Kelly Clarkson - American Idol 1 - Without You

[sonioelucas]

brazil

[mrjlwjlw]

I love this woman...she could sing to me anytime, I luv her voice

[Vergadoce]

Is it the video quality here, or are her low notes shaky?

[coolsims1234]

better than james

[celinhomartins82]

Obviously Mariah's version is very superior!!!! But Kelly is good too! Love both!

[Matshoppahulle]

@celinhomartins82 Actually i meant the first cover, not original, is

the best: Harry Nilsson, it was no.1 in the US, UK and Canada 1972.

Kelly is good. Hard song!!!

[Matshoppahulle]

Its ok, nowhere near Mariah Careys cover, or the original.

[axelle32]

The time difference between audio and video is really super frustrating here but thks for posting. She's AMAZING

[MsKGB1]

Go Haley Reinhart!!!!!!!

[paulus1st]

all fucked up

[REDEADjoker100]

Kelly know she love herself some Mariah!

[CaranLonde]

pffffttttt best version of this is th Bulagarian one...xD nothing can beat Ken LI!!!!!!! :X

[frisc0pn0ib0i]

@CaranLonde LMFAO



[aBreannaSession]

@CaranLonde lmfao my mom showed that one to me a few years ago lol some funny shit

[CaranLonde]

@aBreannaSession :)) dnt chu love how confident she was that the title was Can't live/Ken Li? :))

[poohbita]

Praise or curse Mariah for making this song so damn hard! still loved it thou kelly.

[jho828]

wow! i love you kelly...

[ParamoreVzla]

Kelly, Carrie and Adam are my favorite contestants from Idol who agrees?

[vermeys21]

all fucked up

[crowstear86]

omg is this kelly clarkson? she looke so different there...

[BllueJeeper]

ken lee...

[xxxwant6]

hehe

[rfgstl]

When it comes to vocals....Kelly can't touch Leona Lewis(Still love you tho Kelly)

When it comes to performing....Leona can't touch Kelly Clarkson(Still love you tho Leona)

[poykub1]

It very very very great Songgggg and I incredible that she do it

[minijmin]

how can kelly beat mariah to this song? mariah does it so much more effortlessly. but kelly did really good so we dont need to really compare.

[u2b9876]

Another post where the audio and video are way out of sync.  Fuck off with these useless posts!

[jodie89smile]

i fudgin love kelly clarkson! amazing

[bimadraj]

not very good but ok

[louie200353]

yah... this ones a better version.. next to Ken lee .. lol

MAriah's untouchable...!!!

[LulyBrown]

@louie200353 Im sorry I just gave u a Thumd down. I didn't mean to. I was laughing so hard I mistakenly clicked the thumb down :-(. I laughed at "..next to ken lee" part of ur comment lol that was one interesting cover lol

[sexykitten0627]

It is funny how she is trying to do both versions of this song from Eric Carmen and Mariah Carey.

[KonZangetsu10]

SOY PERUANO.... ERES MARAVILLOSA KELLY ....

[norandrostenedione]

mariah was in a studio with machines and many takes. lets see who is better live. Kelly clarkson

and Carrie Underwood much better.

[bigsteel]

@norandrostenedione Mariah has sing this song Many times live, do your research - God.

[Oceanic180]

video seems to be off-sync. but incredible performance :)

[MarcosRock88]

hm , não sei qual a pior versão ; Carly ou Kelly

[carlaxoxosweet143]

I LOVE HER!!

ALWAYS BE MY NO.1!

xD

[TheLbutterfly]

I remember watching this live.... this song was the judge's choice. And they loved it, of course. the original and still the best American Idol.

[hermiraven]

O_O O.O O.O awesome woow it´s just great

[MizzKat103]

plus, who would suck that bad at lip-syncing? you'd get booed off the stage if you were that bad at being a fake.

[mikaylajadejones]

cant believe how skinny she was then lol

[xpriscy]

Mariah version is unique and better....but kelly did it well !

[TheMickj23q]

Not everyone is Mariah! She is herself and her voice is amazing! I love it! Hence I prefer Mariah's version Kelly is amazing!!

[Numporn]

I like kelly^.^ but I think Mariah did better on this song.

[peterdaniel66]

I can never listen to this song without thinking of "Ken Lee' lmao...

[shadowceci]

@peterdaniel66  Dude u killed me :D:D:D:D:D::D:D

[TheKanddy]

AWESOME!! :O

[singingmysong20]

This song isn't the best choice, but she NAILS every song she sings. If you can do better, please post a video response.

[daysfan15yrs]

She does not suck! Clean out your Ears. She's amazing in this song. Its hard to beat Mariah but Kelly holds her own in the song!

[dino17692]

@beavertown2006 as someone said before me in this. leona is awesome, not taking anything away from her. but kelly is much more versatile and she can sing almost anything. leona thrives at a certain range. but kellys range is just so much bigger, you really cant compare the two.

however i do believe that kelly beat mariah and leona anytime.

[TRISAND]

This song is not what a strong woman should sing??????????? yea right lol This song is perfect for a females range. Boy lol you have a tin ear.

[nmortola1]

shes so hot and shes a really good singer she kicks asssss!!!!!

[merkurius046]

she looks alot like jennifer aniston - and she is beautiful!

[PunkPrincessAvrilFan]

yes ! i like her so much

[MrSpiQ]

amazing ;D

[jas05281978]

leona lewis is a man heheheh...man face i mean!!!peace yo!

[SABOREAME68]

DAMN HOT!!!

[everybodywants2rule]

please explain?

[undala]

incluso Leona Lewis le da mil vueltas a esta chica en factor x cantando without you

[undala]

comparada con Mariah, esta version es malissima

[poetic1993]

es la mejor

[bjork8606]

Carrie Underwood Still the Best American Idol Ever!

[SugarKatie]

i feel she yells more than sings. not my fave.. this song is not what a strong woman would sing, so i prefer leona's version. vulnerable yet hit all the right notes

[Mongoose015]

that's the stupidest comment i've ever heard - "this song is not what a strong woman should sing" - ummm have you even HEARD the origional? i guess not..

[Loveisme09]

I love Kelly Clarkson

[PofMovie]

Her voice is so stunning when she reaches low notes..!! Amazing girl..

[CharlieWarlie16]

sheees Amazing!

[RITK311]

shes so hot!!

[melscrum]

The video is out of synch.

[Hewhosucksatviolin]

Are you kidding me? Leona Lewis' voice doesn't fit the beginning (its too low for her)...although her later parts are good but I personally think overall, Kelly Clarkson's better throughout the whole song.

[AIFanPA]

I agree that Leona's voice doesnt fit well in the beginning.Personally I prefer Kelly's version

[simvolt13]

I agree with you! There is something quite not fiting in Kelly's version although she did a good interpretation of it. Leona's version has more emotion in it

[rjangel80]

have you even heard of the original version of this song? If you have, you would not make a comment like that

[xkristyee]

lmao shes not lip synching. its just the vid.

[muzicrox9]

YOU GOT THAT RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[disneyprincess777]

i love this!

she sounds amazing!

anyone who says its crap, you trying singing this live

[chiggy74]

This was ABSOLUTE favorite song that she performed on AI!!! I also loved her hair like that!!! She looks really good like that. I really can't stand her hair being blonde now!!! I still love her though!!!

[Ninaki13th]

love her hair like that

[928sniper]

The encore the next night is WAAAAAY better. Simon says "singing like that is absolutely unbelieveable"

[brienisme]

d best!

[chorleygirl]

wow, im supprised, i didnt no she could sing like that!

[hallooooo1987]

ich liebe kelly sie ist die beste und keiner kommt an sie ran!!

[girlygirlma]

shess gooddd

[rcdbeast]

HAHAHAHAHAHAH

WTF??? SHE'S NOT LIP-SYNCING!!!

its american freakin idol, its LIVE TALENT! lol. im guessing you're referring to the fact that youtube screws up almost every video and throws off things like that?

[FanOfKelBel]

haha your obviously a c*nt =]

[texasinstrument82]

you dip shit. she's not lip-syncing.. It's just another screwed up video someone posted on youtube.

[ShadowKiller422]

hows she lip syncing?

[ch3v4li3r]

Nobody can be that bad at lip sync ! lol She would be like 10sec late on the actual song :D

[xXmissNobodyXx]

stop comparing them. besides, kelly can sing just anything. high, low notes. pop, rock, jazz... anything you want.

can you imagine leona singing any rock song?

she's amazing, but amazing at pop songs. and kelly is amazing in any kind of music.

[rustydevilll]

@xXmissNobodyXx

actually

Leona lewis does a very good led zeppelin.

she did it at the closing ceremony of the beijing olympics

[Funnypandalonies]

@xXmissNobodyXx that's why america picked her.

[kellysj2]

i love u kelly clarkson

[Ellesdeee]

she has grown so much though since american idol.

[Ninaki13th]

kelly's voise is more powerfull,but u can't compare them cos they are different.

they are both great

[rekywidjaja]

shes completly great singer..

its a fact..

[nenichuchi]

kelly clarkson beats leona lewis every time!!

[volley654321]

@nenichuchi i wouldn't say all that. your right, kelly is very talented, but you and i must have watched two different version's of when leona sang this song. because leona's version is easily up there with the mariah version. and i honestly can't say that about kelly's version. still a very good performance though.

[victor0711]

that's why she never sang i will always love you

[gabrielalulaa]

carly smithson version is wasy better but this one is awesome!

[o0ber]

Carly has a great voice but I was not a fan of her performance. I don't really think it was the right song for her, I know she likes to try to do the rock thing, but it just wasn't really amazing. I love Kelly's version though. Leona's was good but I couldn't hear her at all during the verses.

[kebin65]

I really like Carly's version. I thought the judges totally underrated it. But I feel Kelly's is a whole lot better.

[gabrielalulaa]

sorry thats just my opinion Lol!

[kelthje]

kelly clarkson is the best

[SunnyDLock]

she's much better than leona! Admit it Simon!!

[Samaz05]

Kelly Clarkson is the best.

[s3ns3sfail3d]

best vocal on AI since it started.

[osahju914]

not this one, her second rendition was SCORES better!  I hate this vocal, but i love her second try with Without You

[3l3TTra]

totally agree!!

[mjcewl1284]

All it took in season 1 for me to change my mind about Kelly Clarkson was this round. Amazing.

[MinxDakoda]

Go kelly

[itsmeanthony]

couldnt agree more

[AllyisHyper]

love the vocals!!

[Alleexandra]

This was sick, but I like Leona's version better though

[stitchcastle]

check out the results show version, it blows this and Leona's version out of the water

[cbotten106]

Another over the top performance complements of "Yellie" Clarkson. Some of Kellie's AI1 performances, such as Stuff Like That There, are truly great but this one was simply a mess, I feel sorry for the people who see this as being so wonderful.

[xxsingerstar]

wow kelly's version kills carly smithsons! haha.

[littlebutterfly19]

I love Kelly also but so disappointed with her version of Without You. I didn't enjoy this one at all. My favorites of hers are

You're All I Need To Get By and The Trouble With Love Is and oh yes....the best is Reba and Kelly singing duet to Does He Love You.

Bravo!

[qg6ff]

i know it and i hate to get negatives on this,, and don't get me wrong i love her, but this really... was pitchy. so i don't get it

[xxsingerstar]

it was one of the best performances ever on idol actually.

[qg6ff]

i know, maybe then it was, i'm sure she'd sing it better now. back then the show i think was different, because if you watch the contestants then compared to now, now they sing so much better. Kimberley Caldwell, Carmen, didn't they come in like 7th or 6th? if they sang that way now i don't htink they'd have much of a shot of going that far

[xxsingerstar]

as a vocalist myself, this is one of the best PERFORMANCES, as well as VOCAL performances on all seven seasons of idol. Kelly was probably the best vocalist, and Katharine McPhee is the only contestant that has come close to her.Kelly would've won no matter which season you dropped her into. She has the X Factor, you want to keep watching her perform.

[qg6ff]

eh, idk about that... i understand where you're coming from, but i'm saying OTHER people like carmen, nikki, NEVER would have made it that far. but hey that's cool i LOVE katharine mcphee

[xxsingerstar]

yeah you're definitely right about them two, but Justin Guarini, Tamyra Gray, and Kelly would still be the best among the competition, even this season.

[qg6ff]

yeah i know i agree.. but for example a good one is kimberley locke made it much further i think than she would have made on any other season. don't get me wrong there either, but back then i don't think she was amazing, but now she is, and she looks great. these people are lucky to have been around then, because then it was more average

[xxsingerstar]

yeah i totally agree about kimberly locke as well as ruben

[Jovanna1992]

But this video is so lame! =( I am so dissapointed.

[Jovanna1992]

I haven't heard other versions of this song, exept offcourse Mariah's, but i love this song no matter who sings it. I am a fan of Kelly, i love her songs, she has one of the most beautiful voices i have ever heard. I love her music! You go Kelly! =)

[liesel1980]

one word: phenomenal!!!

[silencemoon]

the image and the sound don't mach ¬¬U

[ghjzdejjdt]

yes,and I like leonas voice much more

[sandrinha1982]

Best action on Kelly

[SmartieGurl]

I love Mariah Carey's version so much, but after hearing Kelly's again, hers is pretty good.

[gomting2]

i'm a big fan of Kelly and i love her voice so much!!!!

[piperronson]

kelly and leona are both great singers-with completley different voices!!!

[ghjzdejjdt]

leona lewis version is great ,too and yes,I think maybe it is a little bit better than kellys

[sandrinha1982]

=)The voice is smoother

[laurenmariemc]

she sings like a black person greattttt

[kralle7611]

get over the black/white shit.

[laurenmariemc]

im not bein racist im sayin that coz black people are great singers

[sippifan]

wow, leona lewis' version is sooo much better ;)

[martunia1414]

are you crazy??

[betts3985]

i'm not a fan of kelly clarkson but she can really sing!

[PaigeMatthews63]

luv kelly, but this video quality is really bad. the audio is really off. it doesn't match up with the video.

[s0methingrare]

Great voice.