What Is And What Should Never Be (Led Zeppelin)

[yoyojamsam16]

good video but whats up with no slide?? thats the only reason i clicked on the video

[whitestripebuzz]

I realy liked this.

[hellobet46]

Funny in a good way, do your thing playing is good keep it goings.

[Amir14Ameero]

tut tut tut tut shit...tut tut utttttt!!

[MrRocket71]

I enjoyed it. Hey all you out there, accept it for what it is. This is a great understanding of this song and nice solo appreciation.

[RT101894]

guitar intro is wrong. ita an A7 to an E7. dont hurt your voice

[Mr5150II]

nice solo :) it was awsome tho!

[tdk3713]

thumbs up for trying though...

[tdk3713]

hey i'm not one for bashing a video on youtube and you have talent on guitar cause i have seen you play from what was on your youtube page. Yes you had fun and overall kudos for taking risks! but dude..this is a no..no...especially on youtube...because a lot of people on hear are viscous no doubt and if you want pleasant comments you should at least work on your craft behind the scenes first, then post when it's perfected, well that's if your truly passionate about this, just a piece of advice..

[ktyczka]

'F' the haters, dude. I liked it. Nice job.

[hunterochoa]

A-

Stay away from the high notes (vocals), but otherwise, excellente, amigo.

[calypsodude]

Very nice job - cheers !

[marekopsa]

u're good man!

[mackc6r]

do your own thing man, you're a line stepper

[thedudehi]

ok dude youre a gud singer but you cant wail like plant so dont try.sry

[31ma2fr3g0t0t0n]

wooow 5 stars, this is one of mi favorite songs, but, whats the chords? hoho

im 16 years old and page is my idol

please, i need the chords

[Kynatics]

Nice guitar solo. You started to sound like an ambulance at one point...until you said 'shit'. Then it was more like frustrated garbageman!

Good job. 5 stars.

[Valgriss]

You are marvellous at hitting the higher notes and your guitar play is unbelievable.

[coolkat1006]

you need to learn the slide

[foolintherain116]

nice guitar playin, but leave the vox to plant

[tygur91]

i know u said in your description you wont read this but whatever.

u arent very good at hitting those high notes they are pretty bad in my honest opinion. plant just isnt for you

[RoomOfMusic]

that was DoOooooooOOtastic

[tahlulah98]

I like this my friend told meh to listen to it its good and Im usually not liking Led~Zepplin so there good ill be listen more...

[zosobri]

is that smack any good

[batbrain72]

I love the guitar solo park. That was very good and a classic. :)

[namnoiz]

Very difficult song to pick on. You were great on some parts of it and not so great on others. Overall good one i would say !!!

[guarani527]

difficult to pick? you must really suck

[enther7]

HAHAHAHAHA theres not many people that could sing like plant i haven't seen anybody sing like plant. this is halarios i give it 4 stars for that but for the seriousness of it i give it a 1

[PerfectionKills]

lmao!

[airplaneguy53]

need COWBELL... OTHERWISE, i give it an 80 , nice try ... no matter what anyone else says...

[RoomOfMusic]

LMFAO!

[thnelement]

haha at 2:14. He's singin his high noted Doo doo dooos then........."SHIT"! haha

[RoomOfMusic]

lmao!

[Eym174]

awesome job, at first during the verse i thought it was plant singing

[mjt11860]

the "shit!" part was a nice touch. i knew u had played a wrong chord but then u corrected it. the best part of your vocals were the high parts which showed a really good raspiness. i wish i could do that. they should have been louder w/ more balls. i just wish u had finished the vocals on the last part. u have a lot of potential. i really enjoyed it. nice job.

[Bleedingbox]

cool xD

[SmileRealWide]

The chorus is too high for you. I'm very much so a vocal critic more so then with the guitar parts, but the guitar parts sounded pretty good to me. Other then the vocal imput on the solo.. You should have just played it maybe? Well, overall, it was pretty good. Just way too high for you. I'm a female, so it's quite easy for me, but the lower parts were great. Four stars.

[71MARTIND28]

Very nice. Including the "shit" lyric. I've never heard it on the record, maybe because that was deemed "Inappropriate" or "offensive" lyrics back then? ;-)

[mopodreamer]

I gave you a 4 so, very good!! The only thing that kept you from a 5 was the fact I feel, you should have played the lead instead of doootin it with your vocal chords:) Big time screw up with the chord change but...you saved it by saying, "sh*t":) Good one! Plus just the fact you ad the guts to take on Robert Plant's vocals, I give you big time credit. Good luck my friend and great job!

[nastyweather1]

Great Job, we enjoyed it

[roland6663]

ur alright..... but u don't hit the pitches in ur lyrics. o and robert plant sang it with balls. when he sang... u were like blown away by his singing. HAHA "shit...". but that's me just being a critic... u have potential though.

[wonderouswonderloo]

people complaining about this video can lick their feet. this is video is good.

[zoso4230]

i dont get how this could possibly be perceived as bad?!? this is amazing! excellent vocals

[stovenutts]

and i bet you do read these comments

[stovenutts]

dont sing notes u cant sing or it sonds like you you cant sing....yeah. haha

[hippo92590]

nice singing with the solo man :)

Great cover

[tehjnest]

ha doo doo

[zep2z]

Nice twist. I like it.

[robypower]

really really good man.. awesome

[guitarman63mm]

i now see why you don't read your comments. these guys are a bunch of wankers without any credentials whatsoever.

[mana244]

i forgot something

EVERY ONE ABOUT TO WATCH SKIP TO 1:43

ITS LIKE JACK BLACK

OR THE STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN FOO FIGHTERS COVER

[NASIMNASIM]

why must you emulate jimmy page?

[mana244]

PLANT has a deep voice (if you've ever heard his interviews) he learned how to hit those high notes vocally. but I can see that YOUR voice is naturally high noted

all I can really say is that YOU tried too hard

[darkowin93]

dude what is with the Doo Doo's those sohuld be played on the freakin guitar, not sung

but anyways, nice job

[superoli17]

well done man!

[salad911]

Yo I got a new video of this song I made Its one of my first vids but I think Its pretty good Pls check it out!!

[jdjustice72]

I see you don't read the comments -- but I liked this version and was wondering if you would let me respond to it with my piano and vocal cover of this song??

Thanks

JD

[breezyboden]

very impressive from Larry Co. Down N.Ire.

[vamosbabe]

I LOVE your cover man! What a voice and what beautiful singing!

[drewhartel72]

Is your throat okay after singing the chorus?

[Ldzeppelin729]

your voice isnt raw enough to do any zeppelin covers. plant was a great singer who had a raw voice. Your voice isnt bad, but it wont work with zeppelin

[brunobabashay]

sucks, it sounds too gay. i give you honest...

[goosu94]

do do do do shit do do do

[Godbe06]

I really liked this, I'm listening to the solo part now and I love it :D

You have a really good voice, but it sounded like you were singing from your throat in some parts, especially the bit where it speeds up after each verse. That was the only bit that let it down for me, but other than that, good job.

[Eduardo10390]

best led zeppelin cover I think I've ever seen on youtube!!

[insomniacl]

Hey dude, nice cover, its really good. your really good with the guitar. You should check out this other site fancovers. com, its a community for cover artists like yourself and you can upload videos too. later!

[angrymob]

then you really shouldn't try.....it sounds really sad, you have a good voice, just not for this. Also, your voice is too clean and technical sounding for this, need to grunge it up a bit.

[acousvnt]

All I know is I let the camera run for over an hour and just did whatever songs I felt like doing. Then I watched the whole thing and kept the ones I liked (mostly). So I obviously didn't think this was *terrible*, but in the future I would probably do more Beatles and Floyd which are more suited to my voice. And I think "shouldn't try" is a rotten philosophy.

[Flagurated]

other than you need to work on the vocals a bit, good.

[mixitup222]

ok you started off pretty good, then you sounded like pure shit

[acousvnt]

I had fun, though, and you're the one who had to suffer. So I win.

[sealine76]

On second thought -- needs more violin bow.

[sealine76]

That's pretty damn good! Except for the part where you swear. There should be no swearing in rock and roll.

[L7WEEINER]

nothing close to robert plant!

well maybe a little!aahh!=]

[acousvnt]

Yeah, in the future I'll try to orient the windscreen so's that it does its job without hiding my beauty. :)

[booradleysstuntman]

hey Keith, you daredevil you. nice one! impeccably played & hilarious at the same time. great vocal slide solo here...& spot on Percy screech at 2:52, looked like you were havin fun, despite seeming to be in a somewhat intermittent degree of pain (i feel moved to offer you a throat lozenge or something).& i've been meaning to mention this before; wot's with the in-your-face pop filter? how 'bout more of a 3/4 cam angle. we need to SEE the pain & sweat. works for Joe Cocker.later, Keith.