Its such a darn shame that Judy Garland the singer could not be separated from Judy Garland the actress,this film proves shes just not some MGM technicolor songbird girl next door,that she could act, had raw emotion,its a shame and a big disappointment that she did not win an Oscar for this but in the end she really one the Oscar not Grace Kelly cause this role is remembered and this film is so iconic,Judy is such an inspiration to so many people including me.
@thx11q38z I know right the only other female who I think that measures up to her Barbra there is a short list of icons left Judy,Barbra etc. I wish we had talent like this nowadays,it does not exist anymore thank God for Barbra and Judy's offspring Liza.
@theproudsquirrel okay, okay she was always brilliant but I would definitely say that some stages were a little better than others and that's what I meant.
@OliviaMcShaneMusic yup epic scene , it reminds of the scene in Dreamgirls when Jennifer Hudson sings and I am telling you I am not going, this scene gives me goosebumps its like Jennifer Hudson's scene this has got to be one the most underrated Garland songs. Judy knew how to phrase songs ,very underrated and overlooked song.
This is amazing. I don't care what anyone says, no one else can sing this song as great as Judy did. Thank God we have her to remember what talent is!
@kittystolemycookie94 No one can sing this song ANYWHERE NEAR as good as Judy - here is a real singer with a voice that makes these so called divas of today sound like screaming bitches.
This is the best scene of the entire movie. Pure Judy. She was one of the great voices of that generation because she felt every note she sang. I could have been that music got her through a lot of tough times.
Wow oh wow Judy Garland thank you for all the memories. I love her so much shes incredible , I know that story of how she felt that the only film she ever felt beautiful in was meet me in st.louis I have to beg to differ cause Judy was in my opinion her most beautiful here truly beautiful this a star is born is my fave of hers. Wow the oscars snubbed her of an oscar for this performance, Judy was one of a kind.
@simoncusonnet This and over the rainbow you know its a shame that she is more known for Meet me in st.louis than her perfomance here in a Star is born ,my favorite movie of hers has got to be this performance wise, Grace Kelly did not deserve that oscar Judy did,her voice was so warm in this song always warm and vulnerable. Wow this is the best a star is born out of the three. goosebumps I get hearing this song.
I agree with all the previous posters--this is what a true talent looks, feels, and sounds like ! This was the performance that should have gotten her the Oscar ! In this film, she sings, she dances, she jokes, she cries ! She does it all ! She was a star ever since she was a child, but, this film truly makes her an iconic superstar for the ages ! Her legend lives on and so does her talent and voice !
beautiful woman, beautiful song, beautiful voice, i can only aspire to be as good as she is, but Im trying to keep music classy (single handedly by the looks of people like lady gaga and cheryl cole)!
Have loved this lady's control, skill and just pure presence since my mum first played Meet Me In St Louis to me as a babe in arms. You do not get better then Judy. RIP you beautiful legend.
Who in their right mind would call Judy Garland fat or ugly? Well they forced her to use diet pills and thats how she got addicted to pills. R.I.P. Judy you will always be in my heart and over the rainbow.
they shot this scene about 6 different times, with different lighting and with different costumes/sets coz they wernt happy with how it came out! this was their final go at it, sometime toward the end of shooting! so glad they chose this style....its perfect....moody, slightly sombre and not to flashy so that you get distracted from Judy's AMAZING voice :D pure class every tme!
This song and this part of film "A star is born" appeared in film "P.S. I love you" so maybe more people will appreciate Judy Garland and more people will get know about her.
I love Judy she is amazing, but it is a little unfair to say there is no talent like this today. Idina Menzel is amazing, you have male's like Alfie Boe and John Owen Jones. These are amazing performers. Like seriously amazing, I am also a huge Barbra Streisand fan. Oh and we cannot forget the goddess that is Miss Celine Dion!
THIS is what actual talent looks like. No mega-bands, no half-naked dancing boys, no fireworks, no pyrotechnics, no see-through outfits, no bizarre outfits. Just a few instruments, low lighting, and a voice that makes all of today's 'singers' look like no-talent hacks.
Today's singers need to look and listen at the master and learn how it's all done. Judy Garland had REAL talent and didn't need to hide behind any kind of façade that today's singers do. But what I can't believe and am really shocked at is that the public is buying these "so-called" singers albums and paying money to go see them lip-synch to a song from their album or with them using autotune--it's ridiculous! All Judy needed was a microphone and with that the magic began.
@PeterFormaini Could not agree more!! One of the greatest singers of the 20thc and never so fantastic as in this classic, no current day popular singer would have a chance in hell competing with this!!!!!!!!
@PeterFormaini But really, just imagine how much better this video would have been if they had tossed in some half-naked dancing boys and pyrotechnics.
@PeterFormaini Oh yeah tuff guy? Gonna come over and slap me silly, liver lips? Look, jerky, me and my troupe of half-naked dancing boys are gonna get all medieval on your ass and we'll show you what it's like!
I agree 100%! Judy belonged in an era where singers had talent! She belonged in an era where singers knew how to sing, how to deliver and sell a song, how to interpret a song, and it was a time when singers didn't need to write their own music (unlike today where it's made such a big deal) because within this golden age of songwriting we had outstanding songwriters like Harold Arlen, Rodgers & Hart, Cole Porter, Johnny Mercer, the Gershwins, Irving Berlin, and many many others.
hands down my favorite Harold Arlen song, BUT my fave song in probably one of the best movies ever. Now for the love of... let's release this movie with no weird takeouts of photo clips. smooth and seamless would be good. this movie is IT!
That is EXACTLY the problem with your point of view. Why do you have to look at COMMERCIAL artists when there are so many others outside the mainstream spotlight who are more about substance than flash. And they are damned excellent. Get off the beaten path and especially the commercial artists.
I consider myself an OK karaoke singer, not brilliant. I'd have a go at most songs. Over The Rainbow being one example, but not this. I can't follow the changes of mood and melody, even though the tempo is constant. Judy Garland doesn't so much sing it, as grab it and run off with it, and not letting anyone else get a look in.
Oh yeah EVERYTHING sucks now, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Why can't people just enjoy talent old AND new. There is actually a lot out there now if you just get off your ass and look for it. Check out any old performer on YouTube and you get somebody saying that talent is dead. Get a grip and look for it.
@unclebobunclebob You're right when you say that as the generations continue the arts keep changing and it has continuously gotten more and more "pop", however there WAS a time (this song being a wonderful example) where popular artists relied on their MAGNIFICENT talent, unlike now where they rely on "image" and 'sexiness". There are talented people today, that's for sure. But too much has been lost in order to make things more and more commercial.
Judy at her finest..one of the most tragic love stories on film..mason and garland are spellbinding..it breaks your heart to see this man fall apart and see her fall apart watching him do it...
Today's phony, contrived "singers" are not worthy to even lick a small piece of ground upon which this woman walked for even the smallest minute of her life.
@Vengeance509 Oh yeah EVERYTHING sucks now, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Why can't people just enjoy talent old AND new. There is actually a lot out there now if you just get off your ass and look for it. Check out any old performer on YouTube and you get somebody saying that talent is dead. Get a grip and look for it.
Judy sets the standard, there's no doubt about it. But listen to Diana Krall -- she's awesome and is 'current.' All is not lost. She does such beautiful stuff.
It's a fucking shame Hollywood ruined her. She was gorgeous and had to deal with pricks telling her she was too big for show business. Such talent wasted.
@BALLYJUNKIE Absolutely. And the amazing thing is that even as she is singing at FULL VOICE, she is still in COMPLETE CONTROL of her voice. Who else can do that???
@RImusclebear i agree that today doesnt have any talent! haha but britney is actually an exception...her producers make her sing in a "baby" high pitched voice....her real voice is quite deep and classical kinda like judy...listen to this song of britney's real voice: /watch?v=iwJgrng2DNk and it was recorded in 2007♥
Academy Awards doesn't mean anything. She can't take it with her after death, but she will always be remembered for her talents in musicals, films and stage.
@Yennerf i am 14 years old, and to be honest, i love judy and inspire her and this era so much, if only i was around when she was... i love the wizard of oz, + any musical she may have been in, what a fantastically beautiful woman she was!
I get goosebumps every time I listen to this. She put so much emotion into all of her songs and it just adds to her outstanding vocal abilities. Bravo!
@jcrobso seen her do that and thought she over-acted too much, with her facial expression, too much of the " Sylvia Young School" method, methinks. Compare the vocal talents and you'll see that Judy is MILES better.
And look! The entire song is done in one take...beautifully set-up, lit and shot, perfectly animated by Garland, not one false move.Incredible!(By contrast, notice how in "Chicago" the editing was dumbed-down to the MTV mentality that rules, and you can''t quite get a grip on any of the numbers, so chopping are they). Pity.
@eldiran2 Agree with you about the Chicago numbers, eidiran, that you can't get a grip on any of them. Good description. By contrast, this great number from "A Star is Born."
@eldiran2 i would have to say i disagree with you. the time in film was different and i am in love with judy garland she is absolutely fabulous. but i love the way chicago was directed because it was directed that way for a purpose not to chop things up.
Its such a darn shame that Judy Garland the singer could not be separated from Judy Garland the actress,this film proves shes just not some MGM technicolor songbird girl next door,that she could act, had raw emotion,its a shame and a big disappointment that she did not win an Oscar for this but in the end she really one the Oscar not Grace Kelly cause this role is remembered and this film is so iconic,Judy is such an inspiration to so many people including me.
cinderelmo 17 hours ago
This is my favorite scene in the entire movie.
2legit64 2 days ago
To feel what she felt.. I hear it and feel it now.. and at times when I sing too..
EvanMancuso 3 days ago
There is and was no one like her. Maybe Barbara but they are different and ther is no one like Barbara. They had and have " IT" .
thx11q38z 6 days ago
@thx11q38z It's Barbra
gilliamjf 1 day ago
@thx11q38z I know right the only other female who I think that measures up to her Barbra there is a short list of icons left Judy,Barbra etc. I wish we had talent like this nowadays,it does not exist anymore thank God for Barbra and Judy's offspring Liza.
cinderelmo 16 hours ago
So beautiful, it makes me cry.
yotidouche 1 week ago
@theproudsquirrel okay, okay she was always brilliant but I would definitely say that some stages were a little better than others and that's what I meant.
ladyavaleigh 2 weeks ago
She had something that was absolutely her own. Nobody today sings a song like this anymore IMO. She was brilliant at one point.
ladyavaleigh 2 weeks ago 2
@ladyavaleigh she was brilliant 'at one point'? she was always brilliant, tut tut!
theproudsquirrel 2 weeks ago
That hair flip is the best part!!!! Love her!
Sweeney1407 2 weeks ago
Now thats singing; A true hollywood CLASSIC can watch over & over looks great in widescreen also!!
MAA8772 3 weeks ago
My God....they just dont make em like that no more.
ThePharaoho 3 weeks ago
Her best performance of a song, next to "Over The Rainbow". Her phrasing is absolutely amazing!!
bobbysoxer97 3 weeks ago 2
who are the idiots that disliked this??????????
siltor67 4 weeks ago
You know someone's a star when she doesn't need flashy costumes and bright lights to shine.
rosebudlilac 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos 9
What are the insturments used in this song? What's the dum dum dum one! She's lovely!
mishisoci 1 month ago
Comment removed
kctornado 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mishisoci It is the bass you hear.
kctornado 2 weeks ago
Singing starts at 1:10
ABsensation 1 month ago
22/1/1969 Muere la actriz y cantante Judy Garland
juliolazzagonzalez 1 month ago
How ironic that I was watching a documentary told in nothing but still pictures of Judy Garland's life when the man that got away left me?
TheCateDiva6 1 month ago
so beautiful yet so tragic :'(
HenrySkye1 1 month ago
epic scene
OliviaMcShaneMusic 1 month ago
@OliviaMcShaneMusic yup epic scene , it reminds of the scene in Dreamgirls when Jennifer Hudson sings and I am telling you I am not going, this scene gives me goosebumps its like Jennifer Hudson's scene this has got to be one the most underrated Garland songs. Judy knew how to phrase songs ,very underrated and overlooked song.
cinderelmo 1 month ago
i just imagine Rachel Berry singing this
dinamohwagdy 1 month ago
RIP Judy Garland. Amazing voice.
BeatriceBlake 1 month ago
Judy Garland is the DIVA!! What a voice and what a lady.
InDaSnatch 2 months ago 6
This is amazing. I don't care what anyone says, no one else can sing this song as great as Judy did. Thank God we have her to remember what talent is!
kittystolemycookie94 2 months ago 2
@kittystolemycookie94 No one can sing this song ANYWHERE NEAR as good as Judy - here is a real singer with a voice that makes these so called divas of today sound like screaming bitches.
TheVaughan5 1 month ago 2
This is the best scene of the entire movie. Pure Judy. She was one of the great voices of that generation because she felt every note she sang. I could have been that music got her through a lot of tough times.
2legit64 2 months ago 2
Very nice...
MarcusLeepapi 2 months ago
Wow oh wow Judy Garland thank you for all the memories. I love her so much shes incredible , I know that story of how she felt that the only film she ever felt beautiful in was meet me in st.louis I have to beg to differ cause Judy was in my opinion her most beautiful here truly beautiful this a star is born is my fave of hers. Wow the oscars snubbed her of an oscar for this performance, Judy was one of a kind.
cinderelmo 2 months ago
One of the best Harold Arlen compositions, especially created for Judy Garland..
simoncusonnet 2 months ago
@simoncusonnet This and over the rainbow you know its a shame that she is more known for Meet me in st.louis than her perfomance here in a Star is born ,my favorite movie of hers has got to be this performance wise, Grace Kelly did not deserve that oscar Judy did,her voice was so warm in this song always warm and vulnerable. Wow this is the best a star is born out of the three. goosebumps I get hearing this song.
cinderelmo 2 months ago
WTH does "the livelong night and day" mean??
wattever333 2 months ago
@wattever333 It means the how the days and night seem endless. Livelong=long, endless.
millers3888 2 months ago
One of the best movie songs ever!
sunsign902 3 months ago
Judy was an amazing performer and entertainer. Once in a life time!
nostalgic1953 3 months ago
This is the very reason why Garland is the ultimate entertainer. The best of the best
creolelady182 3 months ago 2
One of the greatest songs ever written for a movie:)
billyboylb 3 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@billyboylb
I will have to agree with your statement
creolelady182 3 months ago
Oscar or no Oscar, Judy Garland received a number of awards in her life, but she couldn't take any of it with her when she died.
saolili 3 months ago
I agree with all the previous posters--this is what a true talent looks, feels, and sounds like ! This was the performance that should have gotten her the Oscar ! In this film, she sings, she dances, she jokes, she cries ! She does it all ! She was a star ever since she was a child, but, this film truly makes her an iconic superstar for the ages ! Her legend lives on and so does her talent and voice !
Latwata719 3 months ago
you can't top this this is a song from top to bottom pure judy....uncut. no wonder she's still the icon she is
jeff57612 3 months ago
beautiful woman, beautiful song, beautiful voice, i can only aspire to be as good as she is, but Im trying to keep music classy (single handedly by the looks of people like lady gaga and cheryl cole)!
BEX9637 3 months ago
all ways reminds m of P.S I LOVE YOU
littlefellaz 4 months ago
Can't get enough of this song! :D
writerspen010 4 months ago
Judy was the best there ever was.!
MargeSteckler48 4 months ago 2
@MargeSteckler48
Where Frank was considered "the Voice" , I say she was the "Voice" of the female genre! They two were the voice I feel.
oohyllab 3 months ago
BEAUTIFUL..THANKS ..ERIK TIELMAN, FLORIDA..
tickyreal 4 months ago
i had a funny dream last night
it was a What If sorta dream
it was if judy garland had never taken drugs
and the dream was me hearing that she died in 2011 :O
we cod have had her dor 42 more yrs
if he damn mother didnt make her train so hard and them agencies forced fed her drugs
IrishFriendsFan 4 months ago
We tend to be overlooking those fabulous musicians that are backing Judy in this.
How I love the "big band" sound - just look what we have today - mostly junk!!
TheVaughan5 4 months ago
@TheVaughan5 Have a look at this version from The BBC Proms 2011. search - The Man That got Away - Caroline O'Connor PROMS 2011
The Orchestra is amazing
CDB8939 2 months ago
Why cant there be more like her?...
Lezty814 4 months ago
The GREATEST entertainer of the 20th century !!!!!!!!
MrS98VAC 4 months ago
Judy garland has been my role model since i was five. And this is why.
luv4dalittlemermaid 4 months ago
Have loved this lady's control, skill and just pure presence since my mum first played Meet Me In St Louis to me as a babe in arms. You do not get better then Judy. RIP you beautiful legend.
NickyLess 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
don't get me wrong i love Judy, but this version is almost stale in comparison to the live version in carnige hall ,lacks passion.
MrDACooling 5 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Judy Garland
Damn!!!!!!!!
raynarayskye 5 months ago
No-one sings this song like Judy Garland. Words just cannot do it justice.
hollybrook252 5 months ago
In two words, in honor of the late, great Frank Barone:
"Holy Crap"
or:
"She's Brilliant."
ianransom7 5 months ago
Judy and a Harold Arlen tune...a match made in heaven!! Great performance.
billyboylb 5 months ago
Dude, have anyone of you seen THIS video to A Star Is Born??? Friggin' UNBELIEVABLY BEAUTIFUL!!!
/watch?v=dtF8sKz5XBQ&feature=channel_video_title
BeautyBabyBridgett 5 months ago 3
Oh. My. Word. <3
JanieTownsendMusic 5 months ago
Classic song, classic arrangement classic Judy Garland.
hollybrook252 6 months ago
Breath taking, from start to finish
Buffy1966 6 months ago
this showcases her amazing talent beautifully!!!! one of a kind!!!
jacksonbrownepuppy 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
mmmm, she is perfection!
Have a look at my cover :)
jessica7993xx 6 months ago
P.S. I Love You.
tipofmytongue1024 6 months ago 29
She gives me goosebumps..No other female singer does that. x
AngieTheEnglishlady 6 months ago 30
I could watch her sing this all day. Love the movie. Greatness.
firewalk2126 6 months ago 2
I have chills. God. I love her.
JocelynPadilla25 6 months ago 2
take it from the top <3
krose4497 6 months ago
Wonderful irreplaceable Judy. Heartbreaking.
MsWendy17 6 months ago 2
Stunning.
chrisman737 6 months ago 2
Do you see a dislike bar? Ya me neither.
jensarno321 6 months ago
simply the best!!!!
smitwit81 6 months ago 2
indeed, as another user commented, sublime. there's no better word. this cannot be matched or eclipsed.
rsolash1 6 months ago
Who in their right mind would call Judy Garland fat or ugly? Well they forced her to use diet pills and thats how she got addicted to pills. R.I.P. Judy you will always be in my heart and over the rainbow.
01ozfan 6 months ago 2
A sublime genius in a simple blue dress. An electrifying performance for the ages.
WinehouseTearsDry 6 months ago 4
AHHHHMEN PETER!!!
GoToJeff 6 months ago
Absolutely magnificent !! There are no words for talent like this !!!
dflartist 7 months ago
they shot this scene about 6 different times, with different lighting and with different costumes/sets coz they wernt happy with how it came out! this was their final go at it, sometime toward the end of shooting! so glad they chose this style....its perfect....moody, slightly sombre and not to flashy so that you get distracted from Judy's AMAZING voice :D pure class every tme!
BriefEncounter1987 7 months ago 3
Judy Garland is the best singer! But she has seen a final ending. Her daughter is amazing, but she isn't as good as her :)
lilinelola 7 months ago
This song and this part of film "A star is born" appeared in film "P.S. I love you" so maybe more people will appreciate Judy Garland and more people will get know about her.
aleksandra14 7 months ago
@aleksandra14
That's how I found this song.....love it.
VirgiliaCoriolanus 7 months ago
How does this only have 241,642 views?
sabrinalouise1987 8 months ago
she sang the HELL outta that song
mannysts 8 months ago
This woman was and always will be an INCREDIBLE talent.
methodicalflash 8 months ago
ol school saucy!
yellowslacks 8 months ago
I love Judy she is amazing, but it is a little unfair to say there is no talent like this today. Idina Menzel is amazing, you have male's like Alfie Boe and John Owen Jones. These are amazing performers. Like seriously amazing, I am also a huge Barbra Streisand fan. Oh and we cannot forget the goddess that is Miss Celine Dion!
TescoShampoo 8 months ago
ah, a time when women didn't have to look like sluts to be considered beautiful....
CookieKitsune 8 months ago 41
She really should have won the oscar for this!
CapricornDavo 8 months ago
THIS is what actual talent looks like. No mega-bands, no half-naked dancing boys, no fireworks, no pyrotechnics, no see-through outfits, no bizarre outfits. Just a few instruments, low lighting, and a voice that makes all of today's 'singers' look like no-talent hacks.
PeterFormaini 8 months ago 109
@PeterFormaini
Today's singers need to look and listen at the master and learn how it's all done. Judy Garland had REAL talent and didn't need to hide behind any kind of façade that today's singers do. But what I can't believe and am really shocked at is that the public is buying these "so-called" singers albums and paying money to go see them lip-synch to a song from their album or with them using autotune--it's ridiculous! All Judy needed was a microphone and with that the magic began.
MusicLoverBrian1 8 months ago
@PeterFormaini I wouldn't say all of today's singers... at all.
elvickRULES 7 months ago
@PeterFormaini Well said!
MsWendy17 6 months ago
Respond to this video... Wonderful irreplaceable Judy. Heartbreaking.
MsWendy17 6 months ago
@PeterFormaini and no "wardrope malfunctions" LOL
squarebird58 6 months ago
@squarebird58 oopps..."wardrobe"
squarebird58 6 months ago
@PeterFormaini Could not agree more!! One of the greatest singers of the 20thc and never so fantastic as in this classic, no current day popular singer would have a chance in hell competing with this!!!!!!!!
TheVaughan5 4 months ago
@PeterFormaini But really, just imagine how much better this video would have been if they had tossed in some half-naked dancing boys and pyrotechnics.
7beers 4 months ago
@7beers Don;t make me come over there and slap you!! :D :D
PeterFormaini 4 months ago
@PeterFormaini Oh yeah tuff guy? Gonna come over and slap me silly, liver lips? Look, jerky, me and my troupe of half-naked dancing boys are gonna get all medieval on your ass and we'll show you what it's like!
7beers 4 months ago
@7beers you're my hero for this.
OhhCow 3 months ago
@PeterFormaini THANK YOU
gigicd86 3 months ago
@gigicd86 My pleasure! :D
PeterFormaini 3 months ago
Nothing is better!
MrThesheenster 8 months ago
she left us with so much awesomeness and her daughter Liza Minnelli sounds exactly like her.
kimpunkrock 8 months ago
The hair flip, perfect and now no prima donna would dare.
standingset 8 months ago
meh.
mistermagoo90 9 months ago
Judy Garland and Frank Sinatra...neither one the GREATEST VOICE. But nobody
could interpret a song with their FEELING! Thanks for sharing this.
haiyuj 9 months ago
@haiyuj so true, the singers back in their day actually new how to interpret songs unlike the singers of today in my opinion!
kimpunkrock 8 months ago
@kimpunkrock
I agree 100%! Judy belonged in an era where singers had talent! She belonged in an era where singers knew how to sing, how to deliver and sell a song, how to interpret a song, and it was a time when singers didn't need to write their own music (unlike today where it's made such a big deal) because within this golden age of songwriting we had outstanding songwriters like Harold Arlen, Rodgers & Hart, Cole Porter, Johnny Mercer, the Gershwins, Irving Berlin, and many many others.
MusicLoverBrian1 8 months ago 3
It doesn't get any better than THAT !! THE best song ever sung/ recorded on film ...Period !! xo
PeaceFan1 9 months ago
hands down my favorite Harold Arlen song, BUT my fave song in probably one of the best movies ever. Now for the love of... let's release this movie with no weird takeouts of photo clips. smooth and seamless would be good. this movie is IT!
amydahdah 9 months ago
@amydahdah If only they would find the footage!
MichaelSxe555 8 months ago
This movie is so good, James Mason is also so good in this.
kimpunkrock 8 months ago
Unparalleled brilliance.
hirhodes 9 months ago
That is EXACTLY the problem with your point of view. Why do you have to look at COMMERCIAL artists when there are so many others outside the mainstream spotlight who are more about substance than flash. And they are damned excellent. Get off the beaten path and especially the commercial artists.
unclebobunclebob 9 months ago
BEST.SONG.EVER... JUDY FOREVERRR <3 <3 <3
gigicd86 9 months ago 4
I consider myself an OK karaoke singer, not brilliant. I'd have a go at most songs. Over The Rainbow being one example, but not this. I can't follow the changes of mood and melody, even though the tempo is constant. Judy Garland doesn't so much sing it, as grab it and run off with it, and not letting anyone else get a look in.
cbak12sg 9 months ago
Judy is a goddess, a deity, a REAL star.
TIESUPHAIRYBEARS 9 months ago 4
Oh yeah EVERYTHING sucks now, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Why can't people just enjoy talent old AND new. There is actually a lot out there now if you just get off your ass and look for it. Check out any old performer on YouTube and you get somebody saying that talent is dead. Get a grip and look for it.
unclebobunclebob 9 months ago
@unclebobunclebob You're right when you say that as the generations continue the arts keep changing and it has continuously gotten more and more "pop", however there WAS a time (this song being a wonderful example) where popular artists relied on their MAGNIFICENT talent, unlike now where they rely on "image" and 'sexiness". There are talented people today, that's for sure. But too much has been lost in order to make things more and more commercial.
gigicd86 9 months ago 3
Thanks for posting, love this, but ugh, it's the wrong aspect ratio.
jeffconsoletti 9 months ago
no one can even TOUCH judy. god she's good. check out my cover on my channel - will never be judy standard obviously, but i've done my best!
mildredsmelodies 10 months ago 2
Judy's song for sure, incredible talent! Love this! Sad movie, but the songs and the end are worth it all.
cljoyner39 10 months ago
Judy's song for sure, incredible talent! Love this!
cljoyner39 10 months ago
This is Judy's song....all the way !....thanks for posting.
sherom 10 months ago
Amazing...I love this song!
ClaireBakerVideos 10 months ago
Judy at her finest..one of the most tragic love stories on film..mason and garland are spellbinding..it breaks your heart to see this man fall apart and see her fall apart watching him do it...
TheWaterfallprincess 10 months ago
No one can dare touch this woman's boots.
Today's phony, contrived "singers" are not worthy to even lick a small piece of ground upon which this woman walked for even the smallest minute of her life.
Vengeance509 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Vengeance509 Oh yeah EVERYTHING sucks now, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Why can't people just enjoy talent old AND new. There is actually a lot out there now if you just get off your ass and look for it. Check out any old performer on YouTube and you get somebody saying that talent is dead. Get a grip and look for it.
unclebobunclebob 9 months ago 2
Judy sets the standard, there's no doubt about it. But listen to Diana Krall -- she's awesome and is 'current.' All is not lost. She does such beautiful stuff.
kween51 10 months ago
It's a fucking shame Hollywood ruined her. She was gorgeous and had to deal with pricks telling her she was too big for show business. Such talent wasted.
OMGdani2010 10 months ago
i can't help adoring this scene. reminds me of the good times <3
conversejunkie2222 10 months ago
This song will haunt me for the rest of my life. (that's a good thing) ;P
Matchfyre 10 months ago
Damn, I wish there was a total Star package like Judy on the scene today. Super Star!
Kasbahkabaret 10 months ago
man ....judy is voice is as powerful as a hurricane !!!
BALLYJUNKIE 11 months ago
@BALLYJUNKIE Absolutely. And the amazing thing is that even as she is singing at FULL VOICE, she is still in COMPLETE CONTROL of her voice. Who else can do that???
7beers 10 months ago
Take that Brittany Spears!
RImusclebear 11 months ago
@RImusclebear i agree that today doesnt have any talent! haha but britney is actually an exception...her producers make her sing in a "baby" high pitched voice....her real voice is quite deep and classical kinda like judy...listen to this song of britney's real voice: /watch?v=iwJgrng2DNk and it was recorded in 2007♥
MoxieLiveAction 11 months ago
@MoxieLiveAction I agree that you that deep down Britney has true talent, when you brush away the tacky packaging.
7beers 10 months ago
@7beers me too!♥
MoxieLiveAction 10 months ago
This a work of genius that will never be equaled! It just happened, It was a one take, as was her style!
FRANKHODGES39 11 months ago
Beautiful. I wish she was alive so I could tell her that.
KerraSeayWhat 11 months ago
Judy Garland died for my sins!!
mykol17 11 months ago
THE Greatest song ever sung on the Silver Screen ....Period !! xo
hillfamily4 11 months ago 2
Love this song, she pulls you through such emotions that it isn't just a song but an experience.
amsellner 11 months ago
powerful
BALLYJUNKIE 11 months ago
the one and only judy garland
how we miss miss you
rip
p12nbw 11 months ago 2
Academy Awards doesn't mean anything. She can't take it with her after death, but she will always be remembered for her talents in musicals, films and stage.
saolili 1 year ago
Judy was robbed of the Academy Award,
fasbc 1 year ago
@Yennerf i am 14 years old, and to be honest, i love judy and inspire her and this era so much, if only i was around when she was... i love the wizard of oz, + any musical she may have been in, what a fantastically beautiful woman she was!
DebsTasha45 1 year ago 3
I get goosebumps every time I listen to this. She put so much emotion into all of her songs and it just adds to her outstanding vocal abilities. Bravo!
you0107 1 year ago
Judy is the ONLY one who can sing this song with such passion, emotion and empathy, enough to convince us that it's what's happening to her.
HanzeUK 1 year ago 4
@HanzeUK There is young woman from Ireland, Jessy Buckley that came very close on the" I'd do any thing" BBC show.
jcrobso 1 year ago
@jcrobso seen her do that and thought she over-acted too much, with her facial expression, too much of the " Sylvia Young School" method, methinks. Compare the vocal talents and you'll see that Judy is MILES better.
HanzeUK 1 year ago
no one is as talented is Judy Garland was, rest in peace, wish you were here now!
DebsTasha45 1 year ago
I love this song
ktmarty2 1 year ago
I wish I could sing as amazing as her
Mirandadorable 1 year ago
This is what I called the movie magic. Simple but powerful
jazzyuyu80 1 year ago
Jessie Buckley did an AMAZNG cover of this! Its the best thing I've ever heard.
aclmk33 1 year ago
Fantastic perfomance by the great Judy :-)
Jeannekm126 1 year ago
Quite simply, the best.
Abbyness94 1 year ago
i.n.c.r.e.d.i.b.l.e.
Vengeance509 1 year ago
And look! The entire song is done in one take...beautifully set-up, lit and shot, perfectly animated by Garland, not one false move.Incredible!(By contrast, notice how in "Chicago" the editing was dumbed-down to the MTV mentality that rules, and you can''t quite get a grip on any of the numbers, so chopping are they). Pity.
eldiran2 1 year ago 44
@eldiran2 Agree with you about the Chicago numbers, eidiran, that you can't get a grip on any of them. Good description. By contrast, this great number from "A Star is Born."
Jayee123 1 year ago
@eldiran2 i would have to say i disagree with you. the time in film was different and i am in love with judy garland she is absolutely fabulous. but i love the way chicago was directed because it was directed that way for a purpose not to chop things up.
bluespoon14 7 months ago
@bluespoon14 The '