Gab & Dad review Sherlock Holmes

[ChrisStuckmann]

He has a "keen mustache" God I love your Dad. I miss this camera set up!

[GabnDad]

@ChrisStuckmann I know, I miss it too... I just got freaked over the copyright issue, thus the less "keen" logo set we use now.

[MikeBannShow]

the film wasent great but it was very entertaining and I think Downy should have gotten an oscar nomination

[MikeBannShow]

the film wasent great but it was very entertaining and I think Downy should have gotten an oscar nomination

[Dexxxtroyer]

now I cant wait to see this movie. have you rated "The Lovely Bones" movie? I loved it.

[DarrylCross]

Excellent review. I agree with the Dad (for lack of another name to call him) that this is the Sherlock as written by Arthur Conan Doyle. It was refreshing to see more of his character fleshed out the typical two-dimensional deer stalker cap and pipe, with magnifying glass version of Holmes that is so often seen nowadays.

I absolutely loved this movie.

[redtailedkite]

Great review!!! I thought the lead characters were wrong!!

I'm a fan of the books!! lol Sherlock Holmes was a gentleman

and professional at all times and Dr. Watson was older and

a war veteran!! I'm surprised I liked the movie!! I still prefer

Basil Rathbone!! lol Keep up the great work!!

[dsclubhouse1]

great review

I really enjoyed this film

it was well done

[Baronesslace]

Actor's Robert Downey Jr./HOLMES and Jude Law/WATSON done an splendidly exciting protrayal of the fame duo Crime Investigators: I like their "true" intake of the characters for the Icon writter Sir Conan Doyle Classic books finally fits to the roles that Prod/Director Guy Richie tried to stay true with. The only thing I found out of step is HOLMES Lab/I don't think his lab would be out of place/disarray...'cause everything to him must be in order. Anyway, great review GAB & DAD, your awesome!

[rawkfist208]

Enjoyed your guys review! And THANK YOU for talking about the faithfulness to the source material!! I'm getting really annoyed in saying this Sherlock Holmes is nothing how Sherlock Holmes should be! It totally is! Anyways, I liked your guys video, keep it up! =)

[danielrobertwright]

I loved the movie, and adding brad pitt to that is making me feel like iv'e died and gone to movie heaven, hes amazing/ Fight club is one of the best movies of all time in my opinion

[Sara875]

I honestly thought the movie was amazing - a bit too long- but the overall story and casting was very good :D

I really liked listening to your review on the movie, but I do have one quick question. At the end of your review, you mentioned Brad Pitt as Moriarty (I think I spelt his name wrong XD ), and I was just wondering where you heard that from?

I'm just wondering because I'm already excited and becoming impatient for the 2nd movie and I was curious who was going to be casted as Moriarty.

[GabnDad]

Thanks! I read a lot about movie news, and have read the Pitt thing mentioned by several sources. Guy Ritchie loves Pitt, and intentionally didn't reveal the Moriarty actor in #1 so that hopefully he can start using Pitt in #2! If you Google Holmes/Pitt/Moriarity/Ritchie, you should find something about it. ;)

[TomChatalbash]

Glad you enjoyed it guys. I thought it was a great deal of fun. You guys have great chemistry in front of the camera btw. I wish my dad would want to do that sort of thing. Bastard lol. Great review. Check out my review when you get the chance.

[GabnDad]

Of course I checked yours out, almost right away! ;) The Strong voice suits you; I'd like to try it so people will listen to me...

[AfterTheseWessages]

Yay our Sherlock Holmes Review is Fiiiinally done, i hop you guys enjoy!!!!

[MrHollick]

I loved this movie! it was great fun! I just uploaded my review as well :)

[rawm2000]

Good review

[moviegoinggamer]

Great Review Guys! I'm supposed to be seeing this on Christmas Day.

[christopherSmac]

I'm looking forward to seeing Sherlock Holmes myself. Always loved Robert Downey Jr.'s work. And Guy Ritchie is a great filmmaker. Lock, Stock, & 2 Smoking Barrels, Snatch, and Revolver are very entertaining movies from the man. (Haven't seen Rock N'Rolla yet) Very nice to see a Ritchie film getting some big screen love.

Great review as always Gab and Phil!

[MatthewLedZepfan]

Great review as always but....why oh why did you have to spoil the cameo? Its not that big of a deal but im just kind of disappointed

[GabnDad]

I know - that was a booboo!!! Hopefully fans are expecting to see M******* anyway, and won't be too mad at us...! ;)

[GabnDad]

Ok - I've added a Spoiler Warning.

[SpecialMark]

Excellent review I can't  wait to see the movie . congrats on scoring the screening pass. Love your guys stuff

[SpecialMark]

How did you guys get to see it early?

[GabnDad]

Won a screening pass.

[jasminaz02]

Great Review,everyone seems to be so excited about this film, but all i can think about at the moment is AVATAR =]

by the way,have you thought of giving the films you review a star rating,for example like 3.5/5?i think it will make a nice conclusion to you review

[dsclubhouse1]

cool review

can't wait for this film

[AfterTheseWessages]

Great Job u Too, if it was my show and i just saw Sherlock Holmes i'd Toooootally put Dad in a Sherlock Holmes get up and he'd have to solve a case, itd be well.... Just magical lol, good job guy go watch my AVATAR review id love to hear what u think!

[GabnDad]

Dad actually does have one of those spiffy hats - just couldn't find it; it's from ye olden days...!

[MybasementReviews]

Good review! Just wondering, how long was this movie? I need to know if I can convince my parents to go to before we go out of town after christmas..lol

[GabnDad]

I'd say it's 2 hrs. easy.

[GorTheMovieGod]

Glad to hear its good, been waiting for this one for sometime now.

[Dreadpirate46]

Great review! I'm a little up in the air about Robert Downey, Jr. as Sherlock. I think a true British actor would have been more suitable - namely Daniel Craig. I'll still give a chance when it comes to dvd cause I like Sherlock Holmes.

One observation - I wonder why did they just call it Sherlock Holmes and not the actual case name. What's the sequel going to be - Sherlock Holmes 2? heh

[QuickMovieReviews]

I'm looking forward to this seeing it Friday! Good job guys!

[orionx42]

Great Review! I'm a huge fan of Guy Ritchie's movies not to mention Jude Law. I really hope to catch this one after the holidays craziness is over.

Hey now... whats with the Iron Man bashing? Not a fan of the comics :P

[augcastillo]

Just curious why you don't have a site for your reviews and such.... :)

[GabnDad]

We're trying to cobble one together - just keep getting sidetracked. ;)

[RullyisJRM]

A rating system would be fantastic! I hope you guys somehow figure out how to implement one without it being too distracting. Maybe one similar to Roger Ebert? He uses stars -- out of 4 to be exact.

A rating system isn't necessary for you guys, I don't think, but it could be a neat idea. :) I support your choice 100%.