That is incorrect what the shiekh said about hanafi method. the difference with the maghrib is the recital of a surah in 3rd rakah and not omitting tashahud, aswell as the qanoot. this all displays the difference from maghrib salah. the hanafis also have hadeeths they believe to be saheeh that suggests 3 witr cannot be done in a 2 unit prayer and then 1 unit. so the hadeeth stating do not pray witr like maghrib is understood differently by many scholars.
salam.could anyone tell me if i could pray withr salah by just praying 1 rakah without reading 2 rakat first and then saying salam and then praying 1 rakat..is there any evidence that our prophet prayed like this or any evidence i could read. a tangible source.
educate yourself Imam Abu Hanifah May Allah have mercy on him learned directly from Sahaba when you say he was wrong then your saying the Sahaba was wrong as well, this guy is bogus hes following a way that barely started like 100 years ago, Hanafi, Shafi, Maliki, and Hambalis arents sects, actually they all promote eachother and are the oldest ways of following islam and are all gateways to jannah but people act like they know more than the sahaba which is ignorance
@jubzfree. I would urge you to listen carefully and absorb what the Sheikh is saying to your brain before writing.I mean no disrespect please.He said even the Scholar Hannafi used to pray the way the Prophet (SAW) prays. That means after the demise of Scholar Hannaf some of his followers are the ones doing this not what the Scholar himself ordered. May Allah guide and give us more understanding.Ameen
no muslims has ever answered my question. Islam is a complete code of life , thats wat all muslims say. then my question is that wat is the islamic way of farting?wat does the shariah , sunnah, quran say about the method that should be used to fart (pass gas). wat is the sunnah, how did the holy prophet(PBUH) used to fart. please guide me as i want to become a true muslim. Jazak Allah
I wish you find out all the answers of yours questions befor your last breth comes to your lips. AND about farting any senceable persen will avoid to fart in public or if it happend he will be litle emberce. i am a servent of prophet (Mohamed) PBUH so take these words very care fully.
@jubzfree I don’t mean to offend anybody here, but why do some of us Muslim’s label our self to be Hanafi, Salafi, Shafi’i etc. are we not one ummah from the prophet peace be upon him? Did the sahabas call them selves such things may Allah be pleased with them? Not to my knowledge I don’t think so…. I think this situation will eventually lead to bidh’a innovation for years to come, I think this divides us, it’s just my opinion, I could be wrong, I’m only human :)
@sidmaih This 'scholar' is the one who is dividing the sunni islam. He is saying that hanafi way of praying witr is false (even though the great scholars of hanafi school derived the ruling from quran and hadeeth). Minor differences of opinion regarding fiqh is allowed in islam, even prophets time there were differences of opinion. What i'm saying is that i don't like those people going around to other muslims and saying 'follow my way' when there are different methods derived from quran,sunnah.
@jubzfree Mash-Allah Thank you for your view, and you make sence, yes there have been different methods recorded according to the sunnah of the prophet peace be upon him, and they seem authentic as hadiths, which tells us you can choose any method as long as its authentic, am i wrong or right?, im still learning so please dont take offence, if you can, i would not mind being rectified
@sidmaih Your humbleness is very refreshing, may Allah give you reward for this great quality. My advice to everyone is to be careful of youtube/internet imams. Stick to your local imam or some scholar who you personally trust. So much fitna is rife in this day and age. Salaam.
@sidmaih Execellent! I have always and will always ask this question which make me angry to the bone when I hear some muslims calling themselves sects. Anyways,the prophet(SAW) already said it that there will be sects amongst his Ummah even amongst the Jews and christians and thats when the world is coming close to the end.This is what I read but dont know if its true.
Subhan'Allah, thanks to the sheikh i now know whento pray witr but i am still confused on the part about how the witr salat should be performed. Can anyone help with details and reference? May Allah reward you.
Abul-Aaliyah (Radhiallaahu Anhu) – a Taabi’ee – states that the companions of Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) have taught us that the Witr is just like Maghrib Salaat. The only difference is that we recite Qiraat in Witr, and not in Maghrib, i.e. in the third Rakaat. (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Muhaddith Nimawi (RA) has declared it Sahih (authentic)
Abdullah ibn Mas’ood (Radhiallaahu Anhu) is reported to have said, ‘Witr is 3 Rakaats like the Witr of the day, i.e. the Salaat of Maghrib.’ (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Imam Nimawi (RA) has declared this narration as Sahih (authentic). (Aathaarus-sunan pg.204). This narration also proves that just as one sits after the first 2 Rakaats in Maghrib Salaat, similarly, one should do so in the Witr Salaat. (I’elaa-us-sunan vol.6 pg.43-44)
It is not like the maghrib prayer because of the recitation of the Dua-e-Qunoot after the rukooh in the third rakat. If you do not sit in the second rakat for tashahud your two nawafil are not complete.
@iPROCLAIMPEACE the Witr is certainly not an ordinary sunnah either, because of the warnings to those who abandon it, and because of the Prophet's regular observance of it - the Witr prayer and the 2 sunnah of Fajr are prayers which he never abandoned, even on a journey. Thus, witr is wajib according to Imam Abu Hanifah.
@ghettodudefrmdahoodz Na'am there is importance of it, but it is not obligatory. It is a confirmed Sunnah that the prophet alayhi assalam never left. But the obligatory prayers are the 5. All else are voluntary. We should ALL strive to do the mustahabb acts and treat them as IF they are obligatory, but nonetheless if one leaves it, he has only left a mustahabb and voluntary act.
@iPROCLAIMPEACE No one said it was an obligatory prayer. Sister please read my past comments, i said it is Wajib, not Fardh. A Wajib or a Sunnat, is different than a "voluntary act" called Nafl.
@mizellecherry Witr is NOT wajib but it is a Sunnah that was done, one should treat it as obligatory like the Prophet alyahi assalaam who never missed it. It is not usually done n the month of Ramadan, but always; a Muslim should make it regular to perform this act. I hoped this clarified any misconceptions.
@ahmedabderaman No, my brother, the witr prayer is not prayed loudly, accept in the moth of ramadan, the witr prayer is prayed with the whole ummah. Just like the fardh prayer.
@ahmedabderaman I said this a while ago, "No, my brother, the witr prayer is not prayed loudly, accept in the moth of ramadan, the witr prayer is prayed with the whole ummah. Just like the fardh prayer.
" I made a mistake, the word accept is except. My english istn perfect :)
I'm so sad, I whant to see an exemple or an explanation clear in french, this prayer is so complicaded for me! I'm scare to do the rong thing, someone can help me?
i had a dream of a man wearing the same clothing but little different he was standing on front of me but facing on his right side was telling me something in my dream dont remember only little i remember
3 Witr explanation is perfectly right. Their is no website that shows the prayer Rabbig ulni muqimusalata...., in which chapter of Qur'an this prayer is?
@5graffitiartist5 yes 2 single rakat's called shafa then 1 witr after ruku and saying sami alahuliman hadida rabana walakal hamd make dua al qunut if you need more help feel free to message
@MohammedMuzzy87 i didnt understand what he said. did he say we're not suppose to sit after 2 rakahs to recite atta hiyatu in witr prayer? should i just contiune without sitting for darud sharif? im so confused. plz help, tell me.
@guest1921 Yes, you stand three times and sit at the end of the third rakaat and not in between. Don't say tashahud after the 2nd rakaat, just stand up and read dua qunoot and then sit and read tashahud and salatul ibraheemia.
@kozkeshful: witr heisst eins oder ungerade. du kannst das witr also als 1 raka oder 3 oder 5 usw. verrichten, allerdings nicht wie das abendgebet (maghreb), wo man ja zur 2. und zur 3. raka sitzt und taschahud macht. also wenn du 3 raka witr beten willst, solltest du nach der 2. raka nicht sitzen, damit es nicht wie maghreb wird. witr war sehr wichtig für den propheten (fsmi), er hat es während des krieges und auf der reise nicht unterlassen. Assalamualeikum!
"There is no need to be dogmatic about this issue. The differences among the great imams on this issue were because of the way the Prophet's sunnah in this issue has been transmitted to them from the Prophet, peace be upon him, via his companions. In other words, it was due to variations of transmission; the variations were due to the flexibility allowed by the Prophet himself. So if the companions tolerated such differences, who are we to object to them?"
Abul-Aaliyah (Radhiallaahu Anhu) a Taabiee states that the companions of Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) have taught us that the Witr is just like Maghrib Salaat. The only difference is that we recite Qiraat in Witr, and not in Maghrib, i.e. in the third Rakaat. (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Muhaddith Nimawi (RA) has declared it Sahih (authentic)
so whats the correct way? Do we pray a 2 rakah then a 1 rakah. Or 3 straight rakah but with only 1 tashahud? The sheikh quoted a hadith to not make witr look like maghrib. If I pray 3 rakahs with 2 tashahud but also do a qunoot-does this not mean the qunoot makes my witr different from a maghrib prayer?
@iloveto.drinkblood, he said clearly that you can do either. Either the straight 3 rakat, or 2, then tashahud and taslim, then after that do 1 and that's it. But to avoid making it like Fajr.
@ilovetodrinkblood Yes brother I had the same question in my mind. I have read hadith you quoted in Tahaavi. I dont know the reference of hadith as quoted by Sheikh in the video. Let say if that hadith is from Sahih Bukhari .. then which one is to be preferred .. Thanks though ... JazakAllah please guide me
This has been flagged as spam show
That is incorrect what the shiekh said about hanafi method. the difference with the maghrib is the recital of a surah in 3rd rakah and not omitting tashahud, aswell as the qanoot. this all displays the difference from maghrib salah. the hanafis also have hadeeths they believe to be saheeh that suggests 3 witr cannot be done in a 2 unit prayer and then 1 unit. so the hadeeth stating do not pray witr like maghrib is understood differently by many scholars.
BillzUnited 6 days ago
Comment removed
BillzUnited 6 days ago
all of them are paths of jannah
AfghanUmmati 1 month ago
depends on which school of thought you follow
AfghanUmmati 1 month ago
salam.could anyone tell me if i could pray withr salah by just praying 1 rakah without reading 2 rakat first and then saying salam and then praying 1 rakat..is there any evidence that our prophet prayed like this or any evidence i could read. a tangible source.
aaadnan88 1 month ago
educate yourself Imam Abu Hanifah May Allah have mercy on him learned directly from Sahaba when you say he was wrong then your saying the Sahaba was wrong as well, this guy is bogus hes following a way that barely started like 100 years ago, Hanafi, Shafi, Maliki, and Hambalis arents sects, actually they all promote eachother and are the oldest ways of following islam and are all gateways to jannah but people act like they know more than the sahaba which is ignorance
Noluomi 2 months ago
@jubzfree. I would urge you to listen carefully and absorb what the Sheikh is saying to your brain before writing.I mean no disrespect please.He said even the Scholar Hannafi used to pray the way the Prophet (SAW) prays. That means after the demise of Scholar Hannaf some of his followers are the ones doing this not what the Scholar himself ordered. May Allah guide and give us more understanding.Ameen
MsRatt77 3 months ago 2
how to make up witr...
by hanafi,maliki, shafii,hnabali mehtod.
shabaanramadhan07 4 months ago
Comment removed
shabaanramadhan07 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no muslims has ever answered my question. Islam is a complete code of life , thats wat all muslims say. then my question is that wat is the islamic way of farting?wat does the shariah , sunnah, quran say about the method that should be used to fart (pass gas). wat is the sunnah, how did the holy prophet(PBUH) used to fart. please guide me as i want to become a true muslim. Jazak Allah
Faraz70 4 months ago
I wish you find out all the answers of yours questions befor your last breth comes to your lips. AND about farting any senceable persen will avoid to fart in public or if it happend he will be litle emberce. i am a servent of prophet (Mohamed) PBUH so take these words very care fully.
MsSajjad1985 3 months ago
Oh no, not another salafi 'scholar'.
jubzfree 6 months ago
@jubzfree I don’t mean to offend anybody here, but why do some of us Muslim’s label our self to be Hanafi, Salafi, Shafi’i etc. are we not one ummah from the prophet peace be upon him? Did the sahabas call them selves such things may Allah be pleased with them? Not to my knowledge I don’t think so…. I think this situation will eventually lead to bidh’a innovation for years to come, I think this divides us, it’s just my opinion, I could be wrong, I’m only human :)
sidmaih 6 months ago
@sidmaih This 'scholar' is the one who is dividing the sunni islam. He is saying that hanafi way of praying witr is false (even though the great scholars of hanafi school derived the ruling from quran and hadeeth). Minor differences of opinion regarding fiqh is allowed in islam, even prophets time there were differences of opinion. What i'm saying is that i don't like those people going around to other muslims and saying 'follow my way' when there are different methods derived from quran,sunnah.
jubzfree 6 months ago
@jubzfree Mash-Allah Thank you for your view, and you make sence, yes there have been different methods recorded according to the sunnah of the prophet peace be upon him, and they seem authentic as hadiths, which tells us you can choose any method as long as its authentic, am i wrong or right?, im still learning so please dont take offence, if you can, i would not mind being rectified
sidmaih 6 months ago
@sidmaih Your humbleness is very refreshing, may Allah give you reward for this great quality. My advice to everyone is to be careful of youtube/internet imams. Stick to your local imam or some scholar who you personally trust. So much fitna is rife in this day and age. Salaam.
jubzfree 5 months ago 2
@sidmaih Execellent! I have always and will always ask this question which make me angry to the bone when I hear some muslims calling themselves sects. Anyways,the prophet(SAW) already said it that there will be sects amongst his Ummah even amongst the Jews and christians and thats when the world is coming close to the end.This is what I read but dont know if its true.
MsRatt77 3 months ago
Subhan'Allah, thanks to the sheikh i now know whento pray witr but i am still confused on the part about how the witr salat should be performed. Can anyone help with details and reference? May Allah reward you.
randomnssness 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Abul-Aaliyah (Radhiallaahu Anhu) – a Taabi’ee – states that the companions of Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) have taught us that the Witr is just like Maghrib Salaat. The only difference is that we recite Qiraat in Witr, and not in Maghrib, i.e. in the third Rakaat. (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Muhaddith Nimawi (RA) has declared it Sahih (authentic)
atutla 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Abdullah ibn Mas’ood (Radhiallaahu Anhu) is reported to have said, ‘Witr is 3 Rakaats like the Witr of the day, i.e. the Salaat of Maghrib.’ (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Imam Nimawi (RA) has declared this narration as Sahih (authentic). (Aathaarus-sunan pg.204). This narration also proves that just as one sits after the first 2 Rakaats in Maghrib Salaat, similarly, one should do so in the Witr Salaat. (I’elaa-us-sunan vol.6 pg.43-44)
atutla 6 months ago
is witr prayed out loud or silently ..i cant get a straight answer about this question .
abc100061 7 months ago
@abc100061 if you are praying in congregation, Out loud
if you are praying alone, silently
atutla 6 months ago
It is not like the maghrib prayer because of the recitation of the Dua-e-Qunoot after the rukooh in the third rakat. If you do not sit in the second rakat for tashahud your two nawafil are not complete.
atifsuniverse 8 months ago
Is solat ul witr wajib? Meaning is it sinful if missed or not performed? Jzk
bobbyjans 9 months ago
@bobbyjans its wajib, its right under the fardh salaat. so its a very important part of prayer.
ghettodudefrmdahoodz 9 months ago 2
@ghettodudefrmdahoodz This prayer is NOT wajib. The Hanafis thought it was obligatory, but the correct view is that it is a Sunnah.
iPROCLAIMPEACE 7 months ago
@iPROCLAIMPEACE the Witr is certainly not an ordinary sunnah either, because of the warnings to those who abandon it, and because of the Prophet's regular observance of it - the Witr prayer and the 2 sunnah of Fajr are prayers which he never abandoned, even on a journey. Thus, witr is wajib according to Imam Abu Hanifah.
ghettodudefrmdahoodz 7 months ago
@ghettodudefrmdahoodz Na'am there is importance of it, but it is not obligatory. It is a confirmed Sunnah that the prophet alayhi assalam never left. But the obligatory prayers are the 5. All else are voluntary. We should ALL strive to do the mustahabb acts and treat them as IF they are obligatory, but nonetheless if one leaves it, he has only left a mustahabb and voluntary act.
iPROCLAIMPEACE 7 months ago
@iPROCLAIMPEACE No one said it was an obligatory prayer. Sister please read my past comments, i said it is Wajib, not Fardh. A Wajib or a Sunnat, is different than a "voluntary act" called Nafl.
ghettodudefrmdahoodz 4 months ago
@ghettodudefrmdahoodz Akhee, Wajib and Fardh are interchangeable. They mean the same thing. There is wajib, mustahhab, makhroob, and haram.
iPROCLAIMPEACE 4 months ago
@bobbyjans it is a sunnah solat which is not wajib, usually it is done after isyak and usually done in month of ramadhan.
mizellecherry 8 months ago
@mizellecherry Witr is NOT wajib but it is a Sunnah that was done, one should treat it as obligatory like the Prophet alyahi assalaam who never missed it. It is not usually done n the month of Ramadan, but always; a Muslim should make it regular to perform this act. I hoped this clarified any misconceptions.
iPROCLAIMPEACE 7 months ago
Wait isn't there other ways? There's the 3 rakah one too like when do you say that?
cinnamonlove13 10 months ago
he is one of the my favourite scholar
dashingalileo 11 months ago
but isnt there other ways to change the witr prayer other than not going into tashahud in the 2nd rakah?
nabillionaires 1 year ago
aS salafuh salih!!! salafi all day everyday!!
Muslimah2Military 1 year ago
can you pray witr loudly
ahmedabderaman 1 year ago
@ahmedabderaman No, my brother, the witr prayer is not prayed loudly, accept in the moth of ramadan, the witr prayer is prayed with the whole ummah. Just like the fardh prayer.
dickcheneythe3rd 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ahmedabderaman I said this a while ago, "No, my brother, the witr prayer is not prayed loudly, accept in the moth of ramadan, the witr prayer is prayed with the whole ummah. Just like the fardh prayer.
" I made a mistake, the word accept is except. My english istn perfect :)
wassalaam
dickcheneythe3rd 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jazakallah khair sheeker
abcdefghijklmno47032 1 year ago
jazakallah khair sheeker
abcdefghijklmno47032 1 year ago
jazakallah khair sheek
abcdefghijklmno47032 1 year ago
Where is the reference where the prophet (pbuh) says this. Jazakallah
john1136 1 year ago
Jazakallah Shaikh Barak ALLAH feek
iamback143 1 year ago
I'm so sad, I whant to see an exemple or an explanation clear in french, this prayer is so complicaded for me! I'm scare to do the rong thing, someone can help me?
blackwhite998 1 year ago
@blackwhite998 sorry i could not find a french translation but these videos might help.
/watch?v=kcKFZmiXEds&p=581DFE64CA2DF038&playnext=1&index=24
if u do not want to make dua then u can pray like this:
/watch?v=7LTQ1hoxrOw&feature=rec-LGOUT-exp_fresh+div-1r-3-HM
please add youtube,com before the link youtube wont let me post a link.
bilaldaruler 1 year ago
@blackwhite998
Pray 2 sunnah inshAllah do taslim (finishing the salah with salam).. then PRAY ONLY ONE SINGLE RAK'AH! :)
UnitedUmmahinshAllah 1 year ago
@UnitedUmmahinshAllah thanks to you two I do it that way now
blackwhite998 1 year ago
i had a dream of a man wearing the same clothing but little different he was standing on front of me but facing on his right side was telling me something in my dream dont remember only little i remember
ntaldee12 1 year ago
3 Witr explanation is perfectly right. Their is no website that shows the prayer Rabbig ulni muqimusalata...., in which chapter of Qur'an this prayer is?
Zeegoner 1 year ago
so correct me if im wrong.
2 rakath
then after finishing that.
i do 1 rackath alone and do dua qunoot.
please can someone show me a vid on how to do witr prayer.
salaam.
5graffitiartist5 1 year ago
@5graffitiartist5 yes 2 single rakat's called shafa then 1 witr after ruku and saying sami alahuliman hadida rabana walakal hamd make dua al qunut if you need more help feel free to message
MohammedMuzzy87 1 year ago
@MohammedMuzzy87 i didnt understand what he said. did he say we're not suppose to sit after 2 rakahs to recite atta hiyatu in witr prayer? should i just contiune without sitting for darud sharif? im so confused. plz help, tell me.
guest1921 1 year ago
@guest1921 Yes, you stand three times and sit at the end of the third rakaat and not in between. Don't say tashahud after the 2nd rakaat, just stand up and read dua qunoot and then sit and read tashahud and salatul ibraheemia.
Alhumdulilah786 1 year ago
hal el witr 11 rakat?
korgpadude 1 year ago
Allhamdulillah
aaminah16AbdulKhaliq 1 year ago
can somebody translate that to german :s
kozkeshful 1 year ago
@kozkeshful: witr heisst eins oder ungerade. du kannst das witr also als 1 raka oder 3 oder 5 usw. verrichten, allerdings nicht wie das abendgebet (maghreb), wo man ja zur 2. und zur 3. raka sitzt und taschahud macht. also wenn du 3 raka witr beten willst, solltest du nach der 2. raka nicht sitzen, damit es nicht wie maghreb wird. witr war sehr wichtig für den propheten (fsmi), er hat es während des krieges und auf der reise nicht unterlassen. Assalamualeikum!
Lhaw06 1 year ago
I asked Shaikh Ahmad Kutty about the Hanafi way of witr (I provided the Hadith mentioned in the video) and he has given me the following answer:
Ignorance2Light 2 years ago
"There is no need to be dogmatic about this issue. The differences among the great imams on this issue were because of the way the Prophet's sunnah in this issue has been transmitted to them from the Prophet, peace be upon him, via his companions. In other words, it was due to variations of transmission; the variations were due to the flexibility allowed by the Prophet himself. So if the companions tolerated such differences, who are we to object to them?"
-Shaikh Ahmad Kutty
Ignorance2Light 2 years ago
Abul-Aaliyah (Radhiallaahu Anhu) a Taabiee states that the companions of Muhammad (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) have taught us that the Witr is just like Maghrib Salaat. The only difference is that we recite Qiraat in Witr, and not in Maghrib, i.e. in the third Rakaat. (Tahaawi vol.1 pg.206). Muhaddith Nimawi (RA) has declared it Sahih (authentic)
Ignorance2Light 2 years ago
@Ignorance2Light the hadith of bukhari is most reliable..
ihatereality94 1 year ago
Comment removed
kadafi150 2 years ago 6
so whats the correct way? Do we pray a 2 rakah then a 1 rakah. Or 3 straight rakah but with only 1 tashahud? The sheikh quoted a hadith to not make witr look like maghrib. If I pray 3 rakahs with 2 tashahud but also do a qunoot-does this not mean the qunoot makes my witr different from a maghrib prayer?
ilovetodrinkblood 2 years ago
both.
ubaid88 2 years ago
@iloveto.drinkblood, he said clearly that you can do either. Either the straight 3 rakat, or 2, then tashahud and taslim, then after that do 1 and that's it. But to avoid making it like Fajr.
MadinahNoor 1 year ago
@ilovetodrinkblood Yes brother I had the same question in my mind. I have read hadith you quoted in Tahaavi. I dont know the reference of hadith as quoted by Sheikh in the video. Let say if that hadith is from Sahih Bukhari .. then which one is to be preferred .. Thanks though ... JazakAllah please guide me
kimskams80 1 year ago
mashallah
ihatereality94 2 years ago
amazing clothes mashallah
NeCliquePasSurMoi 2 years ago 14
JazakAllah o Khair
sawm11 2 years ago 16