Added: 7 months ago
From: SilverSkall
Views: 12,698
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (36)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i like the second song the most 

  • this part of the show i thought was one of the best least they let ace go down fighting instead of on his knees

  • You did a fking awesome Job there dude.

    Keep it up. :D

  • AMAZING !!!

  • Thanx for all the positiv comments and also for the criticism :D I think my next AMV will come out between 14.12. and 18.12!

  • Really good :)

  • so beautiful, I alredy saw some amv with the same subject, but for someone who see this for the first time and doesnt know the name of the songs, it must be a epiphany, and will earn a special meaning. Congratulations, your effort pay it.

    By the way the subs are suitable for remplace it with lyrics in your next works. good luck

  • @PowerFireCanon666 Thanx very much I'm glad to hear such words, it encourages me for my next Amv :D And ty for the tip^^

  • cant watch this and help not to think holy fucking shit that is one hell of a fight.

  • epic stuff right here good work

  • klasse lied gewählt :) i like it ° !

  • @PitifulHeartless Danke :D

  • IIGiaSecandoII, GiaThirdo, JettoBazooka, LoosecontroI, 0TheHumoner0 & SILVERSKALL

    Subscribe these 6 AMV makers to see the best One Piece AMVs

  • @RealLoader1 Hehe that makes me proud :D

  • u forgot thallasin @RealLoader1

  • perfect~ No subtitles would be epic amazing etc etc xD sorry mi english is bad.. I like this amv. I subscribe :D

  • @KaizukeMiyato Haha another one who's annoyed by the subs^^ Seemingly I HAVE to do a remake xD Anyway really thanx Kaizu for subscribing and the comment, I'll make sure that you won't regret it :D And my English is bad too xD

  • The remake'll be almost completly new, I'll try to fix there every timing-mistake and parts where it's too slow or doesn't fix in the shema of the rest of the AMV, like the part with Jimbe. But as I said, this should be much work and I'll only start it when I've got really much experience, so there'll be much other AMVs of Impel Down, Sabody Archipelago, maybe even of the Fishmen-Arc before I'll do this, but then I hope I could make this one as perfect as I can ;)

  • CONT: damn good reason!" I hope that you take these tips into consideration and continue to increase your abbilities. Now that that's all said and done, my final rating: 8.5/10.

  • @soundcrewreborn Oh it seems like you have much experience, so I'll take in accound what you told me and thank you for the advice, dude :D But I still have to say something too: I din't want just to use the beat / rythm "because" it's such an long AMV, because it needs a bit variation (I thought :-/ )

    You are right, I really broke the rules of a good AMV-maker with using subtitles...and the information you gave me about the position of the emblem is new for me too oO

  • @SilverSkall I see what you were doing with certain moments where you didn't use the beat or rhythm to stress the scene, but it's times like 4:06 - 4:17 that just don't seem to fit at all that I'm talking about, but as I also said, they're VERY few and VERY far between. In this exact case, you quickly make up for it not even but a few seconds later at 4:25, where the Smoker scenes seem to take it to another level.

  • CONT: I forgot to mention this before, but if you do remake this, remove the double-take that you have at 1:30 - 1:32. It's two seconds that stand out too much and it's just something that you never really want to do in an AMV.

  • @soundcrewreborn Oh yeah the part with Jimbe at 4:06-4:17 was really too slow, I'll try to take more clips in for using the rhythm or beat. I never liked the part although I was the one who made it. The part with the giants will be fixed too, with my latest AMVs I learned a lot that I didn't know when I was making this one. Moreover there'll change the intro, the part when the whitebeard-pirates start fighting, the part when Jozu is throwing the iceberg will get faster clip-changing etc...

  • But know the problem with the subtitles will be solved because I've got raw-episodes for my 4.th AMV, maybe I'll make a remake of this one too, but this should be much work... the problem with the rhytm - timing is at least in my 4.th AMV solved too.. For my coming AMVs I'll think of your critic and try to use them as good as I can. Anyway I don't want to ruin my work just because of the emblem or the subtitles :-/

    The positon of the emblem'll change when I use my new one in my 5.th AMV

  • To be honest it didn't really annoy me, but it wouldn't annoy me at an other position too and I anyway have to use a new sign or emblem.

    Anyway thank you for your criticsm - although some parts surprised me. I wanna get the best AMV-maker so I'll take your tips into consideration ;)

  • CONT: your emblem is now located, it distracts the viewer from watching the video, which is definitely something that you don't want. Now on to your most fatal mistake. Don't ever, ever use subtitled footage. It does absolutely nothing except distract people, ruin the quality of your work, and ruin any mood that you set out for. It is okay to add in subtitles to sceens that you're stressing the importance of, but do so in an artistic way that says, "I did this for a

  • CONT: first, the use of your emblem and second, the fact that you broke the first rule of good AMV's. When using an emblem or some other form of signature, the best thing to do is copy what almost all television stations do and that is to place it in the bottom right corner. I know this doesn't seem like much, but in most television broadcasts, the majority of actions that are ment to draw the attention of the viewers happen in the top three-fourths of the screen. Where

  • InsomniaMan: I've gotta say, I've watched this four times straight and it truly is second to only Gia Secando's own. With that said, I'd just like to say that there are a few things that disappointed me. First, there were some moments where you could have used the beat or rhythm a little more, but they were very few and very far between and completely excusable for such an insanely ambitious three song AMV. With that said, the only other problems, which are big ones that are very avoidable

  • esta bien chingon te la rifaste bato 5 estrellas

  • @BATUZAI4 Oh 5 estrellas are 5 stars, right? ^^ Thanks alote dude.. but I don't speak Spanish :D

  • Yeah yeah yeah! These are how AMV are supposed to be made! Thanks Giasecando for inspiring to many new talents!

  • @HCNguyen86 Omg I thank YOU for the nice comment :D

  • and i forgot saying it before, the first and i think the greatest amv of marineford battle i have seen in my life^^

  • @leGrugnegueur Oh thank you very much I'm very happy to hear this :D I didn't expect a positiv comment like THIS! and than it's the first comment :D Thumbs up his comment! xD And this songs are one of my favourite songs too ^^

  • great combination between 2 epic power metal songs....both of them are one my favourites songs, congratulations, dude^^

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more