Just because Bach came from Europe, doesn't mean all Europeans are the best piano players. Where they come from has nothin to do with it. Whatsoever. I even live in Europe(England) and I do play piano, but am I better than everyone else because composers came from my continent? No.
@XPureSpiritX I don't say all. I'm just saying, that Europeans prefessional pianist can play it better, than other professional pianist, but yes, there can be exceptions. Yes, she's playing good, but if there was any Asian composer, some Europeans pianist will play it worse, than she, but she's playing Bach worse than for example some European pianist. I don't know, what is racist about it, it's just my view. Are you racist, because you are think, that black are best runners ? NO
@patpat1102 WE are the Europeans. This is our music :). Yes, Lang Lang was fantastic, but there are over 1,3 bilions Chinese in the world, it just hapen that some of them is fantastic. But we (better than Europeans is white people to say) have this music "in our blood". I think the most fantastic pianist are from Russia and the most famous composers are from Europe. What can you say to me now ? :-P...Sorry about my English, I know, many mistakes
@bumtaratasmrt Good music doesn't come from ethnicity, good music comes from inspirations and influences from culture and the individual's personal likes and dislikes. You are ignorant and racist. Just because someone happens to be different than you doesn't make them any better or worse than you. Everyone has the equal right to interpretation of a musical piece.
@ninetailnaruto341 You are ignorant. I'M just saying, that Europeans can play Bach etc. best in the world. If Bach was Asian, Asians can play it best in the world. Don't call me racist if you don't nothing about me. So please, shut up telling me, that I'm racist. I'm not full idiot, I play piano for a long time and bassguitare for half year.
@bumtaratasmrt You're a jerk. It's people like you that make the world worse than it has to be. You said she can't play dynamics in your previous comment, well great. There were no dynamics on a harpsichord. Ethnicity or as you said, 'blood', does not have anything to do with musical ability. Learn how to speak English before commenting. Maybe it would help your spelling to stop fingering your ass while typing.
@Jkljkl2009 True, she looks tired and pressed. And this Bach piece is beautiful. I hope she's playing because she likes it, and not because of her parent's preasure. I also hope that her face is related to being in front of a camera.
even if it wasnt harphischord, does it need dynamics? i get the feeling that it operates like a machine and the patterns in pitch build up some sort of macrostructure that couldn't be made in real life. its awe inspiring and i dont think anyone needs to put emphasis on any specific parts because if any part was relatively lessened, the machine would break.
harpsichord music indeed isn't intended to use dynamics, but it uses tempo variation instead, important notes are stretched just a tad longer and less important notes are played faster.
I made this mistake when first learning this piece, I thought the dots above the eighth notes were stacatto, until I found out in this piece its actually PORTATO. Staccato is a dot above notes without a slur line. This piece has the dots with the slur line. Bach intended these notes to be played to "carry" the piece and develop a cantible (song-like) style of playing.
Other than playing staccato when she should have played portato it's pretty well done for her age
i see she has a tiger mom too. FORCE and TORTURE your kids to play piano at too early of an age. it SUX. they have NO friends and can't go outside and play, and tiger moms won't let their kids eat, sleep, drink, or go to the bathroom until the piece is PERFECT! and the kids don't go to bed until 1am, or until the piece is perfect. you parents SUX and should be JAILED for torturning your children.
Bach didnt write dynamics in many peices, but left to interpretation. The voice switches between hands and he likely would have played each hand louder or softer in order to voice the melody. If this peice is played without dynamics it can sound like a robot which i dont think bach intended...? Overall the whole peice has a ebb and flow quality which must have been intended by the composer, im sure he played it with dynamics available to him on the harpsichord.
and ow girl, what do you play NICELEY ! really impressive work ! I would burst out of joy if I saw you doing this in real, really IMPRESSIVE WORK MISS !
@ darkskin2009 you were correct she didn't play the dynamics quite like it was written. For the rest of you who say Bach didn't use dynamics, get some music theory. Bach was a genius. This girl did play it though the way it was meant to be played. Both hands are suppose to "talk" to each other. As one plays eighth notes softly the other is playing sixteenths loud. This piece is one that makes the musician have to split his/her mind. But still well done to this girl. I would give her a ten out o
Nice job! That was really good. You should add some loud and soft, crescendo and
diminuenco with this music will make a great masterpiece. I played this song a lot and my teacher taught me, adding crescendos and diminuencos and it came out much better than I used to play it.
@sannehuijbregts still a child...she'll have one of course! Some kids spend there time playing video games and watching Tv....others practice piano...both are rewarding in there own way. Deal with it.
Man she killed it! This is so boss! Very well done, indeed! :) And to all the haters, you have to cut some slack, because, yes there really is no feel or emotion in it, but you have to understand that she hasn't been through enough or lived long enough to have experienced the things and felt the feelings that make music come from the soul, you know? It'll come with experience :) Technically this child is amazing, and I and others can only wish we were this good at that age! (or in general! ha!)
well done that was played with perfect accuracy!! iv learnt that song and i know the time and effort it requires to learn well. try giving it some dynamic expression to give a nicer feel to it, bt you are deffinitly on your way to becoming a famous musician!! remeber do it for fun!!!!!! :)
@mysticarosa These pieces are written for harpsichord which only produce dynamics. When performed on a piano, however, it is natural to add some dynamics to the piece, although, IMO, not strictly necessary.
@darksin2009 I have the score in front of me... there are no dynamics marked lolololololololololololololololololololololoolololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololol
@darksin2009 It's not the composer who makes the rules, it's the artist ;) Anyways, Bach was in the baroque period, they didn't have ANY dynamics for the keyboard.
@darksin2009 Well this piece was written in the Baroque period and to perform as it was originally written you wouldn't play dynamics as the harpsichord couldn't change volume.
@darksin2009 its bach, and baroque music. Dynamics didn't exist. It's not even technically a piece written for piano. the articulation is where it's at, and she nailed it.
@allmusician5 there aren't any dynamcs, but there are certainly places where it's forte or piano, it just doesn't have to ease into it--meaning, it shouldn't just be plain flat either.
@darksin2009 Bach didnt include dynamics in this composition . So including them wouldnt really make it the original invention . jussayin .(: cuz I JUST FINISHED THIS SONG TODAY ! :D
@darksin2009 who cares you perfectionist bastard! This girls probably like 8 years old and your gonna judge her playing? I swear people can never just say something is great and EPIC. They always have to look for mistakes....
@darksin2009 who cares you perfectionist bastard!? This girls probably like 8 years old and your gonna judge her playing? I swear people can never just say something is great and EPIC. They always have to look for mistakes....
@darksin2009- yeah its alright :D before i wrote that comment I was fed up because every video with music that I was wathcing had criticsm. things like that can sometimes get me a bit mad(especially the thumb downs)
bach wanted music to be played like singing. in the time of bach there was not notation for dynamics, but with the invention of the pianoforte they surely played with dynamics.
@pianomasterbrandon1 good but wheres the feel? thats the problem with these players, bach may have made is so that there were no dynamics, this was so we could express this music ourselves, she didnt :( she just played it.
@isuckbananaz No actually, there are no dynamics because this was originally intended for the harpischord because the piano, nor no keyboard instrument with dynamics had been invented yet so placing dynamics would be pointless.
@Ayumura96 there were dynamics in Bach's days just not written. Music was just beginning to become organized and labeled. dynamics didn't have a label on what means loud or soft so it was left out of the music, but emphasized through sequences and harmonic progressions.
@darksin2009 Well ... the orginal is for harpsichord to I think, and there are no dynamics to on it .. so well ... there is always the question, what should bach have do if he could control the dynamics when he did wrote this pieces ..
ha yes I thought so, but I thought that she did it the wrong way but I've watched the other comments and now I get what it's about. I have to play this song too you see, that's why i'm curious
@darksin2009 To you and everyone who liked this comment, if you look at the music for this piece there are no dynamics written. Invalid criticism. Sorry!
maybe he doesn't know alot about dynamics but he wasn't wrong when saying there weren't any.
It was awesome playing and she is superb for her age but I think the little girl in this video deserves to know how important dynamics are. Constructive criticism is good.
Just because Bach came from Europe, doesn't mean all Europeans are the best piano players. Where they come from has nothin to do with it. Whatsoever. I even live in Europe(England) and I do play piano, but am I better than everyone else because composers came from my continent? No.
XPureSpiritX 1 week ago
@XPureSpiritX I don't say all. I'm just saying, that Europeans prefessional pianist can play it better, than other professional pianist, but yes, there can be exceptions. Yes, she's playing good, but if there was any Asian composer, some Europeans pianist will play it worse, than she, but she's playing Bach worse than for example some European pianist. I don't know, what is racist about it, it's just my view. Are you racist, because you are think, that black are best runners ? NO
bumtaratasmrt 6 days ago
Asians can't play our European music so good as we. For example - this is Bach on piano - I didn't hear dynamic. Asian can only copy copy copy copy
bumtaratasmrt 1 month ago
@bumtaratasmrt Who's "we"???????????? I mean, the Chinese pianist Lang Lang was fantastic!!!!!!!!!
patpat1102 4 weeks ago
@patpat1102 WE are the Europeans. This is our music :). Yes, Lang Lang was fantastic, but there are over 1,3 bilions Chinese in the world, it just hapen that some of them is fantastic. But we (better than Europeans is white people to say) have this music "in our blood". I think the most fantastic pianist are from Russia and the most famous composers are from Europe. What can you say to me now ? :-P...Sorry about my English, I know, many mistakes
bumtaratasmrt 3 weeks ago
@bumtaratasmrt Good music doesn't come from ethnicity, good music comes from inspirations and influences from culture and the individual's personal likes and dislikes. You are ignorant and racist. Just because someone happens to be different than you doesn't make them any better or worse than you. Everyone has the equal right to interpretation of a musical piece.
ninetailnaruto341 2 weeks ago 2
@ninetailnaruto341 You are ignorant. I'M just saying, that Europeans can play Bach etc. best in the world. If Bach was Asian, Asians can play it best in the world. Don't call me racist if you don't nothing about me. So please, shut up telling me, that I'm racist. I'm not full idiot, I play piano for a long time and bassguitare for half year.
bumtaratasmrt 1 week ago
@bumtaratasmrt You're a jerk. It's people like you that make the world worse than it has to be. You said she can't play dynamics in your previous comment, well great. There were no dynamics on a harpsichord. Ethnicity or as you said, 'blood', does not have anything to do with musical ability. Learn how to speak English before commenting. Maybe it would help your spelling to stop fingering your ass while typing.
JohnnyMcMormon 1 week ago
@JohnnyMcMormon To the word blood, that is, how we say it in my country.
And that is all what you can ? Just vulgarisms ? So what, you don't have any other aguments so you have to show me, what a big dumbass you are ?
bumtaratasmrt 6 days ago
@ninetailnaruto341 PS: please read what i wrote before. There's nothiong racist about it.
bumtaratasmrt 1 week ago
little to fast
pianochampian 1 month ago
@PresentsForJulie
patpat1102 1 month ago
Asians...
BringMeFrost 1 month ago
@BringMeFrost What is so bad about Asains? I am one too!
patpat1102 1 month ago
She's concentrated. Not sad. Take it from a pianist. When I'm playing on piano, I don't smile -_-
XPureSpiritX 1 month ago
To the person below me
Ad how would you know if you she didn't want to do it? Seriously,dude, fuck off.
XPureSpiritX 1 month ago
AND SHe doesn't even look happy !!! you piece of... you know the rest
Jkljkl2009 2 months ago
@Jkljkl2009 True, she looks tired and pressed. And this Bach piece is beautiful. I hope she's playing because she likes it, and not because of her parent's preasure. I also hope that her face is related to being in front of a camera.
Anyway, she plays it well..
PauuLiiZz 1 month ago
I am sick of Asians dominating all instruments... MAKE IT STOP LET YOUR DAMN CHILD DO WHAT HE/SHE WANTS TO DO!!
Jkljkl2009 2 months ago
3 top comments?
Redisthecolor0 2 months ago
woah, impressive!
partyandahalf 3 months ago
,,,BRAVA,,,! :)
MrFreetraveler 3 months ago
好鬼勁
he214abc 3 months ago
Who cares about how Bach wanted it. I play it, I do what I want.
Slopies 4 months ago
[ Insert stupid and depressing comment about Asian superiority here ]
MrJoel397 4 months ago
I prefer Harpischord, but good
Symeon94 4 months ago
>_>
speedyguy8 4 months ago
Wow! She's so good, and so cute! I'm just learning this song.
OKidsRule 5 months ago
I can play this one, too!
It takes me about twice as long, and I'm nowhere near that smooth...
On second thought, I don't think I can play this song.
Hats off to you, Rachel!
ShayMcSudonim 5 months ago
even if it wasnt harphischord, does it need dynamics? i get the feeling that it operates like a machine and the patterns in pitch build up some sort of macrostructure that couldn't be made in real life. its awe inspiring and i dont think anyone needs to put emphasis on any specific parts because if any part was relatively lessened, the machine would break.
papapap2 6 months ago
Asian
Lisztman88 6 months ago 2
U better play young lady!!
DW313 6 months ago
o.o
FRANCESCO199525 6 months ago
Wonderful!
REV 18
goscott4 7 months ago
That kid kicks ass.
XPureSpiritX 7 months ago
Wow, excellent! Such talent!
cebukid70 7 months ago
You are wonderful! What is your name?
willryoo 7 months ago
That's pretty good for a little girl. I have one question- is she Korean, Japanese or Chinese?
willryoo 7 months ago
............I quit
Dnova16 7 months ago
excellent! it's wonderful. a real talent!
Ernayooo 7 months ago
i'm inspired ♥
MeganLozada13 7 months ago
Nice playing, good interpretation.
Wonder how Bach would have played the piece himself?
thepianoplayer416 7 months ago
harpsichord music indeed isn't intended to use dynamics, but it uses tempo variation instead, important notes are stretched just a tad longer and less important notes are played faster.
MrFudoken 8 months ago
wonderful! Greetings Inge
PreuschoffPerrier 8 months ago
amazing
alekos2233 8 months ago
Beautiful!! good 5 stars *****
galaxian06 8 months ago
Could have added some dynamics...with the lack of dynamics you're supposed to interpret it yourself
TheTalentedMrArashi 8 months ago
How dare she play this good! WHO does she think she is , Mozart?:)
MrEido08 9 months ago
Wow she's so good!! Wonderful playing!
romulo560 9 months ago
this is so good! (:
she's amazing!
haha i'm older and not quite this good but someone should come look at my video of this. just uploaded itt
courters1204 9 months ago
good
a12196935 10 months ago
omg i luv th sound of this one its probably my favorite
GusBus2843 10 months ago
49 of them couldn't do that when they are at such age.. maybe even now too.
aeonfulx 10 months ago
Shes playing staccato
I made this mistake when first learning this piece, I thought the dots above the eighth notes were stacatto, until I found out in this piece its actually PORTATO. Staccato is a dot above notes without a slur line. This piece has the dots with the slur line. Bach intended these notes to be played to "carry" the piece and develop a cantible (song-like) style of playing.
Other than playing staccato when she should have played portato it's pretty well done for her age
mikeisapro 10 months ago
@quantumgirl651 My piano teacher told me the same thing!! About the dynamics, harpsichords possibilities, etc!! :p
GrapefruitAndChaiTea 10 months ago
i see she has a tiger mom too. FORCE and TORTURE your kids to play piano at too early of an age. it SUX. they have NO friends and can't go outside and play, and tiger moms won't let their kids eat, sleep, drink, or go to the bathroom until the piece is PERFECT! and the kids don't go to bed until 1am, or until the piece is perfect. you parents SUX and should be JAILED for torturning your children.
PianoTHIS 10 months ago
@PianoTHIS Or she's actually really talented....
XoLittleCadet 10 months ago
@XoLittleCadet the million dollar question...
PianoTHIS 9 months ago
@XoLittleCadet kids who are tortured don't want to evern SEE a piano when they grow up. google it.
PianoTHIS 9 months ago
FOR GOD...SHE´S JUST A CHILD!!!
Yngorius 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
CHECK OUT MY VERSION AND THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA SONGS ON MY CHANNEL!
ClassicalMusicPiano 10 months ago
You made my favorite piece of piano-music just sound even better!
sunniemiriam 10 months ago
Bach didnt write dynamics in many peices, but left to interpretation. The voice switches between hands and he likely would have played each hand louder or softer in order to voice the melody. If this peice is played without dynamics it can sound like a robot which i dont think bach intended...? Overall the whole peice has a ebb and flow quality which must have been intended by the composer, im sure he played it with dynamics available to him on the harpsichord.
quantumgirl651 10 months ago
has anyone ever heard of TERRACED dynamics? that, i assure you, there were....
hoodiesss 10 months ago
wonderful! continue playing like that
frankwit123 10 months ago
asians ...
luisangel23p 10 months ago
her mom that was filming didnt clap
Taneeababe 10 months ago
omg i am having a hard time trying to learn this piece and yet this tiny little girl beats me, a freaking high schooler, so badly. x_x
LaughingBread 10 months ago
puré ca fé é moi ke je lé jen sui meme pas a la moitier jsuis vraiment une nul, j'y arriverer jamais
SetM7 11 months ago
GREAT TALENTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT-----------WHEW! keep it up young lady, you are an awesome pianist
pedomohd 11 months ago
*Whistles*
... I have officially been outdone by a girl that I'm twice as old as.
How humiliating! But she's fantastic!
Digipup4life 11 months ago
@Digipup4life Unless you mean to say that you're 5 years old, I think you meant to say, "Half your age." :D
grammar nazi. :P
irot3456 11 months ago
@irot3456 Oi! XD
Digipup4life 11 months ago
@Digipup4life Lol, I'm sorry. :(
irot3456 11 months ago
@irot3456 actually, digipup4life had it right... he/she said "i'm twice as old as." which would be correct. that would not mean she is 5 years old.
-the real grammar nazi.
blerg500 11 months ago
@blerg500 Oh, silly me. XD
I reread it. I was WRONG. D:
Thank you for correcting. :\
irot3456 10 months ago
and ow girl, what do you play NICELEY ! really impressive work ! I would burst out of joy if I saw you doing this in real, really IMPRESSIVE WORK MISS !
Darkboy2525 11 months ago
tutorial please
marians95 11 months ago
@ EvanWang999 the fingering I use on this awkward passage starting on the 3rd beat would be 5, 5 2 1 2 5 2 1
cmccoy02 1 year ago
10/10
cmccoy02 1 year ago
@ darkskin2009 you were correct she didn't play the dynamics quite like it was written. For the rest of you who say Bach didn't use dynamics, get some music theory. Bach was a genius. This girl did play it though the way it was meant to be played. Both hands are suppose to "talk" to each other. As one plays eighth notes softly the other is playing sixteenths loud. This piece is one that makes the musician have to split his/her mind. But still well done to this girl. I would give her a ten out o
cmccoy02 1 year ago
she makes this look easy. in reality, it's an EXTREMELY difficult piece. shit.
nsroly05 1 year ago
I feel so overwhelmed and mesmerized right now..
TheAmantaRay 1 year ago
17 people are jealous
marians95 1 year ago
47 people are jealous
marians95 1 year ago
Im just starting to play this piece for my Grade 6 piano exam. Any tips on how to practice and speed it up?? It's actually not that hard!
MusicClassical1 1 year ago
:~)
dividendrama 1 year ago
You are talented
pianomasterbrandon1 1 year ago
素晴らしい
kazutomig51 1 year ago
Nice job! That was really good. You should add some loud and soft, crescendo and
diminuenco with this music will make a great masterpiece. I played this song a lot and my teacher taught me, adding crescendos and diminuencos and it came out much better than I used to play it.
TekuVertWheeler 1 year ago
Is that what we call a wonderchild or what? ;)
NiccTheBlackParade 1 year ago
i can do that im god!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MrBonerboy0 1 year ago
congragulations. My dream is to play like you. I would like to know your exercise program.
mdoenyas 1 year ago
i've always loved this song but couldn't get the speed down. great job.
tigerlibra 1 year ago
oh why are there sooooo many young chinese musicians I mean I thought they were technologic or something.... :o
manise29 1 year ago 2
just osom :D
elmax316 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
omg, you're my idol....
wasygirl 1 year ago
omg, you're my idol....
wasygirl 1 year ago
47 Justin Beliebers people xP!
WinterDeath001 1 year ago 2
i watch this religiously, this is by far the best video on youtube and you play it the best out of anyone ive ever seen!
1armedspoonbandit 1 year ago
oh my god!
leoalpiano 1 year ago
i've been playing piano for almost 8 years and i still cant play like that
fossbros2 1 year ago
She's way better than Glen Gould...
danishpride1 1 year ago
At 0:13-0:15, there is an awkward part with some bizarre fingerings. If you have played this song before, what to do you use?
EvanWang999 1 year ago
She is the next Sarah Chang- for the piano.
imedia4u 1 year ago
WOW.... She is amazing
TheNadiac31 1 year ago
Well done! Solid playing. As time goes by, you will learn about dynamics and structure. If you like Bach, listen to Glenn Gould and Rosalyn Tureck.
ycooreman 1 year ago
There's forte and mf in each bar, the first and third note.
tianyulu 1 year ago
¡Joder cómo toca la nena!
pepitho 1 year ago
Funny always an Asian!
superscoutman 1 year ago
Rofl, Asians push their children way too much. I'm as good as her, but probably 6 years older. :D
XXDKDK 1 year ago
46 people are jealous
BigBeats52 1 year ago 12
plays well, but i feel sick and bad watching her face while she plays... some reason.
Singlerity 1 year ago
She's way into it... and I love her tempo. not too fast, not too slow : )
nospamreceived 1 year ago
this is sick.. did she even have a childhood..?
sannehuijbregts 1 year ago
@sannehuijbregts She's still in her childhood ? :s
JaejoongieLove 1 year ago
@sannehuijbregts still a child...she'll have one of course! Some kids spend there time playing video games and watching Tv....others practice piano...both are rewarding in there own way. Deal with it.
AkMastamind 1 year ago
Man she killed it! This is so boss! Very well done, indeed! :) And to all the haters, you have to cut some slack, because, yes there really is no feel or emotion in it, but you have to understand that she hasn't been through enough or lived long enough to have experienced the things and felt the feelings that make music come from the soul, you know? It'll come with experience :) Technically this child is amazing, and I and others can only wish we were this good at that age! (or in general! ha!)
kewl2006 1 year ago
well done that was played with perfect accuracy!! iv learnt that song and i know the time and effort it requires to learn well. try giving it some dynamic expression to give a nicer feel to it, bt you are deffinitly on your way to becoming a famous musician!! remeber do it for fun!!!!!! :)
MusicChickSince96 1 year ago
x__x
Increible!
esternoclaid 1 year ago
BRAVOOOOOOOO!
00catarina00 1 year ago
wow *__*
RumoVonZarmonien 1 year ago 2
very impressive kid!!
seahyimin 1 year ago
She's great!!!
Archiecomicgirl 1 year ago
Love the Burberry. :)
Azlaier 1 year ago
dear god! :D
macmac031680 1 year ago
in great and all but theres no dynamics
darksin2009 1 year ago 16
@darksin2009 baroque music has no dynamics marking
mysticarosa 1 year ago
@mysticarosa These pieces are written for harpsichord which only produce dynamics. When performed on a piano, however, it is natural to add some dynamics to the piece, although, IMO, not strictly necessary.
I still think this performance is excellent.
Fuglebolle 1 year ago
@darksin2009 it's bach
phil8888 1 year ago
@darksin2009 Oh, I see, you play with dynamics...
pierolivier111 1 year ago
@darksin2009 I have the score in front of me... there are no dynamics marked lolololololololololololololololololololololoolololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololololol
Shortmediumtallguy4 1 year ago
@darksin2009 It's not the composer who makes the rules, it's the artist ;) Anyways, Bach was in the baroque period, they didn't have ANY dynamics for the keyboard.
Bruceforge 1 year ago 2
@darksin2009 dude she's like 6
kgtarbert84 1 year ago
@darksin2009 They're dynamics in Bach's music? Since when?
rsoeyadi 1 year ago 2
@darksin2009 Well this piece was written in the Baroque period and to perform as it was originally written you wouldn't play dynamics as the harpsichord couldn't change volume.
zachydj 1 year ago
@darksin2009 You are such a noob.
MrMalheureusement 1 year ago
@darksin2009 eh fuck off for once you complainers
fruitisforhippies 1 year ago
@darksin2009 its bach, and baroque music. Dynamics didn't exist. It's not even technically a piece written for piano. the articulation is where it's at, and she nailed it.
allmusician5 1 year ago
@allmusician5 there aren't any dynamcs, but there are certainly places where it's forte or piano, it just doesn't have to ease into it--meaning, it shouldn't just be plain flat either.
hoodiesss 1 year ago
@darksin2008 when you play bach, you are nor allowed to ply dynamics, because bach only played on a cembalo and there you can`t play dymanics
PottingParting 1 year ago 2
@darksin2009 i barely find pieces in classical music with any dynamics
soadfe 1 year ago
@darksin2009 Are you kidding me? She's a little girl for fucks sake..
chaplinconspiracy 1 year ago
@darksin2009 I agree there a not any dynamics, it would make a lot more exciting if there was!
CtvtvC 1 year ago
@CtvtvC
the harpsichord doesn't have any dynamics as far as i know, if you mean in the way of varying volume, so maybe it's the way Bach intended?
Eirik175 1 year ago
@darksin2009 Bach didnt include dynamics in this composition . So including them wouldnt really make it the original invention . jussayin .(: cuz I JUST FINISHED THIS SONG TODAY ! :D
OnexSilentxTear 1 year ago
@darksin2009 who cares you perfectionist bastard! This girls probably like 8 years old and your gonna judge her playing? I swear people can never just say something is great and EPIC. They always have to look for mistakes....
Gwampa777 1 year ago
@darksin2009 who cares you perfectionist bastard!? This girls probably like 8 years old and your gonna judge her playing? I swear people can never just say something is great and EPIC. They always have to look for mistakes....
Gwampa777 1 year ago
@Gwampa777 yes i am sorry for that, what i meant to do is give some advice i did not mean to crticize her
darksin2009 1 year ago
@darksin2009- yeah its alright :D before i wrote that comment I was fed up because every video with music that I was wathcing had criticsm. things like that can sometimes get me a bit mad(especially the thumb downs)
Gwampa777 1 year ago
@darksin2009 Bach never wrote with dynamics
pianomasterbrandon1 1 year ago 14
@pianomasterbrandon1
bach wanted music to be played like singing. in the time of bach there was not notation for dynamics, but with the invention of the pianoforte they surely played with dynamics.
rolandjosef 10 months ago
@pianomasterbrandon1 But he wrote with phrasing..
markerman23 9 months ago
@pianomasterbrandon1 good but wheres the feel? thats the problem with these players, bach may have made is so that there were no dynamics, this was so we could express this music ourselves, she didnt :( she just played it.
isuckbananaz 9 months ago
@isuckbananaz No actually, there are no dynamics because this was originally intended for the harpischord because the piano, nor no keyboard instrument with dynamics had been invented yet so placing dynamics would be pointless.
HectorAndresMayoral 8 months ago
@pianomasterbrandon1
AnneloreMusic 6 months ago
@pianomasterbrandon1
What are dynamics in dutch?
AnneloreMusic 6 months ago
@darksin2009 yea but she is only what, 10? That usually comes later in a musician's life.
TheRealrocker74 1 year ago
@darksin2009 u dont have to have dynamics...BACH wrote this piece...they dont have dynamics back in Bach's days
Ayumura96 11 months ago 2
@Ayumura96 there were dynamics in Bach's days just not written. Music was just beginning to become organized and labeled. dynamics didn't have a label on what means loud or soft so it was left out of the music, but emphasized through sequences and harmonic progressions.
cmccoy02 10 months ago
@darksin2009 Well ... the orginal is for harpsichord to I think, and there are no dynamics to on it .. so well ... there is always the question, what should bach have do if he could control the dynamics when he did wrote this pieces ..
Greatings
Darkboy2525 11 months ago 5
@Darkboy2525
What are dynamics in dutch?
AnneloreMusic 6 months ago
@AnneloreMusic haha I it is almost the same, we use the word 'dynamiek' :)
Darkboy2525 6 months ago
@Darkboy2525
ha yes I thought so, but I thought that she did it the wrong way but I've watched the other comments and now I get what it's about. I have to play this song too you see, that's why i'm curious
AnneloreMusic 6 months ago
@Darkboy2525
en gij spreekt gewoon nederlands, ik zit hier in't engels bezig :p
AnneloreMusic 6 months ago
@AnneloreMusic hahaha inderdaad niet nodig ! ;)
Darkboy2525 6 months ago
@darksin2009 she's better than you and all
pierolivier111 11 months ago
@darksin2009 To you and everyone who liked this comment, if you look at the music for this piece there are no dynamics written. Invalid criticism. Sorry!
wesll 11 months ago
@darksin2009 stupid person stop commenting, wat do u know about dynamics
diabolico5 10 months ago
@diabolico5 get over yourself
maybe he doesn't know alot about dynamics but he wasn't wrong when saying there weren't any.
It was awesome playing and she is superb for her age but I think the little girl in this video deserves to know how important dynamics are. Constructive criticism is good.
Awesome playing!!
link1478 10 months ago
@darksin2009 You know nothing about Bach, right?
112358miau 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fucking chinese.
maggothim 1 year ago
IN YOUR FACE BEETHOVEN!!!
MysteryPianoMaster 1 year ago