Added: 1 year ago
From: GoddessOfTheAir
Views: 28,386
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (186)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • FMA FOR THE WIN!!!

  • I fell in love with this song the moment i heard it! Vic has such an amazingly beautiful voice! It breaks my heart when i talk to people and they say that they have no idea who he is! How can someone like Justin Bieber be more famous than Vic Mignogna?! IT'S INSANE!!! WHAT HAS THE WORLD COME TO?! SPREAD THE MIGNOGNA MADNESS!!!! XD haha <3

  • @kayz1313 This made my day - IT'S SO TRUE! Vic is too good of a musician to be so obscure in the mainsteam!

  • Now... my favorite song next to guilty beauty love ;P

  • hahah funny.. this is my ring tone.. WARNING: raging vic fangirl pass this point. WHAT ASSHOLE WOULD DISLIKE THIS EPICNESS!! GRRR

  • @bmxsoo224224 where did u get the ringtone and was it free???

  • @bmxsoo224224 the people who have never felt any pain, and basicly don't care.

  • @897theman i'm not trying to be Emo, but it is the truth (in my opinion)

  • Lol! to me its like it was made for loveless :D

  • vic is full of badassnessness

  • The one dislike was from Roy. He's jealous of the Elricest.

  • FUCK YEAH!!!

  • oh. oh my. thats was. amazing. o.o

  • COOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Ed can sing! ;D

    Lol just kidding! I love you Vic!! -3

  • This song is also written in the style of Evanescence.

    Wiki-it to Wikipedia.

  • I...I think my heart just melted.

  • al found ed singing this and made his first youtube video ...i guess ed finally found it

  • I keep seeing Ed singing this. I like it :3

  • DUDE HE SHOULD BE A SINGER BESIDES HIM BEING AN ANIME VOICE ACTOR!! XD

  • @Fmalover41 He is! Vic's been singing, playing and writing music way longer than he's been voice acting. He's done a lot of different music types. Check him out on iTunes! ^^

  • @Fmalover41 He does both!

  • This SO should have been the ending theme song for the FMA movie The Conqueror of Shamballa

  • @XxilovemangagirlxX I agree!

  • WHO DISLIKED THIS? D8<

  • @1993CathyBee A member of the miniskirt army! D8 <<

  • ... nice

  • I'm pretty sure it is about FMA only because "My brother" and "Return the soul to where it lives) cuz al's soul doesn't belong in a body of armor~

  • woooooowww I love it!!

    Vic is so awesome for writting this amazing song *_*

  • Reason 22 that Elric pwns Cullen: This song.

  • I love this song!!! i have it on my ipod <3

  • Was this song inspired by FMA? The fact it said: It cost you more than it cost me. and My brother. reminded me that Al lost his whole body where Ed only lost an arm and a leg. And: To make atonement for my sin. being where Ed promised to make things right again. Since in the original FMA, Sloth was their sin.

  • @CrimsonDragon298 I'm such a nerd...

  • @CrimsonDragon298 Indeed it was! Vic himself said it was a message from Ed to Al inspired by his work in FMA :)

  • @GoddessOfTheAir thats awesome!!

  • @CrimsonDragon298 ikr. but no. it was actually written about fma.

  • vic's awesomeness and smexyness, and awesomeness brought me here 

  • 0:56 I really like the bit when it does 'My brother'

    I really Love this Edward themed song!!!!!^^ :)

  • I emailed him about if he can come to Otakon in 2012. He replied back saying that he wants to come so badly, then he asked me who I was going to cosplay as and I told him Ed and that I'm short so I fit the character profile perfectly. It was funny, we had a full conversation about who I was going to cosplay as. I then told him I cosplay as Ed, Dark, Tamaki, and Zero.

  • Uh, I love this song <3

  • i just emailed him, and i'm waiting for a response

  • im so gonna ask him to sing a little bit of this at the Anime Expo in 2012!!! :3333

  • @Deidarafreak14 He's gonna be in AX 2012?! :D

  • @BreakingNinja17 im pretty sure!!!!!!!!!

  • @Deidarafreak14 OMG YAY! 

  • I love this song :)

  • Very rarely do American-speaking voice actors make character songs.

    That's pretty awesome.

  • whats this guys email?!?! i wanna email vic mignogna!!!!

  • @hahahahajks victhewop@aol.com ^^ He's great about answering fan emails!

  • @GoddessOfTheAir Yeah I'm trying to get him as a guest at Otakon 2012! He reccomended that I write the Otakon staff and request it :D I love Vic. I'm drawing Edward Elric in a Star Trek uniform for him xD

  • @Kakashisensei63 R U Sure Its Him? It Could Be some1 eals :P :P

  • @dgreeky Well yeah. As you see in the comments, he replies to all of his fans :D

  • @GoddessOfTheAir does he really have a email? :P :P

  • @dgreeky Yep! I've emailed him before, he replied that same day :D

  • @GoddessOfTheAir Woah He does answer! He answered my email in like less than 24 hours! He's really dedicated to his fans ^_^ Its official I like him even more, Vic Rocks! :D

  • @GoddessOfTheAir haha... it's an automated response

  • @Kikyo539 Ima test it out >.< lol

  • @GoddessOfTheAir does he really have a email?

  • @GoddessOfTheAir i ask him and he sed YES!! <3 <3 but that it :( :(

  • @GoddessOfTheAir I'm so tempted to email him. alkfjasldfjasl. I don't wanna be be a creep though. lmao.

  • @hahahahajks vic @ vicsworld . net is the email on his website.

  • @hahahahajks he did a whole rant about how terrible it is for fan girls to email him because he gets hundreds everyday and he is so nice that he answers them all, do you really wana email him? :/

  • @fruitsbasketmangalov I think that's just fangirls, though...I don't think he'll mind xD The first time I emailed him, I actually mentioned, "I know you must get tons of fanmail everyday, so I hope mine isn't an inconvenience for you" and he still replied xD

  • @GoddessOfTheAir nice xD

  • *Fangirl Squeal* Oh-My-God. I didn't even know Vic could sing! xD <3 I'm in fangirl heaven. x3

  • Ouran Highschool Host Club brought me here! (>^w^)>

  • @RileyTheeCat And Vic and Fullmetal Alchemist will keep you here, I hope! lol ^^

  • I can't wait to see him in july :)

  • O.O ~falls out of chair screaming like a banshee~ KYAAAAAAAAAAAAA VIC MIGNOGNA IS MY HERO! He changed my frickin life!!!! I LOVE U VIC!

  • @Flowertail100 KYAAA! I know how you feel! :D I consider him one of my ultimate heroes of all time - he totally changed my outlook on life and faith <3

  • @GoddessOfTheAir :D :D I get to meet him in june ~Squeals til end of time~

  • This is now my favorite song by him.

  • Comment removed

  • there are no words to discrid the love I have for this song

  • 0 dislikes!!!

    No member of the miniskirt army has seen this!!! 8D

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam lol! :D Even if a Miniskirt saw this, I doubt they'd be able to deny Vic's amazing singing voice! :3

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam Apparently only Risembool Rangers have seen this! :D

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam Don't count your chickens. They just converted.

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam Why bring attention to it -.-' now it does have a dislike...

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam of course the mini skirt army can not set foot on this land!

  • @TheSailorHetaliaTeam apparently 1 has now

  • OMG this is on itunes!!!!!

  • HOLY CRAP, guys! Over 15,000 views! I'm honored :'3 (wipes away tear)

  • Comment removed

  • Lol I thought Vic was Ed? No? Lol my bad.

    Still GREAT SONG! AND I LOVE IT SOO MUCH!!!

    VIC FTW!!!! <3

  • @NonRealBoysAreBetter I did the first time I saw it now I put a lot of passion into it even if I'm just whispering the words.

  • Did anyone else start crying?? <3

  • ಶ_ಶ I feel like I should be disturbed by how awesome this is.... But I think I'll get used to it. xD I gotta show this to my friends! They're in the middle of Brotherhood! I wanna see if they get it! xD

  • Is there nothing Vic CAN'T do? How I love him!!! <3

  • @Bloodyblackwolf1 I know right! I mean he's a amazing voice actor and a singer to boot! Its all just to much XD

  • @XxXDreamSeekerXxX yeah! I met him at Youma this year....I think he just gave me the best birthday present EVER

    Kissed mah head twice and sang me happy birthday.....He's a great Christian to...is there anything bad about him at all?!

  • @Bloodyblackwolf1 Absolutely nothing :D

  • This song reminds me of FMA...

    Im so making an AMV with this song :D

  • @xXTemarixStrifeXx Haha, it was actually written by Vic about FMA! xD

  • I am... in love!

  • I really wanna meet Vic! D8

  • ;3; ....B-....Beautiful!! EEEP!! :D I'm going to get a piggy back ride from Vic in December. xD

  • This song reminds me very much of Evanescence, lol! I love it!

  • R.I.P.

    The Replay Button...

    it has served its purpose well and will be dearly missed.

    hahaha XD

  • I saw Vic at the London expo. He sang this in his sunday panel. I think he sings it better live. Not saying it's not still amazing like this. But watching him perform it and hearing how much emotion he puts into it just kinda kicks you in the heart a bit more ^_^

  • Just saw him in real life, this was epic, actually, never liked anime that much, saw this guy, now I'm going to watch all of full metal alchemist

  • *falls out of chair and foams at the mouth*

  • @michanxstatus Whoa, you okay there? xD

  • i cosplay as edward elric and i got vic to sighn my coat...(i'm also going to see vic in january

  • i might start crying... i cried the first time i heard brothers it is just so sad.

  • I saw him sing this on the 22nd at EXP-con. It was so amazing :')

  • YEAH!!!!! Do i get a cookie?!?!? *.* X3

  • @AnimeFreakazoid11117 You sure do!!! *gives cookie* ^^

  • @GoddessOfTheAir YEAH!!!! Thank you!!!! *bows*

  • @AnimeFreakazoid11117 You can has~

  • Whenever i hear vic sing i can't help but think "wow, ed would be an amazing singer" or "this what ed would sound like is he sang"

  • hehe have the cd :)

  • Absolutely amazing song <3 I don't think Vic could get any better now... and yet he gets better with every single video I watch with him singing.

  • lawl. calli's gonna hate me for this.

  • i could totally picture Ed singing this!!!!

  • @WinryRockbell20 I know right

  • Anyone else notice how this is one of the very few songs to have NO dislikes? Let's keep it that way

  • I keep hearing Tamaki. XD

  • I love the way Vic sings the song, but I think the song itself needs work.

  • @flayremoon Oh? How so?

  • @GoddessOfTheAir I feel like the "Before the day /she slipped away" could be separated to follow the basic rhyme scheme they use for the rest of the song, and the "The day/she slipped away" could be slower, to make it more emotional.

  • *squeal* OMGSH HE SOUNDS SO AMAZING!!!

  • this sounds like a song I would hear on the radio,awesome

  • OMGOSH IT'S EDWARD AWSOME

  • The part where he says Once we've payed the price at last and we are whole once more, everything will be the way before the day she slipped away...

    Is soo sad because it is true TT^TT GO VIC!!!

  • I love Vic, I defiantly want to meet him some day <3 He is an awesome singer and VA :3

  • AHHHH! VIC!!!! I LOVE YOU! There is not one voice I don't like! any one in any anime, show, song, anything it doesn't matter I love it! <3

  • Holy crap I need to learn to play the piano version of this, when I get my eletric guitar I need learn how to play it, then I need to find some drums hmm I NEED to learn to play this!!

  • Dear YouTube,

    I have discovered a horrible mistake in the programming of this page--the idiots who encrypted it programmed one of the Like buttons upsidedown. Please fix this immediately.

    Dumbasses.

    Sincerely, SFTD.

  • @SuckerForTragicDeath Now THAT just made my day! Why haven't I ever seen your comment before? lol :D

  • I just met Vic a few days ago, and he sang a part of this song live for us XD It was epic :D I may not watch English dubbed Anime (or, any anime for that matter. I'm more of a manga reader) but Vic Mignogna has an amazing personality, is extremely talented and is an awesome singer. I'm so glad the American dubbing industry as people as talented as him :)

  • I don't know why, but I knew this song before. But I thought it was by any Band like Linkin Park or something like that...But know....Yes, this is Edward! These lyrics...perfect!! it's fantastic!

  • You know, I'm not really fond of his voice acting, so I didn't think I'd like his music, but I actually really like this :)

  • @jena414 lol, it does tend to have that effect on people xD I didn't really think I'd like his singing at first *sweatdrop*

  • @jena414 I thought the same thing! I didn't think I would like his singing because I mainly listen to screamo but this is freaking amazing!!

  • GO DARK MOUSY!!

  • @JokerMoreauFangirl lol, once you listen to Vic's music for a while, you get used to it :3

  • 1 word: meep :3 <3

  • omg vic is awesome!!!!!he has such a good voice and i love everyone of his characters!i love him!

  • Thumbs up if you listened to this song at least 50 times or more.... and then looked for it on itunes and saw it there!

  • I wish Vic would come to my school and sing his songs I would be so happy.

  • *depressed I can't see him for his birthday* His birthday is tommorow, and my birthday is on wednesday.... :3 I share quite a bit with him, my astro sign, my intials. Seriously, VM. And I also do a little voicing... haven't voiced anime yet on Youtube. But I have a video of me voicing chapter fifteen of FMA, well, the first one in volume 4. :3

    Got to do Envy's 'LUCKY!'.

  • My little sister is in love with this song LOL!

  • I am going to see him at FanExpo...I am having major fangasms....I'm a guy

  • @goldranger222 I knew there were a few Vic fanboys out there somewhere! :D

  • @GoddessOfTheAir Hahaha, of course, there has to be :D And even if I'm the only one, I'll never stop being one!

  • @goldranger222 AMEN!!! Even though I'm not a guy xD And don't worry, there are tons of other fanboys in the Rangers :D

  • @GoddessOfTheAir I'm living proof that there is! I <3 Mignogna!

  • hes going to be in sandsucky next june!i cant wait to meet him!

  • I really wanna meet Vic! :(

  • *cough* Edward Elric, Hercales Karpusi, Tamaki Suoh...just to name a few...

  • @mikurulove10 Don't forget Zero Kiryu, Yukito Kanasaki, and Broly! ^^

  • @GoddessOfTheAir lol yup! i forgot about dbz! love it ^_^

  • @GoddessOfTheAir  and spirit albarn and kurz weber too :>

  • @GoddessOfTheAir Fai Flourite as well :3

  • @GoddessOfTheAir and Dark Mousy XD ^^ Vic's awesome :D

  • @stephanielightsong lol, how could we forget Dark?! He's one of my favorite characters! xD Vic IS amazing! I lubve him ^^

  • @GoddessOfTheAir yes! :D

  • Comment removed

  • Oh my gosh! He is Amazing!! :D I heard him do Guilty, Beauty, Love and I loved it! :D <3 He's an amazing singer :O <3

  • I WANT VIC TO COME TO MY ANIME CON!!!!!!!!!!!! I WANT TO HEAR HIM SING SONGS OF SONGINESS AND SONG-SUCH AND SUCH!!!! SONGS!!!! VIC MIGNOGNA!!!! FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST!!!! I AM SO ENERGIZED!

  • @Maddie11611 I met him at Colossalcon this June, he's such a nice guy! (:

  • I think.... I'm even more in love with him now.... Vic!!!!! And Edward is so amazing!!!!

  • i love this i might have found a wrestling entrance entrance theme

  • ^.^ this melted my heart. i loove this series. great job!!!!

  • Amazing , Love VIC!

  • Can i haz a cookie?pwezzzzzz i will luv you

  • @okamiamaterasu2 I sorry, I'm all out =(

  • @GoddessOfTheAir awww:(, well nice video by the way totally love the song

  • @okamiamaterasu2 Thank you! ^^ I love the song, too - Vic is one of the best singers I've heard, hands-down! xD

  • @GoddessOfTheAir Totally! :D