Added: 3 years ago
From: fhlew
Views: 386,179
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (362)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • musica linda

  • Enjoy!

    

  • when ever i feel his song, all martial artist like us feel inspired and it gives us inner strength like its says you are determined to overcome a very difficult task ahead

  • Enjoy!

    

  • Oh come on people, Cantonese AND Mandarin both are excellent when sung with passion. We are brothers/sisters, stop saying Canto or Mando is better. Let's not forget what Wong Fei Hung's life was about: his heroic efforts to defend the pride of the Chinese when we faced oppression from foreign powers. I speak Cantonese, Hakka, Mandarin, Fuzhounese, and have friends who speak Wenzhounese, Taisanese, Shanghainese, etc, etc. We are one big family. 中国加油!

  • Enjoy!

    

  • @fhlew 

  • 在任何時代, 這首歌聽起來都令人熱血沸騰.....

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • 粤语歌曲确实很好听

  • 谢谢您喜爱 与您分享!

  • no one sings it better than him

  • Enjoy !

  • 我非常喜欢粤语,可是我不会讲,只有唱歌的时候能唱,因为喜欢很­多粤语歌。其实大家不要吵了,从语言的发展来看,粤语比普通话保­留了更多古代汉语的发音方式,是非常传统而古典的。

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • 「过绵软的粤语」

    粵語係中國語言之中最鏗鏘有力。例如「強」在粵語中係第四聲(調­值11),發此聲要用最低音,而低沉能令一首歌更有男子氣概。而­普通話四聲中,每個調值有高音部份,加上沒有入聲,所以普通不能­表達歌中意思。另一個例子,「熱血熱勝紅日光」中有四個入聲兩個­去聲,入聲「短速急收藏」之特質就如刀劍相交,令此歌更蕩氣迴腸­。「熱血」沒有入聲,非熱血。

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

    

  • cantonese is the real feel!!!!

    

  • Enjoy !

  • 我喜欢粤语版的,也喜欢国语版的,这首歌就是有气势。

    那天楼下几个外国人开party吵着我睡不着觉,我就放这首歌给­他们听:-)

    林子祥先生最后自己唱的也是国语版的,寓意估计是不仅要做广东香­港的好汉子,也要做中华好汉子!

    其实喜欢某首歌就喜欢某首歌,有的人总喜欢把所有的事都跟政治扯­在一起,还写那么多,看着烦。

    反正就是顶这首,过了十年也顶,过了二十年也顶,一直顶。

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • @liu19950912 明明就是粵語好聽 自己在那邊扯政治說林子祥唱國語是中華漢子

    反正共產黨就是破壞中華文化的人 偏偏又怕人講

  • @casa1029 中华汉子有政治含义?难道你觉得中华等于共产党??你们还叫中华­民国咧,没见过像你这样曲解我意思的,难道台湾也有五毛党??不­攻自破的话以后别说,要不然让人看着笑。

  • 在唱歌的領域,廣東話是遠勝普通話國語!因為廣東話很少需要拗音­(即改變字的發音)去遷就曲調但是所有普通話國語的歌曲幾乎每句­曲詞都有拗音字(連國歌都有很多拗音字)!所以在廣東人的耳裏,­很少有普通話國語歌曲是好聽的!每個普通話國語的字只有四聲但每­個粵語字可以有多至九聲;剛好覆蓋了全音階的九音。所以好的粵語­歌聽來就像說話一樣!所以在粵語來說唱歌就是說話;說話就是 唱歌。這點普通話國語根本無法做到!歐洲的語言更不用提!可以說­粵語是中華文化的瑰寶。可惜中國內地的廣東人現在已經作不出好的­歌曲和歌詞了!因為中國政 府為了推行普通話國語,以行政命令強迫所有學校以普通話授課,大­部份國內的廣東人對很多中文字的粵語發音都弄不通,他們已經失去­了很多粵語的優勢!除了粵語外,全世界沒有一種語言有粵語這種每­字九聲的優點的。香港人可以學普通話國語,但絕對不應以普通話國­語授課;保留粵語的重大優點和優勢!並取代廣州以粵 語宗師自居,領導粵式文化!否則香港人便變了不懂粵語的中國廣東­人!

  • 只用四聲又不用拗音來創作好歌已經是非常困難了!普通話國語還有­一個在歌曲創作上的重大困難。大約有一半的普通話國語字是雙音字­!例如(江)字的普通話國 語發音是ji和ang兩個音前後齊發的!這跟粵語幾乎百分之九十­九的字都是單音字差很遠!所以幾乎所有普通話國語的歌曲都是有歌­無詞或有詞無歌。與粵語歌曲的詞曲合一不可同日而語!有很多廣東­人都有一個錯覺;認為普通話國語字的發音清晰。其實每個中文字的­粵語發音都是鏗鏘清晰,其清晰度比普通話國語有過之無不及!所以­粵語歌曲才可以做到說話即唱歌;唱歌即說話!北方人不明嶺南文化­,急功近利式推行普通話,對部份中華文化做成重大傷害!

  • 歐洲所有的語言和普通話國語一樣,在唱歌時無法不借助拗音字(即­改變字的發音)去遷就曲調,所以有時倒不如全部拗音,形成了一種­獨特的歌唱方式,叫(藝術歌曲)!普通人有時完全聽不懂這種音式­高而且幾乎每字皆拗音的歌唱形式!但是唱者都引以為榮!可是廣東­人因為要求好歌的首要條件是詞曲合一(即沒有拗音),所以廣東歌­是沒有歐洲人和中國北方人那種(藝術歌曲)的!但是也可以說所有­粵語好歌都是藝術成就高的產品!但是就是因為世界上沒有粵語藝術­歌曲,所以有些北方人的歌唱家是看不起粵語歌曲,認為沒有藝術!­同時大部份廣東人都不喜歡聽藝術歌曲,因為廣東人普遍聽不出唱者­唱什麼(因為藝術歌曲實在有太多拗音字了)!因此世上有兩種歌曲­:粵式歌曲(就是詞曲合一,幾乎沒有拗音);它的成就大部份有賴­作曲和填詞人的本領和修為。非粵式歌曲(就是准許有拗音);它的­成就只有賴於歌唱者的唱功!

  • 大部份(百份之九十以上)的人,一生只可以精通一種語言。如果再­多學另外一種語言,又完全忽視母語;那麼他原來的母語能力一定會­遭削弱。一個很好的例子: 中國廣東省的人從少便在學校被迫接受普通話教學。現在中國廣東人­對很多中文字的粵語發音都不懂!所以中國廣東人在過去五十年裏竟­然作不出一首好的粵語歌! 好的粵語歌曲音韻悠揚,詞曲合一,舉世皆知。普通話歌曲無可比擬­!中國廣東省過份提倡普通話,間接壓抑粵語,中國廣東人也被改造­,變了不懂粵語的廣東人! 使嶺南文化全面衰亡;可悲可嘆!清末民初時,廣東人還是人才輩出­。梁啟超、孫中山等都是廣東人。可是廣東人在1949年後便再沒­有出現震驚全國的人才!廣東人放棄了粵語;就連好歌都作不出一首­,又怎會出人才?

    粵語歌曲也是有拗音字的。但是通常都是一個始,兩個止。對比普通­話國語所有歌曲每一句歌詞最少有一個拗音字,粵語歌曲的拗音字變­了少得無傷大雅。

  • 明显粤语好听。。。。国语听起来根本没感觉。。。

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • 的確 我不認為粵語是比華語綿軟

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • 这首歌「男儿当自强」,林子祥最先用粤语唱过,不过绵软的粤语始­终无法真正表达出其气势。直到后段的华语版出现后,歌中那种奋发­图强的中华精神才酣畅淋漓地散发出耀眼的光­芒。

    我並不認同粵語比華語綿軟, 綿軟與否, 要視乎歌者如何演釋, 不在方言本身.

  • 谢谢您喜爱 与您分享

  • @youbadcrazyman

    I don't want to say this but you start it first. I feel that all of us Cantonese speakers need to defend against your bias. Cantonese is a much better language to use in this song. After all, the original lyrics was being written by James Wong. YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND CANTONESE! Stop comment on something you don't know. You should not let you ignorance put out comment like that. Cantonese is not soft by any remote standard.

  • @0881benjamin

    I think so too, although I don't understand neither of them. Cantonese is generally better for songs, the sound of mandarin always sounds really unpleasant, harsh and strict. This also applies for normal speaking!

  • @Jackpower1989 I don't know whether you are confusing the two or not, but it is Cantonese that sounds "unpleasant and harsh." Mandarin sounds quite nice, as long as the "r" sounds are where they're supposed to be, while Cantonese always makes conversations sound like fights, due to the mass amount of nasal sounds.

  • @HyperZergling mass amount of nasal sounds? do you mean "n", "ng" something like that? i think they exist and are quite common in both dialects. "sound like fights" is your OPINION anyway.

    ok, which one sounds better, is all up to an individual.

  • @youbadcrazyman "Ng" doesn't occur nearly as much in Mandarin as in Cantonese.

  • 中西方音乐结合啊……

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • ITs too good...

    fab singer

    fab song~!!!

  • Enjoy !

  • 这是我知道的唯一一首国语粤语版都用一样歌词的歌

  • 谢谢您收看 与您分享!

  • the drumming is just amazing

  • Enjoy !

  • 這首歌最好聽的地方 在於用方言唱出來 很多意境 聲音 要用方言才能表達的更出色

    而且這首歌還有一個特別的地方 就是在一個特別的時代下被傳唱 那時候我還小 可是我還記得那時候國家的生命力 是那樣的強大 不像現在

  • 谢谢您喜爱 与您分享!

  • 喜欢那鼓声、、激扬、、、振奋人心

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • Thanks for uploading, it's the very best version of this song! George Lam's "Lamusique" CD was already excellent, but his new "Lamusique Vintage 2011" CD is even better still. The song selection and new arrangements are amazing!

    The Limited Edition K2HD-CD version of "Lamusique Vintage 2011" will be released on 30/6/2011. Made in Japan.

  • Thank you for information and update!

    Cheers !!!

  • Thank you for information and update!

    Cheers !!!

  • 陳獨秀在《青年雜志》創刊號上所發《敬告青年》一文,實際上相當­于發刊詞。他提出六條倡議︰“一、自主的而非奴隸的;二、進步的­而非保守的;三、進取的而非退隱的;四、世界的而非鎖國的;五、­實利的而非虛文的;六、科學的而非想象的。

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

    

  • 林子祥唱得最好。他那叱吒聲是純管樂、弦樂模仿不到的。

  • 謝謝您喜愛 与您分享! 

  • 剛剛個演唱會都有唱...依然有高水準演出!寶刀未老!!!

  • 謝謝您喜愛 与您分享! 

  • 始終都係亞Lam唱得最令人振奮.

    

  • 謝謝您喜愛 与您分享!

  • 始終都係亞Lam唱得最令人振奮.

  • 謝謝您喜愛  与您分享!

  • 超高水準的演奏, 聽出耳油!

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • 有3 个不会自强

  • 自小爸爸就开始播这首歌了!只有林子祥才可唱出这份热血!!

    

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • may i knw whr can download pure music version?

  • Please try to search on Youtube.

  • 粵語不是華語嗎?

    標題應該打粵語/普通話

  • anyone else feel like exercising at the beach with a thousand monks behind you?

  • Enjoy !

  • I feel extremely pump up after listening to this song..

  • Enjoy !

  • am i wrong if i say that this is cantonese ?

  • Yes! Cantonese with Mandarin towards end.

    

  • BOW DOWN TO WONG SIFU!!!

  • Enjoy !

  • it may be in my 20s only but i like old song much better, new song sometime make no sense at all

  • Enjoy!

    

  • It's better interpretation!!!. That´s truth.

  • Enjoy!

    

  • ...now I want to watch a certain Jet Li series

  • Enjoy!

    

  • jack1995918 你好柒呀

  • @ProfuWarrior 你老母仲柒,仲打機,多d睇下你老母,如果唔係比人吊死,你無得­見

  • wtf? why are they wearing suits? they should be in kung fu clothes

  • 嗌都嗌到斷氣呢隻歌

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享! 

  • @fhlew יודע עברית?

  • לא יודע.

  • 中国当自强

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • @fhlew 感谢您才对 楼主宣传中国文化辛苦了!

  • only george lam gives justice to this song, AH LAM DA MAN!

  • חחחחחחחחחחח שמע אנ

  • שיה שיה

  • 真帅 林子祥!

  • drummer (Hell yeah, i'm badass)

  • Hello !

    

  • true dat - martial arts.

  • 这鼓敲的就是专业的

  • 太棒了 !

  • 刚发现这是港乐演奏的耶,水平算是可以

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享! 

  • Ah Lam is the only one who puts enough power behind this song. I like that he does both the Cantonese and Mandarin versions. This should be China's national anthem.

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you. Cheers !!!

  • @nooyawkfun yeah you're right, it should be the anthem, but maybe it should be more powerful than this.

  • 我好喜歡大鼓的獨奏喔,太有氣勢了..............­

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • classic !! ! 

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you. Cheers !!!

  • only HE can rock this song

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you.

    Cheers !!!

  • @bluedithia jackie chan sang a variation of this. it rocks too

  • 太棒了 !

  • 謝謝您喜愛 与您分享! 

  • Bi Tai Yang geng guang!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • 犀利啊 太威了

    

  • 与您分享! 

  • 犀利啊

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享! 

  • hey

    

  • Cheers !!!

  • 龍向榮:)

  • 太棒了 !

  • Proud to be Cantonese

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you.

  • @ac911007 proud 2 b cantonese as well as chinese

  • Cheers !!!

  • Comment removed

  • 成龍真係垃圾@_@

    林子祥唱得好聽好多

  • 謝謝您喜愛 与您分享! 

  • @dogdog20032003 你收啦,咁成龍好打d定林子祥?

    各有各好,why要話成龍係垃圾

    你唔識欣賞仲垃圾

  • @dogdog20032003 講緊唱歌啵,你又拉埋打黎講,咁就李小龍好打D啦~

    成龍差唔多套套戲都係比人追既

  • Proud to be Han Chinese

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you.

    Cheers !!!

  • 喜欢那个打鼓的!!

  • 太棒了 !

  • @qtyrubnvfm 我會打鼓的

  • Hi, how do we get the chinese version of this song ? thanks!

  • mp3?

    

  • 很有气势

    

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • wonderfull song :) do zhe tsi tseung :)

  • Share with you. Cheers !

  • music today can't compare to this.

  • Thank you for your support. Share with you.

  • 棒极了,谢谢,让人充满志气!!!

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享! 

  • THE CHINESE WAKEUP ANTHEM TO RIGHTEOUSNESS NEXT ONLY TO THE DESCENDANTS OF THE DRAGON.....

  • 謝謝您收看  与您分享!

  • @ Fhlew

    THE PLEASURE IS MINE.XIE XIE NI

  • he is singing it in cantonese and in mandarin??

    however, greatest song ever!!!

  • Singing in Cantonese for the song and Mandarin towards the end.

  • 唱的好..........我是男兒當自強......讓人熱血­沸騰

  • 謝謝您收看  与您分享!

  • Salute~!

  • Share with you!

  • 謝謝分享!

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享!

  • 很棒的一首歌!喜欢听打鼓的声音! *_*

    感谢您的分享哦!哈哈哈! (^_^)

  • 謝謝您收看 与您分享林子祥超强的唱腔 ~~ 謝謝 

  • Comment removed

  • Share with you.

  • Proud to be a Cantonese!!!!!!!

  • Share with you.

  • Excelennt !!! Proud to be a Chinese :-)

  • Share with you !

  • thanx for watching my video and commenting. I love this song as much as the next chinese guy. I've attached a new video of me playing this song on a new instrument that I got 3 days ago called the Japanese Nardan Harp, which sounds very oriental, that not many people know including Japanese people. I hope you like it.

  • Good rendition !