Currently reading all of the extant Sophocles for fun and this is the first production of a play I've watched since starting. The lines that popped out in reading are just as vivid in the live performance, and a few I didn't pickup on reading I find appreciation aloud. Glad to see students still cram to get some semblance of Sophocles!
MILLENNIUM SHAKESPEARE art exhibition ... M.S.A.E. during the Olympics 2012 - Artists from around the world, Japan, England, France, Ukraine, Russia, Turkey, Iran, USA, and many many more....Michael J Stewart creator and Visionary of Millennium Shakespeare began his series of Books for children in 1998....to introduce Shakespeare to a young audience...Come and see the Amazing Art Exhibition....click on 2012UKOlympics
After watching this, my main criticism is that Creon is too vicious. In the play he is certainly prideful, and stubborn, and enjoys being in power--but this version makes him cartoonishly villainous. The totalitarian imagery may be engaging for 20th-century audiences but is distracting from the actual substance of the play. Creon and Antigone seem more evenly matched in Sophocles: the conflict is not between what is ("obviously") right and what a raging tyrant decrees, but between
family and political obligation. Each party of course reads the conflict according to his or her own priorities. Creon does deserve the criticism he gets from other characters, but the reader is left in no less doubt about Antigone's self-aggrandizement, morbidity, and disregard for her sister.
@SCWguqin I agree. This interpretation clearly favoured Antigone. It was consistent throughout though. I think a different interpretation- the one you are proposing- is also valid.
As seen in this production, the director clearly doesn't leave Antigone's cruelty towards Ismene unnoticed. But, he portrays it as an act: Antigone doesn't really despise Ismene, as by the time she has been condemned Ismene has found the courage to also stand against Creon and his unjust decree, and be ready to face the consequences herself. In my opinion, Antigone is satisfied by her sister's newly acquired strength
and now tries to PROTECT her ("My death is enough - you must live").
There are many themes in Antigone, but in my opinion the main are three: the measure of human wisdom to tell right from wrong, the strength to do what's right and the readiness to do it in due time.
That's the way the play is named after Antigone: she can tell right from wrong, she's strong enough to do the right thing and she knows when it's time to do it.
Ismene can also tell right from wrong, but she's not strong enough to do what's right, and when she is, it's too late.
Creon on the other hand, like Antigone, is a character of action. He acts immediately, but is betrayed by terrible judgement. When he realizes what the right thing to do is, he doesn't hesitate to do it... but by then it's also too late.
(A final thought) By our modern sensitivity, I think the play could easily be named after Creon instead of Antigone
- he is, actually, the most tragic of all the characters in the play: a man who is at first firm in his cruel orders, but by the end of the story lies broken and with bitter remorse, useful only to the watchful eye, but not at all to himself.
Thanks so much for this series of videos!
I wish the BBC productions of the Theban plays would one day be released on dvd.
@Ke1raak Because, in certain ways, he is. It says it, like, a million times in the script. "Now you're talking like someone far too young. Don't you realize that?" -Haeman
Thank you so much for posting. Excellent version. I'm reading the play right now for my Literature class in college and these videos have helped me a lot.
I loved this production when I first saw it but they've not shown it on tv since then. I thought the riot police costumes of the guards was interesting given that this was done during the eighties, the era of Thatcherism, miners' strikes, inner city riots etc. Juliet Stevenson was great. I would recommend looking at the Jean Anouilh version with Genevieve Bujold which is also excellent. It's much more sympathetic to Creon's position.
THIS HELPED ME SO MUCH IM READY FOR CLASSS TOMROW. THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH!!! WHO EVER POSTED THIS YOUR AWSOME!!! i like NEVER comment youtube videos but i had to thank you this time:))
DIE CREON DIE!
cocoakiwi1 1 month ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
so friggin awesome
TheBeardedThinker 1 month ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
heh. Bernard Hill.
lothlorien182 2 months ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
tnx
TheKravojed 2 months ago
"Today it has happened here, with our own eyes, we have seen an old man, through suffering, become wise"
Daroga1 3 months ago
thnkx 4 posting tho :)
30Zoidberg 3 months ago
thank fuck its over. worst thing i have ever seen. made my head hurt and ears ache.
30Zoidberg 3 months ago
Sublime.
6netfire 4 months ago
Love the fact that the views decrease with each part of this play....
BeeneyBoy3 4 months ago
Thank you for putting this up! This has helped me a huge amount, Philosophy students, holla! :)
Boofie19 4 months ago
WHEN WILL THIS END
ameeliavirginia 4 months ago
thanks man, helped a lot on my test.
Reloaded622 4 months ago
Comment removed
speedx50 4 months ago
thank you for the play so it all
it really helped me to understand the story
0muslim4ever0 4 months ago
This helped me understand the play so much more!!!!!!!! Thank you!!!!! :D
conieo96 6 months ago
Creon is a dumbass motherfucker.
Horicert 6 months ago
@Horicert You're getting Creon confused with Oedipus.
koenan1 4 months ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
Currently reading all of the extant Sophocles for fun and this is the first production of a play I've watched since starting. The lines that popped out in reading are just as vivid in the live performance, and a few I didn't pickup on reading I find appreciation aloud. Glad to see students still cram to get some semblance of Sophocles!
sftommy01 7 months ago
What about Ismene?
itay3bg 11 months ago
@itay3bg She lives, and presumably becomes queen one day, as Creon's wife and children are dead.
Elanel 10 months ago
Thank god I'm done watching this shit, now I have to write a 6 page paper. It's due in 6 hours -____________-
volcomstonne21 11 months ago
@volcomstonne21 Tch...
HighPriestFuneral 5 months ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
this city's royalties are all sorts of fucked up
BillyWingFTW 11 months ago
thumbs up if this is gay homework or for connections academy that you have to do :/
yourmomlovesmehard 11 months ago 2
@yourmomlovesmehard Pathetic...
HighPriestFuneral 5 months ago in playlist Antigone by Sophocles (1984 TV) complete in 11 parts
thank god its over but yea, this is the bible to this play. id b lost without it
peasrgood666 1 year ago
homework sorted :)
cronhole 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
MILLENNIUM SHAKESPEARE art exhibition ... M.S.A.E. during the Olympics 2012 - Artists from around the world, Japan, England, France, Ukraine, Russia, Turkey, Iran, USA, and many many more....Michael J Stewart creator and Visionary of Millennium Shakespeare began his series of Books for children in 1998....to introduce Shakespeare to a young audience...Come and see the Amazing Art Exhibition....click on 2012UKOlympics
2012UKOlympics 1 year ago
Absolutely AMAZING!!!
HarleyQuinzelle 1 year ago
Thanx for posting this video it was extremely useful and it has given me a deeper understanding of what the whole thing is all about :)
sinister1000 1 year ago
HI MR LAPLANTE!!!!!
bobcatsrock69 1 year ago
THANKS SO MUCH!
got an exam on Antigone tomorrow, this was great confimration of my revision, cheers matey :)))
tincfest 1 year ago
thanks to the video, now I can read the book for more understanding
yhemysun 1 year ago 2
After watching this, my main criticism is that Creon is too vicious. In the play he is certainly prideful, and stubborn, and enjoys being in power--but this version makes him cartoonishly villainous. The totalitarian imagery may be engaging for 20th-century audiences but is distracting from the actual substance of the play. Creon and Antigone seem more evenly matched in Sophocles: the conflict is not between what is ("obviously") right and what a raging tyrant decrees, but between
SCWguqin 2 years ago 4
family and political obligation. Each party of course reads the conflict according to his or her own priorities. Creon does deserve the criticism he gets from other characters, but the reader is left in no less doubt about Antigone's self-aggrandizement, morbidity, and disregard for her sister.
SCWguqin 2 years ago
@SCWguqin I agree. This interpretation clearly favoured Antigone. It was consistent throughout though. I think a different interpretation- the one you are proposing- is also valid.
123arry321 4 months ago
@SCWguqin
Your view is interesting, but I beg to differ.
As seen in this production, the director clearly doesn't leave Antigone's cruelty towards Ismene unnoticed. But, he portrays it as an act: Antigone doesn't really despise Ismene, as by the time she has been condemned Ismene has found the courage to also stand against Creon and his unjust decree, and be ready to face the consequences herself. In my opinion, Antigone is satisfied by her sister's newly acquired strength
deargdoomster 4 months ago
@SCWguqin
and now tries to PROTECT her ("My death is enough - you must live").
There are many themes in Antigone, but in my opinion the main are three: the measure of human wisdom to tell right from wrong, the strength to do what's right and the readiness to do it in due time.
That's the way the play is named after Antigone: she can tell right from wrong, she's strong enough to do the right thing and she knows when it's time to do it.
deargdoomster 4 months ago
@SCWguqin
Ismene can also tell right from wrong, but she's not strong enough to do what's right, and when she is, it's too late.
Creon on the other hand, like Antigone, is a character of action. He acts immediately, but is betrayed by terrible judgement. When he realizes what the right thing to do is, he doesn't hesitate to do it... but by then it's also too late.
(A final thought) By our modern sensitivity, I think the play could easily be named after Creon instead of Antigone
deargdoomster 4 months ago
@SCWguqin
- he is, actually, the most tragic of all the characters in the play: a man who is at first firm in his cruel orders, but by the end of the story lies broken and with bitter remorse, useful only to the watchful eye, but not at all to himself.
Thanks so much for this series of videos!
I wish the BBC productions of the Theban plays would one day be released on dvd.
deargdoomster 4 months ago
of course it's cartoonish... the actor has interpreted creon as a childish figure
Ke1raak 2 years ago
@Ke1raak Because, in certain ways, he is. It says it, like, a million times in the script. "Now you're talking like someone far too young. Don't you realize that?" -Haeman
Elanel 10 months ago
thanx :)
MagentaSodaPop 2 years ago
Thanks for posting this, I'm reading it for my humanities class and this helped a lot
ena1490 2 years ago 3
I had to read Antigone for my Western Civ class. thanx for posting it helped alot :)
jazzbabe55 2 years ago 3
@jazzbabe55 how does Antigone in any way represent a basis for the study of Western Civ?
Ke1raak 2 years ago
i have no idea but it was one of the assigned readings i had to do in the class.
jazzbabe55 2 years ago
@Ke1raak a woman stands up to a man, its similar to the woman's rights movements in the united states
Tienzu1 4 months ago
Comment removed
Tienzu1 4 months ago
@Ke1raak are u being rhetorical? concepts such as statehood, religion, duty to the state, tyrancy v democracy etc etc....
123arry321 4 months ago
Thank you so much for posting. Excellent version. I'm reading the play right now for my Literature class in college and these videos have helped me a lot.
mel577 2 years ago 28
Comment removed
Molislily 2 years ago
I loved this production when I first saw it but they've not shown it on tv since then. I thought the riot police costumes of the guards was interesting given that this was done during the eighties, the era of Thatcherism, miners' strikes, inner city riots etc. Juliet Stevenson was great. I would recommend looking at the Jean Anouilh version with Genevieve Bujold which is also excellent. It's much more sympathetic to Creon's position.
TheTubeMouse 2 years ago
Catharsis
pyromohanzed 2 years ago
thanks.
2009lovestory 2 years ago 2
THIS HELPED ME SO MUCH IM READY FOR CLASSS TOMROW. THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH!!! WHO EVER POSTED THIS YOUR AWSOME!!! i like NEVER comment youtube videos but i had to thank you this time:))
MizzDamnhot 2 years ago 70
@MizzDamnhot BALLZANDREALLYBIGCUCUMBERONYOURFACEWITHASLICEOFLEMON.PAPERCLIPSUPYOURNOSEANDANAPPLEINYOUREAR.
00Avenger17 1 year ago
@MizzDamnhot i know right! i was thinking the same thing. great post!
proberson07 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
finally over this fuckin movie
annchovies 2 years ago
that duo at 3:42 i noticed, that their voice levels are uneven, the guy on the right was alot higher. It was kind of funny.
Grayfox82 2 years ago
at 3:35 tell me the guy on the left doesn't look like Bill Murray
Thanks
Anzelone18 2 years ago
Thanks for posting - I loved it!
jcucor 2 years ago 2
Thank you so so so much for this!!!
yessyesyes 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that sucks in english!!
pepe4rock 3 years ago
ty so much XD
azcatrac 3 years ago 2
by no doubt great tredigies by sophocles... thanks!
moviefan005 3 years ago 2
Thank you for videos!!!!!!!!
myfairlady83 3 years ago
Great play. Thanks for posting it. As I watch, I cannot help but think of our modern era. Hauntingly timeless work.
nuscholar1979 3 years ago 4
Great stuff. Thanks very much indeed *****
starcloudz 3 years ago
Thank you so much for these videos. I had seen all three plays on TV back then and I could never forget how wonderful they were.
I always hoped I could see them again...
Thank you!
thalassaouranos 3 years ago 2