Tiebreaker, with 33 likes and dislikes! I tipped the balance into Like because the performance of practitioners should be judged by their skill level, not by the perceived skill of the judge's own abilities. Even if my kata are better than hers, hers are still good by her own skill.
Students are often reflections of their teachers. Judge her not for what she's learned.
BEST ANSWER on this subject: I do not like to get in the habit of saying one style is better than others. In regards to karate as a sport-I believe tournament compeition, that while it has some benefits, it does create a mindset and habits that will not work for actual combat. I also agree that when you can not attck the joints, eyes, throat, fingers, groin, etc that a true martial artist would not be able to effectively use their style.
good kata just needs power and body feeling...well done, people that say its bad can you put yours on here so she can see where she is going wrong!!!!
@thecj29 watch the performance of higaonna morio sensei then you will see that the real goju ryu version is called different and is performed different
@thecj29 that´s not true because higaonna said you are not allowed to make changes in the kata. that is also why goju ryu is a ko-ryu style and not a style that changes kata every 6 months.Please check iogkf.com you wil not find seienchin there the goju ryu form is seiyunchin.
@thecj29 you´ve obviously missed the first 2 lines of my reply....there is no kime or muchime in this performance and some of the techniques are just wrong.this is the shotokan version impossible that you can call this goju ryu. and if your teacher teaches this as a true form you´re being ripped of. this is gonna be my last comment since i haven´t seen a single argument from you´re side. train real goju ryu then come back and revieuw your opinion about this video
@thecj29 you´ve obviously missed the first 2 lines of my reply....there is no kime or muchime in this performance and some of the techniques are just wrong.this is the shotokan version impossible that you can call this goju ryu. and if your teacher teaches this as a true form you´re being ripped of. this is gonna be my last comment since i haven´t seen a single argument from you´re side. train real goju ryu then come back and review your opinion about this video
@louisoostra No "karate" is a Koryu as "karate" was introduced to Japan around the 1920's by Gichin Funagoshi.Chogin Miyagi was also responsible for the spread of "karate".
Koryu refers to ancient schools of Japanese martial arts which is almost exclusively weapon styles like kenjutsu,kyujutsu,naginatajutsu,yarijutsu(that would be sword,archery,halberd,& spear for those who don't know Japanese terms)
@louisoostra every school has changed kata from the originator of the kata.Some styles change every 6 months.The only kata that are original are the ones made up by the founder of the style.For "Japanese" styles this would be the original Okinawan masters.Other modern styles have different kata made up by there founders.Some are bassed on old kata and some are brand new.Some are crap and some are good.
eu dava uns 5 pra ela... primeiro lugar é que ela nao fez bem, ela nao fez os movimentos firmes como deveriam ser. ela apenas executou o kata como qualquer um
Hi, she is tall and beautiful and nice 2 watch;) Technique is fluid and soft ( chinese influence?) , but lacks raw power. Keep on working ,darling. Best of training.
@12sf5 nao. eu faço goju-ryu e nos so temos a seiyunchin. a seienchin e a "versao de competiçao" da seiyunchin mas nao e aprendida no goju-ryu tradicional
@12sf5 engana akeles ke nao estao atentos ;) ha muitas diferenças entre a seienchin e a seiyunchin. kem conhece as duas minimamente consegue notar a diferença. as aplicaçoes de uma kata de competiçao nunca sao efectivas. por isso se keres saber se uma kata e tradicional ou de competiçao, faz as aplicaçoes com os movimentos da kata
Very good! Interesting how many styles there are. I noticed that you didn't kiai the fist time though, but thats not too major. Keep it up, you make me want to work on my kata more.
Tiebreaker, with 33 likes and dislikes! I tipped the balance into Like because the performance of practitioners should be judged by their skill level, not by the perceived skill of the judge's own abilities. Even if my kata are better than hers, hers are still good by her own skill.
Students are often reflections of their teachers. Judge her not for what she's learned.
Xinsama 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BEST ANSWER on this subject: I do not like to get in the habit of saying one style is better than others. In regards to karate as a sport-I believe tournament compeition, that while it has some benefits, it does create a mindset and habits that will not work for actual combat. I also agree that when you can not attck the joints, eyes, throat, fingers, groin, etc that a true martial artist would not be able to effectively use their style.
pomminsu 1 month ago
TheWolfjr 3 months ago
Shito-ryu Rules
MrCipotMan 4 months ago
good kata just needs power and body feeling...well done, people that say its bad can you put yours on here so she can see where she is going wrong!!!!
TheKev1972 4 months ago
Very weak. Poor stances. Where is the spirit? You must practice much more. Do research on Real Okinawan Goju Ryu. Good Luck.
dgpranayama 4 months ago
@dgpranayama Here we go with keyboard warrior comments. Dude where are your videos?
Arealmartialartist1 3 months ago 2
chinese influence is visible
batulefou 4 months ago
good job:)
ROCKNINJA777 5 months ago
Seemed more like a Sneeze when the name of the kata was taken . . . =(
iAKATheUltimate 8 months ago
one of the worst martial arts perfomances I have ever seen....
TheWolfwatson 8 months ago
you forgot dinamic tension!!!
0ch0853 10 months ago
you forgot dimamic tension!!!
0ch0853 10 months ago
why is shoring-ryu and gojo ryu thesame, not these, this isnt gojo ryu, its shoto base from the action secuted, its shoto
khenlee202 1 year ago
this is not the goju ryu version in goju the kata is called seiyunchin this looks more like the shotokan version
louisoostra 1 year ago
@louisoostra Its Goju
thecj29 11 months ago
@thecj29 watch the performance of higaonna morio sensei then you will see that the real goju ryu version is called different and is performed different
louisoostra 10 months ago
@louisoostra Each school of Goju do their forms differently. Seienchin is a Goju form not Shotokan.
thecj29 10 months ago
@thecj29 that´s not true because higaonna said you are not allowed to make changes in the kata. that is also why goju ryu is a ko-ryu style and not a style that changes kata every 6 months.Please check iogkf.com you wil not find seienchin there the goju ryu form is seiyunchin.
louisoostra 10 months ago
@louisoostra You are commenting over a spelling, this form is a Goju form not Shotokan. The movements are Goju, forget about the spelling.
thecj29 10 months ago
@thecj29 you´ve obviously missed the first 2 lines of my reply....there is no kime or muchime in this performance and some of the techniques are just wrong.this is the shotokan version impossible that you can call this goju ryu. and if your teacher teaches this as a true form you´re being ripped of. this is gonna be my last comment since i haven´t seen a single argument from you´re side. train real goju ryu then come back and revieuw your opinion about this video
louisoostra 10 months ago
@thecj29 you´ve obviously missed the first 2 lines of my reply....there is no kime or muchime in this performance and some of the techniques are just wrong.this is the shotokan version impossible that you can call this goju ryu. and if your teacher teaches this as a true form you´re being ripped of. this is gonna be my last comment since i haven´t seen a single argument from you´re side. train real goju ryu then come back and review your opinion about this video
louisoostra 10 months ago
@louisoostra This is a bad form. But, Shotokan does not have this Kata. It is just a bad goju ryu form.
thecj29 10 months ago
@louisoostra No "karate" is a Koryu as "karate" was introduced to Japan around the 1920's by Gichin Funagoshi.Chogin Miyagi was also responsible for the spread of "karate".
Koryu refers to ancient schools of Japanese martial arts which is almost exclusively weapon styles like kenjutsu,kyujutsu,naginatajutsu,yarijutsu(that would be sword,archery,halberd,& spear for those who don't know Japanese terms)
jadekayak01 8 months ago
@louisoostra every school has changed kata from the originator of the kata.Some styles change every 6 months.The only kata that are original are the ones made up by the founder of the style.For "Japanese" styles this would be the original Okinawan masters.Other modern styles have different kata made up by there founders.Some are bassed on old kata and some are brand new.Some are crap and some are good.
jadekayak01 8 months ago
Comment removed
louisoostra 1 year ago
eu dava uns 5 pra ela... primeiro lugar é que ela nao fez bem, ela nao fez os movimentos firmes como deveriam ser. ela apenas executou o kata como qualquer um
caarlosize1 1 year ago
@immanualkant1989 yes a cat stance.
jabbertones 1 year ago
what stance is that at 0:37 and 0:43......???
ImmanualKant1989 1 year ago
@ImmanualKant1989 neko ashi dachi
jabbertones 1 year ago
@jabbertones not that it was, b/c it ends with a perfect neko ashi dachi. good question.
jabbertones 1 year ago
@jabbertones Cat stance ?
ImmanualKant1989 1 year ago
Looks so different from how I learn it :/
0KatanaCoD4 1 year ago
at last the same as what i'm learning. every clip on youtube seems to be different or under the wrong name. brilliant stuff!!
milkypop16 1 year ago
Hi, she is tall and beautiful and nice 2 watch;) Technique is fluid and soft ( chinese influence?) , but lacks raw power. Keep on working ,darling. Best of training.
ccthedragon 1 year ago
O Karaté de Goju-Ryu tem o Kata Seienchin?
12sf5 1 year ago
@12sf5 nao. eu faço goju-ryu e nos so temos a seiyunchin. a seienchin e a "versao de competiçao" da seiyunchin mas nao e aprendida no goju-ryu tradicional
kyuubifox66 1 year ago
@kyuubifox66 pois, bem me parcia ... igualmente , faço o mesmo LOOL
mas com o titulo deste video pode enganar muitaa gente :p
*
12sf5 1 year ago
@12sf5 engana akeles ke nao estao atentos ;) ha muitas diferenças entre a seienchin e a seiyunchin. kem conhece as duas minimamente consegue notar a diferença. as aplicaçoes de uma kata de competiçao nunca sao efectivas. por isso se keres saber se uma kata e tradicional ou de competiçao, faz as aplicaçoes com os movimentos da kata
kyuubifox66 1 year ago
Are wa akai shatsu desu. Arigato.
View: 11,613
2-4-2009
Saynara
Hokayshenao 3 years ago
Nice work keep it up!
webslinger1 4 years ago
Keep the fingers tight on the open handed blocks or you'll break em when you fight. Also, don't have such narrow Sanchin stances.
xDynaBlade 4 years ago
very good form, keep polishing it now..
uraken must be an effective strike, fast..
as you pull in and thrust with nukite, allow your torso to turn with the nukite..
second break 45deg arms must go to right side then push forward, not just put them in front.. practice bunkai oyo..
shisoshin 4 years ago
it's just a little bit different from our isshin ryu version, but I like it! good performance.
RUSEMANE 4 years ago
wow were i learn it's completely different.. lol
cris781211 4 years ago
Very good! Interesting how many styles there are. I noticed that you didn't kiai the fist time though, but thats not too major. Keep it up, you make me want to work on my kata more.
shadowofninja 4 years ago
very beautiful, but try to keep your elbows in more.
slashmastah 4 years ago
Very good, keep up the work
webslinger1 4 years ago