their voices are great if they could have performed individually i supposed. but as a duo, it was so mismatched...there was no harmony in there... it was like each one is busy doing his/her thing. also the band really (i hate to say this) sucks...
they kinda lost in the end...they don't harmonize very well..and the lady was having extreme difficulty to sing those runs in her higher register.. I guess nothing beats the original
their performance is kind of shaky, there voices does not complement well together, but i think they are good singer still. how ever for this PERFORMANCE no!
they were both pretty much pitch-perfect. yeah, they dont sing it exactly like brian mcknight and mariah carey do.. but they are both on pitch.. and obviously, they are both really talented. ;)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
they had a hard time hitting the high notes especially the bitch. She doesn't even have the blue notes. All i hear are just screams from her. Kim Bum Soo is better but not really impressive 'coz his diction is just awful!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
what? better? these idiots are not even close! I'm telling you moron, even Bryan Mc Knight himself commended Regine personally on their concert! Now, did Bryan commend any of these ugly Koreans! Their pronunciation are so pathetic. Short-tounged singers! hahahaha
I wont say this is the best rendition of this song ever. But, Regine? She's off-key, doesn't have any depth in her voice, and sings like an amateur. Kim Bum Soo can outsing her anyday of the week. And FYI, Brian Mcknight has worked with SEVERAL korean musicians and have commended them for their work as well. Regine isn't that special. And who are you to make fun of Koreans? You dirty Flip. Go work on your grammar before you attack other people's pronunciation.
IveeLee012, whoever you are senseless creature in this world. Don't you know how to respect someone's opinion? This video was uploaded for public viewing and anyone has the right or entitle to his/her own comments. If you can't deal with other people's opinion here, I would suggest it would be better for you to shut up and get a freaking life.
lol "respect someone's opinion?" So if I told you that your a fucking geek, and a loser are you going to respect my opinion? Did you not read what this guy wrote? Its one thing if its constructive criticism, or something non offensive, but obviously he's some fucking racist dill hole...and another thing, stop trying to sound smart and righteous you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about.
"FPCPineapple", so if you think that i'm a fucking geek so be it you can say whatever you want, who the hell cares? i'm not gonna argue with you when it comes to that because i knew myself better than you or to anyone else.Please idiot don't discussed me with your stupidity comments it doesn't make sense at all.Hey, you better find your brain i think you left it somewhere else because obviously you are just pretty dumb asshole.
lol I never said you were a geek, read my comment you ESL challenged retard. I was merely trying to make a point, about your so called 'respecting other people's opinion' and how you were siding with the other moron who made the previous comment. Hmm I know where my brain is, I think your the one who needs to find a new brain, just like the scarecrow from the wizard of oz you stupid fuck. Go learn some proper grammar before you criticize the intelligence of others.
lol "respect someone's opinion?" So if I told you that your a fucking geek, and a loser are you going to respect my opinion? Did you not read what this guy wrote? Its one thing if its constructive criticism, or something non offensive, but obviously he's some fucking racist dill hole...and another thing, stop trying to sound smart and righteous you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about.
awesome!!i really love kim bum soo,even though im not korean i relly adore korean artist especially korean singers like kim bum soo and sung shi kyung...
Very impressed... i've liked Kim Bum Soo really much but haven't seend of this one before.... really amzing!!!!!! i think he did soooooooooooooooooo well!!!!!
The guy can sing but he sings it exactly note for note and trill for trill like Brian. Which makes him more of a cover band singer and not original. The female vocalist is no Mariah but but she added her own flavor and rendition of her part of the song. For that she understands how to put her own twist on it. I give her madd props for that. They sang nice together.
the girl can't soften her voice... her voice is definitely not for the song... but her chest voice is good! but she ran out of breath in the high part of the song.
so r u saying Regine is better than this girl, and MC is the worse? god, smone's gotta open ur brain and c what's in it. besides, that girl was obviously un-prepared... GEEZ.
Yeah, I can see from her make-up, her well done hair & her brand new dress that she is obviously very unprepared for this event. She probably only learned the song that moment. Poor thing huh.
Thanks. I'll use your "unprepared" excuse every time I see someone mess up :-) BTW, do you know these people personally for you to say that they were not prepared? :-) We're you a part of this project and all? :-)
I'm not attacking the performers, I was just giving out opinions, and who knew that there will be someone that's so unreasonable saying things like"I'll use your "unprepared" excuse every time I see someone mess up" the performance was pretty good. I mean, the notes and melody were definitely in tune, but what I meant "unprepared" was that the female
singer didn't do the original version (and I'm NOT saying that she SHOULD do the OV, but she was OBVIOUSLY{listen to the OV, then u'll know} trying to do the OV and failed)And I repeat, this performance was good, I've never said that this performance was bad. I was just trying to get my point across-> Mariah Carey(was)better than Regine and this girl.
Mariah was great in her CD, but her live rendition of this song was terrible. You do not compare a CD version versus a live one. There's a Regine vs MC comparisom of this song here in YouTube. Check it out & you'll see who clearly does better. And yes, this lady here did a better live rendition than MC, but not as great as Regine's.
mc's voice before 1998 was the best. u hav to listen to her live back then. I know how voice's crap after 1999. and no one can be better than her live performance back then.
This logic/excuse could apply to the likes of Barbra Streisand & Julie Andrews who are now a senior citizens. Not on singers like MC who is not OLD yet :-)
wow the professor is pretty damn good. and of course kim bum soo (one of the few korean singers i have respect for) did a pretty okay job. but both need to work on their melisma.
for all those haters stop hating, Kim Bum Soo LOVES singing... his life is singing... and to those who are saying they had a hard time with the song try singing it yourself in the same key they attempted it, if you do better, then you can hate otherwise STFU.
uh. ok. you're just rude. that's a great way to be respectful. if you don't have anything nice to say then please don't say anything mean. nice vid btw. ^_^ they both sing great! and the orchestra is awesome.
hey, cut the crap! they were so great!!!Guys, maybe he wrecked in the climax. We were created imperfectly so, there's no point that he wrecked the climax. And after all, the performance was a good one. They were great!!!!
they were awsome...i dont think u guys shud say that they are mediocre and etc because they made that song their own..they arent up there to duplicate mariah and brian...they are there to portray the song in theire style
i was actually impressed (which is definitely hard to do with me)...Kim Bum Soo actually pulled off a pretty good and difficult performance. The only thing holding him back was his accent. Ms. Goodman, is pitchy at times, but pretty good.
so what? that's retarded, cause everyone can do that, takes no skill, that's why it looked amateur, if he himself relistened to his vocals, he would say the same, so be quiet
"he did not sing like brian mcknight ergo he is a bad singer"
is arguably the most retarded thing i've heard in my life. this is something classical musicians say all the time, "lang lang played this sonata 10 beats faster than vladimir horowitz, ergo he is far inferior."
listen to Tony Bennett sing christmas songs, and Christina Aguilera sing christmas songs. Same song, differnt style, both great. Your argument does not work here.
i can, and there's no need for me to record myself on my video camera, noobs like you think you know crap and then say oooh why dont you do it yurself, chill out, it was only a comment, and besides, im right, yur trying to make an argument out of nothing and try to misinterpret what im really trying to say
I asked you to record yourself and present a link to your video because I question the accuracy of your statement: "...everyone can do that, takes no skill...looked amateur..."
If this is the case, then I merely ask for proof because it doesnt seem easy and not everyone can do it.
You claim and imply you are a much better singer. Proove it.
why are you being the biggest idiot on here...dude, singing the chorus, like the way he did, is easy and every baritone and tenor that i've talked to can do it, so you are being a dumass trying to say 'oh EVERYONE can do it' of course if you dont sing, then no, you gotta realize that everything i've said is correct and if you dont think so, just message me about what you misunderstand
Singing's not all about technique. Yea, so you can sing the chorus like he did. That doesn't make you as good as him. Don't go around criticizing everyone's singing because it's not how Brian McKnight sings it. Music is not about who's better than who. Stop being such an arrogant prick and acting like you know everything. Even if you did know what you were talking about, your cockiness makes you seem like an imbecile.
Hi, you are still an idiot. Get raped, you don't know crap about singing. It's not cockiness when the other person is stupid. I can sugarcoat everything and make you feel good about yourself but the truth is, you are stubborn and ignorant of facts. GG
u obviously don't know about how stage works. this was kim bum soo's concert and he on the stage cannot hear clearly if he's overshadowing her or if he's being overpowered. if someone made a mistake, it wasn't kim bum soo's; it was sound engineer's, who did not control the microphone volumes appropriately.
shut up, he was using pure chest voice, which is definitely not what brian mcknight was using when he sang this live with mariah, i was actually there, you dont know crap about singing songs, so shut up, im not saying kim is a bad singer, becasue he certainly is decent
u said he wrecked the climax... yeah, i do see that his voice was a little shaky at highest pitch, but not to the point of wreckage. and u also pointed out that some of the "probably inferior singers" have done a better job, please give me a link.
i still believe this was a wonderful performance, considering that they haven't had time to practice together for a while like some other duet singers do.
sorry man. Kim Bum Soo may be considered the best male vocalist in Korea, but he wrecked the climax. And in the harmony, he was supposed to hold back and complement the lady in the background, not overpower her. I'm not saying he's not a good singer, but 1. he pushed himself too far, and 2. I've heard other probably inferior singers do a better job on this DUET.
noobs? are u kidding... kim bum soo is a national singer in korea who's considered to be one of the best male vocalist in Korea. and the woman is a professor in prestigious Berkeley College of Music, where this concert was held. noobs? mediocre? please guys.. open ur ears
this was mediocre I suppose...but the harmony between the two singers (or lack therof) made me cring. I guess I've been spoiled by the original version
Oppa<3
L9G2J1 4 weeks ago
He out sung her... but great duet :)
Applejoydc 3 months ago
indian singer?!?! lol he is a KOREAN!! hahahahaha
jooya1027 6 months ago in playlist CCM찬양곡 3
just just just...beautiful
almadulce 6 months ago
More like Kis Bum Son
joeyteoh 6 months ago
great!
RaciouS91 6 months ago
Why are there absolutely 0 indian singers on Youtube?
sunnyastronaut 7 months ago
Wow what a great performance
patwestlife 9 months ago
His English is gd where I he from?
TheGossipgirl911 9 months ago
@TheGossipgirl911 He is a south Korean singer.
Thaimasker1 6 months ago
their voices are great if they could have performed individually i supposed. but as a duo, it was so mismatched...there was no harmony in there... it was like each one is busy doing his/her thing. also the band really (i hate to say this) sucks...
kirbyjimenez881 10 months ago
Asian people really can sing,,,especially Filipinos and Koreans.......:)
cutevincentboron 11 months ago 6
Asian people really can sing,,,especially Filipinos and Koreans.......:)
cutevincentboron 11 months ago 3
I don't understand why this video has 15 negative votes. I think it's a good performance, and the two singers have a great voices.
StevenSanz 1 year ago
DAMN YOU KIM you are so GOOD!!!!!!!!!
kalakalachuchu 1 year ago 2
that guy sings great.... but please please sing a bit lower when you singing the harmony.... ....
davidchubo 1 year ago
Nothing like MARIAH CAREY!
BEST FEMALE SINGER OF ALL TIMEEEEE :)
MartinKgpcD1 1 year ago 3
here's a Better rendition from Philippines. From the Philippines Prince and Princess of RnB.
watch?v=frM3J8eawzM
noimicu 1 year ago
KBS is a great singer. Looking forward to his new projects.....
noerjadi 1 year ago
They don't blend very well on chorus...the guy's voice is too loud...though they are both good singers...(:
romneytata 1 year ago
another flawless performance by the king.
yayyyzzz 1 year ago
I think Kim Bum Soo is way way better than his partner !
lockritahchicqk10 1 year ago
0:51 The kidding point where they start to rip off this music.
beenthesun 2 years ago
they kinda lost in the end...they don't harmonize very well..and the lady was having extreme difficulty to sing those runs in her higher register.. I guess nothing beats the original
bouncingsiopao 2 years ago 3
i think this is one of the best perfromance! i mean alot of people tries to sing this song, but i say that this is one of the best!
thaostaboi010 2 years ago 3
@thaostaboi010 .....TRY TO WATCH FILIPINO RENDITION OF THIS SONG....YOU MAY SAY THAT THIS IS THE PRETTY OBNOXIOUS PERFORMANCE OF ALL TIME..
ijuwey 2 years ago
@ijuwey tama!
ijuwey 1 year ago
The woman is fat and the guy looks like a child
but they sounds good
alexanderT83 2 years ago
their performance is kind of shaky, there voices does not complement well together, but i think they are good singer still. how ever for this PERFORMANCE no!
jacrspo1821 2 years ago 3
the guy is not bad at all..
yucosci05 2 years ago
the guy rocks!!!!!!!!!
Divinia43 2 years ago 3
hmmp... not that good.
i still prefer REGINE AND BRIAN
manfromphil02 2 years ago
regine? Do you even know who originally sang the song? It's Mariah Carey ft. Brian McKnight
akotr3mor 2 years ago 4
yeah i know who's the orignal singer of this song.
and my opinion is regine and brian did better than this. mind ur own business huh?!
manfromphil02 2 years ago
well i'm sorry you have a flagpole up your ass i hope that works out for you
akotr3mor 2 years ago
lol
myrules89 2 years ago
who is kim bum soo? im from the philippines, see.. but i like her vocals! in what country is she performing?
Erg0 2 years ago
kim bum soo is the guys at left.. a korean... if you wanna talk about 'HER' she's Gabriel Goodman.
beomme 2 years ago
Im sorry, just realized that. i liked kim's strong vocals, dont worry, im checking out his songs as well. :)
Erg0 2 years ago
actually a close match to the original!! excellent rendition!
zapsurfer238 2 years ago
nice... u should kinda mke sense while singing,. but, nice as i said.. so,keep it up u two!
arnnabua123 2 years ago
good stuff
coatfactory356 2 years ago
真厲害!! superb
lomuz9 2 years ago
I would like to hear Wahnee sing this.
armjoint1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that is so wrong...
ThugLoveD 3 years ago
Damn...it was my mistake that I expected performance like Brian Mcknight and Mariah Carey showed...But this is still good though
IXUSLOVE 3 years ago
great vocal.....bum soo is great!
yy8283 3 years ago 6
they were both pretty much pitch-perfect. yeah, they dont sing it exactly like brian mcknight and mariah carey do.. but they are both on pitch.. and obviously, they are both really talented. ;)
maxvinsanity 3 years ago 6
I saw this LIVE!!! woohooo
^_^
JuneJJ90 3 years ago
both talented singers and in tune, just not harmonised. out of tune. in tune. out of tune. i dont know what im talking about =]
kien725 3 years ago
il ragazzo asiatico è qlc tono sopra!
Irenethesinger 3 years ago
damn! Asian guy can sing!
djr320 3 years ago 26
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why what do u think with asian guys?? me im an asian guy and i can sing..im a Filipino ..
cleinore 3 years ago
Yeah man, that dude is pretty good especially considering that it was sung by Brian McKnight
Antikas 3 years ago 5
omg....the guy was AMAZING!...
bUT THE fat lady was OFF KEY!!!
nhanv313 3 years ago
your ear is off key.. that was great
trungtin 3 years ago 2
holy shit he sings soo great!!
crazymanthomas1654 3 years ago 18
chaka ng kumnta, un lang!!!!!! mukang pusit yung gurl hehehehhe
twofiveaugust 3 years ago 2
Que linda voz la de KBS, si practica un poco mas de diccion seria aun muchisimo mejor para el mercado anglosajon.
leilarojas 3 years ago
KIM BUM SOO is good for a korean guy,
what can i say? i'm speechless when i heard him hit that high note brian mcknight hit.
wow.
impressive!
musicgenius808 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they had a hard time hitting the high notes especially the bitch. She doesn't even have the blue notes. All i hear are just screams from her. Kim Bum Soo is better but not really impressive 'coz his diction is just awful!
brainymechanical 4 years ago
hahaha i agree with you...his diction is....yeah, like what you said. but otherwise, his range is pretty good :)
musicgenius808 4 years ago
what a great performance kim bunsoo your the best tho iamnot a korean i like korean artist like kim bun soo.
edith5689 4 years ago 2
BETTER THAN REGINE!
anotherlateday 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what? better? these idiots are not even close! I'm telling you moron, even Bryan Mc Knight himself commended Regine personally on their concert! Now, did Bryan commend any of these ugly Koreans! Their pronunciation are so pathetic. Short-tounged singers! hahahaha
brainymechanical 4 years ago
I wont say this is the best rendition of this song ever. But, Regine? She's off-key, doesn't have any depth in her voice, and sings like an amateur. Kim Bum Soo can outsing her anyday of the week. And FYI, Brian Mcknight has worked with SEVERAL korean musicians and have commended them for their work as well. Regine isn't that special. And who are you to make fun of Koreans? You dirty Flip. Go work on your grammar before you attack other people's pronunciation.
IveeLee012 4 years ago 7
IveeLee012, whoever you are senseless creature in this world. Don't you know how to respect someone's opinion? This video was uploaded for public viewing and anyone has the right or entitle to his/her own comments. If you can't deal with other people's opinion here, I would suggest it would be better for you to shut up and get a freaking life.
flameheart888 3 years ago
lol "respect someone's opinion?" So if I told you that your a fucking geek, and a loser are you going to respect my opinion? Did you not read what this guy wrote? Its one thing if its constructive criticism, or something non offensive, but obviously he's some fucking racist dill hole...and another thing, stop trying to sound smart and righteous you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about.
FPCPineapple 3 years ago
"FPCPineapple", so if you think that i'm a fucking geek so be it you can say whatever you want, who the hell cares? i'm not gonna argue with you when it comes to that because i knew myself better than you or to anyone else.Please idiot don't discussed me with your stupidity comments it doesn't make sense at all.Hey, you better find your brain i think you left it somewhere else because obviously you are just pretty dumb asshole.
flameheart888 3 years ago
lol I never said you were a geek, read my comment you ESL challenged retard. I was merely trying to make a point, about your so called 'respecting other people's opinion' and how you were siding with the other moron who made the previous comment. Hmm I know where my brain is, I think your the one who needs to find a new brain, just like the scarecrow from the wizard of oz you stupid fuck. Go learn some proper grammar before you criticize the intelligence of others.
FPCPineapple 3 years ago
lol "respect someone's opinion?" So if I told you that your a fucking geek, and a loser are you going to respect my opinion? Did you not read what this guy wrote? Its one thing if its constructive criticism, or something non offensive, but obviously he's some fucking racist dill hole...and another thing, stop trying to sound smart and righteous you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about.
FPCPineapple 3 years ago
im referring to brainymechanical and flameheart888's comments..
FPCPineapple 3 years ago
i love kim bum soo...he is so good....i would be more nice if kim's duet is mariah....no offense please...
yukitotc143 4 years ago 4
That's what I was just thinking!!!
saved2play 4 years ago
yeah is so great and amazing
yukitotc143 4 years ago
ya well mariah doesn't sing this song live
dibeas 4 years ago
i would agree, she is not good in performing live anymore...
yukitotc143 4 years ago
i say wow...the first time a korean singing an english song this great...he is very good...
yukitotc143 4 years ago
awesome!!i really love kim bum soo,even though im not korean i relly adore korean artist especially korean singers like kim bum soo and sung shi kyung...
ladybhien 4 years ago
sighhh KIM BUM SOO SARANGHAEYOH!!!!
LOL.... omg hes so cute/.amazing/sighhh....
hEAVENsXtEARs 4 years ago
Very impressed... i've liked Kim Bum Soo really much but haven't seend of this one before.... really amzing!!!!!! i think he did soooooooooooooooooo well!!!!!
ingkko87 4 years ago
what is she wearingg?? lol.
but voices are greattt .
KIM BUM SOO SARANGHAEE <33.
immafatpig 4 years ago
bloody hell ..they are both good,but i'm so freakin amazed by the guy's range .
hiperpoop 4 years ago
HE'S GREAT.
jheibian 4 years ago
That woman's singing gave me goosebumps. She was amazing!
bondingo 4 years ago
It's Berklee College of Music. Not UC Berkley ahaha.
Faith804 4 years ago
sorry ill fix it
myrules89 4 years ago
If I could get to be that close to kim, I think I'll get a Ph.D., too.
iutldm 4 years ago
I believe black people have some kinds of genes for their amazing voice and singing skills. Kim Bum Soo may be the only Asian have the same genes.
sungewon 4 years ago
they're all over the place.
singmeasong 4 years ago
kim bum soo is the bomb....really in bogoshipda...
mnjdmeg6 4 years ago
propz to gabriel goodman... she would fit into like a gospel choir... got a good voice
dubblecx301 4 years ago
The guy can sing but he sings it exactly note for note and trill for trill like Brian. Which makes him more of a cover band singer and not original. The female vocalist is no Mariah but but she added her own flavor and rendition of her part of the song. For that she understands how to put her own twist on it. I give her madd props for that. They sang nice together.
d2197v 4 years ago
Lee Bum Soo is just amazing!! the lady is good too.
MizNouP 4 years ago
what the fuck you guys think you can sing better stop criticizing ok!
achanchan 4 years ago
yes, in this duet, Kim Bum SOo is the better singer.
poopzassshit 4 years ago
hid twists and turns on the song are but fantastic
like it
igatcli2 4 years ago
the guys sings very well huh.....is he korean????
pretty good
igatcli2 4 years ago
he's a korean singer very popular
jefke08 4 years ago
the lady gets screechy in high notes because she can't hold the notes.
ginsengjin 4 years ago
the girl can't soften her voice... her voice is definitely not for the song... but her chest voice is good! but she ran out of breath in the high part of the song.
hibernate02 4 years ago
I'm Italian and big fan of MC...I think this performance is VERY VERY GOOD...she hasn'y a voice like Mariah, but a one good anyway
nicedreamer1 4 years ago
This is a good performance.Way way better than Whoriah Carey!
fatam19 4 years ago
Nah, the girl is good, but Regine is still better. But this girl is better than MC though.
gemininer 4 years ago
stay away from drugs :)
Faglia 4 years ago
Are you speaking from experience :-)
gemininer 4 years ago
so r u saying Regine is better than this girl, and MC is the worse? god, smone's gotta open ur brain and c what's in it. besides, that girl was obviously un-prepared... GEEZ.
gucci1022 4 years ago
Yeah, I can see from her make-up, her well done hair & her brand new dress that she is obviously very unprepared for this event. She probably only learned the song that moment. Poor thing huh.
gemininer 4 years ago
dont ppl LISTEN to songs??? some of the harmony parts r just obviously unprepared. geez. the guy's good though.
gucci1022 4 years ago
Thanks. I'll use your "unprepared" excuse every time I see someone mess up :-) BTW, do you know these people personally for you to say that they were not prepared? :-) We're you a part of this project and all? :-)
gemininer 4 years ago
I'm not attacking the performers, I was just giving out opinions, and who knew that there will be someone that's so unreasonable saying things like"I'll use your "unprepared" excuse every time I see someone mess up" the performance was pretty good. I mean, the notes and melody were definitely in tune, but what I meant "unprepared" was that the female
gucci1022 4 years ago
I was giving an opinion myself. & I think this girl is good but not good enough in my book. She didn't do the original version coz she can't.
gemininer 4 years ago
singer didn't do the original version (and I'm NOT saying that she SHOULD do the OV, but she was OBVIOUSLY{listen to the OV, then u'll know} trying to do the OV and failed)And I repeat, this performance was good, I've never said that this performance was bad. I was just trying to get my point across-> Mariah Carey(was)better than Regine and this girl.
gucci1022 4 years ago
Mariah was great in her CD, but her live rendition of this song was terrible. You do not compare a CD version versus a live one. There's a Regine vs MC comparisom of this song here in YouTube. Check it out & you'll see who clearly does better. And yes, this lady here did a better live rendition than MC, but not as great as Regine's.
gemininer 4 years ago
mc's voice before 1998 was the best. u hav to listen to her live back then. I know how voice's crap after 1999. and no one can be better than her live performance back then.
gucci1022 4 years ago
This logic/excuse could apply to the likes of Barbra Streisand & Julie Andrews who are now a senior citizens. Not on singers like MC who is not OLD yet :-)
gemininer 4 years ago
u just dont get it. and I dont wanna continue this immature convo anymore. c ya.
gucci1022 4 years ago
Kim Bum Soo is One of my most favorite singers...
check his song NIGA NAL DDUNA!!!! its the best!
afficionado 4 years ago
good one..but nothing like regine and brian together
eldano 5 years ago
Are Mariah Carey the one who made the song
9jar9 5 years ago
brian mcknight composed for her
eldano 5 years ago
??? making things up there lol
littlegreenbag 3 years ago
yes mariah wrote the song with another song writer. and other people sing it too, like them
lxavier85jerseygurl 4 years ago
That Korean guy has a wicked voice. I am pleasantly surprised.
CCBaby 5 years ago
The female singer is better that Regine in giving justice to this song.
adiksabata 5 years ago
orchestra is so damn horrible.
pjunnkie 5 years ago
wow the professor is pretty damn good. and of course kim bum soo (one of the few korean singers i have respect for) did a pretty okay job. but both need to work on their melisma.
StacyOh1717 5 years ago
Awesome..! Loved the performance...
HybridRoninX 5 years ago
Whenever You Call is very hard to sing. Especially the duet version. They did a good job.
ilovekeane 5 years ago
for all those haters stop hating, Kim Bum Soo LOVES singing... his life is singing... and to those who are saying they had a hard time with the song try singing it yourself in the same key they attempted it, if you do better, then you can hate otherwise STFU.
hillsong1004 5 years ago
the both have trouble finding the right key, but i think this was great
kellyemu 5 years ago
kim bum soo is usually so good, but he was too loud in this duet
lizz7489 5 years ago
WHOA! awesome. but that ending was too much tho, lol.
luvjunjin0819 5 years ago
I agree that they were great! I'm with CagedBird88 on your comment to iheartyou1246! Iheartyou1246, if you can't compare don't be jealous!
mnlkv 5 years ago
NIIICE!!! SAVED TO FAVOURITES!!!
iheartyou1246 << ignorant shit!
CagedBird88 5 years ago
Awesome! =)
jokumusic 5 years ago
dude soundz pretty cool fo an amatuer. wit mo practice he might make it. iz dis like talent show?
tokyoflypaperdrift 5 years ago
tryin to sing an american song.. probably wipes his ass barehanded in asia... fuckin COPY CAT STOP STEALING AMERICAS SHIT
iheartyou1246 5 years ago
racist are we? stop hatin
caramelcandy254 5 years ago
shut the fuck up
iheartyou1246 5 years ago
whatever ur fuckin ignorant
caramelcandy254 5 years ago
uh. ok. you're just rude. that's a great way to be respectful. if you don't have anything nice to say then please don't say anything mean. nice vid btw. ^_^ they both sing great! and the orchestra is awesome.
BounmyP 5 years ago
Kim Bum Soo isn't a duet singer...he's just used to singing by himself...Duets and singles need different skills.
Scubachink5768 5 years ago
i think they did a great job on this song and kim bum soo voice is sooo amazing luv him
ashleybee123 5 years ago
hey, cut the crap! they were so great!!!Guys, maybe he wrecked in the climax. We were created imperfectly so, there's no point that he wrecked the climax. And after all, the performance was a good one. They were great!!!!
harraco 5 years ago
they were awsome...i dont think u guys shud say that they are mediocre and etc because they made that song their own..they arent up there to duplicate mariah and brian...they are there to portray the song in theire style
Latinpapi574 5 years ago
i was actually impressed (which is definitely hard to do with me)...Kim Bum Soo actually pulled off a pretty good and difficult performance. The only thing holding him back was his accent. Ms. Goodman, is pitchy at times, but pretty good.
kwinseeeee 5 years ago
so what? that's retarded, cause everyone can do that, takes no skill, that's why it looked amateur, if he himself relistened to his vocals, he would say the same, so be quiet
Wendiesel 5 years ago
"he did not sing like brian mcknight ergo he is a bad singer"
is arguably the most retarded thing i've heard in my life. this is something classical musicians say all the time, "lang lang played this sonata 10 beats faster than vladimir horowitz, ergo he is far inferior."
listen to Tony Bennett sing christmas songs, and Christina Aguilera sing christmas songs. Same song, differnt style, both great. Your argument does not work here.
jinhyungahn 5 years ago
dont be such a noob
Wendiesel 5 years ago
Also, "that's retarded, cause everyone can do that, takes no skill, that's why it looked amateur..."
please record yourself and give a link of it, I doubt you can hit that pitch or sing half as great.
if you can, you win :)
jinhyungahn 5 years ago
i can, and there's no need for me to record myself on my video camera, noobs like you think you know crap and then say oooh why dont you do it yurself, chill out, it was only a comment, and besides, im right, yur trying to make an argument out of nothing and try to misinterpret what im really trying to say
Wendiesel 5 years ago
I asked you to record yourself and present a link to your video because I question the accuracy of your statement: "...everyone can do that, takes no skill...looked amateur..."
If this is the case, then I merely ask for proof because it doesnt seem easy and not everyone can do it.
You claim and imply you are a much better singer. Proove it.
jinhyungahn 5 years ago
Also, I think you misunderstood.
I am not saying "OH YEA!! well YOU CANT DO IT, ERGO YOUR WRONG". This is more like ad hominem.
Clearly, this isn't what im doing.
jinhyungahn 5 years ago
why are you being the biggest idiot on here...dude, singing the chorus, like the way he did, is easy and every baritone and tenor that i've talked to can do it, so you are being a dumass trying to say 'oh EVERYONE can do it' of course if you dont sing, then no, you gotta realize that everything i've said is correct and if you dont think so, just message me about what you misunderstand
Wendiesel 5 years ago
Singing's not all about technique. Yea, so you can sing the chorus like he did. That doesn't make you as good as him. Don't go around criticizing everyone's singing because it's not how Brian McKnight sings it. Music is not about who's better than who. Stop being such an arrogant prick and acting like you know everything. Even if you did know what you were talking about, your cockiness makes you seem like an imbecile.
MartyrOfMusic 5 years ago
niiiice, good one, that's the comment i wanted to see : ), thanks, i was merely trying to find someone to 'argue', ha if you only knew me
Wendiesel 5 years ago
Hi, you are still an idiot. Get raped, you don't know crap about singing. It's not cockiness when the other person is stupid. I can sugarcoat everything and make you feel good about yourself but the truth is, you are stubborn and ignorant of facts. GG
Wendiesel 2 years ago
na you're stupid, 2 years later, i'm still correct ^.^
Wendiesel 2 years ago
o.0 wow nice dress lol
jer18x 5 years ago
u obviously don't know about how stage works. this was kim bum soo's concert and he on the stage cannot hear clearly if he's overshadowing her or if he's being overpowered. if someone made a mistake, it wasn't kim bum soo's; it was sound engineer's, who did not control the microphone volumes appropriately.
whitelynx 5 years ago
shut up, he was using pure chest voice, which is definitely not what brian mcknight was using when he sang this live with mariah, i was actually there, you dont know crap about singing songs, so shut up, im not saying kim is a bad singer, becasue he certainly is decent
Wendiesel 5 years ago
u said he wrecked the climax... yeah, i do see that his voice was a little shaky at highest pitch, but not to the point of wreckage. and u also pointed out that some of the "probably inferior singers" have done a better job, please give me a link.
i still believe this was a wonderful performance, considering that they haven't had time to practice together for a while like some other duet singers do.
whitelynx 5 years ago
sorry man. Kim Bum Soo may be considered the best male vocalist in Korea, but he wrecked the climax. And in the harmony, he was supposed to hold back and complement the lady in the background, not overpower her. I'm not saying he's not a good singer, but 1. he pushed himself too far, and 2. I've heard other probably inferior singers do a better job on this DUET.
RhythmNSilk 5 years ago
noobs? are u kidding... kim bum soo is a national singer in korea who's considered to be one of the best male vocalist in Korea. and the woman is a professor in prestigious Berkeley College of Music, where this concert was held. noobs? mediocre? please guys.. open ur ears
whitelynx 5 years ago
this was mediocre I suppose...but the harmony between the two singers (or lack therof) made me cring. I guess I've been spoiled by the original version
RhythmNSilk 5 years ago
i've yet to see a duo nail that song, have you? if so, please show me, i'd love to be surprised...searched everywhere
Wendiesel 5 years ago
nicely done by the noobs
Wendiesel 5 years ago