啦 就算你死都吾信有南京大屠殺.

    你都要知道你地班日本人以前幾咁變態.eg斬殺百人競賽

    我無捏造呀!!你地以前日本東京1937年12月既報紙有登嫁.

    做錯事就一定要認嫁啦 小朋友都知啦 聰明既日本人無理由吾知嫁?!

  • 美好的身教!推己及人!身為日本人的松岡環教師真是不容易!!!­!

    (太勇敢了)

  • I always feel disgusting to see that some Japanese always shits on video like this one about Nanjing Massacre. They denies everything about what their ancestors done and pray for the evil soul.

  • Chinese government has taught wrong history to school kids. The fundamental reason for that is the Chinese Communist Party became the core power that united the nation. For these reasons, no one learns that 30 million people died from famine because of catastrophic decisions made in the 1950's, during the Great Leap Forward, by the founder of Communist China, Mao Zedong and the 1989 protests in Tiananmen Square. Can we call this mind controlled? I think YES!

  • @AOTORA86 This video talks about Naning Massacre. It is irrelevant and out of issue to talk great leap in China here.

  • According the NYT, a teacher said a blistering pace, during a lecture on China's relations with the world from 1929 to 1939 in one of this country's, Japan decided to pursue its own longtime desire for a continental empire, and attacked China. I heard teachers have used 1937 pictures which showed the fake of Nanking Massacre.

    That’s why what Chinese people in youtube said were so one-sided.

  • Amendment to pt. 7 :

    USA didn't have sovereignty right of Diaoyu Islands either.

  • If China wants Japan's true respect to her, just defeat Japan downright by force.- just my insight. Laugh!

  • @Thak11 LOL!!! I do agree with you.

  • Chinese may forgive and forget, but denial of Japanese atrocities in Nanking and elsewhere in China only let Chinese hatred to Japan undissolved and would be inherited by Chinese youngsters in more generations.

  • Continued :

    8. Japan govt. never appologized to China clearly and officially for their invasion to China and the damages done to the Chinese people in writing .Only by saying feeling of remorse or regretfulness for what Japan had done to China by a couple of Japanese officials.

    9. Worst but not all the present Japanese Rights denied the Nanking Massacre had ever happened. These Japanese rape China a second time since World War 2.

  • Continued :

    5. Bride foreign scholars to fabricate twisted interpretations on Nanking Massacre besides the Japanese Rightist scholars.

    6. Self- imposed extent of sea boundaries between China and Japan without recognition from China. Construct underwater reefs to become a surfaced structure and say it is an island and the adjacent sea are Japanese territories.

    7. Occupy Chinese Diaoyu Islands and say it is Japanese territories. USA only gave Japan administrative rights not sovereignty.

  • The reasons why Japan is disliked by most Chinese :

    1. Only respect and submit to the only power defeat them by force like USA in WW2 and dispise all others.

    2. Think that the Japanese was the superior race. (more valid to be found on old Japanese) and all other races are disposable like pigs and logs.

    3. War criminals are still worshiped in Shinto Shrine by govt. officials and Japanese rightists.

    4. Liberal and leftist Japanese are intimidated if holding different views from Rightists.

  • @undertakerRach Japanese are the true victims. They are brainwashed by the Japanese government.

    Japan is a defeated nation.

  • Japan is a defeated nation.

  • 中国∶明天用集会召开的活动网络第3次的号召 6日打算召开的寻求【北京·成泽健一】中国的政治改革的「中国茉­莉花革命」集会号召在因特网上被写入。成为第3次的号召的此次,­是全国人民代表大会的期间中。当局成为集会的召开和海外媒体采访­的压住发急。 在海外的交流网站复数的号召被写入,由于最多东西中国本土的38­城市的集合地方被表明了。只是北京有10处的号召。

    

  • China is a maverick of the international society that do control of free speech.

  • @undertakerRach 你天天都說謊. You are lying everyday.

    How much you get pay to whitewash Japanese military bloody history?

  • We have survivor testomony, independent testimony, Japanese testimony, dead bodies, photographic evidence and written evidence, distorting the truth of Nanking Massacre is absurd.

  • 看到落淚,好難過哦...我們的同胞以前被殘殺...他們又沒有­犯錯,為什麼會遭到這種事情呢...

  • Japan was taken Diaoyu Islands from China by force in 1895, check 馬關條約.